Formulating and implementing national social protection policies in a changing world
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Thanks a lot, everyone, for being back on time. This is really great. We can get started on time. Charles, please, go ahead.
Hello, everyone. I hope you can hear me all right. Welcome back. And yeah, really excited by this first session of the afternoon, which focuses on formulating and implementing national social protection policies in a changing world. So, I mean, I think to frame this, we can actually kind of build on or move on from the, or take the kind of the end point of the last session where Shay ended saying, talked about how we're kind of moving beyond the why of social protection and more to the how and how do we achieve universal social protection. So I think throughout the morning, we heard in depth about, in particular the first sessions, about the why, the importance of social protection for reducing poverty and inequality. fostering inclusion and empowerment, but also linking and supporting through those various different kind of transitions, economic, technological, demographic that the world is facing. Yet, despite that, I guess, growing recognition over the last decades of the role and importance of social protection, we're still very far from universal social protection systems in most countries. We know that almost half the world's population is still not covered by any social protection benefit that was mentioned. So on that basis, one key element to moving forward at the national level is the development of different kind of policies, strategies to advance social protection. And I guess I'd unpack a couple of things which I think are key there and are going to come out in this session. I mean, one thing is really defining, you know, an importance of those policies and strategies is to define a vision, a level of ambition for social protection, what we actually want to achieve to address all of these issues that we know social protection can address, gaining the buy-in and consensus across a range of actors to do that. But also, it's not enough just to have that vision. We need to also set out kind of pathways to achieve it. You know, what are we going to prioritize? How are we going to sequence our way towards universal social protection, particularly given different financing constraints that so many countries face? But equally, what are the kind of institutional arrangements? What are the approaches to delivery? How do we combine tax finance and contributory social protection into a kind of coherent universal system? So this session is going to focus on some of those key points. And what we're going to do is start with hearing about a piece of analysis by the ILO of 52 national social protection policies and strategies. We're then going to have a panel discussion, and I'll introduce our panelists a bit later, or sharing experiences from the panel. Some broader Q&A, and also a bit later, we will have an intervention from colleagues at the colleague from the World Bank who share some of the experiences in this space as well. So I think we can move ahead with our first intervention from Veronica, who you already know well, who's going to share the experience of this piece of analysis.
Thanks a lot, Charles. And I will have a few slides to share, and I'll try to be quick. I can't do justice to the analysis that we've done on those 52 strategies, so this is just a snapshot. As Charles rightly said, we consider national social protection policies or strategies a key planning instrument. In the morning, we've talked a lot about the global constraints. We are now moving down to the national level. What do governments plan to do about extending social protection? So, the 52 strategies that we've analyzed were overwhelmingly from Africa. We've heard those particular challenges this morning that Africa is facing with regards to informality, with regards to low social protection coverage. So maybe it's no surprise that there are a lot of policies and strategies originating from that region. developed an indicator framework of 57 indicators that are based on our ILO standards, the Minimum Social Security Standards Convention 102 and the Social Protection Floors Recommendation 202. around how the policies and strategies were developed, but also their substance, to what extent they pursue a rights-based approach, to what extent they look into adequacy, comprehensiveness of coverage, et cetera, to what extent they look at how to implement this with a sound administration and sustainable financing, and monitor progress. So in terms of how are these policies and strategies developed, there's often not a lot of information in these documents, but often they do list who participated in the process. And we find that international actors are often invited to the table, social partners very rarely so, civil society also quite often. Among the international actors, we see UNICEF very active, representing their strong presence at country level if we look at UN agencies. World Bank as well, and then slightly less so ILO. And I just move straight into the substance. To what extent do they look into adequacy? A lot of these principles, adequacy, comprehensiveness, they are reflected and articulated as an ambition. But we also looked at the extent to which they then plan concrete actions to live up to that ambition. And here we find a lot of the strategies fall short. So even if they acknowledge the importance of adequacy, only eight of the 52 strategies actually found concrete measures to ensure that benefit levels are adequate. And similarly, comprehensiveness, there is a life cycle ambition, for example, but only seven strategies do systematically address comprehensively various risks. If we look more at this attention to the nine life cycle risks, this is, of course, a core part of Convention 102, we find that, again, they are very unequally addressed in the strategies. Children, health care, old age are the three most prominently addressed branches. Sickness and unemployment, but also maternity, around those that have fewer mentions. And only seven, as I said before, mentioned all nine life cycle risks. Sorry. Then a lot of attention also in this morning discussions on covariate shocks. It's not only the idiosyncratic risks, but it's also climate change, natural disasters, et cetera. The vast majority, 49 out of the 52, acknowledge the importance that social protection systems are also ready to respond to these covariate shocks. And then you see on the slide, natural disasters very often, health shocks. I should have said, the policies are from 2011 to 2020, the time that they were adopted. So this was before COVID. So back then, not that many strategies actually also considered epidemic shocks as a covariate shock that are important to address. Then another aspect that we found important to look at is Which barriers do the social protection policies and strategies identify to reaching universal social protection? And here we find that this is something that 49, almost all the strategies look into one barrier or another. For me, surprisingly, only 27 actually mentioned financing as a key barrier. Coordination even comes more often than financing. And then lack of data, there are various others, but they were far fewer. Infrastructure, I mean, there are many different challenges countries and different contexts face, right? And then we look at, I summarize this under the heading of good governance principles, so things like prevention of fraud, having sound complaint and appeal mechanisms so that if people are not able to realize their entitlements, they have a place to go to and complain. These were mentioned in very few of the strategies. Almost all of them had foreseen a system for monitoring and evaluation of progress and of the policy itself, but also of the social protection system. Sound financing was widely acknowledged as a key point, but also participation came very often to ensure participatory processes. So I have to rush through this because I'm running out of time. But to conclude, overall, we found that clearly social protection policies and strategies are important planning tools, but they sometimes lack in clarity of vision, clarity of actually when the vision is articulated, also planning for the sound implementation and identifying concrete steps with concrete targets and timelines to move into implementation. And this is perhaps, I would say, the strongest weakness of a lot of these policies, where perhaps more support is needed. The process matters for national ownership and for implementation, and we've seen a variety of actors being involved or not involved. And so from this, perhaps we can see that it may be important that development partners support these formulation of policies and strategies where needed and when countries seek such support. And with this, I'll stop presenting and hand back to Charles.
