Conference on the Commercial Lunar Landscape and Policy Needs [Meeting 3]
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. As you take your seats, I'll just do a quick housekeeping note. First of all, thank you for those who attended the lovely reception yesterday evening. And for those who have the opportunity to network over coffee this morning, I will note that that coffee will be served until about noon this morning. So if you do need to caffeinate or get a juice or a quick bite, then please feel free to help yourself to the coffee section over there. Before we kick off the first session today, I'd like to welcome Director Arti Halimaini to say a few brief words. Arti.
Hi, good morning, everybody. Welcome back to day two of our conference on the commercial lunar landscape and policy needs. I hope that you enjoyed yesterday and are ready now to hear from industry. I do just want to take a moment to thank once again the permanent missions of Japan and Italy for hosting us last night, and of course our industry partners, ArcEdge, iSpace, and Space Data for giving us the wonderful reception yesterday evening. I feel like the connections made really built on the presentations from yesterday. There was a lot of conversation being generated after hearing all that information across the different work streams. And today, we're going to hear from industry, and that gives me also the opportunity to thank Telespazio and our Italian industry partner for sponsoring the coffee break this afternoon. Before we get started, I did want to say that at the end, we're going to have a wrap up, and it won't just be us wrapping up from here. We would really welcome feedback from the audience because as it was forecast yesterday, we're going to be doing this again next year. But so your feedback really matters, and we would like to hear from you on your main takeaways, suggestions, and any thoughts that you might want to share. So thanks again for being with us, and I'm going to hand back over to Matt to announce the first session. Thank you.
Thank you, Arti. Now we'd like to kick things off today discussing issues related to lunar orbit. So I'd like to ask Clive in the first panel to please come to the dais.
All right, good morning, everyone. Yesterday was a major information dump, and it took a lot to, it was a lot to take in. But I want to just give you a warning that today may be just as much fun. This is what we're trying to do here, is to get the information from commercial and industry partners that what their needs are and how to move forward together so that we can go to the Moon in a sustainable and hopefully stay there in a permanent way. This session is about lunar orbit. And I just want to read you what it says in the program, because it may help focus the questions. Lunar physics presents multiple challenges stemming not just from the relatively smaller size of the Moon compared to Earth, but also due to the instability of Sun lunar orbits. Topics will include the risk of collisions between assets in lunar orbits, opportunities for their interoperability, lunar traffic coordination, and plans for their safe disposal. And we want to hear about this from the commercial perspective, given the number of relevant UN working groups that are working on the international regulatory framework for the international enthusiasm for lunar exploration. And it's been, from my viewpoint as a lifelong lunatic, seeing how many people and how many nations want to go to the moon or are interested in going to the moon is very gratifying, and have this body try and unify those efforts is something that may take a miracle or it may not, because when we all go together, everybody is going to win. So I'm joined on stage by three industrial commercial representatives, one from Italy, one from Canada, and one from the United States. You will be able to tell that, that he and I are both from the United States from our American accents. I will briefly introduce each panelist, and then they will have five minutes each, and I'm going to be timing you, to tell us about their respective companies, and then we will commence with our panel discussion. So, Nicola Pizza Lo Russo.
All right.
Vice President is Vice President of Strategic Planning, Scenarios, and New Initiatives at Tele. Let me guess if I can get this right. Telepazio. And thank you for the coffee. It's much needed today. With over, he has over 15 years of experience in corporate strategy, business transformation, and management control, and therefore he has played a key role in shaping strategic plans leading M&A transactions and driving growth initiatives in the aerospace and space sectors. He is also responsible for the business planning activities of the Moonlight program, a public-private partnership with the European Space Agency aimed at developing a lunar orbiting infrastructure to provide communication and navigation services for upcoming lunar missions. Paolo Pino. serves as Chief Technology Officer at Volta Space Technologies, leading the development of lunar satellites that provide affordable, wireless energy to assets on the lunar surface, with the goal of enabling a sustained and sustainable presence on the Moon. He has a background in space systems, engineering, and has worked on the design of space exploration missions and systems, with a particular focus on lunar exploration. Benjamin Bussey is a planetary scientist who is currently the chief scientist for Intuitive Machines, who was educated in the UK before moving to the United States. He gained both science and mission experience during his 20 years at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. And Ben spent five years at NASA headquarters, which included roles as the acting deputy associate administrator of exploration in NASA's science mission directorate and as the chief exploration scientist in the human exploration and operations mission directorate. He joined Intuitive Machines in 2022. So, gentlemen. Starting with Nicola and going down the line, you have five minutes to tell us about your companies.
Okay. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. Good morning, distinguished delegates, colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. It is an honor and a privilege for me to be here and to contribute to this important panel about the lunar orbit issues. As said by Clive, I'm serving Telespazio. For those who don't know Telespazio, it is a joint venture between Thales and Leonardo. That are two of the major global aerospace and defense players. And Telespazio activities span from midstream to the downstream of the space sector, basically all segments, from Earth observation to satellite communication, navigation, and of course, exploration. Regarding exploration, the exploration domain, Telespazio is mainly active in the engineering support activities for in-orbit operations and space logistics. One of our flagship initiatives is the ESA Space Rider program. We also support microgravity experiments, experimentation on the International Space Station. But let's say in 2024, we sign a major contract with ESA. It was mentioned before, it is the Moonlight program. We are priming a consortium of satellite operators from Italy, Spain, UK, and we have to develop, build, co-fund, actually, operate, launch, and maintain this infrastructure that is going to provide communication navigation services to the future lunar missions. My role there is to, I'm in charge of the business planning, financial modeling, market analysis, and user engagement activities. And this puts me in a very good position to basically be aware that safety, interoperability, transparency are key principles and drivers to address some of the issues we are going to discuss today.
Good morning, everyone. It's a true pleasure and honor to be here. I'm Paolo. Thank you, Kalai, for the introduction. Co-founder, Chief Technology Officer at Volta Space Technologies. Volta is a company from Canada, which has a presence in the United States as well, which is working towards establishing a lunar energy grid. We believe that one of the main enabler of a sustainable and sustained lunar presence, we're going there to stay, as Hiv pointed out before, we think that one of those enablers is energy, and particularly abundant, affordable energy. And we plan to deliver this energy and to make this available globally on the Moon from satellites orbiting the Moon, providing energy to assets wirelessly on the surface using light beams. And this is why we care deeply about the sustainability of orbital operations and all the implications. Volta has been working to develop this capability with the space agencies across the globe, and is going to the moon next year to demonstrate a core element of this infrastructure, and we'll work towards establishing full commercial services. in the years following. So I truly hope that this conversation today can really shed light on how we're approaching this and can establish a fruitful communication with you all so that we can do this in the best possible way. Thank you. Orkiu.
Yes, good morning, everyone. It really is very exciting and slightly intimidating to be here. I am Ben Bussier, I'm Chief Scientist for Intuitive Machines. Intuitive Machines is an aerospace company that really wants to see the Moon brought into sort of the commercial ecosystem. So there are really three parts to the company. There's a delivery component. Those of you that know us probably are aware that we're a lunar lander company. We're part of NASA's Commercial Lunar Payload Services. We've had two missions to the Moon. We have two more planned, one next year. One the year after. Those missions take a mixture of NASA payloads, international payloads, as well as commercial payloads. We also do delivery of orbiters. IM-2 had three small orbiters that were co-manifested on the Falcon 9. We can also drop off orbiters in lunar orbit, which is particularly relevant for what we're going to discuss today. The second pillar of the company is sort of our infrastructure as a service. We're one of three companies competing for NASA's Lunar Terrain Vehicle contract, which is the unpressurized rover. But while that is a rover for the crew, it's also to be used commercially when the crew aren't there. And then the third pillar is lunar communication and PNT, and particularly relevant for today. So Intuitive Machines won a NASA contract to provide communications and precision navigation and timing called NSNS for NASA. As part of that, we are putting up five satellites around the moon that we're building. The first one will fly next year. We'll put two more up in '27, and then numbers four and five will go up a year later. And those will be in high elliptical orbits. And again, they are there to support NASA Artemis, but they're there as a resource for anyone to use. And so we'll be very interested in the topic of orbits around the moon.
All right, thank you, Ben. And to get the ball rolling, I'm going to ask the first question. From each of your perspectives, please tell us your views on the potential risks to missions in lunar orbit as interest, traffic, and also size of craft increase. We'll start with Ben and work down towards Nicola, and then we'll mix it up. So nobody gets too comfortable.
Tricked. Yeah, so first of all, I think it's already a problem. And in a way, it's exciting that we're having enough activity at the Moon that it is something we have to consider. So while we're here mainly talking about orbiters, when we do a lander mission, that lander is an orbiter for several days in lunar orbit before it lands. And so we already have to consider conjunction analysis or conjunction avoidance for our lander missions. As we put the com relays up, and there are multiple countries now that have orbiters around the moon, and there is no single location that one can go to access, predict ephemeris for all those orbiters. So NASA has a system called MADCAP, because it's NASA, it's an acronym, Multi-Mission Automated Deep Space Conduction Assessment Process. obviously. And so MADCAP is run out of NASA JPL, and it handles all the US missions. It will accept ephemeris from other countries, but they're not obligated to do so. And so I think the setting up of something to ensure that we can avoid everything as we're doing either a lander or an orbiter is important.
Yes, it's pretty convenient to be in the middle. I always know when my turn is, unless you change, right? You can be unpredictable. Well, so for us, it's extremely important. I guess, the risks associated to operating satellites in lunar orbit has a direct implication on the unit economics of our business. We operate orbital satellites, orbital assets, and these assets need to provide a service to users, and users will pay Volta. based on the energy that they deliver. So the moment we, for some reason, need to interrupt this operations, or at the moment where operating in lunar orbit is extremely risky and puts the integrity of those assets at stake, it could be a problem for us. And of course, Volta itself, having assets in orbit, can represent a problem for other assets operating, like landers staging in lunar orbit, et cetera. So coordination is extremely important. I think risk of collision is something that we have to be very careful about. I believe the Korean orbiter received about 40 collision warnings in the two years since launching, and then they decided to perform, I think, two or three collision avoidance maneuver out of those 40 warnings. And this, to me, also speaks to something very important, another risk, which is not only the risk of collision, but the risk of having a lot of warnings to deal with. And the number of warnings we're going to receive is somehow dependent on how precisely we can determine the position of our satellites around the Moon. The more precise that determination is, the fewer the collision warnings that we're going to receive and the ones that we will have to worry about. Every time there's a collision warning, of course, teams are activated to assess the threat, and time is spent perhaps designing collision avoidance maneuvers. And so this poses a good amount of challenges for organizations that are operating, and that's something that we have to be very, very careful about.
