Skip to main content

Conference on the Commercial Lunar Landscape and Policy Needs [Meeting 1]

17 November 2025·04:00·04:53:53Meetings & Events

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

UNOOSAConference moderator

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. If you can begin taking your seats, we will kick off the conference here in just a few moments.

Speaker 2

All right. Stop.

UNOOSAConference moderator

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Conference on the Commercial Lunar Landscape and Policy Needs. This event is organized by the UN Office for Outer Space Affairs, or UNOOSA, as we call it, and we're very pleased to welcome all of you here in person, and for those of you joining online. We think this will be An excellent opportunity over the next two days to both understand what is happening within the UN bodies as regards to lunar governance and hear from the commercial sector to understand what they have planned on the Moon and around the Moon in the near to mid future, as well as the needs that they have for the international community. And so, without further ado, please allow me to introduce UNOOSA's Director, Arti Halimayini. Arti.

UNOOSADirector

Excellencies, distinguished delegates, dear friends, thank you so much for coming to Vienna, and thank you to those who are joining us online for this conference. It's my great pleasure and privilege to host you here for our second lunar conference. I know that some of you followed or participated in our first conference last year, and we're glad to be doing it again this year. Now, I know that many of you, especially our commercial counterparts joining us in person and online, are wondering, why is the UN holding a lunar conference? Or, what is the UN doing on lunar policy? These are questions that I have received in the last few months. And just hearing these questions actually speaks volumes. Indeed, it reminds us that when people think about the United Nations, they think about world peace and global development, but they most certainly don't think about space. Commercial actors are familiar with their national landscapes, obligations imposed by regulators, the needs for launch and operation licenses. But what they may not realize is that so many of those national rules are based on the agreements that are reached here in Vienna, the home of space governance. Yes, the UN does work on space, and in line with the ambitions of maintaining world peace, COPE was established precisely to ensure that those ambitions extend also into outer space, including on the Moon. And so far, it has worked well. The entire flourishing space economy that we see with all its dynamism, the millions of dollars of investment that go into it every year, all of the innovations that we see, has been enabled by six decades of treaties, resolutions, principles, and guidelines that have been negotiated here by member states in COPUS. This work underpins what you see nationally, and usually that's where visibility for the commercial sector starts and ends. But when it comes to lunar, with 100 plus missions going to the Moon between now and 2040, there is a clear need for policies and procedures to ensure that the Moon remains a peaceful domain with safe operations on and around it. And so it is natural that COPUS should also work on this topic. With this conference on day one, we aim to shine a spotlight on COPUS's different work streams. You will hear about the Space Resources Working Group, the Action Team on Lunar Activities Consultation, the Working Group on Nuclear Power Sources, and the work of the International Committee on Global Navigation Satellite Systems, which is working on defining a lunar time zone. But of course, nothing is possible in space without radio frequency spectrum. And so we will also hear from the chair of the ITU's Working Party 7B, which is working on that. As I said, decisions taken in these multilateral processes will be implemented in national legislation, and they will trickle down to industry via licensing requirements and contractual obligations where appropriate. We hope, therefore, that industry will find this day insightful and will use it as an opportunity to ask questions and connect with some of the delegates that are involved in this work. Similarly, COPUS delegates also take a very keen interest in hearing about the real missions from different countries, because these missions bring the work that is done here in the Committee to life. It is only by communication and exchange that we can ensure that policy is fit for purpose and future proof. So on day two, we will have the opportunity to hear from commercial companies planning or operating lunar missions to better understand their plans and their operations, and most importantly, where they see a need for clarity when it comes to governance. This is a unique opportunity for industry to inform responsible, forward-looking governance. Of course, we're not going to solve every issue related to lunar activities. In fact, the conference may give rise to more questions than it answers, but that is precisely the point. The panel discussions and side conversations that will happen over the next two years will help illuminate areas that need to be addressed as we strive to build a safe and sustainable lunar future together. By facilitating informal dialogues between member states and industry, UNOOSA hopes to foster a better understanding between both worlds in order to support more efficient and more effective policy making. Dear guests, this is the first initiative that UNOOSA has done under our One Moon for All program, and we see this event as the beginning of a dialogue that will continue in the years to come. I thank you so much for joining us, and I look forward to a very insightful and enlightening two days ahead. I would now like to invite the panelists for the first session to join me on stage. Olpe and Hassan, please join me. So here we are, jumping right in. The first session of this conference is going to be an opportunity to learn more about the Action Team on Lunar Activities Consultation, affectionately known as ATLAC, as we call it. So for context, the proposal creating ATLAC was formally adopted last June by COPUOS, following UNOOSA's first lunar conference. Its prime mandate is to facilitate focused, expert-level exchanges to develop recommendations to improve how states and other stakeholders coordinate and share information in an era of increasing lunar missions. I'm extremely pleased to be joined by the co-chairs of ATLAC. We have Oltia Botezatu from the Romanian Space Agency and Hassan Abbas from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Pakistan. Obi, if I can start with you, can I invite you to briefly introduce yourself? And perhaps as a first question, you could explain how and why ATLAC was established. Thank you.

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much. It's an honor to be here. Good morning, everyone. I'm Oulpia. I work for the Romanian Space Agency as space policy officer. I'm also the current chair of the scientific and technical subcommittee of the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space for another two months or so. And I'm also, together with Hassan, co-chairing action team on lunar activities consultation. And with regards to the first question, ADLAC was established by the UN Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space at its 67th session in 2024, following the intense debates among member states on how to improve consultations with regards to lunar activities. The initiative has been tabled by the delegation of Romania. And that proposal, initial proposal, has been developed, refined, and ultimately endorsed by consensus by the committee. The decision to create APLAC recognized that lunar exploration is entering a new and very complex phase involving a growing number of actors, not only national space agencies, but commercial entities, and potential overlapping missions in the outer space. COPUOS saw this need for clear, expert-level inclusive mechanisms to help coordinate these initiatives, these activities, and ensure that to a certain extent, these are conducted in a sustainable and responsible manner. Thus, ADLAC was formed within the COPUOS framework with a focused mandate not to duplicate the ongoing legal or technical work, but to develop recommendations on how lunar activities should be structured, improved, possibly paving the way for a future international mechanism. Thus, in essence, ADLAC reflects the intention and the need for discussing, sitting down and discussing about lunar activities.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you, Ulpia. Hassan, if I can come to you, please introduce yourself. And could you provide an overview of ADLAC's current work and areas of focus as outlined in its work plan?

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much. Thank you very much, Aarti, and a very good morning to all colleagues. My name is Hassan Abbas. I am currently the Director for Arms Control, Disarmament, and International Security at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Pakistan. But less than one and a half months ago, I was posted here for a wonderful three and a half years in Vienna, where I was working on all outer space issues. And so I've had the privilege to work with a lot of friends who I see here today and welcome a lot of new colleagues as well. Regarding the ATLAC's work plan, so we have a multi-year work plan which was agreed from 2025 to 2027, and it was endorsed by COPUS at its 68th session in 2025, which lays out a phased and inclusive approach. In its initial phase, the action team is concentrating on mapping current consultation practices and identifying emerging challenges. Which means that ATLAC is studying how states and organizations presently consult about upcoming lunar missions, where gaps, overlaps in these practices exist, and what specific difficulties states anticipate as lunar activities expand. And while I make this point, I also want to highlight that 2025, we're already nearing the end of 2025. So if I can add just a personal reflection on this, that 2025 was more where we set the foundations. We've had initial consultation. We worked on the work plan. We've recognized the initial list of priority topics which are need to be discussed, which helps us go into 2026, which is critically going to be perhaps the only year that ATAC has to have substantive deliberations and have recognition of and hopefully have consensus on all of these issues moving forward, since 2027 will be more about delivery. So 2025, as it was about planning, 2026 about substance, and 2027 about delivery. And at the same time, I also recognize that ATLAC, given its mandate and its frame of work, also enjoys a very special position within the architecture of the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space, because, as colleagues over here would know, that there are the subcommittees, the scientific and technical subcommittee, and legal subcommittees, and within those subcommittees, there are specific working groups that are working, but ATLAC cuts through all. It's present in the STSC because its relevance is there. We have our meetings there, then we have in the LSC and then the corpus. So I also want to highlight that as the current work as identified within its work plan, also within its its initial list of priority topics, but also highlight its importance of deliberation that we recognize that time is of the essence. And we are here, we are availing every possible opportunity to continue and further these discussions as we move forward towards a focus and have these focused and direct exchanges.

Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you both. So what are some of the implications of emerging lunar activities that ATLAAC is currently considering in its deliberations?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

I will start. Emerging lunar activities bring both opportunities and new challenges for the international community. We are really witnessing a rapid increase in planned lunar mission from robotic landers, rovers to proposals for long-term infrastructure. And most of this are done through partnerships between governments and private entities. This expansion of activity, lunar activities, remains critical for APLAC, is very mindful of. And just to give you some examples, multiple actors targeting similar lunar regions, for instance, must consider the interoperability of systems and avoidance of harmful interference. Issues like how to coordinate landing sites to prevent spacecraft from endangering each other, or how to mitigate lunar dust from landing that could affect nearby assets, or how to manage cislunar traffic in orbit to avoid collisions. These are questions that we have been addressing in the ATLAC. Likewise, communication frequency management, data sharing channels, preservation of sites of scientific or historical importance to the Moon have been also highlighted as concerned or as topics in the ADLAC. ADLAC's deliberations specifically take these developments into account by examining how improved consultations practices could help mitigate risks and possible frictions. The idea is that if states exchange information and consult early about their plans, consistent with their obligations of due regard under the Outer Space Treaty, issues like conflicting missions, interference with critical experiments, or disputes over resource rich areas can be anticipated and addressed in a cooperative manner. ADLAC remains grounded in the international law. The Article 9 of the Outer Space Treaty mandate to avoid harmful interference. So we recognize that and the consultation practices, we also recognize that the consultation practices must adapt to this new environment on the Moon.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

And just to complement what Utpiya just highlighted, that we also recognize that lunar operations perhaps at the moment no longer fit neatly one specific discipline. They require legal clarity, technical interoperability, policy predictability, and trust. So consultations, which is embedded in ATLAAC's name, the Action Team on Lunar Activities Consultations, it is one of the more practical tools that we have to manage these risks, enabling transparency, preventing conflict, building predictability among actors and different capabilities, objectives, and most importantly, Again, coming from a developing country, for many emerging space actors in developing countries, this existence of a transparent UN-based process is what gives confidence that all relevant actors can participate in future lunar activities on fair terms and not only on existing norms, so they can also evolve in due course.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you very much. I appreciate very much what you say about building trust, et cetera. That really goes to the heart of COPUS's work, indeed. So why is the work of APLAC relevant to commercial lunar companies, in your view? And how might it shape future lunar activities?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

AFLAC's work is directly relevant to government, industry, the broader space community, because international consultations are not just diplomatic manners, they are fast becoming an operational necessity. As lunar activity intensifies, multiple missions targeting the same or similar regions or timeframes, coordination of trajectories, landing sites, surface operation is essential for the safety, sustainability, and of course, mission success. So if we look from a commercial lunar operator perspective, clear and transparent consultation practices established at the international level can significantly reduce uncertainty. If companies know where they There is an agreed process for sharing plans and resolving potential conflicts, for instance, two missions eyeing on the same landing area. They can avoid harmful interference and costly last minute changes. This builds trust, again, among all actors sharing this lunar environment. On the other hand, states participating in ATLAC are gaining insights into the practical realities faced by the commercial actors. For example, the tight development of timelines or cost constraints, innovative approaches that characterize usually the private ventures. These are important for governments as they have duties under the Outer Space Treaty, including the due regard for others' activities and responsibility for national space activities. Then, lastly, academia, scientific community are also stakeholders. By staying informed of emerging consultation norms, for instance, researchers can also align their experiments. They can contribute data in various ways that reinforce safe and sustainable exploration.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

And just to add one point. Within the work of ATLAC, we also endeavor to build that mutual understanding by clarifying how, when, and why information should be shared internationally and by creating a trusted multilateral space where this exchange can occur. And ultimately, our work overall is laying the foundation that will allow not only member states, but within member states, also allow the industry, academia, new entrants also operate more responsibly and confidently in an increasingly crowded lunar environment.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. I mean, there's nothing worse than regulatory uncertainty, right? But when we say regulatory, we're not talking about new regulations per se, but at least some indications or guidelines which reflect a shared agreement by member states globally for something so important as the Moon. Okay, thank you very much for setting the scene with that. This conference is meant to be for the participants. We would like to open the floor and invite questions for our co-chairs. So if anybody has questions, please feel free to raise your hand. The event is being live streamed, but we're not able to take questions online, I believe. But yes, we have a question from the room. Please, can I ask you to introduce yourself to start?

TAS

Yeah, Maria Antonietta Perino from Thales Alenia Space in Torino, where we are super busy doing moon stuff. Wanted to ask you, who are the members of this committee?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

I can start. The AHLC is established under the UN COPUOS, meaning that we have representatives from the member states. However, we don't have only member states, and I can take the example of Romania. We have been building into our note verbal to the UNOOS Secretariat, a delegation that is containing experts from academia, from the industry, from space agency. We have diplomats. So we have a little bit of everything inside our delegation. And we hope that that kind of framework of representation into ADLAC work is actually meaningful. So I hope that answers your question, as an example.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much for the question. And just to supplement what Ulpija was highlighting, ATLAC is open to member states. And initially, as per the mandate in terms of reference, every member state can nominate up to four experts. And as I think Romania is one of the best case examples for this, that it is up to member states to nominate whether they can be diplomats, they can be experts from the industries. So I think it really blends in the conversation of member state act like being a member state driven process, but also allowing that sufficient flexibility that member states are free and open as they see fit who to nominate and participate in this process. Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Can I just clarify? So you're saying that member states can nominate their industrial experts to also be on their delegation amongst the four experts? Is that what you're saying?

