Skip to main content

3rd Meeting, 5th Session, Forum on Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law

14 October 2025·04:00·03:01:10Meetings & Events

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

Chair

So, dear participants, excellencies, I hereby declare open the fourth panel of the fifth session of the United Nations Forum on Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law. The title of this panel is "Legal Clarity, Democratic Defense and Creativity". This panel will consist of six presentations. Each speaker will have a maximum of eight minutes. for their presentation. Approximately 30 minutes will be reserved for questions and statements from the end of the floor, from the end of the, from the floor. So, the list of speakers is now open if you wish to inscribe yourselves. And let me introduce the distinguished panelists. We have with us His Excellency Mr. Sumbue Antas, Permanent Representative of the Republic of Vanuatu; Ms. Liliana Avila, Director of the Inter-American Association for Environmental Defense, Human Rights and Environment Program; Ms. Shuraya Ahmad Pauzi, Deputy Permanent Representative of Malaysia in Geneva; Mr. Chris Mburu, Chief of Africa Branch of Ad Interim, Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights; Ms. Maria Diamandopoulou, Chair of the Ad Hoc Multidisciplinary Group on the Environment at the Council of Europe; And last, Mr. Danilo Garrido Alves, legal counsel for campaigns at Greenpeace. Now, let me now turn to Mr. Clément Nyalitsosy Vule, senior research fellow at the Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights and former United Nations Special Rapporteur on the rights to freedom of peaceful assembly and association, who will moderate the discussion. Mr. Vule, you have the floor.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Ambassador. I want also to thank all of you for coming to this session. I think this panel is so important in our time because you will be talking about several initiatives that happened this recent year, which then impacts the way that we see the climate change, but also push the boundary, I would say, in terms of the legal perspective. So I want just to start, because we have only one hour and 30 minutes, Excellency, and to make sure that you can have a floor to be able to to ask questions, to contribute. I think we will start right away. I want also to invite all panelists. Since the ambassador already introduced the panelists, I won't go again to introduce them. But they can, whenever they take the floor within their eight minute, they can maybe talk a little bit in one second about their own work. But I want just to also encourage our panelists. Since this is talking about regional perspective, this is talking about what happened in this recent year, I want also to connect, invite all of you to connect this with democratic process, how democratic process in the country can trigger or can strengthen such process, such legal process that happened recently? How indigenous communities are able to participate in these processes? How without democratic institution, such achievement cannot happen? So I want also to invite you also to connect that. And I will start as in the order that your excellency, you present it. I will start with his excellency Ambassador Sumbhu, and thus, and the ICG recent decision, some may say, and then the ICG also mentioned that, that this decision is really an existential change, because that's the climate change is an existential threat. And what is your perspective and how this decision also, we can expect that decision can impact the way that states handle climate crisis issue, but also companies and all of those that polluted the planet today, how this decision can change them? What will be their legal obligation? And can we talk a little bit about this?

VanuatuPermanent Representative

Thank you, moderator. Good morning, everyone. The questions being asked for me to respond to is The International Court of Justice advisory opinion, what is next? And the ICJ advisory opinion has been hailed, as mentioned by the moderator, as a turning point for climate justice. How can the ICJ advisory opinion be leveraged to hold major polluters accountable for climate harm? So in the last, since the advisory opinion was issued in July, this year. We had a plastics treaty discussions here, it failed. And we can ask the question, why did it fail? Because there's lots of pressure from those who, the source of plastics, who ensured that, wanted to see a balance, I'm not sure if it's balanced, but something that would prevent us, the world, from agreeing to a plastics treaty, plastics ocean treaty. The second thing I want to mention right at the beginning is, last week, the Pacific countries pushed for a Human Rights Council resolution on sea level rise. Despite our major efforts, we were not able to meet the objectives, trying to use language from the ICJ advisory opinion into a Human Rights Council resolution on climate, on sea level rise. Why was that? Again, there was a lot of pressure. And so the question that's being asked here, how can the ICJ advisory opinion be leveraged to hold major polluters accountable? It is a very, very big task we must do, we must take. So I am honored to speak to you on this important topic, and I thank the forum for this opportunity. This is an important question, one that demands a deep understanding of the International Court of Justice's advisory opinion on climate change. The opinion represents a defining moment in international climate law and governance. It not only clarifies states' legal duties in addressing climate change, but also provides the foundation for transforming legal principles into concrete accountability, especially for major polluters whose actions or inaction have global consequences. The ICJ affirms a simple truth, very simple truth: states have clear legal duties to prevent climate harm, to protect human rights, and to regulate private actors, including through the phase out of fossil fuels. The ICJ has gone further clarifying that failure to act, whether through continued fossil fuel production, consumption, granting of fossil fuel exploration licenses, or the provision of fossil fuel subsidies, can amount to an internationally wrongful act. These opinions are not abstract legal theories. They speak directly to the lived reality of people in Vanuatu, in a lot of Pacific Island countries, and a lot of countries in the world. Rising seas, stronger cyclones, and the slow loss of territory are not environmental issues. They are violations of the fundamental human rights to exist with dignity and security. That is why accountability lies at the heart of this discussion. The ICJ’s advisory opinion has rightly been hailed as a turning point for climate justice. It provides us with the legal clarity we have long sought. But now the task is to translate that clarity into concrete accountability. For Vanuatu, this begins at multilateral level. We are currently advancing a UN General Assembly resolution to endorse and operationalize the ICJ findings. The resolution will embed the Court's conclusions in the UN frameworks, strengthen accountability mechanisms in New York and Geneva, and empower human rights institutions, treaty bodies, and special rapporteurs to monitor States' compliance with their climate obligations. It is also to advance action on fossil fuel phase-out, equitable climate finance, and the protection of our oceans and areas where major emitters conduct has global consequences. At home, Vanuatu is translating these legal duties into domestic action. Our updated nationally determined contributions reflect our duty to prevent harm and safeguard communities, and we have just issued this NDC about three weeks ago. We are also advancing a constitutional amendment to enshrine the right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment, ensuring that in the national law, clarifications are reflected in national protection. Originally, through the Pacific Islands Forum, we are integrating these principles into our cooperation, from maritime decarbonisation to expanding marine protected areas. These are tangible examples of how legal clarity can guide policy change. Excellencies, colleagues and friends, the ICJ opinion has also offered an opportunity to address systematic inequities in global climate governance. Too often, consensus-based processes have left the most climate-vulnerable states with the least voice. By embedding principles of equity, common but differentiated responsibilities, and accountability into the UN resolution, we can begin to correct these historical imbalances and ensure fairness in how obligations are applied. including for those most responsible for emissions. Finally, let me emphasize: accountability is not about punishment. It is about protection. It ensures that the rights and lives of those most affected are no longer disregarded. The ICJ opinion empowers states and communities to insist that those who cause harm, whether through action or inaction, are held responsible under international law. The Court has given us legal clarity. Now, the responsibility lies with us to turn that clarity into justice. Accountability is the bridge between law and justice, between words on paper and the protection of lives and rights. Thank you very much.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Ambassador. Thank you for highlighting some of the initiatives that your country is carrying out currently, but also the fact that this opinion also clarifies some of the accountability issues and that the states now need also to take necessary measure to protect climate. So I'm turning to you, Liliana. And the Inter-American Court also issue an advisory opinion. The ICG talk about the existential threats, Inter-American Commission talk about the climate emergency. I'm sure in these processes there have been a number of the participation from the community. Please tell us how this decision shape legal and policy response in the American, but also what can we expect from now that decision that country will be taking?