Okay, I try to get this from maybe a market standpoint. First of all, let's, I mean, this growing interest for the lunar missions, I think that it is clear that we are shifting, basically. This is marking a shift from a scientific exploration phase to a more, I'd say, to the early stage of an industrial lunar economy. And this is something that we should be aware of. And this transition doesn't just involve, I think, space agencies and governments, but also commercial operators. venture-backed startups, and of course, who want to invest in infrastructure. And this basically is a material factor that is affecting the business plan. So going to your, this is, I mean, set the stage. Which are the risks? We already talked about the increase of probability of collision. And from a financial standpoint, this means higher mission assurance. much more flight dynamics, flight operation costs, propellant loss, and also, I mean, lunar operators need to focus on something else and not on their own, on their commissions. All this has an impact on profit and loss, higher cost, higher return, you know, required return, and so not a successful business case for private investors. There is another point, I think it is important, it is permanent debris. I mean, if we start to have you know, this constant and more numerous, you know, assets on orbit, this means that we start to have, you know, these negative externalities and also these enduring shared liabilities. This has, again, an impact for those who want to invest in long-term infrastructure, because the risks of collision is higher. Then there is another point, I think, the last risk is radio frequency congestion. This could, for instance, create a deterioration of SLA. And for those who wants to pursue recurring revenues model, this in game could be something that would prevent from an investment. Maybe I conclude saying that it's not a risk, it's more like a status, the lack of or the gap at the governance and regulatory level. is something that doesn't help in creating a more certain scenario, and uncertainty brings higher costs, higher rates, and this is a chain, you know.
So, gentlemen, if I may summarize, and I want to get your opinion on this summary, and we're going to start with Paolo, just to mix it up. It seems then that you're all in favor of having a unified body to coordinate and regulate this type of activity. Am I correct in saying that? And I'd like your comments on that.
Thank you, Clive. You know, I'm going to play the card, I'm not a lawyer, but it's hard to tell whether it should be a single body or a specific implementation, but I guess the capability that we require is knowledge of those risks, and that probably entails some degree of data sharing, some degree of coordination with as many actors as possible, right? So for us, it's extremely important that information is available, is up to date, is accurate, and reduce uses and mitigates the risk for all the players. So I guess we will very welcome, to answer your question, any effort towards this that enables this coordination across as many actors as possible.
Yeah, not to play semantics, but I'm not sure regulate is the right word. I think, to second what Paolo said, I think it's to ensure that there is a mechanism by which the trajectory data can be shared, so that we all want to not collide with something else. And right now, there's not a process for where do you put those data so others can use it to make sure that they're safe. That's different from regulation. You don't want someone telling you what orbits you can and can't go into. Just subtly, just, yeah.
Good catch. I used the R word. I will not use regulate again, but enable is probably a better way. Nicolas.
Yes, I agree. I agree to the fact that for sure, a highly centralized control is something that would bring overheads, compliance costs. It would kill the commercial momentum, and this is exactly what we don't want. Maybe, for instance, if we talk about space traffic, I wouldn't say management, maybe we say coordination, we maybe should resemble something from the aviation maritime sector. So from models that work actually, where you have distributed, data-driven, and service-oriented mechanisms. You don't need really to command spacecraft, but you need to provide them actionable information, for instance, recommended maneuvers or conjunction or standardized alerts, something that it is in interest of the private, also space agencies, to adopt, not something that would be highly centralized. I think this wouldn't work.
Can I one add on? Everyone might not be aware, there isn't a capability to do to orbit tracking around other bodies apart from Earth. And so we have to rely on those entities, be they government or commercial, who are putting things around the Moon to share that trajectory. It's not something that someone can just go and work out.
I'm going to open it up to questions from the audience. All right, very vigorous hand right there.
Hello, hello.
Please introduce yourself and you.
Pinat Arandan from CosmoBus UK. So I have a question about the safe disposal of comp, like from the orbit. So the main question from my side is, let's say if a company is already working on their project, so how do we make sure that safe disposal can be incentivized? Because most of the companies don't.
Cover the cost of safe disposal.
So my question is, is there any possibility for incentives or something similar like that?
Actually, this is one of the, I mean, we said that permanent, this would imply a higher probability of collision, permanent debris. Here, COPOS could help, actually, and also, of course, national entities should then implement this rule. I mean, the debris, the proper disposal of assets should be not just a compliance check, but it should be part of the business case. I mean, mission planning should have already Delta V budgets, assurance about passivation. And also, you know, a distinctive selection between, you know, stable orbit, gravity orbit, or controlled impact. This is something that, if not, you know, proposed should be, I mean, an operator should not have the, you know, the possibility to launch, because this would put at risk the entire lunar orbit ecosystem. Of course, this is something that could start from a sovereign national entity or from COPOS, then it is up to the national entities to integrate. But again, this is in the interest of everybody, because if you have this permanent debris, you have a systemic risk, you have higher costs, higher return required for your investors, this would kill the commercial entity. So it is in the best interest of everybody.
Thank you.
To add on top of what Nicola was saying, that's absolutely the case that we have a conversation on end-of-life strategies and disposal strategies. Not all strategies are born equal, and that's probably important to specify as well. Doing the maneuvers that takes the spacecraft in a heliocentric orbit, for instance, is more expensive than, in some instances, doing a controlled disposal on the surface of the Moon. On the other side, though, landing on a surface might have other implications. So finding the right balance is probably something worth considering. If the end-of-life strategy is extremely complex, it might have some implication on the feasibility of several missions, but on the other side, we definitely shouldn't let that irresponsible disposal put some other assets or sites or resources at risk.
Yes, just to echo, I think we are self-incentivized because we don't want debris up there. But also, I think it matters what orbit you're in. If you're in a low lunar orbit, even if you fail, you will end up on the Moon. Where it gets trickier is if you're in higher orbits and you cease to function before you can implement your end of mission plan, then you are going to have something up there essentially forever. So at some point, We will need to think about the ability to have an asset that can remove dead orbiters around the moon. And it'll be a great problem to have when we have it, but the level to your problem depending what orbits those spacecraft are in and whether they die before they can even implement the plan.
All right.
Yeah, Bernard Frank. So when I was a lead scientist for SMART-1, and at that time, we were operating the spacecraft. Okay, we were alone around the moon at the time, so we could say, oh, that's easy, no risk of collision with other spacecraft. But still, due to influence of Earth and sun, due to the mass cone, so-called mass cone, mass concentration surface of the moon, it's very difficult to predict accurately an orbit. And these orbits are breathing. And for us, we had a perilune of 300 kilometer. And so we had to do a series of maneuvers to maintain it at this altitude. And so only in case of some frozen orbits, then you can have more stable configuration. But then I'm wondering now, how are we going to have the ability Two, like we drive on the highway. I know, drive on the highway, I would have a warning of a possible collision every second because other cars are within 10 meter. But if you have accurately a knowledge of your corridor, a bit like in the aviation maybe, you don't need to control so much the time. In our case, we were able to predict our bit within half a second, but half a second was one kilometer. But if the corridor is very well determined, then you could have a much safer management. But now the point is, you need a good tool to be able to predict the orbit with the mass concentration and so on, but also how you integrate the last minute maneuvers. So how are we going to handle any maneuvers that are done to be able to reactualize almost in real time, this corridor information so that we will have a safe situational awareness.
Yeah, so I would say that compared to sort of the early 2000s, we know the gravity field of the Moon well enough now that actually you can predict well into the future what your trajectory is going to be. And so I think it comes back to what we all said earlier, which is What we need is a place to place those predict ephemeris so that others can check. And whenever you do a orbital maneuver, you refine your predict ephemeris, and then you would re-upload it so that people are always checking the latest. And it's only really relevant for fairly low lunar orbits below about 100 kilometers. And so it's going to be a while before we have lots of spacecraft in those kind of orbits. But I would say that that isn't a problem like it was. We can predict very precisely what the trajectories are going to be for the spacecraft?
But as we discussed yesterday, you still need a lot of new PNT data so that you get your corridor within like a few tens of meters.
Yes, without, I don't want to go with any advertising, but I think it's the same kind of, you know, the constellation between the machine as the one of more like as this. I mean, we are enabler of the lunar economy and, I mean, providing, you know, Pvt. and also real time with very performing level of accuracy and so on. Basically, this is our job, let's say, while the lunar missions that need to land or to orbit because they are making some remote sensing missions, they should focus on their primary mission. So going back to the point, they should be focused on their core missions and stay with their profit and loss, and all the problems concerning you know, potential collision and so on will be, you know, externalized to those that have this as the primary focus, as our constellation. Another point, though, it is that maybe a space domain awareness, lunar space domain awareness, you know, infrastructure, maybe a multi-layer infrastructure with ground segment sensors, lunar orbiting sensors, and also sharing of information and catalog between volunteers. This would definitely help in lowering the overall cost and also in having higher performance in terms of visibility and management of the situation.
Just in 30 seconds to your question, Bernard, I think. So you're pointing to an extremely relevant issue. Accuracy really makes all the difference. I will add perhaps something worth considering is also increasing the autonomy and the computing that can allow us to more rapidly determine what are those collision avoidance maneuvers that otherwise will have to be designed by teams. Perhaps this takes a lot of effort, but it will significantly reduce the time required once a warning rises in order to take action and ensure safety.
Okay, go to Italy and then China.
Thank you very much. This is Antonio Tedesco from the Italian Mission to the UN. My question regards this mechanism for data sharing for collision avoidance. The question is very simple: when do you think that this is needed ideally, and when that will be too late to have such a mechanism in place? Thank you.
You wanna start?
I'll get it started. That's a difficult question. You know, missions are being planned for the very next few years. Volta is targeting 2028 for first mission in lunar orbit, but there are many others that are gonna happen even prior than that. And so this capabilities, I think, will be important as soon as possible. There might be factors that will induce us to take action, such as how easy it really is, and over time, to sustain things as they are today. If lunar spacecraft keep increasing, the problem is just going to get worse, and all of a sudden we're going to have to bear higher cost, higher complexity. And so maybe this will prompt us to establish those capabilities a little earlier. But I think, you know, we're already approaching the time where there already are, in fact, issues. I was making examples of the Korean orbiter. There have been incidents I think with the Apollo 11 ascent stage, there's been significant uncertainty for years on what its position was. And with another satellite, I think Chandrayaan-1, it was lost and was found after several years. So we're already at a point where there could be issues. And if there's a collision, we know that most of the debris have been caused by collisions. And so it takes one collision to increase significantly. significantly the problems you may have to deal with. So, as we refine our ability to determine those probabilities, probably we want to always keep an eye on that and try to be ready.