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

We've kept it open for member states to nominate who their experts can be. So they can come in from as the government experts, but we leave it up to member states who they nominate.

Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Okay, and I think an important related question to what was asked is, we know that only a handful of member states are actually having missions going to the moon. Does that mean that ATLAG is limited to discussions only between those member states? Could you clarify?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Yes, thank you for the question. I think it's a really important question. We are attempting to grow together in ATLAG, meaning that we have invited member states or delegations from member states to present their past, present, or future lunar activities and to highlight the challenges that they envision. particularly for the future. And while they are doing that, we hope that those representatives which don't have as much experience in lunar activities can also understand the importance of addressing lunar activities and addressing possible mechanisms for consultations in this regard. And really, the idea is to build trust among us and to grow together in this.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. Are there developing countries participating as well?

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Yes, definitely. And Pakistan, we have our own delegation and as well we have a healthy contingent of other Member States who are actively sending their representations for ATLAS. So, yes, we've had from developing countries, from all countries, and we continue to welcome and invite Member States who have not done so far to please send in their delegations details as soon as possible so we can continue this discussion. Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you very much. Yeah, indeed, it's worth highlighting that COPUOS convenes from January next year 110 member states out of the 193 UN member states, but all decisions of COPUOS and its sub-bodies are reported to the General Assembly and approved by the General Assembly, so all UN member states as well. We had two questions. I think the first one was over here, and then coming back over here. Thank you. Thank you.

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you.

OSI

Am I doing this right?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Mike, thank you.

OSI

Robin Frank, the Outer Space Institute of Canada.

A follow-on question to what you've been discussing. Is the list of representatives appointed by member states publicly available on?

Copious website or otherwise.

And then a related question to what Mr. Hasan Abbas said, which is, could you give us a sense?

Of the schedule of APLAC meetings in the coming year, whether virtual or in person? Thank you.

Speaker 29

Thank you for the question. You could scan the QR code there. It's the website of APLAC. You will find there non-verbals from delegations with the appointed members. You could also find there the excerpts from the reports, the mandate, terms of reference, methods of work, and you will also find the work plan on the website.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. And then I think, Lubna, you had a question.

Speaker 31

Yes, please. Thank you. Can you describe a bit how exactly ATLAC conducts its outreach to the private sector to get their insights?

UNOOSADirector

And then relatedly, are the members of ATLAC, does that include private sector for individual states or not?

Speaker 33

Thank you.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much, Lubna, for the question. And at the moment, since ATLAS is a member state-driven process, and in delegations, we have invited, we've left it up to the member states to nominate their experts. So it is up to member states, and we hope to facilitate the process, and we are actively engaging with member states on how to most effectively and efficiently proceed with ATLAS work as per its mandate in terms of preference. And we hope that we can have deliberations which include all relevant actors in this discussion moving forward. But like I highlighted before, since 2025 was more of setting the foundation right, So we believe that if the foundation is strong enough, then it's easier to build as we move forward. And also recognizing that the action team within the corpus architecture is the first step of a conversation starting to happen. We hope that we can already establish an environment where all relevant stakeholders from all member states can actively participate moving forward so we can have substantive recommendations which take the work forward. Thank you.

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Maybe I can add the last bit of the answer about the timelines, apologies for that. The timeline, so as my co-chair, Hassan Abbas, has been already mentioning, 2025 was really the planning stage. 2026, we aim getting really into substantive discussions in ATLAC. And by the end of the 2026, I know it's a little bit ambitious, We hope that we have some proto-recommendations, like very, very broad idea whether we would need an international mechanism for lunar activities. But really, our mandate is until 2028, and we hope to do it by 2027, because we are aware of the rapid speed that we are now experiencing, so we are doing our best to really address the existing situation. I hope that answers your question.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. I go to the far corner of the room and then to the front. Thank you.

NSS

Hello, Frederick Chenee from the National Space Society. First, if I may say, congratulations on creating ATLAC. I know that a lot of work went behind this with both of you, as well as people, other people that may even be in this room. It is a fantastic accomplishment. And we at the National Space Society are extremely excited to see such a global leadership coming together on something so important as humanity going to the moon. So with that, I would really love to hear from each of the co-chairs, if possible, what do you think the number one thing you would like to see that comes out of ATALAC, that you would say ATALAC was a huge success?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you for the question. I personally would like to see this I don't know, mechanism for international well-being really set up by the end of our discussions, like an international community on lunar activities or whatever, however we want to call it. But I think this would be the desirable outcome. Of course, that would be the wishful thinking. On the other hand side, we may end up with something different, and I wouldn't like to prejudge right now because we are still considering various options.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

And just to add that in all the discussions that we have, there is the underlying motive is also that to ensure that there is trust and transparency in all the new discussions as we break ground, but also that there's a shared understanding of what we're trying to achieve. And I think this is where a lot of work has gone in, and this is the efforts of all the delegations present in this room and and within COPUS who have worked to bring AGLAC together, identify its mandate and its scheme of work. So we hope that, as we also understand that time is of the essence that we are able to achieve whatever is set out within the mandate as it runs in its course. We are able to facilitate not only a dialogue, but have recommendations which facilitate the work forward and which also recognize, being cognizant that this entire domain is developing at a very quick pace, and we are also able to complement that with work that is happening within these platforms, so they are also able to grow organically. So that is also one person reflection, if I may add, that we're able to, it's a big challenge to have that the policy and the substantive discussions can match the technology as it goes up, but that is what we endeavoring, and that is where ATLAG is the first step towards establishing recommendations, towards further international mechanisms that we continue it like that. So I would really highlight that to have deliberations where we have trust and then also to recognize that the process matters. We are learning more now than ever about what to consult on, how to do it, which topics come up. The discussions are really rapidly evolving, and we hope to have all the discussions and our outcomes that facilitate these discussions as they happen.

Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you very much. We had a question at the front. Javier.

ESALunar Navigation Lead

Hello, very good morning. Javier Ventura from the European Space Agency, leading lunar navigation on the Moon.

Actually, I very, let's say, understood, related to the previous question, I see the purpose. I see the priority objectives, but my question is a little bit more formal. What are the formal deliveries that this committee is doing?

There is a formal delivery.

How are those formally also endorsed by COPUOS?

To understand a little bit the formal mechanisms and the final deliveries that come out, which has a value? And what is the value they have? These are the questions.

Thank you.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much. And also adding to my last point for the previous question that the process is important, and when we have ATAC, as the mandate also highlights very clearly, that there is that we have focused exchanges to develop recommendations which can include the possible formation of an international mechanism to take this conversation forward. So ATAC is the consultative mechanism as the first step. And you really rightly pointed out that whatever these recommendations or whatever the outcome of ACT-LAP would be, it will go into COPUS for its approval and for the recommendations to be approved. And then we have the following and subsequent actions to take as we have those deliverables coming. Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. We have a lot of hands up. I think the first one was over here, Ashu. And then we go there, and there, and there. Thank you. Remember your spots.

ChinaRepresentative; ATLAC member

Thank you, Ahti. Thank you very much. As members of ACLAC, I do have a question about the planning. As both co-chairs mentioned, this is still the planning year. So look forward to the next year that must be substantive deliberations. So my question to the co-chair is what you think we need support from UN OOSA and UN COPERS for the next year? Because there will be a lot of deliberations, what support or guidance we can get from the UN COPERS. We know next year we also will have the Lunar Conference, I hope, whether we can plan some meetings at that session or how to get the leverage of the UN OOSA, your convening power, to more engage developing countries. So that will be a boost to the next year's substantive discussions. My second question is about the information sharing, and the co-chairs also mentioned that it's very important. So look to the outcome, whether there is any ideas that we can have some pilot project on the information sharing, which all the members can consider to improve information sharing. So that is my question. Thank you.

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much for the question. I will start and then perhaps Hassan can complement. We are now continue to advance the work that have been starting last year. through this intersessional consultations. We already had two intersessional consultations, and we have another three lined up to the STSC. We have invited the members to present, to share information about their lunar activities and the challenges. So we are looking from a more substantive perspective to see what kind of challenges are there that we could address in this potential international mechanism for the future. So we are now in this phase of analyzing, structuring the information. Of course, we have this idea that there are technical challenges which will be then developed further once we get into the scientific and technical subcommittee. There are also legal challenges that we hope to address during the legal subcommittee. There are also geostrategic aspects which we aim to address, perhaps at the COPOS plenary. And once we have this very in-depth discussions within our group, then perhaps we will be able to build, to grow, first of all, all together, to understand why we need to address these topics and at the same time to learn how to trust one another and grow together.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much. And just to complement what Ulpeya was highlighting, that since we've had the agreement on the work plan and the initial list of priority topics in the recently concluded COPUS, since then, almost one inter-sessional per month has been ongoing. We've had two sessions so far, we're planning another three. And the idea has been that, as I emphasized before, that time is of the essence. that we are able to not only utilize the time leading up to the subcommittees and the committees, but we also are able to utilize as efficiently as possible the time where we don't have the meeting. So usually the second-half of the year, so after COPUS ended until New Year's until the next STSC. We also continue these deliberations, and we have an active way of consultations ongoing. With this, we have also started to highlight, encourage Member States to have the presentations. Perhaps they can share the information of ongoing or any planned activities, and that also helps to open the floor for Member States to recognize their own challenges, their own ideas, their own perspectives, which also facilitate the action team to identify possible issues going forward, possible challenges, and facilitate ATLAS work. And also to come to your second question regarding a pilot, possible pilot on information sharing. As ATLAC is a member state driven process, and within ATLAC we are working to develop recommendations, we are definitely open for member states if there is such a proposal for a recommendation that comes in, I think it would be very welcome. And it also aligns with ATLAC's work where we have more transparency. Any sort of regulation or any proposal where we can tie in and have information sharing that benefits everyone. Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. We had a question on this side, Clive.

UND

Yes, thank you very much. I'm Clive Neal from the University of Notre Dame and in the USA. Otherwise it'd be Notre Dame, I suppose. A very ambitious list that you gave at the beginning of this panel of what you want to achieve. And then you told me the timeline. So, question I have, definitive conclusions probably aren't going to be reached in many of these. So, how have you mapped in evolveability of your recommendations? And are you planning to have a list of next steps that would be needed in order to reach resolution in some of these?

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much. And I think it's good to be more ambitious when we start out from the gate. So, yeah, so we are definitely endeavoring that we can achieve as much as possible. And while I highlight and I recognize that this is definitely one of those challenges that comes in because ATLAC is aiming to develop recommendations. Again, as deliberations go, we And as a timeline goes, so as I highlighted, the first half was on the work plan and the initial list of priority topics. So that is exactly how it's termed. It's an initial list of priority topics. And now that when the intercessions are ongoing, we are encouraging and we actually having more member states who will deliver their presentation and share their ideas. So I think that would really accelerate the process of recognizing possible issues and challenges, and that also starts to cut through how we're planning to see things if there's certain recommendations that come organically. I think we just had a colleague who highlighted that we can have possible a pilot on information sharing. Again, it's a proposal that we invite member states to share. And once it is actually there for deliberation in the room, then we can organically and very quickly move forward and see how the discussion proceeds. But the initial framework, how I would see it, is that we actually set the stage where we can have more regular and more open conversations about all of these topics, even while recognizing that certain member states or certain all participants might not be on the same page on many of these issues, but it is allowing that platform that way we can have these discussions and hopefully come to a conclusion where we have something which are mutually acceptable for everyone. So these recommendations, I recognize that some ideas will be at a different, we might be in a very nascent stage of its development and some might be at a very advanced stage of development. And that is where we really bank on the expertise from the room to facilitate our work.

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you. If I can add, I really liked this idea of evolvability. May I take it for the future discussions? I would like to say that we were trying not to look at the final, the finalization of APLAC, but we were also trying to look at the process. So the process itself is very important because while we are in this process, we understand better and better, and we can find ways, challenges, and ways out. And so we would like to, not to prejudge, as I said, but keep it as an open process. And hopefully, if next year we're going to be here in the same room or maybe a different one for the same conference, we will be able to tell you, to answer you about the evolvability capacity of ATLAS and how we have changed or developed, where it went into more depth of our concept, initial concept.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. There was a question at the back here.