Thank you so much. And I think that kind of broad global view sets us up really nicely for the more in-depth kind of country-focused discussion we're going to have over the next few minutes. So to that end, we have four speakers that are joining us today to discuss this on our panel. So I'll just introduce them all and then we can dive into some of the questions. So we have Mr. Chea Vanara, who is the head of the Monitoring and Evaluation Unit at the UHC Secretariat in Cambodia. We have Ms. Smriti Lama, the Secretary General of Foreign Affairs at the General Federation of Nepalese Trade Unions from Nepal. Hopefully as well, we have Mr. Guido Ricchi from the Coordinating Committee of Agricultural, Commercial, Industrial, and Financial Associations in Guatemala. I'm not sure if he's joined online yet. And finally, Ms. Priscilla Gavi, who is the Executive Director of Helped stage in Zimbabwe, but also the chairperson of the Africa Platform for Social Protection. So turning to our first question we had. So Mr. Vonara, Cambodia is an example of a country that's recently adopted the National Social Protection Policy Framework that runs from 2024 to 2035, and that follows on from a similar framework that ran from 2016 to 2025. I'm aware you're the head of the Monitoring Evaluation Unit at the Universal Health Coverage Secretariat in Cambodia. So it'd be great if you could share Cambodia's experience in developing, implementing, and kind of revising, now adopting a new social protection policy framework.
Yeah, thank you. Yeah, I think, first of all, I feel like the jet lag is real. Just to break the silence, dear distinguished participants, organizers, ladies and gentlemen, it's my honor and privilege to represent the Royal Government of Cambodia and National Social Protection Council to participate in this Universal Social Protection Conference in Geneva. Over the last decade, with the visionary leadership of the Royal Government, Cambodia has transformed the National Social Protection Council into a fundamental pillar of human capital development and sustainable economic resilience. Today, I also bring the book of the new policies, which say that the National Social Protection Policy Framework 2024 to 2035. With this year mentioned at the end, we can say that it's an update and also replacing the previous National Social Protection Policy Framework, which I can call short as NSPPF. We can say that it's a paradigm shift, which Meaning that it's a transition from the silo pillar approach to the comprehensive lifecycle risk approach. If I recall it, back in 2022, where we implement the previous policy framework, there is like COVID and global inflation. There is flood. So the previous framework lacked some update, because the previous book was developed in 2016, which we don't take into account much more about the shock or the other system make or individual shock. So this book with the midterm evaluation and input from different stakeholders, both government, civil society, DPs, and implementers, we come up with this new book, a framework which is the fundamental to build social protection in Cambodia. So this new book is to ensure the sustainability of the development for a stronger and more effective and sustainable social protection system which is to ensure that people at all different life cycle can be covered or sealed or protected against the shock or individual shock, a system shock, and which is leaving no one behind. Distinguished guests, ladies and gentlemen, this social protection policy framework, it has, if I would like to highlight a bit more, it has two key seven principles, which I can elaborate as, first of all, which is equity and inclusiveness, adequacy, efficiency, adaptiveness, sustainability, good governance, and gender responsiveness. And the framework can be strengthened through the seven life cycle risks, which are maternity and child risk, health risk, occupational risk, disability, unemployment, homelessness, old age, and survivor. One of the key success of implementing the new framework is the foundation built from the previous framework, which is the good governance of the social protection system, which to ensure to fulfill the function of the government. There are three levels. First of all, is the policy level. which is the, we have the National Social Protection Council to fulfill the function of policy direction and guidance. And we have the regulator level, which to supervise all the social securities and social assistance program. And certainly, we have the operator level. Currently, we have the National Social Security Fund, we have the National Social Assistance Fund. We have the National Payment Certification Agency, and we have the hub operator and sub-national level at the, which is at the provincial or urban or like the sub-national. Yeah, if I'm going to deeper into the how we progress or develop the social protection program, we have expanded from the coverage of around 22% to currently to 50% of the population in the recently in 2026. First of all is the social assistance program. which cover around 28% of the population, meaning that equivalent to 1.81 million population have been covered by the social assistance program, which include the family package, the homegrown school feeding, the technical vocational educational training. We have a helicity fund. We have the cash transfers for pregnant women and young children under until two years old. And also, we have implemented recently, in early 2026, the ID Poor Graduation program as well. For the social securities program, currently, we cover around 3.7 population, which equivalent to around 22% of the total population. There are three main programs in this system implementing at the moment, which is the pension. Pension is for civil servant and employees in the private sector. And secondly, we have the social security on healthcare, which currently cover around 3.7 members. Certainly, we have occupational risk, which is currently cover around 2.6 members in both public and private sectors. Yeah, I think just to highlight the current development of social protection in Cambodia, maybe we can discover more in the Q&A session.
Great. No, that was a really brilliant summary. And having had the kind of privilege of being a bit engaged in a previous life in some of the development of the policy framework there. I think it's really impressive to see how the country has developed the framework, including the strengthening of that life cycle approach, as you mentioned, the real emphasis on the governance arrangements, and of course, that this is really linked to real concrete developments in practice. So really interesting and important case study. Okay, so moving on to Ms. Lama. So we heard in some of the analysis that was shared at the kind of global level that workers' representatives and social partners haven't always been strongly represented in some of these policy making processes. So I think it'd be interesting to ask, understand what you see as the kind of key asks of trade unions for government with respect to social protection policy making. Equally, what are some of the key implementing challenges and opportunities?