Yeah, I think you raised a good point. There's also a difference between, i think what you're referring to is more the active satellites and sharing of those ephemeris. You've also got the fact that once a satellite dies, then typically that ephemeris is no longer generated because the team doesn't exist. And so we have to consider both those cases as we go forward that you are having older satellites tracked, which, as I said, the capability doesn't currently exist, and then the ephemeris shared, as well as sharing the ephemeris for current missions. I think the one-word answer to your question is now. I mean, we are, as you say, we are already having to take into account, and we can only do that to the level that ephemeris are shared.
Delegate from China.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you for all the panelists for your very informative presentation and discussions. My question is based on the chair's early intervention. As all the industry sectors look for the unified approach to address those threat or risks, most of them look to the governmental organizations, space agencies to provide guidance and regulatory certainty. But at the same times, Do you think that industry also can fill the gap? I look to the self-governance, we are quite familiar with other sectors. If you look at AI or internet, they do provide a lot of certainty through their own self-governance. They have the standards, they have a unified market at least. Whether that is feasible for the commercial industry in the space sector, I know all of them All the three panelists from different countries, they have very close relationship with the government. They provide funding, contract. Whether that will be a barrier for a unified market, which will provide all the certainties you want, because market will trump all those governmental limitations. They will provide level playing field. So that is a question, I think it's an open question. I don't have answers. So you identify the issues, whether you also will be eager and willing to provide some partial solutions to address those issues. Thank you.
I will give you an answer that is not technical, but I can tell that when you talk about unified market, there is, and that is also, let's say, itself where the private participate actively, proactively to this, it is, again, in their interest. We're talking about the space sector, where unless you have a lot of public money that is going to not just co-fund your investment, but also be the anchor customers, and there are very few cases in the world that have this kind of power, you need to have a unified market, because otherwise you don't have a business case that is viable. So it is, again, in the interest also of the private to work on the interoperability and to work on common standard, even if this means to be transparent, if this sometimes could be against an immediate short-term financial incentive. If you know what I mean. So I make this example, we are as Moonlight, we are interoperable with LunaNet standards because we know that we are not going to address only European missions. We plan to have also US missions, Asian missions, real missions. We are planning missions with JAXA, with basically all the entities that are and space agencies and private players that are interoperable with LunaNet. This, of course, implies that there is a common framework where we need to work for and work with. And yes, I think this is, again, going back to what is sustainable for a private player to stay in the game and to have a playing field.
Yes, I mean, so that's interoperability. To come back to talking about conjunction avoidance. As we touched upon, it's in our interest to try and make sure that that never happens. I would say we need the national agencies for each company to help with that, because we can interact, for example, in our case, we can interact with NASA, but not every orbiter is a commercial orbiter. There are orbiters from space agencies, which are obviously government assets. We as a company can't reach out to other governments saying, we need information on your assets. That has to happen at State Department or United Nations type level. So I think there's two parts. There's us coordinating within our country with our agency on conjunction avoidance, but then there has to be higher level conversations between countries because of the nature of the orbiters.
Okay, start here, and then we'll go back. Three, right, we got three.
Monique Greenstein, International Space University alumni.
You mentioned the mechanisms or the lack thereof for data sharing of trajectories. Do you already have some forums or mechanisms that you use already out of necessity, so unofficial ones? or even proposals for frameworks to share this data.
There are some initiatives that are taking place. I think one has been mentioned yesterday, the Open Lunar Foundation ledger that invites organizations that are operating assets on the moon or around the moon. It invites them to share on a voluntary basis some of the data that might be relevant to this, and there are similar efforts going on. So this is, I think, what I can tell at the moment. There's some informal mechanisms, if you will, where whenever we have an opportunity to socialize our emissions with the broader community, we do it in conferences, workshops, et cetera. Nothing more structured than this, to my knowledge.
So NASA does have systems in place that we can use, and we do use. So they have something called CARA, which is another acronym, which defines what defines when a conjunction event. And then they have, as I mentioned, the MADCAP system, which is voluntary, where you can share, and that helps provide you with information to make sure you're avoiding everything during your mission. Things already exist and we are using them. It's how to expand them to be global.
Thank you. Can I have for the floor? Gu Yu Wang, space lawyer from BID China. So I think there are some similarities between, we say, space traffic coordination in LEO, Earth orbit, and the lunar orbit traffic coordination. So I can see the endeavors offered by you guys, you know, is super, is from a technical solution, operational mechanism. I believe we do have the same goal, but maybe some different approaches, not only because I'm a lawyer. So I still believe legal solution is a precondition. We can discuss on that. So do you think that the legal discussion regarding, say, the right of road in lunar orbit should be deemed as some sort of prerequisite to allocate the right obligations among operators, which side is obliged to provide certain information to the other, which side has a priority of the road right there, and which, how to say, for instance, when considering the lifetime of the spacecraft there, five years, 25 years requirement, Such kind of legal discussion, I would say, will be the precondition to define when collision occurs in future, the fault goes to which side. So my question again, I'm trying to raise the concern, operational, the solution from operational level, super important. But I have to say, I emphasize again, legal discussion sometimes is the prerequisite for such kind of operational solution. Unfortunately, that's the one I think we are just like such kind of a discussion. Any response from your side would be very welcome. Thank you.
Any lawyers up here?
If I can just build a little bit on Goryu's question, which might help the answer. With space traffic coordination, the operators are calling for coordination as a matter of urgency, knowing also that there's no mechanism to enforce legal rules. There's no police in space who can really enforce. But when it comes to lunar, we are ahead of the game. So, of course, there's still calls for coordination we see from Korea's Pathfinder, how they've had to perform maneuvers. So, yes, there's still a call for coordination. We could put a mechanism for coordination in place, and probably ATAC will do that, in order to not come after, to be ahead of the game. But is there an opportunity, and what does industry think about actually having rules? because we are ahead of the game at this moment.
Okay, Paolo.
I'll try. I appreciate your question. I think it's extremely relevant. It's good to have call for coordinations. I think, you know, it's hard for me to establish exactly all the ramifications and implications of rules at a time where there's so much to learn. But to the extent that this frameworks can be adaptable and take into account what we learn over time and how to do best moving forward, I think that's very valuable. And to the extent that it provides safety and certainty to operators and industry, that's also very welcome. As we think we can all agree, it's key for industry to have predictability, safety, certainty of the operations and make sure that it's a good input.
If I might just, what kind of rules could you imagine? Like rules that you have to carry some fuel to put yourself into a graveyard orbit? What kind of rules could you imagine? Yeah.
I think that's a great example. That's a great example about end of life, perhaps, or rules on how to set ourselves up in case there is a collision risk. So how is that best avoided? And how can the rule prevent that from happening or from being addressed in an irresponsible manner?
We partially touched this point before when we said that there should be some mechanism that at national level should be implemented, that there would be no authorization unless you have a clear plan for disposal, and you have also to have already budgeted with evidence of delta V for disposal, or for instance, you have also to already identify which is your disposal option, if it is stable graveyards or orbit, or if it is control impact. This is for sure something that could be implemented. It could be something that, again, it's not just a check for compliance, but it is part of the business case for whoever is going to launch. Just to answer to what you were saying is, for me, it's a prerequisite to have legal aspects involved, because otherwise, I mean, in the end, we're talking about contracts. So it is the operational comes after. So before, you have to have a legal framework that, you know, that if something doesn't work as it's stated, you have penalties. And this could have also, which is, the problem is empowering these choices, which is a deterrence. For instance, the next time that you launch a mission, if you can launch a mission, you have a higher insurance cost because you didn't respect something or you were not, you know, you were deemed liable for something that has happened before. So there are mechanisms also working together with insurance. Yes, please.
Thank you, colleague. Just a half a suit there. I thank RT for providing more specific questions there, make it clearer. And I think I have maybe some possible answers to RT's question relevant to your interest there. So the rules to be discussed, at least the two, the first one, to identify the priority right on the road of lunar orbital, you know, lunar orbital right of priority right there. The second one is to consider the specific debris mitigation guidelines suitable for lunar environment. So that's two topics supposed to be discussed maybe in the relevant platform. Thank you.
Thank you very much.
Harris Kousmas from Lunar Cargo. I see the data you may provide as very valuable asset for the future missions. We know the gravity model of the Moon to a certain degree of detail, but your missions, if with sufficiently good format, your data of upcoming maneuvers be communicated, recorded in some database, will enable academia to establish a better understanding of the gravity model, which is very important for low lunar orbit missions. So far, they all try to be high up to avoid these implications. So do you have envisaged what would be the format of those data you're gonna give will be suitable for?
Academia in particular? to go deep into the gravity model.
And shall we already engage academia maybe to format these data needs? Thank you.
Yeah, so I think there is a standard format, SPICE format, already used for trajectories, which is, for example, on the US side. Or, so you have the predict ephemeris, but then you also have, you regenerate the ephemeris to see where you actually went. And that's what you are referring to, to use that in low lunar orbit to improve the gravity model. But I would say the formats for that are pretty standard worldwide already. So it's a good question, but I think that we are already there from that. When we store those ephemeris, they are in a format that everyone is expecting.
But ephemera is enough, or we need upcoming maneuvers as well?
If you're looking at trying to do gravity analysis, what you care about, I believe, is where the spacecraft was, how did The maneuvers you want to know, because you're predicting where the spacecraft is going to be, that's important from conjunction analysis. On the science side, if you're trying to improve the gravity model, you simply want to know how the lunar gravity affected the trajectory of the spacecraft, and you're looking at those small movements to improve the gravity model.
Thank you. At the back.
Hi, good morning. I'm Professor Güven, Advisory Council member of CISTEP, CEO of Prometheus Space UK, and an aerospace scientist for the last 35 years. So I have a question. No disrespect to other space agencies, but it's my personal opinion that four major players are there in the lunar competition, which is obviously China, United States, India, and Russia, and maybe we can count Japan to some extent. But of those players, there are two major players. One is China, and one is the United States. And they're having a very nice, healthy competition between them, which I feel as a scientist, competition is always good because it makes both sides try to create newer technologies. As part of my profile as a professor, I travel to countries in Africa, South America, Asia. I was with a prime minister of an African country just two months back, and they asked me this question: "Professor, the United States and China are going to the moon. They're getting all these good orbits, getting all these lunar resources. What's going to happen to our rights in the future if one day we are able to go to the moon? Maybe not today, but 20 years, 30 years down the line, will we have a chance? So I have a very specific technical question. As I'm aware, China has a very detailed map of the moon, or rather atlas of the moon, especially of the lunar resources. And looking at that, I could see as a scientist, there are certain specific permanent orbits around the moon if you want to keep a satellite constantly doing a remote sensing operation that would be preferred by companies or governments or agencies whatsoever. So, who gets to pick these orbits? Like, for example, because Earth is much bigger than the Moon, the Moon is much smaller, so you don't have like thousands of unlimited orbits, and some of these orbits are preferable from technical point of view, energy point of view, financial point of view. So my question is, who gets to pick these orbits? Let's say these orbits are picked by China and the United States. Will there be maybe, UNOOSA Director, Dr. Arti, could also answer, is there some mechanism for reserving some of these orbits for these countries in the future? Will they also have a chance when time comes, when it's their turn? This is my question. So it's a bit of a technical question as well as a legal question at the same time. Thank you.
