Recentering Citizens in Peace and Political Progress
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Audio no longer matches transcript
This transcript was made from an earlier 2h40m version of the audio that has since been shortened to 1h54m. Some parts may not match playback.
Good morning, how are you? Thank you very much. It's been a crazy five years.
Lila, I think we can start. I think we can start. And we're almost on time, so with only a three minute delay. Good morning, excellencies, distinguished guests, dear colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. My name is Andrea Pozderac, and on behalf of myself and my co-moderator, Mark Nurkic, a peace building fellow at Jackson School of Global Affairs, It is our privilege to welcome you to this roundtable conversation on recentering citizens in peace and political progress. This event is organized by the permanent missions of Bosnia and Herzegovina, Luxembourg, and European Union delegations to the United Nation in collaboration with United States Bosnia and Herzegovina Exchange Council. At the center of this event are presentations of two bodies of research. on Citizen-Informed Pathways for Peaceful Institutional Progress in Bosnia and Herzegovina, completed in 2026 through a research partnership of Yale Jackson's School of Global Affairs, the Institute for Development Impact, University of Luxembourg, and University of Sida. It is our hope that this event will introduce citizen-informed evidence and a successful example of a youth-led initiative into dialogues of member states, United Nations, and policy and research communities. While grounded in research completed in Bosnia and Herzegovina, the results are important for broader consideration and conversation about how citizen and youth participation can strengthen nationally owned peacebuilding in divided and post-conflict societies by examining what enables cooperation across divisions to be translated into meaningful and durable public decisions and institutional action. We expect a very fruitful and dynamic discussion, headed by our co-hosts, the esteemed Permanent Representatives, His Excellency Dr. Zlatko Lagumdzija and Her Excellency Veronika Dokondof. Good morning, and thank you for your leadership and support. We're also honored to have with us this morning Her Excellency Elizabeth Spehar, Assistant Secretary General for Peacebuilding and Peace Support, and Her Excellency Mo Bliker, Special Advisor of the Secretary General on Responsibility to Protect, joining us via video conference from Geneva. Good morning and welcome. And last, but certainly not the least, we would like to welcome the research partnership representatives here with us today, Dr. Josip Glodich from University of Luxembourg, Dr. Catherine Panter-Brick and Dr. David Simon from Yale University, and Mr. Imran Pashalic from Center of Research and Development and former president of the Students' Parliament of the University of Zajevo. They will present the main aspects of their respective research and initiatives that are the focus of today's event. Without further ado, I would like to give the floor to His Excellency Dr. Zlatko Lagumdzija, Ambassador, Permanent Representative of Bosnia and Herzegovina to the United Nations, for his opening remarks. Excellency, you have the floor.
Thank you, Andreja. Excellencies, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, it’s an honour to welcome you to today’s event. It also allows me to express my sincere appreciation to my dear colleague, Ambassador Veronique Dockendorff. and the Permanent Mission of Luxembourg, as well as the EU delegation to the United Nations for co-organizing this important discussion with us. I also warmly welcome Assistant Secretary-General and good old friend, Elizabeth Speer, and Special Advisor Mo Bleeker, who is joining us from Geneva. Their participation reflects the importance of today's conversation for the United Nations' work on peacebuilding and prevention. My gratitude goes equally to our research partners, with full respect to the University of Luxembourg, the Yale University Jackson School of Global Governance, the Institute for Development Impact, and of course, University of Sarajevo, and EU Peace Alliance, as well as to the good friends, United States Bosnia and Herzegovina Exchange Council for their partnership and contribution to this initiative. My welcome lines exceed this. More than three decades have passed since the Dayton Peace Agreement brought an end to the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Preserving that achievement, however, requires more than absence of conflict. Post-conflict societies are often viewed through the lens of persistent divisions and political disagreements. These challenges must be acknowledged and addressed, but they should not overshadow the cooperation, shared priorities, and constructive initiatives that continue to bring people together. Our experience demonstrates that peace is built not only through the political arrangement and institutional processes, but also through the evidence and everyday actions of citizens, communities, civil society, and the private sector. Research that will be presented today, thanks to our dear friends and respective colleagues, offers valuable insight into these dynamics. It highlights an important reality in Bosnia and Herzegovina: cooperation across political and ethno-national divisions is more prevalent and productive than political institutions and public discourse often acknowledge. Despite institutional fragmentation and limited shared decision-making, individuals and organizations from different communities continue to build relationships, pursue common interests, and achieve tangible results. Some of these research findings remind us that Bosnia and Herzegovina’s social fabric is more interconnected than political divisions alone might suggest. Shared experience, everyday relationships, and practical cooperation provide a foundation for peace and progress without requiring people to abandon abandon their different identities or political views and country. At the same time, much of this cooperation remains informal, localized, or dependent on individual projects. Too often, it does not translate into sustained institutional action, lasting policy change, or broader reform. This gap between constructive, pragmatic cooperation on the ground and political decision-making at the institutional level, often hindered by divisive political rhetoric preferred captured as people, some people say, dual reality of modern Bosnia and Herzegovina, and remains one of the central challenges facing our country. It is encouraging that citizens across Bosnia and Herzegovina continue to recognize the importance of peace and stability, even when they hold different views on political and constitutional questions. Peace is not simply an achievement preserved since 1995, it remains a shared priority and responsibility for the future. Institutions must be better equipped to recognize this common ground identified in this research, respect it to citizens' needs, and demonstrate that public service is guided by professionalism, fairness, equal treatment, and accountability. Young people have a particularly important role in this effort, and we'll hear this a little more later from our dear partners and guests. The Student Peace Declaration, led by University of Sarajevo and the EU Peace Alliance, demonstrates their commitment to peace, dialogue, human dignity, and cooperation. The commitment to peace lies at the heart of the United Nations Charter, since we are here in the United Nations, whose first purpose is to maintain international peace and security. Yet the Charter begins with the words "We, the peoples." Reaffirming the importance of human dignity, fundamental rights, social progress, and improved living conditions. Article 55 further connects stability and well-being, economic and social progress, and universal respect for human rights. These commitments are reflected in three mutually reinforcing pillars of the United Nations: peace and security, development, and human rights. Bosnia and Herzegovina’s experience demonstrates that these objectives cannot be pursued in isolation. Peace is not everything, but without peace, nothing else is possible. Someone smarter than me said that a long time ago. Peace creates the conditions for development. Inclusive and sustainable development strengthens stability, and respect for human rights and human dignity reinforces the foundations of just and peaceful society. Bosnia and Herzegovina has sought to translate their principles into concrete actions through its engagements with the United Nations. In January 2011, during our presidency of the Security Council, my two best diplomats were part of that team who are sitting in here today. We invited an open debate on post-conflict peacebuilding and institution-building. The Council recognized institution building as a critical component of peacebuilding and emphasized the importance of national ownership. For Bosnia and Herzegovina, these principles are not abstract concepts. Sustainable peace requires dialogue across ethnic, religious, political, and generational divides, recognizing a victim's suffering, respect for survivors' dignity, accountability and justice, willingness to confront the legacy of the past, residents to hate speech and discrimination, and last but not least, inclusive education. These objectives are closely aligned with 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and reflected in UN Sustainable Development Cooperation Framework for Bosnia and Herzegovina for year 2026 to 2030, which identifies inclusiveness, accountability, institutions, and social cohesion among our shared priorities. So connections is fundamental. Where institutions are accountable, citizens have greater reason to trust them. Where participation is meaningful, institutions are better able to understand and respond to public needs. And where the rule of law and equal opportunity are upheld, and the foundation for lasting peace becomes stronger. Bosnia and Herzegovina remains firmly committed to peace and stability, the rule of law, sustainable development, and on our European path. We showed a readiness to share our experiences in peacebuilding, post-conflict recovery, and reconciliation with other societies facing similar challenges. While every context is different, as we all know, One, our experience can contribute to the broader international understanding of what it takes to sustain peace, and that's what I'm thankful again to our dear friends and guests and owners of this project who are with us today. The central lesson is clear. Lasting peace must be built with citizens, not simply for them. Political arrangement can end violence and establish institutional framework, but citizens give peace its enduring social meaning through participation, solidarity, accountability, and committed mental justice. The challenge before us is to bridge the gap between citizens' aspirations and institutional delivery, ensuring that the cooperation already taking place across our communities becomes a stronger foundation for inclusive governance, reconciliation, and sustainable development. Key words from the title of our event, "Recentering Citizens," are encapsulating the core principle for Bosnia and Herzegovina and other divided societies of institutional capacities needed for sustainable peace and political progress. On the conclusion, It's worth repeating. The encouraging lesson I learned myself from the research before us is the cooperation across political and ethno-national divisions is more common in Bosnia and Herzegovina than political discourse might suggest. I knew that for decades, but I have now scientific proof. So I thank you for that. It is, in a way, a message that citizens, the real people, through the practical cooperation, are keeping together the very fabric of our shared society, which has been our reality for centuries, regardless of institutional insufficiencies, of still present political attempts to drive us in direction of non-European values, if we can call it that way, and segregated societies. It is a message that citizens are more interested in building bridges of cooperation among different constituencies and peoples. rather than in creating walls and segregation. Or to make lesson I have learned simplified, citizens, the real people, are much more interested in peace and cooperation than some leaders whose aim is to push them in another direction into confrontation. Peace of the people, by the people, for the people, right? Or something like that. Shared society and state of the citizens, by the citizens, for the citizens. with all of their multiple identities, which we do have as Serbs, Croats, Bosnians, others, Muslims, Christians, Catholics, Orthodox, Jews, our multiple identities being our asset, not our liability, institutionally guaranteed by the very heart of UN Charter: peace and security, sustainable development, and human rights. I really thank you, all of you, for sharing your thoughts with us today. Thank you.