ChinaSpace Lawyer; Nominated Expert, ATLAC

Thank you. RT, good morning to all. Gu Yuwang from Academy of Aerospace Policy and Law, Beijing Institute of Technology. I'm also one of the nominated aspirants to ADLAC from China. So I do believe that it's super important, I mean, ADLAC, with regard to information sharing, from the promotion of information sharing, as Mr. Xu just mentioned, among stakeholders. And I also believe it will just pave the way for the possible consultation among the states on the Moon, no matter bilaterally or multilaterally. But as the chair just pointed out, it's also conducive to enhancing predictability, certainties, including legal ones. So from the lawyer's perspective, I concern about, you know, in this regard. what would be the expected synergy between ADLAC and the Space Resources Working Group. I believe the recognized principles from Space Resources Working Group will provide a guidance for a possible consultation among stakeholders. And also regarding other specific mechanisms, like coordinative zone, safety zone, heritage protection, what you see I mean, again, the relation between these two working mechanisms. And the second question, also, I think that also you mentioned there are possible commercial lunar activities there in future. Then what will be the consultation between commercial actors? Again, from lawyers' perspective, the consultation obligation is supposed to be taken among the member states. Then what do we do, I mean, at LAC? in this regard, how to build up the bridge to streamline mechanism among private sectors and governments? That's another question. Thank you.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much for the question. And just was to highlight because, as I was saying earlier, that we want to have, we have endeavored to have a very strong foundation, and that also comes with the recognition that we don't try to duplicate any existing legal or technical work. We are very cognizant of the work being done by the working groups within the subcommittees and the committee, and we really bank on their support and their expertise. So whenever there will be some, we have already been also been in touch with the chairs of those other working groups, and we hope that whenever there is a topic relevant for those working groups, we can bank on their expertise, we can have more discussions and have them guide the work as relevant to ATLAS in itself. So that is the first thing I would add.

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

I would also like to mention, maybe we are not in this very moment fully capable of offering a very detailed answer, but as we already discussed, we are planning to address some of these issues from a technical perspective, some others, as you have mentioned, in the legal subcommittee with the legal experts, and then after all this work, we will probably be able together, jointly, to come up to the proper or the right answer to this question. So may I invite you, as the previous speaker, to discuss this next year, maybe within the same format, we will be able perhaps to offer you a more detailed answer.

UNOOSADirector

You see, your calendars are already booked for this time next year. I think there was a question here, before we go over there, here and here. Thank you. Please.

UNDSSInnovation Projects Staff

Hi, I am Jayadassan Shobha. I'm working at the United Nations Department of Safety and Security, UN DSS headquarters in New York. Basically, we work on the innovation projects. So, you know, there's a guiding principle in UN DSS. It's like, where there is UN, there is UN-DSS. So since UNOSA is right now leading us towards the Moon, Mars, and other places, so my question to Arti is that how UN-DSS can also participate in those activities. And I have another question to Mr. Hasan. So it's like, in Bangladesh, we are working on a lunar satellite project. So it's for NASA's moon mission. So it's led by NASA's Core Aerospace Game Consortium. So my question to Mr. Hassan is that how students can also contribute to the lunar activities that's going on over the world?

Speaker 57

Yeah, thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you very much. So being relatively new to the UN, I've only been here two years, I'm not yet familiar with your part of the UN, but I'd be happy to take that conversation offline. Thanks. Sure. Hassan.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you, and likewise, I'm still very new to the overall UN system as well, but of course, i would be happy to join this conversation online as well. But just on the other point that you highlighted, I think with regards to your question on the engagement of students, if it's relevant to just as a general point, I think now we are at a stage where we have to encourage everyone, like at the very starting point as well in any way possible. And I think we have so many, so much development happening at such a quick pace, just to make that information more readily available for students to also realize that there is a path on to have these discussions forward. But again, we can have further discussions offline on this. Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. We had a question over here, please.

RUGGraduate

Hello, is it working? Yes. Hi, my name is Luciano. I am a graduate for the University of Groningen. And I wanted to ask about the topic of how are decisions being made. And the title is Action Team. And from my studies, one of the big topics is decisions are deemed based on a unanimous point of view by simple majority. Because there are interests at stake, and I'm really looking forward to, from the private sector or academia, how to support. This is the main topic regarding making decisions fast, especially if you're thinking big, which I think is great. And we are looking forward for your success, especially from other places. Thank you.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much for this very pertinent question. And I think just to highlight that we make all our decisions by consensus, so everyone has to be on board with this. So whenever we have all of the deliberations that we've been highlighting, all of the decisions that have been taken so far on the work plan, on the mandate terms of reference, of the work of ADLAC, how it's proceeding, these decisions to have intercessional meetings, to have presentations, to have, they're all as a member state driven process, but it all happens with consensus. So we are always at the hands of the room of the delegations to guide our work forward. Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. We had a question right at the front here somewhere. Bernard.

SRIPresident, Space Renaissance International; Vice-Chair, COSPAR Planet Exploration Panel

Hello, I'm Bernard Frank. So I'm the father of the first mission that went to the moon this millennium. It was launched by ESA 2003. And I've been working on project for payload, landers, and moon base. Now I left ESA. But continue to work on some pilot, and I'm president of Space Renaissance International, that is an observer at UN COPUOS, also vice chair of COSPAR, Planet Exploration Panel, and Berti Commission. Next year, 2026, the substance year for ATLAC. So how can we help as well? I saw that in addition to the 45 countries of UN COPUOS that are member of ATLAC, so there are still more to join. their input, written input that observer can bring on. But I was wondering how we could help also to get input from the community at large. In particular, we organize the largest astronomical congress in Antalya in October. We organize the largest space research congress, COSPAR, in Florence in August. We organize also here in Vienna, the European Geoscience Union planetary session, where we have always lunar session, and sometimes we get exchange with our UN colleagues. So how could we also together collect inputs from this community and particularly help eventually to develop some pilot projects that would support at large or even UN sustainable goals at large? how we could also develop some action that could be then enacted by the community at large, inspired by ATLAS.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you, Bernard. If I can just piggyback on Bernard's question a little bit. Indeed, we have multiple non-governmental organizations and not-for-profits who work on lunar activities. Some of them are arguably getting a head start on some of the work that needs to be done. Is there any scope to not reinvent the wheel and perhaps make use of some of the valuable work which is done in the NGO community?

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you very much for the question. I think this also highlights the relevance and the urgency of the work that we're conducting as the following year, and this is just my terminology to call it a substance year, so the planning, substance, and delivery. But just to reiterate both sides of the question, what Aarti expanded on your question, that we remain in active consultation with Member States, as ARCLAC is a Member State driven process. But while we recognize that there are useful contributions from all relevant stakeholders as well within Member States, within delegations, so we are actively engaged with Member States and we hope that we are able to utilize all existing channels that are available, and ARCLAC can also perhaps be a positive conduit for taking these discussions and we can utilize on all all possible expertise, so that will definitely work because a lot of work is already being done. And I also recognize that coming from Pakistan where certain expertise are available, but a lot is not, we are still learning on many fronts. So we also take benefit from the fact that there is expertise available from all quarters, which can facilitate not only one Member State, but also all Member States, and that feeds into the work of ACLAC. So we remain actively engaged and committed to this endeavour that we can we can have a possible channel, but it starts with the consultations from Member States, and that is what we continue to do.

SRIPresident, Space Renaissance International; Vice-Chair, COSPAR Planet Exploration Panel

So on pilot project, is there a potential for commercial companies or some of us to contribute, for instance, to some pilot project involving young generation, and that to support you in this?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

I'd also like to add to the fact that we would like to hear all voices, because lunar activities are really addressing us all in various forms of shapes or silos we are, right? So this is one reason why we have such meetings, to hear all the voices. To anticipate a little bit on our process, we were thinking, of course, we haven't taken a decision yet. This needs to be discussed within AGLAC. But we were thinking that maybe once we have this topics identified, challenges, then maybe we could involve somehow the experts, whether they are coming from the industry, whether they are coming from NGOs, academia, individuals, I don't know, experts real experts that could help Member States take decisions, inform decisions. So we are having that in mind. It's in our mandate. But right now, we haven't been addressing because we just started our substantive discussion. So we are in the process, as I said.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you. I think an interesting point has been raised, and we see also from organizing this event, how at IAC in Sydney, where many of you were present, when Yunus spoke about this event, companies asked, why would we ever go to a UN conference? So this notion of raising awareness of what is of this important work and how to engage is important. Here with this event, we're trying to open the doors a little bit, pull back the curtain, shine a spotlight on the work that's happening. But I think there's also a need to take it out of Vienna and have you speak at other events too. How do you react to that? Because, of course, there's a certain formality, there's a certain process, and you are entrusted by all of the member states in your roles as chairs. How would you respond to this need and the restraints that are?

RomaniaSpace Policy Officer; Chair, COPUOS STSC; Co-Chair, ATLAC

You know, two years ago, when I started my chairship of the Scientific and Technical Subcommittee, I had a statement. And in that statement, I had one sentence that was to, i pledged to promote the work of the subcommittee and the committee on the global arena. And this is what I have been doing over the past almost two years, or without two months, really everywhere I've been and in all sort of settings I've been, whether with the industry, with the academia, UN circles, member state circles, I have really attempted to present that the work we are doing here is really relevant and representative And we have to work together. That's the key thing. We have to sit down and discuss about these issues, and we have to work together. And of course, there is this difference in timing. There is this difference in approach. But at the end of the day, if we really sit down and talk, we should be able to find a consensual way forward that would be beneficial for everyone, I think.

PakistanDirector for Arms Control, Disarmament and International Security; Co-Chair, ATLAC

Thank you. And I think this is also, i think, one of the points which I think Clive was raising about the vulnerability, that as we have discussions, we also recognize the need to have substantive discourse, which continues to evolve really quickly as well. And I also take it as a point that while we are sitting at the United Nations, it offers an opportunity and also the ambition for all representations or delegations to be more represented. I understand as this domain is developing, there are so many avenues and so many relevant avenues, whether it's some are more technical, some are more substantive, or some are more policy oriented, some in all different ambits of it. But one of the real challenges that we do face, and I say this with this experience that I was the coordinator for the Group of 77 in China for two years in Vienna, that a lot of it comes down to that for developing countries, there is the possibility for representation remains limited. So the United Nations, when we have platforms such as this, it allows delegations to be more present, it allows delegations to put their case forward more strongly, and it also allows that with events such as this, which provides an opportunity for all other relevant stakeholders who we might not have the opportunity to meet in other avenues, that everyone is able to come over here. While this does not dispense the fact that Of course, discourse should be fluid, active, more evolving. It should continue all the time. As the co-chairs, and I think Olpiya will agree with me as well, that we are certainly committed to take this conversation and have this discussion because this is a very timely and important topic. And as we see, there's the interest in this room and also online, that we have so many colleagues who are joining us from a host of expertise within this domain. that we are able to also have this discussion as much as possible, but we also have to recognize the utility of the platforms we're in, and hopefully that with the support of everyone, we can certainly help Atla grow and recognize the ambition that it is setting out to achieve.

Thank you.

UNOOSADirector

Thank you very much. I think we don't have time for more questions, but this has been an informative session, I think, for me as well, but surely for everybody here. I'd like to highlight a few points. One is, it's an action team, therefore there is an expectation of action. You have set out some ambitious goals, and indeed, it's good to throw as much as we can against the wall and see what sticks. But I think one core outcome which is being hoped for is some kind of a mechanism that allows for consultation, coordination, because we know that if there's any kind of interference or if one mission lands on the other or something like this, it can so easily escalate and become a political issue. So the importance of the work of this action team cannot be emphasized emphasize more, it is really critical. And you've talked a lot about building confidence, ensuring transparency, predictability, all for the purpose of building trust. Here in the UN, we care very much about trust between the member states, because only if we have that trust do we know that we will have voluntary cooperation with whatever the recommendations and principles that are agreed on happen. But actually, it goes beyond. We are realizing that we're informing a broader community that doesn't have visibility over this work, about the work as well, and we also need their buy-in and their trust of the process, because ultimately, it affects the real actors of these missions. So thank you so much for having given us your perspectives and for sharing your ambitious goals with us. We stand with you, and we will convene again in a year's time, and hopefully you'll tell us more about the progress that you have made. Thank you so much for your questions. Everybody, please join me in thanking our panelists.

UNOOSAConference moderator

Thank you, Artie, Hassan, and Opiya for that excellent overview of AFLAC and its work. Now, recognizing that many of you have come to Vienna from points all over the world, some of whom are recovering from jet lag. We'd like to take a brief break. We have plenty more coffee and snacks over in the coffee corner, which is just to the left as you exit this boardroom. You go down the steps past the actual cafe, and there you'll see the items there. We encourage you to re-caffeinate, grab a bite to eat. Please be back here in 15 minutes so we can begin promptly at 11:30 for the next session on the legal aspects of space resource activities.

Speaker 74

Yes.

Hello.

Thanks. Thank you very much. What? Thank you. I mean, Thank you.

Yeah, that's right.

No, not from above. He gave it to me. Hello. But So, we need this confirmation in point 1 to sort through the documentation for us. Not only now, but over any length of time, regularly. Regularly. So, we can say that today we have a plan for the construction of the big wind turbine installation plant. As a local organization, which is large, we should contribute to this. Not at all. Of course.

We're all going to be dependent on the.

Weather.

Yes, there is. But actually, I will let you Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

Yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

Sì.

Okay, final ball.