Thank you. Who wants to take that one?
I feel the other two if you step back. I'm going to start with the positives, which is because of what's going on at the Moon, actually, the bar of entry for the countries that you're talking to has come down. So, for example, I mentioned that one of the things that we do as a company is the ability to drop off small orbiters en route to the Moon. And so now you can actually get to the, you can be delivered to the Moon. There are other companies that can do that too. The bar of entry is lower, so I think you will see more countries having small orbiters at the Moon because of the infrastructure that is being put in place. The com relays that are going up, again, will allow smaller satellites, smaller space agencies, or even university level have the capability of building. Regarding the orbits, if you're resource mapping, you're typically in a low orbit, and that is a finite lifetime orbit because of the gravity. The com relays are in much higher orbits, but even there, spacecraft have a finite lifetime. So, for example, our com relays have approximately a five year lifetime, and then we will have a disposal plan, and then the idea is we replace them. So I think as more countries come online with wanting to do satellites in certain orbits, You're correct, the moon is, you know, it's a smaller volume of space than around Earth. It's still a large volume for the number of satellites that are foreseen even in the next 50 years. So I think it is a problem that we might have longer term, but I think it's a solvable problem then, because satellites will not last forever in the orbits that they are in, even if they're in higher orbits.
Yes. Yeah, we say that the orbits under this point of view, well, from Ben described, it is, let's say, a sort of, let's call it democratic still place. It's not an oligopoly. So the un-oligopolistic instead, maybe situation you would have on the lunar surface, that's another totally another story because you need to have high capital-intensive initiatives. At the same time, you need to be able to have the technologies, and then you need to extract, for instance, resources, generate and produce propellant, and so on. In this case, it would be a total another story. I like to recall that we had the conversation yesterday with Ben. I don't know if it applies, but the ocean is everybody's, but then the fish is of the one who can pick them. So, This is something that I don't think we are yet there. This is something that maybe will be daily basis during discussion after the first half of the first daygate of the next daygate. We don't have a thinking answer yet, no.
Ari.
The companies that are going to the moon, apart from Telespazio on this panel, but typically they're not satellite operators. There's got to be some lessons that we can learn from space traffic coordination that would apply to lunar traffic coordination. I mean, the companies that are going to the moon are learning by doing. We see that. But there's no, because each one of you is concerned with your own mission, you're not necessarily thinking about the coordination angle holistically, if I may. What mechanism can we have, or how can we bring lessons from satellite operators on space traffic coordination to lunar traffic coordination?
So, first, I think we are thinking at it holistically because we're thinking longer term. We understand that what we do affects what others do and what they do affects us. And so, you know, Nicolas said, you've It can involve, it can affect investment. If you're trying to get external investment to do a project, you've got to be able to show that you understand all the problems and you're not causing more problems. I'm not sure if that answers what you're saying, but I think we aren't just worried about our individual missions being successful. We're also having to think five, ten years from now, how is what we're doing going to affect what it will take to do things in that time frame, because we're going to want to be doing things then as well, we don't want to be affecting what we do.
I think the thing is, can we learn from what's happening around Earth and take those lessons to the Moon? And that's something we can't ignore what's happening around Earth because there's a lot of debris. We don't want that to happen at the Moon. So maybe think about it that way. And is there a regulatory way, sorry, is there an enabling way to move forward.
I think some of the lessons learned from Earth operations is the end-of-life disposal, right? Today, it is expected that satellite operators will launch something in Earth orbit, have a clear plan for end-of-life. So the same might apply for the Moon. And there are other factors, I think, that Our specific, perhaps we're more specific for private organizations that somehow align nicely with a sort of sustainable coordination of the activities in the lunar environment. Besides, of course, what Ben already pointed out to, which is ensuring safety of the assets and avoiding collisions. But private actors have an incentive towards maintaining assets full capabilities, they may not be willing to plan the lifetime of an asset to be essentially infinite, and they may not afford to be in a frozen orbit because it just doesn't align with the mission goals and the business goals. Matter of fact, for Volta, If we want to provide broad coverage with energy and supply as many users as possible, being always in one of those finite frozen orbits is simply not convenient. It might be useful. Matter of fact, many satellites, like the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter, they took advantage of frozen orbits. They saved 90% of their, they reduced by 90% their fuel consumption, and it could extend the lifetime of the mission a lot longer. But the same might not hold true for a private-driven endeavor. or the use of that frozen orbit might be conceived as something temporary that enables perhaps a safer approach towards satellite commissioning and preparation for the mission, but not necessarily the condition that has to be kept and maintained indefinitely by an actor.
I'm going to go to someone different first. We got two here, then we'll come back to you. Yeah. Okay, at the back. Yes, you.
Thank you for sharing your insights. As it was mentioned before, there are some orbits that will be probably saturated.
In 20, 30 years time, like the low lunar orbit or the non-rectilinear halo orbit?
I wanted to ask you, since the issues were more or less identified, what kind of business models or commercial commercial synergies, commercial partnerships do you foresee that would be able maybe to help you or?
Solve some of these issues potentially.
Thank you for the question. That's a great question. I think there are many ways to be creative and work together to achieve more in this regards. Partnering to transfer assets more effectively, perhaps, and deploy them in the target orbits is definitely useful. So being able to rely on transport service providers is definitely a great way to partner up. I will point to what we mentioned at the very beginning, which is P&T services. So the more accurate we are in determining our satellite's position, the more we can be conducting our operations safely and reduce burdens, risks, and costs. So those two partnerships are probably vital. And I think the rest is about coordinating and sharing data on how operations are unfolding, even on the surface, so that we can be even safer. The last thing I will add to this point is There is a curious sort of correlation between what happens on the surface and what happens on orbit. There might be events where a landing of a large assets lifts off some dust plumes that might reach orbital altitudes and pose a risk to some satellites orbiting there. So a partnership in those regards whereby a commercial partner maybe establishes a landing pad or some sort of structure that mitigates those landing ejecta, that can be another way to ensure sustainability.
And safety. The answer goes back to what it was said before when we talk about lunar space domain awareness. I mean, this, of course, a stage that maybe we will reach maybe in 10 years from now, and it could be It will be based by a partnership among operators that have this mission to provide Pvt. and to provide, for instance, such as, again, companies such as Telespazio and 2D Machines, there will be others or maybe other that are owned by space agencies that will be called to coordinate and to provide this information for safety. And also, again, for market scalability, because in the end, it is not just the idea to control, but it is also to enable others to come. That's the spirit.
Okay, done.
Thank you, sir. M.C. Senghila, I'm a space lawyer and space law professor in the United States. I don't want to bring you back to regulations and governance and make you shudder.
No, no, no, no. It's enabling. It's not regulations.
Exactly. But I did think it was, your comments were very interesting in terms of lawyers think of things directly in terms of law and governance and regulations, but there are also a lot of problems that can be solved extra legally. And that's what I wanted to explore. Some of the things that you talked about in terms of transparency and interoperability and sharing information for trajectories, are there other aspects of your work where that could be beneficial as well? Basically, I just want to make sure I capture. everything that we might be able to help solve short of regulation and governance, other aspects of transparency or other aspects of your work in terms of cooperation and information sharing, that would be helpful.
Who wants to be helpful?
I can't think of any, you know, I don't want to not answer, but I think The delegate from China mentioned the one, do we get to the point where you have two entities both wanting an intent to be in the same orbit? And that's something you think you've thought about all the problems, and then there's a new one. And so, again, it's a down the road problem, but having a mechanism in place, I don't want to, it's tricky though, because you don't want to get to the point where you have to ask for permission, but equally, if you've got enough sharing of information that you become aware that there are two entities both intending to launch it, you know you've got a much higher increased chance of a conjunction event, which is going to have other implications, and the sooner you can learn about that. So I think a lot of it does still come back down to sharing of trajectory information of planned, of future trajectories, either once you're already in orbit or years before launch, what your plans are, would help identify where those kind of conversations could help.
Thank you.
And perhaps if I can super quickly add on this, I think sharing more with who's on the surface is also helpful to the point we made before. So am I planned a control disposal, surface disposal of a satellite in an area where somebody might be willing to traverse or conduct operations? That's information that should absolutely be shared. In some other cases, perhaps. A disposal may not be controlled just because the satellite has issues and is not able to access resources that allow the satellite system to control that re-entry, in which case there is even perhaps more caution to be taken on the surface. So that might be another example, just to extend a little bit more the scope.
To conclude, just these two words: data policy.
Antonino and then Bernard, and that will be the end of the questions. Oh, really? All right. Okay. All right. I'm sorry, Bernard, but we're going to go to him for the last question. Antonino, then you.
Okay. Just want to piggyback on the information sharing to underline that information sharing becomes more useful if it's shared timely and earlier. So yesterday, we heard from Kati Sham about the Space Frequency Coordination Group, and that's where you do early coordination of things you may want to do before you start doing them. If you learn that two missions are going to the same place and the missions are already It's a bit late to coordinate that, because you're not going to back off from the mission you already developed. You already spend money to have the hardware, you already secure your license, you're not going to change your plans at the last minute, you simply can't, or it's going to be much more difficult. So information sharing will be useful if we share information early enough that you can alter your plan and have a real negotiation with who is going to interfere with you. Otherwise, it's just going to be, oh, okay, now what are we going to do? And so I think right now, information is shared about lunar mission, but only later, even after the mission, or like one week before, one month before. And I understand sometimes there are business concerns behind it. But we need to shift that mindset and understand, as Nicola was saying, the short-term gain should not overrun long-term benefit of actually enabling coordination. Otherwise, information sharing becomes futile if you do it too late. You will just be aware of a problem you cannot solve, or that will give you further headache in a way. Thank you very much.