Thank you. Namaste and very good afternoon, everyone. It's my privilege to part of this important discussion by representing workers and trade union here. And thank you, Charles, for asking the questions that can just give me more space to discuss about that. The picture of the banner that itself shows how important social protection is for the workers. the old lady carrying the small baby, for us, it's the womb to the tomb. So social protection means that much important for the trade union we're thinking. So I would like to say that the trade union movement has the one fundamental demand to the government, is what? Is protect what we have achieved and do not dismantle existing social security scheme. Instead, strengthen them and into robust and inclusive sustainable system. That is where we are thinking about the social security system on that. Let me explain why. In the founder of the modern Nepal, Prithiv Narayan Saha, once famously said, "Yusano dukhale arjeko mulukaina." It means in Nepali, this nation was not built through the small effort and sacrifices. We can say the same about the Nepal's contribution-based social security system. It was not from the charity from the government or the favor from the employers. It was achievement through the nearly 25 years of the struggle, advocacy, and collective action of the workers. GEFEN and wider trade union movement initiated to bring the workers, expert, policymaker, political leaders, and employers together to build a system. That's why also this is very, very important for the workers as a trade union, we think so. Today, our responsibility is to protect the achievements and extend social protection to every workers who remain excluded. This morning also, we can see how the informal workers are just excluded. This is the same happening in Nepal also. Based on Nepali experience, I would like to highlight five major priorities area. Nepal contribution based social security was launched in November 2018. Workers contributed 11% of their basic salary, and an employer contributed 20%. So we do have 31% of the fund. This was the part of broader compromises. Greater labor market flexibility to extent for the guarantee social protections. So our position remain very clear on this. We are not against the flexibility. We are against flexibility without security. This is what we trade in our field. We demand mandatory participation, regular contribution, effective enforcement, and employment contributory. Social security contribution has not the donation or the charity, they are legal obligation to the part of the cost of decent employment. This is what the part of the decent employment that we think as a part of the trade union. The government must ensure the transparent and effective social security fund. And then second is include the informal excluded workers. How we can claim social protection while the millions of the workers remain outside the system? This morning also, we heard about some of the questions and then discussion that in Nepal also, millions of workers in agriculture, domestic worker, home-based workers, daily wage workers, and of course, now the broader going on is a platform-based workers. And the migrant worker is one of the key areas that we are facing. Yet many have little or no access of the social protection yet. Our demand, again, declare social protection must not depend solely where the workers has the formal employment contract or not, because now the formal employers or the employees are getting the social protection while the informal huge economies is outside the, you know, this protection where they need more. We need simple registration, flexible contribution, and publicly financed support for the workers who cannot afford regular payments. Universality does not mean everyone must contribute equally. It means everyone must have access to protection according to their need and capacity. Employment may change, but the workers' right must not disappear. Third is the legal rights and real protections. Having laws and institute is very important that we fought for it, but the right on paper are not enough. Workers must receive a real benefit in their livelihood. Nepal's Social Security Fund provides the framework of health care, maternity, employment injury, and then protection of the world's benefit. However, challenge remains, including irregular contribution employer. And an employer reluctance is one another challenges that we are facing. Limited awareness and administrative barriers is another one part that we need to work on it. Employers must fulfill their obligations, the government must strengthen monitoring and enforcement, and workers must receive their benefits transparently and on time. We must also rethink employment security. Today, in the changing world of work, protecting only permanent jobs is no longer enough. Workers need income security, social protection, and the freedom to move between jobs without losing their rights. Our demand not simply protect the job, it is protect workers throughout their working lives. And fourth is to ensure the social protection across the border. As I mentioned that one of the key area of Nepali migrant workers, as Nepal is sending labor migrant sending country, huge number of Nepali workers are contributing in economy around the world, but their social protection right often stop at the national borders. They may face difficulties accessing health care, workplace injury compensation, pension, and other benefits. Their entitlement may not become accessible when they return home. Bilateral labor agreement must therefore go beyond the recruitment and employment. They must also guarantee social security protection and portability of eligible benefits. We need strong bilateral social security agreement, cooperation between the government, and meaningful trade union participation. As we talk about the beyond the border or the MOUs, then we say G2G. Now we need to think from the ground how we can make T2T collaboration, means trade union to trade union collaboration, to make the workers' right a meaningful participation. And another one, very important area that we are missing for the women workers, and then, of course, the women migrant workers, including domestic workers, must also receive the equal protection. When we talk about the women issues, that is always the women are half of the sky. Now we need to think from the ground, because they are on the ground who have been working. So, and the last thing is that how we can cover the workers in the crisis. When we talk about the climate change, for the in the case of Nepal, this is not the climate change. We are having climate crisis. As we mentioned, 100 of thousand people have been or the workers have been. lost their life due to the crisis. As we mentioned, how the climate, we contributed less and we are paying high. And then workers are the one who have been bottom of the bottom. That's why also we need to think how we can protect the workers. So at last, I would like to say, workers create the wealth, workers deserve protection, and no workers should be left behind at home, across the border, and in the time of crisis. So I would like to end here. Thank you so much. If anything, I would love to answer any Qs and thank you.
Thank you very much. So now we'd like to move online to our next panelist, Mr. Guido Ricchi, who I wanted to ask a similar question, but more from the employer perspective. What do employers expect from government in terms of social protection policymaking? And again, what do you see as the opportunities and some of the challenges for implementation of social protection policy, in this case, in the case of Guatemala? So hopefully we can get Mr. Riqui to get in.
Thank you very much, moderator, for the questions and of course for inviting us. We have been very much looking forward to this and are very committed to what you're doing. And although we can't be there in person, we wish you every success. In Guatemala, something of particular concern to us is that we have only around 1.81 million active contributors to our Social Security Institute. This is a very small amount of our population. A huge proportion, majority, is not part of our social security system. And in terms of what we, as employers, expect of the government and what we've proposed can be boiled down to five very tangible points, which I'd like briefly to go through. Addressing social protection and growth together as inseparable, indivisible topics. Social protection helps to reduce poverty and makes us more resilient. Productive employment and sustainable enterprises can give rise to the financing for a better social protection system, which makes the labor market more resilient. Growth isn't enough if we cannot generate formal employment. This is something I'd like to dwell on in the next few minutes when it comes to the issue of informality. Guatemala's GDP rose in 2025 by 4.3%, but the needle barely moved on formality, and that is worrying. We have a program that I would like to refer to in the course of this intervention. It's a public-private program, and this is one that we very much hope the present and future elected government after next year's elections will continue. The goal is to create 2.5 million extra formal jobs in the coming years, and this will, I believe, have a very decisive impact on social protection. We need more investment, better export, and strengthening of our human capital. And I invite you to look at our website on this matter. Secondly, we believe that we need a realistic approach to social protection with proper financing. There's no one-size-fits-all approach, but we do have the ILO recommendation 202, which sets out a social protection floor framework as defined by each country. But if we're to broaden coverage, we need to be realistic and avoid contributions leading to undue burden for employers. and workers. We face a problem of underfunding by the government. The government is failing to live up to its obligations in terms of social protection. We tend to say that everybody should bear the burden. It's not fair that employers and workers have to make their contribution if the government hasn't for many years been making the constitutionally defined contribution it should have been to the system. In addition, and this relates more to the labour market, the cost of labour has increased, and this lacks a technical rationale. There has been a failure to look at long-term wage policy. And we have unfortunately seen undue increases in minimum wage without any corresponding increase in productivity or any long-term plans, and that has given rise ultimately to unemployment. It's a structural problem. Third point. Something which we have stressed many times is that the formalization of the economy needs to be at the heart of any policy. I've just mentioned wage policy, but this relates to any other policy in relation to job creation. Informality, as I said, is the biggest barrier to universal coverage and its financing. Formalization broadens the base of contributions and increases protection. Every year, 240,000 people look for formal job, but we are able to create less than 100,000 jobs a year. This cannot continue. Small and medium-sized enterprises are the ones that create the most jobs and represent the biggest part of the business fabric, eight out of ten enterprises. And this needs to be supported. This brings me to the next point. We need to adopt new forms of work and adapt existing systems. For some time, we have been flagging this, but one salient point is part-time work. Many years after Convention 175, some progress has been made, but not enough. And it's largely down to poor regulation by the social security system. What we need, therefore, is better capacity building, training, accelerated programs, and proper management of the opportunities that exist. Lastly, point five, social dialogue, which is very important. Fortunately, this is well rooted in terms of social protection. in occupational safety and health, and also in the Guatemalan Social Security Institute, and this can be broadened further. I would like to conclude looking at opportunities and challenges moving forward. The public-private agenda I mentioned offers opportunities which need to be harnessed. The other major strength of our country is its macroeconomic stability, which is broadly acknowledged globally. and which we need to try to harness and continue to foster. We need to look at new ways of working, as I said, some useful first steps have been made, albeit partially, but we do need to push forward with that, with proper regulation. The state needs to further digitalize what it does. This is set out in law, but practice is falling behind. This will make it easier for small and medium-sized enterprises to create formal work. Looking at challenges, and this brings me to the end, moderator, the major challenge, as I said, involves closing the formality gap. We need to get more workers into the formal labor market year on year. We need trust in the system, a state that fulfills its social security obligations. We need jobs which are established with a proper, well thought out long term wage policy underpinning them. It needs to be possible for the government to actually implement what it promises. Unfortunately, this has not always happened. We have the resources, but they are not properly invested or done so at the right time, always. And I will try at this point to try and share our closing thoughts. I'd be delighted to discuss anything further with you in light of what I've said. Thank you.