AIDADirector, Human Rights and Environment Program

Thank you. Good morning, distinguished delegates and colleagues. It's a true honor to be here today to reflect how democracy, human rights, and climate action can and must reinforce each other. Last April, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights issued its advisory opinion on climate emergency and human rights. This is not just another legal test. is a landmark of hope, a moral and legal call for all states in the America to act decisively and democratically to confront the climate crisis. The advisory opinion request by Colombia and Chile was followed by the most participatory process in the court's history. Over 200 interventions were presented in seven days of hearings. Not only states, but also indigenous people, Afro-descended communities, young scientists, and human rights organizations were present. This show how urgent is for states to respond. Citizens are no longer asking if states should act. They're asking how and when. Because the climate crisis is not a future threat. It's a present reality already harming the rights of millions, mostly of them marginalized. In response, the court did something historic. It officially recognized that the world is facing a climate emergency. This recognition was based in three elements. The first one, the urgency and effective action. The second, the severity of the impacts. And the third one, the complexity of the response required. The court warned that even if the Paris Agreement goals are met, a temperature raise of 1.5 degrees will still cause irreversible human rights impacts. The courts rely on the best available science. It found that current policies are leading us toward catastrophic scenarios, and adaptation efforts and funding are coming too late. Developed countries are carrying most of the adaptation costs, which goes against the principle of common but differentiating responsibilities and the polluter space principle. This is not only unfair, it contrasts international legal principles of the rule of law of climate governance. By declaring this climate emergency, they could reshape the legal landscape of our region. It made clear that a state has binding obligations to prevent, mitigate, and repair climate harm under human rights law. One of the most powerful contribution of the decision is the concept of enhanced due diligence, the due diligence at the highest standards. That means that the states should act proactively and ambitiously and not readily And they must, according to what court rules, first, identify and assess climate risk, take prevent measures, use the science, integrate a human rights approach, ensure transparency and accountability, regulate corporate conduct, guarantee access to justice, and strange international cooperation. But beyond this legal reason, there is a deeper message the court is telling you. The call is telling us that the way out of the climate emergency is through more democracy, not less. Through participation, accountability, and inclusion, not technocracy of silence. In times with misinformation, corporate lobbying, and short-term policies still delay actions. They could remind us that the rule of law, transparency, and citizen participation are the strongest tools we have to climate justice. This opinion is also about people. It's about the communities already suffering loss and damages, the young people demanding livelihood futures, and the indigenous people defending forests and rivers, often at at great risk. The court recognized of a climate, the club recognition of a climate emergency gives legal voice to those who have been calling for action for decades. It turns the claims into a legal duties. So what does it mean for us here today in this forum? It means that responding to the climate emergency is not optional. is a human rights imperative. The Inter-American Court has given us not only a legal framework, but also a language of hope, one that connects law, scientists, and moral duties. It calls us to transfer commitments into actions and actions into justice. Thank you.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Ms. Iliana. And thank you also for really bringing this nexus between the climate and the democracy. And you mentioned currently, the court is saying that the only issue to be able to mitigate the impacts on environment is democratic institution, is the participation, is the participation of indigenous people, is the participation of scientific, is the participation of all society in shaping the norms, in shaping also policies that can help to advance the combat against global warming. So I want also to turn now to Mrs. Soraya Ahmad, and I know that ASEAN will be probably adopting its declaration by the end of this month, probably. Tell us a little bit about that. Do you think that all of this, from the ICJ opinion to the Inter-American Commission opinion, this will also have impacts on how ASEAN also will shape its declaration?