Luciano from the University of Groningen. I wanted to maybe bring back the topic of lunar orbit issues back to Earth, since you are private companies. What do you think are the capabilities that private companies need in the future? We're talking about legal issues and so forth, but do you need infrastructure on Earth? Do you need people trained on Earth? And or without being disrespectful, are going to be like free riders on public agencies and nation states infrastructure? What are your business plans as private companies to make this happen? Because if you're going to use satellites on the moon and you will need an infrastructure here on Earth to update so far and so forth, now maybe you're startups, but in 10, 15 years, you're going to be big companies, CEOs. So maybe from the private sector point of view, what are your expectations? expectations of what you need, and maybe how can UNOOS or states can help you to achieve that? Thank you.
I think that as soon as we said before, we are entering this early stage of industrial lunar economy. What is maybe really not missing, but it needs faster development, is to build sustainable business cases that could be that maybe would happen on the Moon, but would have benefits on the Earth. So this positive spillover needs to, I mean, the benefits from lunar exploration activities would be really beneficial if there are benefits, even indirect, on the Earth for maybe in other sectors. And this is where a lot of creativity and innovation is required. I mean, there are already many industrial players that have many years of experience in the legacy business, big space players have legacy competencies, they are building new ones. What is really missing to build and to grow the lunar economy is having something that is successful, that would allow us to say, okay, we have this infrastructure, we are able to provide these common services, everything is ready, but which is the business case that at the really end of the downstream is going to produce valuable data that could be useful for the lunar operation on lunar missions, but also on the Earth. So this is where we expect more, where maybe the market is still immature, and where we expect that companies, not just from the space sector, would apply, but also from the Earth. I mean, we don't expect that someone that has never drilled on the Earth is going to drill on the Moon. Maybe we need to be able to bring people that is drilling on the Earth. to the moon. So we expect that there will be more not space players on the lunar surface, and even in the lunar orbit is a different story, but we expect that there are more not space players approaching to the moon. This is where we will definitely make a leap.
Thank you for your question. And by the way, these two are publicly traded companies, I think, so we are the small startup. To your point, I think one of the capabilities that's required is definitely ground segments that are more capable and able to support all those operations, perhaps handling a bigger number of satellites. In some instances, the ground antennas and the networks might be strained and overstressed in over capacity on the Earth. So having more of that infrastructure is definitely enabling, and teams on Earth that are able to handle perhaps an increasing number of collision warnings and operations to be conducted, of course, as these companies and these activities grow. But I think the number one point here is creating that Earth-Moon economic sphere where there are business cases that close sustainably and keep creating good externalities and a virtuous cycle.
Okay, I think we are at time. I'm a little over. Just a quick recap on what I thought we heard, and of course, you can correct me if I'm wrong. We need data and up-to-date data on each mission to be available to all, info sharing early before a mission and during a mission. Need disposal incentives and to think about managing the Moon sustainably. Need ability of early collision prediction to reduce fuel used in avoidance. Industry is starting to provide the PNT comm networks around the Moon and establishing a unified market, but national agencies need to be involved. We need enabling coordination to promote commercial space missions or even campaigns to grow the economy. And we need legal discussions first that will enable coordination and data and info sharing, and this needs to start now. And it seems that space lawyers have job security. And on that note, I want to thank the panelists for a very productive hour and 17 minutes, and we'll move on to the next one. Thank you.
Yes, thank you for what was a really interesting panel. And we started to touch on some of those lunar surface issues that I think we'll be picking up even more in this next session. So I'd like to welcome Catherine and the next panelists to the stage. Clive, don't go anywhere. We're going to double tap you for this next session as well.
Great, I think everyone's ready. Wonderful, let's start. Good morning, distinguished delegates, participants here in Vienna and also online. Good morning, welcome to the second panel of this day two on the Commercial Lunar Landscape Conference. In this session, we're moving to the lunar surface. I'd like to thank the organizers of this conference, UNISA, for putting together such an interesting program. I think these discussions between those of us who work maybe more on the technical side and policymakers, lawyers, and so on are absolutely critical. I'm delighted to be moderating the panel today. I'm the director of ESRIC. ESRIC is the European Space Resources Innovation Centre based in Luxembourg. Actually, today, ESRIC is marking its fifth anniversary since launch. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. We are a research and innovation centre, but also we host a business incubator and accelerator programme in partnership with the European Space Agency. And over the course of the programmes that we've been running, we've now supported 32 early stage ventures in our incubator and accelerator. And that's given us a real insight into the challenges and priorities of these early stage ventures as they try to establish themselves as economically sustainable businesses for a future lunar economy. So as I said, in this session, we're focusing on lunar surface missions, lunar surface activities. There are many, many missions planned in the next five years. We're really starting to see a new cadence in missions with humans once again to set foot on the lunar surface. The drivers for these missions include technology demonstrations, precursor missions for setting up lunar habitats, missions to establish infrastructure for future lunar activities, and missions to explore the lunar environment, including its resources. So we're really starting to see the foundations being set for the bigger systems, bigger infrastructure on the lunar surface. Many of these missions are focused on common regions of interest, for example, the lunar south pole, or resources of interest, for example, water ice or helium-3. We start to see a thematic approach to missions and an increasing focus on building up the capability to have a longer duration presence on the moon, whether that's human or robotic or both. So our approach to lunar exploration from this mission by mission approach is set to evolve. With infrastructure and bases comes a need for repeated landing in the same location. We might expect to see multiple operators servicing one location or a habitat or base, or competing operators based in close proximity of each other, however we define proximity, and that's something we'll discuss in this session. Operating in the lunar surface is complex. I'm sure we will discuss this plenty in the next hour or so. The environment is hostile. We've got the high vacuum, radiation, low gravity, extreme temperature swings, and of course, the lunar regolith. Under the lunar conditions, under the vacuum of the moon, the lunar regolith, the small abrasive particles that coat the surface of the moon become electrostatically charged, and with an absence of drag, the particles travel at long distances and ballistic speeds. Under these conditions and with our future ambitions of increased lunar surface activity, we need to understand what are the limitations with respect to safe operating from the perspective of the commercial sector. Yesterday, we heard Matthias Link of the Luxembourg Space Agency say that we're very far from having large scale space operations, space resources operations on the Moon. And that's true. However, we're at the beginning of building up. towards more complex systems that may be on surface of the moon, and this is something we need to consider now. So we need to understand how our future lunar surface activities are being considered by the commercial sector today and for the future, whether we're focusing on technical challenges, who the customer is, this is a discussion we have a lot in our sector, and how those architectures might evolve. And so, I would like to introduce the panelists for this session. So providing the perspective from the established space industry with several flagship lunar surface projects from Talis Elenia Space, Italy, we have Maria Antonietta Perino. Good morning. Providing the perspective from early stage ventures, looking to grow as an economically sustainable business from Unmanned Exploration Laboratory, we have Jaiho Lee.
Good morning.
And finally, you will note a change in your program. On the program that was released last week, we had Jim Caravalla of Offworld. Unfortunately, he had a last minute issue, which meant he was not able to attend. So we're very sad that Jim wasn't able to join us. However, in his place, Clive, Professor Clive Neal has stepped in at the last minute. Now, Clive is a world renowned lunar geologist, but don't let that put you off. He also knows a lot about the commercial sector and lunar surface activities. So we will hear from him as well. I would like to now hand over the panelists and for them to introduce themselves. So I will ask the panelists to give a short introduction to themselves.
Starting from.
Starting from, we'll start. Yeah, absolutely. Let's start with you, Maria Antonietta.
Okay. Good morning, everybody. I'm very happy to be here to share the little bit I know. I've been working in this field for 40 years. I'm a nuclear engineer. So that's the reason, the background of my question yesterday. But I've been working in this wonderful company, Italian Space Agency. Next year will be my 40th year. I've been discussing, you asked before, what do we need? We need to develop common roadmap because To be in space is already difficult around our planet, but around the moon or on the moon is even more difficult. So we need to do that together in a very honest and transparent way. This is what we need. Coming back to myself, I've been dealing with all the initial adventure in this field with many friends that I see in the audience. Finally, we are almost there. And so we need to hurry up because I really want to see what is going on on the Moon and Mars in the next years. In Thales Alenia Space, I have the responsibility for the development of Moon and Mars economy. And to this end, as soon as I will be given the opportunity, I will tell you what we are currently welding not designing, welding. Surprise.
We look forward to this. Jaiho.
Thanks for inviting Anne and Easton to be here. Let me introduce myself. So, Catherine, think about three parts to introduce myself. So I a little bit arrange about my research background and some experience and career. So my major is civil engineer, project management, and space construction. And my master thesis is study on lunar concrete binder for landing pad construction. Also PhD thesis is development of lunar concrete using polyethylene binder in vacuum condition. During that time, I have experience about the space. First official experience is NASA Lunar Mining Competition in Kennedy Space Center 2012. After that, I participated in NASA 3D Printed Habitat Challenge as the Moon X Construction Team, page two and page three. Our team got a first award at Page 2 level 2, 2016. During the time for competition, my role and responsibility was a team leader, which specialized project management. and material development using Korea Hanyang lunar simulant and polymer. And last one is my career is I was in policy research department in Korea Institute of Civil and Building Technology. And also there was my responsibility was improvement of enforcement regulation and enforcement ordination in Construction Technology Promotion Act in Korea. So right now, I'm working on unmanned exploration laboratory for the first robot landing on the moon in Korea. Thank you.
Hello again. I'm Clive. I'm a professionally trained geologist, and as Catherine said, don't let that put you off. I have spent almost 40 years Yeah, yeah. This is gonna see who's the oldest here in a minute. I think I know it's gonna be me.
I guess I look younger.
She does look younger.
You wanted me to be provocative. Just starting.
Well, Jay Hu has achieved so much in his young career. He's probably older than both of us. So, but I've been working on all things lunar. It started off with geology and got into exploration. and then got into resources, commercial ideas, and different commercial firms, and then policy. I am a student of Antonino and trying to follow his very legal lead. But I think in coming here today, it's really important to understand that the world is going to the moon in this 21st century. There are countries that are going to the moon, but the world is going. And I listened to things yesterday about, well, benefits for those that think they're getting left behind. Well, don't get left behind and come along with us. And I think to open that invitation is important to do that. But in terms of that, the commercial space industry offers incredible new opportunities for students at every university in the world. And Jay Hu is a shining example of that, setting up his own company. All right. A company that is fresh, with fresh ideas and new ways forward. But that's the living embodiment of what this new push to the moon is doing. It's inspiring that next generation to follow in the more seasoned people to take it to the next level. And I think we're here to discuss that today with regard to the lunar surface.