Thank you, Ambassador Lagunja, for your remarks and for offering a glimpse or the highlight of what we will be discussing today and how relevant that conversation really is, not only for Bosnia and Herzegovina, but more broadly and to the United Nations as well. I now have the honor to invite Assistant Secretary General Spehar to deliver her remarks. Excellency, you have the floor. Thank you.
Thank you very much indeed. And I want to start by thanking very much our dear Ambassador of Bosnia and Herzegovina here and his mission, as well as all of the others, also the mission of Luxembourg, Yale, University of Luxembourg, for bringing us together today. And really, my congratulations to the researchers who have put some excellent pieces of work before us, which really are wonderful bases for discussion and debate. Excellencies, colleagues and friends, dear Ambassador, I think we can all agree that Bosnia and Herzegovina's hard-won peace should never be taken for granted. It's for the country's leaders, institutions, and societies to safeguard that achievement, uphold the Dayton framework, and address political differences through dialogue. And there's no doubt that women have a vital role to play in shaping Bosnia and Herzegovina's future. There can be truly no inclusive or lasting peace in the country without women's meaningful participation. Overall, peace should never be taken for granted. Today, violent conflict is increasing in both numbers and complexity. Political polarization is deepening across the globe, and it's dividing societies. It's deepening humanitarian crises, and there is growing violence, systemic violence, against citizens in so many countries. Re-centering citizens, the theme of today's event and the research that we're discussing, has never been more critical for the wider international agenda. So how can partners better incorporate citizens and young people's perspectives into peacebuilding? First, we have to preserve and help expand the civic space. Citizens need to feel able to participate freely and meaningfully in decision making. It's not a coincidence that for this year's Global Civil Society UN Peacebuilders Dialogue, we'll focus on promoting civic space at a time of rising authoritarianism. We look forward to welcoming civil society representatives from across the world, including from Bosnia and Herzegovina, to help shape global peacebuilding policy. But as we've seen in many contexts, there cannot be participation without protection. Where people can safely hold institutions to account, peacebuilding is strengthened. This takes me to my second point, and that is that citizens' perspectives must be an integral part of our efforts to build more effective and trusted institutions. In the case of Bosnia and Herzegovina, as was presented in the Yale policy paper, we see that a certain level of cooperation is already happening across divides. We also see that durable peace depends on how this cooperation is sustained by effective and trusted institutions. In a recent review that we conducted on our own efforts through the Secretary-General's Peacebuilding Fund to support institutional strengthening for peacebuilding, it was confirmed that most citizens' experience with the state first occurs through municipal authorities and local service delivery. Strengthening institutions has to involve not only strengthening more state capacity, pardon me, not only strengthening core state capacities, but also improving how these institutions relate to the populations they serve, in particular at the municipal level. In Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Secretary-General's Peacebuilding Fund supported the institutionalization of local dialogue platforms across 10 municipalities. To date, these platforms have involved more than 800 young people, fostering cooperation with institutions and building trust and consensus on shared priorities. I also believe that digital technology offers great potential for positive citizens' engagement with institutions. I hope that we'll be able to see and promote as partners Much more innovation in the coming years to put AI at the service of citizens, obviously with strong guardrails to help make sure that technology builds trust in institutions rather than the reverse. Recently, a series of digital dialogues promoted inclusive national ownership, and especially the engagement of young people in Libyan and Yemeni peace processes. Supported by the Innovation Cell in our Department of Political and Peacebuilding Affairs, these digital dialogues offer an example of the kind of platforms that could be more widely replicated to engage citizens in peace and governance. Third, we must keep learning and co-generating evidence together with citizens. We share with all of you a commitment to strengthening the evidence base for peacebuilding, based on the experience and priorities of the people whose peace is at stake. In many cases, the causes of conflict revolve around exclusion, including perceived exclusion. Earlier this year, we launched the inaugural Peacebuilding Overview Report, titled Investing in Peace When the World Pays for War. The report finds that people's experiences of peace are often grounded in practical needs as well as in perceptions, whether institutions are reliable and whether information can be trusted. Listening to citizens and co-generating the evidence can reveal common aspirations and opportunities for cooperation that may not be apparent in political debates. It can also help identify where trust has eroded, where improvements and perceptions still diverge, and where peacebuilding efforts can make the greatest difference. This is why, together with civil society organizations from a number of countries, we are co-creating a peacebuilding impact measurement toolkit to help all peacebuilders, governments, their citizens, and local civil society to jointly measure and communicate impact. I'd like to close with one further reflection. The experience of Bosnia and Herzegovina, as the Ambassador noted, is highly relevant for the wider international agenda. I'm particularly pleased to see the growing role of young people through efforts such as the Students' Peace Declaration. I'm looking forward to the issuance of the second independent study on youth's participation in political and peace processes, which was mandated by the Pact for the Future and should be out in December of this year. And I believe it will reveal some important data about youth perspectives today in terms of peace and politics, as well as sharing with us recommendations for their greater empowerment and impact. In our volatile world, building a culture of peace means building a global constituency for peace, together with those who are traditionally excluded. I hope that our youth will be leading the way. Thank you.
Thank you very much, ASG Spehar, for your valuable contribution and for offering a new dimension on the importance of women's participation in these processes, as well as technological considerations that we need to have, as well as the importance of promoting a civic space and evidence-based decision-making to help shape global peacebuilding policy and incorporating citizens' perspective into institutional strengthening, particularly at the municipal level. Now I would like to turn to the Special Advisor joining us online, Special Advisor of the Secretary-General on Responsibility to Protect, joining us from Geneva, Her Excellency Mo Bliker. Her Excellency, you have the floor.
Do you hear me well?
Yes, we hear you quite well.
