4239th Meeting, 144th Session, Human Rights Committee (CCPR) Human Rights Treaty Bodies Date: 3 July 2025 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/ar/ccpr/4239?lang=en Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- CCPR · Chair [0:01]: Good morning, everyone. I'd like to welcome you to meeting number 42/39 of the Human Rights Committee. This is a public meeting and on webcast. It is devoted to the continuation of the consideration of the seventh periodic report of Spain. Your Excellency, Mr. Marcos Gómez, You have 15 minutes to continue with your outstanding replies. Thereafter, I will give the floor to a number of members of the Committee to pose their questions on the second-half of the list of issues, which are issues 13 to 25. As yesterday, your delegation will then have a 15-minute break to allow you to prepare your response to the questions posed by the members. You will then have one hour to respond to the questions posed, after which we will allow time for follow-up questions and answers. The meeting today will adjourn at 1:00 PM. Without further ado, I'd like to give the floor to Your Excellency Mr. Gomes. Excellency, you have your floor. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:26]: Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, and good morning to one and all. Good morning to all the members of the committee and those present. Since you have afforded the delegation some space to continue with responses to follow-up questions and questions in general from yesterday, I would say the following: First, on our follow-up commission for human rights treaty bodies recommendations, including on the 1997 law and the compatibility between that amnesty and the democratic memory instrument. I would give the floor to my delegation. Spain [2:16]: Thank you very much, Ambassador. Continuing with the follow-up questions of the questions from yesterday, first, on the follow-up body for decisions from the Committee, or rather our Commission, we have a decree in place from July of 2024, 709/2024. That Royal Decree has the objective of regulating the management of the Second National Human Rights Plan for the Kingdom of Spain. Among the objectives is the follow-up on the rulings from the treaty bodies. It sets forth a new regulation that provides follow-up on the rulings from the treaty bodies and the resolutions handed down by the other special procedures as well from the Human Rights Council. That is to say, those that are not covered by treaties ratified by Spain, but rather those that arise from human rights instruments in the Council, such as special procedures and the treaty bodies. This decree creates a steering committee. That steering committee oversees many things, including the follow-up on reports from the treaty bodies with recommendations. And it addresses all of Spain, civil society, and the autonomous communities as well. It also creates an interministerial committee. That is a commission, rather, that is made-up of representatives of the central government in Spain, all ministries. And among that, rather, in that commission, we see a working group as well called the sub-directorate or sub-commission that is tasked with drafting reports. on follow-up on the treaty bodies' decisions, recommendations, and rulings. That subcommission has met. It has got to work. It has a draft document that regulates its makeup and the regularity of its meetings. Those reports that they draft, the follow-up reports, are then brought to the Interministerial Commission, where they are adopted and sent along to different treaty bodies or special procedures in the Human Rights Council. Now, secondly, the relationship between the amnesty law of 1977 and the historic memory document of 2022, this is a matter that was already addressed for our constitutional tribunal. A ruling from last year, the Constitutional Court already indicated what we said yesterday, and that's that they are just different realms. The democratic memory document is not organic. It addresses areas within its remit, but that does not affect the amnesty law. They're separate. That is an interpretation or ruling from the Constitutional Court that dates. We have rulings from 2021 as well, and that is the practice of the Constitutional Court to interpret these documents. It is also necessary to explain to some degree what the remit is of the 1977 amnesty law, is what it covers. One must understand the coordination or the aspects of what happened at that time. My colleague will address that. Now, the amnesty law of 1977 includes a process that included a ruling from June of 2024 addressing this within the matters that arose in Catalonia. It looked at the transition from a dictatorial regime to a democratic regime. There are four years, really, that lasted back in the 70s. There was a call from those political parties that had suffered during the dictatorship and that had people either in exile or in the jail there. They called for an amnesty that allowed all of the exiles to return to Spain, and it allowed those who were in prison to be released through an amnesty. That is the reason for which the amnesty was issued in 1977 that came through parliament. almost with unanimity. There were just two votes against and 18 abstentions, particularly from the party that had interests that were most linked to the previous regime. What did that mean? That amnesty law continues to be applied today. There are cases between from '84 and more recently from 2005 before the Constitutional Court in which the rights of amnesty are extended to groups that initially were not addressed, for example, the brigades of forest workers. their rights to their right they had suffered from imprisonment, and the amnesty affects them. And then there were other rulings from 74 as well that addressed military or civil servants that had not had their rights protected, and the amnesty law addressed their cases as well. That was the That's the implementation of the amnesty of 1977. It's a law that is very broad. It continues to address all of these different groups. That's why the Law for Democratic Memory brings a covers matters that could not be covered prior to the democratic transition. My colleague would take the floor. Spain [9:02]: Thank you very much. To continue with what Alfonso has said. And to clarify, the activities undertaken by the prosecutor for democratic memory is undertaken, that's where some of the doubts lie as regards the law from 1977. The specialized prosecutor's office was created for Article 18 and the law on democratic memory, and Article 19 sets forth the right to investigation. And that is what this prosecutor's office is doing. It is investigating the events of those periods, trying to shed light on the truth, and in this process, to provide support to the victims. So the prosecutor's office is opening investigations with the goal, as I have said, of hearing the victims, with investigations still open. And the victims, once they have been heard by authorities, to establish the truth and the facts. The idea is to have them compensated by meeting some of one of the goals of the Democratic Memory Law, which is recognition of their reality, symbolic and material redress. This is the work that is being done by the Democratic Memory Prosecutor's Office. This is essential in the healing of these events or of the victims as a result of these events. We are not seeking to breathe new life into the law of 1977, but rather we are trying to address this law within the scope of other international instruments adopted by Spain and ensuring that there is a right to investigation as set forth in that law. Also, in compliance with the commitments that Spain has taken on, the Law of Democratic Memory has withdrawn the declarations that were made by authorities within the regime. And so far, as of March 2025, we have found 7,000 mortal remains, and others have been exhumed or rather are soon to be exhumed as well. That's what I could provide on that topic. Also, in order to not have to take the floor later, I will address some of the other questions. For example, the reports from any victims that are in irregularity migratory status, whether this immediately gives rise to work permit, et cetera. I would say the following. There are three levels, really, that are considered in the case of victims in these scenarios. There are, first, the victims of gender-based violence, sexual violence. or trafficking, in the case of women, their rights automatically arise after they are declared victims without any type of necessary cooperation with authorities in the investigation. Now, the victims that have been found trapped in organized crime networks, a wide array of activities, really, of criminal activities, Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [12:43]: The head of delegation interrupts and says that we will have to submit that information in written form because we need to move ahead to address the Commission, CEDR, the Commission for Elimination of Racial Discrimination. The Ministry of Equality has a minute and a half to address those questions. Spain [13:00]: Hello, and thank you. To clarify on this matter and to provide additional information, the Council for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination or Ethnic Discrimination is a body within the Ministry of Equality. It is decentralized, working with local governments, it's working with private sector, unions, and civil society. The main goal is to work in the promotion of equality and non-discrimination. Among our activities are, for example, recommendations on topical events related to racism, studies, reports, such as that published this year on the study of perception of racial discrimination by potential victims that addresses previous versions of that study. We can see that in Spain there continues to be victims or potential victims. or perception of racism, as has been mentioned here. This is for Afro-descendants and Gypsy groups. These are the two ethnic groups that most perceive it thus. We also provide assistance to victims of racial discrimination directly or indirectly through victim support units. This was mentioned yesterday in regards to hate crimes. These services began in 2013. In 2021, we saw an increase in the funds, a meaningful increase, that is, to these services. This allowed for us to increase the offices to 23 throughout Spain, broaden the telephone access, and a 021 hotline as well. All of this facilitates the reporting options for victims. of there, there have been, we have seen increased cases in 300 to 600. Now we have 1500 cases and 2500 cases, 2024, and then 2013 so far. That doesn't mean that there are more cases. It's just that there's more information and more information for the victims to report, more reporting options. The idea is to reduce the underreporting, really, because We know that only one in five victims report discrimination. Now, to conclude, we need to work on victim attention, but we also need to work to reduce the amount of acts of racism. So that's also a matter of prevention outreach from the early age period. Thank you. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [15:32]: Now, health care will address the issue of forced sterilization. Spain [15:38]: Thank you. The removal of an article addresses a contradiction in the issue of those that are declared to not have capacity. In the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, we have addressed this case, and this practice is now a crime without exception. Since the reform of this, we have not seen any new cases or reports of sterilization without consent. There are reports from specialized agencies. to indicate that we are, the law is being enforced. One of the primary challenges, however, that we face as moving toward, as we move towards reparation is the real difficulty in identifying how many people were subjected to these practices. In December of 2021, On the day of this, International Day of Disabilities and the first anniversary of the vote on this matter in the Senate, when these practices became illegal, the government held an event in which forgiveness was offered to the victims. An institutional solidarity document was issued for the women and girls with disabilities that were victims of forced sterilization. That strengthened the commitment to the compliance with the convention, the strengthening of public policies on equality and non-discrimination against persons with disabilities. victim support, and the recognition of the role of associations. The National Council for Disabilities is currently working to redress, to provide redress, and bearing taking studies that move towards effective reparation or redress of this historic harm. We are also seeking to adopt the first plan for the promotion and protection of women and girls' disabilities as a key policy for helping these women and girls from the patriarchal societies that help to support their sexual and reproductive health. I thank you kindly. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [17:32]: I see that we have gone over time, over 50 minutes, but we are available for additional questions. CCPR · Chair [17:43]: Thank you very much, Mr. Gomes. Now I’ll move to the second round of the questions by the members. The first, I will give the floor to Mr. Quesada. CCPR · Committee member [18:04]: Thank you, Chairman, and good day to one and all. Welcome to the delegation from the State Party as well. Today, I will be asking questions on paragraphs 14, 15, and 16 of the list of issues, care provided to those deprived of liberty. The three paragraphs refer to the same topic under the same article of the Covenant. First, paragraph 14. Here are my questions. As we understand it, the National Protection Mechanism from torture, that is, the NPM for torture, in annual visits, 26 visits in 2024, have indicated material deficiencies in the oldest prisons, as well as a dearth of psychiatric and health care officials. There's a lack of full incorporation of health care in the penitentiaries. There are recommendations for effective transfer to autonomy. There are also uses of subjugation, mechanical subjugation. It's recommended that this be limited in time. There has also been a search for more respectful alternatives for those who suffer from mental illness. Please, your report on the response from the competent authorities to these observations on the NPM. Secondly, the State Party has provided reports on the punishment of isolation under Organic Law 1/1979, and that it cannot be for more than 14 days, and that it is only in extreme cases, and it can only be extended for 42 days when there are numerous different convictions. And of course, there must be a prior authorization for this. Please explain the reasons for this type of incommunicado detention, and if you can explain if you've looked into the possibility of eliminating this. We also, third, would like to have information on the situation of persons deprived of liberty that have disabilities or serious mental illness and that are isolated from the rest of the prison population, please give us information on the conditions of their isolation and the medical attention that they receive. I'm now moving to paragraph 15. I have four questions under this paragraph. Kindly report as to whether there are alternative measures to migratory detention in the foreign holding centers, and should there be, what are the measures taken and in what percentage are they used with regard to those being held in these centers? Secondly, Regarding minors that are detained, please report on the measures adopted when there is ill-treatment reported in detention centers by private security officials, when acts are committed by these minors. On this issue, have Has this arisen as the result of a lack of appropriate training for the guards in the use of force in this type of holding detention facility? Third, we have heard of reports on experiments in the Huelva and Cordoba prisons between 2016 and 2019. This involved the electric shocks, electric cerebral shocks to those deprived of liberty as part of a study on aggressiveness. We'd like to know whether disciplinary or judicial investigations were launched into these events and what the results might have been into these investigations, as well as measures that might have been adopted to avoid this being, this happening again. Fourth, kindly report on the situation of women deprived of liberty. We have heard that there are only two penitentiary establishments exclusively for women, and in the majority of these cases, these women are far from their homes, and the majority are in primarily masculine prisons without a gender-based focus. Now, paragraph 16. First, regarding detention or incommunicado detention set forth in the law of criminal convictions, which can be handed down by the investigative judges. State parties reported on modifications made to restrict the use of incommunicado detention. However, measures have not been adopted to abolish this practice. Kindly explain what the need is to keep this type of detention on the books and whether you've seriously looked into the possibility of its full elimination. Two, the State Party has reported that the reform of Article 509.4 of the Law of Criminal Conviction or Prosecution expressly excludes the possibility of implementing incommunicado detention to minors, those less than 16 years of age. Regarding minors between 16 and 18 years of age, this measure is still in place. However, it does require prior knowledge and oversight by the prosecutor's office. As well as the case, the prior question, we are asking what the need is to maintain this type of detention, whether you've seriously looked into the possibility of eliminating it. Lastly, we would like to know, if we might, we'd like to know more about the situation of those deprived of liberty that are considered to be first degree detainees and that are in a closed or special center, might they remain for a long period of time in this, as there are no norms that establish maximum time limits on the use of this? According to that enshrined in Article 72 of the Granic Law on Penitentiaries, their remaining in these conditions will be for, and I quote, "for the time necessary until the reasons or circumstances that determined their entry into that disappear or reduce." Might the delegation provide additional information on that item. Thank you for your kind attention and for your responses. CCPR · Chair [25:16]: Thank you very much. Now I'll give the floor to Mr. Taraya. CCPR · Committee member [25:23]: Thank you, Mr. Chairperson. Good morning. Buenos dias. I hope the delegation of Spain had a restful night. This morning, i raise four issues, issue 17, 20, 22, and 23. Issue 17 pertains to trafficking in persons. As noted in the State Party report, the State Party is primarily a country of transit and destination owing to the country's strategic location. Accordingly, the State Party's efforts have significance not only at the national level, but also in the broader international context. In this regard, the Committee appreciated detailed information provided in the report. With regard to the statistics, the State Party's report notes that a quantitative study on trafficking, sexual exploitation, and prostitution among women and girls in Spain is currently being conducted. Could the State Party elaborate on the nature and scope of this study and indicate when its findings are expected to be published? One of the most pressing challenges appear to be the timely identification of victims of trafficking. It is also noted that the message for such identification vary across regions. In this regard, the state parties response highlights the proposal developed by the special government office on gender-based violence to harmonize the criteria for clarifying that women was at risk of trafficking, sexual exploitation, or other situation vulnerability in context of prostitution. While this initiative is still at the proposal stage, could the state party elaborate on the nature of this harmonization? To what extent has it been implemented in practice? And what are the prospects for its full realization? In the State Parties' view, what challenges remain in achieving uniformity of criteria across regions? This brings me another question concerning the absence of comprehensive anti-trafficking law, which is also linked to the reported lack of genuine national referral mechanisms. And the committee takes particular interest in the state party's statement during the opening remarks of the delegation, noting that a draft comprehensive law on trafficking has been developed following concern recently raised by several states during the state party's UPR. It was also noted that the process of public consultation and stakeholder input on this draft law has recently been completed. While it may be somewhat early to ask, could a state party provide a timeline for the adoption of this draft law? What areas is it expected to cover? Furthermore, beyond establishment of the unified legal framework, is a state party considering the development of a more comprehensive national referral mechanisms? Issue 20 pertains to treatment of foreign nationals, including refugee and asylum seekers, which will be covered by Mr. Helfer. I will focus on some specific issues on unaccompanied foreign minors. One of the most significant concerns, similar to the earlier observation on trafficking persons, is the absence of standardized protocol and the lack of fully established uniform procedure for age determination. Many institutions, such as the Committee on Right of the Child, have repeatedly raised doubts about the liability of the age assessment methods used in state party, citing multiple violation with the Convention of the Rights of the Child. And the committee noticed that the state parties report emphasizes an age-based approach in assessing applications and the development of more right-based framework. Could the State Party elaborate on current progress in developing a unified standard for identifying and protecting children? In doing so, how do the age-based approach and rights-based framework contribute to this process? Do they enable sufficiently agile responses to the diverse range of cases? Are there any limitations to these approaches? Secondly, A critical issue to be addressed concerns the protection afforded to children. In this regard, the Committee has received information confirming instances of abuse and discriminatory treatment in reception centers, some of which are currently under judicial investigation. Furthermore, the Ombudsman has identified a significant number of individuals who claim to be minors but were nonetheless placed alongside adults. In this light, How does the State Party ensure that all unaccompanied foreign children receive appropriate legal assistance as well as support for social and labor market integration once they reach adulthood? Additionally, how does the State Party ensure the agile identification of international protection needs, including safeguards for protection and the preservation of family unity? Issue 22 pertains to freedom of expression, which will also be covered by Ms. Degruy later. The first issue concerns slander and libel, to which the State Party's report offers only a limited response. The Committee also take note of the recommendation that the State Party should decriminalize deformation and incorporate it into civil deformation legislation in line with international standards. First, to what extent is the restriction of freedom of expression on the grounds of slander and libel compatible with international standards, particularly with Article 19, paragraph 3 of the Covenant, which provides an exhaustive list of legitimate grounds for such restrictions? How does the state party ensure such compatibility in its legal framework and practice? Second, does the state party have an intention to consider decriminalizing defamation? What is the rationale for maintaining defamation as a criminal offense under the current legal system? Regarding access to public information, the Committee appreciates the intensive amount of information provided by the state party, particularly under under Article number 19, 2013 of 9 December on transparency, access to public information, and good governance. At the same time, some sources mention that certain structural and practical challenges have been noted. For example, the transparency law does not fully cover the legislative and judicial branches. There are no penalties for noncompliance by public bodies. As for users, the overlapping regional and local rules with multiple oversight bodies can be confusing for users. The volume of requests maintain low, with only about 10,000 per month at the central level. Also, women represent just 30% of requesters. In light of the above, is the current legal system sufficient to ensure transparency in the scope of information disclosure? Is information being disclosed reliably and consistently in practice? What measures have been taken to promote more active and widespread use of the transparency law? Issue 23 specifically pertains freedom of expression and related other rights in Catalonia. The state party's report emphasized that politicians, journalists, and the general public in Catalonia must follow the constitutionally established channels and respect to the fundamental rights of all citizens, while also affirming that they may advocate constitution change without facing any adverse consequence for any of their rights. The Committee wishes to recall that the obligation to respect the fundamental rights of all citizens lies first and foremost with the state itself. In this regard, the Committee has received multiple reports raising serious concerns about the use of surveillance technologies in a State Party, particularly in relation to political dissent and the right to privacy. One report indicates that between 2017 and 2020, at least six 65 Catalan politicians, activists, and public figures are targeted with Pegasus and Canju spyware allegedly linked to the National Intelligence Center. No Pegasus and Canju spyware-- sorry. No official investigation has been launched, and the public prosecutor has remained inactive in related judicial proceedings. Additional report highlighted instances of policy Infiltration into social movement without judicial authorization, including cases involving intimate relationships developed into uncovered operations. Courts have refused to investigate these cases, and the prosecutions appear to have normalized such practices. In light of these reports, how does the state party respond to these allegations? Does it intend to Initiate investigation into these practices? If so, what procedure would be followed? If not, what are the obstacles preventing such investigations? Regarding situation in Catalonia, the committee notes recent significant developments concerning the 2024 amnesty law, which grant amnesty to individuals involved in pro-independence activities in Catalonia. This includes a Constitutional Court ruling issued last week. The Committee has also received reports urging that the 2024 Amnest Law is not appropriately being implemented in practice. The Committee also wishes to recall its view in individual communication number 3165/2018, versus Spain, in which it found the state party violates the author's rights under Article 25 of the Covenant. And further stated that the state party is under an obligation to take all steps necessary to prevent similar violations from occurring in the future. The Committee would appreciate the state party's clarification on the following points. Could you provide information on the current implementation of the 2024 amnesty law? What procedures are in place, and which categories of individuals fall within the scope of the law? What is the anticipated impact of the recent Constitutional Court ruling on its application? How does the state party consider the compatibility of the 2024 law with the international standards and with the committee's view in the Pretty Diamond case? These are the questions I would like to raise at this stage. I look forward to receiving your response. CCPR · Chair [37:55]: Thank you very much, Mr. Tawada. Now I give the floor to Mr. Helfer. CCPR · Committee member [38:02]: Thank you, Chair, and welcome back to the delegation. My questions for today are focusing on issues 18 and 19. Beginning with issue 18, the Committee understands that migrant intake facilities, known as the Centros Atención Temporal de Frontereros, or CATES, can detain migrants for up to 72 hours. However, reports indicate that these centers continue