Thanks, everybody, for the introductions. So we heard yesterday that predictability is good for business. And so we have prepared some questions, but I also want to leave plenty of time for questions and answers from the audience. So we'll see how we go. But first off, I want to start with the vision. The vision for your companies, and Clive will come to you as well with your vision for the lunar surface. So we'll start with Maria Antonietta. Maybe you can give your vision, the vision of Teleselema Space Italy for the lunar surface.
Thank you for the question. I think that is very important to have a vision, to remain on the right track. You know, a company is an industry. So the first need we have is to maintain a good business, because we have to pay salaries. So we cannot just sing a nice song because we like it. We need to coordinate, first of all, at national level. And I'm glad to say that since I can remember, we always said a direct conversation with our national space agency, not only with TASI, but also with ESA. And this is very important. Yesterday, somebody mentioned that, raised the point that we need to shake hands. We need to do much more than that with our political people. So we need to develop a vision. together. We need to have a credible support. We cannot just embark in a project that will not continue to be supported. And so we started many, many decades ago, and our vision was to contribute to make it possible for people to live and work in space. So we really start, Thales Alenia Space is a huge company. I don't want really to, how can I say, present the company to you because you know what we can do. We can do satellites, telecommunication, navigation. But in Torino, what we do the best is to develop artificial places for people to live and work in space. And we did that, I believe, with a huge contribution to the International Space Station. Now, for us, our vision, it comes as a natural continuation to contribute to the possibility for people to live around the moon and on the lunar surface. And so again, This is a super difficult asset to be developed, much more difficult than a satellite, because we have all the very same problems that you mentioned before. But in addition to those, we have to deal with radiation protection, with extreme, you mentioned on the surface, extreme thermal conditions. And so we are currently working at the design of what it will be according to a common shared roadmap, the first building block of a lunar surface infrastructure that needs to be an open infrastructure. So we need to talk about common interfaces because the different elements we need to be able to interact with each other. So our vision is, yes, developing infrastructure with automatic means, like rovers, for example, like telecommunication satellites that we are working with Telespazio on that end, but even more developing the first little house for people on the moon. We truly believe in that. This is our vision.
Thank you very much. Jae-ho, perhaps you can give the vision for unmanned exploration broadly.
Yeah, I have some material for the. Could you? Yeah, you can see the 2027 and 2032 vision of our company. First of all, that is only our ideal dream and goal, but it's not confirmed from CASAP program, so it is still progressing. So we are the startup, and we are the future of lunar exploration for finding valuable resources. UEL is providing the planetary mobility service platform, currently working on three different type of robot platform designed for various lunar exploration missions. Those three types of robots are two of the two-wheel robot specialized for cave exploration and proving the technology of the robot system, ourselves. And one of the four-wheel robot are larger, more intended to future resource exploration and extraction. For our mission planning, we have our own lunar simulant, Korean lunar simulant, and Martian simulant, which are manufactured for testbed to drive a single wheel and evaluate mobility performance. This allows us to develop and validate advanced mobility system optimized for harsh planetary surface. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Now to Clive. Rather than ask your vision for the business, maybe you can tell us something about the initiative, the grassroots initiative you've been spearheading related to coordination of data for prospecting. Okay.
Thanks, Catherine. So the idea of resources on the moon is, we've talked about it here, it's been talked copious over the last several years as being very important. But we're not ready to go to the moon and start digging and moving and refining and using, because we don't know exactly where to go. So what is needed is a prospecting campaign. We need to find the resources and evaluate them in such a way we reduce the risk of sending expensive landed assets there and finding nothing. And there has been no integrated approach to doing this. It's been done in very piecemeal ways. There are papers published for certain sites. The VIPER landing site has what they term prospectivity maps developed. So the idea is that the Moon may be one-sixth the size of Earth, but it's got a large landmass. No one country can do a prospecting campaign alone. So it requires international cooperation and coordination, and that's what we've been trying to do by coordinating existing and scheduled missions to get data, at least from orbit, over the areas that we've highlighted to be important. And that is a way to bring people together. And the way to get people involved, even though they may not have a mission, by just integrating the current data sets that we have. And what we're focused on are the polar water ice deposits at the Moon, as well as the rare earth elements, just to look at something different, because everybody wants to use the water ice. But there are many other resources on the Moon, which I won't have time to elaborate on. So this requires international cooperation and coordination, and for a common goal. And so for phase one of the International Lunar Resource Prospecting Campaign, we're trying to develop these integrated data products that define hot prospects. Where do we actually need to send important mobile landed assets to go and ground truth those hot prospects we've identified from orbit? And once those data are fed back into the models, our predictive models that we get from those orbital data products become much more valuable. And this is a way to understand what, or give input to the legal aspects of space resource activities, that working group that is being undertaken, because if we come and find there are three permanently shadowed craters at the south pole of the moon, that are going to be useful. The regulations will be very different than if there are 300 or maybe even 3,000. And so this is something that I'm very passionate about. And we're about to start that. It's starting at ESRC. You're developing, and I can never remember the name of what you're doing. It's a lunar resource.
Lunar resource reports.
Reports, there we go. And this is to sort of catalog what we actually know, and what we want to do then is to start integrating those data sets into prospectivity maps. And the delegate from China raised the, you know, there needs to be a pilot study for information sharing. And we heard one in the last panel about space traffic management around the moon and that sort of thing, but there's another one here with prospecting and understanding the resources. Finding the resources is a collaborative and cooperative venture. What you do with after that, that then is up to negotiation, because those data will feed in to the august bodies of the United Nations, and then we can make informed decisions to develop enabling structures so that everybody wins. That's the utopia that I see. Now we just have to make it happen.
Okay, so now we've heard the vision for our three panelists. We have the living and working on the Moon, the exploration, the robotic swarms that will support exploration on the surface, and this coordinated approach to prospecting. But often when we talk about lunar surface activities, what's happening in the future, what's happening now, is in a whiz class. Now we're going to come to the near term. This is the vision. This is what we hope to achieve in some time. So for our three panelists, I'm now going to ask, what's next? What's immediately happening in your entity or your initiative in the near term? And again, I'm going to start with you, Maria and Tonietta.
What's now? Yes. Not next. We are, as a company, as Talis Elenia Space, deeply committed in helping the overall community in establishing the initial seeds of this lunar surface infrastructure. Let me mention that in two days, for now, in Cologne, at ESC, We will sign with ESA the contract to carry on the current activity to develop a small cargo lender, Argonaut, that will have the capability to deliver at least 1.5 tons to the lunar surface. Is that enough for people on the lunar surface? Not at all, but it's super important to prepare, you know, the infrastructure before sending people there. There will be different players delivering cargo to the lunar surface. We, as Europe, we like to be part of the community, and we are committed to even anticipate the landing date. So the big news for you today, I was authorized by my company to mention that we are intending to anticipate the landing date from 2031 to 2030. So it's a big challenge for us, but we are developing the project in a good, promising way. Everything is easy? No. There are aspects like the one I mentioned yesterday. it will help to have a little bit of radioisotope working our payloads. Are we going to do that? So you asked yesterday, what do we need from you, the political people, supporting the industry that have daily practical problems. For example, to come up with decision like this one, we cannot delay a decision about power provision to the very end, because that will affect the design. An industry is committed to a client with covering the cost of the development. We are committed to a schedule. So we cannot restart the design, you know, few months before the end. So there are some, you know, it's like when you want to go on holidays, you jump on the car, you may drive a few kilometers in an open way, say, "Ah, it's a nice day today in Vienna. Shall I go right? Shall I go left?" But then you need to come to a decision. And there are some technical decision, in addition to political and programmatic decision with respect, for example, to budget availability, that are very important. And they have to be taken, as Antonino said, well in advance.
But it's not just the Argonaut, you've also got the multi-purpose habitat, the Telos. That's also on the card.
I love it. Do you want me to talk about that now?
Yes, because we're talking about what's in the near term.
Okay, okay. So I mentioned Argonaut on a, let's call it, not easy side, it's super difficult already, Argonaut, but it's even more challenging. The other project we are carrying on in Torino to develop a small habitat solution that we'd have to host at least two people, how long? The habitat we are designing is designed to be effective for at least 10 years, but we will not have people living there continuously. It's already super difficult to be able to offer a habitat for two people. for a period that will vary, for the time being, between seven days up to 30 days, implying to be there during the lunar night, implying that we will need resources, power resources there, implying that we will need to find, and we develop a lot of these new technologies on R&D money quite often. So just to mention how much we are committed, I lost the track, developed solution for thermal control, for radiation protection. This habitat is not only a fixed habitat, but was not difficult enough. So we said, okay, let's put some locomotion under the habitat. So we'll be, I know somebody said before, Intuitive Machine, you are developing a non-pressurized rover. What we are doing is a sort of little pressurized rover. So being a mobility system, we won't be able to use Regolite to cover it for radiation protection. So we have to think about other solutions. Yes.
Thank you.
Launch date, 2033. May June. It's not in 50 years, it's soon.
I was about to point out, it's 2033 intended launch for this one. Yeah.
And again, the Italian Space Agency is our client. Not only client, we discuss with them. We develop the design together. And not only from the top. Also from, I don't like to say from the bottom, but the strength of our company relies on the fact that in the last decades, we really managed to develop a strong network with small and medium companies that are growing with us, and the academy and university. Projects like these ones are so big that there is room for everybody. It's not in a solo play.
Thank you very much. Jaiho, perhaps you can tell us a little bit about your near-term plans?
Thank you. We signed an IPSA, Interoperable Payload Service Agreement with iSpace at IAC. and aiming to deploy our small rover to the Moon in 2027. For a two-wheel rover, which has focused on resource finding from the private funded. And we are discussing some payload about the vision camera under 200 gram in our rover. For the 2027 lunar exploration mission with i-SPACE, we have three milestone included 2027. So preparing for the qualifying robot to onboard the lander, we are going to the ground verification test and including thermal vacuum chamber and propulsion vibrating. Also, we have a plan to test on low orbit component using next two weeks will be launched. We thought we made some CubeSat, also we have a Nuri-5 launch next year. Specifically in the Nuri-1, our CubeSat is for our component to onboard computer and electronic speed controller. After the Nuri-5, we are going to have a test for fully robot system on CubeSat. For the risk mitigation, of our strategy, we have a plan to conduct two global missions within the same year. Yeah, that is our near-term method.
Very exciting and quick development as well. Clive, for your coordination of prospecting campaign, what's next? What's on the horizon?