MalaysiaDeputy Permanent Representative

Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Madrit-Tavouille. Assalamu alaikum and good morning, excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. On behalf of the Permanent Representative of Malaysia, I would like to express our sincere thanks, first of all, to the organizers for inviting us, as you said, ASEAN Chair this year, to speak at this panel. We are especially glad about the timing, as Mr. Vule mentioned, as ASEAN gets ready to adopt its most impactful declaration on environment. Here, I'm referring to the ASEAN Declaration on the Right to a Safe, Clean, Healthy, and Sustainable Environment. This is a document three years in the making, and once adopted, it will serve as ASEAN's first dedicated framework recognizing environmental rights with our human rights system. But first, a bit of background. ASEAN's journey began almost six decades ago, inspired by a vision of peace, stability, and prosperity. Today, over 680 million people live in the Southeast Asian region. which is about 8.5% of the world's population. As a regional grouping representing these many lives, ASEAN has a long and solid record of coming together on environmental and climate change issues. Since the 1980s, ASEAN's commitment to this has been reflected in our various annual documents and declarations. Even at the Conference of Parties, ASEAN actively issues joint statements, reiterating its commitment as a regional grouping towards protecting the environment. It was in 2002 that we adopted our first environmental agreement, which is the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution. We then established the ASEAN Centre for Biodiversity in 2005, and it will celebrate its 20th anniversary this year. In 2012, we launched the ASEAN Action Plan on Joint Response to Climate Change. And in the same year, our leaders adopted the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration. So this declaration is notable in this context because it has a specific Article 28F that recognizes the right of every person to a safe, clean, and sustainable environment. And we also have this ASEAN body on human rights called the ASEAN Intergovernmental Commission on Human Rights. And they have consistent related initiatives, organizing programs on climate change, pollution, environmental impact assessments, and the role of communities and business in environmental protection. So as chair this year, Malaysia also leads the dialogue at the ASEAN Environmental Ministers Meetings. And we have a theme for this year, and we call it ASEAN One Voice. Accelerating Climate Action for Stewardship, Partnership, and Ownership. So as the theme itself suggests, we are indeed looking for an ASEAN-led, ASEAN-owned contribution to environmental rights. And this year, we've had numerous regional initiatives. Among others, the member states have all signed agreement on the establishment of the ASEAN Center for Climate Change, and this will be in Brunei. The meetings also made progress in two key documents. One is the development of the post-2025 ASEAN Strategic Plan on Environment, and two is the ASEAN Climate Change Strategic Action Plan. So as Chair of ASEAN, it goes without saying that Malaysia actively supports and encourages the strengthening of regional climate governance mechanisms, and we will continue to do so when we are no longer Chair. Ladies and gentlemen, The ASEAN Declaration on the Right to a Safe, Clean, Healthy, and Sustainable Environment is the culmination of great effort among all member states. This is expected to be adopted by the ASEAN leaders in Kuala Lumpur later this month, which is next, next weekend. Besides advancing on Article 28F, I mentioned, in the ASEAN Human Rights Declaration, it articulates a regional commitment to universally recognized environmental rights. The declaration, among others, underscores key commitments. So one, progressive enforcement of environmental law in line with international standards, to answer Mr. Bulley's question. Two, transparent and inclusive environmental impact assessments. Due diligence to the private sector, including use of green technologies and scientific data. And four, protection of indigenous people, environmental defenders, and vulnerable communities in which there are many and varied in ASEAN. So negotiating this document, ASEAN maintains that equity, justice, and most important of all, means of implementation remain crucial factors in empowering developing countries like ours to undertake greater climate action. And although the declaration is technically non-legally binding and entails no new financial or legal obligations, it does represent our collective moral and policy commitment to sustainable development and human rights. And it still points to all ASEAN member states as duty bearers. And it helps all the ASEAN member states to harmonize national policies, coordinate regional initiatives, and ensure that environmental protections are implemented inclusively and effectively across the region. And further, it will enable ASEAN organs and sector bodies under the ASEAN umbrella, civil society, and private actors to develop their own action lines and good practices. And we are convinced it will serve as a transformative game changer consistent with the spirit of ASEAN Community Vision. We call it ASEAN 2045, our shared future. So before I conclude, I would also like to share some points on Malaysia's own initiatives. From the national standpoint, Malaysia shares the view that climate change poses a serious threat to the full realization of human rights for all people. The climate governance landscape in Malaysia has evolved rapidly in terms of efficiency and sustainability. In this regard, we have adopted various strategies that embrace a green future. We have enacted policies such as the National Climate Change Policy, the National Energy Transition Roadmap, and the Environmental, Social, and Governance Framework. But on top of that, we have also amended certain laws. Last year, the Malaysian Parliament passed the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Act. So these indicate our commitment to the issues. In this regard, we look forward to working with all to promote and protect the environment and tackle the problem of climate change together.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you. Thank you very much, Ms. Suraya. For it also pointing also the action that your country also is taking and on your country view that climate change pose a serious threat for the realization of human rights. I want now to turn on Mr. Chris Guru. You are the chief of the African section, and there have been also, as the same at Asian level, initiative from the continent to ask the African Court on Human and People's Rights to to issue an advisory opinion in relation to the state responsibility or the state responsibility towards human rights when responding to the climate issue. So I just want also to know from your perspective, if you think that the Court's opinion will be building on what we already hear here in terms of ICG opinion, Inter-American, and what are some of the participation on climate justice issue that this opinion will contain probably?

OHCHRChief, Africa Branch, ad interim

Thank you very much. And it has been very interesting to sit here and listen to some of the other experiences from different regions, because this is an issue of global concern. And I am very glad to share with you some of the developments that are happening in the continent. of Africa on this issue, because it's out of a recognition that it's indeed an issue on which you should engage the legal processes, legal jurisdictions in the continent in general. Now, we've had what has been happening in the other areas, like in the Inter-American Court, Asia, ASEAN. Within the African continent, on the 2nd of May, the African Court on Human and People's Rights received a request for an advisory opinion by the Pan-African Lawyers Union. This was a group of civil society organizations that came together, including what we call the Africa Climate Platform, Natural Justice, Resilient 40, an environmental lawyers collective for Africa. And the idea was invoking the obligation of states in the context of climate change under the African Charter on Human and People's Rights. In doing so, the petitioners invite the African Court of Human and People's Rights to interpret its Article 24, which guarantees the right to a general satisfactory environment in a way that explicitly addresses climate change. And now, if you let me just tell you the background to this and why it was seen as such an urgent issue to be canvassed before the court. The average temperatures across Africa in 2024 were approximately 0.86 degrees centigrade above the 1991-2020 average, making 2024 the warmest or second warmest year on record, 1900 to the present. depending on the dataset used. The past decade has been the warmest on record. Africa is one of the lowest contributors to greenhouse gas emissions causing climate change, yet key development sectors have already experienced widespread losses and damages attributable to human-induced climate change, including biodiversity loss, water shortages, reduced food production, displacement, loss of lives, and reduced economic growth. There's been exposure and vulnerability to climate change in Africa that are multidimensional with socioeconomic, political, and environmental factors intersecting. Africans are disproportionately employed in climate-exposed sectors. 55 to 62% of the sub-Saharan workforce is employed in agriculture, and 95% of cropland is rain-fed. In rural Africa, poor and female-headed households face greater livelihood risks from climate hazards. In urban areas, growing informal settlements without basic services increase the vulnerability of large populations to climate hazards, especially women, children, and the elderly. Throughout 2024, exceptionally heavy rainfall and devastating floods affected multiple locations across Africa, causing widespread fatalities, displacements, and infrastructure damage. In Western Central Africa, torrential rains impacted millions of people, with Nigeria, Niger, Chad, Cameroon, and the Central African Republic among the hardest hit. Prolonged drought in Southern Africa, for example, the drought led to widespread crop failures, food insecurity, and significant humanitarian and environmental challenges. Critically, low water levels in Lake Kariba, the world's largest man-made lake, caused severe electricity shortages in Zimbabwe and Zambia, drastically reducing hydroelectric power generation, triggering prolonged blackouts and economic disruptions. So it's against this context that this advisory opinion was sought before the Court. The petition seeks clarification on the positive climate obligation of African states under the African Charter on Human and People's Rights. Petition, paragraph 93B: In doing so, it invites the African Court to interpret Article 24 in a way that addresses climate change, as I said before. The request notes that, as a result of the climate crisis, several human rights are affected. including the right to life, article 4 of the Charter, the right to health, article 16 of the Charter, the right to economic, social, and cultural development, articles 21, 22, and 24 of the Charter, the right to a satisfactory environment conducive to development, which we have cited before, and several others. The petition additionally seeks clarification on States' obligation in respect to adaptation. resilience and mitigation measures, as well as the obligation to cooperate internationally. See that they're trying to make sure that the issue is interrelated globally and interconnected, and that the actions are done in synchronicity. Similar to the ICJ advisory opinion, This underscores the inextricable link between human rights and environmental law. The petitioners urge the court to consider other relevant instruments. And again, that's where we are trying to bring it closer to the others and get some sort of a judicial solidarity beyond the African Charter, and to interpret and lay down applicable custom. with Article 4 of the Protocol establishing the Court, which limits this to human rights instruments. And finally, I just want to, i can't raise all the issues, but the questions raised in the petition, what, if any, are the state's specific human rights and people's rights obligations to protect and safeguard the rights of individuals and peoples of the past? present and future generations affected by the adverse negative impacts of climate change, considering the relevant provisions of the African Charter. Given the unique significant implications of the responsibilities and duties to vulnerable individuals and populations, whether State Parties to the African Charter on Human Rights have positive obligations to protect vulnerable populations, including environmental, human rights defenders, indigenous communities, women, children, youth, future generations, the current generation, past generations, the elderly, and people with disabilities from the impact of climate change in line with the relevant treaties. Third, what if any are applicable human rights obligations of states to facilitate a just, transparent, equitable and accountable transition in the context of climate change in Africa? D) What, if any, are the applicable obligations of African states in the implementation of adaptation, resilience, and mitigation measures in response to climate change? What responsibilities, if any, do African states have in relation to third parties? This is very important. including international monopolies, multinational corporations, and non-state actors operating on the continent to ensure that international and regional treaties and laws on climate change are respected, protected, promoted, and implemented? And lastly, what, if any, is the nature of the obligation on African states to cooperate in the framework of international cooperation with other states, especially historical emitters, to limit global warming to below 1.5 degrees centigrade threshold to avert an existential climate crisis for present and future generations. So that is what are the developments that have been going on on the African continent. The process before the court right now is once the advisory opinion request is submitted, The court registers the request, which it has, and conduct a preliminary examination to ensure it meets admissibility criteria. We believe that this by far large conforms to the criteria, and the final advisory opinion is adopted by a majority of the judges and issued in writing. So we are expecting that we are going to get some good judgments, and especially since the court has been conversed to look into other jurisdictions, which I know it will, I believe that we will have a good result from the court. Thank you.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Chris, Ms. Kristin Buru. And we also hope that as the same at Asian Declaration, but also the African Court on Human and Peoples' Rights opinion, advisory opinion, we hope that also that this both initiative will again reinforce what the ICJ was saying, but also what the Inter-American was also, as climate emergency, climate existence threat, but also the important part, which the reason why we are here, to establish also that in fighting against global warming, states have responsibility towards human rights protection, towards indigenous people, that the participation, that the democratic institutions are key in dealing with climate issues. So, Mr. Maria-Juan Pulon, I want also to turn on you. We hear about Africa, Inter-American Commission, we hear about Asia. Now, you are the the chair of the ad hoc multidisciplinary group on the environment at the Council of Europe, and the Council of Europe also are taking quite initiative, important initiative, and it will be important also in order to kind of complete the picture, to hear about you, what is happening there, how Council of Europe initiative are also reinforcing what we hear here in relation to the clear legal obligation that states have towards the climate protection.