Okay, wonderful. Excellencies, colleagues, and dear friends, ambassadors, I would like to express my gratitude to the Permanent Mission of Bosnia and Herzegovina to the United Nations and the Permanent Mission of Luxembourg to the United Nations, as well as the U.S.-Bosnia and Herzegovina Exchange Council, Yale University, and University of Luxembourg for convening us all today. This is a very important discussion. I'm grateful to be able to join you, even if remotely, for this important and very timely discussion about this interesting research study. And allow me to outline, to begin with, three main evidences of this report. Cooperation across political and ethno-national divisions is more common in Bosnia and Herzegovina than political and public discourse might suggest. The second point is cooperative arrangements work best when participants have a clear reason to rely on each other and sufficient authority and institutional support to carry the work forward. And there are distinct points where cooperation could lose force and does lose force when political agreement over authorities is required. Furthermore, the report also quotes a 2026 consent survey that underlines that while substantial difference of opinion exist among Bosnian, Bosniaks, Croat, Serbs, and others over territory, sovereignty, representation, and international supervision, they do share very similar opinions exist about the need of judicial independence, professional public administration, equal rights, institutional integrity, judicial independence, ranking ahead of every other element tested. These findings tell us that 30 years after the Dayton Peace Agreement, citizens, Bosniak, Croats, Serbs, and others, despite their differences, are engaging on a daily basis together to achieve concrete common goals, and this despite the institutional deadlocks and the divisive political narratives. But on another note, during the recent electoral campaign, the disputes over wartime narratives and the constitutional future of Bosnia and Herzegovina occupied a central place in the public discourse. And furthermore, the funeral of Mladic, serving a life sentence for genocide and crimes against humanity, highlighted again the issue of denial, and generated again competing accounts of statehood, entity autonomy, and victimhood. Ladies and gentlemen, I had the opportunity again this March to visit Bosnia and Herzegovina. I listened carefully to people talking about the legacy of the past, about memorialization, about hate speech, and powerlessness. I heard people saying that in some cities or neighborhoods, youth groups from different technical backgrounds are not talking anymore to each other. They are not meeting, and this is dangerous. I heard people saying they want to leave the country. I heard people longing to a maybe idealized past where they were all together independently of the ethnical background. I heard people speak about corruption, about blocking joint initiatives. I heard people expressing also the need to hand over a peaceful legacy to their children and wanting to contribute to a new societal contract for their country. So this study and other research are telling us that people, whatever their ethnical background, do need and do work together. They do cooperate, and they rely on each other to achieve concrete goals, to live and to survive. But the study tells us also that when political agreement by highest authorities is required, too often these initiatives are failing. And the other element I mentioned recalls also that the Dayton Agreement certainly halted the armed conflict, but did not achieve the very goal of a holistic transitional justice process, that is, a societal transformation based on the joint acknowledgement of the truth, the establishment of responsibilities across ethnic lines, and a peaceful coexistence respectful of diversity. So criminal and retributive justice by itself did not yet achieve the highest goal of justice. in a post-war context. That is a shared understanding of the facts, of truth, of responsibility, independently of who were the victims and who were the perpetrators. Victims could hence not yet become also citizens, bearer of rights, dealing with the state, bearer of obligations. And furthermore, the stories of the ones in each community who did protect, who did hide, help, and save people independently of their ethnical identity, are still not celebrated as the ones who are the real heroes. Immediately at the end of the conflict, I remembered the regional initiative, RECOM, collecting evidence to contribute to establish the facts, whoever the victims and whoever the perpetrators were. Families of missing, Bosnian, Croat, Serbs, and others were cooperating. They were victims of the same crime. They shared the same needs. So this report is recalling us that Bosnia, Croats, Serbs, and others have shared needs to move ahead, to be acknowledged as citizens, as right bearers. But they do need an interlocutor, a leadership, a state that fulfills its responsibility towards all its citizens, a state that prevents risk. that protects its population and ensures that norms and standards are equally valid for everyone. And these common needs are also the promise of a potential shared common good, a potential new societal contract based on shared norms, shared values, shared standards. So let me ask you a question to conclude. What if civil society and government across ethnic lines could jointly define together the content of this so expected new societal contract in Bosnia and Herzegovina? A societal contract based on shared needs, shared resilience capacity, shared understanding of the societal vulnerability that shall be addressed: discrimination, violence, racism, inequality, and others. And what if civil society and government across ethnical lines could jointly define the contact of a new societal contract, building further on the promises of a transformative and holistic transitional justice across ethnical divides, so that an agreement on facts, truth, and responsibility could finally emerge. And even more, where civil society and government across ethnical lines could jointly define about the best ways to prevent harm, to protect those who shall be protected, and to overcome the weaknesses of the state and strengthen its capacity to ensure non-recurrence of past dark history, a societal contract that finally can highlight shared priorities for the future. This is, I believe, the original promise of a holistic transitional justice, societal transformation. 30 years after Dayton, Bosnia and Herzegovina is really at the crossroad. The youth in Serbia just showed that the future cannot wait. It's high time in Bosnia and Herzegovina, all citizens, society, and state to work and dialogue together on this new societal contract towards the best future they all want to see for themselves, for their children, and the future generation. Thank you.
Thank you very much, ASG Bleeker, for that very inspirational opening remarks and for highlighting the needs of everyday citizens to be at the center of peace and political progress, and the question of the new social contract that might exist in Bosnia. That is certainly something that I'd be very curious to listen to at the Q&A session of today's roundtable. I would now like to turn to the presentation of our research initiatives. as highlighted by our speaker and already, who provided already a glimpse of what we might be discussing today. First, we will now turn to Dr. Glaudisch from University of Luxembourg to lead us into the presentation of part of our event, and followed by Dr. Panter-Brick and Dr. Simon from Yale University, and then concluding with Mr. Imran Pashalic, who will be presenting the Students' Peace Declaration. Dr. Glavrdic, you have the floor. Thank you.
Thank you very much for the introduction, and especially to the US Bosnia and Herzegovina Exchange Council, our colleagues at Yale, and I4DI, the permanent missions of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Luxembourg, and the EU delegation for making today's discussion possible. Thank you also to all the speakers before. We always in academia wonder if our research makes an impact. And you've read our work, and you have understood it, and that's wonderful. So I come from the University of Luxembourg, presenting the work of our consent BIH team, which also includes, i have to recognize my colleagues, Kristof Leschave, Enser Muharemovic, and Mia Jepina. So our project begins with a simple question, which is relevant well beyond Bosnia and Herzegovina. What happens when we stop asking political leaders what their communities want? and start asking citizens themselves. So we approach this through four stages, from listening to citizens individually and collectively, to testing constitutional compromises and public reactions to our findings. Today, I'm going to focus on the first two stages, which were completed this summer. We began by listening. Through interviews and focus groups, we discovered that citizens rarely approached constitutional questions as abstract debates about institutional design. They were much more interested in what institutions actually delivered. Can government make decisions? Can politicians be held accountable? Do constitutional safeguards protect communities or just enable political obstruction? What emerged was a widespread sense of limited political agency, which was present in all communities. People expected a great deal from public institutions, but felt that they personally had little influence over how those institutions operated. And I think there's a broader lesson here for international peacebuilding. We often assess post-conflict institutions by their formal design and capacity to accommodate competing elites. Citizens, however, judge them by something rather different, whether they are fair, responsive, and capable of improving their everyday lives. Building on these findings, we surveyed then more than 2000 citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina across 18 constitutional questions. But before getting to those preferences, some of which you're going to see there, let me highlight something important that we also found. The citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina are remarkably similar in their broader ideological orientations, regardless of ethnicity. Whether we look at nationalism, populism, economic preferences, even attitudes towards the Bosnian war, we find exceptional levels of similarity. People in Bosnia and Herzegovina may belong to three or multiple ethnic national communities, but they are inhabiting one polity. So what do these citizens actually want their constitution, any possible constitutional settlement to protect? Peace and stability come first, followed by equal rights, preventing corruption, political accountability, and economic well-being all rank higher than ethnic group rights. When it comes to constitutional issues that these citizens want their constitution to address, judicial independence ranks first across all ethnic groups. Now, this doesn't mean that ethnic protections are not important, but citizens' priorities cannot simply be inferred from the issues that dominate negotiations between their political representatives. Good governance. institutional impartiality, equal citizenship. Those are central to what citizens expect any political settlement to deliver. So where do the sharp ethnic divisions actually emerge? Our findings suggest that ethnicity does matter significantly, but selectively. There is considerable agreement on institutional priorities. But the picture changes when we move from questions of what institutions should deliver to questions of who should control them. Territorial organization, collective representation, secession, military alignment, and international oversight do reveal sharper divisions. And these disagreements are real. They reflect different concerns about political power, collective security, and protection from domination. We shouldn't underestimate them. But neither should we allow them to define our understanding of the entire society. For international peacebuilding, I think this means identifying more precisely where group accommodation is genuinely necessary and where extending ethnic principles into political institutions actually undermines citizens' shared expectations of government. Our findings complicate the familiar picture in another important way. Even where ethnicity matters, members of individual communities do not necessarily agree among themselves. To explore this, we constructed a measure based on eight constitutional questions that are central to our understanding of consociational democracy. where we classified respondents' preferences along three dimensions: centralism versus territorial ethnic power sharing, consociationalism, and compromise between the two. That's what these four graphs essentially show for the four different sets of communities. This figure shows you the resulting distribution for each of those communities. So darker shades indicate where preferences are concentrated, and the black dots, if you can see them, represent average positions. And two things for me stand out. First, Bosniaks and others lean stronger towards centralist solutions, while Croats and Serbs are more inclined toward ethnic power sharing and compromise solutions. But second, there is considerable variation within communities, and this is particularly the case among Croat and Serb respondents, but not only them. Those are distributed across a much broader constitutional space. No single position adequately represents everyone within any ethnic or national community. There do not exist three coherent ethno-national constitutional sets of preferences. And international mediation frequently treats community representatives as expressing relatively unified collective interests, and I think this can obscure important political diversity and narrow the perceived space for negotiations. Crucially, ethnic identity can constrain political preferences without determining a single preferred constitutional solution. So where does this leave us? Citizens share important institutional priorities, but genuine constitutional disagreements do remain. An agreement on individual questions doesn't necessarily translate into agreement on an entire constitutional settlement. And this is what our next stages of research will investigate and do investigate, which comprehensive constitutional packages citizens are willing to accept, and how do they respond when they're confronted with those findings. Let me conclude with three broader lessons I see for international peacebuilding from our research. First, we shouldn't assume political elites represent the full diversity of preferences within their communities. Second, shared expectations of fair, accountable, and effective institutions offer an important foundation for political progress, even where disagreements over the distribution of power persist. And third, citizen participation should not end with consultation. Citizens need opportunities to confront alternatives, to consider trade-offs, and engage with evidence about what others in their society actually want. So recentering citizens does not mean pretending that political divisions have disappeared. It does mean refusing to let those divisions define the entirety of what is politically possible. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, Dr. Glaudisch. I would now like to turn it over to Dr. Catherine Panter-Brick and Dr. David Simon. There's a button.
