Skip to main content

8th meeting, 33rd Session of the Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters

23 October·09:00·01:04:30Meetings & Events

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

Co-Chair

So if everybody could take their seats. I hope you had a good lunch. Before we move to capacity building, we will report from some discussions in the closed session. Sylvia, if you have the slide ready, I will pass the floor to Matthew to report from our closed meeting.

Co-Chair

Thank you very much, Trudy. Good afternoon, colleagues. In the closed session, we did a small realignment to the work mandates of three subcommittees, the Transfer Pricing Subcommittee, the Digitalize and globalized economy subcommittee and the UN model subcommittee. You will recall that in the course of the session, the various reports from the DGA and the TP subcommittee were considered by the committee and approved. with suggestions, the recommendations that were made, and with some amendments for the transfer pricing report on the attribution of profit, the committee decided to review the whole article number seven. And as regard the DGE, report with respect to PE, in respect of cross-border services, the committee decided to pursue option A and B. Option A is to develop a non-physical presence PE, and the committee further decided that that work should include both goods and services. And so what the committee have done in a closed session to allow for proper alignment and coordination of the work is to request the subcommittee on the UN model to take on the additional work with respect to option A of the DG subcommittee and also with respect to the option C plus of the transfer pricing subcommittee. And so with that, all the work that has to do with Article 5 in respect of PE and all the work that is required in respect of Article 7 as regards the allocation of profits to PE will be handled under the UN Model Convention subcommittee and will be coordinated by the co-coordinators of that subcommittee. This was the decision of the Committee in closed session, and we thought to bring it to your notice. Thank you very much.

Co-Chair

Thank you, Matthew. So now we will turn to the agenda item on capacity building. It's item 3L, and there is no paper on this. The Secretariat will provide an update on the recent capacity development activities. These activities remain central to ensuring that the Committee's work translate into practical support for countries. And I think throughout our discussions here, many members and stakeholders and observers have mentioned the importance of capacity building. So I now invite the Secretariat to make its presentation.

UN DESAChief, International Tax and Development Cooperation Branch

Thank you so much, Chair. Good afternoon. So this will be a team presentation, but a concise one. So thank you. Next slide, please, Sylvia. Great. So here's a quick overview. We'll give a brief illustration of how the committee guidance connects with country practice, as Chair just said, an overview of our work since you last convened in New York, an update on our efforts as UN secretariat with our partners in the platform for collaboration on tax and the many other stakeholders that participate in that work, and then a quick look ahead. Next slide, please. Right, so hopefully this is a familiar idea and practice to everyone here in the room and following on the web TV. The committee's mandate is exactly to produce practical guidance that's responding to diverse country contexts with a special emphasis on priorities and needs conveyed by developing countries. We as the Secretariat and Department of Economic and Social Affairs have a mandate to support the uptake and effective use of that guidance in a variety of ways of capacity building and training. This is very much bringing country experience and cases right back here into the work of the Committee, but also into the wider work of the UN, other expert bodies, the Economic and Social Council, General Assembly and beyond. And we do this in a very collaborative way, inspired by the way this committee works, drawing on expertise from member states and from diverse range of stakeholders. So there's that continuous feedback loop. Next, please. Right, so from the last session until this one, we've been busy and many of you with us, because the only way we deliver this work is by looking to you as committee members and you as observers and experts to help us side by side deliver these trainings. So you'll see some statistics there, over 1,100 participants in this last period, reaching over 70 countries and almost achieving gender balance there and really hitting a diverse range of developing countries. You're going to hear a little bit more highlights on the specific activities. We've had a blend of in-person workshops, which we are reserving really where hands-on training, especially simulation exercises, are really critical to the learning objectives. We've done a diverse range of virtual workshops where special emphasis has been making those multilingual, again, to make them more useful and accessible to a wider range of countries. And as you'll hear, we've been doing these in collaboration with many other partners, regional tax organizations, other UN partners and beyond. Next, please. actually would be much more interesting with musical accompaniment. I take the tip for next time. Thank you, Jorge. So what is the evidence telling us? Yes, again, this is some statistics for you on participation, but I draw your attention to the right side of the slide. It's really important to know how these activities are really translating into improved knowledge and understanding. So we ask participants very directly, immediately after the activity, but increasingly six to 12 months after we ask again on the knowledge transfer. And then in very practical terms, what you've learned, is it useful in your daily work? And sometimes also, are you able to share the knowledge with other colleagues? We have some testimonials there from workshops that you'll hear about, but this is really important to get this feedback and we also convey it to you as committee as it relates to how you produce practical guidance and what can make it even more useful for countries and also for taxpayers. Next, please. Right, so here's an overview. of what we've been doing since June, and you'll see there a blend of in-person workshops, and a lot of these are applying the simulation model, but we also have some new workshops in there. You'll hear from colleagues related to another longer-term multi-year project we're doing at country level, and then we've been rolling out a series of virtual workshops that I think many of you will recognize. These are very much focused on getting the amazing 2025 output of the previous membership out in a wider way to countries for their use. So over to Emily now for the next part of our presentation. Thank you.