Interesting. As I said, we're starting phase one. with integration of existing data and gathering new data from sites at the South Pole for water ice, and also on the near side for rare earth elements, trying to evaluate those. But the whole point of this is to evolve that idea, because more data is going to be needed, and it's going to be specialized. And we're going to need to get to the lunar surface and ground truth the hot prospects that are going to be identified in phase one. So how are we going to do that? Rover missions are non-trivial, and landing and getting them out to the areas that they're needed is a gain. You're now in a very hostile environment, in a permanently shadowed region. trying to operate a mechanical, electrical rover and have it survive between 20 and 60 Kelvin. That's a very, well, it's a bit chilly. And it puts winters into perspective, let's put it that way, on this planet. So coordinating existing missions becomes the way to do it. The Viper Rover in the US has had quite a turbulent history, but it is going to the moon. It is gonna be delivered by a commercial entity, Blue Origin, who are also going to put into orbit at that time Oasis-1, which will get much better resolution data over the poles of the moon, in fact, over all of the moon. And this is something that is really exciting. It's a paradigm shift from the way things are being done. But VIPER, the team has agreed to share their data, but they do that anyway, but we will then feed that into what our data products are gonna provide. In fact, this is the trial product which has just been published in the Planetary Science Journal, and it's the prospectivity of the VIPER landing site. And this is something that is really exciting because now it can be ground truth. And in fact, the data that Blue Origin get are going to be ground truth by VIPER as well. LUPEX from the JAXA and ISRO of India, their rover is going to the South Pole. There's a potential there to integrate their data into these data products for ground truth. I spoke with the project lead for the Rashid 3 rover from United Arab Emirates, very interested in participating. It's a technical demo, if you like, of what they want to do, but they can also add to this because of what we now know from orbit is happening at the South Pole of the Moon. So it's Trying to get that coordination in is phase two, is to get the ground truth that is needed. And I can't not mention Chang'e 7, which is a very capable mission to do prospecting at the South Pole. I know very little about it, but I do know it's going to be very capable. And so when I mentioned, you know, the information sharing pilot study, could that be the study that could pilot or at least could promote, could be to be piloted so that the ways that we share information can be set up and the conduits by which we share information could be set up. Because, as I say, that's the utopia I envision, and we just have to make it happen. So what's next? That's the plan. Now we just have to execute.
I have more questions, but actually, I think I would like to throw it open to the audience, because I'm sure there's plenty of questions in the audience. And I can see some hands raised already. So we're going to open questions for the audience. The first person with a hand up was over there.
Hi, Terese Jones with the European Space Policy Institute. We heard a bit yesterday from the Space Resources Working Group on the draft principles that they're developing, and I wanted to get the panel's take on one of the principles, principle 5, which surrounds sustainability and protection of the environment of Earth and outer space. The principle says, in developing, planning, and conducting or carrying on space resource activities, states shall, should, verb still to be determined, take all necessary measures to, and part F is, to the greatest extent practicable, remediate all areas affected by their space resource activities and restore them to their original condition upon completion of such activities. So wanted to get your take on that, particularly because it references an original condition. And some planetary scientists will say you've destroyed all of our scientific objectives, depending on what those are. You might be more concerned about mobility, whether that's from the disturbance of the lunar surface or from assets left there. So wanted to get your take on what remediation means to you and what you think of this draft principle.
Thanks.
Who wants to go there? Clive.
Okay, there's a lot there and a lot of legal words that I glazed over on, I have to admit, but it's a thorny issue. And I come back to what I said earlier on. If we go to the moon, we've got to go together. So if you have a mining operation, it should not be devoid of science. And we need to be able to understand the environment. So first thing we need to do is to put down environmental monitoring network over the area we're going to visit, because if we don't know what the original environment is really like on the surface, how can we put it back to its original state? So that's number one. Number two, I'm a scientist. I do not believe in keeping sites prohibited for commercial activity. I don't believe in scientific sites of, what do they call it? Sites of special scientific interest. So that's, i think if we go together and we take a leaf out of the construction model in Europe, that when we go to a resource site, and find something that is outside what we expected from the prospecting data, which includes ground truth, everything stops at that location. So it can be documented, it can be sampled, and it can be recorded before things continue. And the reason I say that is because that's how it works for archaeological sites in Europe, and the science gets done because They are constructing. The science gets done because we're there to extract resources. And if we protected that site, it's highly likely that we would never go there, because the science mission will be taxpayer funded, and it would, the tax, you know, budget's a little tight. And so, this is the way we get, we maximise the science, we maximise the exploration, and we maximise the commercial opportunity. So, that's number one. Environmental protection, we need to know what the original environment is. That's number one. Number two, we need to understand Those words, and this is why I said space lawyers have job security, because putting it back to its original condition will not be possible. It's unobtainium, and it's unrealistic to think that way. And I put it out there as a point to be noted by various working groups that Original condition means that we basically would not be able to touch it, and it would inhibit sustainability or sustainable exploration of the moon. It would inhibit commercial participation, and it would inhibit science. So I think we need to think very carefully about how we move forward, and words mean a lot.
Thank you, a compliment.
Absolutely.
Yeah. beside the resources or better material extraction to turn the materials in resources, there will be plenty of other activities that will change, quote unquote, the moon. As soon as we land there, we will modify the original environment. So we have an ethical obligation to, how can I say, make sure that we do that in the best possible way. Not to modify the moon, we shouldn't go there. But this is not our intention. Our intention is to go there. Then we need to develop up from regulation. You don't like the word, but
enabling.
Enabling, okay. that will allow humankind to behave better with respect to what humankind is doing on our planet. I heard the previous panel talking about satellite disposal on the lunar surface. Some satellites will end up in an unprepared, let's say, unselected location because they will not be functioning. But for all those other cases, I'm sure that we will need to discuss possible places where it would be even intelligent to land our no longer working satellite. Why intelligent? Because with the evolving technologies, we might use components, material to further develop the lunar surface infrastructure. So I think that we need to be honest to ourselves. We will affect our satellite. Let's do that in a cleaner possible way.
Thanks very much. I think next question.
Michael Castle Miller, I'm creating the Lunar Development Cooperative. My question is, what are the kind
of, when you think forward about what's needed to create a lunar economy, a real lunar economy,
what are the biggest sort of governance challenges to realizing that vision? What I mean by governance challenges are problems that could be solved through better coordination, better regulation, or that sort of thing.
Is anyone, Marie?
Well, I tried to answer. I believe that today we cannot even imagine the potential commercial opportunities that space will unfold, both in LEO with new commercial space station, in orbit around the moon and on the moon. Materials, I believe, will probably be the first natural one, but there might be other commercial opportunities that we cannot imagine now. So we need to understand better. I joined the DiHAG group years ago to discuss precisely this point. Who owns the moon? I appreciated a sticker on the computer of our Chinese lawyer. I apologize, I don't remember your name. Nobody owns the moon. It's a nice sentence, but who will have the right to handle the extracted materials? Because water, okay, if we manage to, I quote a colleague of mine, a very technical female engineer, "Come on, Maria, do you really want me to shrink that many tons of lunar regolith to get few water drops?" And I say, "Yes, we shall learn how to do that." So be realistic, water is not going to be for the initial decades, a commercial opportunity for the Moon, but maybe Helium-3? Maybe Helium-3? What do you think about Helium-3, Clive?
I think we need the data to make that decision. That's my thought. So to answer your
question, any commercial opportunities, for sure.
Yeah, Jaehyun.
Yeah, actually, I think moon is a resource, it's part of the earth. So it is to protectable share with our humanity. And also, if we Government want to take resources, they will. And also commercialized will make the market in space market, lunar or Martian. And so government aspect, I think, government aspect will be make more intensive our humanity and/or some resources tax. Yeah, that's true.
Thanks very much. I think Clive uttered the word evolvability yesterday, which is, i think, while I dispute the actual word, evolvability, I think that also will be of importance. Next, I will move around, I think, the back.
And then.
Yeah. Lutz Victor here. I'm leading the society called International Society for Terrain Vehicle Systems. It's a nonprofit organization, and I am a space entrepreneur, I would say. Now, I have a question regarding the integration of data sets, Clive, as you were describing it, the integration of data sets regarding the prospectivity, the understanding of resources versus reserves on the moon. My question is the following, should this effort, should it be perhaps entrusted to a, I don't know, a globally acting organization, a nonprofit organization, or would you, Clive, or others, or Catherine, see this as part of the scientific process? the integration of these data sets, the orbital ones that we have, plus the ground truthing that's coming up? How do you see that scientific process versus perhaps a body, an organization, an entity that could be entrusted to take care of that?
Well, my immediate question is, don't you trust me? No.
I mean, you may have the impression that this effort could be, I don't know, something like a closed shop. No. Or not.
No, no, no.
No, certainly, right now, obviously, it's part of the scientific process.
Exactly. And I think that scientific process with peer review, as I said, when you're trying to find the resources, that's the collaborative aspect of it. Once you've found them and you really want to get deeper, that's where the enabling aspects of the UN come in. And I think that we go together to find them, and then we go together to figure out how we're going to extract and use them, and in a way that protects the environment and, I'd say, preserves the environment. Let's do it that way rather than protect, because I think preserves is a better way to think about it. But the scientific process under peer review works really well. And if something gets published that is incorrect, believe you me, it will be found and there will be retribution for that. So it's a self-governing aspect of the finding of the resources that becomes important. So the scientific process works. Is it a closed shop? No. No, it's not a closed shop. But the thing is that what we're struggling with now is developing the standards. that could be uniformly applied to doing prospectivity maps across different locations. And one of the other big things is trying to get a common geodetic reference frame for data from different missions. So this is a non-trivial thing that the USGS has been working towards for a long time. And it's going to be important to make sure that the data sets you integrate and overlay actually sit on the same point that you're interested in. So that's the biggest issue, initial issue, anyway.
Oh my goodness, I have a sea of hands. We will, I think, the delegate from China, and then if you could just keep your hands up a second, it just could work out. Okay, and then we'll come back around. Delegate from China.
Thank you, Catherine. Thank you for recognizing me. The speakers before me just raised a question I also share. I want to ask Cliff, I think you use the term prospecting campaign, whether that look to the reserves rather than the resources. So that is a part of that. But also want to highlight, it seems based on your introduction, you are on the receiving end of the data collection. Whether in the future you have the phase one, phase two, you will be more proactive to provide your research outcome to feed into the design of the lunar missions, which will be more relevant for scientific research, not only limited resources. I think that is very narrow, but you use prospecting, that is mainly for the mining, at least from our national program, the resource is only a very limited part of our project. We look to study the history of the moon as well as the birth of the Earth. So that is a much broader picture if you look at O2PN. I hope you can look over the mining. So that's the first question. My second question is addressed to Maria. I think you, in your introduction, you mentioned you look forward to a common and shared roadmap, but look to the habitat, you highlight the client orientation, the client will be your first look forward to. Do you see there is a tension between a common shared roadmap and client orientation? In particular, if you have a plan to set up a habitat. China also wants to set up an International Lunar Research Station. Under the OST, there is a right to visit the facilities on the Moon. So whether you anticipate in the future, you will open your habitat for the visit from other facilities on the Moon. That is a kind of common shared roadmap. Thank you.