Thank you very much. So we've heard perspectives from government, from workers, from employers, and finally, we'd like to hear from you, Ms. Gavi. I mean, what do you, representing both a national civil society organization and also the Africa Platform for Social Protection, what do you think is the role of civil society in social protection, policy making, and equally, how can barriers to social protection extension be overcome?
Thank you very much, Charles. It's an honor to be here and to be talking about social protection, representing my two organizations, Africa Platform for Social Protection and Help Zimbabwe. Africa Platform for Social Protection was founded in 2008. It is 37 members. It is in 37 countries. of Africa, and membership is from NGOs, from trade unions, disability organizations, all the persons, you name them. And our role really is to sit between citizens and policy while we monitor what is taking place in social protection and provide a platform for organizations to discuss issues of social protection. In terms of demography, we find that Africa has a growing aging population, which will probably reach 163 million by 2050.
Sorry, I don't want to interrupt, but you have slides, if I'm not mistaken, right?
Yes, I think if we go through the slides, that would take longer, so it's okay.
Okay, then maybe we can switch the view to be back in the room, please. Sorry, no slides, but room view.
Yeah, it's okay. And we realize that about 85% of the people in Africa are found in the informal sector, and this has been mentioned before in the other presentations that took place earlier in the morning. So in terms of looking at a changing world that demands a new social protection response, We look at the intersecting risks, which are, they've also been mentioned, the climate shocks, the changing work, the demographic pressures that exist in Africa, and the digital transformations. We also look at the constrained choices that exist in Africa, which are the debts that countries have, the limited fiscal space that exists, and the competing development priorities that are also in place. And for the Global South response, we are looking at building nationally owned, inclusive, and financial sustainable systems throughout the African continent. And we are also looking at policy progress, where we are in terms of the African governments, how they have responded in terms of the encouragement to have policies on the ground. The African Union commitments that exist, most of you will remember that some years back, African heads of state agreed that they would have an AU protocol on aging, and they agreed that they were going to have policies that are linked to that protocol. And as APSP, we look and we monitor the progress of countries and how far they've gone in terms of signing and ratification of those policies. We also look at the persistent gaps that are there, that exist, the issues of the informal workers, the unpaid carers, all these are issues that have been mentioned before, but this is the role that we play, the climate change issues and how they expose our communities, the lack of national budgets in terms of social protection, and the many unfragmented schemes, social protection schemes that exist. And the practical lesson that we move forward because of that is we want to move beyond registration of beneficiaries, and we want to have policies that can be adopted, that are aligned to the existing national and existing international and regional policies like the AU protocol that I have mentioned. So as civil society, we realize that we ought to shape policy. in many ways, and not only to endorse, but to help to shape the policy. And the agenda is to bring the lived realities that exist out there and the evidence into the problem definition. We also want to be able to assist in the designing of those policies, the co-creation of inclusive benefits in policy formulation, eligibility, and the actual issues of financing, as we discussed earlier on in the morning session. And in terms of the decisions, we are saying that we have to engage on the priorities that are in existence. What are the budgets that are there, that are in place? And how can the different African states bring in social protection into their national budgets? And we are also looking at the issues of accountability. Africa is struggling with issues of corruption in one way or another, and we are saying as an organization, as CSOs, how do we monitor? How do we bring about audits, social audits, to be able to bring about accountability in terms of what the governments can provide? How do we safeguard the vulnerable groups in our communities? CSOs. And from policy formulation to implementation, we are then saying, we have five bridges that we are looking at. The first one is the bridge that is related to cost. Are we able to set realistic costs that are phased and measurable commitments? The second one is the finance issue. Are we able to protect equitable domestic investment as Africans? Are we looking at the resources that we already have in terms of minerals and other natural resources that exist? In terms of connection, the linkage existence, the issues of insurance and livelihoods, what is there that can be actually be done? In the morning, we talked about the issues of community-based groups, what can be done in terms of connections. Inclusion. Partnering with workers and employers and community-based organizations, is that something that can be done? And we say, yes, it can be done. And also in terms of learning, tracking the benefits that are received in terms of social protection, and actually giving citizen feedback, making sure that the citizens also participate in what is taking place within their country, when budgets are formulated, that people are also, that they are also consulted. So this is what we bring as APSP. And we are saying that amid all the issues that have been discussed, climate change, demographic shifts, and digitalization, the question is not whether Africa can afford universal social protection. We are saying that Africa can afford to have social protection in place, and social protection is not a safety net for when things go wrong, but it is the social contract that prevents things from going wrong. Thank you very much.
Thank you. I think we had one more presentation to bring in that we were going to have earlier in the session, but we are now going to have now. I think Sarah's online, right? So, yeah, we're going to have some insights now from Sarah Cole-Black, the Adaptive Social Protection Lead at the World Bank, on some of her perspectives on this key issue.
Good morning. Good afternoon, everyone. Can you, oh, I see myself talking, so that you must be able to see me too.
We can, we can see you.