UN DESAChief, Capacity Development Unit

Yes, thank you very much. And just I noticed today that some people actually we're introduced by the first name only. So my name is Emily Moya, Chief of the Capacity Development Unit, for those who do not know me. I don't take it for granted that I know many people in the room. So thanks again. And I mean, just building on what Caroline has said, if we can just go back a bit, Sylvia, to the slide, the one with the, yeah, this one with the summary. So across all these workshops that you see here, which were quite many, I think they sort of tie the points that Caroline mentioned on the partnerships we have, which we'll come to later, but also just the diversity of the thematic areas across all the parts that the committee is dealing with. And we are actually maintaining a very strong focus on the practical application of the committee's guidance. And as you see there, on the tax treaties and transfer pricing, particularly on dispute avoidance and resolution, but also tying in with emerging issues like environmental tax, which the committee has been working on now since 2021 across 2025 with the handbook and the emerging, the sort of the supplement on emerging issues. And also on crypto assets, which is a key area, I think one challenging for many countries. And for most developing countries, as many would attest, all these emerging issues also fall to be dealt with by the normal tax administrators who deal with other international tax issues, at least particularly in smaller economies. So we try here really to simply deliver, not to simply deliver more workshops, but to build on the capacities of countries to be able to apply in practice. and sustain over time the knowledge that they gain. So we also have a few on tax avoidance risk assessment, multinational tax avoidance risk, and Irving will take us through that in a bit. But Sylvia, please, let's go to the next slide. So one important direction in the capacity development program is really the move towards more sustained learning and engagement. And as we see in this slide, the virtual activities that we managed to do, potentially at low cost, but also really with wide reach, help us to support countries in their areas of needs while also having the double dividend for us in disseminating the committee's guidance. So we had around 460 participants in VAT and GST seminar earlier on this year with 103 315 transfer pricing procurement activities. Again, a very specialized area of transfer pricing, one that was actually developed in the last membership, not this one, but the one in 2021. I think now there have been too many really to deal with the issues that arise in centralized procurement activities and It's really interesting to see how countries continue to engage even in these very technical areas and sharing experiences amongst themselves, really promoting peer learning and also providing a basis that countries can have a base for a community that they can go to and they have problems to address. And then we have the new services provisions under the UN model, already one that we delivered quite early, in fact, during the mandate before the model was finalized. And that brought in 250 people. And as Caroline said, many people in this room have actually been to a couple of these events, either as facilitators or participants. But also, most of the people who've been in any one of these workshops have actually come back to the other workshops. And that also, apart from everything else, of course, with the constraints of virtual participation, does ensure, as I say, that sustained learning, people having a community that you have the familiarity to really continue learning. And again, we had the multilingual delivery in the previous slide, but just to mention that particularly for the five-part carbon taxation series, we also then added interpretation in Arabic. We normally do French and Spanish for all the virtual workshops. And the carbon tax series, attracted 130 plus participants each session for the five sessions. And this was, as I mentioned, an emerging area, one quite complex and quite one that also calls for different stakeholders in the application, in policy setting and application. And we saw very sustained attendance across all those five sessions. So it was actually the same repeat attendance by the same participants across all the five sessions. which covered areas developed by the committee in the 2021 handbook and the supplement of 2025. So I think the strategic directional question here is increasingly not only how many officials we reach, but how we help them to sustain that learning beyond one particular intervention. And also, again, helping countries based on their demand expressions to deal with the complex areas of the tax committee guidance. Next slide, please, Sylvia. For the area on emerging policy issues, the committee in the previous mandate also developed the guidance on tax, trade, and investment agreements. And again, one that involves a lot, a lot of players from both the regulatory, Ministry of Finance, tax authority, justice, really it's everywhere, particularly