CoEChair, Ad Hoc Multidisciplinary Group on the Environment

Thank you, Mr. Moderator, for this very helpful introduction, and I take this opportunity also to thank you, Mr. Chair, for this professional way you are leading our today's forum. Dear participants, in May 2023, the Reykjavik Summit marked a pivotal moment for the Council of Europe. because it reaffirmed a collective commitment to address environmental challenges as a priority for the organisation and its 46 member states. Building on this momentum, this summit laid the foundation for the Council of Europe's strategy on the environment for the period 2025-2030. This strategy was prepared, as you mentioned, Mr. Moderator, by an intergovernmental body, the Multidisciplinary Group on the Environment, that I have the honor to chair. The strategy was adopted last May by the Committee of Ministers, which is a governing body of this organization, and embodies a forward-looking and holistic vision aligning environmental protection with the core values of the Organization, which are human rights, democracy, and the rule of law. At the heart of this strategy is the recognition that a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment is essential for the full enjoyment of human rights. And to that end, the strategy sets out five key objectives. Firstly, to integrate human rights considerations into environment-related strategies, instruments, legislations, policies, and actions. Secondly, to promote the principles of good democratic governance within environmental governance. Thirdly, to support and to protect environmental human rights defenders, environmental defenders, and whistleblowers. Fourthly, to prevent and prosecute environment-related crimes, and finally, to protect wildlife, ecosystems, habitats, and landscapes. The strategy also calls for just transitions, inclusive public participation, transparency, and, of course, accountability. It supports the recognition at the national level of the right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment. At the same time, it addresses growing concerns over democratic backsliding, misinformation, and the serious impact of environmental degradation on vulnerable communities. Crucially, it acknowledges the voices of children and young people, who have consistently called for urgent action. Their leadership in transformative initiatives underscores the urgency of achieving climate justice and of ending the triple planetary crisis. In order to address these concerns, the strategy also envisions practical guidance in order to ensure effective and equal access to justice and remedies in environmental matters, access to information, to education, and awareness raising to improve transparency through time, and of course, meaningful public participation in environmental decision making. It also provides targeted measures, such as legal assistance, protection from threats, and, of course, access to justice, in order to support environmental human rights defenders, ensuring that they can make the work without undue restrictions. Moreover, the organization's monitoring system is designed to enhance accountability, but also provides guidance to improve legislation, policies, and practices. In a very significant development, last May, the Committee of Ministers adopted the Convention on the Protection of the Environment through Criminal Law. This new Convention targets serious environmental crimes, such as unlawful pollution, habitat destruction, and wildlife trafficking. A provision on particularly serious offences encompasses intentional unlawful conduct that could lead to severe results, such as widespread pollution, major industrial accidents, or large-scale forest fires. Such offences may be comparable to what we call ecocide, already present in the national legislation of Member States, at least of some of them. The Convention also strengthens protection for whistleblowers and victims of environmental harm. A full chapter on prevention measures is also included. covering awareness raising campaigns and recognising the important role of civil society and other stakeholders. Ladies and gentlemen, this new Convention will be opened for signature in Strasbourg on 3 December of this year, not only to Council of Europe member states, but also to all states in the world. I therefore invite you to call on your governments to sign and to ratify this groundbreaking convention as soon as possible. The European Court of Human Rights has also played a transformative role. Its jurisprudence, spanning over 300 environmental cases, has covered pollution, disasters, access to information, and public participation. Beyond the Court, the European Committee of Social Rights contributes meaningfully to this agenda. Through its collective complaints procedure, open to all NGOs, it addresses the social impacts of environmental degradation, ensuring that the right to health, housing, and safe working conditions are well protected. In conclusion, my ambition today is to convey to you the message that the Council of Europe can play a key role in the efforts of the international community to protect the environment. Its unique contribution lies at the intersection of the environment, human rights, rule of law, and democracy. Thank you very much for your kind attention.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Ms. Maria Diamantopoulou, for also bringing and for also enlightening us in relation to what is happening around the Council of Europe. I want also to second your call again and ask all of the states also to sign this convention. And I think any small action is important that states can take, that everyone can take, to mitigate or to fight against climate degradation is essential for the future and for saving the planet. So I want to thank you for that. We will turn now on our last speakers, who is Mr. Danilo Gariu Alves, you are the legal counsel campaign at the Greenpeace. So I know that in all of these processes, to achieve some of these great initiatives that we just hear from different regions, the participation is important. The climate justice activism are important, and you mentioned this, Maria, in terms of ensuring that these climate activists have space, that they can operate in a democratic processes, they can operate without fear of reprisal. So I want to know from your organization perspective, how litigation, how some of these action are important to really advance climate issue around the world? And how do you think these processes cannot happen without any conducive environment for the work of civil society, without democratic processes, without rule of law.