Fantastic, thank you. So thank you so much, and I'm excited to be able to contribute to the conversation from across the ocean this morning. And so I think sort of starting from the initial presentation, which set out a very, I think, helpful picture in terms of the ambitions governments have for their social protection programs and strategies. And this was, I think, very richly complemented by the speakers that followed. I'd now like to come in from a World Bank perspective and focus on this core question of how can we translate the ambitions that are set out in national policies and strategies into the programs and systems that can actually reach people with the support that they need when they need it? And we from the World Bank think that this is a particularly pressing question, given that fiscal space is increasingly constrained, that shocks are more and more frequent, and the ways in which labor markets are already changing and anticipated to change further as a result of AI adoption, as well as other global forces. Now, for us, this question is really at the heart of SP500. And this is the shorthand we use to articulate the ambition the World Bank Group has put out to reach 500 million people, including 250 million women, with social protection and employment support by 2030. even as we, at the same time, work to strengthen national digital delivery systems in at least 25 countries. Now, for us, SP500 is very much both an ambition and an implementation agenda. And the way we envision delivering on SP500 is through a set of scalable solutions. Now, these scalable solutions themselves are not new. Many of you around the room will have been working for some time on income support, public works, care services, economic inclusion, and labor market programs that are then delivered through national digital delivery systems or locally led delivery systems. What is new is the way we bring those together, we bundle and adapt them. And we sit them and organize our support around four practical objectives. It is first to protect people, to overcome barriers to work, to help people earn more, and then deliver at scale. And to be extremely clear, we do not expect countries to implement all of the seven solutions that are articulated that sit behind these four objectives. Every country is at a different starting point. And so the task that we see is to identify the bundle or the combination of programs that responds to each country's priorities and constraints, and then to adapt these such that they sit within the institutions, economies, and the needs of people, both now and how these evolve over time. And so we are not saying that there is a single model. It is about, in each country's case, bringing together the evidence of what works, the demand of a country, the institutional capacity, and available financing to build the systems governments will then have to operate, scale, and sustain these types of support. Now, with this implementation agenda in mind, I would like to highlight three lessons that come from our experience. First, we need to collectively build delivery systems, not simply the programs. So a cash transfer program, an employment and active labor market program, care services are only as effective, in our opinion, as the infrastructure that sits behind it. And this is because governments need the capacity to identify people, to enroll them, to make payments reliable, to manage cases and grievances, to connect people receiving income support, for example, with other services, and to respond when their circumstances change. This is why within SB 500, we are connecting protection with, sorry, one second. My mistake, I got slightly mixed up. So this is why within SB 500, we put an emphasis on social registries, digital payments, case management, grievance mechanisms, and labor market systems. Although I heard what the colleague from civil society mentioned about we need to move more than just registering people in these systems to ensure that these systems are very much used to deliver the benefits and services that people need. And that is why, for us, that is the primary objective and the focus within our target, which is moving beyond an investment into a delivery system, but ensuring that that system is then used to ensure that people then receive the support. And investing in these delivery systems is particularly critical in the event of a crisis. We all know that we cannot and should not be building delivery systems from scratch when a crisis hits or in the aftermath of a crisis. These need to be useful, to deliver support with the speed and accuracy that we can aspire to have and to do. These systems need to be in place beforehand. Second, and I've already alluded to this already, is that implementation has to reflect a country context. In a low income or fragile setting, the priority may be providing basic transfers or putting in place the locally led delivery systems that can reach underserved populations. Elsewhere, where systems are more mature, the challenge may be, or the priority may be to connect income support with care, employment, and other economic inclusion supports that enable those people then to move into more productive jobs. The principle that guides our support is, as a result, that we are seeking to apply a more standardized, scalable approach, but without rigidity, and to take what works to scale while adapting to each country's starting point and institutions. And finally, and this to reflect back on a point I just made, which is very much central to our work going forward, is that implementation must connect income protection more directly with opportunities for people. We all know and we have seen how social protection can cushion poverty, but it cannot stop there. Most poor and vulnerable people around the world already work. They remain, however, concentrated in low productivity and precarious employment. And a core feature of SP500, therefore, is to seek to address barriers to people's work that enables them to move into more productive work and to improve the skills and access to opportunities that would enable people to access better jobs. Finally, a core lesson from our work has been that we need to focus on how to finance social protection sustainably, and that we cannot look to a single financing source or a succession of individual projects. So we at the World Bank can deploy different financing instruments for different parts of the challenge, from investment in national programs and delivery systems, to supporting policy reforms, to crisis preparedness and response, all complemented by technical assistance. But the broader direction is important. External financing can help build the systems, can expand and reform these systems as they evolve, but the long-term sustainability of programs ultimately depends on stronger domestic financing, institutional capacity, and country ownership. And this is becoming even more critical in today's constrained fiscal and aid context. In our opinion, therefore, the financing conversation needs to evolve beyond how do we finance the next project towards how do we build systems that countries can progressively finance and sustain.
Just to say, if we can wrap up in the next two moments.
I would like to make three very quick comments, if I may, so lessons looking forward. And these emphasized points I've already made, so I won't dwell on them. So looking forward for the World Bank, the priorities are Invest before the next crisis. I think I have made that point, and we all understand why that is important. Second, implementation needs to be integrated. We need to move beyond program by program responses to very much an integrated suite of investments that reach people when they need it in the way that they need it. And third, even as we focus on implementation, we need to learn, to build evidence, and to evolve our responses to country context and people's evolving lessons, as I learned, excuse me, people's evolving needs, as I said. And I'm going to stop there, given the time constraints, rather than connecting this with the USB 2030 agenda, which I hope, given the intervention I made, is clear to all of you, but I'm happy to come back and elaborate that if time allows.
Yeah, thank you so much, and thanks to all of our speakers and panelists for condensing a lot of rich information to not very much time. We have about 15 minutes for now some Q&A, and then we'll also provide moments for all our panelists to kind of wrap up and any key points. So we don't, as far as I see, have any questions yet on the online. So, yeah, but maybe we can start with the room, see if anyone has any. Brilliant.
Hi, I'm Bernadette Lumbela. I'm a lawyer and researcher at the Max Planck Institute for International Law in Heidelberg. And I would like to make a comment and pose a question to Ms. Lama's intervention. I'm very glad that you brought up the issue of migrant workers, because I think we focus so much on the national level, but in this ever globalizing world and movement of workers, I think the question will be as important as social security on the national level, how can workers transfer their social security rights? And you mentioned bilateral labor agreements, and I think it's super important that we have provisions In there, but in the end, I think it has been shown that many provisions in these agreements rely on negotiations between those two states, their bilateral, their power imbalances, and so on. And I just wanted to bring up that I think in the end, we might need to have like a multilateral. approach. Unfortunately, I think the chances are not as good if we look at the 1999 Migrant Workers Convention, which was also not really ratified. But my question would be, what is your experience, Annapol? Did you see that the government succeeded in having stronger social security transfer provisions in the agreements? Thank you very much.