in the context of disputes. So we co-organized this workshop with the UN Conference on Trade and Development, UNCTAD. It brought officials, really 245 registered officials from 54 countries. We saw very strong participation, very strong interest in understanding the key challenges that arise in the context of applying domestic law. So the tax system and how that interacts with tax treaties and investment agreements. and particularly, as I mentioned, also looking at investor-state dispute settlement resolution. Here, of course, again, we saw, and the committee guidance really emphasizes the need for a whole-of-government approach, and we had 96% of the participants actually attesting to the fact that the learning during the virtual training really helped to emphasize that principle, what is it all about and how do you ensure that you are actually collaborating and really bringing in the perspectives of all those particular government agencies involved. And then similarly, in October, we had the workshop on crypto assets. I want to mention that is also a very particularly emerging. I think of all the workshops, of all the areas tackled by the committee in the last mandate, crypto assets might actually be one of the most emerging, you would say. And Already in that workshop, I remember just reading through the charts as they were coming in during the workshop and people are saying this is a very new area and we had a great interest in registrations. Of course, with virtual workshops, there are always constraints on time and other issues that may not always see the full registrations coming in, the people who registered coming in. But we had 657 people showing interest. In fact, we had also, I mean, particular countries showing even more interest. And when you look at that, it's really the dynamics of where already you see crypto assets, even from a general regulatory perspective being in the light of the government. So in this workshop, we had 236 participants and the discussions highlighted the challenges that governments face in identifying, assessing and responding to crypto related tax risks, including the need for coordination across taxation, financial regulation and other relevant policy areas. So again, a whole of government approach. And we also had the OECD in attendance, teaching alongside us, and then really speaking on the crypto asset reporting framework, which some participants also reported to have been a very important addition for them to understand also that particular part on information exchange in the context of crypto assets. So that was a global forum actually that was represented there. So, these experiences point to an important evolution in capacity development. So, countries increasingly express the need for support, not only in understanding tax rules, but also in managing the interaction with wider regulatory and policy frameworks. And I think this was a very good development also in the last committee membership to be able to really bridge that gap and produce this practical guidance for countries. So we hope that this is an area we will continue in future to develop. Sylvia, the next slide, please. I will really just almost not tackle this slide because Jian did a very good job of presenting on the dispute avoidance and resolution elements earlier. So I would not, we have these slides, we will post them on the website. So I will really save time and not have to go through this slide, but just to note, that these were very, very practical workshops with great simulations, extremely, extremely interesting, exciting feedback from participants. And sometimes, particularly for those who are from certain regions, I can speak of Africa since having been there and practiced there. Some people actually say that they thought that advanced pricing agreements was so scary. But the workshop helped to demystify it. I think that's one of the testimonials we had here. And both these workshops on dispute avoidance and resolution were highly practical. Also getting, and we managed to get facilitators who have been part of the committee's work, either from transfer pricing, dispute avoidance and resolution, and also from developed countries, and also countries country of the government officials who are very interested in really bringing the experiences to the room. So this one is in the CRP that John presented on dispute avoidance resolution and we'll also have these slides online, but I would now really just want to give the slide back so we don't take too much time, but I just want to emphasize here that the practicality of especially this in-person workshops is precisely the kind of practical outcome we aim for. So moving from understanding technical guidance to developing the confidence and skills to apply it in real administrative situations. So I think for the next slide, I will hand over to my colleague Irving. who will take us through further areas of our capacity development, particularly on tax treaty negotiations and the multinational tax risk avoidance. So over to you, please, Irving. Thank you, Silvia. Next slide. Oh, you're there. Thank you.