Yeah. Thank you. Yes, Thank you. Yeah. So, Yeah, I've had people touch and touch her, shut down. Okay. This is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is, uh, this is,

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

So welcome back, everyone. I'd ask everyone please to take a seat so that we can continue with session two. I'll allow for another minute of seat taking, and then I think we get started. All right, welcome back. I hope you had a nice coffee break. And I hope that today's opening session was already very informative. I heard that there were a lot of interesting questions, and I'm excited that we'll continue those discussions with this session. So Before handing over to the panelists and opening the floor for discussions, I have a few opening words just to inform participants in the room a bit about the background of the working group that we will be delving into today and the history of the working group and where we stand today. So yes, without further ado, let's get started. Distinguished delegates, Colleagues, dear participants, it's truly a pleasure to join you at this conference as we take a collective look at the rapidly evolving commercial lunar landscape and the policy needs that accompany it. Across the two days, one theme I believe will connect all of the sessions, and it's the urgency for clarity, coordination, and predictability as lunar activities accelerate. And against this backdrop, it is a privilege to address you today in my capacity as Secretary of the Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities. We meet at a moment where activities related to the exploration, exploitation, and utilization of space resources are no longer abstract or distant. They're becoming part of concrete mission plans, investment decisions, and national policies, and even laws. This brings, of course, significant opportunities for science, for innovation, for economic development. But there's also a real risk for fragmentation, for uncertainty, and for diverging approaches if states don't work together. And that's exactly why the working group's mandate matters, the working group that we will delve into today. And why it matters that these discussions are taking place at COPUS, a forum where more than 100 states sit together and develop international space rules together. And it's the only setting And I know that we have a lot of industry participants in the room, so please do allow for a brief introduction to COPUS as well. But it's really the only setting capable of ensuring that the future legal landscape is inclusive, transparent, and grounded in international law. So in 2022, the Legal Subcommittee of COPUS established the working group with a clear mandate. The mandate is of course, based on a comprehensive work plan, but the overall mandate is to develop an initial set of recommended principles for space resource activities by 2027. And since then, the working group has advanced through a structured consensus-based process. So as you may know or may not know, COPUS works based on consensus, no votes. If there's disagreement in the room, this will be discussed until agreement can be found. And member states have submitted texts. They have commented on successive drafts that have been issued and engaged in heading by heading, principle by principle discussions. And this collective work has, in fact, resulted in a draft set of recommended principles. But I'd like to clarify one thing before we continue. All the content within that draft remains a draft at this point. So the preamble, the headings, the principles themselves, nothing has been formally agreed on. Everything remains open for refinement. But the draft does reflect a general understanding of what the main topics to be discussed by the working group should deal with. And the draft, if you look at it, and it is openly accessible to everyone on the working group's webpage, even the updated, updated draft. So whenever the working group meets at intersessional meetings, changes are made and track changes, and it is reflected on the working group's webpage. So if this is of interest to you, I would really recommend you take a look at that, at the draft as it stands today. It's divided into two parts. Part one reflects a general sense of direction where agreement appears to be emerging. So part one consists of the preamble and a set of headings and principles. And part two are possible additional provisions on issues where no common understanding currently exists yet. So I wanted to also give you a brief overview of the headings as they stand now. And this might look very confusing to you, but again, you should be able to see how the process works in reality. In reality, a draft set was issued, was drafted by the chair and vice chair of the working group, and you see that in the letters on the screen in white. additions made. And you can see that the key thematic areas are, for example, definitions. You need to have a definition of what a space resource activity is. What do these principles apply to at the end of the day? Information sharing, compliance with international law, freedom of exploration and non-appropriation, peaceful purposes, cooperation and due regard, international responsibility, Sustainability, scientific research, and safety, just to give you an overview. And those are really the headings. Under the headings, you will then find very clear, defined, and drafted principles. And the principles are what the working group is currently looking at. And we've already gone through, I believe it is principle one to three, if I'm not mistaken. We will continue now with principle four at the end of November at our intersessional meeting. So, to summarize, what has really been quite impressive is that the working group has maintained a truly constructive, cooperative, and highly engaged atmosphere. We have really been able to push through the work plan constructively, and of course, we hope that this will continue with the support of member states. And that is also why I'm so excited that we're here today with representatives of some of those member states present in the discussions. But before handing over and introducing you to the panelists, it is my sincere pleasure to introduce the working group's chair, Professor Steven Freeland, who sadly could not be with us here in person today, but he has provided a pre-recorded video for him also to elaborate a bit on where the working group will move forward and what the challenges, but also the immense positive outcomes are of the working group as of today. So without further ado, if we could have the video, thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities

Dear friends and colleagues, my name is Stephen Freeland, and it gives me great pleasure as Chair of the United Nations Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space Legal Subcommittee Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities, also on behalf of the Vice Chair, Dr. Ayman Ahmed of Egypt, to say a few words to you attending the conference on the commercial lunar landscape and policy needs, which have been organized by my friends at the United Nations Office for Outer Space Affairs, UNOOSA. As indicated by UNOOSA, your conference takes place in the context of the growing complexity of many proposed lunar missions and the need for inclusive dialogue amongst stakeholders to inform responsible, forward-looking governance. As humanity looks towards further proposed activities on the Moon and other celestial bodies, one potentially significant aspect of those proposed activities is what I refer to as space resource activities. In 2021, the Legal Subcommittee of COPULOS established a working group under its agenda item on the general exchange of views on potential legal models for the exploration, exploitation, and utilization of space resources. The working group, which I have the honor of chairing, is titled the Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities. The agreed mandate and five-year work plan of the working group includes a number of things. Gaining a greater understanding of current practices and potential technologies related to such future activities, in essence, to see and determine what is real and what predicted timelines might operate before such activities are undertaken in earnest. Further. to assess the current international legal framework for such proposed activities and to determine what gaps might exist, to develop non-binding initial recommended principles for such proposed activities so as to provide further clarity for stakeholders. And once all of that is done, to determine what is next. following the conclusion of the Working Group mandate in 2027. During our numerous Working Group meetings to date at sessions in Vienna, at the Legal Subcommittee and the Committee, as well as a number of online intersessional meetings, the discussions in our Working Group have been rich, substantive, and very positive. We've made good progress in a highly cooperative manner, which epitomizes what is known as the Vienna spirit. In April 2024, the Working Group held an international conference on space resources during the 63rd session of the Legal Subcommittee in Vienna. That followed an expert meeting held in Luxembourg the previous month, collecting preliminary inputs for consideration at that conference, which was co-hosted by Belgium and Luxembourg and organized in cooperation with the United Nations. Both events involved significant inputs from industry and commercial organizations. from academia, from research institutes, from non-governmental organizations, amongst others. These two events provided important contributions to the ongoing work of the working group, addressing the multifaceted nature of the exploration, exploitation, and utilization of space resources, and assessing the benefits of the further development of a framework for such activities. In March 2025, I presented to the working group a draft set of initial recommended principles for space resource activity, taking into account the need to ensure that such activities are carried out in accordance with international law and in a safe, sustainable, rational, and peaceful manner. These draft principles are currently under negotiation by the working group in an open, transparent, and inclusive manner. The initial draft has updated versions reflecting amendments proposed by member states at our meetings. and these are included after each meeting and can be found also on the dedicated webpage of the Working Group. Whilst there is, of course, much work to be done, the Vice-Chair and I remain optimistic that such progress will continue over the coming months and years. Naturally, we continue to welcome inputs from Member States that also reflect the views of their respective industry, commercial, scientific, and civil society communities. In that way, we aim for the agreed initial recommended principles to be as relevant, useful, clear, and timely as possible, even in a paradigm where the technology and commercial circumstances change rapidly. I therefore would encourage all of you attending the conference to continue to consult and engage with your respective governments so that the most up-to-date information is included in our working group discussions. In addition, the Vice-Chair and myself are in close liaison with the co-chairs of the Action Team on Lunar Activities Consultation, known as the ATLAC. which was established by COPUS in 2025 to foster consultation between stakeholders wishing to engage in future lunar activities. In this way, the governance frameworks with which our working group is concerned and is currently addressing are being developed in lockstep with the practical consultative arrangements that are also being discussed. so as to enable more effective operation and avoid undue overlap. Of course, we all recognize that these are complex issues, and it will be ultimately up to the Member States to decide the precise scope of the frameworks so as to best promote safe, sustainable, and peaceful lunar activities. I'm sure that these are things that will be discussed during your two days at the conference, and I wish you well with those discussions and hope that they are productive and fruitful. Thank you again for giving me the opportunity to update you on the activities of our working group. I'm sorry I cannot be there in person at your conference, but I wish you well, and I look forward to meeting you in person at a future event. With that, i say goodbye. All the best. Bye-bye.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Thank you so much. I'll extend our gratitude to the chair at our intercessional meeting that we will have, in fact, next week already. But now I'm really excited to introduce the panelists that are here with me today. And in fact, we have three distinguished experts when it comes to this topic. David Reinecke, who is a foreign affairs officer at the US State Department, working on to me, who's the head of the legal department at the Brazilian Space Agency. He, in fact, also chairs one of COPUS's working groups, specifically on definition and delimitation of outer space under the legal subcommittee. And we have Matthias Link, who's the deputy CEO of the Luxembourg Space Agency, and he played a central role in developing the Space Resources Luxembourg Initiative. Now, I sent an e-mail to all of the panelists yesterday evening with the opening question I want to start with. So if you have not read that e-mail, I do apologize, but I just arrived back from mission. So if I may begin with an opening question to you, and I have some other prepared questions as well, but I really then want to allow for questions from you, the audience and participants. But from your national and institutional perspective, what would you say is the single most important contribution that the multilateral process at COPUS can make to support safe, sustainable, and predictable space resource activities? And David, maybe we can start with you.

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

Thank you, Rosanna, and good morning, distinguished delegates and everyone joining us here today. I was able to join last year for last year's conference, and it sounds like we're already off to a great start this year with the third version to come next year. In short, to answer your question, I think consensus from the member states is the most important aspect of of what COPIUS can bring to safe, sustainable lunar exploration and space exploration more generally. This is a very unique forum that has all the relevant moon-faring nations, emerging space nations, countries that are maybe anticipating to explore the moon in the coming age. And that shared understanding that's built up through what can sometimes be a slow process, but I think the correct process, is really the distinct benefit that we have in groups like the Space Resources Working Group, conferences like these, the COPUS process more generally.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Great, thank you. Matthias.

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

Yeah, thank you very much, Rosanna. First of all, I would like to thank UNRWA for convening this conference. It's extremely important to bring together the commercial sector with the diplomats and the lawyers here in Vienna, so that both worlds meet each other and can exchange. I think that's really a huge benefit. And so thank you very much for organizing it and for inviting me on that panel. Thank you. For the Space Resource Working Group, I can only agree with what was said. The main benefit is that it exists. That would be the short answer. There have been discussions in COPUOS since, i think, now more or less 10 years on the space resource topic. And initially, these discussions were extremely controversial, with very strong positions taken on the different sides of this room. And this has calmed down by bringing a better understanding of the topic, of the opportunities that are linked to this topic. And this creation of the working group is sort of currently is the culmination of this positive way that the committee took with this topic. So indeed, having such a working group at the level of the United Nations is already a huge benefit. And as was said, we're all looking forward, of course, to what comes next in this working group.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Yeah, thank you so much, Matthias. And I have to agree. I think the general approach that member states are taking in regards to this topic has changed tremendously from 10 years ago to where we are today. So yes, thank you for mentioning that. Ian.

BrazilHead of Legal Department, Brazilian Space Agency; Chair, Working Group on Definition and Delimitation of Outer Space

Hi, good morning, everyone. So first of all, thank you for invite me to discuss this in this panel. It's a pleasure. on behalf of the Brazilian Space Agency, and I hope on behalf of the Brazilian delegations here, to talk about what this working group is doing and what our perspective on it. From Brazil perspective, the single most important contribution that the multilateral process in COPUS can make is to deliver balance, inclusive, and internationally accepted set of recommended principles that provide legal clarity while preserving sustainability and equitable access to space. COPUS is a uniquely positioned to do this because it's the only forum where all states, spacefaring and emerging, developed and developing, can negotiate norms on equal footing. For Brazil, this is essential. National legislation such as our Brazilian Space Law Act can provide internal guidance, but long-term safety, sustainability, and predictability can only be guaranteed through multilateral consensus. Such consensus-based principles clarify how space resource activities can be conducted in harmony with the Outer Space Treaty, ensure that environmental protection and long-term sustainability are embedded from the start, and promote equitable participation so that developed countries are not left behind on this new phase of lunar activity. In short, COPUOS' greatest contribution Is it ability to proceed, share, legitimate, and globally trust principles that anchor national regulations, support responsible commercial development, and preserve the moon as a space for peaceful, sustainable, and cooperative use by all humankind?

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Thank you so much, Ian. So now we heard from all of you why the working group at COPUS, why is it important today? But I believe it's also important to hear, why should industry care about this? We have a lot of industry in the room, which I'm really excited about, because at the end, we also want to hear a bit from you, in fact. But maybe David first, why should industry care about what the Space Resources Working Group is doing?

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

Excellent question. I think from our perspective, if I put on the US hat a little bit, Things like the draft principles, the work of the Space Resources Working Group, can help create an enabling framework for future activities, future exploration, ensure the kinds of key values that Ian, that you were talking about, things like long-term sustainability, safety, transparency, and create additional policy predictability. And I think that the good thing is that there's a long list of similar efforts in the past that demonstrate that this process can work, and that, more importantly, can be useful to commercial actors the long-term sustainability guidelines, the orbital debris guidelines, the remote sensing principles back in the 1980s. So this is a well-established process, a thing that member state driven, and then can feed into the work that not only civil space agencies are doing, but commercial actors as well, ensuring those values, ensuring that kind of predictability, reinforcing the things that many of us have already said today.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

All right, thank you, David. And maybe just also hearing from a very clear national example, Matthias, Luxembourg adopted its national space legislation in 2017, specifically also in regards to regulating space resource activities. Why this approach? Was industry involved in this process? Again, they're here with us in the room today. What would you want to share with them regarding your experience with Luxembourg's experience in this?