It's on. Thank you, Professor Glaudisch. Good morning, Excellencies, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen joining us online. I'm really honored to present our research this morning with my colleague, Dr. David Simon, and I thank both our host and co-host for this session. Let me start with summarizing how our two research studies complement each other. The Consent BIH study, which you've just heard from our colleagues from University of Luxembourg, asked the question, what do citizens want from the constitutional order? Our study, called Building Cooperation from the Yale Jackson School and Institute for Development Impact, asks, how does cooperation work in practice and where does it lose force? So what we're here doing is documenting citizens' constitutional preferences and everyday cooperation across ethnic and political division within the system. I want to emphasize that this work emerges from this wonderful innovative research partnership between Yale's Jackson School of Global Affairs, the Institute for Development Impact, with our university partners in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and with support from the United States Bosnia and Herzegovina Exchange Council. So I will name our colleague, Mark Norkic, Andrea Pozderac, Zinana Sabit Hamidovic, Amia Kachapal, Anan Hadrovic, especially as being the force behind the work. This slide shows our policy brief, published in 2026, with our key research question. And I want to show you who we spoke with, people from the armed forces, from the business sector, from academia, from civil society, and from the diaspora, along with officials working on the country's accession to the European Union. And I think here, If you retain one fact, it's the breadth that matters from these different sectors to understand in each how does cooperation work in practice, in each where does it lose force, and above all, where we can act. So we have three main findings. Cooperation already happens and its conditions are clear. The points where progress stalls are identifiable. And there's room to act within the system, within existing authority. Just as their excellencies emphasize at the beginning, you know, the first point is really important. One of the most rewarding parts of our research has been hearing from people who are already making cooperation work in practice, and their experiences deserves much attention, particularly when you're talking about the country's future. So, when while public and political debate in Bosnia and Herzegovina centers on division, people routinely work, trade, research, and solve problems across political, ethno-national, and generational lines. I want to focus on our first two sectors, the armed forces and business, to ask what makes cooperation last. And the people we interviewed for this research told us that it depends on two major factors, two conditions that have to work together. Mutual reliance, i.e., partners that have a clear reason to cooperate and work together. and authority and support to carry that work forward. Within the armed forces, we find that both mutual reliance and authority and support are there together because there is personnel from across the country serving with one institution, one mission, one chain of command, and shared professional standards. So, for example, a senior officer told us that he works every day with colleagues around different parts of the country. without difficulty, because the mission is clear. It is clearing mines from an area. It is disaster or flood responses. And the safety of one person depends on the judgment of the person that's next to them. So they are working together. And there are laws of defense and laws on service in the armed forces that set common rule for everyone. Within business, you have also mutual reliance. People we interviewed stressed that cooperation is routine, actively chosen. There's a clear commercial reason to cooperate regardless of political relationships across jurisdictions. Firms in Sarajevo and Banja Luka will form consortia when they need each other's expertise. As one business participant put it, Cooperation becomes surprisingly easy when people have a serious project in front of them, with a deadline, nobody around the table has time to ask who belongs to which ethnic or political group. We just get on with the work. Finally, let's look at two case studies to understand when reform happens, why you can get two different outcomes. Efforts to reform the armed forces and the police in Bosnia and Herzegovina have required political agreement over how power could be distributed. Amongst the armed forces on the left, the 2005 Defense Force reform created a single chain of command at the top, where commanders could assign personnel, set tasks, and inform standards such that cooperation became routine down the chain of command. Police restructuring, however, went differently. Reforms required moving legislative and budgetary control to the state levels, and because there was no agreement, negotiations stalled, and the country's first formal agreement with the European Union was delayed. So basically, in the armed forces, you had a common structure that enabled cooperation, but within policing, authority remained contested. And that explains why these two, in these two case studies, why the second condition, authority and support, matters just as much as mutual reliance on personnel to build and sustain cooperation. And I now hand over to my colleague, Dr. Simon.
Thank you. Thank you very much, Catherine, and I'll echo you in thanking everyone who's here, the the distinguished guests, our colleagues who we're presenting with, and all of those who've taken some time out of their day to listen to us. I'll continue in the same vein and talk a little bit more in detail about some of our research findings, particularly on this question of the nature of cooperation within different sectors. In academia, we found many examples of cooperation that befit the standards of the profession. People teaching across universities, research collaboration, mentorship across universities, the way it works worldwide. But there were also limits in some instances where faculty members felt less supported by their administration. and that they felt it was difficult to reach the public with their research. So much work goes into creating research, and often there's not the opportunity, such as we're enjoying here, to disseminate results. Civil society, perhaps, is a even more clear example. Civil society in Bosnia and Herzegovina is rich and well-developed. The example that we like to draw on was that of youth clubs in Brcko, where local organizations that had been developed, perhaps prior to the conflict in the '90s, revived and with local support, sorry, with international support, were able to essentially institutionalize themselves, even resulting in the formation of a law on local communities which in some sense, I think, reflects what Her Excellency ASG Bleecker suggested, was that it might be a model for the social contract in contemporary times. And then there's the diaspora, another sector of society, if you will, not obviously by definition, not in the country itself, but comprising as many as Over 2 million people, which is two-thirds the size of the population in the country, ready to help, but often lacking the recognition or the institutional interface that might allow them to participate in everyday affairs and to cooperate in everyday affairs. We, from these different sectors, we're able to draw some conclusions about where cooperation also loses force. One of them is when there's a change in the political backing that at some point underlay cooperation. Perhaps the fruits of cooperation were not appreciated. When that happens, those that are cooperating shrink into a shell without the support that they need. External decision making can be another roadblock for sustaining cooperation. For example, the European accession process. sort of stumbled on the determinative nature of implementing the Sajak-Finchy findings, which require the implementation of a constitutional change that was effectively rejected by veto players and on that particular issue, resulting in a larger stumbling block for accession plans. And in fact, related to that, related to the issue of European accession, is the loss of over 100 million euros in growth plan support that was withdrawn by the failure for Bosnia and Herzegovinian negotiators or to even field a negotiator and to hold up their end of the process. This is an example of where cooperation might have happened, and its failure to be realized resulted in real consequences. There is much more at risk at the end of this year. The loss of funding or the loss of knowledge of cooperation is something else that undermines that process. We found this one example, there's an example in the EU, but another example is within the military where generational concerns arose, where military members who have cooperated for 30 years under the Dayton framework and along the lines that my colleague Dr. Panter-Brick has described, are reaching a retirement age. Those that are coming in behind them have had a different experience. They haven't had the experience of the immediate Dayton settlement area. They may have had an experience or may have grown up in some sense a more divided society than the pre-conflict. certainly than the pre-conflict society that that older generation had. And so it's uncertain times whether or not this new generation in the military context will be able to sustain the cooperation that has characterized the military to this case. I'd like to turn to some of the recommendations that we have resulting from our research. The first is that I think it's really important to recognize that there is a desire for cooperation out there, cooperation broadly in many senses, and that desire is broad. The first step is simply to recognize that it exists. Second step is to be cognizant of what enables cooperation and what blocks cooperation, and particularly with respect to the role of formal authorities. When cooperation is blocked, where authority that fosters cooperation is blocked, there needs to be some sort of effort to maintain that space in which cooperation can continue. Cooperation, I see, as something of a journey, that, like peace itself, it needs to be built. It needs to be allowed to build upon itself as the American political scientist Robert Axelrod describes in The Evolution of Cooperation. And it takes some effort to sustain it. Cooperation craves continuity. It doesn't handle ruptures all that well because it is based on habits, habits of the heart, in the words of another scholar. It falters when it's blocked. It falters when it is neglected. So I think that the, we'll add that there is a space for a durable counterpart in terms of diaspora engagement. The diaspora is not always unified, it doesn't always cooperate, but in some ways, it's been less subjected to some of the winds of division that, such as divided schools or segmented local media that characterize the political environment locally, political and educational environment locally. So it's a real resource that needs to be supported and brought into the cooperation scenario. If I can say a final word on these topics, I'd return to the concept of veto holders, those individuals and organizations who reject the vision of pluralism and multiculturalism that, as my colleague from the University of Luxembourg has described, is widely held by a majority of the people who responded to their survey. The veto holders reject that pluralism, multiculturalism. They should not be determinative of Bosnia and Herzegovina's future simply because they have access to points of power, to the media. Instead, I think we have to find ways to make this everyday cooperation visible, to find ways that this institution, that is to say the United Nations and others, including the European Union, can appreciate that there's a certain momentum in cooperation that is desirable to support, and that to invest in building it will create a fruitful partnership and can create a constituency for peace and a culture of peace, as Her Excellency ASG Spahar has mentioned earlier. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Dr. Simon and Dr. Panter-Brick for all your work and what you continue to do, and also for highlighting the ways to make everyday cooperation visible. I think that will be especially important as we go further into the discussion. And that's a nice segue into the next portion. of this roundtable is the Student Peace Declaration, which will be presented by Mr. Imran Basalic. You have the floor. Thank you.