UN DESA

Thank you, Emily. I will continue in Spanish.

UN DESAChief, Capacity Development Unit

So you have time to.

UN DESA

Good afternoon to everyone. Pleased to report on the ninth edition of that event on the negotiation of tax agreements in Vienna, 24 July of this year. This workshop was part of a series of training opportunities that we've been developing together since 2014. The primary goal of the workshop is to strengthen practical capacity of developing countries when it comes to negotiating, interpreting, and administering bilateral double taxation agreements. This contributes to international tax cooperation that's more effective and that allows for the mobilization of domestic-- of resources for sustainable development. The workshop brought together 22 participants from 14 countries. There was a strong female presence, 59%. Further, we saw the participation not just of experts from the UN and OECD, but also regional experts with broad experience in treaty negotiation. One of the distinctive features of the workshop was the extremely practical focus instead of limiting itself to theoretical capacity building. The workshop was structured in such a way as to simulate negotiations of agreements. There are three teams representing two countries, a developing country and a developed country, and they receive training as well. during the morning session from the facilitators. And in the afternoon, these teams simulate a real negotiation, so a mock negotiation utilizing the tools that have been put together for that purpose. And when I refer to materials, each has a country model that reflects the economic reality in the given country, a reference point of a previous negotiation, and they also have legislation, domestic legislation of both countries concerned. In this mock negotiation, in the afternoon workshop, the facilitators, we did not take place in, or take part in it, rather. It's the parties that do it, simulating negotiation, try to bring about the best possible result for their country, bearing in mind the specific needs of each of their countries. This capacity building, this training, not only bolsters the technical aspects of the treaties vis-a-vis that established in the UN model and the OECD model, but also it underscores different tax policies, depending on what each country is seeking. They establish different negotiation strategies and they establish next steps for this. Each team has to designate a speaker. And of course, and they enjoy that because they don't always have an opportunity when they are part of real world negotiating teams at this point in their careers. So this initiative from 2014 between UN and OECD is not merely happening in Vienna. Now it has allowed for cooperation, ongoing cooperation between these two international organizations. And we're the ones that are the holders of these models. But there are other international organizations, other members of academia, other countries, other stakeholders. taken a role or taken an interest in garnering this training for their region as well. So today we have training in Asia, in Seoul, that will take place in November. And then also there's more trainings slated to be held in Madrid. The Madrid training will be of particular importance because that will be the first time that in the UN, OECD, the Spanish government, the Center for Tax Studies, and the Inter-American Development Bank will have that event 100% in Spanish for the countries of Latin America and the Caribbean. We have other plans as well to expand cooperation between the UN, OECD, and other international and regional organizations to provide such training. targeting agreement negotiators, members of negotiating teams, and any other tax official that might be administering tax treaties. So we have preparatory courses. We have in-person workshops, such as the negotiation workshop, but we also undertake follow-up. We offer follow-up courses. for experts on thematic items. We have had virtual, specific virtual sessions for participants in such workshops, specifically addressing the new articles in the model agreement from 2025 and also the 2021 content that had not been developed fully. So in the next session in Geneva, we'll have the 10th session of such workshops and then others that will be held in the year ahead. Next slide, please.

I will speak a bit about two initiatives taking place in the last few months in the context of the UN project. When it comes to international taxation and internal resource mobilisation, the project that we highlighted in previous sessions has the goal of developing a tool that is designed for developing countries to identify vulnerabilities when it comes to aggressive tax policies used by TNCs. It is important to stress that the instrument is centred on tax forms that are legally allowed but that can significantly reduce tax collection in countries where the economic activity takes place. The tool adopts a perspective of a TNC and analyses how certain features of legislation, tax treaties, fiscal incentives and administrative capacities can create opportunities to move benefits or reduce the tax burden. In the context of that project, two activities were carried out: two workshops at a regional level, one in Nairobi from 17 to 29 August organized by DESA with cooperation from ATAF, SIAT, OECD and the Intergovernmental Forum on Minerals Mining and Sustainable Development, IGF in English. There were 29 tax officials from 18 developing countries present, including 17 African countries. Now the sector The focus sector was the extractive industry, and it allowed us to subject the tool to a real-life test in different regional contexts. The tool, the instrument, was developed with three pilot countries, two of which were from the African region. During that workshop, we tested it out to see whether the tool not only to see whether it worked for those pilot countries but to see whether it could be of utility to any other country in the region. Participants analysed risks related to tax legislation, tax incentives, treaties, preferences, auditing processes and dispute prevention mechanisms. At that workshop, We highlighted the importance of using data, new technologies and artificial intelligence to strengthen tax administration and improve evidence-based decision making. Subsequently, from 21 to 25 September, there was a second regional workshop in Panama City, which was organised by UN DESA in cooperation with CIAT and with tax experts. In fact, one of the members of the committee was one of the experts there, Juan de Montero, and there was also the participation of Gian Marco Cattani. That activity brought together 25 participants from 15 Latin American and Caribbean countries. Its chief focus was the tourism sector. The workshop allowed us to implement the tool in a sector that represents a major source of income generation for many countries in the region: tourism. The discussions tackled questions such as intragroup tariffs, hotel models, all-inclusive hotels, payment for management, royalties, cross-border services and designing tax incentives. In the workshops, the three pilot countries played a very important role, because they shared their own experience of being part of the project and part of the development of the tool. There were also presentations from other countries in the two workshops. At the end, the action conclusions to be implemented with a view to strengthening tax administrations and reduce vulnerabilities. The tool will be available starting next year and it has a web page dedicated to project that we will give to all of you and all updates when it comes to the material capacity building that's going to take place after publication of the tour will be freely accessible to the general public. That project won rave reviews. Countries that took part both in Panama and in Nairobi They need assistance when it comes to the application of the tool, so we will see how the UN has co-operated with other organisations and how the best way to provide that technical assistance is. With that, I want to thank all those from the UN and from related international organisations that took part, the facilitators and all other stakeholders.

It's Ilka.