Greenpeace InternationalLegal Counsel for Campaigns

Perfect. Thank you very much, Mr. Vule, for the questions, and also many thanks to the organizers of this forum for this kind invitation to speak. As a background, I'm a legal counsel at Greenpeace International, so I'll be speaking both from an NGO perspective and a litigator's perspective on this issue. My intervention will be in three parts. First, I'll talk about strategic litigation and the state of climate action. Second, on what I like to call the new era of climate accountability. And finally, on the increasing use of strategic litigation against climate action. So firstly, I would like to recall a quote by Professor Jeffrey Sachs, former UN Special Advisor, who said three powerful words: "Flood the courts." He was encouraging every actor to bring climate suits, and that might have very well resonated. That speech was from 2017, and now we have over a thousand climate cases against corporations, states, individuals in all continents. More keep being filed year after year. I would argue that in 2025, we need not only to flood the courts, but to do so strategically. That is, bringing cases that have a strategic ambition, cases that are concerned with broader systemic, governmental, or corporate change. and also cases that are litigated strategically, that is, cases that are not seen in isolation, but in dialogue with what is happening in the global climate movement and that have the potential to inspire others to take climate action. That is because the sad truth is that cases by themselves will hardly get us the results we need and want to tackle the climate crisis. Don't get me wrong, it is a very important tool, litigation, to drive climate action, and one that has yielded some of the best results we have seen in the past years in scaling climate ambition. But to be most effective, it must be accompanied by strategic communication, political action, and civil society engagement, all of which are essential elements of what I call a strategic litigation. Something fascinating happens if you have all these elements in place. You can actually drive climate action, even if the outcomes of a case are not a win in the traditional sense. Unsuccessful cases on the courts can be just as effective drivers of climate action if you are working in a strategic litigation framework. This is what happened, for instance, in the Klima Seniorinnen versus Switzerland case, which was a landmark legal win in the European Court of Human Rights in 2024, but only after a series of decisions by Swiss courts that repeatedly rejected the plight of the claimants, which was an association of Swiss senior women who were disproportionately impacted by climate change. So this links me to the second part of my intervention, that we have now entered a new era of climate accountability at a global level. In the past two years, we have had five incredible decisions by international courts on this topic. Two of them have been mentioned, the ICJ and the Inter-American Court decisions. Hopefully, we'll have a sixth very good decision from the African Court as well. But I would also highlight three others that are quite significant. The after decision in Greenpeace versus Norway that said that states must take scope three emissions into consideration while doing environmental impact assessments. The first of this wave, which was an advisory opinion by the ITLOS on the marine environment, and also the climate scenario case I mentioned from the European Court of Human Rights. These decisions, they have been very important in clarifying what the legal rules are, especially the AOs, and now we need to build upon them. That is because even contentious cases in international courts are not the end all for climate action. And what we really need to push this is implementation at the domestic level. So three areas I would just highlight here that, to me, are very ripe for courts to act in terms of implementation are on NDCs and the climate plans that are adopted domestically to meet them. The ICJ clarified that if states do not show the highest possible ambition, there could be breaches of international law. on the state failure to regulate high-emitting sectors, especially the fossil fuel industry. This has been an area that was explicitly mentioned by the ICJ in its advisory opinion, who said that new licensing, exploitation, exploration, and subsidizing of fossil fuels could be breaches of international law as well. And finally, on the state failure to respect, protect, and fulfill the right to a clean, sustainable, and healthy environment, especially when the state is not taking measures to address those that are disproportionately affected by climate change, such as women, children, senior citizens, coastal communities. And now going to the final part of my presentation. that this trend of strategic litigation for climate action is also being met by another trend of strategic litigation against climate action. As this is a forum about human rights, democracy, and rule of law, it's important to stress how the courts are being used to clamp down on civil society and political dissent. A 2024 report by Michelle Force Special Rapporteur on Environmental Defenders under the Aarhus Convention, found that state repression of environmental protests was a major threat to human rights and democracy. And this repression often includes criminal charges and other uses of the legal system against activists. This phenomenon, however, is not restricted to states, but also corporations who use the legal system to try to silence dissent. Many NGOs, including Greenpeace International and other Greenpeace organizations, have been targeted by what we call SLAPP suits, or strategic litigation against public participation, claims that often lack any merit and whose purpose is, as the name suggests, to silence those who stand up against harmful state or corporate actions. And those laps are not trivial. In some cases, they can rank up to the hundreds of millions of US dollars in claims, such as one that Greenpeace is currently fighting, and that was in the United States for $660 million. For a lot of NGOs, this means that if those cases are successful, they will close doors. And this have a very worrying, chilling effect on other organizations as well. But there is hope even in those scenarios. There are initiatives such as the EU Anti-SLAPP Directive that are being used to stop the courts from being manipulated by interests in that manner. I would say, um, as my final remark, that even in the face of those lapses and almost paradoxically, climate action can still take place, uh, if they are strategically countered, this is what happened in another case. in the UK at this time, Shell versus Greenpeace UK and Greenpeace International, which initially was for 8 million pounds. And then thanks to civil society movement, very engagement, not only from civil society organizations, but also from the public, it was reduced to 1 million pounds and then finally settled with no money being paid to the corporation. So thank you very much. I appreciate once again the invitation.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Mr. Danilo, for also pointing out some of these important initiatives, strategic litigation, but also the use at the national of both from states, but also from the corporates of slabs in undermining the capacity of the climate activists to be able to challenge some of the climate damage. So, we have a little bit of time, and I would like also maybe to get back to you, and maybe if you want to elaborate more or anything in relation to how do you see the rule of law and the democracy being like a driver for this action. You mentioned this, Mr. Danilo, and I would like also to hear in particular from Maria, in terms of inter-American level, how indigenous people, the participation was instrumental in ensuring that the Court's decision reflects what those indigenous people want and what really is important to advance climate justice. Yes, I will start with you. One minute, sir.

AIDADirector, Human Rights and Environment Program

Okay, thank you. Firstly, the Inter-American Court has a huge opportunity to people and communities and NGOs to present their statement before the court. And many indigenous communities and local communities participate in the process, and they went by their own to present themselves, their request. and they focus mostly on the right to participation and, of course, the land protection. And historically, the Inter-American Court has also developed a really good standard on land protection and indigenous people. So in the decision, the court mentioned that human rights defenders and indigenous people are vital to protect the climate system, and that's why they need to be protected. And also, the highest standard of due diligence mentioned that in cases that involve indigenous people and local communities, a high standard of participation and prior consultation is requested. So this kind of a legal action promoted also for all the advocacy of the indigenous people and local communities were vital in the process of the human rights, the Inter-American Advisory Opinion process.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you. Thank you very much. And Ms. Marie, I want also to turn on you also to see what role civil society plays, really critical role in how the Council of Europe advance climate protection.