to operate without a unified regulatory framework. Please clarify the legal basis that authorizes this temporary deprivation of liberty. We also understand that migrants detained for a longer period, up to 60 days, are held in the Centros de Internamiento de Extranjeros, or CIEs. The Committee has questions concerning the detention of migrants in these centers. Credible reports document inadequate medical care, overcrowding, and self-harm in the CIEs. How does the state party identify the needs of vulnerable migrants, both prior to and during detention, and does it provide consistent access to medical care, psychological support, and legal aid? The Committee also notes with concern reports of inadequate reception conditions for migrants, including at Madrid Airport in February 2024 and in Ceuta, Melilla, and the Canary Islands, where asylum seekers have been forced to sleep on the streets due to insufficient reception capacity and delays in the asylum application process. Now, my colleague Mr. Toraya has noted the issue of overcrowding and abuse of unaccompanied children in detention centres. We have also received reports that minors have been expelled from detention centers without documentation when they reach 18 years of age, in violation of domestic law. Would the delegation comment on these reports? In addition, please provide an update on the plan to redistribute unaccompanied minors from detention centers in the Canary Islands to other places in Spain. Turning to asylum, the Committee notes some recent improvements to the asylum assessment procedures, including Law 12/2009, which clarifies deadlines and better regulates border posts. The Committee has nevertheless received multiple reports that assessment procedures remain inadequate, for example, in terms of digital systems and understaffing, resulting in long wait times and even the development of a black market for appointment slots. In addition, Ministry of Interior statistics indicate that more than 240,000 asylum applications were pending in 2024, an increase of 27% over the previous year. What concrete steps will the state party take to address these concerns? Turning to issue 19, the committee understands the formal opportunities available to migrants to apply for international protection. However, Numerous credible reports indicate that pushbacks and automatic summary returns have continued, preventing migrants from entering Spanish territory from which they can lawfully apply for asylum. As the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights noted in her report of 2023, quote, "There seems to be no other way to enter Melilla and Ceuta and request protection from the authorities other than swimming or jumping the fence, risking one's life." These ongoing pushbacks result in a range of human rights violations. For example, the committee has received reports indicating ill treatment of migrants by border officials, including beatings, excessive physical force, and even deaths. Now, regrettably, this is an ongoing problem. In 2014, at least 15 migrants died while trying to reach Ceuta. The state party, we understand, looked into these events, but the investigation was definitively closed in 2020 by a decision of a court in Cádiz without anyone being held accountable. Again, a few years later, in June 2022, border officials used excessive force at the Melilla border, resulting in deaths of at least 23 individuals, mostly Sudanese, and injuries to many others. And these are just the most well-known examples that involve deaths of multiple migrants. Therefore, my questions are: What specific measures will the State Party take to prevent the deaths and ill-treatment of migrants, ensure that border forces are properly trained against such actions, and provide effective, timely, and transparent investigations of alleged violations? Now, I want to underscore the Committee is not alone in raising these concerns. In March 2025, the High Court of Justice of Andalucía ruled that the immediate return of individuals intercepted at sea or on the beaches of Ceuta is unlawful. The court held that border controls must follow ordinary return procedures, including guarantees for refugees seeking international protection. What steps are being taken to implement the High Court ruling? For example, will the State Party consider repealing or modifying the special regime for Ceuta and Melilla of Organic Law 4/215? And most important, when will the State Party cease the practice of pushbacks and summary returns and ensure that all persons intercepted at or near the border of the Spanish enclaves are admitted to the territory and can apply for international protection? My last issue for today concerns bilateral agreements with Morocco, including a 2022 security cooperation agreement authorizing Spain to deport migrants back to Morocco without administrative processing or a judicial order. Please clarify the specific terms of this agreement. In addition, how does the state party assure that migrants can apply for asylum and are guaranteed humane treatment by both states parties when they are returned to Morocco? Those are my questions for today, and I look forward to your replies. CCPR · Chair [44:12]: Thank you very much, Mr. Helfer. Now I'll give the floor to Madame Tigruta. CCPR · Committee member [44:20]: Thank you, Chair. And I'd like to welcome the delegation. I'll be addressing questions in paragraphs 21, 24 and 25. First, I'd like to thank the delegation. I very much appreciate their pedagogical approach and the replies regarding the connection between the amnesty law of 1977 and the Democratic Memory Act of 2022. It's not yet totally crystal clear, but as the special rapporteurs of the UN say that in the communication of December 2024, I think that is connected also, this lack of clarity, I mean, is connected to that famous Article 2 of the law of 2022 that also is interpreted differently in Spain by the prosecutor's office and the courts. So there's still, I think, a question of legal security, there are legal guarantees, but we're very grateful for your explanations. I now go to paragraphs 21 and 24. These are connected because they relate to the protection of the civic space and freedom of expression and demonstration. These are connected to questions raised by my colleague, Mr. Tiraya. Paragraph 21 specifically looks at the Public Security Act of 2015. This was very controversial because it creates administrative offensive that have a dissuasive impact, a significant dissuasive impact. both when it comes to expressing one's opinion, and for journalists who are filming the acts of the police, and for the public to actually be informed of these acts. Furthermore, the Constitutional Court was allegedly tempted to reduce the application of the scope of Articles 36 to 2036-23 in relation to the filming of law enforcement officers, stipulating that the prohibition to film can only be applied when there's a specific danger for the agent in question. My question, therefore, is, what's the status of the reform of this act and the problematic offenses that I mentioned, or the lack of respect towards authority? How many convictions on the basis of these offenses have been issued since the entry into force of this law, and what kind of sanctions have been handed down? According to my information, in 10 years, there have been around 300,000 convictions on the basis of this Public Security Act. and in particular on the basis of three particular provisions: resistance, disobedience, and refusal to identify. But I just want to be very clear that those figures that I have shared are precise and exact. I would like to also refer to something that my colleague Mr. Taraya raised, and concern has been brought to our attention which relates to the use by the authorities of undercover agents, infiltrados. They act like undercover agents in groups and social movements to observe, spy, and gather information on how they operate. This outside of any, as Mr. Teraya said, outside of any kind of criminal procedure. The this police undercover action has been noted in Barcelona, Valencia, Madrid, for example, and the practice has been explicitly recognized by the Ministry of the Interior. This is a very this is a great concern because it takes place in the most complete secret, outside of any kind of legal framework, any judicial guarantees and are covered, if I have understood correctly, by the 1968 Official Secrets Act. So in addition to the questions raised by Mr. Taraya, I would like to add the following: this dangerous practice of undercover agents, is it still used? And what recourse or appeal do victims of these acts have? On question 24, I am focusing on freedom of expression and the offences included in the criminal code, such as the glorification of terrorism or others that have been mentioned. According to information we've received, this offence, for example, of glorification of terrorism, has been used in 2024 against two Palestinian activists. If I've understood correctly, one case has been closed and another is still pending. with a procedure underway. Yet it would seem that reforms of the criminal code have been under discussion with a view to decriminalizing this use of freedom of expression, and our Committee would therefore like to know what the status of these reforms are in order to restrict, that would restrict to as far as possible and keep with keeping with Article 19, the usage of criminal law when individuals exercise their freedom of expression. Such as we've seen in the case of Andy Side versus Roux, which also covers the aspect of ideas which offend, shock or disturb. I'm referring now to question 25 relating to the judiciary. To this end, I'm looking at the second report, the compliance report of GRECO. This is a European Union body. This report was released on 16 April 2025. And just to pick up on some of their findings, the general conclusion is quite severe because GRECO notes that none of the 19 recommendations has been implemented or dealt with in a satisfactory way. So, some of these recommendations, for example, are that work related to requirements on transparency and integrity of advisors are currently at, are still at the early stage, so the goal of transparency has not been fulfilled. GRECO also regrets that the draft bill on transparency and integrity of interest groups has not been adopted. It further adds that the implementation of amendments of Act 19/2013 on transparency, access to information and good governance has not been fully completed. And finally, there's the revision, the fact that the revision of the disciplinary regime for the police and the Guardia Civil to improve transparency and objectivity has not been completed either. In addition, and here's where the judiciary comes in, that combating corruption in the judiciary does not seem to have borne fruit or made much progress over the period that has lapsed. It would seem that in 2025, after a five-year stalemate, political parties finally agreed on establishing the General Council of the Judiciary. This delay had been significantly criticized by the Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers in 2024, and she raised the fundamental role normally that the Council should play in all aspects of a judge's career. And this delay has therefore had significant knock-on effects on the independent and impartial functioning of the justice system and the principle of separation of powers. More generally speaking, a reform of the Organic Law has been launched, but according to what I've read in the Spanish press, even as we're speaking, judges and prosecutors have gone on strike from the 1st of July, so this very week, to protest against this reform because it's likely to undermine their independence. So my questions to this end are to know, first of all, if the General Council of the Judiciary is operating fully and in full independence of any majority or opposition parties? Secondly, what is the goal of the reform of the organic law on the judiciary that seems to displease the judges and prosecutors? And any information you can send to the Committee on this, of course, would be very welcome. And then finally, what measures are being taken to ensure that this draft reform of the Organic Act respects both Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights and Article 14 of our Covenant on the independence of judges in all aspects of their career, from their appointment to the end of their career, through the disciplinary regime as well. Thank you. CCPR · Chair [52:32]: Thank you very much, Madame Tigris. So we have completed the second round of questions, so I'll give the 15 minutes to the delegation. to prepare the answers. So, meeting is suspended for 15 minutes. Okay, good afternoon. I will resume the session. Before we get to the replies, I want to say a couple of things. The interpreters sometimes have difficulties, you know, because you speak so too fast. So I hope I can speak a little slow. I may give you some more time if it is necessary. I know it's a limited time, you have to convey many messages to us, but interpretation is very important, so please understand that aspect. And second one is, forgive me, i take my jacket off. This room is really hot. For those who follow online, don't feel, don't understand how hot this room is, so I just allow the delegation members also take jacket off, you know, it's unbearable, okay? Please. Okay, wonderful. So now, no, it's difficult to concentrate when the weather is too hot, so I'll give the floor to Mr. Gomez. You have one hour, but you may have some more time. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:18:15]: Thank you very much, Chairman, and thank you for your climate clemency and for your flexibility. We take note also of what you said about the interpreters and their work. Yes, we are trying to pass through the most amount of content in the least amount of time, but sometimes that becomes a problem and actually more becomes less. So we will pay attention to that. Now, to respond to the questions from the committee, we'll do as we did yesterday. We'll divide the content into numerous blocks. The first was broad, albeit with a great deal of detail, regarding those deprived of liberty. On that topic, I'll give the floor to the Ministries of Interior and Justice. I ask that they Stay within 12 minutes total. Floor is yours. Thank you. Spain · Representative, Secretariat for Penitentiaries [1:19:13]: Thank you very much. Good morning. Responding to the doubts expressed by Mr. Quesada in particular, but to other members of the Committee as well. Again, deprivation of liberty. I'll try to be brief, of course, and I will try to speak more slowly to facilitate the work of the interpreters. There were numerous questions regarding the penitentiaries. Indeed, Mr. Quesada was talking about health care in prisons. This is one of the priorities of our Secretariat for Penitentiaries. We recognize the problem. The number of doctors and allied medical professionals is a problem. We do need to understand this within the context of the whole medical reality in society and the country. and Europe on the whole, really. The issue of medical care in prisons is part of that. We discuss this issue and share realities with others from other countries in the Council of Europe. We know that this is a problem, a shared problem. The UK has these problems, as do Holland, and France, and Portugal. That is to say, a dearth of doctors. In our case, in Spain, it's true that there is a law from 2003 in which health care is provided not by the state, but the central government, but by the autonomous communities. And we still have not seen enough doctors in all of the penitentiaries and all of the autonomous communities, Catalonia, the Basque Country, and also Navarra. have what they need. However, the central government continues to provide medical support with its own resources in all penitentiaries and the other autonomous communities. This guarantees the essential quality care for all of those deprived of liberty. However, measures are being adopted to address the dearth of doctors in all of the prisons. Technology is one possibility. One of the few positive things that we've seen with COVID-19 is the use of telemedicine. That worked quite well during 20 and 21, and that's something that has remained a lingering asset. We have a system called the GAT, G-A-T, that's the acronym. And we see this system assisting or helping to make sure there's a remote doctor available 24 hours a day, 24/7 for all prisons that are under the general central government administration. Now, we are also working with the autonomous communities to make sure that their roster of medical professionals is enough for them to operate autonomously. There's the technology issues, there are agreements with all the autonomous communities to address this technologically. That is to say, it is possible to have access to all of the medical files inside and outside of the penitentiaries to be able to address any pathology, any illness suffered by the inmates. We also provide emergency care through the hotline 112. And we coordinate with the police as well for urgent medical transfers when it is necessary to bring inmates to hospitals. All penitentiaries have a local hospital that they work with for more serious medical conditions, so they can get to those hospitals quickly. Also, annually, all vacancies are being addressed to try to fill the rosters for doctors in all prisons. When we talk about penitentiary health care, the other professionals, not just doctors, other medical professionals to support nurses, we almost, we have 90, 95% completion in those rosters. That also helps to provide proper medical attention to the inmate population. There was another mention of experiments, I think was the term used, with inmate population in Huelva and Córdoba. Let me be very resounding and clear here. Any experimentation on inmate population is prohibited. There is no experimentation on inmate population. However, should – yes, there are scientific studies that are being conducted with all scientific guarantees and tools in the free population, in the non-prison population, and there are universities and entities that, with their scientific parameters, do ask the penitentiary officials for authorization to continue to study specific items in the penitentiaries. For example, Huelva and Cordoba, the experiment on people with violent conduct and a study with people who voluntarily want to participate. The voluntary nature of this is the same in prisons as it is with people out in general population society. There can be a study and analysis. It might be gender violence. It might be drug addiction studies. These studies are very interesting and helpful for scientific specialists in universities, for academia, or accredited bodies as science agencies when they have a population group that wants to participate in a study, whether it's inside or outside of prisons. This is This is done along the same lines. The idea is that people that are volunteering and want to help, for example, in drug addiction, people that want to solve these problems or people that want to help these studies of gender violence, and having a control group on a given item under study that is that is conducted, whether it's an issue of violence or addiction or drugs. As I've said, the amount of things that can be studied in such scenarios, scientifically speaking, is relatively endless. Now, mechanical subjugation, this is a coercive measure that is regulated in the law on penitentiaries. There's the mention of that includes, for example, handcuffs. Since this is a -- as regards mechanical subjugation, they can be more invasive. For example, when a person needs to be fully contained or subjugated, for example, the use of straps. as is used in the psychiatric scenarios or settings, sometimes that can be less harmful than handcuffs, straps, that is. All guarantees are in place to protect individuals from coercive measures. Legality, minimal intervention and proportionality in the use of these There are guidelines on these in all cases. Now, in the matter of straps, mechanical subjugation, there's a specific protocol for the use of straps dating to 2018. Yesterday, Madame Tagrouja mentioned that there were recommendations from the – she mentioned the national protection mechanism, and our protocol does look at the criteria used by the national protective mechanisms from 2017. That protocol, both protocols, both documents are public. Bear in mind, in the case of mechanical subjugation, sometimes in the case of the most extreme cases with extreme violence, extreme aggressivity, or mental illness outbreaks, for example, when restrictive measures are necessary or when medical interventions are necessary, tranquilizer, for example, a chemical substance, where there is very specific protocol that has to be followed, all mechanical subjugation that needs to be conducted. It's all videotaped. It's all analyzed. If we look back to 2018 till now, till 2025, there has been a meaningful drop in the use of this, largely because of the work that's been done since 2018 in training the penitentiary facility staff in the use of these as a last resort when someone does need to be restrained. their previous protocols for previous de-escalation prior to resorting to these methods. In the training period in 2023 and 2024, we did address exactly that. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:29:12]: I'm sorry, I have to interrupt because otherwise there won't be time for the colleagues. Please be as telegraphic as possible, as precise as you can, so that all ministries can take the floor. Minister of the Interior, please. Spain · Representative, Ministry of the Interior [1:29:26]: Thank you very much. We can continue now with the issue of incommunicado detention. As regards this reality, there's a reform in 2015 to incorporate international law, a European directive on communication with third parties and consular authorities. The European Council has not established any infractions as a result of deficient use of this or implementation of this directive in Spain. We believe that we are in step with the norms as a result of this as well. This reform in our Council of Ministers, in the Council of Europe, that is, cancelled all oversight procedures that were open as a result of previous cases in Spain where there was alleged non-investigation of cases of torture. in the case specifically of incommunicado detention, so we are fully in step with the EU and the Council of Europe. Now, these are full exceptions. There are medical protocols to ensure that those who are in incommunicado detention, they must be visited twice per day by medical forensic authorities when they are in incommunicado detention. the right to consular attention cannot be restricted at all. For minors, for example, there is a draft law in criminal procedures indicating or establishing that these protocols, the two visits, for example, by two visits by day, are established by law. And there is over there's oversight mechanisms in place to ensure that there's transparency in the incommunicado detention. This is for those that are detained and also for those that are involved in the process. Legislation is fully aligned with the European standards and the standards from the Council of Europe. It is thus that reform will, there's reform that has added guarantees to this, but the concept of incommunicado detention is still in place to the degree that other rights of protection might be undermined. Thank you very much. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:32:05]: There were questions on combating human trafficking, and I'll give the floor to representatives of the Ministry of Equality and Ministry of the Interior. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Equality [1:32:18]: Thank you, Ambassador. On the question on this, the quantitative study on trafficking in persons, the Committee is referring to the macro study on trafficking, prostitution and exploitation of women. This was a quantitative study that was promoted by the government to combat gender violence, and it's published on the website since the end of 2024. The goal of this study was to try to find out roughly how many women were in a situation of prostitution in Spain and where they're located, and to have an initial estimate of how many women are at risk of being victims of trafficking with a view to sexual exploitation and the number of victims of trafficking for sexual exploitation. I'll give you a bit of an outline for the results of the study because there was also a question on the results. This study was focused exclusively on analysing the adverts for prostitution on websites. and following a process and looking at data and trying to establish what was false and what was true. We had around 140,000 adverts. Some of these were related to women in prostitution, others transsexual women in prostitution, and 1.8% men in prostitution. by Porerades on ages, they were mostly people between 18 and 24. This was the age group that had most women in prostitution, and there is a significant number of women who are from Latin America. 16%, according to our study, are women from Europe. According to the distribution, the Balearic Islands has the highest number of women prostitution, followed by Catalonia. There are between 9,000 women at risk of trafficking for sexual exploitation, which is between 8 and 50% of the total women in prostitution. in 2023, there may have been between 152,000 and 184,000 women in prostitution. On the processing of the law against trafficking, this draft bill before 2024, was part of the previous legislature, and this preliminary draft bill has been resumed. There's a general approach that is being embraced, moving towards criminalisation, and we're also looking at prevention and raising awareness within society, as well as to try to find out more about certain rights to ensure that these women have support for their children and any dependents, for female victims. Along with the Ministry of Equality and co-sponsors, we have co-sponsors in the Ministry of Interior through Parliament and the Ministry of Inclusion, Social Security, and Migration. Currently, this preliminary draft bill is being negotiated within these co-sponsoring ministries. Regarding the public hearing from civil society and participation in this preliminary draft bill, the public hearing section has been concluded. We have significant numbers of contributions, and in the file on the act, we also have a section on a collective of over six civil society organizations in Spain. In July of 2025, negotiations are taking place. Following, there'll be a consolidated text to ensure that meetings are held with experts and associations, and then ultimately in September, it will go through the legislature and calling for appropriate work from the Council of the Judiciary, the Council of State, and so on. And then finally, on the question on the national mechanism, we can say that yes, the preliminary draft bill provides for a national mechanism which would send victims to specialised services, and this is in step with the new directive on trafficking adopted in 2024 and recommendations from expert groups against trafficking, the GRETA group under the Istanbul Convention. Thank you very much. Spain · Representative, Ministry of the Interior [1:37:04]: Yes, good morning. Speaker 26 [1:37:06]: Microphone, please. The interpreter needs a microphone, please. Spain · Representative, Ministry of the Interior [1:37:20]: I wanted to pick up with human trafficking, addressing the question raised by Mr. Terraya on a potential lack of criteria on trafficking. This currently relates to the security forces. It's important to bear in mind this criterion because identifying a victim of trafficking allows them to be afforded appropriate protections, opportunity for return, opportunity to receive authorization for residency and work, and a whole host of other connected rights, as well as monetary support and social support. On this question, obviously, it's an issue that is streamlined nationally. There are a number of courses that are shared or rolled out with the security forces, and they address this across the board. This when they come on board, as well as continuous learning and for promotion. Since 2011, we have a single national document which is a framework protocol on trafficking. This includes identification of criteria or indicators that need to be borne in mind to assess whether there is a victim of human trafficking so that they can be appropriately identified. For example, need to analyze a number of behavioral indicators, any fear that they can show, any hesitancy, other indicators. are on the place where they have been intercepted, on any false information that has been provided, any relationships or friendships that they might have with the person who is allegedly responsible for the trafficking, any indicators connected to the mode of transport, the lack of documentation and inability to freely communicate with family and friends, any other aspects of background that could be relevant. This is just an example. So I can assure you that the security forces are now trained in identifying victims. They have objective, streamlined criteria in order to be able to identify victims. Thank you very much. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:40:00]: Thank you. The next round of questions raised related to treatment for foreign nationals, asylum seekers, and migrants, and for child migrants. There were many detailed questions here. The delegation will do its best to identify those that they can answer. Once again, I would ask you to be very telegraphic in the information you share. I'll give the floor to the Ministry of the Interior on inclusion. and migration, and then on childhood. We have around six minutes for these answers. Spain · Representative, Ministry of the Interior [1:40:38]: Good morning once again. From the Minister of the Interior, we will address the questions on migration that fall within our remit. A number of questions have been raised. The first pertains to alternative measures to internment in centres. in these migrant holding centres. First and foremost, I'd like to highlight that entering a migrant holding centre is the last resort, and this would be in the case of a foreign national who is going through a return or deportation process. This only happens in cases of irregular. Residency. So, for example, there could be cases of flights, there could be cases where an individual could face a risk if they were to be deported or if there is a risk for public health or security. In these cases, we, under Article 70, there are a range of provisions that are alternative to entering a migrant center. This could be to be held for 72 hours, withholding their foreign national documents, or the obligation to remain in one specific place. And this is as long as this person with irregular status has a process underway to ensure that there is no fine that is imposed on the temporary migrant holding centers. Although these are different to the internment centers, these are detention centers with a maximum duration will be 72 hours. A foreign national is held under a regime of detention here, we were asked what is the legal provision for this, or what legislative framework exists to regulate the operations of these temporary holding centers. Well, to date, there's no specific regulation as such for these temporary centers, but because it's not necessary in that these centers are answerable to the commissariat in the local area where they belong. So their legal regime will reflect the same that they have within the police stations and will have to align with the corresponding protocols. So they will be given food and drink in the same way as they would if they were held in a police station. and each individual that is in Spain with an irregular status will be held initially before the launching of a deportation process. There was a question on overcrowding. I can tell you that this is not true. The average occupation rate in these centres in 2024 does not exceed 30%. So you can see that we cannot talk about overcrowding, and in fact, it could hold three times as many as it currently does. Now turning to asylum applications, there was indeed an episode, an ad hoc moment that has been overcome, where between November 23 and January of 2024, There was a mass arrival of foreign nationals at the airport of Barajas in Madrid that asked for international protection. Measures were taken. We expanded the asylum rooms from two to four. One of them was restricted for women, reserved for women and girls. So we also tried to ensure that We sped up the process for asylum applications, and protocols were passed with the National Refugee Agency. to try to optimise the work at Barajas Airport. So there was a swift solution provided to that mass influx, and that is no longer the case. On Fuerte Amalia, I must highlight that a few months ago, a joint instruction came into force between the Secretary of State on Security and the Subsecretariat of the Interior that established that in Fuerte Amalia priority would be placed on processing asylum applications of those who accessed regularly. So Spain is placing priority on the group of people who have entered irregularly. And on the Canary Islands, there's been an influx of individuals in the past few years. Between 2023, around 38,000 arrivals, and 2024, around 46,000. arrivals, and this has required a significant effort by the administration to try to deal with this challenge, to try to streamline access to international processes. There is a plan that's been rolled out in cooperation with the police in order to strengthen resources, and this includes a specific plan for minors across the And we're working with the Secretary for Migrations to ensure the placing of asylum seekers so that they can have access to that aforementioned procedure. Thank you. And I need to give the floor to the next ministry, Ministry of Inclusion, Social Security and Migration. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Inclusion, Social Security and Migration [1:47:20]: I'm going to refer to the conditions referred to in migrant centres. It's true that, as my colleague from the Ministry of the Interior said, in Spain we've seen a significant spike in the number of arrivals in the past number of years, particularly in the Canary Islands. To this end, the Ministry on Migration has made an effort to expand its capacity to be able to welcome migrants that arrive on the islands. We have two programs in place for migrants who have arrived. a humanitarian program, which is specifically geared at those who arrive to the coast and those who request international protection. For example, people who across Spain are asking for asylum and say that they do not have the economic means to be able to support themselves, and they therefore fall into the slots for humanitarian assistance and the international protection system. For international protection in 2015, we had 920 places across Spain. Currently, there are 34,000 places. that Spain has increased to in order to respond to the huge spike in individuals calling for international protection. This is principally through the various crises that we've seen for people coming from Syria, Ukraine, Afghanistan, and the mixed flows that we also see with people coming from Canaries. We have tried to balance out these places in the Canaries, and we've opened four large centres on the mainland to try to house those people that arrive in the Canaries. We have a centre for 5,700 so far, and since it opened in November of 2023, around 35,400 people have been have benefited from the centre. I'd also like to highlight the effort made by the Minister of the Interior and the Ministry on Migration to try to open an exceptional procedure so that people who get to the Canaries and were not able to formalise their request for international protection, given the lack of capacity to respond to all of these requests in that area, one of the Ministry of Migration centres, we have made it possible to process individuals who are in Canaries and who find themselves in one of the centres on the mainland. In coordination with the Ministry of the Interior, the National Police, and the Office for Asylum and Refugees since February 2023, 3,704 people's requests for international protection have been processed. Thank you. And I give the floor to the Ministry for Children and Youth. Spain · Representative, Ministry for Children and Youth [1:50:49]: Good morning, everybody. Thank you. Well, I'm going to focus on the previous cluster on people deprived of their liberty, in particular minors. and questions on migration and unaccompanied minors. So that I don't change the structure too much, I'll begin with the measures taken by the government regarding unaccompanied minors and the exceptional situation that we're seeing in the Canaries, as well as other places such as Menorca. Since the establishment of the Ministry of Youth and Childhood in 2023, Our government has been firmly committed to defending minors' rights, particularly the rights of migrant minors who are very vulnerable, and the strategy passed in May 2023 on the rights for children and adolescents. A number of specific measures have been passed to establish a protection framework for child migrants. the ambassador said yesterday, Spain is a very decentralised state, so we have the autonomous communities who have their own systems. There is a framework for cooperation and coordination. And we've been working on a protocol to ensure that there is a hub across in each part of the country, and in 2022, there was a number of contingencies that have been passed, a model which involved the collaboration of a number of autonomous communities. In April, we passed the Royal Decree 2/2025, through which we passed emergency measures to ensure the best interests of the child in cases of exceptional migration situations. This royal decree establishes a series of criteria to be able to ascertain at what stage a minor can be welcomed within an autonomous community, regardless of their origin or their nationality. This is just the foundation for the protective system. Once it's been established that these minors can be welcomed in by the autonomous community, then they can be part of the system. But often the autonomous communities are dealing with a number of minors that are beyond their capacity. So what we're doing is trying to redistribute the load across Spain. At the moment, there are a number of sectoral conferences and seminars, and there's a process that's underway, administratively speaking, to be able to pass laws. So we're waiting to see adoption of the regulation so we can establish what each autonomous community is capable of doing. in the face of this exceptional circumstance and what support they require. This Royal Decree also provides for around 100,000 euros of support for all of these autonomous communities that are reporting excess costs in order to be able to deal with the excess incapacity and the numbers of migrants. For the Ministry of Children and Youth, we're working in the Canary Islands because of this huge influx. We are mindful that obviously minors there will not be able to enjoy the same services that they could in other autonomous communities because they're saturated. We're also therefore working on our royal decree for minimum standards and quality to ensure that there are minimum baseline criteria in each autonomous community in Spain. This also ties in with one of the question raised in a previous cluster. This royal decree establishes directives for training, for professionals, establishes measures on how to guarantee a whole host of rights for minors, but of course I just have to insist that these are minors regardless of where they come from. What we're trying to do is just to ensure that all the centres for minors, whether it's an initial reception, that we ensure that minimum rights are granted to these minors. In this Royal Decree, more weight is given to those who are perhaps single panels, there's a focus that is placed on having some kind of plan for departure, for employment, try to prepare the minors for independent life, for autonomous life once they have to leave the center. And I know I'm running out of time, but I'm just going to pick up on the other round of questions related to the visit that took place with the mechanisms for the prevention of torture to a minor center. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:57:28]: Bueno, muchas gracias. Thank you very much. CCPR · Chair [1:57:33]: Bien, gracias. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [1:57:36]: Thank you. The next statement is from the Ministry of Justice along these same lines, please. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Justice [1:57:48]: Thank you very much. I'm going to speak on the age determination procedure. This relates to a number of parameters that have always been respected, of course, the presumption of being a minor, and also the principle that any evidence that is gathered or any tests that have to be conducted are non-invasive. We can, of course, imagine that you may be concerned about certain processes, but I can say that any reports are not true. We have requirements where there are minors who want to be considered as adults because when they're considered as adults, they can work in Spain and send money home to their families. So we have a process which is actually Completely the contrary. If there are minors who are minors, well, they need to be declared as such. In Spain, we have a network of specialized prosecutors in trafficking and smuggling of migrants, and this is connected to this very issue. There's an internal network across a number of specialized prosecutors to be able to establish shared protocol, shared criteria. in order to ensure accreditation of age as part of these cases where we need to determine age, and when there's a particular doubt, their advice is requested. And as things stand, we have a draft bill to amend the civil proceedings to be able to guarantee and protect the rights of minors in age determination procedures. So we're moving from an administrative process to a legal civil procedure with all of the associated guarantees. And during the case, the presumption of being a minor is upheld, the right to be heard, and processes can only be initiated when the minor Age has been repealed. In any case, all minors will have the right to free legal aid. Thank you. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:00:21]: Thank you. The next round of questions relates to questions raised on freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association. I give the floor to the Ministry of Justice and the Interior. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Justice [2:00:46]: Thank you very much. And briefly, as regards the progress that have been made in regulations and that are being produced, there is a draft law that is being pushed to the parliament right now, or being addressed in parliament right now. What it does is eliminate the article from the criminal code that addresses the issue of religious feelings. Now, behind this law, or this trap law, the idea is to address the doctrine in the European Court of Human Rights, specifically the limits of criticism of religious sentiments. There's jurisprudence on this. and references made as well to the limitations on hate speech. This is something that the state is now addressing. There are mechanisms still in place that protect the fundamental right to religious freedom through numerous articles of the criminal code and also through civil legislation as well. So this is one of the most significant changes we've brought to legislation. Now, terrorism. We will be sending along all of the argumentation that we have included in our note. I can't Or rather, we won't be sending that along anew. It's already in our information sent along. But in 2020, we saw an inflection point in which we indicate very clearly that the criteria to be evaluated by a judge are not exclusively the content, the forms of emission, and the effect of the message, but also a longer, a broader series of parameters in step with European human rights courts. controversial content in a democratic society, legitimate political opposition, whether there can be a discouragement of freedom of expression, etc. So this has led to policies to fight the the fight terrorism, and I'm looking at all of the sentencing from this year and the past year, and in all of these, the issue of glorifying terrorism and pushing back against this, there is always the issue of a clear threat that goes beyond the limits of legitimate free expression. There are additional elements that lead to these convictions and the sentencing. So working with the European on the European level, we have been able to very much incorporate that content into our rulings. Thank you very much. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:04:13]: Minister of the Interior. Spain · Representative, Ministry of the Interior [2:04:15]: Very briefly, I would like to refer to the organic law for the protection of religion. Spain is a democracy with full respect for fundamental rights. We see this in the Second National Plan for Human Rights, in place since 2023, covering through 2037. On the Organic Law of the Protection of Citizen Security and Safety, this is an administrative measure. It does not have a criminal aspect. Secondly, as regards the infractions that Madame Tigrerouja mentioned, authorities of the State do not They do not, the state is not the, the courts are not the only ones to hand down a ruling. There are other appeals processes that are available. There are two articles in particular, 26.6 on disobedience and resistance, and another as well that addresses the use of images. This data is all published by the Ministry of the Interior. And since this law has been in place, beginning with 26.23, there is data that is clear on this, and this covers the entirety of our territory. And in 26.6, on resistance and disobedience, things are rather linear there as well. 2,000, 3,000, 18,000 this year, or 12,000, 13,000, 18,000. There, we see that Madam Tugurja has focused her attention on the increase in administrative sanctions. We have to interpret the concrete moment in which these sanctions came, not criminal, but administrative, and this had to do with the pandemic and with the exceptional reality on freedom of movement. Those sanctions, we do see spread throughout the country, and El Ocio is where we saw the most administrative sanctions. Now, the organic law on citizen protection, citizen security, We currently have a ruling from the Constitutional Tribunal dating back to 2021, in which the Chief Justice of that court proposed both two resolutions, and they backed, they ruled in favor of the constitutionality of both. So it's not just vos populi. It is in the Parliament right now. They are making modifications, specifically in the Chamber of Deputies, and then after that, it will go to the Senate. But that's another realm. Administratively and technically, we handle things, but then legislatively, that's handled in the Parliament. Thank you. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:07:25]: Thank you. We will ask for the Ministry of the Interior that has not been able to complete their responses to circle back to the first block. devolution of the border, other border incidents, both in Ceuta and in Melilla? Spain · Representative, Ministry of the Interior [2:07:45]: Thank you very much, Ambassador. Yes, succinctly, in devolution of the border, trying to be telegraphic in my responses, I would like to indicate that this is a tool that is used in Ceuta and Melilla. The unique nature of these national territories, which are beyond the Schengen space in Africa, they have a series of unique circumstances that required unique measures adapted to those realities. The devolution or pushback, really, at the border. which is covered in the 10th article of the rights and freedoms of foreigners in Spain, is backed by the European Court of Human Rights. From 2020, in a ruling, there is a reference that guarantees as well the fourth protocol. It's also backed by the Council of Europe. This has been echoed by the Constitutional Court. Spain does work in step with these instruments. There have been sad incidents in Tarajal and in Melilla as well. Spain has shared in the pain and condemned this type of action, which really just shows the gravity of the abuses that take place by these criminals on vulnerable populations. In Tarajal, There was an escalation of judicial rulings. There have been an increased amount of cases before the investigative judges, but also in the provincial courts and even the Supreme Court, according to news that I have. They are being – the matters are being appealed before the Constitutional Tribunal. Now, in terms of jumping the fence in Santa María, there have been two investigations by the prosecutor’s office as well as by the ombudsperson’s office. The ombudsperson – both bodies closed the cases. Thank you very much. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:10:13]: Thank you very much. Penitentiary. Would your team like to mention penitentiaries for women? A question was asked on that matter, please. Spain · Representative, Penitentiary Administration [2:10:29]: Yes, thank you. On this issue of women in isolation. Members of the Committee mentioned the existence of the two penitentiaries. The administration in the Basque Country and Catalonia have their own facilities. There is one in Barcelona that is exclusively a women's penitentiary also. That doesn't mean in modern penitentiaries in Spain that have their modular, that doesn't mean that we don't see all manner of of modules specific for women within a bigger prison facility. There might be 14 to 16 wings, really, and there are some that are specifically for women. In the case of numbers of women in the general central government penitentiaries, there are currently more than 5% are women. So it's a minority population. At any rate, the Penitentiary Administration does address the realities of women, recognizing specifically their realities to facilitate the possibilities for them. There is a program, Ser Mujer, to be a woman, and this has been in place for almost 20 years. The idea is to help women specifically or to be able to detect cases of domestic violence that these women suffered, detecting as well cases of prostitution, and also the idea is to provide tools specifically so that these women, once they're released, to not suffer from these realities. The gender perspective is very much borne in mind. When looking at the issue of suicide in prison, from 2014, there was an administrative decree for all penitentiaries, specifically to address the issue of gender perspective in the matter of suicide in prison. In 2022, this is all published. We can send along information as well. But this is being addressed. I'm not sure whether that's, yes, 30 seconds for the issue of isolation. I think that there was perhaps a mistake in the understanding of the concept. There are those in first degree, there are just 400 in the entire prison state administration, and this in every three months, less than the six months, which is normal. This is revised. And the first degree regime is governed by a specific program from 2011 that has not only been backed but has received the support from the European, the Council of Europe's torture unit. The idea is to work with this most conflictive group. Isolation is a method to separate someone when there is an immediate conflict. That just lasts minutes or hours. That's a separate issue. That's a very acute use of isolation. of isolation, and that's covered in our 1996 penitentiary regulations. I think that Mr. Casella was referring to this as well. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:14:02]: Now for the last block of questions, we are looking at the fight against corruption. The Ministry of Justice has four minutes to address that topic. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Justice [2:14:14]: Thank you, Ambassador. Regarding the GRECO report from June 2024, there are 11 recommendations from the experts. Seven were met, and the rest are still pending, the other four. As regards the judicial branch, there were two issues that arose regarding the renewal of the Council of the Judiciary and the naming of magistrates. In June of last year, an agreement was reached between the political forces that were able to name people to those posts. And since then, the 120 vacancies in Spanish courts for magistrates were filled. There was also a renewal of the Supreme Court, for example, by consensus. There's a new process as well for electing the new members of the council for the criminal branch that is being studied by the general counsel of the judiciary. Now turning to the problem of strikes of prosecutors and judges these days, this is within the framework of a broader problem. What we're seeing is that a new selection process is being put into place for prosecutors and judges. The idea is to give priority to written reports. This year, a complete reform is being brought into the creation of new courts. Now, transparency, we would like to reiterate what we said yesterday. Note that any time there's lack of transparency, this can be appealed before the courts, and if the courts order compliance with the civil servants. Now, in the judicial and legislative branch, the same thing. Of course, with the judiciary, there is the issue of privacy and confidentiality. It's covered in the organic law. When someone thinks that they have an interest in having access to given information, there's a process for this. Thank you. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:16:50]: Now, I would like to mention other items tied to the efforts made in Spain to consolidate the rule of law. And just briefly, I will mention first the adoption of the law 222-2023 regarding those that are guilty of infractions and the fight against corruption. There's been a modification of the laws in place for prosecutors to address the matter of judges and magistrates, specifically to ensure that these prosecutors and judges also are in step with regulations when they have undertaken activities that are, have links to political groups, sometimes tied to the legislative branch. We do see that sometimes there's incompatibility, and when that is the case, these are addressed through our oversight mechanisms in the judiciary. Whenever there is incompatibility, there is an oversight mechanism in place to bolster transparency. Also, I would like to note the Plan of Action for Democracy that was adopted in September 2024. And in that, we see 11 specific areas of action and numerous measures. Many have already been undertaken. Protection for informants and two new specialized units in the General Prosecutor's Office have been created. One to fight against public and private corruption. The chief there has been taken up office this week, and there are also efforts to bolster the integrity of the state. And importantly, there is a draft law on transparency and integrity for the interest groups, the lobbies specifically. There is a reform of the organic statute as well for the prosecutor's office to strengthen their autonomy. and to ensure that their mandate is in step with that of the – is in step with the guidelines. There’s another series as well of matters underway, such as the draft law on the open administration and the fifth government plan for an open government. We are then strengthening all of the mechanisms in place for rule of law and for the fight against corruption. I thank the members of the delegation for their efforts. Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman, for your indulgence in time management. We are aware that we have not been able to respond to all of the questions. However, we are willing to complete with a new round. Thank you. CCPR · Chair [2:19:58]: Thank you very much. After we get the follow-up questions, you will have time to respond more. Okay, so the follow-up questions, first I give the floor to Mr. Carazo. Microphone to the speaker, please. CCPR · Committee member [2:20:23]: Thank you to the delegation for those responses. Decorations. that have been withdrawn? An observation. Police decorations that were granted to Guardia Civil members that were later convicted under democratic rule, why have their decorations not been withdrawn? We have reports indicating that there are civil guard members, Galindo, Vaquero, Dorado, and Bayo. They were sentenced to 75 years of prison. Lasa y Zavala in 2000 as well. Why were their decorations, why were their medals not withdrawn, particularly when those medals glorify criminal conduct? This re-victimizes and humiliates the victims of those crimes. Another question, perhaps I could ask for information, specific information, it can be provided in written form, on the human rights treatment of people of African descent in Spain, as the colonial legacy and the real reality currently. Particularly as you are contiguous, you have areas contiguous with the African continent. And in Latin America, there's the issue of independence of areas that also were involved in slavery. Falcone’s book, “Slave of Liberty,” for example, I was just reading that, and that tells a great deal of that reality. Thank you. CCPR · Chair [2:22:36]: Very much. I will give the floor to Mr. Halfar. CCPR · Committee member [2:22:43]: Thank you, Chair, and I do sincerely appreciate the detailed answers from the delegation, the Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Inclusion, Ministry for Children and Youth. Really, we spend a lot of time trying to coordinate our questions. You clearly spend a lot of time trying to coordinate your answers, and that helps us, and we greatly appreciate it. I had one clarification, one response, and then one question I didn't hear answered. So the clarification, there was reference made, and it may have been unclear because of the translation, as to who were being prioritized. I couldn’t – I think in terms of – excuse me, the applications for asylum, I believe that that was those who were regular migrants as opposed to irregular migrants. I just would appreciate clarification on that. There was quite a lot of information in terms of who was being prioritized for processing of their asylum applications. The point I did not hear any information about, although apologies if I missed it, was the bilateral security cooperation agreement with Morocco from 2022. What are its terms? And also, what does it allow in terms of the possibility for individuals who seek international protection to file an application for asylum and how their rights are respected if they are, in fact, returned to Morocco? What I wanted to spend a bit more time on was the discussion on the pushbacks and the questions of the summary returns. So I appreciate the delegation's reference to the European Court of Human Rights case, although it wasn't mentioned, I'm sure you're referring to the Grand Chamber's judgment in ND and NT versus Spain from 2020, which concerns, i would submit, not the entirety of the relevant legal issues. I would first point out that the European Court of Human Rights interpretation of the European Convention does not necessarily govern the application and interpretation of the Covenant. Article 7 of the Covenant contains a prohibition on cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment. It also contains implicitly the provision against non-refoulement for individuals who are at risk of protection. The case against Spain before the ECHR concerned questions of collective expulsion of aliens, a very different issue, and questions about individuals who were seeking international protection and the ability to seek international protection and to have the possibility of submitting such arguments to be considered by the authorities in Spain was not at issue in that case. And indeed, the Grand Chamber majority was quite clear to point out that there are these other remaining obligations under the European Convention concerning the prohibition of refoulement, concerning the right to avoid being exposed to referral that might lead to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. So I would just respectfully suggest that because the European Court of Human Rights has set a particular interpretation of its convention, that does not mean that Spain's obligations under the covenant, which are cumulative, are necessarily limited. And indeed, I would argue they're not limited under the European Convention either. And final point on this, yes, it's the, this is a serious concern. We do understand it. Irregular migration, particularly with regard to the enclaves of Spain, of Ceuta and Melilla. But the problems continue. So the ECHR Grand Chamber judgment was in 2020, and one of the incidents I asked about was in 2022. And indeed, there have been more recent litigation within Spain, including the High Court of Andalusia judgment. I understand now that that's being appealed. But I would say, with respect, that there are other precedents that point in a different direction, so that what I believe the delegation referred to as sad incidents in Tarajal and Melia really do deserve more serious investigation and response than what we've heard here. Thank you very much. CCPR · Chair [2:27:36]: Thank you very much, Mr. Halfar. Now I give the floor to Mr. Taraya. CCPR · Committee member [2:27:46]: Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Chairperson. And it is really hot. If I may say so, we have been misunderstood due to the heat of the moment. I have not yet received about the issue of Catalonia. This is much cooler than Spanish Catalonia, but I would like to raise the issue again. Of course, this is a sensitive issue, but legal assessment can be and should still be made, even in relation to politically charged incidents. If possible, we would appreciate receiving any kind of assessment during this session, if not, We welcome written paper at a later date. Also, I'm afraid that probably I have not yet received the issue of surrender and as an assessment to limit the freedom of speech. While the delegate explained the other justification in relation to the question by Mr. Grugier. Thirdly, I'm very satisfied with the extensive explanation about the trafficking in persons, and I'm also mostly satisfied with the responses in relation to unaccompanied minors, foreign minors. But I just like to confirm my understanding. First, recognizing that the State Party is a decentralized state, I understand that the number of autonomous communities are the first to assume responsibility for unaccompanied foreign minors. Could the delegate clarify approximately how many such communities are involved in the initial reception process? While acknowledging that there may be various variations across regions, would it be correct to understand that these differences remain within a certain acceptable range? Given that some differences in standard may be unavoidable, can the committee assume that certain key principles, such as the presumption of minority, are commonly shared and consistently applied across regions? I also like to appreciate the State Party's detailed explanation regarding a large number of unaccompanied minors in the condition with their care, and I find the answers very, mostly satisfactorily. That said, I would like to raise concern regarding whether the administrative resource of the State Party is sufficient to cope with such huge difficult situation, in particular, given the high number of victims and the fact that the best interest of a child must be assessed individually in each case, I presume that the workload for the authorities is extremely heavy. Could the delegation comment on this point? Thank you. CCPR · Chair [2:31:24]: And I'll give the floor to Mr. Quesada. CCPR · Committee member [2:31:32]: Thank you, Chair. First, I'd like to thank the delegation for the replies and for the very specific information they've shared with us. And I hope that for the questions that haven't yet been answered, that we will receive written replies in the time frame. I have a couple of follow-up questions, perhaps rather requests for clarification. First, relating to these restraint mechanisms for persons who are detained, mechanical restraint mechanisms specifically, and I understood the mechanism given, or the explanation given, the explanation for this, but really my question was on the NPM against torture that issued recommendations on this, and that it would be good to explore more respectful alternatives and reduce the length of time in which these restraints are used. So I'd like to know how you've given effect to the NPM on torture vis-à-vis its observations and recommendations in this area. Secondly, on isolation or incommunicado detention, or rather solitary confinement, I think that there would be, obviously, there are reasons to maintain that in serious circumstances, but there's still a challenge from civil society as to the maximum duration of this measure and the specific circumstances in which a person could be deemed dangerous, and therefore this particular process of solitary confinement would be applied, but I just want clarification. Is this under Organic Law of 1971? And in parallel, there's the question about detention, incommunicado detention as opposed to solitary confinement. So the incommunicado detention can be issued by the investigating judge. So why do you have this incommunicado detention? What is the justification for it? Because here, we're not in a situation where that's a penalty for being dangerous or for offences. I'd like to have clarification, specifically on what circumstances or justification is given for incommunicado detention as provided for in law. Thank you. CCPR · Chair [2:34:51]: Mr. Cazalet, I will give the floor to Madame Tigrisza. CCPR · Committee member [2:35:03]: Thank you very much. I’d like to thank the delegation once again for their very specific answers. They’ve been very rigorous in their answers. I am conscious of the time, so my follow-up questions will perhaps require written replies, particularly on corruption. The answer was brief, so please, if you could send the committee any additional information you have on the implementation of the framework to combat corruption, procedures that are under way and so on. That would be very useful and very important. I have another question, in fact two, in connection with the justice system. First of all, according to information we've received, there are still empty posts in the Constitutional Court, and I wonder why that's the case, and that's if I'm not mistaken, if my information is accurate. The second question I have relates to the reform I referred to, this reform of the organic law on 1985 on the judiciary. This is really I wanted to find out more about what is being implemented. I looked at the website of the Ministry of Justice, and I understand the different modalities of that reform. And if I've understood correctly, there are at least two aspects. First, a reform of the Attorney General's post with, in connection, this future act on prosecution, criminal prosecution. But from what I've seen. And we need to know a bit more about the reform of the role of the criminal prosecution service in this future act on criminal prosecution and the connection with the independence of the. Prosecution service or of the prosecutor. And the second aspect, as you said, relates to the operations of the judiciary, but there's a challenge as to how it perhaps undermines equal opportunities. So reading this webpage, I couldn't quite understand where this criticism as to undermining equal opportunities comes from. So of course, any information that you could send the Committee on that reform that is underway would be very much welcomed. Thank you. CCPR · Chair [2:37:39]: Thank you very much, Madame Tigrisza. Now, these are questions to be raised, and we have 22 minutes, but I need a final 5 minutes for the concluding remarks, so you can spend the rest of the time. You have the floor. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:37:56]: Thank you, Chair. Obviously, we're not going to be able to answer all of these questions. We'll continue the dialogue with the Committee, which we, of course, appreciate. But in the last 22 minutes, we'll try and answer the specific questions that have been raised now. Instead of doing this by block or cluster, we'll perhaps follow the concerns that have been raised by the members of the Committee. And I'd ask the members of the delegation to answer in one minute, please, if If not, I'll have to cut you off. So each of you can have a minute so that we can try to answer most of the questions that have been raised. We'll begin with Mr. Carasso. Perhaps you can answer the question on the medals or the decorations that had been given to members of the security forces. Ministry of Justice, of course. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Justice [2:38:48]: Thank you, Ambassador. This is a provision that is covered in the organic law. this could be applied in the dictatorship and in the Guardia Civil has this possibility open to it, and I imagine that it will be applied. It's a procedure that comes under the Ministry. Referring to the law on democratic memory from 2022. Speaker 60 [2:39:20]: Thank you, Ambassador. Well, Regarding the law, the Democratic Act or the Amnesty Law, we're talking about the decorations. You're referring to a law, but it wasn't clear. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Justice [2:39:34]: So the law 20 of 2022. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:39:36]: Thank you. On people of African descent, the Ministry of Equality, please. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Equality [2:39:43]: Thank you. Just to add. In the Ministry of Equality, as has been said, the Latin American population, population of African descent, and Gitano population, all of the studies would indicate that the perception of discrimination is rather high, so that's therefore a priority for us to tackle. When it comes to political representation, for example, the general director is a Gitana person, and previously it was a person of African descent, and the work on public policy Well, all of the studies underway help to support public policies, not only, but also to help promote the rights of people of African descent. For example, there's work that we've been doing with the Latin American region, Bored Afro, and a network for politicians with people of African descent. This took place in Cartagena in cooperation with the Spanish International Aid Agency. We've also been holding awareness raising campaigns to try to raise awareness with the Afro conference, and there was a conference that was held in Barcelona in 2023. This was very successful. And there's annual promotions that we do in March, for example, an International Day for Elimination of Racial Discrimination, where there are events held to try to raise awareness as to racial discrimination. And specifically, discrimination against people of African descent. And the next event that we'll be holding with other agencies from the state and civil society is the Afro Conference in Madrid, which will be hosted by the Committee of Experts of the Forum for People of African Descent from the UN, organized with civil society organizations. And this will be held in October in Madrid. Thank you. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:41:33]: Thank you. On this as well, I'd have to say that we keep constant communication open with the committee from the corresponding convention when we're submitting our periodic reports. Mr. Helfer wanted clarification on the priority given to asylum seekers. Perhaps you can clarify for us. Spain [2:41:54]: Yes, I think I was answering the questions. Here, we're dealing with people who've arrived in the Canaries irregularly, and therefore they're in irregular status. I'd like to highlight that I don't like to talk about prioritization. These people, because of the large number arriving in Canaries, were unable to formalize their status there, so the Ministry of the Interior made it possible for them to be moved to another place for the application to be submitted, and this is in Madrid. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:42:30]: Thank you. Mr. Helfer also asked about the agreement with Morocco. If anybody can elaborate, then we can do that, otherwise we'll send the answer in writing. Spain [2:42:47]: Yes, on the bilateral security agreement with Morocco. At the moment, any return or deportation procedure to Morocco is processed in keeping with Spanish standards, in keeping with the law passed in 92. And it is this bilateral agreement for any processing needs to comply with the signing State in keeping with the Convention signed in 1992. So we would ask the Committee if we can send you a more detailed answer in writing. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:43:35]: Mr. Helfer also referred to pushbacks and summary returns, and connected issues. I think here we'll get into a legal discussion that will perhaps extend, we don't have enough time for now, but we will come back to this and we'll convey the answers. What I'd like to say to Mr. Helfer is that Ceuta and Melilla are not just enclaves, they are autonomous as cities or autonomous units within the Spanish state. Mr. Terraja? also asked for some clarification on a few questions in connection with the events in Catalonia. We could perhaps give clarification on the undercover agents or the application of the amnesty act. Please, if anybody could elaborate on these particular points. Spain [2:44:43]: On the undercover agents, Mr. Tiraia referred to, if my memory serves, activities of undercover agents. We need to separate two things. One, the undercover agent, and this is regulated in the Criminal Prosecution Act, and this includes oversight, judicial oversight, whereas the undercover where the infiltrator is covered by an Organic Act from 1986. Here I'm talking about the infiltrators. Sorry, I got confused. So this, as I was saying, is from Organic Law 2/1986, and their task of these infiltrators, infiltrados, is to try to gather information with a view to guaranteeing citizen security, public security, and of course, the rights and freedoms of the rest of society. But I want to clarify the difference between an undercover agent and an infiltrator. So the undercover agent relates to the law on criminal prosecution and the other to the law of 1986. Turning to the organic law on amnesty and Catalonia, this act applies to those who promoted or opposed the independence of Catalonia. The second question pertains to the reference or connection of the view issued by the Committee on Puigdemont. This is a different scenario because this view related to 14, 19, 20 and 25 of the Covenant. And under 25, this related only to one particular section as the suspension of his membership of the Assembly. and whether this was automatic. So, the amnesty law does not bring, it does not have any bearing here. This relates to other circumstances. On the application of the Amnesty Act, my colleague will perhaps complement But this relates to the judiciary and the application of the standard and the sentence last week of the 26th of June, it passed the Amnesty Act, apart from three very specific sections, which is not really relevant to the content of the amnesty. And the main questions relate to the fact that the law says that it cannot apply to those who had personal assets, and therefore there's a discussion in the courts as to the diversion of funds. And the other, which is an exception of the law, related to the acceptance of community funds, because in this case, this is a European Union law, and there are questions put to the court to see if they could provide clarification. and they're not applying this until this issue has been resolved, and I think this will be done in September. Just to add to my colleague's comments, a couple of things to bear in mind. We echo the fact that this is a situation where there are a number of questions pending solution by the courts, which obviously is brought to bear on the cases underway. And this is the very nature of the case. The states must adopt, mustn't adopt any provisions that can hamper or distort the case that is underway. These are a number of findings from the court itself. which has issued its opinion on a number of occasions, is also the Article 23 of this statute. And so we find ourselves in this context where we're waiting for this ruling or this finding, and this also, of course, has a bearing on the cases underway. And as my colleague said in connection with this suggestion that we're not applying practice. I also refer to the views regarding the separation of powers, and the conclusion is that administratively, there should be adoption of laws and the judiciary legislation, the commission of The Venice Commission said that as to the annulation or the cancellation of courts, as long as the decision relates to the amnesty, it's down to the judge to decide within the purpose of the law as to the lifting of the pre-trial detention and interim measures. and that there's no issue with the separation of laws, the proposal for amnesty must be applied to ensure that it does not change the result. So it's down to the courts to consider the application of the law in all cases. Those involved can call for support at any moment, the judge can call for postponement until the law establishes that Article 1 of the amnesty law can be invoked. And according to Article 16 of the Amnesty Act, that there needs to be provision of resources as we see stipulated in the legal order. Spanish judges are independent. At the moment, we cannot enter into any discussion on whether or not they are fully applying the law in a specific case. And what's more, we must also share that, contrary to what we're seeing in the popular opinion there in our justice system, it's possible to lodge complaints and have access to appeal. And with that, those would be my comments. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [2:52:25]: Thank you. Mr. Taraya also asked a specific question on minors and the capacity of autonomous communities and any discrepancies. and also whether sufficient resources are available within the system to be able to deal with the issue correctly. Perhaps the Ministry on Childhood and Youth could respond. Spain · Representative, Ministry of Children and Youth [2:52:56]: All autonomous communities can protect minors. The difference is that some autonomous communities that share a land border with Africa or a sea border such as the Balearics or the Canaries, so there are some autonomous communities that, of course, can afford protection to minors, but the problem is that they are saturated, as we've seen in Canaries. On the budget as to whether it's sufficient, probably not. given the excessive burden that we're seeing in the system, but it has tripled from 2023 and 2024. The fund was given 33 million euros, and with the royal decree that's been passed, it's been increased even further. As the ambassador said earlier, we're facing a situation of extension of budgets We're hoping that if we can release the budget, then we can broaden capacity, because that's something that's been mentioned. Autonomous communities have been complaining that they need support to be able to increase capacity, but that. Money is not reaching the autonomous communities. And as part of this draft bill, what we're seeing is that the communities with greatest demand need to be given greater priority. So probably it's not sufficient, but at the moment, it's almost three times what it was before. As to the age issue, if there's no clear indication that a person is not a minor, there's always a presumption that they are a minor. So they will be supported by the autonomous community where they arrive. And then there is a judicial procedure that can be initiated to determine the age, but it They will always be hosted in a temporary fashion and given guardianship by the autonomous community. Thank you. Spain · Representative, Secretariat for Penitentiaries [2:55:39]: Mr. Quesada asked again about the restraint mechanisms used. and what was the response to the NPM on Torture's report. As we'd heard, the current regulation from 2018 relates to the criteria and the recommendations from the NPM of 2017, where alternative measures have been elaborated. It stressed the importance of de-escalating, training personnel, trying to find places where the person could be calmed down. And in cases of serious aggression, they're using mechanical restraints mechanisms. We can send you in writing the statistics from 2018 to 2025. I think there are around 300 cases where it's necessary. The most clearest example, for example, because of health care, where medical treatment is required and we provide a tranquilizer in the same terms as a hospital or in the community. And of course, we're always upholding communication with a judge, and all of this is always filmed. Another attempt has been made, for example, in Catalonia in the circular for 2021, as possibility And their alternative was to place somebody separately, and they found that they had increased numbers of attempted suicide and so on. I don't know if I can really elaborate. Speaker 73 [2:57:33]: You have a minute to distinguish between incommunicado and solitary confinement. Spain · Representative, Secretariat for Penitentiaries [2:57:39]: So I need to highlight the first grid. A regime is not disciplinary, it's rather, and this relates to Article 72, as mentioned by Mr. Kersella, and Article 10 of the legal, of the organic law, where this due, where this mechanism is applied. This is when somebody demonstrates violence or whether committed very serious crimes, suspected terrorists. concrete cases, there is a program where scientific methods are applied. At least 390 people really have been part of this process, 15 women. And this is individualized. This is on a case-by-case basis. If you like, I can send in the Instruction Room 2011. And this regime is revised more frequently. Every three months, it's revised and is subject to legal oversight, to judicial oversight. This is different to the solitary confinement, which is a disciplinary mechanism. There are two people who perhaps punch each other, beat each other up, and then they're separated. And that can be for a maximum of 14 days. But it's controversial when there's successive violations. For example, in the case of 42 days, and the administration followed the recommendation from the NPM that this cannot be consecutive, there needs to be an interruption, there can be a first duration of 14 days, then there needs to be a break and an oversight. And this is separate from the incommunicado detention where there is a five-day maximum duration with a view to ensuring the successful investigation in case that person could be hiding evidence or could be in touch with people who are in the outside world, and therefore to ensure due process, we have that process. That's very specific. For example, a terrorist organization or criminal gang, and for a precise duration, they are held in incommunicado, maximum of five days. CCPR · Chair [3:00:06]: Can we answer in In 30 seconds, the final question. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [3:00:15]: Thank you. Yes, we've completed it then. CCPR · Chair [3:00:23]: I'll now give you the floor back for your short concluding remarks. Spain · Ambassador; Head of delegation [3:00:31]: Thank you very much. I will be very brief and merely thank our thank the entirety of the committee and you, sir. Thank you for the dialogue and for the quality of the questions and the depth of the questions. This is just a phase of this dialogue that we very much hope to continue with you. As I said in my initial remarks, the full guarantee of civil and political rights. It's a process that is never finished. We're very aware of the relevant, very relevant role that the Committee has in helping the State, because that is what you do. You help us to improve our legal framework and our administrative practices as well, so that we can seek to offer these guarantees. Thank you to the Secretariat, to the interpreters as well for their patience, and to my delegation as well for your contributions. CCPR · Chair [3:01:19]: So, thank you, Your Excellency. Over the past two days, our dialogue has addressed key aspects of the implementation of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights for Spain. We commend the State Party for progress in several areas, but on the other hand, there are some concerns raised in some areas. So we appreciate the delegation's efforts in addressing our concerns. and look forward to continued progress toward the full implementation of the Covenant. As per Committee’s standard procedure, the delegation may submit additional information within two working days. This means it should reach the Human Rights Committee Secretariat by Monday, 7 July, at 1:00 PM. Such additional information will contribute to a more comprehensive assessment and will be reflected in our concluding observations. On behalf of the Human Rights Committee, I thank Mr. Excellency, Mr. Marcos Gomes and the entire delegation for constructive dialogue, and I wish you a safe return home. Finally, I would like to thank all the Committee members for their thoughtful interventions and express my sincere appreciation to the Secretariat, in particular interpreters, for the extra time and technical staff for their essential support throughout this session. Thank you all once again for your cooperation and commitment. The meeting is adjourned.