SBI 6: 8th Plenary Session Agencies, Funds & Programmes Date: 19 February 2026 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/en/asset/k17/k17qyuiiyr Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- CBD · Chair [0:03]: Hello, colleagues. I would like to begin our deliberations. I would like to continue our deliberations on CRP 6, the functional review of the Secretariat. I know that some Parties made some suggestions, but I don't see them right now here, so I would like to continue receiving inputs from Parties on our paragraph 4 of the decision to the COP, on the draft decision to the COP, paragraph 4, requests the Executive Secretary, subject to the availability of resources, And please do not repeat what has already been said, because we have convened some solutions for this paragraph. So, yes, I see the European Union. European Union, you have the floor. EU [1:05]: Thank you, Madam Chair. This paragraph under A is about the remaining actions. Actually, in paragraph 3 of the SBI recommendation, we have some wording on the actions, which we would like to repeat here as well, because we like them. So we're supposed to add after actions, comma, that are aligned with the core functions and strategic priorities of the Secretariat, as determined by the COP, including actions, and then it continues with what already was there. CBD · Chair [1:42]: Thank you very much, European Union. I will ask you to repeat it, thank you, so that we can catch it. Thank you. EU [1:48]: So after the word "actions" under 4A, remaining actions, that are aligned with the core functions and strategic priorities of the Secretariat, as determined by the Conference of the Parties, including actions, and then it continues where the text was. CBD · Chair [2:10]: Thank you very much, European Union. I think we got it. Yeah. I see Canada. Canada, you have the floor. Canada [2:19]: Thank you, Madam Co-Chair, and good afternoon to everyone. Yes, on that same paragraph, in a similar vein to our distinguished colleague from the EU, And similar to a suggestion that we provided in the SBI recommendation, we would like to suggest near the end of that sentence, after where it says that enhance operational efficiency, we would like to add, alignment with the KMGBF, and the servicing of CBD meetings. And then it would continue recommended in the functional review and so on. And just to provide a quick rationale on that, the way that the original paragraph reads, it makes it seem like the remaining actions are only intended to enhance operational efficiency, which we, of course, agree with. But again, the main purpose of the functional review was to help the Secretariat better align with the CMGBF and focus on the servicing of meetings. Thank you. CBD · Chair [3:26]: Yes, thank you very much, canada. I see Japan. Japan, you have the floor. Japan [3:32]: Thank you, madam Chair. So are we on paragraph four? Okay, okay. So Japan considers it is important that parties are involved and free informed on this matter, as budgetary issues require the approval of the parties. Therefore, we believe that close consultations should be incorporated into the informal sessions so as to facilitate for understanding and endorsement, which would in turn support smooth approval by the parties. In this regard, we would like to request the Secretariat to clarify the modality of the information sessions referred to in paragraph 4B so that the sessions can be planned and organized accordingly. We would also like to request the secretariat to submit proposals for organizational restructuring and job descriptions, if necessary, of additional posts at SBI7. Thank you, Madam Chair. CBD · Chair [4:53]: Yes, thank you very much, Japan. I understand that you are making suggestions to paragraph 4(c). Could you please give us some language? I understand that we are already foreseeing here that the Secretariat will do its job in consultation with the Bureau as we normally do, and of course, parties as a whole will be informed through the proper reports. But at any rate, please, just give me your language, if you could. Thank you. Japan [5:41]: Thank you, Madam Chair. So, sorry. CBD · Chair [5:51]: Japan, are you addressing the paragraph 4 of our recommendation to COP or the paragraph 4 of the SBI? Japan [6:02]: Just a moment. I'm just. CBD · Chair [6:08]: Okay, I will take the Russian Federation while we settle this up. Russian, you have the floor. Russian Federation [6:15]: Thank you very much, Madam Chair. We have a very small amendment to paragraph 4A. to continue to implement ongoing and remaining actions. We think that it makes much more sense than just to continue implementing remaining actions. Thank you. CBD · Chair [6:33]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I will ask the Secretariat to read paragraph 4 (a) as amended, so that we are all on the same page. Thank you. CBD · Secretariat representative [6:48]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Paragraph 4A of the COP component, to continue to implement ongoing and remaining actions that align with the core functions and strategic priorities of the Secretariat as determined by the Conference of the Parties that enhance operational efficiency, align with the KMGBF and the servicing of CBD meetings recommended in the functional review, in line with the Secretariat staffing requirements approved in the core budgets of the Convention and its Protocols for the period 2027 to 2028. CBD · Chair [7:41]: Thank you very much, Secretariat. Are we all clear? Yes, do we have agreement on this text? Yes, I see no objection. Thank you very much. So 4(a) is approved, and I would like now to go to paragraph 4(b) above. I understand that we had already Japan, we have already approved 4b. I understand that your suggestion was related to 4b of the SBI recommendation. Japan [8:43]: Yeah, it's unfortunate. I had another consultation just in front of this room that prevented me to participate in this discussion, but actually we don't have a very organized text proposal, so maybe to save time, I should refrain from proposing new text here. However, my concern is that our concern that there should be some consultation process involved in this information session. It is not just information provided, but the consultation part should be involved. And also to see the functional review report and the reorganization proposals, but we don't have any information how those changes will be reflected to result-based budgeting of the Secretariat. So in that sense, at the information sessions, it would be useful for parties to have those additional information, in particular for those new additional positions, if there are some, with job descriptions and those detailed information so that the discussion at the budget contact group will be facilitated. Thank you. CBD · Chair [10:30]: Yes, thank you very much, Japan. I think that this will be reflected in the report. And of course, as I understand, those information sessions are additional to what we always have regarding budget decisions, so you will have more information than you ordinarily have. I think that we are on a safe place right now regarding budget decisions, regarding this additional proposals. I, well, we do have some, i don't know if we have any other suggestion for paragraph 4. For A, it's agreed, as we had said. We do have some suggestions for the proposals made by Jamaica and China. I don't know, China is there? I don't think so. Oh, yes. China. Yes. OK. So can we read our suggestion for text for the proposal presented here? OK. Thank you. China [11:52]: Thank you, Chair. Just to clarify that you're asking for our proposed text for the paragraph 4(a) or for CBD · Chair [12:02]: It was not for 4A, I understand it was for 4C, and that we should keep it separate, and that's what we did. Can we present the text? China [12:13]: Could you please give me a few more minutes for this one? CBD · Chair [12:18]: No, no, we do have a suggestion. Can we present the suggestion made by the Secretariat? China [12:25]: Yes. Thank you. CBD · Chair [12:27]: Thank you very much. Yes, Secretariat, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [12:32]: Thank you. So the proposal would be to introduce 4bis to replace 4c, and it would read: “also requests the Executive Secretary to keep the Bureau of the Conference of the Parties informed in a transparent manner of progress in implementing the remaining actions recommended in the functional review.”. CBD · Chair [13:03]: I will ask the Secretariat to read it again so that we are all on the same page. Please, notice that what China did is to remind us that this 4C does not have a budgetary implication and that's why we are separating it and making for bis. I will ask the Secretariat to read it again. CBD · Secretariat representative [13:34]: Also requests the Executive Secretary to keep the Bureau of the Conference of the Parties informed in a transparent manner of progress in implementing the ongoing and remaining actions recommended in the functional review. CBD · Chair [13:59]: Can we approve? the paragraph as read out by the Secretariat. China, are you satisfied with the changes proposed? Thank you. China [14:13]: Yes, thank you. CBD · Chair [14:16]: Thank you. Do I see any objection to that? I see none. So 4bis is approved. Yes, I would like, of course, you all remember that we also had some proposal from Jamaica regarding paragraph 4A, and I would like to ask the Secretariat to read it out loud, so we can approve this paragraph as amended. I understand that informal consultations with Jamaica were made, so if we are all in agreement, i understand that Jamaica also has already agreed with that. It's basically, we are adding some elements. I ask the Secretary to read it. Thank you. CBD · Secretariat representative [15:50]: The addition is in the middle of the paragraph, after paragraph 3 above, and any additional activities related to the implementation of the functional review, together with proposals and rationale for adjustments in post classification, including additional posts, as well as changes that have budgetary implications to the Conference of Parties for consideration at its 17th meeting. CBD · Chair [16:27]: Thank you very much. Secretary, it's basically we are adding a rationale and some additional elements, including additional posts. I see Canada. Canada, you have the floor. Canada [16:41]: Apologies, Madam Co-Chair, you've lost me. If you could clearly indicate exactly where is it in the COP decision, is it in the SBI recommendation, what number, what letter, and read out the whole paragraph, that would be helpful. Thank you. CBD · Chair [16:56]: Yes, I'm so sorry, Canada. Yeah, well, Jamaica made an intervention when we were reviewing the SBI decision, so we are now back to 4A of the SBI decision, and I ask the Secretariat to read it. Thank you. CBD · Secretariat representative [17:16]: Thank you, madam Chair. Paragraph 4A of the SBI recommendation: to transmit the executive summary report on the external in-depth functional review to the Conference of the Parties at its seventeenth meeting, and to submit a progress report on the activities listed in paragraph 3 above and any additional activities related to the implementation of the functional review, together with proposals and rationale for adjustments in post classification, including additional posts, as well as changes that have budgetary implications to the Conference of Parties for consideration at its 17th meeting. CBD · Chair [18:18]: Is it clear to all? Do I see any objection to the addition, the amendments proposed? Yes, I ask the Secretariat to read it again since it's a little bit long. Thank you, Secretariat, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [18:37]: Thank you. Paragraph 4A of the subsidiary body component. to transmit the Executive Summary Report on the external in-depth functional review to the Conference of the Parties at its seventeenth meeting, and to submit a progress report of the activities listed in paragraph 3 above and any additional activities related to the implementation of the functional review together with proposals and rationale for adjustments in post classification, including additional posts, as well as changes that have budgetary implications to the Conference of Parties for consideration at its 17th meeting. CBD · Chair [19:38]: Thank you very much, Secretariat. Welcome, Jamaica. We are just reading your suggestions for paragraph 4A of the SBI recommendations. I understand that you have been fully consulted on this. Do I see any further comment on this text? Can we agree to the proposed made by Jamaica? Yes, I see there is agreement. Thank you very much. So it is approved. And with that, i understand. And also, we have a last paragraph, which had, I understand, no changes. So on the COP decision now, we are back to the COP decision. It's paragraph six. Do I see? Oh, yes, the Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [20:56]: Apologies, Chair, I like to check with you and actually with everyone if my reading of this paragraph is right. I'm a little bit puzzled how to implement it. The three meetings goes in parallel and finished basically with a difference of 5, 10 minutes from each other. How come the final result of COP17 can come to the parallel meetings of MOPS? I don't understand it. Or my reading is wrong. So I just like to get clarification. CBD · Chair [21:41]: I want the Secretariat to answer because I didn't understand your point. So, Secretariat, please, could you please help me? CBD · Secretariat representative [22:05]: Thank you, Madam Chair. So the budget decisions for the COP and the COP/MOPs are done. at the same time, together, but