UN DESA

Next slide, please. Hi, my name is Ilka Ritter, and I want to give you a short update on the Platform for Collaboration on Tax, or PCT. And as many of you will know, the PCT brings together IMF, OECD, UN, and World Bank Group with the goal to aid countries in strengthening domestic resource mobilization, and it was founded exactly 10 years ago. in 2016 and marking its 10th anniversary, there was a large conference held in Tokyo with generous support from the Japanese government. And many of you or some of your colleagues attended the conference and it was very enlightening to hear many of the reflections on what is working well with DRM, but also what is not working well. And I'm going to present a couple of lessons now, but then you will also see in the second part of the presentation where I will talk about medium term revenue strategies, how these lessons are actually reflected in this tool. So from the PCT conference, we heard stories from from countries about how any tax reform needs to be country led. It needs to have a medium term strategy. It needs to be tailored to country circumstances. And something we also heard was that the sequencing of reform is very important to allow for comprehensive reform, but also to allow for absorptive capacity, to allow for communication with stakeholders to allow for the reform to actually be successful. And then maybe I'll focus on one more thing. Working together is essential, and that's along many dimensions. So both in terms of state capacity, so working the finance ministry, working with tax administration, working with customs administration, working with regional partners, but also collaborating and coordinating with development partners along the way. Next slide. As I mentioned, you will see that some of exactly those lessons are reflected in MTRS. So, MTRS is a framework that was developed by PCT and first launched in 2016, and it's built on four building blocks. One is the idea to set realistic, achievable objectives that are both linked to fiscal needs that you've previously identified, but also to other priorities and also linking to behavioral changes that taxes can bring about, such as fighting inequality or environmental aspects. Then the second building block would be the design and sequence of reform. So you design and implement an integrated package, and you take into account tax policy, tax administration, and the broader legal framework, so data protection, taxpayer rights, and so on. Then the third pillar would be sustained political commitment and reform management. And we talked about this during the wealth segment of the session that leadership for reform is very important, effective governance of a reform process, communication and change management. So reaching out to stakeholders, ensuring buy-in, coordinating different ministries and so on. And then the last pillar would be coordinated capacity building, and that's kind of reflecting on how development partners have to be aligned, have to be mobilized in order to adequately support any reform processes. So this tool was launched in 2016. More than 30 countries have, entered into an MTRS, haven't necessarily completed it, but have entered into it. And I believe a couple of countries that you're coming from have also entered into MTRS. Now, 10 years after it has first been launched, there was some reflection on what has worked well, but also what hasn't worked well. So we know that actually that perceptions of MTRS as a tool to guide in tax policy reform is overall positive, but performance is mixed and attribution of tax revenues or increased tax revenues to certain reform packages is hard. And I should maybe caution that this mixed performance or is likely also due to COVID and other geopolitical circumstances. But still, after 10 years, there was a decision to revisit MTRS and to see what can be approved. And overall, the ideas and the four pillars that I've just shortly described were seen as still being valid and helpful. But there were some key failures that were detected. One was setting maybe unrealistic targets. having weak reform management, limited monitoring, and also where partners, development partners, aren't coordinating amongst themselves enough. So certain elements have been updated in MTRS, and MTRS 2.0 will launch probably towards the end of the year, and it will have better reform management, so stronger focus on country ownership, governance of the reform process, monitoring and communication. It has more flexible time horizons. So, in the past, MTRS was three to four years, and now it will be three to eight years, and also will link better to existing, for example, budget cycles and political cycles and so on. And there will be more readiness guidance. So, how do I, as a country, decide whether or not I'm ready to enter into an MTRS? They have added tailored pathways, and this is especially relevant for LICs or fragile states, which may not be ready to do a full MTRS, but which may be ready to do a smaller, more tailored MTRS to help towards their goal. Then MTRS 2.0 also looks at credible targets and costing. better sequence and will introduce or has introduced and will continue to introduce some additional operational tools such as gap analysis, roadmaps, and so on. So as I said, this will be launched towards the end of the year and we'll be happy to provide further information should you be interested. Thank you.