Your Excellencies, professors, dear friends, ladies and gentlemen, I'll be speaking about an idea coming from Sarajevo, a local idea, but that began and resulted as a European movement. So what is the Student Peace Declaration? Well, it was idea of mine and two of my friends, Mumin and Riad, that we must gather all student representatives from all eight public universities in Bosnia and Herzegovina, from different entities in Bosnia and Herzegovina. We presented idea to them, universities and students from those universities, to our rector, Professor Dr. Tarik Zaimovic, who supported us during this work. And they all accepted our proposal to sign this document. But then we realized that this story cannot be just local story, it has to be much more, because peace is not just local story, not even regional. We said to each other, we need peace globally. At that moment, this idea evolved, and later on it was presented to EU Peace Alliance. which University of Sarajevo became part of. So the initiative was then embraced by students within EU Peace Alliance and launched on 17 September in Sarajevo, 2025. And what began as a University of Sarajevo initiative has since grown into European student movement with more than 156 signatory parties. EUPs gave this idea a unique environment in which to grow. The Alliance brings together nine universities in seven countries, representing more than 200,000 students and around 15,000 researchers. This declaration is also supported by ten European University Alliances and by the European Student Union, whose national member organisations represent approximately 20 million students across Europe. So as you can see on the following footages from the signing event in General Assembly of Bosnia and Herzegovina, which was set on fire during the aggression on Bosnia and Herzegovina, later renewed and gathered all the youth from Bosnia and Herzegovina, but also from Europe, to sign a document to send a peace message to the world with all prior stories coming from that building. So our stating message is simple. A local idea from Sarajevo has become a European movement, and peace is not inherited. Every generation has to build it and pass on to future generations. But the important question for us today is not how many organizations signed this document. The real question is what happened after the signature. First, student voice became more structural. Students now have formal channels into EUP's governance. and strategic discussions. Second, action has resources. Through EUP student challenges, students can develop cross-university projects and receive up to 8,000 euros per project. And also, the student challenges has developed further to ensure that at least two student organizations must work on that project from two different universities, so it is something that is That is, connecting students from different universities from EU Peace Alliance. Third, cross-border projects are already happening. Initiatives such as EU Voice, eUnited, EcoJustice, Scroll to Social, and Exchange to Engage demonstrate how students from different universities can work together around shared social challenges. And fourth, the declaration has developed a public life through institutional presentations and public dialogue. We should be precise, not all of these activities were created by declarations, but all of them were affected by it. But they demonstrate that EUPs already provides the network, partners, and resources through which the values of the declarations can become an action. The effort is therefore not simply a document. It is the beginning of a student action ecosystem. Turning peace into practice, the next question of our idea is how we can make it sustainable. This declaration gives us the direction: peace, dignity, inclusive societies, academic freedom, the right to study, and the students as agents of change. EUPs already provides three important channels through which these values can move into practice. In education, through the European track as a interdisciplinary certificate with around 220 courses and modules open across disciplines, values can become competencies. Student life, through the student associations, student council, and student challenges, student voice can become concrete projects and students can co-create solutions. And the social dialogue, through living peace labs in partnership with civil society and public authorities, these values can be beyond the university and can be tested in the communities. Making peace, lasting commitment. At the same time, we should be very clear about what is not yet strong enough. We do not yet have systematic monitoring of what all signatories did and are still doing after the signing. We do not yet have a recurring Bosnia and Herzegovina-wide program under the declaration. Its principles do not yet reach all academic disciplines equally. And continuity can still depend too much on individual students or individual projects. Instead of hiding these gaps, we want to turn them into commitments. Our proposal is to create a recurring annual cycle every 17th September in Sarajevo. And we call it four A's. First, assemble the signatories, the initially 103. until this today 156 and all the others that will come. Second, analyze what has been achieved, what all these universities in a specific way did in their own surroundings, in their own countries, their own academia. Third, adopt common student priorities and demands. And fourth, act through projects, partnerships, and advocacy direct towards universities, government, European institutions and international organizations such as this. Alongside this, we want to build a Bosnia and Herzegovina peace network, bringing students from different communities together, develop peace in my profession, regardless of what the profession is, showing how these principles relate to health care, public space, technology, and disinformation, and create continuity through the institutional co-ownership. Hand over the recurring support. Our concrete target is a joint student activity across Bosnia and Herzegovina by spring 2027, because durable cooperation requires more than enthusiasm. It requires routines, responsibilities, and follow-throughs. From Sarajevo to the United Nations: A Call to Scale. And this brings us from Sarajevo to the United Nations. This declaration has already created a continuity. The next step is to transform the continuity into action and accountability. Our invitation today is simple. Join us, bring universities and student organizations from your countries into growing network, partnership, work with us to transform shared commitments into student-led projects and cross-community cooperation and support help us create the continuity that allows student peace initiatives to survive beyond one event, beyond one generation of students, leaders, or one funding cycle. Because students are not citizens in waiting. They are citizens now, and the peace is not inherited. It is learned, practiced, and handed forward. You can see the QR code for finding our form to apply and to join us to become a member of our EU Peace family, to support our Student Peace Declaration. We have 156 signatories until up to this date, and we are open to accept all the new ones coming that want to come with us in our peace family.
Thank you very much, Imran, for showcasing the importance of the Students' Peace Declaration and how actually can be translated into practical and tangible outcomes. I would also like to thank our esteemed academic panel for your valuable research and for sharing with us today, including your detailed presentations, insightful observations, and most certainly findings. I believe that this opens up a space for really informed dialogue and discussion. reflections on how ordinary citizens, especially young people, can help build lasting peace in societies affected by conflict or perceived divisions or actual divisions. And we can perhaps recognize that peacebuilding becomes more sustainable, as ASG Spehar mentioned, when local communities actively shape the process, rather than relying solely on political leaders. to do so, or international organizations. And with that, it is my great honor to hand over to my fellow co-moderator, Mark Nurkic from Yale University, Peace Building Fellow at the Jackson School of Global Affairs, who will moderate the Q&A session of this roundtable discussion. Mark, over to you.
See if this works. Thank you kindly, Andrea. And thank you very much to all our esteemed and distinguished guests, to our distinguished panelists for their presentations. Before opening the floor to the room and to our colleagues online for questions to our panelists, I'd like to first give the floor to the European Union's delegation. as co-sponsors for today's event. The EU's engagement in Bosnia and Herzegovina, including in the country's accession process, came up many times this morning through our conversations already, and we're deeply grateful for your support for today's event, but also for our continued work in the country and in the region. So please, Mr. Weiler, the floor is yours.
Right, thank you so much. Thank you. I'm Quentin Wheeler, I'm the political coordinator at the EU delegation to the UN. I'll be very brief. I think a lot of things have already been said very eloquently by the ambassador of Bosnia and Herzegovina, by actually all the presenters. I think today's event reminds us of the importance of evidence-based approach. And I think that's the critical element of this very interesting event, because we've heard very different perspectives and very interesting perspectives about the perspective of the citizens. And I think Andrea just mentioned it, the idea that political progress cannot be made from above. It has to be made with citizens, hearing about citizens, what they experience in order to be able to build ways forward collectively. And so for the EU, the concept of like nationally owned peacebuilding is absolutely critical. Inclusive institutions are not only a governance objective, they are a peacebuilding imperative. So institutions that are impartial, that are responsive to citizens, that are accountable, help build trust across divisions and create the conditions for durable progress. And this is why the EU's engagement in Bosnia and Herzegovina is also about supporting civil society in its different shapes and forms, whether it is academia, community actors, diaspora, youth delegates and youth initiatives, in order to keep that cooperation alive very much. And so that includes, obviously, listening to young people. And it was very interesting to listen to the last intervention, because those youthless engagement is really about building the future. And from our perspective, Bosnia and Herzegovina's future is within the European Union. That's why it's so important to listen to these kind of initiatives in order to be able to build bridges across communities and across countries, really, which is the European Union's DNA. And through the Generation Change program, the EU in Bosnia and Herzegovina is engaging students from all public universities in the country to discuss the EU's accession process, the reforms, and all issues that matter to young citizens, whatever they are, in order to be able to, again, build those bridges that are absolutely necessary to then build a common narrative on the future of Bosnia and Herzegovina. So supporting these initiatives, citizens-led initiatives, youth-led initiatives, are really central to our engagement in Bosnia and Herzegovina, and I'm very grateful to be part of this event. And for us, it was obvious that the EU had to co-sponsor it and to be able to listen to the voices of the different actors, but also of the countries in the room and the participants in the room. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Wheeler, for your intervention. I don't know. Thank you, Mr. Wheeler, for your intervention. It would be my honor to open the floor for questions for our esteemed panelists to the room and online. I'd like to ask you to introduce yourself when you're making your intervention, your affiliation, and please, if you could keep your intervention brief, just so that we might be able to hear from as many participants as possible. Indeed, today's event is intended as a roundtable discussion, and so we'd really value to hear any insights from people and the varied perspectives that we have among us here today. To begin, perhaps, professor Kemal Juric, the Vice Rector of the University of Sarajevo, as independent academic institutions, perhaps it'd be interesting to understand how universities and academia as a whole, as a sector within Bosnia and Herzegovina, can play a role in recentering citizens in these important topics, also as an alternative institutional pathway for much of the progress and change that we're perhaps discussing today. So if you have Something on that note.