Thank you so much for giving me this opportunity to share a little bit more on migration. That is also one of the key areas that we trade union in our specialisation has been organising migrant workers in destinations since 1993. So it's already three decades that we have been organising migrant workers in major destination countries, especially. GCC and then Malaysia is a key volume of the workers are there. So we have been thinking on that, how to protect the migrant workers. So we work the cycle of the migrations. So during the discussion of the social protection, as we have a tripartite bodies, however, it is now shrinking the trade union space on that also. But however, during the discussion, we were much aware about that how migrant workers can be protected from the social protection system. So in a Nepali social protection system, is that clearly mentioned that the migrant workers who have been working in Nepal has already been covered. So that is a mechanism for us. So we want to say that our counterpart partner countries that it can be possible to portable social protection system. So now, as I mentioned that how T2T intervention is needed is one area that we are closely working with Malaysia, where the SOCSO is there, so that cover a little bit for the migrant workers. So make the trade union intervention in the destination country as well as the country of origin to ensure that how we can intervention for the social protection. Now we are making our effort to more close collaboration with Oman, because they have also very progressive social protection system. So we have been working especially those where the workers volumes are high, because in GCC also they can portable, and EU also that kinds of mechanism, if there is that. And the dimension of new wall of work that now migration is a global phenomena. So we have to work that how to protect the social protection and then to protect the contribution that made by the migrant workers in a country of destination to the country of origin. Some good example that from the Malaysia we receive, I mean, not in the government agreements, as I mentioned that the labor sending country, there is still a lot of thing we need to work because more like my part of the world, there are several country who have been sending migrant workers. So there is some sort of discussion is needed that how we can make the common standard for the sending country of the our part of the world. So some in the trade union basis we did, like in Malaysia, we have a good example, some of the contribution from the SOCSO, they are just bringing back from as a personal level. So if that can happen, then why not to have more discussion, the country who have a really progressive social protection law, like I mentioned about Oman. So we have initiated discussion of the Oman trade union to work on the portability if there is any possibility. So we are looking forward for the protecting migrant workers' rights and social protection. So if I answered well, thank you so much.
Thank you. Do we have any more questions at the moment? Great.
Yes, thank you. I don't know if you hear me well. So my question is related to...
Why don't you introduce yourself, though?
I'm sorry, thank you so much. My name is Sebastian Bermudez. I'm from Colombia. I'm an international consultant in social protection, labor migration. And that's where my question is going as well, in regard to migrant workers and the extension of social protection. The migration trends will likely change due to climate change, right, in the following years. So my question is how regarding how to prepare countries that have been, during the history, mainly countries of origin and not countries of destination, to receive this or to how to, can they, what will be the better approach for them to manage this shift in the migration dynamics? For instance, in the case of Colombia in 2014, 2015, Colombia has been mainly a country of origin, and Colombia received thousands of Venezuelan refugees and Venezuelan migrants, and Colombia didn't have the legal or the economic infrastructure to receive or to manage this situation. So how to prepare these countries that are mainly countries of origin to guarantee access to social protection to these new migrants in the following years, and to guarantee not only for national borders of migrant workers that will be arriving in the following years. Thanks so much.
Thank you. I'd also flag there was another, there's been a question online, which also links to this topic of migrant workers. Maybe I'll just read that out for everyone's benefit. That's from Karen Rodriguez. Currently, Europe has become an increasingly common destination for migrant workers. Are there any specific guidelines for aligning national migration policies with social protection systems to prevent migrant workers from being excluded from protection and left without support, particularly those in irregular administrative situation? So I think some of that's already been touched upon from the Sri Lanka perspective. What I might just do is to ensure we keep the conversation broad, see if there are any other questions, and maybe we can loop in the, continue the migration discussion in some of the other responses that we have. So do we have any other questions or comments on this topic? Remember, thinking, I guess, Keep in mind the focus on building, developing national social protection strategies and policies that create a vision for social protection, set out a pathway for universal social protection, and moving to implementation on the basis of that. Shay.
I think my question is probably primarily for our colleague Sarah from the World Bank, but also if others have thoughts on this. As we know, and this is sort of connecting the previous session to this one, a lot of times international financial support for social protection can also affect the way that systems are designed and systems operate, and can contribute and has contributed to fragmentation as one of the unintended consequences. And so my question would be, I really appreciated in the description of the SP500 the link between cash and jobs that the bank is trying to make. And I think my question would be, what kinds of resources or where would that next step connection to formalization and to formal employment and to social insurance or contributory systems? especially given the importance that you placed on building systems and taking advantage of the systems that are already in place? Thanks.
Thank you. I don't know, Sarah, do you want to take that question now? Or prefer to do it.
Yeah, yeah, I thought you were going to bundle some questions, but sure. I mean, I think this is a really good question, and I think there's some different ways of posing, going about answering. So I think I'm going to pick it up sort of where you ended. which is, and I think particularly given the fiscal space constraints that we've been talking about, but also the evolution in many countries' economies, we at the World Bank are very much looking to reinforce an emphasis on social insurance systems, but also to think creatively about how those can be extended to populations that are traditionally not contributing by virtue of their formal employment contracts. And we think this is important both because it's those more innovative approaches, such as promoting savings, et cetera, that are able to move, expand this agenda. Given the trajectories or how we anticipate labor markets to change, as I indicated earlier, we think that there's need to rethink and really innovate and imagine how we can collectively think about financing these systems going forward, such that they're not put under undue strain. And finally, to recognize that, so we've been working on social insurance, excuse me, social assistance for the poorest populations. We have social insurance for formally employed workers, many of whom are better off. And so we really need to, as we've been saying for some time, think about extending into this missing middle piece. And so that is both thinking innovatively about these things, how to enable people to contribute who can in some way. And then also to think about how do we bridge that social assistance to social insurance trajectory so they don't have these very firmly demarcated barriers or populations which they serve. I appreciate your question could have also come from a how do we connect social insurance and jobs from an employment support and enabling perspective, but I thought that financing question was potentially one that the room might find more interesting. So I dwelt on that, but happy to come back to the other part if that's more of interest to you.
Great, thank you. And apologies for putting you slightly on the spot there. Okay, so yeah, do we have any, we've still got some more time for some questions and discussion. Do we have any more questions in the room? I can't see any more at the moment online. Again, equally, I mean, one thing to kind of maybe throw in there, which maybe some of our panelists can think about with their responses, but also others in the room may have insights or reflections on this. I guess one thing that strikes me about this whole question of developing national social protection policies and strategies is I think we're clear on what we want them to do. Often, we're thinking about, as I think was described, identifying gaps, seeing what vision we want for a system to fill those gaps, coming up with a plan that looks at the financing, the sequencing, the institutional arrangements, the delivery, all of this. But I think as we kind of heard and was referred to in different ways throughout, I mean, that's a quite political question in many respects. We have different actors with different perspectives. They want different things. We often, as was alluded to, have quite fragmented systems where different organizations, institutions with different vested interests in how the system should be designed. So I guess one thing I'd kind of provoke a bit, and again, our panelists can maybe reflect in their final two minutes if they have examples, but I'd be very happy to hear others' reflections as well. How do we do the strategy development, the policy development, in a way that actually tackles some of those questions? We can obviously come up with a lovely policy or strategy with a big long list, and we're going to do this and this, and we have a wonderful vision. But likely those strategies are going to be more effective if we start to make some of those tougher decisions and choices. So yeah, I'll be interested in any experience where that's happened, whether it's we managed through a process. to agree on a way we can harmonise institutional arrangements and make the system fit together. We agreed on a way that those three policies are going to be our priority, and we're going to do the other ones later, even though there are winners and losers. So that's a provocation. I don't know if anyone has immediate thoughts on that, or equally, if you have any. Great.