UN DESAChief, International Tax and Development Cooperation Branch

So then just to quickly wrap up and we'll share the slide deck with you. These are workshops to come, continuing on tax treaties, some more virtual on border carbon adjustment, carbon offset frameworks, and a follow-up virtual workshop on the APAs. And of course, the online courses are always available online. Next, please. So very important slide here. We do Most of this on voluntary contributions that come to our team. We have a small amount of regular resourcing, including from the UN's regular program of technical cooperation, which also provides one of our advisory posts. But we are heavily reliant on contributions of these governments you see on the screen. Thanks to Norway, Denmark, India, Singapore. These are not time limited commitments so we also want to welcome because we are in a position where the demand for the activity and support we can provide is much higher than what we can do. So we've already had to defer a lot of requests and other activities. So any interested contributions, but these are complementing very much the significant contributions through committee members and stakeholders and observers you've been hearing. You are a huge part of our being able to deliver this support and maintain these communities of practice, really all anchored here in the committee itself. Next slide, please. Yeah, so just a few questions, welcoming your insights and feedback. Of course, we always want to hear the latest from you on the pressing needs and priorities you have in capacity development, near term and medium or long term, and then anything else you'd like us to keep in mind as we proceed with planning for next year and years to come. Thank you so much for the time and attention, and back to you, Chair.

Co-Chair

Thank you to you, Caroline, Ilka, Emily, and Irving, for the presentation, and also to the team for all the things you're doing, capacity building. It really is encouraging and inspiring, I would say, to see the work that we do here and our products brought to life, and also that they are so I will open the floor for any comments and input that committee members and stakeholders and observers have. Kapemba, please.

Zambia

Thank you very much, Chair, and thank you so much to the capacity development team. I am amazed by the volume of work that you've managed to do in the last six months and really, truly grateful to all of you for all the efforts that you put in. I was particularly interested to see the course, which I think is new on APAs. I think that's such a relevant topic, and I know it's something that we are looking to, especially because of the conversations that are happening at the Intergovernmental Negotiation Committee and the rising prominence and discussions around APAs. So it's very nice. that the UN has taken that up in the same format as the DTA training, which I was privileged to be a part of quite recently. And I know the effectiveness of that DTA negotiation training. So I am wondering how we get Zambia on the shortlist for the APA training. And yes, more generally on the work coming up under the MTRS, Zambia is also walking down the MTRS path and we had the benefit of having an early meeting with the PCT and I think the changes that are being pointed to in the MTRS 2.0 are super relevant and it was encouraging to know that the flexibility has now officially been introduced into the MTRS process as well as that openness for revisions and more talk about political buy-in. So all this to say that I think your work is extremely helpful. We are beneficiaries even under the UN aggressive tax planning work. We have seen the capacity evolve among our workers, among our officers, and Zambia truly is grateful and I myself am a beneficiary of all of this and obviously I'll always be on hand to support wherever needed. Thank you, Chair.

Co-Chair

Thank you. Angela, please.

Speaker 14

Thank you, co-chair. I would like to thank the UN Secretariat for the work that you do on this. I think it's very interesting how, for this presentation, all of you in a row took turns to present, and it really shows also how the work of capacity building involves many partners. And I really appreciate that. I wanted to speak also because I remember intervening on this topic the last round when you asked how can we measure the success and the effectiveness of our capacity building programs. And I was very encouraged to see that already reflected this round in the updates, how you looked at not just the number of programs that were pushed out, but also the satisfaction levels of the participants. And you even included quotes. And I think that's the richness of it, that we go beyond numbers, but we also want to see the quality of the impact that we are creating. So I would say a lot of support for the work that is being done, and thank you for being so always willing to enhance what we are delivering to our members and those who are in need. My only suggestion, I guess, as we consider what to prioritise or what to cover in the coming year or years, is a perspective that I also carry for myself, which is every time when we look to prioritise and to look to add new programmes to meet new needs, a question I ask myself will then be, what could I discontinue? Because I think if not, the needs will keep growing and soon we will have 10, 20, 30 programmes and I think we will never be able to fully cover all the needs that are necessary. And so in terms of prioritisation, I guess it's useful then to use the outcomes that we have achieved, whether it has reached a point of maturity or whether the kind of impact that we are creating could be better deployed at a new area. So like APAs, for example, So these are suggestions that I hope could be useful as we look to continue to improve our program. But great congratulations for the impact that you're creating. Thank you.

Co-Chair

Thank you. Vanjay, your please.

Speaker 16

Thank you, co-chair, and thank you to the capacity development team for all the great work they're doing. and also for all the identified parties who support this work by giving it financial support, and also for the trainers who support your work. During yesterday's presentation on the UN model, there were a number of requests for capacity development on the subject to tax rule, uh, I understand that it's a new rule and maybe there wouldn't be so much practice to, to borrow from. But I think countries really need some help in terms of how to implement because it is being negotiated by quite a number of countries. And maybe when they're faced with questions of how does it apply to certain articles, that's work that's currently being done by the UN model. But I think since countries are currently negotiating it, they would really benefit from examples of how it would apply and how it also interrelates with the other articles. So I just wanted to bring that to your attention as much as it was also raised in yesterday's presentation. Thank you.