Thank you, Mark, for your question. Your Excellencies, distinguished ambassadors, distinguished representatives of the United Nations, dear organizers, esteemed professors, dear colleagues, ladies and gentlemen, on behalf of the rector of the University of Sarajevo, Professor Tarik Zaimovic, and on my own behalf, I would like to extend our warm greetings to all of you. And I also would like to express our sincere gratitude to the organizers for this opportunity. to share the experience of the University of Sarajevo and our commitment to peace, justice, inclusion, and the broader development of our society. It is a particular honour to contribute to this important discussion here at the United Nations. And now, coming back to your question, Mark, there is an important connection between the two studies presented today that I would like to overview from the point of view of the higher education, from the point of view of the universities. And actually, we heard today that Luxembourg research shows that despite the political and constitutional disagreements, citizens across Bosnia and Herzegovina share fundamental expectations regarding peace, equal rights, fair institutions. And the Yale research actually demonstrates that cooperation across divisions and is already taking place, but also reminds us that cooperation needs institutional, of course, support and continuity to become sustainable. That is the magic word, I mean, sustainable. So for me, these findings raise an important, really an important question. What responsibility do university have in preparing the next generations to build on this shared values? As a university professor, I believe our responsibility goes far beyond on educating competent professionals. We must also educate responsible citizens. So future doctors, pharmacists, engineers, teachers, they have to understand the importance of ethics, human dignity, inclusion, and cooperation. And peace building should not be limited to those who study peace and conflict. It should become part of education across all academic disciplines. We heard that as one of the aims of our EU Peace Declaration. So this is precisely where I see, actually, the potential of the Students' Peace Declaration and our EU Peace Alliance. So providing students and not only students, but researchers and our academic community, opportunity to turn these principles into shared experience and concrete actions. So our challenge is not only to help our societies to overcome existing divisions, but also to educate generations capable of preventing the new ones. So this is the first thing. And if you allow me just to make another reflection, actually, Over the past, I could say, two decades, our universities actually, thanks to European and international programs, our university have developed remarkable institutional capacities. And through our participation in European University Alliance, EUP's alliance, actually, we are no longer simply, let's say, beneficiaries of international cooperation. We are increasingly becoming co-creators in the European Higher Education Area. But I see an important challenge emerging, and we all see in Bosnia and Herzegovina this, all, let's say, major universities. So in some respects, the institutional capacities of our universities are developing faster than the capacities of the wider national level institutions. And now, the question that actually is rising up of our, what should be the next responsibility of our university is actually that we must move building capacities within individual universities to using those capacity to strengthen the institutions and system around us. So that is the next challenge, as I see it, for our universities, those to use our capacity, develop capacities, to build our national system level capacities. And to be able to do this, There is an important things we have to mention here, and we have to, I am trying to find the best word to see how to not to say to, how can I say, not to ask our governments, but that is to respect what they commit, what they committed by signing and by undersigning the Rome communique in 2020, and with that communique also Bosnia and Herzegovina, our government, actually, they committed that we will respect the academic freedom and the university independence. That is the really necessary precondition if we want the university to be able to build what we are talking about and to act as an academic community. So let's say one let's say, important reflections that I would like to underline. I have some concrete, if we will have later time, I can also give you an example of where university at the level of the Bosnia and Herzegovina organize themselves to act and to promote, I mean, to act, to build this system level. I mean, this is, I can also tell you briefly if I already have a word, and that is actually the question of the participation of Bosnia and Herzegovina into JAND. And the JAND, actually, for many years, our country has struggled to establish a national research and education network needed to join JAND. And the JAND is the European Research Education Network Community. And over the past two years, universities across the country have organized themselves and submitted the application for membership through the Rector's Conference. And now we hope this finally allows our academic and research community to benefit fully from the European Research Infrastructure. And I would like to underline that Bosnia and Herzegovina is the only one country in Europe that is not a member of this prestigious association at the European level. This is also a really concrete example that illustrates an important principle: universities should not only wait for the national system to develop, they should actively contribute to their development. Thank you.
Thank you, Professor Drulic, and perhaps to the panelists, to pose a question on this very topic. You've discussed today the shared goals and cooperation that's witnessed at the micro level across Bosnia and Herzegovina, which lie in want of an institutional home. So perhaps these alternative pathways and alternative institutions to maybe the more public and government sectors, such as academia, what role might they play in not perhaps offering an alternative, but also as a model for shaping these new public institutions as a way to produce the outcomes, especially among younger generations that are educating themselves as future professionals. Perhaps to Mr. Juric's points, if you might have any comments in terms of this academic cooperation. And perhaps also across seas, we've worked together at Yale with the University of Luxembourg and the University of Sarajevo so successfully in these projects. What might that hold for the future?
Thank you, Mac. I'll take that. First of all, I'd like to really thank you for your remarks. I found myself taking notes and cheering at the same time, because I think that's exactly the message about the role that universities can play as agents of not just beneficiaries of cooperation, but agents of fostering cooperation. And so per the question, that there is such, because of those sort of professional proclivities to cooperate among academics, because of the way that different universities are pursuing knowledge, seeking answers to the same questions, and working together to do it. That's how academia works and how it works best. It's a natural place for this type of cooperation to really flourish, and I really welcome the efforts like those at the University of Sarajevo to foster that environment. And I think it is a leading light within Bosnia and Herzegovina to foster more cooperation, to inspire more institutions to join them, I think that part may not be so hard. But also to stand as a sort of a beacon or an example within the broader government structure of here is how cooperation works. For those who might be afraid of it, don't be afraid of it. There are real benefits. to cooperation and that the essential work is to convince the state, perhaps, of its – as you said it very nicely – of the benefit of sticking to its commitments that have already been made. to create that sort of cooperation. And as to the overseas element, I think absolutely. I think that I’ve found – we’ve found in our visits to Sarajevo really fruitful opportunities, even just to start our work. And I hope there’s a lot more to come from that.
Thank you, Dr. Simon. Before proceeding with other questions, we'd like to turn to the Member States and the delegates from the Member States that are here in the room to ask if they have any interventions on these topics. Please, if you could just introduce yourself and your affiliation. Thank you.
Thank you. My name is Hrvoje Curić. I'm the Hrvatinic. I'm the Chargee of the Mission of Croatia here. I don't have a written statement, so forgive me for meandering a bit. Thank you, Zlatko, for organizing this, Luxembourg and the EU for co-sponsoring, especially to the student association for coming up with your declaration and for all of your valuable work, really. Appreciate it. A friend of mine, she's a photographer, and her crown jewel of her work was the work that she had on macro focus. She would do extreme close-up macros of a kiwi or a strawberry or an ant, and you would never guess that it's a kiwi. It looks like just like a tiny bit of hair or something. You wouldn't guess that it's a fruit with green stuff inside it. Actually, that's the point of the kiwi. And on the other hand, This conversation today reminded me of this, the British mathematician, John Conway. I don't know if, I used to love math a lot. Conway was famous for zooming out of problems. So he would solve most of his problems just by extreme zoom out. And something that looked really complex and un-understandable looking close in, when you zoom out, it makes sense, or he would find a way to solve it. And the two extremes, in fact, show the points of view that we have on most of our cultural societal problems as well in political science. In this case, we can look at it in a micro individual level or at a macro constitutional peoples, national groups levels. And the results differ as to where we put the focus of our lens. And it's a very delicate game. It's not a game for show. And I'm not surprised that the youth have called out for more effective institutions, because I think the same answer we would get from the youth in Tehran, in Zagreb, in Tokyo, in Sarajevo, or in or in Rome, we all want more effective institutions, but we also want the institutions that are at the same time just or transparent, accountable, and formed to serve a certain political or social, cultural environment where we live. I don't know how the institutions imposed by the UK in India looked like. Maybe they were effective or not, I don't know, but I'm pretty sure that the local population disagreed with the fact that they have such institutions. So institutions have to reflect on certain reality, and that's why we have in Canada, our fellow diplomats here, they would, while representing their country and the institutions that they work for, the Foreign Affairs Ministry, they would speak part of their statement would be in English, part in French, not to show us that they can do that, but to reflect the reality of their own country. and as a token of cooperation or stability. And you, sir, you mentioned that the most of the youth that you've spoken with actually agreed on the need for more political stability, and it was a peace and stability was the highest ranking agreement between all of them, which shows how important this is still in everyday life. My question would be, is how do you, because you're all political scientists here, and aside from this, what we've observed now, which I think most of us would agree even before we saw the results, that people would want to cooperate, and then on the micro level, people will always reach out to their neighbor. What, as political scientists, would you see as an ideal focusing distance between this the need to have more effective institutions and at the same time reflect the realities of the country and of the society we're talking about, especially considering the fact that you mentioned that agreement and peace and stability is of the highest importance, and what we have here is a constitution which was made as a peace agreement, so it's not just a minor chat we had in the history. Thank you.