the COP one is adopted first, and then the two MOPs separately take their own decisions as well. So that's why the COP would take its decision, and then the two MOPs would take their decisions as well. CBD · Chair [22:51]: Russian, you have the floor. Russian Federation [22:58]: Okay, maybe that work, although the adopted decision is actually placed in its final form after editing some time. So it's really still how come within few minutes adopted by COP decision goes to protocols for how long to consider? So what's the practicality? Again, maybe there is something about it. So if you can explain. CBD · Chair [23:38]: Thank you very much. I will give the floor to the European Union. European Union, you have the floor. EU [23:43]: Thank you very much. Could it be that this is actually paragraph 6 of the SBI recommendation? There's also no paragraph 5 of the COP decision, and the SBI recommendations go to paragraph 5 with a recommendation then for a COP decision, and follows with a paragraph with a recommendation to the COP MOPs. That may make sense. Editorial, it's a bit tricky to see because it's precisely where the page turn is. But also when you look at the indentation, it's just a bit different. CBD · Chair [24:17]: Yes, I see. Thank you very much, European Union. I was the Russian Federation. Yes. Russian Federation [24:25]: No, I fully understand that it's a recommendation of SBI 6 that it's not part of COP. But still, it's recommending COP to send its decision to two MOPs. No, it is a difference of some minutes between considerations. Is it the case in those 10-15 minutes or half an hour between them? CBD · Chair [24:58]: Yes, I will give the floor to the Executive Secretary and then to other parties. Executive Secretary, you have the floor. CBD · Executive Secretary [25:05]: Yes, thank you, madam Chair. I'll try to explain, because I've also only experienced it a couple of times, but the budget negotiation is an integrated negotiation that looks at the budgets for the three instruments, the Convention and the two protocols, and is then submitted first to the Convention for approval, and the same decision with the same text is then also adopted formally by the two protocols. And hence, it literally happens within a few minutes, because it has all been negotiated as one part, but formally has to be adopted by the three instruments. And then luckily, we have Watsi here, who is the secretary, but she's not listening. We have Watsi here, who is the secretary of one of the protocol meetings, and she has done that several times, so I hope I've explained it also correctly. Can you confirm? Yeah, okay. CBD · Secretariat representative [26:01]: Yes, just to confirm that the budget decision, when it comes to plenary, it comes, there are three different documents where the COP budget, the MOP, the two MOP budgets, and so it happens at the same time. And the also recommends is going directly to the MOPs. And so this is going straight for the MOPS to take note of the decision. But I understand the complexity, and I agree with you, and the sentence will stop after the sixth meeting. So basically, It will read also recommends that the Conference of the Parties serving as a meeting to the Cartagena Protocol and the MOP take note of, then we would be taking note, not of the COP decision, but of the recommendations on the functional review, because they're happening at the same time. CBD · Chair [27:26]: Thank you very much, Secretariat. What I understand, and I do agree with the European Union, is that perhaps this belongs to – I don’t know if SBI can recommend something like to take note of the decision, but I read it as something that we are saying that, of course, the functional review also has effects on the protocols, and then we should be aware of that. This is a reminder for us that we should be aware of that and that the protocols should also take note of any decision regarding the functional review, and I really don't see any problem because we can foresee this on our draft decisions to be approved by the protocols. I see the Russian Federation. I would like also to hear from Fiji and Norway, perhaps they could help us, and then I will give the floor back to the Russian Federation. Fiji, you have the floor. Fiji [28:28]: Madam Chair, I cannot help you, but I was not going to comment on that particular paragraph, but I just wanted to seek clarity on 4C, and I understand the placement of five will be between them. Just on 4C, do we keep the Bureau informed or do we, because I think, again, is it, do we keep parties through the Bureau? So I think it's just to understand that very carefully, because usually you keep the parties informed through the Bureau. And if I'm reading that correctly, it's like keeping the Bureau informed, but the Bureau represents us, like they represent our voices in these spaces. So maybe if you can just clarify, because this is a very minor comment, but I wanted to seek clarification before we go into six. Thank you. CBD · Chair [29:29]: Thank you very much. Fiji, I will get back to this. Perhaps we could, Norway, is this about six? Yes, thank you. Norway [29:41]: Yeah, so it's, thank you, chair. It's about six, so we don't have any problems with that language in six because this is how we are used to it's being done in the past. As the Secretary said, these are integrated, the budgets integrated issues. Another example is the DSI issue, which the COP takes a DSI decision and it's mirrored in the Nagoya Protocol MOP decision. This is not a problem. Thank you. CBD · Chair [30:09]: Thank you very much, Norway. I see Switzerland. Switzerland, on this also. Switzerland [30:16]: Yes, thank you. Since it's the COP conclusion, it would have to say also invites the COP MOP because it cannot recommend the COP MOP, it can only invite it to the legal status. So it would be also invites the COP MOP and then it's correct along the fact that it's a COP decision. Thank you. CBD · Chair [30:35]: So, thank you very much, switzerland. So, we would change recommends to invites. And I would now like to give the floor to the Russian Federation. Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [30:48]: Yeah, still seek the final clarification from the Secretariat. So, what the if you can say again, because when you said that it will be changed for taking note of of the report of functional review, that I understand completely. So the difficulty is with the decision. So it can be mirror five times, but the decision itself can't be sent to the meeting, which is actually parallel, or this five minutes difference for consideration, yeah, or for note only. And decision, again, is not really final before it's edited and published. But if you're saying about the report, then absolutely clear and perfect. Thank you. CBD · Chair [31:44]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. So I would ask the Secretariat to read it with their latest suggestions to see if we can have agreement on this paragraph. Secretariat, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [32:02]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Paragraph six would read, also recommends. Invites. CBD · Chair [32:10]: Also invites. CBD · Secretariat representative [32:11]: No, invites doesn't go with this ending. Invites doesn't go with. Thank you, madam Chair. So just to clarify that paragraph 6 was intended to be a recommendation from the SBI to the COP/MOPs, and it's not to the COP. So paragraphs Yes, so paragraph six refers to the COP/MOPs directly, and that's why they're not, it's not an invitation, but it's a recommendation that the COP/MOPs take note of the functional review. So it will read, also recommends that the Conference of the Parties, serving as a meeting of the parties to the Cartagena Protocol at its 12th meeting, and the Conference of the Parties, serving as a meeting of the parties to the Nagoya Protocol at its sixth meeting, take note of the executive summary of the report on the external in-depth functional review of the Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity as contained in Annex 1 to document CBD/SBI/6/10, and additional actions requested by the Subsidiary Body on Implementation at its sixth meeting, as contained in document SBI/6/ to be determined. And in that way, the COP/MOPs mirror the decision that the COP is taking. Thank you. CBD · Chair [35:01]: Thank you very much, secretariat. And of course, we are now dealing with paragraph 5 of the SBI recommendation and not 6 of the Conference of the Parties. Okay, so do I see agreement in the room to this? No objections? Yes, thank you very much. So the CRP is approved. Thank you, thank you very much. And I ask the Secretariat to prepare a document for us, thank you. Yes, and I would now suggest that we go back to CRP 5 on agenda item 6, capacity building and development and technical and scientific cooperation. As you recall, before we broke for lunch, I had proposed an informal consultation to be led by Canada. Thank you very much, Canada. I would like to ask Canada to report on their work. Canada, you have the floor. Canada [36:32]: Thank you, madam Chair, and thank you, colleagues. To all the colleagues that participated in a very constructive and collaborative discussion before the break. We are happy to report that we do have a proposal of a clean paragraph, so subparagraph D would read: To further support, in collaboration with the global coordination entity, in line with decision 16/3, the technical. And scientific cooperation support centers in identifying and facilitating their access to predictable funding sources, including through relevant partners, to enable them to deliver effective, context-specific and demand-driven capacity development support to Parties. CBD · Chair [37:51]: Thank you very much, Canada. I would like to ask the Secretariat to read it for us so that we are all clear. Thank you. CBD · Secretariat representative [38:02]: Thank you, madam Chair. The subparagraph D would read: To further support, in collaboration with the Global Coordination Entity, in line with decision 16/3, the Technical and Scientific Operations Support Centres in identifying and facilitating their access to predictable funding sources, including through relevant partners, to enable them to deliver effective, context-specific, and demand-driven capacity development support to Parties. CBD · Chair [38:39]: Thank you very much. European Union, you have the floor. EU [38:43]: Yeah, thank you. And I agree with the text, except at the end, it should probably be capacity building and development as agreed language within the since COP15. Thank you. CBD · Chair [38:53]: Yes, European Union, thank you very much for reminding us. Well, I see that we have agreed on the most of the language on this CRP. Of course, there is still the question of adopts and welcomes, and I would like to ask Japan, with now that we have agreed on terms of reference, we should lift the brackets and have adopts. Japan, you have the floor. Japan [39:25]: Thank you very much, madam Chair. I have been explained by the CBD Secretariat about the intention to and the necessity to prepare the TOR in advance because of the time needed to process the procurement and the recruitment, and also the TOR would not be changed much even if Corona pandemic or UN system will collapse or something, but rather the information will be fed into the panel. So with that explanation, we are happy to remove the. CBD · Chair [40:18]: Thank you very much, Japan. So I think that we have another CRP ready. Thank you very much for flexibility. CRP 5 is approved. Thank you very much. Thank you, colleagues. We are making very good progress. Thank you all. I would like now to go to CRP 8 on agenda item number 7, cooperation with other conventions and international organizations. As you know, we have convened a contact group on this agenda item, and I would like to invite the co-chairs of the contact group that met last night for the second time to report back on their work. I would like now to give the floor to Madam Martha Kalemba of Malawi. Malawi, you have the floor. Malawi · Contact group Co-Chair [41:35]: Thank you, Chair. On behalf of my co-chair, Ms. Clarice Kela Siebert of Sweden, and myself, I am happy to report on the further work of our contact group on item 7, cooperation with other conventions and international organizations. We met for a second time yesterday evening from just after 9:00 to 11:30. The group continued to consider the non-paper that integrated views heard in plenary and through submissions. It started its work with non-paper paragraph 8 bis, without reopening the first 15 paragraphs discussed in the first contact group held on Tuesday evening. Yesterday, the group exchanged on 11 paragraphs under consideration. Six of the paragraphs have not been considered. There was generally a good spirit and continued willingness to cooperate amongst participants of the group. The result that has now gone to CRP is quite mixed. Progress has been made with some clean paragraphs. There was agreement on deletion of other paragraphs, and square brackets have been introduced in some paragraphs. would like to thank the Secretariat for supporting the contact group and of course all participants who joined the group till 11:30. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [43:09]: Thank you very much, Malawi, Ms. Marta. And thank you also your co-chair, Ms. Clarissa Siebert, and all the participants on the contact group for your very hard work and the results that you bring for us. I would like to propose that, given the intensive work on the contact group, I would like to propose that we consider and approve the document as a whole, but before, i would like to open the floor to make a few remarks and suggestions, because I understand that there are some still some pending issues from what we have understood from the report. First, in the third preamble paragraph, i would like to propose to delete, so we are on the third preamble paragraph that starts with “recognizing”, I would like to propose to delete “in accordance with capacities and priorities of each party” as the deletion of the expression was agreed in the group, as I understand. Okay, do I see any objection? I see none. Thank you very much, colleagues. And I also believe that some parties consulted to reach a compromise proposal on paragraph 8, which, from what I understand, was mostly agreed upon pending rephrasing of the paragraph. Could I please invite Brazil to take the floor and provide the suggested text for paragraph 8? Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [45:11]: Sorry, madam Chair, you pick me with surprise here. Let me just find the text. Okay, I do have it, yes. The text goes: further welcomes the establishment of the Intergovernmental Panel on Chemical, Comma, Waste, and Pollution, and invites collaboration between this platform and the IPBES, together with the IPCC and the UNCCD Science Policy Platform. CBD · Chair [46:02]: Thank you very much, Brazil, thank you very much for this proposal. Do I see any comment on this? Yes, Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [46:15]: Thank you, Madam Chair. If I could recall correctly our late discussions at the evening before yesterday, we all were clear that IPBES is something that we could invite, encourage, and so on, so forth. So my understanding was that we have agreed to address this cooperation of new panel with IPBES and put aside other two. Thank you. CBD · Chair [46:49]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I understand that you did not was that you were not part of the consultations that were made. Okay. So, yes, I think that perhaps we could put the language proposed by Brazil, which is, of course, inviting and invites the IPBES and together with the other two panels and platforms from the other two Rio Conventions, brackets and leave it on brackets for the moment. Canada, you have the floor. Canada [47:36]: Thank you, madam co-chair, and appreciate the efforts from our colleague from Brazil. We think it's quite an eloquent way of moving things forward and would be very supportive of adopting the paragraph with the changes proposed from Brazil. Thank you. CBD · Chair [47:53]: Thank you very much, Canada. I see Switzerland. Switzerland, do you have the floor? Switzerland [48:01]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Yes, in the same line, I think we would definitely support the very good proposal by Brazil. Thank you. CBD · Chair [48:09]: Thank you very much, Switzerland. Russian Federation, are you very clear on what we are proposing? Russian Federation [48:18]: Not 100%. If you could read it once again, thank you. CBD · Chair [48:22]: Thank you very much. I ask the Secretariat to read. Thank you. CBD · Secretariat representative [48:27]: Thank you, madam Chair. The paragraph reads: Further welcomes the establishment of the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Panel on Chemicals, Waste and Pollution. It invites collaboration between this platform and IPBES, together with the IPCC and the UNCCD Science Policy Platform. Thank you, Chair. Again? CBD · Chair [48:54]: Yes, again. Could you please read again? CBD · Secretariat representative [48:57]: Yes. Further welcomes the establishment of the Intergovernmental Science Policy Panel on Chemicals, Waste. And Pollution and invites collaboration between this platform and the IPBES, together with the IPCC and the UNCCD Science Policy Platform. CBD · Chair [49:20]: Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [49:23]: Thank you, Chair. We would be okay to keep the whole text if we go for notes, but at this moment, we are not ready to further welcome. So it's either keeping in brackets the whole thing and moving forward, or we need to discuss further whether welcome or not and so on. Thank you for understanding. CBD · Secretariat representative [49:44]: Russian Federation, if I may make a suggestion, perhaps we could keep the language of Brazil and just bracket notes and welcomes. Thank you. CBD · Chair [49:57]: Thank you very much. Yes, I see that Chile is also requesting for the floor. If it's only to support. Okay, Chile, you have the floor. Chile [50:09]: Yes, madam Chair, it was just to support the proposal that was just read by the Secretariat. Thank you. CBD · Chair [50:16]: Thank you very much, Chile. Yes, I think that we can move forward with the brackets around the welcomes and notes. Thank you very much. And now, and thank you, Brazil, for coming with this good suggestion, thank you. Now, I would like to draw your attention to the last part of the recommendation, which are subparagraphs 16 through. Let me first correct a typo in paragraph 16. There should be no brackets around land degradation. Noting that these subparagraphs were not considered by this contact group, as we heard in the report, I would suggest adding brackets around the whole paragraph 16D to I. And now I would like to propose with this, if we can agree to this, yes, Canada, you have the floor. Canada [51:29]: Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. We completely agree with your proposed way forward, but just noting that we noted that in paragraph 6G, there was a proposal made by IAFB that was supported by numerous parties, and that wasn't included here. It was to report to the subsidiary body on implementation and the subsidiary body on Article 8j. And we noted that it wasn't included. And so, noting that we're putting everything in square brackets, we're hoping that we can include that so that we can consider it at COP. Thank you. CBD · Chair [52:12]: Of course, Canada, I think that we all heard you, and of course there was support for the submission made by the IIFB. So on paragraph 16G, which are we are bracketing for COP, we would add to report to the subsidiary body on implementation and the SPAJ, okay? And then we bracket the whole. 16, d through i. And now, as I have stated before, I would like to proceed with the adoption of CRP 8 as a whole. Yes, Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [53:04]: My apologies. Could you reconfirm that we put the brackets starting from small d? Thank you. CBD · Chair [53:15]: Yes, Russian Federation. It's from D to I, because those paragraphs were not reviewed by the contact group. And I would like now to see if we can approve this CRP with the amendments and brackets that we have just reflected here. Yes, I see no... Yes, Zimbabwe, you have the floor. Zimbabwe [53:42]: Thank you, Chair. Maybe just procedural clarity on what exactly we are attempting to do here. Are we saying we are proposing adoption of this CRP with brackets, which we wish you put in last night as the entire CRP without further discussing the bracketed items in other paragraphs? Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [54:10]: Yes, Zimbabwe, we are proposing that because we are at our last day and unfortunately, we haven't been very efficient and effective. And of course, we have lots of CRPs. I think that we have very fruitful discussions on the contact group and we did register lots of progress, but I would like to move forward other issues, because we don’t have so much time right now. If you can agree to do that. I see Mexico. Mexico, you have the floor. Mexico [54:49]: Thank you, madam Chair. It’s my understanding that bracketing D to I is a way of saving time. But what we’re doing is leaving the work to be resolved in Armenia. We know that it's quite a complex document, and perhaps I'm naive, but I think it would be worth knowing whether there are any objections to any of these paragraphs. We might, to not leaving some of these in brackets. There might be some where there are no objections, rather than leaving it all for COP in Armenia. Thank you. CBD · Chair [55:30]: Okay, Mexico, I, well, I'm just following the recommendation from the contact group. I understood that this was agreed in the contact group, that we would proceed on this way. But of course, I'm in your hands. If you want to lift the brackets, from paragraph D to I, I would be more than obliging. So I ask the plenary right now, do we have any objections to approve paragraphs D to I as they stand, of course, with the... Yes, as they stand right now? Yes, I see several parties asking for the floor. So I will try again. Since this was what us agreed in the contact group, can we proceed like this? Thank you, Mexico. Thank you very much. Thank you. Do any parties have to elaborate on this, or could we just proceed as agreed in the contact group? Okay, i see Japan, Japan, no, okay, yes, japan, you have the floor. Japan [57:02]: Thank you, madam Chair. We prefer to keep these smaller items in bracket because we still have a concern on small e, paragraph 16. We do not think this small paragraph e is necessary, for we prefer this to be kept in bracket. Thank you. CBD · Chair [57:21]: Thank you very much, japan. So I would like to get back to what I've proposed. So we are approving CRP8 with the remaining brackets. as agreed on the account group, and of course with the small corrections and changes that we have proposed here. And do I see any objection to do that? I see none. Thank you very much. Another CRP. Congrats, people. So we will prepare an L document on this agenda item. Thank you very much. And I would like now to direct our attention for CRP 7 on agenda item number 8, specialized international access and benefit sharing instruments in the context of article 4, paragraph 4 of the Nagoya Protocol. As you know, we had a contact group co-chaired by our colleagues Mary Ciacci and Patience Gendua. And I would like to invite the co-chair of the contact group on this item, Miss Mary Ciacci of the EU, to report on the progress. Miss Ciacci from the EU, you have the floor. EU · Contact group Co-Chair [59:02]: Thank you very much, madam Chair. Madam Chair, distinguished delegates, it is an honour to report back on the work of this contact group. At the second session of the item 8 contact group last night, we began by expressing our appreciation to the small friends of the co-chairs group and inviting the group’s two co-chairs to present the outcome of their very productive consultations. They informed us that the group had been able to converge on several key elements, including agreement on a budget-neutral online process composed of three virtual meetings supported by the Secretariat and operating as an open-ended informal modality. Delegates also confirmed that this process would remain entirely distinct from digital sequence information, and they underlined the importance of submission of views by Parties and the use of information contained in the Nagoya Protocol national reports. The Group further agreed that outcomes should be reported to SBI 8 with a view to concluding the discussions on the work at COP/MOP 7. Based on this outcome and inputs that we received by the Small Group, we circulated a co-chaired text addressing paragraph 3 and Annex II in the known paper. Delegates expressed broad support for the draft, along with constructive suggestions for refinement and further improvement. To take this forward, we established a small informal drafting group during the contact group. The contact group then reviewed the revised text, paragraph by paragraph on screen, and approved it with two sets of brackets remaining. Additionally, in line with the guidance, wise guidance provided by you, Madame Kocher, to retain concise preambular elements, we invited the contact group to consider reverting to the preambular paragraphs contained in the pre-session document. and the Group agreed to this approach. We inform delegates that a conference room paper would be prepared on the basis of the revised non-paper that guided our discussions, and that the CRP will be tabled before the Plenary for your consideration. Madam Chair, we would like to record our sincere gratitude to all Parties, observers, and contributors for the constructive engagement and spirit of cooperation that characterized the work of the Contact Group. Our meeting last night concluded at 9:00 PM, and we now respectfully submit the CRP to the plenary and encourage delegates to approach it in the same positive, solution-oriented, and compromise spirit, the very same one that enabled us to progress on this. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [1:02:24]: Thank you very much, co-chair, and I would like to echo your congratulations to you, your co-chair, and of course all the members of the group. I was very pleased to see how you advanced this issue. I would like now, please, to table CRP 7 for your consideration. As we have discussed, the CRP was prepared on the basis of the contact group discussion, mainly on one operative paragraph, the preamble paragraphs that were reverted to the original draft recommendation, and the second annex. The contact group concentrated on the timelines, modalities, and process required to advance work towards CSBI 8. The text outlining the proposed process and actions was developed during the contact group discussions and received wide support among participants. There were some different views on how to address Article 4.4. But I understand that this CRP that we have before us was discussed in depth and reflects the possible consensus and compromises on this issue. I would like now to invite the Secretariat to provide some further details. Secretariat, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [1:04:05]: Thank you, Chair. To recall, a non-paper was produced and considered by the Contact Group, as was just introduced now by the co-chairs. However, due to time constraints, the group was not able to review the full document. The outcome of the group focused its efforts on the specific sections noted earlier, as per the mandate given by the Chair. And therefore, Secretariat will now take you through the structure of the document, starting with the preamble. As informed by the co-chairs, the preamble was discussed in the contact group and reverted to the text of the pre-session document. It is therefore proposed that we do not reopen the preamble for discussion this afternoon. And with regard to the operational paragraphs, we note that paragraph 3 Paragraph 4 and paragraph 5 were discussed in the contact group, and it is proposed that these paragraphs are also not reopened in this session. With regard to the annex, only annex 2 was discussed. Given the limited time available, it is therefore proposed that the annex remains as it now stands. Noting, of course, that parties will have the opportunity to further discuss and refine this document at COP/MOP 6. Thank you, Secretariat. CBD · Chair [1:05:43]: Thank you very much, Secretariat, and thanks again for the Co-Chairs. So now that we are clear, as explained by the Secretariat, we are not really discussing the outcomes of the contact group. So we are not discussing the preamble as it was tabled, and we are not discussing paragraphs 3, 4, and 5, and we are not discussing annex 2 right now, so I would like to invite you to proceed in this manner, and I would like to propose that we start with paragraphs 1 and 2, and then afterwards we proceed to paragraph 6 and 7, and I hope that my proposal is acceptable. Switzerland, you have the floor. Switzerland [1:06:35]: Thank you, madam Chair. Apologies to come in on the floor. On the approach, we do have crucial amendments to the preamble. We also made that clear in the small group that especially the reference to Article 10 of the Nagoya Protocol for us is highly, we strongly disagree with it, and we made that clear in the contact group as well as in the small group. And our engagement on the compromise was in the understanding that. It would not be in the context of Article 10 of the Nagoya Protocol. So therefore, the recalling of that article for us would have to be removed or at least bracketed if other countries need to see it. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:07:19]: Thank you very much, Switzerland. I understand that this text that has not been really discussed and tabled is of course under consideration, and I would completely agree that we can put brackets on the sentence saying recalling article 10 of the Nagoya Protocol and the whole preamble, as a matter of fact, since it has not been discussed. My proposal was not to accept the text, was to not discuss it here, to not reopen the text, but I'm in your hands. I see several current parties asking for the floor. I will propose that we bracket the preamble as a whole so that we can skip the discussion about the preamble? Could we proceed this way, colleagues? Because we haven't had the opportunity to discuss the preamble, and we would just bracket everything? Okay, I see that there are parties still want to ask for the room, so United Kingdom, you have the floor. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [1:08:39]: Thank you, madam co-chair. We could go along with that. I think it is important to recognize that there was no discussion on the preambular paragraphs. There might have been some previous preambular paragraphs that we saw there before, but we did not discuss any of them. So I think from our side, we could bracket the whole thing, otherwise we can work through the text now. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:09:01]: Thank you very much, UK, for your understanding of my proposal. Togo, you have the floor. Togo [1:09:11]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Togo is concerned at the compromise solution that's being proposed by the Secretariat and recalls that the point in 4.4 was inserted in COPMOP 3. There's been no progress. It was then postponed to COPMOP 4. There was no progress. It was postponed to COPMOP 5, and it would appear that that's still the case because what's being bracketed are matters that could help us advance this item. So, what's next? True, we might not have the time, but will we still not have a report for COP/MOP 6? Thank you, Madam Chair. CBD · Chair [1:10:06]: Thank you very much, Togo. I see Malawi, followed by Japan. Malawi, you have the floor. Malawi [1:10:16]: Thank you, madam Chair. Just to also in line with what Togo said, I think for us, we would also want to move forward, and we are mindful of the time. And I think it's regrettable for us being a delegation of one, we really face challenges in terms of participation in this kind of discussion. And we do have some areas that we wanted to work on in paragraph 4, and like Togo indicated, this is one of the most important paragraphs here because it defines the future of the work under this agenda item. So we are in your hands. Otherwise, in our case, for paragraph 4, we wanted to also understand the brackets around paragraph 4 of article 4. Otherwise, what would be the future of the discussion? Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:11:20]: Thank you very much. Togo, I will have Japan, and then I will consult with the Secretariat. Thank you. Japan [1:11:27]: Thank you, Madam Chair. It was Malawi, not Togo, who spoke before me. We discussed paragraph 3 and Annex 2, as far as I recall, last night, and nothing else. So my understanding is that other parts, except for this we discussed yesterday, should be bracketed, and especially Annex 1, which is appearing on this CLP, seems to be a new one, which we haven't discussed. And even we haven't discussed at all. So this Annex 1 must be taken back to an old version, original version, which is SBI-6/8 still. Still, discussing this issue itself is a big compromise for this delegation. So we as I strongly support what was said by Switzerland and the United Kingdom, everything must be bracketed. And we should make a decision that no consensus has been reached at this SBI on this matter. That must be the right path forward. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:12:34]: Thank you very much, Japan. I will consult with the Secretariat. Perhaps the co-chairs could also approach. Thank you. Thank you very much, colleagues. What I would like to propose, if we can pair with my proposal, is that we just take the results from the contact group. So we will just take operational paragraphs 3, 4, and 5, and Annex 2, and we will revert those that were lengthily discussed to the pre-session document, the pre-session draft recommendation, and then we bracket everything, and we continue these discussions. on COP, because then, of course, there are lots of insertions derived from the first reading of the document and the submissions, but unfortunately, we did not have any time to discuss them. As a matter of fact, I'm now just repeating the suggestion that I made at the Bureau meeting regarding these issues, because I thought it would be easier for us, and if we could go along of these lines, we would not waste the work that we had during the contact groups, so we will be a step forward when we resume discussions on this item, and parties will be in a better footing to start negotiation. Could we do that? Do I have your agreement to proceed this way? Okay, yes, I see Namibia. Namibia, you have the floor. Namibia [1:17:01]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Unfortunately, we are a bit hesitant to align to that proposal. We see the brackets that were added into the text that we worked on, which is part of what you have mentioned, brings a compromise to the whole text, and we were not explained exactly why and how we resolve this bracket, so it's difficult for us to not engage into this this issue so that we are clear and we know how to move forward. Thank you, madam Chair. CBD · Chair [1:17:44]: Thank you very much, Nabibya. I will invite, I will apologize, but I have to rely on the participation of the co-chair, on the leadership of the co-chair, if she could please enlighten us about this. even Mr. Ciacci from European Union, thank you very much, european Union, you have the floor. EU · Contact group Co-Chair [1:18:10]: Thank you very much, madam co-chair, madam chair. We would prefer to return the brackets around paragraph four because it is our understanding that the The whole discussions around specialized instruments cannot be just based on paragraph 4, it's the entire of paragraph 4 of article 4, it's the entire paragraph, article 4 of the Nagoya Protocol that needs to be looked at and instructed. So we would really prefer to retain the brackets around it at this stage, but happy to work with the colleagues at COP MOP to see if we can solve this. CBD · Chair [1:18:55]: Yes, thank you very much, Madam Co-Chair. And I understand that those brackets were introduced during our first reading. I do remember it perfectly well. And I do remember that the rationale was also because we were discussing it. So we would like to see how discussions developed. and see if this was really the reason, I'm sorry, the results that we were expecting. So it's a kind of procedure brackets as well. But I see Senegal. Senegal, you have the floor. Senegal [1:19:39]: Good afternoon, madam Chair. Thank you for giving me the floor. I simply wanted to echo colleagues' remarks. If there had been reports, two or three successive reports, well, essentially what this shows is that we have yet to nail down the real issue. Perhaps something is slipping through our fingers and We just keep deferring this discussion. I think we need to be very careful, even if we need to defer the decision or to the next meeting. I still think we need to take this seriously and really ensure that we hone in on the problem, the way things stand, it's as if we're playing with time. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:20:48]: Thank you very much, Namibia. I would like to propose that we park this discussion now, and I would like to invite perhaps the co-chairs to have some informal consultations and come up to us later on at this meeting with some kind of solution, perhaps, consulting with the parties that have manifested some disagreement with the proposed way forward. And I would like to highlight that what we are proposing is not really to defer the discussion is to take advantage of what we have discussed so far and to table it again at the next COP, so we would not have lost our time here. I would ask for your flexibility on this, because if we don't have any kind of compromise here, I think that then, yes, we will be deferring the examination of this issue. But of course, I'm in your hands, and I would ask our co-chairs to continue their work for a while longer. Thank you very much. Sit this way. Malawi? Yeah. Okay. Thank you very much. So I would like now to park this CRP, and thank you very much, thank you Secretariat, thank you very much, you all. And I would like now to go to CRP 4 on agenda item 3B, the financial mechanism. As you... No, no, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Okay, colleagues, I apologize for the delay. I was consulting with the Secretariat. We have been making very good progress. However, I think that we will still have some informal consultations to be had, and I would like to propose the following. As we have agreed, this session will end at 5:30 so that we give our colleagues that are observing Ramadan a break, and then we will have informal consultations on some issues from 6:30 to 8:30. And we will have a very joyful night plenary session from 8:30 to 11. I hope that then we will be able to finish all of our work. I ask for your indulgence on this, and we were consulting with interpreters as well. I hope that we finish by 11, and I understand that we have a decision that we should finish by 11, but let's see. Thank you very much for your understanding. Can we proceed this on this matter? So we will go now until 5:30. And I see no objection. Thank you very much. Thank you. I would like now to go to CRP 9 on agenda item number 9, the review of the effectiveness of the process under the Convention and its protocols. I know that we are shifting teams, and I will read very slowly. As you may recall, I requested Mr. Gote Hansen of Norway to facilitate some informal consultations among representatives of regional groups on the draft recommendations under this agenda item. And I would like now to invite Mr. Gote to provide a report on the outcome of the consultations. Mr. Gote, you have the floor. Norway, Norway, you have the floor. Norway · Informal consultations facilitator [1:27:40]: Thank you, madam Chair. So the informal small group on effectiveness, composed of representatives from all regions, met yesterday, Wednesday, at lunchtime to solve some outstanding issues. There was a good atmosphere and we discussed what we might say were long-term and short-term aspects of effectiveness before we dive down in the concrete issues. We were able to resolve the most contentious issues related to para 5 in the note from the Executive Secretary on the issue of first readings. The group converged on deleting this para. Connected to this, creative suggestions surfaced to recommend from the SBI to COP17 that a party-led group be formed to assess issues of long-term effectiveness. There seemed to be initial convergence on this idea, but regions and parties needed more time to consult. Therefore, language to this end was placed in the CRP as para 11, as a placeholder in square brackets, pending consultations. After the meeting, an outline of CRP was distributed to the participants, after the meeting, sorry, to the participants, and the input received was worked into the CRP. Thank you, madam Chair. CBD · Chair [1:29:33]: Thank you very much, Mr. Gott. So, dear delegates, the CIP before you contains four sets of recommendations. We will consider the CRP paragraph by paragraph, but first, there was a typo, and I will ask the Secretariat to please enlighten us and suggest the due correction. Secretariat, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [1:30:07]: Thank you, madam Chair. So the typographical error is on paragraph 3 of the recommendation to the COP. So where it's written General Assembly resolution 79138, it should be General Assembly resolution 79318. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:30:36]: Thank you very much, Secretary. So this is only, really only a typo. And then I would like to invite you to review the CRP paragraph by paragraph. I would first ask you if you have any suggestion for the preamble part. I would take the preamble paragraphs as a whole, and then operative paragraph by paragraph. Do we have any comment on the preamble paragraph of the recommendation? Yes, European Union, you have the floor. EU [1:31:30]: Thank you, madam Chair. Maybe just a question for clarification, because we're talking now about the preamble paragraphs of the COP decision, is that correct? just talking about the request to the executive secretary in the SBI part of the decision. I don't, otherwise I don't see any preamble paragraphs that are not in the COP recommendation. Sorry. CBD · Chair [1:32:05]: Oh, yes, my mistake. Thank you very much. Because there is a draft recommendation to the SBI as well, I skipped it. So, no, first, the first paragraph, thank you very much, european Union. Do we have any comments on paragraph one? Argentina, you have the floor. Argentina [1:32:29]: Thank you very much, Chair. Given that this morning there was a request to evaluate progress made in implementation of modalities here, we would be more comfortable replacing welcomes by notes. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [1:32:52]: Yes, thank you very much, Argentina. Could you please clarify where are you suggesting this amendment? Argentina [1:33:02]: Yes, in the recommendation made to the COP, paragraph two, sorry, paragraph one, welcomes the progress made in the implementation of measures. It should be notes instead of welcomes. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:33:16]: Thank you very much, Argentina. Okay, so do I see any requests for the fall for paragraph one of the recommendation, draft recommendation of this SBI? Yes, Fiji, you have the floor. Fiji · 14 Pacific SIDS [1:33:35]: Thank you, madam co-chair. I believe we can support this. We had robust discussions as well that as long as we are not contradicting or not compliant with the rules of procedure, it's very important for us to consult on the possible modalities. So I think it gives us comfort to know that The recommendation to the Executive Secretary is to consult on all possible modalities for a possible party-driven process, which we understand would be coming out of this process. So I believe for Fiji and the 14 Pacific seats, this is acceptable. CBD · Chair [1:34:17]: Thank you very much, Fiji. So I understand that we do have consensus on this. paragraph, this draft recommendation? Yes. So it's approved. Thank you very much. And I would like now to go to our recommendation to the COP. And I would like, yes, Jamaica, Jamaica, you have the floor. Jamaica [1:34:46]: Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Madam Chair, we have been very slow, so please forgive us. You went a little bit fast and we were a little bit confused. Because the SBI recommendation, which is one paragraph, we had a suggestion for, my region had a suggestion for insertion. So can I read it? So in the second line after party-driven process, with the participation of the Secretariat. And in the line after effectiveness of, the convention processes and meetings, and we continue. Madam Chair, you... Okay. Is it good? CBD · Chair [1:35:41]: No, could you please repeat it? Jamaica [1:35:42]: Okay, so let me just read. To consult the parties on the modalities for a possible party-driven process. And here's the insertion, with the participation of the Secretariat in the form of an advisory body to further improve the effectiveness of the Convention processes and meetings under the Convention and its protocols. And we continue. Madam Chair, just to say that the advisory body, we believe, should not be permanent. It could also be ad hoc when it is needed. So, it's not a permanent body. It's not to replace any of the subsidiary bodies or their functions or the functions of the Bureau or the functions of the Secretariat. Thank you. Or the functions of the Presidents or Chairs. Thank you, Madam Chair. CBD · Chair [1:36:41]: Yes, thank you very much, Jamaica. I would like to first invite the Executive Secretary. I don't recall, but perhaps this is my mistake, that we do mention Secretariat as opposed to Executive Secretary regarding your suggestion. Yes, Executive Secretary, please. CBD · Executive Secretary [1:37:14]: Yeah, Jamaica, we are not entirely clear at this point about your addition, because the previous text simply spoke about modalities, and Fiji's suggestion was to be very general on possible modalities. CBD · Chair [1:37:28]: For a possible process. CBD · Executive Secretary [1:37:30]: If you wanted to add the advisory body, which, if that is your suggestion, with the participation. CBD · Chair [1:37:38]: Okay, maybe we clarify. Jamaica [1:37:45]: Madam Chair, please, please forgive me. I have, we made some suggestions on outline that we had been given, and so I was responding to that. So, yeah, I have to go sit with some of my colleagues to be sure that we get all the comments. I apologize. Sorry. CBD · Chair [1:38:06]: Thank you very much, Jamaica. So, well, we'll park this paragraph and we'll go to paragraph 2, I'm sorry, the recommendation for the Conference of the Parties, and I would like to take the preamble paragraph as a whole. Do we have any comment on the preamble paragraphs of the recommendation for COP? Yes, UK, you have the floor. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [1:38:38]: Thank you, madam Chair. It's really just a question. I know one of the preamble paragraphs in the draft is underlined. Is that to underline it as a preamble paragraph or is that an editorial mistake? I have no problems with the content, just want to clarify why it's underlined. CBD · Chair [1:38:56]: Thank you. Yes, you can know it's just editorial. Thank you very much. Yes, I see. Okay, so is there any comment? I see, yes, Fiji, you have the floor. Fiji [1:39:16]: Madam Chair, this is a cosmetic change. It's not important, but our group feels that the letter preamble paragraph should be replaced with the second, and then the second is moved to the third, if that's okay with others, which means that you will reiterate the importance and then you reaffirm. So recognize, reiterate, and then reaffirm. CBD · Chair [1:39:47]: I'm in your hands. Of course, we can change. I don't see. I am okay. Yeah. So it will be recalling, recognizing, reiterating, and then reaffirming. Fiji [1:40:03]: Yes. CBD · Chair [1:40:04]: Canada, you have the floor. Canada [1:40:08]: Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. Apologies, we're just trying, we're still trying to digest the document, this CRP that came out quite late. And so you have to apologize if we circle back on some things. I'd like to ask for a little bit more time to consider the paragraph on reiterating the importance of secure funding. We'd just like to have a little bit more time to take a look at what we've decided in the past and make sure we're aligning and being consistent. So if you'll bear with me, I'll come back in a little bit. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:40:39]: Of course, Canada. I see Zimbabwe and the European Union. Zimbabwe, you have the floor. Zimbabwe [1:40:47]: Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. We support the proposal that has been put forward by Fiji, just to tweak and change the positions. And we also, in that vein, would want to, would like to maintain the component pertaining to the issue of securing funding to allow for more than one delegate for each of the developing country parties to stand. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:41:24]: Thank you very much, zimbabwe. I see the European Union. European Union, you have the floor. EU [1:41:30]: Yes, thank you, chair. Just like Canada, we're also still very much digesting the text, and we feel, while we fully underscore indeed the need for equal participation at these meetings, this is something that might require a bit more thinking about how we want to do this, and So for that reason, i think for the moment we would like to put the paragraph in brackets and then digest it so that by COP we can figure out a way to not only talk about what we should be doing, but do it. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:42:19]: Perfect, thank you very much, european Union. I see Switzerland. I think that Yes, Switzerland, you have the floor. Switzerland [1:42:30]: Thank you, madam Chair. Yes, similar to Canada and the EU, we also would need a bit more time to discuss this and agree to put it in brackets at this point so that we can have a look at COP. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:42:46]: Thank you very much, Switzerland. So I would like to propose the following. We shift the verbs as proposed by Fiji, and we put the last preamble paragraph that I understand that this one causing us some trouble, but I see willingness to deal with this during COP, and so we put it on brackets. And then We have dealt with the preamble paragraphs. Can we proceed this way? I see no objection. Thank you very much. And then I would like to call your attention to operative paragraph 1, welcomes the progress. Do I see any suggestions, any comments? Argentinian, you have the floor. Argentina [1:43:51]: Yes, thank you, Chair. We see that our previous comment has not been taken into account, replacing welcomes with notes. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:44:01]: Yes, of course, we can put into brackets, welcomes/brackets notes. Can we do that? Chile, you have the floor. Chile [1:44:23]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I'm sorry that maybe we are being too slow or you are being too fast, but the paragraph we just left in bracket, we wanted to add some text regarding to more than one delegate. We would like to change that and say at least two delegates. CBD · Chair [1:44:51]: I don't know if that's possible at this point. Chile [1:44:54]: Thank you, madam Chair. CBD · Chair [1:44:55]: Thank you very much, Lili. So it would be reaffirming the importance of securing funding to allow for more, and then, of course, brackets inside the brackets, one delegate slash brackets at least two delegates for each developing country party to participate and engage effectively in meetings. Yes, Chile, you want the floor again? Chile [1:45:32]: Yes, it would be to allow for open brackets at least two delegates, not for more than. CBD · Chair [1:45:41]: Oh, of course, we cannot really decide on this right now. We have to have the two formula. You are adding tax right now, so we keep one and the other. So that's what we normally do. Thank you. But your suggestion is also reflected. Thank you very much. I see Brazil. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [1:46:04]: Thank you, madam Chair. Just to say that Brazil is supportive of Chile's proposal. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:46:10]: Thank you very much, Brazil. So we could move to operative paragraph one. I see that Argentina asked for notes instead of welcomes. But of course, we all know that we have made some progress. I think that, okay, we could discuss this during COP, but I noticed that we had made some progress on effectiveness. Do you really want to keep your bracketed text regarding welcomes, Argentina? May I ask for your flexibility? Thank you, thank you very much, thank you, thank you very much for flexibility. So with this, can we agree on paragraph one, welcomes? I see no objection, thank you, colleagues, thank you very much. And operative paragraph number two notes the pilot of the oral submissions. Any comment? No. Oh, Jamaica. Jamaica, you have the floor. Jamaica [1:47:35]: Thank you, Madam Chair. And Madam Chair, we have no difficulty with most of it, but we would like in the last line, after the subsidiary bodies, to talk about the challenges, that the challenges be addressed. any challenges that have been, or lessons learned in implementing the pilot be addressed as we move forward. So we're going from subsidiary body to subsidiary body trialing this pilot, and so any lessons learned along the way should be addressed as we move to the next meeting. So, Madam Chair, so for submissions on a trial basis at subsequent intersessional meetings of the subsidiary bodies, as well as to identify or note the challenges experienced and have those addressed to improve the efficiency of meetings. Something along those lines in the last line, the lessons learned along the way. Thank you, Madam Chair. CBD · Chair [1:48:38]: Thank you very much. I will wait for the Secretariat to draft a proposal so that we are clear. I would like to take advantage of this break to remind you all that we have received some consultations about the pilot modalities that should be answered. We will receive it. so that we can all evaluate the early submission of states' pilot modalities. We receive it through email, and we have already received it, and I think it's, what is the deadline, Assad? Speaker 172 [1:49:20]: The 25th of February. CBD · Chair [1:49:22]: So we can all have a say on this. and have a full evaluation. Secretariat, could you please read the paragraph as amended by Jamaica? CBD · Secretariat representative [1:49:43]: Thank you, Chair. So the paragraph reads as follows: Not the pilot on the early submission of statements carried out for the 27th meeting of the subsidiary body on scientific, technical, and technological advice, and the application of the modalities for such submissions on a trial basis at subsequent sessional meetings of the subsidiary bodies, as well as to identify challenges or experiences to improve the efficiency of meetings. as a measure to improve the efficiency of meetings. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:50:28]: Thank you very much, Secretariat. Switzerland. Switzerland, you have the floor. Switzerland [1:50:37]: Thank you, Chair. So we could go along with amendments by Jamaica. we would just like to not only note, but note with appreciation. I think we recognize that there are still many challenges, we can still much do better, but still it has been an improvement and we really think this pilot helped us, so we would like to note it with appreciation. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:51:01]: Thank you very much, switzerland, European Union, you have the floor. EU [1:51:06]: Thank you, chair. So, on the addition by our Swiss colleagues, I think we are happy to follow that. On the Jamaican addition, while we fully agree that it is important to evaluate what these pilot modalities are doing, we do note that this paragraph in the COP recommendation It's just looking back from COP at what has already happened, so then talking about evaluating doesn't fully make sense in that context. If there's a place where we could introduce it, it might be under 5A, where we're talking about continuing to improve the modalities of the modalities. So just to be aware that in the current context, it doesn't quite fit. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:52:02]: Thank you very much, European Union. Australia, you have the floor. Australia [1:52:06]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I was going to suggest something, but I take the European Union's point that it doesn't quite belong here, and I'm happy to move it. But I think that, and I have no problems with the Swiss insertion, I would support that. But I think that if we're going to continue to improve the modalities through identifying challenges and experiences, we need to put in the positive outcomes that we've seen from the pilot as well. So we would say identify challenges, benefits, and experiences associated with the use of the pilot for early submissions. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [1:52:46]: Yes, I would give the floor to Brazil, and then I would like to hear from Jamaica. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [1:52:54]: Thank you, Chair. Thank you, colleagues, for the contributions. I think we could solve this issue brought by the European Union by just changing the verb tense from identify to identified challenges, experiences, and the addition by Australia. I forgot right now what it is, but we can just change the verb tense. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:53:31]: Thank you very much, Brazil. I will ask the Secretariat to read the paragraph with the suggested amendments. Secretariat, you have the floor. Thank you. CBD · Secretariat representative [1:53:48]: Thank you, Madam Chair. So I will start with on a trial basis. at subsequent intercessional meetings of the subsidiary bodies, as well as identify the challenges, benefits, and experiences associated with the use of the pilot to improve the efficiency of meetings. CBD · Chair [1:54:24]: Yes, and of course, we are beginning with the suggestion made by Switzerland, so we have notes of appreciation, but we are dealing with the last part. Can we have it as it is? Yes, I see nodding. Thank you very much. So paragraph 2 is approved. Thank you, colleagues. And now we have paragraph 3. takes note of General Assembly resolution amended as proposed by the Secretariat regarding the typo. Can we agree with it? I see no objection. Thank you very much. Approved. And paragraph number 4 encourages parties. Yes. I see Canada, followed by European Union. Canada, you have the floor. Canada [1:55:26]: Yes, thank you, Madam Co-Chair, or sorry, Madam Chair. I mean, the issue here in this paragraph is, for us, is the reference to online submissions being translated and made available in six official languages. And so, you know, of course we understand that this is one of the main, this is one of the challenges identified, and we need to figure out a way around this. But I think we all understand that if all of our early written submissions are translated into six official languages, then it's not going to be feasible. And so we're certainly willing to get together with everyone and think about how we can do this. in an efficient and effective way so that it's not a barrier, but doing it this way would not, I don't think, would be one of those, and so we would at least want that in square brackets. I mean, our preference would be to delete that text, but I think at the very, very least, it would have to go into brackets for us to continue discussing at COP17. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:56:38]: Thank you very much, Canada. I see the European Union. European Union, you have the floor. EU [1:56:45]: Yes, thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Just to indeed agree with what Canada has said, I think if we need to translate each of the early submissions into all languages, this might become a very expensive exercise, and I don't necessarily think this was the intention. So we would also just prefer to brackets or delete the paragraph, or at least this addition. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:57:10]: Yes, thank you very much, European Union. I think that there are some parties that support, that of course suggested this amendment. Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [1:57:24]: Thank you, Chair. And we may see the issue raised by colleagues. And yes, it's potentially an issue, but then we need to think about all discussions around those pilots. It's really difficult, for example, to follow the language in paragraph 2 when we are supposed to note something with appreciation if we hardly can read half or maybe more submissions. So that's not much about appreciation of that kind of process. as well as many other disadvantages. So if we continue the way it is now, so we will see a pretty limited value of all those submissions. Although, of course, there are certain positive elements around them. And I probably agree with the colleague from Canada, so we don't want to delete it, we like to keep it. But we definitely will have probably a more extensive conversation later on on how we can do it better and what can be done. But for the moment, we like to keep it, because otherwise, from our perspective, all this exercise and process is actually really of a pretty low efficiency. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:58:53]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. So I understand that we will keep this last part provided, that online submissions on bracket so that we can further discuss it. I think that this is part of the discussion about challenges and, of course, also about the improvement of the use of technologies that are right now available to you all. So I think this discussion will be very interesting during COP. So, yes, Togo. Togo, you have the floor. Togo [1:59:32]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I simply wanted to draw everyone's attention also to the fact that paragraph 4 also links in with paragraph 2, I would say, because if we look at the change that was made, then either We will have to say "notes with appreciation" in brackets, because if we bracket "for," that would mean that the issue of early submission is still on the table. Therefore, I suggest that we bracket what was added to paragraph two as well, and then also, of course, keep four bracketed, given all the reasons that were already set out in terms of the challenges, in terms of translation into all languages, it's going to be struggle, of course, we want to move forward, but also are aware of the huge amount of work this entails for the Secretariat and the resources as well. Thank you, Madam Chair. CBD · Chair [2:00:57]: Yes, Togo. Yes, I understand. Are you suggesting that we should bracket notes of appreciation? Because the translation was not so clear for me. Togo [2:01:13]: Yes, as we postponed paragraph 4, so we think it's a good idea to put in brackets the additional language in paragraph 2. I think it is noted with appreciation. I don't have the English version, but the Secretariat can help us. CBD · Chair [2:01:38]: Okay. I have just approved this paragraph. I would rather not to change the paragraph right now. Of course, you can reopen every kind of appreciation that there is here at the COP meeting, but I would rather not to go back and change things that we have already approved. And I will ask Colleagues, please pay attention from now on. I don't intend to go back to paragraphs no longer. I don't think this is a very fruitful use of our time here. We don't have much time and we have to move forward. Togo, I would ask for your flexibility on that. Can we agree on not bracketing already agreed text? Togo [2:02:36]: It's not my intention to delay our work. There's no problem because we can always come back to this. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:02:43]: Thank you very much, Togo. Thank you. So we I see Mexico. Mexico, you have the floor. Mexico [2:02:53]: Yes, thank you, madam Chair. Regarding paragraph 4 and after listening some concerns that rightly expressed by the Canada delegate, maybe If we insert some words in the last part of the paragraph after early submission process, whenever used for subsidiary or governing body meetings, and explore ways for provided online submissions to be translated. and may develop in the six official languages, maybe it's a way forward because leaves the door open to look for ways. I mean, so we're not deleting the whole idea. We're not bracketing the whole part because it has two elements, because we want to encourage more use of the system. We understand the heavy load to translate and the cost to do this, but we can leave the door open if we agree after meetings and explore ways for provider line submissions to be translated. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:04:13]: Okay, in Mexico, i understand that your suggestion would be an explore ways for, I think that provided doesn't really fit it. Yes, I ask the Secretary to please make a suggestion here. CBD · Secretariat representative [2:04:41]: Thank you, Madam Chair. The proposal that we heard was after subsidiary or governing body meetings, and explore ways for online submissions to be translated into the six official languages. CBD · Chair [2:05:03]: Thank you very much, Secretary. I think that this captures the, yes, I see nodding from Russian Federation. Russian Federation [2:05:17]: Chair, thanks to colleague from Mexico coming with solution. Our preference will be to keep both. That will give us opportunity then to consider at COP. So but please include the Mexican suggestion, as it can be a good starting point also for the discussion later. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:05:38]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. So we will keep both to explore ways and provide it. And we move forward. Can we continue this way? Yes, I see European Union, you have the floor. EU [2:05:56]: Thank you, madam Chair, and apologies, maybe it's because it's the end of the fourth day and I'm getting a bit tired. Just for clarity, because of course we can and should include the Mexican proposal to explore this at COP, but we would also still like to maybe just keep the whole paragraph in brackets, so just for clarity that that is still the case. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:06:24]: Yes, European Union, this is the case. Thank you. So with the amendments and the brackets, I would like to see if we can approve this paragraph. Yes, I see no objection. Thank you very much. This paragraph is approved. I would like now to go to paragraph 5 and paragraph 5 as a whole. So 5A and B, request the Bureau. Any comments? European Union, you have the floor. EU [2:07:13]: Thank you very much. Regarding 5B, we feel that it's still a bit early to already put in a recommendation to COP that we need to apply the modalities when we're still filling in the form and making sure that we have time to process the modalities and how they have been used. So for the moment, I think we would prefer to put 5B in brackets and then come back to it at COP once we've done our thinking. CBD · Chair [2:07:46]: Yes, thank you very much, European Union. Togo, you have the floor. Togo [2:07:55]: Thank you, Madam Chair. As I was saying just now, I believe that these paragraphs are linked. Perhaps the proposal I’m going to make might help if Madam Chair feels this is relevant. As our colleague said just now, these are paragraphs that are all linked. Therefore, if we found that in paragraph 4 this required broad discussion and we bracketed it, then it would seem to us that what follows are details as to what the Secretariat needs to be able to do in terms of achieving early submission. I believe, therefore, that this part, all of 5, should In any case, everything that links in with early submission should be bracketed so that discussions can continue, so that this allows for more information in the fashion in which this will proceed. That will perhaps bring us a way forward. CBD · Chair [2:09:11]: Yes, Sogo, thank you very much. So I see that paragraph 5. should be bracketed as a whole, and I understand this rationale. Thank you very much. Can we then proceed with the proof of the bracketed text of paragraph 5? I see no objection, so thank you very much. It's approved. And then I think paragraph 6 is very easy. Could we approve paragraph 6? Any objections? Russian Federation. Russian Federation [2:10:01]: No, Chair, I don't think I have objections. I'd just like to say that in the initial version and pre-session document, we had an important element, which we also raised in our intervention and later on discussed in a small group yesterday. that it's not only about decisions, it's actually about streamlining agendas, meeting agendas. That's where a substantial number of problems starts. So that's why just adding after streamlining meeting agendas and. CBD · Chair [2:10:39]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I do recall your suggestion in this sense. Can we then approve? our willingness to streamline. Yes, thank you very much. I see no objections. It's approved. And then I would like to turn your attention to paragraph 7 as a whole, if I may be so bold. So 7, A until H. Yes, Russian Federation, you have the floor, followed by Argentina and the European Union. Russian Federation [2:11:24]: So before I go, Chair, would you like me to address all concerns we have around this paragraph, or you like to go like paragraph, sub-paragraph by sub-paragraph? How do you like? We have several comments for different sub-paragraphs. CBD · Chair [2:11:41]: Yes, I understand. I would rather that you have it all explained so that we can save time. Thank you. Russian Federation [2:11:48]: So for sub-paragraph B, we don’t, again, have a strong opinion, but it looks a bit unnecessary work to put for the Secretariat. Our procedures for meetings actually mentioned in the rules of procedures, modus operandi, they are all available on the website, on languages. So we don't really understand what's supposed to be done here. Everyone can open and read. And it will be much better to read the original rather than listen to somebody's interpretations. So C, we, of course, don't want to be too harsh to the Secretariat. But we unfortunately believe it's not enough to continue efforts. It's simply to issue pre-session documents on time and to limit their number and length. So we will not be very happy to hear, oh yeah, we did some efforts, but sorry, we failed. So just issue. So continue effort to delete. Paragraph D, we see not really appropriate for that kind of delay. So this kind of draft guidelines are important for us now, as we're moving toward COP17. So we prefer to move it to the first section when there are recommendations of SBI 6. That's actually secretariat prepared. and make it available for us ideally before Substar 28, SBI 7, but at least for COP 17 already. So move it there. F, I am a bit puzzled to understand how you can retire agenda items. Sometimes I understand many convention practice retirement of decisions, but retire agenda items, that's something new. So just like to know what does it mean and how we need to read this text. And the last one in H, the second line, to serve as chairs of, and we add subsidiary bodies, comma, working at la, la, la. So because that's also to be included into the list. That's it. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [2:14:31]: Thank you very much, Russia. I guess the Secretariat did get your suggestions. Okay. So I would like now to move to Argentina, followed by the European Union and then Canada. Argentina, you have the floor. You can take the whole paragraph. Argentina [2:14:52]: Thank you very much, Madam Chair. First, We welcome the adoption of 6 and support Russia’s comment on paragraph b. Given that we just approved 6, and it refers to the adoption of agendas and improving the procedure for adopting them, the truth is, we don’t see the need to include this in 7f that’s in front of us now, especially because retiring agenda items and the reduction of the number of items is up to COP and the Parties, rather than the Executive Secretary. Therefore, we would suggest doing away with the language after "including", so deleting "the retirement of agenda items and the reduction of the number of items and of" or at the very least, we would like to bracket this text. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:15:56]: Thank you very much, Argentina. I do understand your position. European Union, you have the floor. No? So Canada, you have the floor. Canada [2:16:10]: Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. One specific comment regarding paragraph 7, subparagraph (c). We note that, and certainly appreciate all the hard efforts that the Secretariat has made in the recent months and several meetings now to get documents ready on time, the in-session documents ready on time, and to keep the lengths down, the length of the documents and the numbers of them. But we have noted in certain instances where the content of those documents, some of the key elements have actually been placed in information documents, which are not presented, don't have to be presented six weeks ahead of time and do not have to be translated into UN official languages. And we're concerned about that going forward. And so we would like to add at the end the following text. It's fairly short, but I'll read it out. So after length, we would simply put, while ensuring that all the information required for decision-making is included in official documents. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:17:28]: Thank you very much, Canada. I see the United Kingdom, followed by Switzerland and Togo. United Kingdom, you have the floor. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [2:17:38]: Thank you, madam Chair. This is to comment on 7 subpara B. Just to provide a little bit of explanation because we were the proponents of this subpara. The idea of this actually came from the pre-session webinars that we trialled this time round. The UK felt that some of the information given in those webinars was around the way that subsidiary bodies work and the procedures of those bodies, and we felt that it would be a more efficient use of time in those webinars to not cover those. So to enable us not covering those, we thought that briefing documents could be developed, prepared, made available, those shouldn't change on a regular basis, so actually they could become a little bit more of a capacity building and guidance for parties, particularly for people that are new to the process, but also for those of us that have been around for some time as well, because these things are complicated. So that was why we decided to put that in. So with that, i hope that that's amenable to parties. If not, we could be happy to keep it in brackets and discuss it further at COP. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:18:51]: Thank you very much, UK. Thank you very much for your explanation. I see Switzerland followed by Togo and Mexico. Switzerland, you have the floor. Switzerland [2:19:00]: Thank you very much, madam Chair, and thanks to the UK for the explanation. We would still like to keep it in brackets so that we can further reflect on that. On sub-paragraph C, we agree with the additions that have been made. On sub-paragraph D, we are also not convinced about providing draft guidelines for operations, etc. I think this should be captured in rules of procedures, annotated agenda, scenario notes. So we would like to keep sub-paragraph D in brackets for the moment. We could agree to keep sub-paragraph F, but I understand it's bracketed. Thanks. CBD · Chair [2:19:48]: Thank you very much, Switzerland. I see Togo, followed by Mexico and the European Union. Togo, you have the floor. Togo [2:19:58]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I wish to raise a point, and I hope But the preamble hasn't yet been adopted, because just now I almost delayed the session a little bit. I hope that the discussion also includes the preamble to 7. CBD · Chair [2:20:30]: I'm sorry, Togo, while you still have the floor, could you please clarify? Togo [2:20:38]: The translation doesn't seem to be going through. Yes, I would like to point out one issue on the preamble of paragraph 7. So I would like to be sure that we have, I can go ahead on that, because I don't want to draw it back. So is this possible? It's okay. CBD · Chair [2:21:08]: You were talking about the chapeau. Togo [2:21:10]: The chapeau, yes. CBD · Chair [2:21:11]: Yes, of course, yeah. Togo [2:21:13]: OK. Hello. The issue here, the problem, has to do with the consultation with the Bureau. Everything that's listed, while generally speaking, we can estimate that the work that's required of this secretariat and bureau still ensures that the secretariat can take on this burden, where it says, this needs to be done in consultation with the bureau. There's an issue here to do with responsibility. The question here is, is everything that's listed, Does this all really need to be done in consultation with the Bureau, because there can be actions that the Secretariat can conduct? For instance, if we look at Russia's remarks and the changes that were made, namely to not make efforts toward publications, Well, does everything under that need to be done in consultation with the Bureau? Perhaps I'm raising an issue to which I myself am looking for solutions. I'm just wondering whether we could add "where applicable" after "in consultation with the Bureau." I don't know whether that works. Perhaps other countries could find a solution with the Secretariat's support so that we can determine whether we really need to do everything that's listed in consultation with the Bureau. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:23:11]: Thank you very much, Togo. So I understand that your suggestion is to insert "where applicable" and where applicable, when in consultation with the Bureau. So thank you very much. I see Mexico, followed by European Union and Saudi Arabia. Mexico, you have the floor. Mexico [2:23:37]: Thank you, madam Chair. There are several amendments to paragraph 7. I'd like to go through. I'll go through them one at a time. We would agree with Togo's suggestion to add As appropriate, perhaps would be better. In consultation with the Bureau as appropriate to the CHPO for seven. We do feel it's useful to consult with the Bureau at different times. It's part of their responsibilities. And here, it's a reference to the Bureau plural. So perhaps that can help with these consultations. In paragraph C, we agree with Canada and Russia and their concern around substantial important information being sent through informal information documents, whereas this is a formal negotiation. I think this is a combination of an effort to make documents shorter, provide pre-session documents and information that's contained in that type of document. We need to find some kind of balance and keep those documents short at the same time. So we do want them short, but we want important information to be contained in pre-session documents. So we support Canada's suggestion. As for paragraph D, we agree with Russia's proposal to move this to a numeral 1 to that section, because these are activities the Secretariat can undertake immediately, rather than waiting for COP to provide these instructions, and we would then have that benefit for the next COP in October. On paragraph F, where Argentina is proposing brackets, we do see a value in the Secretariat making this effort to explore which items can be retired or reducing agenda items. The Parties don't have time to conduct that type of analysis. Perhaps if we add at the end of the subparagraph for consideration by COP, that might address Argentina's doubt, someone needs to conduct this analysis, and it's the COP that makes the final decision. In any case, we would rather keep subparagraph F to be kept in with the change proposed, so that it's clear that after the Secretariat's analysis, it's the COP that makes a decision on this. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:26:37]: Thank you very much, Mexico. Yes. I can see. I think that the Secretariat also got your suggestions. I would like now to invite the European Union. European Union, you have the floor. EU [2:26:55]: Thank you very much, Madam Chair. And I've been trying to follow everything, and it worked too well, so I think I'll add another layer of complexity. In paragraph 7, we've noticed that in the chapeau, We request the Executive Secretary, in consultation with the Bureau, as appropriate, or whatever it was. But what we notice is that in the subparagraphs, there are some subparagraphs that are indeed subject to the availability of resources, but there are others in there that do not necessarily require any resources. So I think we need to do another exercise to pull the two apart. now to help that along. According to us, subparagraphs A, B, E, and G do have to have the subject to the availability of resources, because they would require resources, while C, D, F, and H does not require the subject to the availability of resources, but I am happy to be in the hands of the Secretariat as well to confirm that what I'm saying is correct. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:28:28]: Thank you very much, European Union. I understand your questions. I would like to ask to really collect all your views right now, so that we at least have everything reflected on our CRP. Saudi Arabia, you have the floor. Saudi Arabia [2:28:58]: Thank you, Madam Chair. We have some comments regarding paragraph 7. In the subparagraph C, we need to comment in. So to provide the press session documents on time in the six official languages and limit their number and length, and to delete the expression "to continue efforts" at the beginning of this paragraph. In this sub-paragraph F, we would like to delete the reduction of the number of items and of the consideration of matters that do not require specific decisions, and here we support. The opinion expressed about the availability of resources. So this also should be put between brackets. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:30:09]: I do have a question, because I understand that pre-session documents may be subject to translation, but there are some documents, pre-session documents, that are not subject to translation. So I would like also that we bear this in mind. I would like now to give the floor to the Russian Federation. The Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [2:30:36]: Thank you, Chair, and also thanks to Togo. As actually, his intervention brought the thinking exactly along the line of our colleagues from EU. They are absolutely right. And I think we need to sort it out right away. I think that if we keep this paragraph seven with a chapeau Executive Secretary is subject to availability of resources and in consultation with the Bureau, where or as appropriate. We should leave only paragraphs A, B, if there is a decision to leave it, as we said, we believe that can be deleted. D, but again, d in a slight modification, of course, for 17 meeting, we still like to move to the first section. E stays here. And that's it, because from our perspective, when we are talking about paragraph C, That's clearly preparation of press session documents, which is actually the major function of the Secretariat, so it's done from the core budget. So D, if you ask for those guidelines, if they do not exist, I will be happy to ask the Secretariat, as actually some of colleagues believe that those guidelines exist, and if so, then what else needs to be done? F, that for sure can be done within the budget. And G, the decision tracking tool, that, of course, we may consider, and we can listen to the Executive Secretary if it's a substantial expenses and require additional money to finalize the decision tracking tool, then we can leave it under this paragraph. And of course, H, that's an essential element. We will not be able to work if all this group of people are not trained. So we will see it as definitely from the core budget. So in this case, those elements to be moved to 8, because the chapeau of eight is just request to Executive Secretary without resources. So then we sort out two paragraphs. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:33:30]: Yes, thank you very much, Russia Federation. I would like to propose the following, because I see that there are several parties requesting for the floor again, so I would like to propose that the Secretariat, that has already taken all those inputs into consideration, that we do an informal consultation on the reformulation of this paragraph, and then we get back to paragraph 7, and probably another paragraph as well, and we We will try to take everything that you have suggested, and then we will review it together, if possible. It's okay if we proceed like this? And of course, everybody that wants to contribute, I see that only New Zealand and Brazil have not taken the floor. I will give the floor to New Zealand and Brazil, and I ask you that have already suggested something to wait. New Zealand, you have the floor. New Zealand [2:34:50]: Yeah, thanks very much. Well, I think it's been a very interesting discussion and does rather highlight that if we'd had this document earlier, we might have had a chance of having informal discussions in the margins that could have progressed the issues. I think it's a very good idea to differentiate for many of the reasons that have been outlined. Togo raised that in the chapeau, there are some decisions that need to be decided by parties, not the Executive. Secretary, and yet we're merging all of those things. Some require additional resources, some don't. Before COP17 as a priority. Some of our existing rules, like C, which there are rules on the availability of pre-session documents, and are we? Rewriting the rules through this document. Anyway, we would be happy to participate in an informal discussion, but When will this take place, and how will we bring those decisions back to this meeting? Might it not be better to kick this somewhere to our next meeting? Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:36:30]: Okay. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [2:36:34]: Thank you, madam Chair. We would have two minor comments. We would suggest deleting 7E. We struggle to understand the intent here. It seems too broad to us, and we have consistently emphasized that sometimes the use of technological tools. Harm the inclusivity of the process under the. Convention, and the last bit in particular for expediting decision-making process seems a bit unclear to us. So we would request deleting 7E. Regarding 7F, I think we would build on the concerns that were raised by Argentina and New Zealand. It seems that deciding on the retirement of agenda items would be more of a decision by parties, not. Exactly the Executive Secretary. It would be helpful to seek some feedback from the Secretariat on how they would actually implement those sub-paragraphs. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:37:30]: Thank you very much, Brazil. If I may, I think that perhaps F should be including suggesting the retirement of agenda items, because I think that it's the, really, it's the COP that should be dealing with that. But I would like to also try to answer the question that has been raised by New Zealand. I think that we can try to, i can moderate a discussion trying to find a rearrangement of this, of those paragraphs, and then we can get back to it. I understand that we still have some minutes. And I would like to ask if you have any comments on paragraph A, 8, 8A. Argentina. Argentina [2:38:41]: Thank you very much, Chair. Not referring to 8, but 7. Just in relation to some confusion we have in relation to F. We are in favor of including suggesting, and we thank Mexico for the mediation attempts. We'd just like to ask for the consideration of COP. Of course, we think it's important that it's clear that this will be up to COP to decide, and the Executive Secretary needs to provide the information behind this decision. And in this case, we would stand ready to withdraw our proposal to insert brackets. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:39:22]: Thank you very much, Argentina. I see the European Union. European Union, you have the floor. EU [2:39:28]: Thank you, Madam Chair. So, very briefly going back to paragraph 7, well, because while I would be happy to go to another informal group to sort this paragraph out, I think because we have very limited time left, It would be much appreciated to already receive a restructured paragraph 7 that maybe already splits into the different sections, so we can at least start there and can move as fast as possible. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:40:11]: Thank you very much, european Union. would like to do, as a matter of fact, I think that we received all your comments, and I would like to make consultation through e-mail with the Secretariat to help. And then I see that, yes, what we will do, basically, is to take on board some of the language suggestions. We will move paragraph subparagraph D to the COP decision, and we will try to keep here only the sub-paragraphs that relate to the availability of resources, and we will put the other ones on paragraph 8, and of course we will put the suggested retirement for the consideration of the COP on F, and as appropriate on the chapeau, and etc. And then we will just circulate it through e-mail to you, and then afterwards we would like to go back to this. Is it agreeable to all? Okay, I see no objections. Thank you. And I would like now to see if we can perhaps advance a little bit on 8. On paragraph 8(a), Do we have any suggestions? Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [2:42:07]: Maybe it's just technical on the last line. We are talking about responses to relevant notifications, yes, but I don't think there are really responses to decisions in this sense. I don't think it needs to be there. And also right away for B. I think that B is actually just a version of A. Not sure why we need B. CBD · Chair [2:42:44]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. Do we have any other comments on 8A? I understand that the Russian Federation is suggesting to delete "and decisions." But then I would suggest that we also delete off the Conference of the Parties, because I don't think that we have notifications from the COP. Okay, thank you very much. And some as well as responses to relevant notifications. I don't see any further request for the floor, so we agree on paragraph 10. Thank you. And Canada, you have the floor. Canada [2:43:58]: Apologies, Madam Chair. I think you spoke a little bit too soon. I mean, I take the point about, i think the confusion is responses as the verb. So, you know, responses to notification. We don't really have responses to decisions. But I could see situations in which We have decisions which are relevant for us thinking about ways to improve effectiveness of processes other than this specific agenda item. Certainly, you know, in the context of here at this meeting of the agenda item on functional review, it's very relevant. And so I think we would want to take those into account. And so I don't think it would be appropriate to remove decisions, but I think we'd probably have to tweak the text. in a way that it's not just responses, so perhaps as well as the responses to relevant notifications, as well as relevant decisions of the Conference of the Parties. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:45:00]: Thank you very much, Canada. I think that we are – thank you very much. We will reflect this. I think that we are running out of time. Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [2:45:14]: Yeah, I may support Canada in a slightly different way because, first of all, decisions, so it will be after processes in line with decisions as well as response to relevant notifications. CBD · Chair [2:45:29]: Thank you very much, Russia Federation. So I understand that this can be packed as it was just suggested. I would like to ask the Secretariat to please read it out loud. Thank you. Secretary, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [2:45:53]: Thank you, Chair. Paragraph 8A now reads as follows: To continue to explore and make use of, it continues, and then you get to, and United Nations processes in line with the decisions the Conference of the Parties, as well as the responses to relevant notifications. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:46:25]: Thank you. Thank you very much, Secretariat. Can we agree with this proposed text? I see no objections. Thank you very much. I will just consult with the Secretariat. One moment. Okay, colleagues, I will ask the Secretariat to make a proposal on our work forward. Yes, Secretariat, you have the floor. CBD · Secretariat representative [2:47:17]: Thank you very much, Madam Chair. We would like to propose that we take a dinner break from 5:30 to 6:30 this evening, also because it's. The time for end of the fasting period during the day. Then from 6:30 to 8:30, we keep the time for informals. There are two possible requests, one on effectiveness, the other one on financial mechanism. And then we have a final plenary from 9 to 11 PM, which will meet here. And that will also include the. Yeah, and then we will have the time to adopt all the L documents and closing. Thank you, Madam Chair. CBD · Chair [2:48:06]: Thank you very much, Secretariat, colleagues, apologies. I know this has been a long week for us all, but could we please agree with this proposal from the Secretariat so that we can deliver results from this meeting to the COP? Thank you. Oh, yes, Argentina, you have the floor. Argentina [2:48:32]: Just to check, the informal meetings are going to be in this place? Are they going to be in the same place? CBD · Chair [2:48:45]: Just a moment, I will ask the Secretariat. CBD · Secretariat representative [2:48:57]: So, sorry, my apologies. The financial mechanism will meet. In the Red Room, and I'm looking at Jibin because he's standing in front of me. Is that correct? Speaker 261 [2:49:08]: Yes, and then the effectiveness will meet here in the plenary room. CBD · Chair [2:50:05]: Okay, colleagues, could we proceed like this? I see no objection. Thank you, thank you very much. So I will elaborate a paragraph, a new paragraph 7, and I would like to take this opportunity to move us forward on this CRP as well, with your indulgence. So we can suspend this session right now, and we will reconvene at 6:30. Thank you. Thank you very much. No, we will not reconvene the plenary, but be here on 6:30 to continue the appreciation of effectiveness. Thank you.