Co-Chair

Thank you very much. Yes, that is noted. Shanice, please.

Speaker 18

Thank you, Chair. I echo the sentiment of my colleagues here in that the work of the capacity building has been very, very useful. particularly for developing countries. I can speak from personal experience having been part of several of these initiatives throughout the year, that the impact that they have is long-lasting. And I can also speak from having been a beneficiary in previous years, and the fact that we were able to take the information back to our particular capitals and be able to train on the ground. And so the impact is beyond this committee, it is across the tax administration. And in so doing, we're actually able to find gaps in the tax administration that we could go back to the team and indicate to the UN group that these are the gaps that we're finding. How do you propose that we can build our capacity to bridge those gaps? And I find that this kind of information, this continuous education, has been very, very useful to the development of the tax administration. Additionally, I want to commend the work of the follow-ups, the six months down the line, the two years down the line. That part has been particularly useful because what has happened in other circumstances is that a team member, a couple team members are trained in an area and they have the knowledge, but they're not able to apply the knowledge. And so over time, the knowledge slowly dwindles away. But six months later, when we get the follow-up and the check-in to see what is the status and how have you used the information and what have you been able to use it to do, that triggers, I find, continuous development. That triggers or that reminds persons of the information that they got, and they're able at that time to indicate this is the reason I was not able to use the information and that becomes a gap that can be plugged, or I was able to use the information but I needed more training or I need training in additional areas, or perhaps, and this was actually something that we noted, many persons have engaged in the training and then didn't use the training, and then at the six-month check-in or one-year check-in, depending on what it is, they realize that perhaps they were not the best suited person or that particular role was not the role that ought to have had the training. And so they're able to direct that particular training to another unit or another part of the tax administration that could benefit better from it. And so again, I commend the work that is being done. I look forward to being part of many future capacity development, and again, I extend my services in whatever way to serve this. Thank you.

Co-Chair

Thank you. And I think it's very good that we have committee members that have actually participated in and benefited from this capacity building efforts because you can also bring this into the work that we do here in the different projects we have. So I think that's a really good. Gedre, please.

Speaker 20

Very, very quickly, I would like to also to congratulate the Secretariat and UN DESA with the activities that have been done. I have participated myself in the carbon taxation workshops and my only suggestion would be to continue them because by the questions that we received from the participants and by the participation I think there is a need. Carbon taxes can raise revenue and solve quite a few problems, not only in developing countries, but also in developed countries. And as it's basically the newest domain of taxation and still very in the margins, changing a lot, I think those future trainings would be useful. So thank you very much. And yeah, please continue like this. Thank you.

Co-Chair

Thank you. Sierra Leone, please.

Sierra Leone

Thank you so much once again, Co-Chair. And also, I want to commend the committee members for the tremendous work being put into this, especially for connecting international tax guidance with practical support. for developing countries. We particularly appreciate the emphasis on learning from countries' experience, using those lessons to improve future guidance. So for now, I would want to specifically forward three aspects for our situation, especially learning from the countries' experience. So firstly, the work on multinational tax avoidance risk in mining and extractive industries is particularly relevant to Sierra Leone. Practical risk assessment tools can help administrations focus limited technical resources on transactions that presents the greatest revenue risk. Continued assistance, specifically in applying those tools to actual country circumstance, will be valuable. Secondly, the combination of practical training, negotiation, simulations, and continuing communities of practice provides an important bridge between acquiring knowledge and also applying it. For developing administrations, the real benefit comes from when officials can use that learning to access transactions, negotiate effectively, and resolve tax issues. We therefore encourage follow-up support and assessments on how training improves everyday administration. Thirdly, we welcome the VAT, GST, should GST exchanges and the emphasis on coordinating nations across government, especially because most developing countries, of which Sierra Leone is not an exception, is not sustainably of digitally for need staff capacity. Therefore, the discussion of MMTRS 2.0 as an integrated strategy for revenue mobilization is highly relevant. For Sierra Leone, its value will lie in helping align existing reform, national priorities, and developing partner support within a realistic implementation plan. My final question, therefore, is concerning the MTRS 2.0. I raise it because countries already have reforms on the way, and understanding the lessons from the earlier approach will help us identify what it contains. what's to improve and where additional support is needed. So therefore, I would appreciate if the committee clarify what framework preceded the MTRS 2.0 and which lessons from its implementation shaped the changes now proposed, particularly for developing countries like mine. I thank you.

Co-Chair

Thank you very much. John, please.