Hello again. Perhaps just to pick back up on my intervention this morning. In fact, I think everything's interlinked. Social protection seen simply as an element of the world of work is very limited. And we have seen the consequences, for example, of climate change, of climate disasters. And I really do think that we need to take an even more holistic view, perhaps with a working group, or I don't know what the format would be, but a clearly international format, which could answer 10 questions. And I can go through the 10 questions I have very quickly. In Silicon Valley, the majority of people there believe that work as we know it will be completely disrupted, if not disappear completely. And I think we need to take that into consideration when we look to 2030. So the first question of the questions that I have would be, what do we want to automatize? Are there activities that we want to preserve as human activities, even if they could be automatized? Another very important question when we speak about multi-billionaires, etc., would be who takes ownership of all this, of robotics? There are states that might be owners. So how do we distribute? The third question: how do we share gains from productivity? How can we allow that a company that hires and creates an employment environment pays more social protection than an enterprise that doesn't create jobs and is making billions in profit? Who should we tax when profit is coming from fewer working days? Today, we have companies, we have unicorns, producing billions of dollars, potentially with no employees. They might have some expenses, but they'll have no rent, they'll have no wages to pay. So what do we have to look at in terms of levels of taxation with regard to them? Then how do we guarantee social protection when it's de-linked or decoupled from employment? If we see increased productivity, there will be fewer people hired. Many companies are laying off, and it will be those who are financing social protection, most who are disappearing. How do we transfer productive time into free time? Perhaps this can feed into a slowdown in growth and the climate change problems as well.
All of this.
Comes down to how do we respond in terms of education, social status, dignity when we are entering into this new world? If we look at conflict, xenophobia, another emerging phenomenon as well. How can we ensure that everyone benefits from this revolution wherever they live? So that the benefits are not concentrated in Silicon Valley. These are some absolutely essential questions that I think we have to ask. I don't think we can answer them today, but I do think that we have to look to all the different specialists, engineers, economists, climate experts, tax experts. Earlier on, I was speaking about the invention of the printing machine. That caused great conflict behind it. There was disinformation flowing significantly in that era with pamphlets that were circulating. And I don't think we can overlook these phenomena. And I don't think anyone here is overlooking these phenomena. But I think we have to start to reflect even more on this facet of things. Thank you.
Great, thank you. I think maybe we have moment for one more question. So yeah.
Thank you so much. This one is a provocation for Priscilla, because you're representing the African body in charge of social policies.
I wanted to know if there is any.
Reflection going on on regional social policies that are not bound to national governments, because Africa is going towards the continental free trade area. Is there any reflection going on in terms of trying to have also regional social policies, or not at all?
You want to answer that?
Thank you very much for that question. Yes, indeed. You realize that at national level, most governments, even though they would have agreed at a regional meeting, in a regional meeting as heads of state, when they come back to their countries, in most cases, they try and run away from responsibility and they renege on the promises that they would have made at regional level. And unfortunately, At that regional level, even at AU level, there are no mechanisms to trace or to enforce the decisions that would have been made at AU level to try and enforce it at national level. They usually find it very difficult because there is no mechanism put in place to do that. All that can be done is to persuade and encourage governments to to formulate national policies based on the regional agreements that they would have made. But to some extent, in that spirit of encouragement, you then find that some governments have actually listened to to the regional agreements, and they've gone down to the ground to have social protection strategies and social protection programs and policies being implemented on the ground. To a lesser extent, things have happened, and yes, there are certain countries that have responded positively, and we've seen some results.
Thank you very much. I think we're now going to move to the closing remarks. So I think everyone has up to two minutes to share those remarks. What I'd suggest is maybe we start going in a similar order that we have before. So maybe we start with Veronica here.
Sure, thanks. I think I have to say I was surprised about the degree of consensus we've been having throughout the day. You were trying to be provocative and saying we have different interests, but as a matter of fact, there seems to be a broad agreement on the importance of social protection across governments, workers, employers, and civil society. But maybe the nitty-gritty details of the design is something where maybe then priorities or preferences differ. I really liked the strong emphasis on the rights-based approach. This came out throughout the day and also in this session, but this session particularly on the integrated approach. And this is, of course, precisely what we are also trying to do with the Global Accelerator on Jobs and Social Protection. But I think we have to be careful in this integrated approach that we don't lose sight of the fact that social protection systems are also there to protect those people not able to work at a given point in their life. So it's not that everyone relying on social protection benefits just needs to be activated and included in the labor market. We don't want to see children in work, obviously. We don't want people in old age to have to work until they drop dead. We don't want pregnant women to work around childbirth. People with severe disabilities may not, or people who are sick. temporarily. So we should not pretend that everyone who needs support can be brought into employment and just simply generate their own income. I think that's something where I think we need to still be careful. And then, of course, I mean, I think the other things we all agree about, I mean, we need strong political and legal foundations, we need sustainable financing, we need the delivery systems that reach every person, no matter whether they are nationals or non-nationals, whether they are able-bodied or people with disabilities, whether they live in remote areas or in urban centers, etc., etc., whether they are men or women, old or young, or working age, etc. It's easy to say social protection for all, but to design delivery systems that, and this was said a lot also, adapt to the working realities and living realities of each and every individual, that is a tremendous challenge.
Thank you. Maybe I'll go in the order that was on our agenda. So, Sarah, would you like to share any wrap up points?
Yeah, no, thanks. I think it's been a really interesting. For me, it was a privilege to have an ear or to briefly engage with the very rich discussion. And I think I would echo Veronika in saying, clearly there's broad-based support and consensus on the critical role that social protection plays, both for people who are facing chronic poverty in their day-to-day life, having difficulty meeting ends meet, but also the role it can and needs to play as people are transitioning between jobs. Employment is not static, and it's going to be increasingly dynamic in terms of the demands placed on people to move between work opportunities, to seek out new skills. And I think we need to be having, I think what's critical in all of this is to both recognize the plurality of views in terms of the specificity around the current design, and current implementation and prioritization about which group should benefit from what, but also very much with this forward-looking challenge that is ahead of us. And so to not lose sight of that. And there is, I raised this because, i mean, I think as the speaker a few moments ago was really stressing what the challenge posed by AI and how that's going to fundamentally disrupt it work. And the challenge posed by climate change was spoken very eloquently from the colleague from Nepal, for example, and the direct impact that has already on workers' lives. And so we need to be thinking forward, we need to be anticipating these changes, and if anything, this is a call to finding a way forward collectively and not to get bogged down in those differences, and rather to focus on where we have consensus and how we can collectively ensure there is prioritization, there is innovative thinking, and we are all moving in the same direction. Because if we get too distracted by finer points of debate, we risk the entire system, I would argue. And so I think I'm just going to call pause there, potentially. I don't know what the broader discussion going forward will be, but I would encourage you all to keep sight of that challenge that is ahead of us, where the fundamental underpinnings of many of the systems that we work with will be challenged and we need to collectively find a way forward. Over.