You're absolutely right, and I've shown a Venn diagram that shows the data you need for science to understand the polar water ice, the data you need for exploration, and the data you need for commercial. And over 90% of the data sets all sit within the common area. You will get, by doing a prospecting campaign, you will get an awful lot of science data to understand the origin and evolution of those particular deposits, whether they be volatiles, rare earths. And I think that that is something, it's data that's important, and data that can inform multiple stakeholders in this is going to be critical. And by so by focusing on a narrow prospecting campaign, we will inform a much broader audience. And that is the beauty of this, is that nobody's doing it. It can be done, but it can't be done top down. It's going to be a bottom up approach. And that's what we've started to do that. It can be, you know, and as I say, the data that are obtained already have been obtained, have been interpreted for the science aspect. Now we're going to use it to interpret it for the resource aspect, the exploration aspect, because one of the big things about prospectivity, at least at the South Pole, is, can you actually get to it? Accessibility, can you actually extract it? We don't know anything about that. We have to get that with ground truth. It's the only way you can get the accessibility down to a resolution from orbital data. But then by going in, you're going to have, you'll figure it out one way or the other. And then when you get there to understand the geotechnical properties of what you've actually got is again going to inform future exploration of these particular environments?
Yeah, I just try to answer, if I understood the question correctly, you are talking about an open architecture that will allow two different assets develop on the lunar surface to interact somehow with each other. For sure, it's a must, it's not a need, my opinion. We are yesterday and today talking about establishing common wavelengths for communication. This is for sure a starting point, but we need much more. We need common interfaces. I think that would be really naive to have a rover on the lunar surface that cannot dock to another country habitat or another piece of infrastructure, or to have a power station where different elements could go to get power, to be refueled, and not to be able to execute the operation because The two things don't talk to each other. As for, if I understood you correctly, the possibility to visit another infrastructure, for the time being, I believe that this would be a dream, using locomotion. Maybe we could have jumpers or other means to reach out. I'm coming to the point. The exploration range for which we are currently designing our rover is 100 kilometer.
According to the OST Article 12, they do have the arrangement of visit, but on the reciprocity basis. So that's the treaty language. You do have the right to visit other facilities, but under the condition that you also will open your own facilities to others to visit your facilities. So that is treaty languages, but there's never put into practice. So that is my question, whether Tesla will open your habitat if China also open our facilities to?
Yeah, if somebody will land close enough to our asset. without destroying it, so not really landing on top of it, but let's say in a safe distance, then for sure, yes. The concept of open architecture is that different entities contribute to the architecture with different building blocks. So a country might provide a power station, let's say a nuclear plant, for example, or Volta will beam down to different rovers the power produced with the solar arrays in orbit around the moon. But then we need to be intelligent enough to allow for the different building blocks to connect.
I think the topic of proximity and close landing, we haven't even touched on, though. We've got time for, i think we've got time for two more questions. I'm just looking for people who we might have not heard from so far. At the back. If you can find your way to a microphone.
Hi, good morning. My name is Marlene Lozier. I'm a legal expert and advisor for All Moonkind. And I had a question for Dr. Neal about sites. And it's a follow up on your commentary on sites of scientific interest. What are your thoughts on sites of cultural interest and historical interest? Particularly given, yes, the potential for resource extraction, understanding underneath those sites, but even more related to the the fragility of sites of cultural and historical interest, as you said, once you enter a site, you most likely will not stay the same. And the issue of preservation of a cultural site, particularly on the moon, implies different technical issues that we're still trying to understand. So depending on your answer, also, if you might be able to address the issue of then How would we collectively decide whether or not a site of scientific interest should or should not be preserved, and whether or not then that reasoning would apply to sites of cultural interest? Would that be the same reasoning or different?
I think they're very different, number one. Why is this site being preserved for science is number one, I would argue for, or argue against, because that elevates the science community above everybody else. And that causes division. And we've seen enough division in this world, and it's annoying. I think if we go together, and now I'm talking about all sites, if we go together, so it includes Indigenous communities, And it's an education that I have to undertake myself to understand what that means, because, you know, we have Native Americans in South Bend, Indiana, and I have it on my to-do list to go and understand how they view the moon. But there's other Native Americans in other states in the US that have different views, and I need to get educated on that, and I think everybody does. There's, you know, you go to the aboriginals in Australia, there's, we need to understand what this means. And how, you know, being sensitive to those cultural issues, I think actually Trump's being sensitive to the scientific issues.
Yes, I just wanna just jump in real quick. Yes, I think the perspective of indigenous communities or communities that are not yet, or may not be space faring at some point is certainly important to consider, but other sites of cultural and historical interest, for instance, other countries who have landed rovers on the moon, who may consider those sites of scientific interest.
Oh, absolutely. I mean, it is exactly right. I mean, there are documents out there that said, you know, you shall not disrupt Apollo 11 or Apollo 17, but you may revisit some of the other ones, to understand, for example, how has space hardware actually fared in the 50-odd years since we've been there? So that's a scientific reason to go back. And so I think that those archaeological sites have significance, and we've got them all documented now with the Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter camera, so we know where they are, we know what sort of state they're in up to a point from orbit. But we would gain an awful lot of knowledge if we visited some of them to understand how that hardware has fared or it hasn't, because it's going to inform us about how we build things in the future. So you've got archaeology, you've got Indigenous, and you've got scientific sites. And I would say that we would get more science done by visiting them together than we would making it off limits to other stakeholders.
Just, I'm sorry, visiting them endangers the site.
Well, maybe we should discuss this offline.
Just in the interest of time, we've got time for one quick question, if we can keep it quick. I was going to go there at the back, yes.
Or me.
No, the one behind. Person behind.
Thank you for the opportunity. I am Ajayason Shobhan, currently working at United Nations Department of Safety and Security as an engineer. But I have the previous background for working on a satellite project in Bangladesh, and that's under NASA's SGLI mission. So it's a student-built satellite that will eventually go to the moon. So I have a question to Maria and also Clive, is that since the big enterprises are also working on the moon missions, and they might have the archive for the data, previous data, or they will have the archive for the future missions as well. So will this be shared with us so that we can also gain some prior experience and prior knowledge so that we go and investigate something on top of it? Because we can also understand that in some areas, this is a very competitive market, also in the lunar missions. But still, if there's a way for sharing those data for the sake of educational purpose and research purpose, that would be really appreciated.
Thank you.
Super quick? Yeah, super quick. We are an industry. So we develop a piece of hardware for a client. The payloads that we collect the information about the environment will be handled by the principal investigator. From a technical point of view, we will not totally disclose industrial property knowledge, but we normally publish and share. the way we develop space hardware. As for the information, again, it will be handled by the scientific community, by the different space agencies, hopefully in an open way.
All the national space mission data is on the Planetary Data System in the US. So that is freely available. And then you see distilled and processed data in the peer reviewed literature. So it is available there too.
And just before we finish, just a very quick question to each of the panelists, quick answers only, if there is a quick answer. So what is it that you are, from the meeting that we've had so far, what is it that you would like for the UN and the various bodies that we heard from yesterday, to hear what's the main message for them.
To help with the agreement on common interfaces and to help maintaining clear, maybe not too ambitious, but clear, step by step, plans, and also some clear position on key technologies that might affect technical solution design wise. This is what an industry really needs.
Thanks, Maria and Teeta. Jaiho.
Yeah.
We believe that the next page of lunar activity requires a balanced governance frame that encourages private innovation while maintaining transparency and international coordination. Current treaties, such as Outer Space Treaty and Moon Agreement, mainly address the activity of nation states. However, as commercial and private lunar operation rapidly expand, there is growing need for clear, inclusive, and enforceable guidance that define how company can operate shared data access resources and ensure safety without overlapping or conflicting claims. From our perspective as a private lunar robotic developer, standard for landing coordination, spectrum usage, and dust and traffic management would be especially valuable. Thank you.
Thanks, Jaiho. Clive.
Isn't this an exciting time? I mean, wow. I mean, we're going to the Moon together. So Having an august body like the United Nations create enabling pathways so that we can all go together, I think, is the challenge, but also the opportunity. And so I like to see lots of opportunity coming out from the United Nations that allows us to go together. And as I say, that utopia can be made real. And I'm really I'm excited. I just wish I was 30 years younger. It's really annoying.
Thanks, Clive. So we're at the end of the session. I think what we're hearing from the discussion, this was a discussion on lunar surface activities. But often when we talk about lunar surface activities, we can't separate out the resources activities from other infrastructure, perhaps, and building. It's a complex and many layered issue. So I think, i feel like we've barely scratched the surface in the last hour and a quarter. But some of the key themes that are emerging again, we hear about information sharing, the importance of information sharing. And also the topic of interfaces and interoperability. I think this is also a topic that is of key importance to those looking to develop technologies for the lunar surface. It's a complex topic. It was a packed session. I thank you all for your questions, and sorry to those of you who didn't get to ask your questions, but feel free to chase the panellists as they head for lunch. I would like to thank the panellists, Jay Home, Maria Antonieta, and Clive, and also to thank UNOOS for organising this forum, bringing together our two sides, all the people who work in space resources, have an interest in space, lunar activities, is critical so that we actually develop a common understanding of near-term activities in addition to the vision for the future. If you would like to, I can't end without a small advert, if I may. If you would like to find out more about what's going specifically in space resources, then I would welcome you all to Luxembourg in May, 4th to 8th of May, for our annual Space Resources Week conference. You can find out more about all of the activities that are going on in our field. But thank you very much for the session, and I hand back to Matt. Thank you.
Thank you, Catherine, and thank you, panelists on the Lunar Surfaces team. We're going to be breaking for lunch now. There's a two-hour break for lunch. So again, the cafeteria is an option, but it is a bit of a nicer day today if you choose to dine outside of the facility. And we'll welcome you back here to start at 2:30 for the afternoon session. We'll be talking about top lunar priorities, and then we'll have a wrap-up session where we'll share some of our takeaways, but also encourage you to think about what you're taking away from the conference and our next steps as we look forward to the Moon. Thank you.