CoEChair, Ad Hoc Multidisciplinary Group on the Environment

Thank you very much. I can tell you from my experience as chair of the GME that civil society was always present in our deliberations from day one. As this ad hoc committee started its work one year ago, in September 2024, we have had until now four meetings, and the fifth and last one is scheduled to take place in December. And during this meeting, we'll have, as I mentioned, the signature of the new convention. And also in some of our bureau meetings, hybrid ones, in January this year, we took into consideration and we managed to ensure the participation of all NGOs. So their opinions, their views, their experience is always respected and taken into consideration in the drafting of the new strategy. But allow me just to add a few details about the new convention. which, as I said before, and you mentioned too, will be open for our signature and we invite all member states. It consists of 58 articles, and it's divided in chapters in order to be more readable and more effective. The minimum of signatures needed for its implementation are 10. out of which eight from Council's member states and two of third states that have participated in the elaboration of this convention, and of course to all states around the world. Thank you very much.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much. And I will also, Christian Bohl, I will also turn on you if you don't. Now there is this initiative around there. African context to see the African Court to adopt this advisory opinion, what will be the instrumental role that civil society will be playing, in particular, for me, the indigenous people? Because they are most affected, and also any democratic processes, we need also people that are affected to be able also to inform and to impact how the policies are designed. Do you think the court will also be open to hear from these indigenous people, will be open also to take on board their concern.

OHCHRChief, Africa Branch, ad interim

Thank you. From my understanding of the processes that take place in these petitions, they try as much as possible to involve the civil society, and I know that PALU is really engaged, they really want to succeed, and they know that for them to succeed, they really have to engage the civil society. As I sat here, I was texting with one of the lawyers in Palu, in Arusha right now, and she was telling me that they are ready to give it all, and they want a huge momentum for change, and they know that they can't have that momentum unless they involve the civil society. One of the things that they emphasize, they just don't want to be lawyers, and it's very interesting what you say, not just looking at the law, you have to be strategic. You have to converse your issues before the court. You have to show that you're going beyond the realms of the legal sphere. So here they specifically said, I didn't have enough time to read that, beyond the legal sphere, the advisory opinion can generate political momentum for more urgent, ambitious, and just climate action. So this cannot be done unless we ensure that all the elements and all the communities, and especially the indigenous people, we have a lot of this in the continent. I just finished a stint in the Republic of Congo, and I know how much these are valued in terms of giving their own contribution. Some of them are living within the forested areas and, you know, and peatlands and all that. And they are very, very important interlocutors, and they need to be consulted on a consistent basis. And some of them have coalesced into groups that talk to these lawyers and policymakers. And I think that as the case progresses, we are going to see more and more consultation and involvement even of the civil society. I just wanted to add that in terms of the admissibility, I've just confirmed from my colleague in the African Court that the admissibility is no longer an issue. Apparently, PALU, let's see what she just said, PALU is a member They say PALU is one of the two NGOs that can directly request the court for an advisory opinion. We do not go through admissibility phase for advisory opinion. In other words, admissibility is automatic. So that's good. So we are looking at waiting for the decision.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much. So the first win then. We hope that the court will make a decision. So my last question was, when I look at many of the submission on the websites, I saw that many states also recognize the important role that civil society should be playing and indigenous people, in particular when it comes to designing of climate policies. I just wanted also to ask you, Ms. Rana, in the context of ASEAN, And states, this declaration is the declaration that states are adopting. Are there processes where people are consulted or people are indigenous people? How this really happen? Because we will be, the declaration will be adopted soon in the end of this. So can you tell us a little bit how?

MalaysiaDeputy Permanent Representative

Thank you. Thank you, Bure. First of all, I think just to go back on basically, the grouping of ASEAN itself is very, very unique. You know, the whole, each country, its makeup, its ethnicity, its religion, its population, it's very, very different. But we do, and I think what you mentioned about our indigenous groups, I think that one How it came into the discussion was it was channeled through individual countries that felt that, you know, this needed to be reflected in the declaration. So I think, at least on Malaysia's side, you know, we have a very kind of active group advocating for indigenous people. So at least from Malaysia, we can say that, you know, that was one of the things that we tried to have included as well. But also, just to -- I just want to add. to your comment about how ASEAN comes up with the declaration and our best practices. Because ASEAN is a relatively new regional grouping, I also want to mention that we also have a lot of specific dialogues and environment with Japan, South Korea, China, and the EU. And I think this is also where we draw kind of a lot of our kind of like best practices as well. And this framework has been going on for a while, and this is illustrative of basically ASEAN's very outward nature and how we try to engage with as many people, as many groups as possible, which I think culminated in this declaration as well.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you. Thank you very much, Sverre, for highlighting. And I think one thing that is important also here to highlight is also across the region, there is this recognition of the climate emergency, the essential role that civil society should play, but also the fact also that a climate issue is about, it was a human rights issue, that we should be dealing with it, that democratic institutions are important within the state in dealing with and in responding to the climate emergency. So I want now to turn the floor to you, Ambassador. Thank you very much for allowing me to share this. Thank you very much.

Chair

For this interesting discussion. Now we'll open the floor to interventions, and then we may have time for a final round of comments from our panelists. So now I'd like to invite Indonesia to speak, followed by the Inter-Parliamentary Union.

Indonesia

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

As an archipelagic country with more than 17,000 islands, Indonesia is highly vulnerable to climate change. We are already experiencing rising sea levels and more frequent extreme weather events, which threaten our coastal communities, ecosystems, and economic stability. This shared vulnerability brings us closer to small island developing states, including our Pacific neighbors, who face some of the most severe and existential threats from the climate crisis. Therefore, we express our solidarity with SIDS and vulnerable communities, and we support initiatives like the ICJ advisory opinion led by Vanuatu, which provides much needed legal clarity on states' obligations in addressing climate change. As a democratic country, Indonesia firmly believes in the principles of inclusivity, participation, and transparency. These principles are essential to ensure climate actions that is effective, fair, and sustainable. They guide not only our domestic policies, but also our engagement in regional and international cooperation.

At the regional.

Level, Indonesia supports various initiatives and tools, such as the ASEAN Taxonomy for Sustainable Finance, ASEAN Transition Finance Guidance, and the forthcoming ASEAN Climate Change Strategic Action Plan 2025-2030. Finally, we also recognize that the impacts of climate change are not distributed equally, and pathways toward a just transition will differ across contexts.

A one-size-fits-all approach is not.

Neither practical nor just. The just transition must be grounded in the principle of CBDR, taking into account the unique circumstances of people, communities, and locations. Regional cooperation can play a crucial role in this regard by pooling resources, sharing knowledge, and coordinating efforts to achieve outcomes that benefit all. I thank you.