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

Yeah, thank you. So I'll try to take a step back maybe and give you indeed our perspective on this. Luxembourg has a space policy overall that is very much commercially oriented. So what is happening here in the room, we have that actually every day. We work very closely with our industry because we believe in the commercial space sector. We've seen evolution of this sector in, of course, areas like satellite communication and Earth observation. But now we definitely see also since a few years this evolution in exploration going towards a cislunar economy. And when we launched our initiative dedicated to space resources in 2016, this topic was still a complete niche topic. Of course, many experts knew about it, but it was not openly discussed, not really here at COPUOS and also not really at certain space agencies, definitely not in Europe. We thought, we believed in this opportunity together, of course, with companies to say, okay, it's going in this direction, this will come. It's pretty clear when we want to open space towards a space economy, we will at a certain stage have to use the resources just for sustainability reasons. And of course, we looked at the different challenges that would need to be tackled. And the legal and regulatory challenge is one of the challenges. It's a very important one, but it's also always good to keep in mind that it's not the only challenge. Sometimes in settings like this, talking to the legal and regulatory aspects are stressed, but it's really important to keep in mind that there are other challenges. The technical challenges are huge. We have in Luxembourg the European Space Resource Innovation Center. We'll also hear from technical experts tomorrow. We're still far from having industrial scale space resource utilization in space. So these topics still need to be tackled and it will take some time. If we talk about commercial companies, we talk about the space economy, of course, we have to look at the business models. Again, we are still quite far from having commercial markets linked to exploration. We can all see them coming, and they will come, but there are also challenges related to business models and to investing in these different markets and in these companies. So I mention this because it's really important to have this in mind also when developing the legal and regulatory framework. And this is again why I really applaud having this kind of exchanges here at the Corpus in Vienna. with the commercial sector. So what we did in Luxembourg is we looked at all these different challenges, and specifically on the legal and regulatory challenge, it was very clear at that stage that there was no shared understanding of what the Outer Space Treaty allows and does not allow. And this is also why there were this quite animated discussion in this room at the start. And so we said, okay, what could we do at our level to progress? And you mentioned the law that we had in 2017. So we were at that stage the second country in the world to have a law after the US, specific law on space resources. And we've always said that this would just be a first step, trying to clarify the situation on a national level. And of course, many other countries have done it today. But of course, it's not enough. There are aspects in the legal and regulatory part that you cannot tackle on a purely national level. So we've been pushing together with many other countries also to address this topic in COPUS, and we've seen today the results. So I'm very pleased to see this working group. And I must say, also following many other topics in COPUS, this working group is progressing extremely well. I think it's remarkable for such a topic, which is rather long term. I mean, this is still, we still have a lot of years to come before we see this full scale, let's say, industrialization. It's really remarkable that we are now progressing so fast. And it's interesting to see that there's such a constructive spirit in the working group under the leadership of Professor Freeland and trying to put the main aspects on paper and find solutions altogether. And maybe a last point, of course, it's very important to progress here, but I also have to mention other efforts that are done outside the UN framework. I participated personally in the Hague Space Resource Governance Working Group, which was, of course, not a very formal process, but which really allowed also to clarify many things. by having both industry, academia, NGOs, and government space agencies sitting around the same table and working on a first set of building blocks that certainly can also feed into the discussions at UN. And then, of course, there are other efforts, like David will certainly mention the Artemis Accords or other NGO related efforts that certainly bring in additional information to the more formal process here at COPUS. So overall, I want to conclude here with a very positive message that it's really good that this working group exists, and it's definitely progressing very fast given the usual timelines of the UN processes.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Thank you, Matthias. And I would have to agree. So in fact, we also have the vice chair of the working group, Ayman Ahmed, here in the room with us. And I have to say, both with Professor Steven Freeland, of course, and with Ayman Ahmed, very impressed by how well this working group is progressing. And again, a lot of you sitting in the room today might often hear how slow the UN works and why is this being discussed at the UN? Let's do it outside the UN, it will go a lot faster. But the working group was established in 2022, and we are progressing faster, in fact, than what the work plan had anticipated. So things are able to progress rather swiftly, even at UN level. And then remember, these decisions are taken by consensus. So everyone, if you're now representatives of member state, need to agree with what is being presented at the end of the day. And that has a long, very strong legal effect as well. But Ian, I'd like to hear from you and specifically also, you know, looking into what Brazil is doing with your national space law. also referencing space resource activities, if I'm not mistaken, and why you see that important in regards to sustainable space activities. Often when we talk about sustainable space activities, we might not necessarily consider having principles in place for space resource activities as being a baseline for it. But how do you see this?

BrazilHead of Legal Department, Brazilian Space Agency; Chair, Working Group on Definition and Delimitation of Outer Space

Thank you for the question. So, of course, we in Brazil, we saw this growing of the private commercial sector and space. So in that regard, Brazil presented, adopted last year its National Space Law Act, the law number 14946. And with this legislation, Brazil became the fifth country in the world to formally recognize the possibility of space resource exploration within its national legal framework. Of course, however, the Brazilian approach is careful and balanced. The new law clear states that any national regulation of space resources must be developed in full conformity with international law and aligned with the principles established under the United Nations Committee on Peaceful Use of Outer Space COPUS. In this context, sustainability is at the very heart of any future framework for space resource exploration. And our law, this space that I mentioned, the Brazilian Space Law Act, recognize that activities in outer space must be conducted in harmony with international law and full respect for environmental and ethical consideration. Brazil broader development strategy already emphasized that responsible use of natural resource on earth, and the same principle extends naturally to outer space. The idea is this progress in space must not come at dispense of environment integrity, whether in Earth's orbit, on the moon, or beyond. Moreover, sustainability has a strategic dimension for Brazil. It ensures that space activities contribute to long-term social and economic development rather than short-term commercial gains. By aligning sustainability with innovation, Brazil seeks to promote inclusive growth, technology transfer, and international cooperation. So basically, we have this chapter in our law. and for giving license and authorizations and this kind of stuff, the space operator has to prove that the entire operation will be followed, for example, the launch stability guideline from UN. So it's we trying to put in our national legislation, but enforce something that we know as non-binding legal instruments from UN. So This is the approach that Brazil try to put in practice right now. Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Perfect. Thank you so much. And that's, of course, after these two days, we'll have the Space Law Conference, and that will be delving into operationalizing space sustainability. And I think you made a really important point there. How can you do that? Also in regards to space resource activities, of course. But now I'd really like to hear from the room, from the participants. You might have some points you'd like to make, you might have some questions, and I already see, wow, seven, eight, nine. Okay, we take one after the other. I think we start with China, if I may, and then we'll continue through here.

ChinaRepresentative; ATLAC member

Thank you, Chair. Thank you for this opportunity. As the Chair of this working group mentioned that The initial draft is still under negotiation, so what I said at this stage will not prejudge our position toward that draft. I do have a question about the future operation of these outcome documents. As we all know, the main essence of this preliminary pre-symposium is based on the OST, the Outer Space Treaty. So, my question is, is there any concerns about the equal and harmonized implementation of those presumptions which have been traced back to the OST, in particular? There is benefit sharing, which is very important principle under the OST, which is not included at this stage in the part one of this principle. But that is very relevant. It's very important principle. So we have to incorporate into the future framework of space resources activities. So that is also come back to the question, the chair you raised, to what extent commercial industry should be interested in this ongoing work. There is principle 9, that is international responsibility. I think the essence is to operationalize the supervision and authorization of commercial space activities in the lunar resources. So we need similar rules to operationalize benefit sharing, then the commercial industry will know the certainty, the predictability, they have to make contribution in the benefit of all nations. So that is my question. Whether you look to the future, they need some mechanism to ensure all the principles will be implemented in an equal and mutually reinforced way rather than in a conflict. way, we do worry that some presumptions are highlighted and others were set aside. So that is a question to the panelists, whether they want to build a framework into the documents to make sure all the presumptions will be followed in a good faith. Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Thank you so much for that question. And may I hand this over to one of the panelists? Would you feel ready to answer this?

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

I'll just say very quickly, in terms of implementation, we're still in the process of figuring out the draft principles. We're still in the process of trying to learn from the activities that we are doing on the national level, looking to other countries for their experience as well. So I think before we jump to the question of implementation, we have to figure out the framework first, which we're still very much in the process of. But implementation of these principles, I think, down the line will be important, right? If we are going to agree to these on a consensus level, making sure that we put them into practice, that's why we're doing that, right? That's why we're here having these kinds of conversations.

BrazilHead of Legal Department, Brazilian Space Agency; Chair, Working Group on Definition and Delimitation of Outer Space

Yes, and I would like to add something. regarding our position, Brazil and for space developing countries. So, of course, it's still, as Rosana said in the beginning, a draft, but of course, Brazil and many other states, G77 and Egypt, is leading this process here and COPUS with Brazil, with Mexico and other countries. And of course, this is a really important topic for us, benefit sharing, you know, in this commercial process. And of course, but how to do it and how to put this in practice is something that we are still discussing. But of course, Brazil is really interested in this topic, and we are trying to put our efforts to solve or to just to present some proposition to the group. Thank you.

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

Yeah, thank you for the question. For us, it's of course also extremely important that down the line we see an implementation of this. This is what companies want to see, and we definitely need to come to that stage. Right now, it's indeed already an achievement to work on these common principles. And if we can agree on them, the next step would then be an implementation. Part of the implementation is done through national laws. I mean, many countries have national space laws, and some of them also space laws dedicated to space resources, or at least part of the laws have space resource included. So in our opinion, these laws should, of course, also play a role in implementing these principles at a certain stage. The other point that I wanted to make is that it's about benefit sharing. Indeed, it's not included in the principles right now. From our perspective, it should be included at a certain stage as well. And I can speak of my experience with the Hague Working Group. I remember that this was a particularly intense point, of course, with many discussions. having both countries around the table and companies. And of course, you cannot ask companies and investors to go for this and develop business models in this domain if you have not a clear rule on benefit sharing. Somehow this needs to be tackled. But the good news is that there are solutions. We came up after long discussions with solutions. I think some of them could also find their way into the UN process, because, of course, you need solutions where you still encourage companies and other operators to work on their plans and to come up with innovation. And for them, they need to feel good about what comes out of what happens to their benefits in the end. So we need to balance all these different views, and I'm pretty sure we can do that here in this working group.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Yes, thank you so much. And of course, part one, as it stands now, and as both the chair and I mentioned, is at a drafting stage, as you know. And we will get to a point, hopefully, under the leadership of member states, that we will be discussing some of the headings in part two as well, which include those aspects. And hopefully, that constructive approach that we've had until now will continue, and this will be added as well. OK. Before, I saw a lot of raised hands. So if we start with you, sir. Yes, in the front. Yes. And then we'll continue.

Speaker 96

Yes, please.

United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern IrelandRepresentative, Innovate UK

So first off, I'd like to congratulate you for making more progress than you had thought you would make at this stage. I have written a number of international standards, so I know exactly how long it can take. So Chris Jones from Innovate UK, I represent a large number or significant number of UK businesses that are looking to actively get involved with the commercialization of space and particularly the moon. Given how long we know these things take, I actually want to challenge the panel and say, in your professional opinion, When are we going to see the first commercial license granted for a company to exploit the resources that are available?

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

I think both the US and Luxembourg will probably have something to say on this, so I hand over to you.

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

I mean, first off, we're already licensing companies to do exploration on behalf of civil space agencies, private missions. So in some ways, depending on where you set the lines, we're already here. In terms of a purely commercial mission doing space resource activities, I wouldn't be surprised by the end of the decade or earlier. Would it have NASA relations or not? It's another question. But I think it's not science fiction, at least from the US perspective.

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

I fully agree. It depends what you mean exactly with your question, who would give this license, but I can speak for Luxembourg. So we used our space resource law last year for the first time. We authorized a mission by iSpace to go to the Moon to collect regolith and to sell this regolith to NASA. And there was a commercial contract between this company and NASA to actually sell this regolith. For me, this looks like very much looks like already like a very concrete case of space resource utilization. Of course, it's on a small scale, but it allowed to test at least the system as we currently have it. So in a certain sense, this was a license given by the Luxembourg government in line with our national law and with the Outer Space Treaty. But of course, it's a small scale and these things will keep increasing in complexity. And again, I think we need to continue working on these principles and at a certain stage also, certainly on a larger scale implementation of certain mechanisms.

BrazilHead of Legal Department, Brazilian Space Agency; Chair, Working Group on Definition and Delimitation of Outer Space

So for Brazilian perspective, our law is really new. So this part of the law still need decrees, presidential decrees or a regulation to regulate this part. So it's something, it's in our radar, but it's not our priority right now in Brazil. But in the future, Brazilian space agents will give this kind of authorization when we'll have specific regulation on this part of the law.

Speaker 102

All right.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

If we could continue. Yes. Please go ahead, sir.

International Lawyer

Hello.

Thank you for your time.

My name is Puia.

I'm a Canadian international lawyer.

I recently finished my LLM on the commercialization of space.

My question is a bit two-part, and it has to do with one of the headings, in fact, and the principle of non-appropriation.

The first question is.

Has the committee decided whether that includes private non-appropriation, or is it restricted to public non-appropriation? And I note that because the OSD and the Moon Treaty, in fact, differ on the language there. The second question is, even if private appropriation is also included under non-appropriation, how does the commercial framework function without the privatization or ownership over these resources.

Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Thank you so much. Matthias, maybe if I may hand over to you for this, because you delved into this a lot, I believe, when you were starting the drafting of your law and seeing how that is in conformity with Article 2. So maybe you thought of this as well?

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

I can give you an answer, but I'm not a lawyer, so I definitely will not go into details. For us, of course, and I guess for many others, we can only speak of commercial space resource utilization if you're able to own these resources, otherwise it doesn't make sense. So this is in our national law, this is actually the first point of our law, is that we are of the opinion that space resources can be owned. And of course, this does not mean that you appropriate a part of a celestial body. But I know, I can see your question, I see your point. The devil is in the detail, and I think we will at a certain stage need to discuss scenarios on how to bring these two together. Because obviously, if you go and mine an asteroid and use the resource of the asteroid, and in the end, the asteroid does not exist anymore. Well, you could maybe say that you have appropriated this asteroid. So there will be cases that need to be addressed in detail and see where does appropriation or where could appropriation start. But for, let's say, for the moon, which is the current focus of most of the companies and operators, of course, taking the resource and utilizing it, selling it, owning it, this should definitely not be an appropriation. And I'm not, no, I cannot say, the part on the question if this is public or private appropriation, I think that's more something for the lawyers on the panel.

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

I was gonna say that it feels almost like a third year law school final question a little bit, so. Probably have to write a law review article to get to the base of it. But Matthias, I agree almost 100% with what you were saying. If you look back to our own 2015 domestic law in the United States, it settles this question that says, yes, companies can own resources, and that does not inherently constitute national appropriation. And that has been the basic framework upon which the coming to lunar economy has been based around the idea of commercial space resource utilization.

BrazilHead of Legal Department, Brazilian Space Agency; Chair, Working Group on Definition and Delimitation of Outer Space

Finally, I think in Brazil, we wait for this international consensus how to do it and how to promote it and how to inherit in our national legislation. But honestly, we will wait for a final consensus in the international working group and, of course, COPUS. Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

All right, thank you so much. I was told that we have seven more minutes. So, you know, I think we're going to have to go through. So, sir, I think you, yes, please go ahead.

Speaker 110

Thank you so much for organizing this amazing event, first of all. I'm Girinath Arunan from Cosmopolis Space, United Kingdom. So I have two questions. One question to Mr. David from US State Department. From a policy perspective, how does US intend to balance the promotion of private sector competitiveness in space resources, ensuring the benefits of the space activities shared by all the member nations? And another question to Mr. Mathias. Considering Luxembourg as a national legalization permitting the space resource utilization, how does CLSA view the ongoing slow-paced policy makings topic within the UN COPUS? And which one is seen the most critical for legal certainty? So thank you.

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

Thank you. In recognizing time, I think we could ruminate on the benefits question for a much longer period. But I'll just say very quickly in terms of benefits for all, the way that we've thought about it. really goes back to our key obligations in the Outer Space Treaty and recognizing that there's many ways to define benefits, including things like open science, transparency around policies and plans, sharing the expertise that we have gained through things like space resources activities, and sharing it in forms like this, UN COPUOS, international conferences, and others. So there's many ways to share the benefits of, you know, not only the vibrant commercial sector, the things civil space agencies are doing, the wide area of expertise that we have from universities and NGOs in the United States, and sharing those benefits broadly through the things that we've learned over time.

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

Yeah, if I get your question right, it's about legal certainty for companies and with respect to the slow process at the UN. So again, I think the process here is quite fast for the UN, and so that's very positive. And of course, not every single issue is clarified. There's still a lot of work to be done. But for companies, and we see it in our own country, you need a solution that works right now for what you want to do right now. And for most companies, the current legal framework, at least the one that we have now in Luxembourg and in many other countries, is sufficient. Because in terms of technical maturity, anyhow, you wouldn't go much further than doing a small demonstration. And this is perfectly fine with the current framework that we have. And I mentioned the authorization that we gave to one of our commercial companies. For that part of the mission, for their plans, this is enough. And I think for many commercial companies, seeing that there is progression also here at the UN is already a huge step towards more legal clarity and being confident that they can prepare business plans and strategies going into the utilization of space resources in the longer term.

Speaker 113

Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Thank you so much. So I saw a question over here, and then I'd like to end with briefly China as well. So over here to the left, please go ahead. And we have to keep it really short.

CanadaMajor; Legal Advisor, Canadian Armed Forces in Europe; PhD Candidate

Yeah, thank you very much. I am Major Andrea Carranza, legal advisor for the Canadian Armed Forces in Europe. and also PhD candidate at the McGill Institute of Earth and Space Law. My question is regarding actually activities involving humans on the moon, because we're talking about resources, but then the question is, there will be potentially tourism, potentially military, and also astronauts, so a different kind of people, different kind of status, and certain protections to give them. So my question is, from that point of view, Has there been any conversations about what it means to have humans on the moon with different statuses and how can we protect them? And it's because my research is about human rights of those who will be present on the moon. Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

So I'm not sure who from the panel would like to answer. I would say generally within this working group, it's about space resource activities, I believe that ATLAQ, if would be more suited to discuss these types of issues, as it's really about coordinating activities on the lunar surface and beyond. And additionally, I would, however, say that we have a space law conference starting on Wednesday, and we'll have a panel on the Rescue and Return Agreement, which will also be discussing these issues. And I believe, yes, this is a topic to be discussed. But not sure whether it's this working group specifically that's discussing these issues in detail. Sorry for not giving a more precise answer on that. And then I think, Guyu, you wanted to And then we'll have to wrap it up. So I would have to ask you to keep it short.

ChinaSpace Lawyer; Nominated Expert, ATLAC

Thank you, Rosanna. It's not a double request from my delegation. It's just on my own capacity as a space lawyer. So I believe that the most fundamental legal question here is about the determination of the, we say, legal characteristics of the RAT over prospective or abstracted resources. So we already have different options, like the property right indicated in the United States law, ownership from Luxembourg. And for me as a lawyer, we talk a lot about balance as well, right? So these are exclusive rights. nor a common property concept could be well accepted in this room. So that's why, personally, I propose the priority right in the Hague Working Group. So my question to you guys, so what do you see the necessity and feasibility to discuss this matter in the working group? So if it's still too early to discuss such kind of complicated legal question, then where and how we can address because it's super important not only to commercial actors, but those two governments to developing countries? Thank you.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

Would somebody like to take the floor to answer this as a final wrap up, maybe? Go ahead, Matthias.

LuxembourgDeputy CEO, Luxembourg Space Agency

Well, I can agree with you. Thank you very much for your question. I think for me, the easy answer is to we are, you see where we are here in this working group. This is the level of detail that is being discussed. It's still quite high level, and if you want to go into more details in certain or certain issues, and I more than agree that this is needed, there are other fora to do so, and these fora should also continue to do their work. I think, again, I'm not a lawyer, but in the IISL, for example, this topic continues to be discussed. I suppose that there will be also other fora where this will happen, and at a certain stage, these things can then also find their way to this committee. And the Hayek Working Group is also a good example. We keep pushing for taking into account these kind of discussions also in the working group. Not everything needs to be tackled here, I suppose.

United States of AmericaForeign Affairs Officer, State Department

I was going to agree entirely. I think civil society, some of the informal forms that you were talking about, Matthias, could be an appropriate place for that. I was just trying to kind of go through my head, do we even have a mature opinion about what you're raising? And I'm not sure that, as a consolidated US opinion, we're even there yet to have that kind of discussion. But that doesn't mean that it shouldn't be happening somewhere, and that taking that expertise and that learning could figure in one day into that, I think, is quite important. And we have lots of examples of exactly that happening. You know, expertise coming from a lot of different places, informing the national opinions, working their way up through the member state process, and then ending up in draft principles like the one that we're seeing here on the screen.

UNOOSASecretary, Working Group on Legal Aspects of Space Resource Activities; Moderator

All right, thank you so much. I wish we would have had more time. I believe there were more questions to be answered. I think it shows that it's good that we are organizing this type of event. Very happy to see the room so engaged in these discussions, and a huge thank you to our panelists for joining us. It was truly an honor to moderate for you and with you. So without further ado, I think this concludes session two. I hope that you have a better understanding of what the working group is doing and what the UN as a whole can do to promote these types of discussions and provide a forum for these types of discussions. And I'm happy to hand over back to my colleague. So thank you so much.

UNOOSAConference moderator

Thank you, Rozana, and for the members of the working group on the legal aspects of space resource activities. I'd like to now call up our guests to speak on the working group on the uses of nuclear power sources in outer space. So, Romana? There were more questions than we had time for, but we hope that you'll find some time during the lunch break and perhaps at the reception this evening to continue the conversation.

UNOOSAModerator

Right, so are we ready? Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen. It is my pleasure to welcome you to session three, which will be all about the working group on the use of nuclear power sources in outer space. Now, in comparison with other two mechanisms and the working group, this working group actually has quite a long tradition. It spans over several decades. It's been established in 1978. Well, I am privileged to be accompanied by the chair of the working group, Mr. Leopold Sommerer, and Dandara da Silva from the International Atomic Energy Agency. As you know, or some of you may be informed, the working group works closely with the International Atomic Energy Agency on this pertinent matter. I will briefly introduce our speakers, and then I will go to a short overview of the principles and the safety framework that is being developed by the working group. And then we will have also, then data will present on micro reactors, and then we will have some time for questions. So, the chair, Mr. Sommerer, has started chairing this working group in 2023. He succeeds in this role Mr. Sam Harbison of the United Kingdom, who has for years chaired this working group and to whom the committee has expressed sincere appreciation for advancing this matter. Mr. Sammerer has trained as a theoretical physicist, completed master studies in nuclear physics and in space studies, and holds a PhD on radiation matter interaction. He directed and managed research projects on advanced space systems and technology at the European Space Agency, and since March 2025 is the head of technology department at ESA. Dandara da Silva is one of the team members of the IAEA in the working group on the use of nuclear power sources. She is an associate nuclear engineer at the agency, where she supports international efforts to develop micro reactor technologies, including their potential applications in outer space. Before joining the IAEA, Dandara spent over six years at Framatome, a French nuclear engineering company that designs, builds, and services nuclear power plants and fuel. At Framatome, Silva contributed to the deployment of system engineering in the development of new generation nuclear reactors, such as the European Pressurized Reactor, EPR, EPR2, and EPR1200. And at the IAEA, her work spans three key areas: tracking global microreactor developments, analyzing how space environments impact reactor design, and supporting innovation in reactivity control systems for small module reactors. So before giving the floor to my distinguished speakers, let me give you a brief overview of the decades of the work of this working group. Can we have? Oh yeah, I had that slide. Right. Thank you. So the working group, as I mentioned, was established in 1978 by the scientific and technical subcommittee of the main committee on the peaceful uses of outer space. Its establishment came at a critical time. Earlier that year, there was a spacecraft, Cosmos 954, that crashed and scattered radioactive debris over northern territories of Canada. That incident highlighted just how important it was for countries to work together on the safe use of nuclear power sources in space. During the 1980s, the working group had detailed technical discussions and eventually developed a set of guiding principles. They were endorsed by the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space in 1992, and later adopted by the General Assembly under title dedicated resolution principles relevant to the use of nuclear power sources in outer space. In 2000, the subcommittee brought the working group back under a four-year work plan, and then the goal was to develop a more technical, clear safety framework for nuclear power sources. So the working group at that time examined terrestrial practices and considered how they could be adapted to the unique challenges of space missions. This work benefited extremely from the expertise by the International Atomic Energy Agency, which continues to be an important partner and contributes to the work of this working group. Now, the safety framework, and you can see the cover on the screen, has been published in 2009. It has been approved by the IAEA Commission on Safety Standards, endorsed by the Committee on the Peaceful Uses of Outer Space, and jointly published in this publication. Just briefly about the principles relevant to use of nuclear power sources in outer space. There's in total 11 principles. They provide guidance for the safe use of NPS applications in outer space, and they are firmly anchored in the Outer Space Treaty as the cornerstone of the international legal regime in outer space. They're applicable to both radioisotope power systems and nuclear reactors used in space. The principles since they were adopted in 1992, call for thorough risk assessment, the sharing of safety information, and measures to protect the space environment and prevent harmful contamination. They also require timely notification if a spacecraft using an MPS is expected to reenter the atmosphere, and they outline expectations for providing assistance in the event of an accident. The safety framework, on the other hand, is more technical in nature. It provides guidance for governments, it provides guidance for management, for those who are designing and operating such a spacecraft, and it also provides technical guidance that the best practices that could be drawn from the terrestrial nuclear reactors, for example. Since then, since the development of these two frameworks, the working group has continued its work under several multi-year work plans. And the work focused really on helping member states apply the safety framework, share best practices, share information, and support also those states that are considering initiating such activities in the future. The working group also keeps track of technological and scientific developments and examines how they might influence or update, or if there is a need to update the 1992 principles and the safety framework. So far, the working group finds that applying principles together with the guidance in the safety framework represent a good foundation to ensure the safe use of MPS in outer space. and that these two guiding frameworks are being taken into account by Member States developing such activities. However, the working group also notes that additional work remains necessary on safety considerations relating to space NPS applications, particularly in regards to nuclear fusion reactors and new types and uses of radioisotope power systems. So with this, the history reflects that, yeah, technical progress, in line with technical progress, there also needs to be constant reevaluation of existing safety framework and the principles. And I'd just like to give the floor first to the chair, Mr. Samerer. The working group is now under the new work plan, 2024-28. And it has developed a dedicated questionnaire to invite or encourage member states to report on their experiences in using safety framework, but also on any challenges. Could you briefly inform the audience what is the current status and relevance of the principles and the safety framework, particularly when we talk about the lunar missions? Thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Thank you very much, Romana. Well, you already said most of it. Indeed, we have two documents that have been developed over the years, and one might ask why we need such documents in the first place and how relevant they are. And the reason is very simple, essentially twofold. Space is and will remain a relatively risky activity. Space is a harsh environment, relatively unforgiving, and there is always a remaining risk whenever you do something in space. And the second reason is that when you use unstable isotopes or produce unstable isotopes, and you put this together with risky activities, there is legitimate concern there. You need to make trade-offs between decisions or requirements from scientists and from policymakers. who typically have an interest in fast results, performance, schedule, cost. And on the other hand, you have requirements related to safeguard, to the health of the general public, the health of astronauts, the safeguarding of the environment. And you always will have to have some trade-offs. And these trade-offs or the approach to these trade-offs, of course, is slightly differently between those who have a direct benefit from these activities than those who have only an indirect benefit of these activities. And what we have in front of us, these two documents, the principles and the safety framework, they represent the current consensus on how these activities should be done in a safe and responsible manner, of course, focusing on the safety aspects. The two documents, since Romana has already mentioned, they have a slightly different flavor to them. the 1992 principles, 11 relatively short principles, and I encourage you all to actually read both documents. They are very short, they are easy to read. Some principles essentially is just one sentence, which is maybe one of the advantages of the UN process, because you have to get agreement among all member states and in all languages. And therefore, if you have a shorter text, the agreement is easier, which leads to shorter documents, which is of value. So they are easily readable, easily accessible. And you will see that especially principles three, four, five, but also then six, seven, and eight, they are directly relevant to safety aspects. Now, they have been put in place during the '80s, adopted during the early '90s, in 1992. And interestingly, when you look at the principle 11, it actually states that COPULS should reopen the discussion on these principles within two years. That somehow took a little bit longer. There was the fall of the Iron Curtain in between, and it took us until the early 2000s to agree on what would be a useful additional document to the principle. And that was the discussion where we then strongly engaged with the IEA. and developed what is the safety framework. Now, the safety framework itself is a slightly different document, also has a different structure. It is meant to be a guiding document so that those countries who have an interest in implementing nuclear power sources in their missions can benefit from the expertise and experience from those member states who have gained decades-long experience in using these nuclear power sources in a safe and responsible way. And therefore, they are structured in a slightly different way. There's a general safety objective that should be observed by everybody. And then there are three guidance sections. One is guidance for governance, Governments, sorry. So what should be the role of governments when there is a plan for an NPS application? The second one is guidance for management. So the organization that actually manages these missions, typically space agencies, also private. private entities that manage these activities, what should they take into consideration when designing, when conceiving such missions? And then the third part is called technical guidance. And this is really addressing the engineers, the ones that actually make technical trade-offs and need to understand, so what should I consider as a principle parameter of these trade-offs. And so we benefited a lot from the involvement of the IAEA, and this safety framework has been published together with the IAEA, and since then the IAEA is continuously involved in our discussion and the current work plan. And these are the two documents that we have now. And the discussion that we are currently having, but maybe I'm jumping a little bit ahead of time, is that we see now a very dynamic space sector, probably more dynamic than over the last 40 years, I would say. And with a lot of new type of applications, we also see a new renaissance of small nuclear reactors that have some similarities between putting them into, for example, naval applications and putting them on the moon. But there are also very distinct differences. And the question that we are asking in our working group is, guidance that we have currently in place, is it sufficient? Is it still the right type of guidance? Is it representing the technical state-of-the-art of what is possible, what is planned now? And essentially, the main current work is on this. But I think I was already a bit too long, so I hand back to you. Thank you, Roman.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you so much. This is a great introduction to our next speaker. Lendara De Silva from the agency. She will actually present more on micro reactors, the synergies between terrestrial and lunar reactor developments, the technical requirements. So without further ado, please, Lendara De Silva.