Switzerland

Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. Thank you for this team presentation. It's nice to see how everybody is implicated in this very important activity. I mean, I'm a broken record since many years regarding capacity building. I always make the same comment on how important capacity building is. It's really one of the one of the committees and one of the activities where our UN Tax Committee and the Secretariat make a real difference on the ground quite quickly. And as Shanice was pointing out, often not only are certain tax negotiators or different specialist instructed and they learn, but they bring back the know-how and spread it back in their home country. And I think it's really such an important work. Congratulations. It's too bad in view of the importance of the subject that we're having this on a Friday afternoon when there's less people in the room, and I think there's even a double-booked event for developing countries this afternoon. That's kind of unfortunate, but because Really, this is one of the most important activities of our committee. So thank you again.

Co-Chair

Thank you very much. I think the record you play is very good in this. I see no further flags or requests for the floor. No. So thank you very much for all your input and perspectives. They bring a lot of value to the work that is being done and you will continue to do so. It's much appreciated. And with that, we are approaching the closing of this meeting. I will invite closing remarks to be delivered on behalf of the Secretariat by Caroline, Chief International Tax and Development Cooperation Branch. Financing for Sustainable Development Office of the UN.

UN DESAChief, International Tax and Development Cooperation Branch

Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you for the comments. And we had some questions. We'll follow up with you individually. It's been a very productive week, as you all know. I'll just give some quick highlights. This is the first session that really marked the shift from your work planning phase to your hard work phase. You had a number of technical outputs and decisions, and we just reviewed them at the top of this session on digital, on transfer pricing, on the UN Model Tax Convention. You also had a first look at the STTR, and you've put in place how you're going to follow up. You've actually taken on some more work and have a clear path forward. You've adopted an outline for the coming guidance on wealth. You have looked at extensive outline for a guidance on artificial intelligence. You've had a series of really interesting presentations on groups of papers on different work streams of the committee. Extractives looked at the critical minerals topic. You looked at the monitoring function. You looked at a series of papers on environment, on indirect tax and tax and gender, and received a lot of feedback and concrete suggestions and heard an open call across all agenda items to continue to send in inputs and feedback and ideas. had also an update on the dispute avoidance and resolution, another monitoring item of the committee. So across all work streams, and you also finished all agenda items on time, used the time very efficiently. So a big pat on the back for all of you. And this brings me to my second and final point, which is just a huge thank you. And let me start by thanking Gian and the Swiss government and the colleagues at the Federal Department of Finance, because because it's such a gracious hospitality and also really helps show how this committee and the whole network it supports just brings the joy to the work. It's so purposeful, but it brings the joy. So we all just want to thank the Swiss government and the people and you and your colleagues, John. We know it's not easy to pull off. So a big thank you. to the wider network that represents as well. Thank you to all the observers. This is a very multidisciplinary, multi-stakeholder work the committee does from academia, from civil society, from our sister international organizations, regional tax organizations, business and private sector. We need everybody in here to help lift the quality of the work. And I also want to say a thank you to the professors and university students who join us. We need to keep growing this interest and the capacity building. I want to thank as well our colleagues here at the Palais, all of our colleagues here in Geneva, from security to conference servicing, our wonderful interpreters. One of whom informed me they actually don't interpret acronyms. This is a new lesson learned for us. So, a thank you to them. It's a very hard work, but how we communicate and understand each other is so important. I think our DESA team that is back home following online and very much part of the whole ecosystem that makes this committee function. And Last but not least, the members themselves. You're here serving in your personal capacity. You're not working twice a year. You're working all year round. And a thank you also to your colleagues. We know, in a way, while you're in personal capacity, it's also a massive in-kind contribution of your governments that you have the time to dedicate to this work when you all have huge day jobs on top of that. And of course, all of us would like to thank both of our co-chairs, for leading us so ably through this week and through everything we do. So a thank you to all, and we look forward to welcoming you to New York in April. Thank you.

Co-Chair

Thank you, Caroline. And I especially appreciate you recapping all the work that we have been doing here and summarizing it. So now, on behalf of myself and my co-chair, Matthew, I would like to thank all of our fellow committee members for all the work we've done here, your inputs, your insights, and also to the observers for participating, providing your ideas, and all stakeholders. We appreciate the efforts of the conference services and the interpreters. And I would like to thank the Secretariat for all the support you provide, not only during the session, but throughout the work that we do in between in supporting the co-coordinators and all the committee members, so that we are, in fact, able to do this work. It's very much appreciated. So now we will move to a closed meeting to formally close this session. I also would like to thank everyone who has been participating online. We look forward to see you all, hopefully, in New York in April. So we will take a few minutes for everyone who is not a committee member to say goodbye, and then the committee members will in a closed meeting. Thank you.