Chair

Many thanks to the distinguished representative of Indonesia, and now we have the Inter-Parliamentary Union.

IPU

Thank you, Excellency, for giving me the floor. I represent the IPU, or Inter-Parliamentary Union, and I would like to thank all the experts who have spoken. We have listened with great interest, and we hope to be able to work with some of you, as we have launched two years ago a climate action campaign that has been supported by all of our member parliaments around the world. And I'd like to ask you a question. We have heard a lot about the role of courts, including international courts. We've spoken about strategic litigation. I'd like to ask a question about what is the role of this other arm of government, which is the legislative branch, parliaments? Because you can make the case that we wouldn't be here if parliaments had fully acted, fully fulfilled their roles in the last decades. We wouldn't have reached 1.5 degrees warming on land last year. But if you have any concrete, practical examples of good practices that you could share, that we could then share with our membership of parliamentary action that has really made a difference and that could make a difference if it's replicated around the world, that would be very useful. And also any role for inter-parliamentary organizations that you see. Thank you very much.

Chair

Thanks for that. Okay. I would actually have a question to the Inter-Parliamentary Union. Your annual meeting is coming up next week, so are these issues going to be in the agenda for the discussions?

IPU

That is correct, Excellency. In fact, the Assembly of the IPU, its 151st edition, begins this Sunday. And we're busy preparing it, including on the human rights program of the IPU here. The issue is being discussed every single time in our Committee on Sustainable Development and other bodies.

Chair

Thanks for that. And now we have an intervention from the organization Just Atonement.

JAI

Distinguished delegates. The efforts of courts, attorneys, and advocates from all over the world to enforce international legal obligations related to climate change, environmental protection, and planetary stability must be commended. Recent advisory opinions from the International Court of Justice and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights have strongly affirmed that international law recognizes the right to a stable climate and to a habitable planet. Nevertheless, a major challenge has emerged in our world today that we can no longer ignore. Certain powerful states continue to exempt themselves from the international legal order and are even attacking international judicial institutions in a manner completely at odds with a functioning international legal system. For example, we are witnessing unprecedented attacks against the International Criminal Court. That judicial body has seen its judges and prosecutorial staff subjected to financial sanctions simply for trying to implement the mandate of that court to enforce international law. A just and peaceful world order depends on the functioning of our international legal institutions. Lawyers and judges from all over the world and from all legal systems should stand together to support their colleagues who work in international law. Together, we must seek ways to apply and enforce international legal rules particularly in the context of human rights, the environment, and climate change. The fight for a stable climate and a habitable planet is at heart the fight for the international rule of law. We must now seek ways to apply the force of such law against planetary lawbreakers and end the global state of exception, whereby certain states carve themselves out from international legal processes. This is the major issue of our time, as critical a task as Magna Carta centuries ago. Thank you.

Chair

Thanks for that. And now I give the floor to the Global Forum for the Defense of the Less Privileged.

GFDLPGFDLP

Excellencies, distinguished delegates, ladies and gentlemen, on behalf of the Global Forum for the Defense of the Less Privileged and as a representative for children around the world, I wish to begin by thanking the panelists for their insightful reflections on legal clarity, democratic defense, and creativity. Climate change is not only an environmental emergency, it calls into question how we uphold justice, democratic values, and innovative thinking. In the remainder of this statement, we wish to highlight our key recommendations. First, legal clarity. You must ensure that climate obligations are not merely political statements, but clear, enforceable laws. National frameworks should align with the Paris Agreement and human right principles so that every promise made becomes a promise kept. Courts and regional mechanisms must be equipped to interpret both science and law, turning commitments into real accountability. We see consequences of unclear laws and delayed actions in places like the Horn of Africa, where prolonged droughts have displaced millions, including many children and women. Reports indicate that women and children constitute approximately 80% of the 1.4 million people displaced in Somalia due to ongoing drought. Additionally, over 20 million children across Ethiopia and Kenya are facing severe hunger, thirst, and disease as a result of the climate crisis. Second, democratic defense. Climate justice cannot exist without participation and protection. Around the world, environmental climate defenders and young activists, especially from vulnerable communities, are silenced, threatened, or even killed for speaking out. We call on all governments to safeguard civic space, include youth and vulnerable populations in decision-making procedures, and ensure that justice is accessible to everyone, not only those at the top of the chain. Third, creativity. The scale of this challenge demands innovation: independent climate representatives for future generations, fair transition councils to support affected workers and communities, and stronger cooperation between courts and regions to share bold legal ideas. Ladies and gentlemen, legal clarity gives us direction, democratic defense gives us legitimacy, and creativity gives us hope. Let us ensure that our laws and leadership do not merely respond to crisis, but build a future that is fair, sustainable, resilient, and full of opportunity. I thank you.

Chair

Thank you. And that ends our list of speakers. So there were some questions to panel, I think, if you wish.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Yes, I think that there's few question in terms of, I think the question came from, yes, to see if there is any parliamentarian experience that you would like to share. But I want to add, Excellency, if you allow me also. For the panelists also, I mean, I think there's main question that the last speakers were saying, what's the way forward? Now that those decisions are there, what will be really action that states will be taking? It's clear in this opinion, but we also know that the opinion try only to clarify what exists already. So how do we make sure now that we are not just promising that it will happen, that We can take action, the state will take action. We hear from Vanuatu, but I would like also to hear, beside this question, if anyone has to add, but also to see how, because today we are also facing what we call climate scepticism, climate scepticism. But through the decision of the court, we clearly know that there is no room for scepticism anymore. The legal obligations are there. The concerns are also there. So how do we move forward? Yes, Manu.

Greenpeace InternationalLegal Counsel for Campaigns

Yeah, I would like to address the question on what parliaments could do concretely. In my view, there are two things that could be done. The first is to adopt climate plans. and national greenhouse gas reduction plans that are in line with a 1.5 threshold, and this taking account that the different capabilities of different states. And perhaps in relation to this section, something that international organizations could do is to facilitate the discussions between the membership on what different states must take, because the court was clear that the more developed states have to take more and to do more to achieve 1.5. But the concrete numbers have not been clarified. Those are up for political forum. And the second thing that I believe could be done is to facilitate also more countries to adopt anti-SLAPP laws. A good example is the EU directive on anti-SLAPPs, because it has an early dismissal mechanism. That is the key point, having an early dismissal mechanism for those suits. Yeah, I'll leave it at that. Thank you.