IAEAAssociate Nuclear Engineer

Thank you, Romana, and thank you, Leopold, because some of the points that Leopold mentioned, I cover in my presentation. So without further First thing is that at the IAEA, we are focusing on promoting the international collaboration between member states and also including the other organizations and the vendors and the market. I work in the nuclear power technology development section, and more specifically with SMRs. My main focus is on microreactors, but here I'd like to give you a little bit of an overview of what we do at the IAEA and mainly at the Nuclear Power Technology Development Section. So within this section, we will cover all the aspects, all the environment of the development of a nuclear reactor. We will cover the technology development in essence. We will also guide Member States on the technology assessment, so which one is the main nuclear reactor, the technology that fits the best our needs in the country. We will also be in touch with the other teams of the IAEA that will work with the safety, fuel management, how do we deal with the spent fuel, with the radioactive waste. and approaches to commissioning and operation, because when we talk about the life cycle of a nuclear reactor, if we provide a design that doesn't consider them, we have a design that is not completely, how can I say, robust, let's say. Let's say it like this. So we will also taking into consideration the economics. And one point that is very interesting is that now we are focusing on safeguards by design, because if we are developing small modular reactors for different applications, and for those different applications, we include sitting them in remote locations, we need to consider safeguards and protection. Safety and security, well, infrastructure development, and technical cooperation, because we cannot do this isolated. If we work in isolation, we have a less robust reactor. And first point, one point that is very important is that when I mentioned about the applications, as Leopold mentioned, now nuclear reactors are not being only used to provide electricity in a very isolated area. We are putting micro nuclear reactors in general through small modular reactors closer to the population. So the legal frameworks, they need to consider those new applications, and it includes naval and also space applications. And that's where we get into the point of the working group, because if we keep developing nuclear reactors for a terrestrial application and we send them to space, that will be a problem. And, well, why lunar mission needs nuclear power? The first thing, which are the main sources of electricity or energy in outer space? Before, now we use mainly solar power, and we use and still sometimes use radioisotopes generators, which are called in general language nuclear batteries. The first thing that why we want to spread the use of nuclear reactors is that we can continuous power during lunar nights, because lunar nights, they take 14 days. So while that, if we rely only on solar power, we won't have electricity during those nights. The high energy density and compact design. One of the main aspects that we need to consider to launch anything to the outer space is the weight. So if we send something that is too heavy or too big, And we have also to reduce the quantity of moving parts, because, for example, we could deploy a solar panel, we fold them, and then when we send it to the outer space, we open it. But if it fails, then we lose the space mission. The support for ISRU, which is in situ resource utilization, because today we are also searching on how to use of the surface of the moon or the surface of the place we are going to sit the nuclear reactor. So we can look for electrolysis or doing industrial operations there for bases, nuclear space bases that can do much more than they do today. Even there are several countries that are now looking for sending people to the moon again. So having nuclear power will be a need. Then we talk about also thermal management and radiation resilience, the scalability for permanent basis, because today we want to send six people, but then if we find something new, we want to be able to send more electricity there or any energy production, it can be heat as well, so that we can continue this. Reduce dependency on Earth resupply, because once we send the core, it's OK. It can be used for several years. And strategic redundancy, because also, if we only rely on solar power or only rely on nuclear, if we have both, we can have this redundancy. And if one is off, the other can work. But, well, it would be great if we only have the good things. There are some challenges. And there are some technical challenges. The first one is the low gravity. So systems that we use on Earth that rely on gravity, notably safety systems, we cannot use there anymore. Also, not only systems that drop, but we have also a different fluid circulation, so we won't be able to use a certain, we cannot use the same assumptions that we use on Earth. Then the second one is extreme temperature swings, because between the day and the night in the moon, the difference of temperature can be over 100 degrees Celsius. Also, this is a point I didn't mention before, is that If we deploy nuclear power, we are able to access other places or other sites in the moon, such as the South Pole of the moon, which is not so easily accessible with, there's no sun there, let's say. And other places where we have, because depending on the solar power, it will depend also how you put them to have the electricity well. Dust contamination, all the regolith and space debris, and so on. We have to consider there the vacuum and the pressure constraints, and reliability and autonomy. So what role do nuclear power sources play in addressing these challenges? What can we do to deploy nuclear reactors that are better fit to this new environment?

Speaker 127

Oops, sorry.

IAEAAssociate Nuclear Engineer

So, let's drive innovation, and most of them, they are already used now. For example, for low gravity, we cannot rely on natural circulation. For temperature swings, we need to have a thermal shielding or an isolation. Heat rejection, we need to provide a different way of cooling those reactors. Lunar regolith, we need to create coatings and protection against them. Autonomy, we need redundant systems, passive safety features, and remote diagnostics. Those are already used for microreactors today that are deployed in remote areas. And launch and operation, we want a thermal output between 40 and 100 kilowatts electrics, and a weight under 15 tons. And in terms of the technologies we are deploying there, we have three main technologies. The first one is nuclear power systems that are historically being deployed, which includes the nuclear batteries that I mentioned before, heater units. We are also looking for nuclear propulsion systems, either through thermal propulsion or electric propulsion. So they would make it possible to access a further planets are going more far from the Earth than we can today access, and the surface power systems for space bases, which would be for fission power, microreactors, all we can use in the future fusion power. So in terms of when we are talking about microreactors here at the IAEA, we have several definitions on microreactors. A common definition is related to the power output. The United States Department of Energy says that it's under 20 megawatts. The market today is focusing more on under 50 megawatts. But there are other characteristics that we need. them to have so that we are able to deploy them at those conditions, which are minimal, no on-site assembly required, small footprint, autonomous or semi-autonomous control system, safety systems passively operated, refilling cycle, and so on. And water source, which is no water source for cooling, which is very needed for a lunar application. In terms of our work, we had a consultancy meeting in June this year. We will have a technical meeting on May next year, and we want to include space applications on this technical meeting and also on the technical document that is expected by the end of 2026. In terms of global perspectives, we had 13 microreactors listed on our databases. And now we have already 37 on the market. Most of them are at the United States, but we have a lot of other countries that are also working on that. It's very distributed geographically. Here are some examples of nuclear reactors that are tailored for space. too much into the details on that, but something that is important is that a lot of them are focusing on heat pipes, reactor type. Also, for example, NASA, when they called for applications for micro reactors for outer space, they specifically requested for a closed Brayton cycle. Also, in terms of refueling cycle, we are focusing more on over 10 years. without any human intervention. And the last one is regarding how can the IAEA work with the UNOOSA and the global community to reinforce this work. Here is a timeline of main milestones that Roman and Leopold already mentioned. One main point, I will mention the first main point, was the incident with Cosmos 954, where the satellite re-entered the Earth, the atmosphere, and we had radionuclides that were landing close to Canada. This was a main point where we said, we need to understand what is happening, what we should do. to deploy emergency preparedness. Then we had the principles of relevant nuclear power sources, the emergency planning preparedness, and so on. And next year, we are planning a joint workshop on the use of nuclear power sources in outer space, where we'll have the IAEA, UNOOSA, other organizations, and member states. Thank you.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you very much for this comprehensive overview, Dandara. And yes, so lunar applications require higher constant power. Whoever will stay powered for a longer time, that will be the trick. If I may, so Leopold, to you, over to you. Where do you see the development in terms of safety guidance is heading and how is this work going to be dealt with within the working group? Thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Thank you very much. I think we should keep some time for question and answers, so I stay brief also because I don't yet have the full answers. And that's part of the objective of the current work plan, to collect information from all players, including industry, to figure out what is currently planned, what is the state of art, and what could be could be next steps for the working group. And you already mentioned that we will have next June, 9th of June, a workshop here in Vienna, where we are currently putting together the program. Some of you, some of the member states present have already nominated speakers and topics to discuss. We are currently putting the program together. We will finalize it in February at the STSC here in Vienna. So if you think you should participate and present, please contact your delegate. He is the one who then will nominate the speakers, and we will agree in February on the final list of speakers. So this is part of the second objective of our current work plan, which is to collect and analyze relevant technical information about potential future uses of NPS. in particularly those involving nuclear reactors. And I think this ties back to the workshop here, as the lunar surface applications are one of those that we have, of course, all in mind. There are a number of public and private actors that are having incredible development plans, partially funded, partially still not yet fully funded, some very well-funded activities to develop activities on the lunar surface that require the type of power that most likely only nuclear. reactors can provide. And therefore, we would like to have this discussion with everybody in the room here in Vienna on the 9th of June, because that is the type of feedback that we need in the NPS working group to then discuss whether we can agree on some further guidance that might be useful for everybody. For this, we have also sent out this year a questionnaire. The questionnaire is online and has been circulated via the Secretariat to all member states, asking them how they apply the current documents, the principles and the safety framework, if they have identified any challenges, any issues, if this guidance is useful, how it is used, whether they would require some further guidance. So this questionnaire, together with the information that we will gather On the 9th of June, we'll determine the next steps that we will recommend to COPOS following, of course, the discussion at the NPS working group. Now, maybe a last answer to the question that you just raised is whether there should be some further guidance or not. Of course, this is absolutely up to the member states of COPOS. But maybe as a first hint, I mean, you will see when you read the documents, both the principles as well as the safety framework, they are both focused on what happens on Earth. They are very much focused on things that happen at launch, that happens in Earth's orbit. They are focused on risks related to accidental reentry, that They are focused on the risks related to the stability of the orbit where they are. Everything that is risk to lunar environment, to the long-term use of the lunar environment Everything that is happening risks to others that are deployed on the Moon. These are, I would call them at the moment, secondary. And of course, the more these activities on the Moon become more important, the more there might be some need for additional guidance so that we all have a good a good general framework that we know when country X or company X is using nuclear power on the moon, that this is the general context, this is what they are doing, this is what's the implication on my activities, and this is my personal expectation of where the discussion is heading.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you very much for this, and now the floor is open for questions. Shall we go first? Okay, first row here, please.