Thank you. Okay, maybe on to Mr. Vanara. Final thoughts.
Yeah, thank you, Charles. I think to wrap it up, I would like to emphasize a little bit more about good governance. In Cambodia, at the policy level, we have the NSPC, which guides through fulfill the function of policy guidance. And NSPC is a multi-stakeholder approach, which represent different government agencies. So they would discuss the the pros and cons and the difference, and agree or reach a consensus at a certain point or level when they have the meeting or convene at a certain time. On top of that, we have the General Secretariat for the National Social Protection Council, which is a coordination body, which help collect inputs and coordinate meetings provide a platform for discussion and input, collect inputs, and also generate evidence for policy decision makings. Secondly, the key success in social protection in Cambodia is also like the use of digital or IT technologies for the single registry or for the monitoring and evaluation. And yes, in fact, for the TS and MPC, especially the digital secretariat, we, in early this year, we received a goal recognition, global recognition award for the digital transformation in social protection. And certainly, we recognize that there is a global reduction in the ODA, but Cambodia doesn't regard financial sustainability as a fixed or static constraint, but we regard it as a dynamic dividend of social economic development. and also the domestic resource mobilization. And, of course, especially the progress or the success of the implementation of the social protection in Cambodia that is not been done, has not been done in isolation, but with the support and partnership from our DPs like ILO, UNICEF, GIZ, World Bank, and its pool fund partners, bilateral donors, such as JICA, KOICA, or the Australian government through DFAT, for example. Thank you.
Thank you very much. On to Ms. Lana Nema.
Thank you so much. We trade union and network believe that Whatever we have achieved, we have to protect it, and then we have to do much better for the betterment of the future. That's why one of the weakness that we found that we sometimes the state or we tread in and also fail to communicate the good story effectively. That is one thing that I would like to add, because G-Fund recently conducted the pilot survey to understand why the young workers specifically, young workers are not sufficiently encouraged to join the social security fund. And we conduct the small survey. Then we found that 61% is identifying lack of information or, you know, not a clear understanding they do have, 61%. 32% pointed that the employer's reluctance, still we do have that also. And 18% created lack of the trust in the system. Once you contributed, you will get it or not. That is also one area that we found. And 17%, 1-7, 17% concerned about the deduction of their wages. So these areas shows that the finding suggestion is, you know, that how we can make it more bring and then broader conceptual issue. Traditionally, that we found labor movement has focused on the job security as the security associated with the holding the permanent positions. However, the introduction of the contribution-based social security as growing flexibility in the labor market that we see and we are facing, we need to broaden our understanding to move toward the employment security. It means ensuring continue of the income and then continue the social protection opportunity to upgrade the skill, freedom of moving between the job, as I mentioned already, the losing social security coverage. Unfortunately, what we found is that we need to work on that. We have to yet communicate this message effectively to the workers, employers, policymakers, and wider public. So this is what we need to work on that, how we can do it from our best as a part of trade union, as a part of employer and the government, as well as the civil societies need to work on that to protect whatever the achievement that we do have. Otherwise, we need to keep fighting for the democracy within a democracy that we are trying back home. So this is the situation that that we need to protect whatever we have. So I would like to add this one at the end. Thank you so much.
Thank you very much. Next, could we go to Mr. Ricky online.
Thank you very much. Thank you. I really do value this space. Spaces like this put a lot of convergence on the table, and I think it's very Interesting to hear different examples of what's been done, how some very concrete suggestions have been put forward, such as those from the World Bank. So congratulations for that. I would finish with a few ideas by way of conclusion. First of all, employers support expanding progressively social security. We believe that financing, implementation, and sustainability should be decided on together with business development and employment. We shouldn't be weakening social security in pursuit of other kinds of development. We see the most direct way in Guatemala of expanding employment is by doing this. We need policies for each country that have a solid financial basis, that are gradually developed and executed by adequately structured institutions. Thank you.
Thank you. And finally, Ms. Kavi.
Thank you. As CSOs, I think our rallying point would be that we need to have policies that people can actually feel on the ground beyond being good on paper. We want to make sure that all workers are visible, formal and informal workers. We also want to make sure that no generation is forgotten. Older persons, children, everyone must be remembered when it comes to social protection. And we are also saying no community really should be left behind. We've seen Africa progressing from the year 2000 when there were very few countries if not none, that social protection schemes or strategies or plans to more countries. Now, I think we have a total of about 48 African countries that now have one form of plan or strategy that they are using. The actual funding of those strategies and plans is another story for another day, but we are glad that at least people are thinking about it and they are drafting documents, and we continue to realize that social protection is being taken as a right and not as a privilege, and we are grateful for that. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much. I won't say much from my side in terms of summary, because I think so much has been captured. As Veronica highlighted, there's a huge amount of synergy in what's being said. I think all I'd say is maybe just pick up on the final point made by Ms. Gavi about looking back to the year 2000, when some of us who worked in this space look back to earlier in our careers when we worked on social protection. You know, I think these global transformations and changes that we've been talking about are disorientating, and particularly the speed at which many of them are happening and developing. And we often think government systems are obviously slow and cumbersome to respond to them. But I would just, I think, listening to this conversation and thinking back, say, to the kind of conversations I was involved in 15 years ago. I mean, the level of capacity, the level of knowledge across a range of stakeholders, the sophistication of the kinds of thinking that's happening at the national level in terms of policy development around social protection, you know, it's not necessarily where we want it to be, but it's a huge development within what's really quite a limited time frame. So I think we have much to be optimistic about. Thank you very much. And we come back at...
Yes, We'll break for another coffee. Apologies for the online participants that we can't serve you online. Yes, and we should be back in the room by 3:50 for the last panel of the day, closing session. You're off the hook. There will be no Q&A for that one, but just some concluding or reflections on the day. by the panelists, and it will be a slightly shorter session as well. We will then, after the closing session, move to a cocktail that, again, thanks again to the Friedrich Ebert Stiftung, we will be able to offer in the same space as the coffee and where everything else was. So don't run off. Please stay with us to continue our conversations also in the evening. Thanks a lot.