Thank you for your intervention and for your question. Professor Glavcic, you have the floor.
Thank you very much. Thank you to my compatriot for his question. Reality has various components. So it is possible in the Bosnian reality or reality of any post-conflict society for there to be part of the reality that says, We are very unhappy with what this state system, constitutional system, is producing on a daily basis. But at the same time, for the element of that reality to be, oh yeah, but we actually do feel dominantly as a community that is defined in ethnic terms or religious terms, and we want protections of that as well. And as in anything in life, the question is where to find the balance so that you can get collective protections, and you can get a functional government. Now, the thing is, and I really like your perspective of what is the proper perspective here. There's a wonderful little documentary that they always show in American high schools. I think it's called The Power of Ten. where you zoom in to the 10 to the minus whatever power, right? And then you zoom out to the 10 to the plus whatever power, right? That's a great little documentary, which film, which I guess gets at, and only at that middle level do we see humanity, do we see the Earth the way we perceive it, right? Anyway, long story short. Dayton was fit for purpose in 1995 and maybe several years after that. I think everybody at that time understood we are going to have to build on this as the country develops. Question is, do the institutions built by Dayton fulfill the purpose of a modern society that should, hopefully will, become member of the European Union? I would say that the overwhelming majority of Bosnian citizens regardless of what their ethnicity is, would say no. They might disagree on how it fails, but I don't think any, very few people would say, like, this is good. Yeah. So then the challenge is where to find that balance. And I would say that if I was a peace builder who's going to go into the field and try to say, okay, well, how do we build something better? I think the right way forward, whether one as a member of the EU delegation or United Nations mission or whatnot, or just as academics would be, okay, well, what is in this Venn diagram of our individual views and community views, where do we meet? And there's a lot where they do meet. Is it possible to build a multi-ethnic setup that can Not necessarily guarantee, but can improve on judicial independence, can improve on accountability, public accountability, can improve on prosecutors' independence. I think so. And I think that would be, so if I was looking for ways to improve on the system that can perhaps foster cooperation, can bring people together and say, actually, why don't we talk about the things where we do agree? and try to fix those things, and we'll see where life takes us after that. That's, I guess, how I would start.
Thank you, Professor. Dr. Pinterbrick.
Thank you very much for that. So I have to admit, I am an anthropologist, not a political scientist, so I always bring two pairs of glasses to any meeting. One is to see far, and one is to see close. So that's my contribution for today. But I think that we have tools, both quantitative and surveys and qualitative and narratives, to understand where patterns of agreements and patterns of disconnect happen. And that's exactly the job of researchers, is to find evidence about where people agree and disagree, for why and what point, et cetera. For moving forward, I always think it's a really shocking evidence that adults realize that young people don't see the world the same way as they do. And I think that's one of the ways we can talk about disagreement and agreement in a much more productive way. Because if in my family, my sons and daughters think differently than I, I have to come to cooperation and resolution in some way because they're family, and you said peace families are families. So I put, as an anthropologist from working at the bottom kind of thing, grassroots, I put a lot of stake about how it, how the everyday family will meet that challenge of new generations coming in and that pattern of disagreement. And if, hopefully, if you look at your families, you know that that happens all the time. So to echo this, the big finding of the political scientists is that where people agree and disagree, we have the tools to actually find you know, the spaces of disconnects which are surprising to people, I think, and the spaces of agreement and how to pivot people from one to the other. Does that make sense? Thank you.
Thank you so much, Catherine. Perhaps before we proceed with the next line of questions, we'll collect two or three from the room and online. Miss Com, online, I see you have your hand raised, if you could. please introduce yourself and ask your question. Thank you.
Yeah, thank you so much. Evelyn Korn, I'm the chair of the governing board of EUPs and sitting in Marburg at the moment. So I'm a part of Marburg University. And I'm really grateful to the encouragement I've received from the two scientific studies we've heard. So one is Academia is still one spot of cooperation because we work with shared values and shared ideas on moving forward, whatever forward might be. And I've heard that people have a lot in common across ethnic groups and maybe are not as homogeneous as they might look like by their political representation. This is a lot of encouragement for the work that we do in EUPs, and I have heard a lot of support for what our student community does in connecting to each other, getting into exchange, and asking for institutions that save a peaceful environment for their futures. And now I'm wondering, if I look at current political movements, the European Union is discussing their next financial frame, and the financial support for academia and student movement is at risk of shrinking. At the same time, we are seeing that frontiers are closing again and people cannot move around, so it is even more difficult to get people into exchange and contact. And that's what I took from all the presentations, that it is so important to get people talk to each other, keep them talk to each other. And so I have two sets of the same question with two aspects. One is for the representatives of the European Union, what would you recommend to academia to show the importance of supporting our youth and having a voice and being able to connect to each other, being able to travel across Europe? And the other one is to the colleagues, what would you recommend us to raise our voices in favor of these questions?
Thank you, Ms. Kumm. And it's wonderful to hear that there's a lot of parallels between your work in Europe and the work that we've spoken about here today. Ms. Chizmich, I think you also had your hand raised online.
Yes. Good morning, good afternoon. My name is Uma Chizmich. I'm a high school student at Wakefield High School in Arlington, Virginia. And my question for all of the panelists, but specifically Mr. Pashalic, is, considering yesterday's election results in Serbia, in what ways do you think this might impact cooperation initiatives in Bosnia and Herzegovina? And also, do you believe that the way in which these results were obtained through a youth mobilization may affect the political efficacy of students and youth in Bosnia and Herzegovina?
Thank you, Ms. Chismich. In the room here, sir.
Hi.
I'm Tom. No organizational affiliation, but it was a pleasure to read your research. So I do have a question for Professor Simon and Professor Van den Brak. You talk. Is there a mic? Oh, is there a mic?
Sure.
Thank you.
Thank you. You talk a lot about institutional handoffs and mapping authority. So I'm just very interested in how do you manage that? How do you distinguish between scenarios where it is actual coordination that is affecting the handoffs between organizations? It might be different administrations going in after each other versus deliberate political obfuscation of handoffs and communication between different government organizations, even, you know, let's say like one party controls it, one another party controls another, and they refuse to communicate, which then sort of brings us to a lack of coordination hands up between them, which then leads to, you know, ordinary citizens trying to start businesses or cooperate on a bottom-up level, getting the short end of the stick. Thank you.
Finicky. Thank you. Thank you so much. And I believe there's one more question online from Ms. Avdagic Fumari.
Yes. Hi. My name is Jasmine Avdagic Fumari. I represent 5 million friends of Bosnia and Herzegovina. I'm their association ambassador for literature and education. speaking for 5 million friends of Bosnia and Herzegovina, a diaspora association that brings together people of Bosnian and Herzegovinian origin around shared commitment to the country, regardless of their background. I'm kind of echoing Ms. Cheesman, what she said. Last night's election in our neighboring country shows something that this research also found. If I remember in a constant study, a young participant in Sarajevo pointed to the Belgrade's protests as a proof that their citizens stood up together against the government and still nothing changed. So yesterday, a movement led by students and centered on accountability, corruption, and independent institution drew record turnout. So those are the same priorities as citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina ranked first in independent courts and priorities as the citizens of Bosnia and Herzegovina, and of corruption. And in Bosnia and Herzegovina, though, as the Yale study shows, citizens' demands must pass through many layers of authority. So my question is, demands for accountability and independent institutions have such broad support across ethnic lines. But what would it take within Bosnia and Herzegovina's divided structure to turn that shared demand into institutional change rather than frustration, and how young people and how we from diaspora can help to carry it out? Thank you.
Thank you so much. And one more question from Professor Pettigrew online, and then we'll turn to our panelists.