Speaker 132

Leopold, you briefly mentioned launch. Let's be practical. Which are the options that Europe has to launch even a small RTG in one of the near-term plan, not conceived really, in calendar missions?

Thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

I'm not sure if we do it like in the UN, where we have the whole thing first, but I can answer this question by not answering it, actually, because I don't think this is the right forum to discuss European launch opportunities.

Speaker 134

It's a need that we need to tackle.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Of course, yeah.

Speaker 136

We use nuclear in space, we need to launch something.

Yes, of course.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

But with all due respect to the question, I think the workshop here is not about European launch capacity evolutions with respect to nuclear power.

Speaker 138

No, but I was referring to the needs to be considered, the critical aspect that we need to discuss. So it's not the answer when we will be able to launch, it's to raise the point.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Well, I'm not speaking for ESA as part of the EPS chair, but what I can tell you, what is publicly known also in the European context, we have, as part of the Endure program within ESA, we have a dedicated work package and initiative that address the safety aspects of launching nuclear power sources, including from European launch site in French Guiana. And there is an ongoing work that is happening with delegations and with industry that addresses how we implement this safety guidance. On the ESA side, ESA has published its own implementation of the safety framework as part of the of the ISA safety framework for the use of nuclear power sources that is also available. You can even find it in the UN document repository. There is constant publications about this, and I think from that side, we are very well covered. Now, when will be the first launch from French Biennale, that, i think, is a discussion that is beyond the scope here.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you. Thank you so much. So I will go first here, then the middle, and then I will move back there. Please, gentlemen.

USRADirector, Center for Space Nuclear Research

This is, I'm Robert Bryan. I serve as USRA's director of the Center for Space Nuclear Research in Idaho Falls. My question is partly to raise awareness and draw attention to a potential challenge or barrier for commercialization, both on the lunar surface, topic of today, but also commercial activities to support government activities in cislunar space and in planetary exploration. And it's related to principle 32C, which, unlike the need or gaps in frameworks, this is quite prescriptive in terms of prescribing the use of highly enriched uranium for fission systems. I want to draw attention to this because this is a barrier for commercial activities, and it draws us towards the topic of fuel cycle. And fuel cycle transcends a trade between both safeguards and security, and also launch safety. And I think that concern of how we go from a fuel cycle discussion to thinking about sustainability operations on the lunar surface. So we need to think about recycle, formerly reprocessing, but recycling. And then in the greater distance, look at in-situ resource utilization and how that impacts fuel cycle itself. If we think about the thorium fuel cycle, potential for thorium deposits on the moon, how that will influence our decisions and structure. So the crux of the question is, is this the most urgent area in the treaty that needs to be addressed, perhaps before 2030, as nation states fair towards lunar activities with reactor systems? And is the working group already making good progress in this area? Thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Thank you very much. You will certainly follow very much already my recommendation to read the documents. You read them very carefully because you noted, of course, one formulation that was the consensus in the 80s when this was agreed to. which very unlikely would be the recommendation at this stage. And I think, I'm not a lawyer either, I use the same pretext as Matthias, but I think in this case, the formulations have to be seen also in the context of their time, and of course that has evolved. And if you read during the proceedings of how this article was discussed during the 80s, you get the intention, and the intention back then might not be the most relevant anymore today. So in practical terms, we had discussed this specific part also when we discussed whether there should be we should reopen the principles, or we should provide an additional document in form of the safety framework and the consensus. Back then was we write an additional document that is maybe more practical for the different governments, management, and technical guidance. And you will see It is much less prescriptive on single topics. There is another topic in the principles, for example, on the 1 mSv dose limit, which, of course, putting in a document Those limit where you know that the scientific knowledge changes and the general acceptance also changes, and the IAEA has changed since then. The recommendations was maybe not the ultimate wisdom during the discussions on these principles in the 90s, but I would suggest that these are not blocking points as such. They need to be explained, they need to put into context, and this is part of the trade-off that needs to be done by governments in any case when they look at the safety case of any NPS application. So that would be my maybe non-legal simplistic answer to this question.

UNOOSAModerator

Yes, if I may add, these are the principles of non-legally binding documents, so it's a guidance for Gentleman's here, then the lady, and then we'll go back there.

ChinaRepresentative; ATLAC member

Thank you. Thank you for both panelists for your introduction. I have the first question about the membership of the working group. As we all know, the membership of the working group on NPS is quite limited. So my question to the chair of the working group is whether you see the values to extend the membership of this working group. I know there's barriers of technical, but also capacity, but look to the environment impact of NPS. So that is quite common concern to the international community. So my second question is based on Mr. Soner's assessment of the current status, you see that most of them are based on what happened on this. If I can add that also based on what happened with one NPS facilities in consideration, we are not anticipated to have multiple NPS applications. But look to the future in the lunar environment, there might be multiple NPS applications. So whether you will anticipate there will be a different risk assessment. with that new development. So the question you mentioned is quite technical, only look at the current awareness and application. I would encourage you to have more forward-looking because as Mrs. Selvaratnam mentioned, there are challenges on the lunar surface. It's quite unique. You have a dust contamination and surface separation, which is not addressed properly when you have all eight MPS applications? So that is a question, but also a recommendation. Perhaps the working group can look be more future perspective. Thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Thank you, thank you very much. So I'm happy to address both questions. The first one is particularly close to my heart. When I took up the chairmanship of this working group, we had a discussion on how we can enlarge and encourage more member states to participate into the discussions at the working group. And the questionnaire that I just mentioned before is one method of reaching out and raising the awareness about the work of the working group to more member states that are currently participating. I have to say We already see the effect of this. Just last week, we had another intersessional informal meeting where we had, I think, something like 20 plus participants, both those that are, of course, actively using nuclear power sources right away, as those that have some plans and projects, and those that might have some in the future, but are not yet at the same planning level. So, yes, absolutely, the working group and the work of the working group is open to all COPUS members, and we have an interest to have have everybody who is interested in the topic around the table. We also try more and more to make sure that we don't have sessions in parallel to the plenary at COPUS, which allows especially smaller delegations to attend also our deliberations. And yes, historically, this is a relatively small working group, but there's a changing environment, as we have seen. There are more and more countries interested in this topic, and we need to have everybody fully involved and on board. So that's your first question. I fully share the objective, and I think it is shared by all members of the working group. The second question is you, if I can paraphrase it, you suggest us to be more forward-looking than what is currently in the concrete plans. And that's indeed exactly our objective. That's part of the objective of the working group. And as you rightly point out, the conditions for lunar surface applications are very different from orbital applications, and they also require different solutions. There is one document that I can also refer to where we have outlined the safety considerations which are specific to nuclear power sources in space compared to terrestrial applications, which is already now 20 years old, but which is very much looking at these aspects that are naturally different once you are on the Moon, from dust, from thermal cycling, from vicinity to other installations. There's plenty of plenty of reason to have very distinct requirements and also safety approaches. So I fully concur with you on the second point, and if I understood your sub-question in there that instead of one-offs, you have recurrent applications, yes, you're also absolutely spot on that these require different approaches to safety.

UNOOSAModerator

So, we have gentlemen then, then the lady. A lot of questions here. We try to please be brief.

ChinaSpace Lawyer; Nominated Expert, ATLAC

Thank you, Romana. So my question just briefly, whether it is 100% to say, to argue, the NPS principle is not legally binding. Because you look at the principle eight. Sorry, regarding liability responsibility, I believe that's purely they are the legal interpretation or implementation of the binding rules in Outer Space Treaty. So I think it's super important for the stakeholders on the Moon and is supposed to be a starting point for the relevant talking in your working group. So then, i remember years ago, some delegations argue this principle need to be developed into a binding treaty. So I'm not sure your perspective, you know, whether it is necessary or feasible to do so. Thank you.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Okay, there, I have the hat here as the the chair of the NPS working group of the scientific and technical subcommittee, not of the legal subcommittee. So I would defer the question on the role of the legal subcommittee and making it binding or not, or to what extent the NPS principles represent some sort of followed practice, and after some time they become, they have a higher status than just non-binding recommendations, I would really like to not answer this question because I would probably not be able to answer it in a proper way. I think what is still relevant as part of the answer is they provide some very useful recommendations, some very useful principles that When you look at the spirit in which they have been written, when you look at the nature of what they recommend, there is very good reason for everybody to follow these principles. Now, whether they're legally binding and in what form, I would keep it almost out of this discussion because there are plenty of papers published every year on this aspect. And I think our brain and the brain of the NBS working group can be more useful to users by providing practical guidelines on what is considered the consensus for a good approach to achieve safety for such applications.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you. And yes, if I may, the principles are strongly grounded in the Outer Space Treaty and refer also to specific articles in the Outer Space Treaty. But before, when we heard the question about potential technical barriers, more on technical issues, on the use of sources of energy. That is what we were referring to. Please, the lady behind.

Space Telecommunications Specialist

Thanks. Naomi from Harlet in England. I do telecommunications for space. I've got a question about moon quakes. So I understand NASA are doing an updated study from the 1960s next year, and I know that you've got working groups and those kinds of things. From what I understand, the moonquakes last over a year, and in Earth, we've only had one for 15 minutes at the nine Richter scale. How do you think that impacts nuclear? The reason why I ask is because I presented a paper at IAC in Sydney and asked a similar question. In terms of safety and ITU telecommunications, Article 40, When we're having to monitor astronauts and those kinds of things, how are you going to test for that stuff? And the other area that I wanted to ask a question on is the mushroom material, because obviously it's very good at absorbing radiation and bunkers and those kinds of things on Earth. Obviously, I've worked in Norway for Statoil. There's a nuclear bunker that I've been into. So how are you anticipating that these kinds of things that we experience in terrestrial is going to work up in the lunar surface?

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Well, maybe I can also defer to some of the technical questions to my colleague here on the panel on the On the moon, moonquakes. This is part of the discussions on what is specific to putting a reactor on the moon than to putting it on Earth. What I can tell you from maybe purely engineering point of view, these reactors are typically designed to be launched and put on a rocket, where you have vibration loads that are typically far exceeding those that you have on experience on on any building or installation during a quake, especially if they are designed to withstand quakes. So I would not say that this is something that is not relevant as a question. On the contrary, it is one of those questions that we need to consider very carefully. I would just argue that it is likely not a showstopper. Okay, and then the second question was on mushrooms, if I understood correctly, which survive very well, high radiation?

Space Telecommunications Specialist

Yeah, I'll just say that it's the fabrication which they're working on to have in situ for the lunar basis. So that's why I was trying to say, what are the ramifications that if there is a nuclear accident, and how are you guys testing that kind of stuff? 'Cause obviously, i understand the nuclear propulsion, don't get me wrong, I understand that. What I'm trying to say is the in situ, because when those moonquakes happen, they can last over a year, and NASA haven't updated their reports until the end of 2026, that study is going forward. So that's what I'm trying to understand, is how do you Is that on? Yeah. How do you get that into your working group for next year? Because those mushroom fabrications are having to be tested for all kinds of things, and that's what I'm just asking. Is that on your roadmap for both of those studies? Because that won't, I mean, they're only launching that study late next year.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

I take it as a question that I will raise with the working group. At the moment, i can tell you we have not discussed it yet, but I'm happy to take it as an input from this discussion and then we see what we take with it. Thank you.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you. We will need to wrap up, so five minutes. We have two more questions there. If you can be very brief, gentlemen, please.

UND

All right. Thank you very much. I'll make a brief Clive Neale again from University of Notre Dame, and talking about your deliberations about power, and something Robert said about the future needs and requirements for space resource utilization. I think it would be important for you to talk with the legal aspects of space resource activities working group, because if there are resources that can be extracted, then we will have multiple sites on the Moon with nuclear power. And we will need lots of power for that, and concur with the delegate from China that we will have those multiple sites if we know that those resources are there and if they can be extracted, which we don't know. But that's something to keep on your radar. I'd like to just make sure that doesn't get glossed over and there's some interaction between the working groups.

COPUOSChair, Working Group on the Use of Nuclear Power Sources in Outer Space; Head of Technology Department, ESA

Yeah, simple answer, yes.

UNOOSAModerator

Thank you very much. My colleagues informed me we need to wrap up because the cafeteria closes at 2:30. So we are very appreciative of your interest, of the questions, and perhaps we can take it also offline. The chair will be here for the full day also for the wrap-up panel at 5:00 PM. So you're welcome to also ask questions offline. Thank you so much for your interest. Thank you very much.

UNOOSAConference moderator

All right, thank you, ladies and gentlemen. We are gonna take a break for lunch. For options here in the Vienna National Center, if you take the bank of elevators over by the coffee corner, take that to the ground floor, and then go down the hallway away from the rotunda, in the F building, there is a cafeteria. As mentioned, it serves until 2:30. There are also options outside of the building, of course. Just keep in mind that when you re-enter the building, you'll have to go through the visitor entrance and security again, so factor that into your timing. We'll see you all back here and begin at 3:00 promptly with the next panel on lunar PNT. Thank you very much.