Oh, thank you. Thank you very much, Mac. I apologize that I was unable to attend the first hour of the meeting because I was teaching my class, and today we were discussing the Srebrenica genocide. So it was an important day. But I wanted to ask briefly that the European Court of Human Rights has determined that the concept of constituent peoples in the Dayton Constitution while perhaps necessary to end a brutal conflict marked by genocide, cannot be objectively justified in today's democratic society, as it results in discrimination based on ethnicity. The Court expected that democratic arrangements would be made without delay. Briefly, the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights has expressed deep concerns that the judgments of the Court have not been implemented and emphasized that it was essential for the authorities to focus on building a state based on the equality of citizens. So my question is that this inaction has further entrenched ethnic divisions, this inaction by the EU has further entrenched ethnic divisions and nationalist ideologies, divisions and ideologies that threaten a repetition of the atrocities we saw recently, the glorification of Ratko Mladic in Serbia and also calls for a third entity in Bosnia. So my question is, if we share the respect for the rule of law, why have the Office of the EU Commissioner for Enlargement, members of the European Parliament, or appropriate EU leadership not facilitated the democratic constitutional reforms expected by the European Court of Human Rights? Why have they not worked expeditiously with citizens groups, leadership groups such as Krug 99 in Sarajevo, Association of Intellectuals, or as well as with the Venice Commission to prepare a draft of a constitution that would support a stable democratic future with equality of citizens and guaranteeing human rights for all, again, under the rule of law. So I appreciate the opportunity, distinguished participants, to pose my question. Thank you.
Thank you, Professor Pettigrew. In light of time, that will be the last question we'll take today. Now, we have an abundance of very interesting questions, but first, we'd like to turn to the delegation from the European Union with the first question about what kinds of support, how they would like to give support to academia and what kinds of questions academia should be asking on these very important topics.
Thank you for the question. I'll be very brief. The European Union is supporting many initiatives of reinforcing links between academia in Bosnia and Herzegovina and in the European Union and beyond as a vehicle precisely to be able to bring that political discussion to also the political leaders, because that's the important thing, is to be able to reinforce the link between academia and the decision makers, so to say. So I think we have a number of initiatives that help to cross-fertilize the type of research that's being made and be able to relay those messages to the decision-makers. So I think, I mean, the studies that we've heard today are examples of this kind of contribution to the type of discussion that should be brought to decision-makers in order to build then discussions for the future. I think there are very interesting points that were made, including on the, you know, the professor from Luxembourg mentioned the viability of the Dayton Agreement. It's a very difficult difficult question to ask, and yet a question that many constituencies in Bosnia and Herzegovina are asking. So I think the idea of the European Union is really to bring about support to these initiatives and the different funding initiatives that can bring about that discussion to the public. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Wheeler. To our panelists, again, we have many wonderful questions. If we don't have the opportunity to answer those questions today, we'd like to encourage you to reach out to the panelists directly, which we'll share after the meeting. But if there is a question that was listed that anyone would like to answer, particularly, Mr. Glavac, you have the floor.
I'd like to answer the last question with Professor Pettigrew. I guess the answer The student movement in Belgrade probably, in Serbia, could probably answer it very well. I mean, when they came to the European institutions and to European politicians to talk about possible support for their movement, tough, yeah. There's been generally in the West, and particularly in, yeah, different quarters in Europe, thinking that someone can deliver, as long as someone delivers stability, that's good, yeah. And then there was, related to that, the feeling that, well, we will deliver for these 52% of the respondents in our survey who said peace and stability. There you go. We've had peace and stability for the past 30 plus years, right, in Bosnia and Herzegovina. So success, right? So, and this thinking is, you know, deeply prevalent in the way that the Western Europe particularly views, and not only Western Europe, but the West in general, views Southeast Europe that isn't member of the European Union yet, still. I think very many people are simply thinking, as long as you can deliver on stability, that's fine. You don't necessarily need to be committed, yeah, wink, wink. to the right, to the norms that we say that we support. So I would say that, you know, to make the long story short, you know, it's basically because there you go. It delivered on peace and stability. It's deeply flawed. Every system has built a class of people who do well in it. Yeah. So this system, as dysfunctional as it is, has a class of political leaders within Bosnia and Herzegovina that love it. It works for them. It's great. It's fantastic. And they then project and they say, well, we are delivering peace and stability. And there you go. You end up 30 years later, lifetime passes, and you're living in a dysfunctional country.
Thank you, Mr. Glajic. Unfortunately, for want of time, we'll have to close the formal portion of the Q&A today, but hopefully this is nothing but a beginning of these conversations in light of the research that we've done and the work for Mr. Pasic and the students at the University of Sarajevo. We've approached these questions today as researchers within the setting of a kind of academic form of questioning, but it is now my privilege to turn to someone who has worked on these questions from within the multilateral system, Her Excellency Ambassador Dockendorf, the Permanent Representative of Luxembourg to the United Nations brings her long experience in multilateral cooperation, and her perspective will hopefully take us in this conversation from beyond the single country case study of Bosnia and Herzegovina, but then to the wider question of work in the United Nations and other countries of interest with societies divided as in Bosnia. On behalf of the organizers, I thank the Permanent Mission of Luxembourg for their support and for co-hosting today's discussion. And please, Ambassador, you have the floor. Thank you.
Thank you so much. Thank you to both of our moderators. Thank you to my colleague to have included us in this side event. It's a particular honor for me to be here today because the University of Luxembourg was part of this research. That does not happen every day in these hallways, so it's a real pleasure to be here. I think this was a very rich exchange and not something that can be summed up easily. And I just want to point out a few things that stood out to me and to my colleague, who kept the seat when I had to step out briefly, but I'm happy to have, I think, heard most, except I didn't hear the students. So if you have a moment after the meeting, I'd love to briefly chat. I think it's unusual for us to have academia take center stage at the United Nations, and you said it, Ambassador, at the very beginning. It's really great for us diplomats when we can be grounded in rigorous research and evidence-based perspectives. As you said, sometimes you know these things, but when you have solid evidence to back them up, that makes our work here much easier and keeps us from engaging into too much politicization of our discussion. So thank you very much for bringing this here to us. Thank you also for breaking it down to language and a level of presentation that we can handle. I was a little bit intimidated when I looked at all your papers, and of course, was not able to read them in detail, but thank you for executive summaries, but also for presenting it in such a telling way to all of us here so that we can build on this and take it forward. And as you rightly said, it offered an important perspective on peacebuilding in Bosnia and beyond, and I think there's a lot here that we can apply to to the work we do every day at the UN. I'm taking back that to really understand the opportunities in a country, we have to listen to what the citizens tell us, also take home the generational point. I have three teenagers at home, and, you know, some of the insights can really be applied to any discussion of different viewpoints and where you feel that there's a a big gulf between you sometimes. I think we are well aware of the political complexity of Bosnia. We know it's been 30 years since Dayton, and there are no easy solutions, but the research also underlined that this complexity, that richness actually, is important to push back against the simplistic views that we are often confronted with, and the narratives that ethnocentrist people people push and that then seem insurmountable, but shouldn't be. The findings that you presented give us hope for the future that, yes, political differences are deep and real, but they do not tell the whole story. And there is common ground across many areas, cooperation across those divisions is possible, and you brought up a number of case studies to illustrate this. Somebody said earlier on that peace can be imposed from the top down, but then peace building has to happen from the bottom up and needs to be inclusive. And now we have to build on these common elements to strengthen the relationships and to see where we can go. I wanted to highlight also the role of the youth, of course, but also of women in peacebuilding. It's been said left and right, but it can't be said often enough. This week is WPS, Women, Peace, and Security Week at the UN, so we particularly focused on these matters and on those valuable contributions that women can bring to peacebuilding. I am heartened by the results of the elections in Serbia. Many have said it, I think Mo Blika said it first, and that gives us hope and shows that maybe the effort of the new generation can really guide us in the right direction. I think we are taking all of us Member States back teachings for peacebuilding in the wider sense, and Elizabeth Spear alluded to that. We see the importance of inclusive, nationally-owned peacebuilding that applies to so many conflict or post-conflict situations that we work on. Luxembourg will continue to support this effort of the peoples in Bosnia and Herzegovina. And we really look forward to the next steps. I think you mentioned that this was only the beginning of a collaboration. There's certainly more to come, and it will be interesting to see how this can translate into tangible. Now, the big bank constitution reform has not happened and might not be achievable, but you've shown us so many avenues of where progress progress could happen and then be built upon. So we look forward to hopefully welcome you here again when your next stage of your research is ready. Thank you so much, everyone.
Thank you very much, Ambassador, for your comments and again for co-hosting today's discussion. I have here in my notes the phrase, if there are no more questions, that we should close. Unfortunately, well, rather fortunately, that's not today's challenge. We will have to close now because we're reaching the end of our time, but hopefully today's discussion will serve as a touchpoint for new connections, for new partnerships, and perhaps in the spirit of cooperation, which was, I think, one of today's most emphatic motifs, we can begin to make some connections and look to the future with the results of today's conversation. Thank you, everybody, for today, for the participation in today's engaging discussion. And yeah, thank you so much.
Thank you.