Chair

So thank you. I'll just take this opportunity and starting from the comments, very important comments. I had the honor to actually participate in the negotiations within the European Union for the Fit for 55 package. And, you know, I'm really proud of that as an EU. We've got an all progressively more legally binding framework that engages us to be climate neutral by 2050. We have to reduce our emissions by 55% by 2030. We have to submit five-year climate and energy plans, which are subject to review by the commission. The commission can take us to court if we do not It's very important this, if as states we do not meet our obligations. So, and the other frameworks you mentioned for the anti-SLAPP. So there's a whole load of things that the European Union is doing now, which I really think would be useful for other regional organizations, perhaps to see how they can sort of, if there are aspects that they would also like to adopt.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Excellency. And I think the main message for the forward is how states take policies within its jurisdiction by also ensuring that there are democratic processes, because climate issues are not just a state's concern. It's about global concern. It's about citizen. It's about community. How do you establish mechanisms that help also to be able to mitigate that? So I think this is one of the main. Miriam, you want to say something? Maybe we still have like two, three minutes.

AIDADirector, Human Rights and Environment Program

Yeah, reflecting on the question about what parliaments can do, I think that there are a lack of opportunities to people to to bring to the courts their claims, and there are a rule of law that is missing on right to justice. And for example, in our perspective and our experience, many big companies cannot be sued because of the damage that they caused. And that's a truly, truly problematic issue, and it has to be regulated. So I think that it's important to advance in corporate accountability, to do it in a local perspective through laws, strong laws, and also in an international perspective with all the decisions that have come up. And lastly, I think that the greenwashing is something that also has to be regulated. The way that companies show the things that they are not doing to face climate crisis is really grave and is against what we need. So I think that these two things are also really, really important to continue working on.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you very much, Lilian. And I think we are clearly from all the region, I think there is a clarity now, there is no legal uncertainty when it comes to the state obligation, but also through all of the decisions that we have, and we expect also, because some of the decision and declaration that are coming up that this will also reinforce the need and also the request of participation, which for me is important, key, because fighting against climate is also ensuring that those who are most affected are part of the processes, are part of the design, but also the implementation of some of this decision. So I want to thank all of you for this on my part, and I think I will let the ambassador also to close the panel if there is no more from the panelists. Yes, I think we have exhausted what we have to say today. Thank you very much, Ambassador Dufour.

Chair

So thank you. Thank all the participants for this, I think, important debate. And I think we can keep that we are entering a new era after this series of decisions. So we'll see how this can actually be translated into concrete action. So now I close this fourth panel, and thank you for participating.

Moderator; Senior Research Fellow

Thank you.

Speaker 42

When you see us from the shore, we become a blue blanket bending towards the horizon. You think, what a beautiful view. See how those waves build and fall like ice melting. Over the millions of years of our existence, we have watched you come and go in all your forms. We have blessed the warriors of the Amakweha, the Amadlambe, the Amakonukwebe, the Amabondo. We have held the nets of fishermen and fed countless villages. From this sunken blue nest, back when cattle roamed far and wide, we watched the ships arrive. Fluttering flotillas from far-flung empires on a quest to conquer and cover up the land. Now, they are coming for us. Men stand on these shores with clipboards and hard hats pointing at us and making numbers in the air. 50k, millions, billions. Sometimes we gather the cormorants to float like funeral pyres on the surface, to scare the men away. And yet they continue. If you spend a moment underwater with us, you would understand why every seismic boom is a wound, every cheap packet a too-bright piece of confetti added to the sewage you pump into us, the churn of drills you grind into us, the slicks of dead seabirds you leave in your wake. 50k, millions, billions. If you could feel with us, you would know that our indigo depths is where the ancestors rest. They are called here when their earthly life is over, and to Abantu Abanthope who enter us to speak with the spirit world and learn how to become healers. This is their heaven. Dive deeper, and it becomes darker, but not in the way grace fills or a nightmare. No, This dark is like being in the center of your heart, within and with everything, as the water hangs around you in an amniotic suspension. And then she comes, her body larger than your imagination. She circles you, that orb eye taking you in, friend or foe. And she comes closer, hanging in Okotai, as though asking, why are you here? who sent you? Are those your tracks I saw on the shore? We have thrown blue over her during every birth. We have given her remote caves for every grief. We have held her in the air for joy and corralled the creature. But now, sure, the men in hats want to extract liquid ancestors from us. Puffed up with greed, with numbers for eyes, they want to blast us with air guns all day and night, while the rest of the world turns its back on fossilized fuels. How have your leaders allowed this? What are promises at climate conferences when they are so blatantly broken? How many kilometers of the ancestral realm will need to be disturbed before you rethink your futures? What will happen to those fishing families who we have fed for generations? Will you feed them oil? Dive deep into the center of your heart and answer these questions for yourself.

Chair

Dear participants, Excellencies, we've now come to the fifth panel of the fifth session of the United Nations Forum on Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law. The title of this panel is "Harmony with Nature: Prioritizing Solutions that Advance Human Rights, Including the Right to a Healthy Environment." The panel will consist of six presentations of approximately seven minutes each. Approximately 30 minutes will be reserved for interventions from the floor at the end. Let me note that the afternoon panel will not have the possibility of interventions, so anybody who wants to intervene should do it now, at the end of this one. The list of speakers is now open if you wish to inscribe yourself. And I'd like to introduce the panelists. His Excellency Mr. José Francisco Calitzay, Permanent Representative of Guatemala in Geneva. Mr. Jorge E. Finales, Professor of Law and Environmental Policy at the University of Cambridge; Ms. Shweta Narayan, Campaign Lead at the Global Climate and Health Alliance; Ms. Penina Mambazi-Tashobya, Program Associate for Climate Justice at the Center for Economic and Social Rights; Ms. Cheryl Lightfoot, Vice Chair of the Mechanism and former Chair of the Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples; and Ms. Francesca Mingrone, Senior Attorney for the Climate and Energy Program for International Environmental Law. The panel will be moderated by Dr. Amira Sawas, Head of Research at the Fossil Fuel Non-Proliferation Treaty Initiative. I now give the floor to the moderator.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you, distinguished delegates and your excellencies. Welcome to this important panel discussion about prioritizing solutions that advance human rights, including the right to a healthy environment. Not all solutions are equal, and dare I say, not all of those put forward as solutions are solutions, certainly from a perspective of human rights and equality in the context of global climate justice and local and indigenous rights. So it's really great to have this discussion, which aims to consciously unpack elements of the transition in terms of their opportunities and challenges for unlocking justice and rights. But before we get there, we do have an interactive component because we want to hear from you. So we do have a question which can be accessed through a QR code here, which it asks you really what does harmony with nature mean to you? And your interpretation of this can be however you like. from policy solutions through to more conceptual, spiritual suggestions. And we will display the replies at the end of the panel because we do want to know your perspectives. But our esteemed panel today is going to talk about the different areas of solutions, and as I said, solutions. And we're going to begin with Professor Jorge. So, over to you to tell us a little bit more about the issues of overconsumption and overproduction growing within planetary limits and sacrifice zones.

Professor of Law and Environmental Policy

Thank you very much. It is a pleasure and an honor to be here. I will try to introduce a topic briefly. It's a vast topic, and seven minutes essentially can be useful to frame it from a legal perspective. So let me make three points in this respect. The first is quite simple, is that the human footprint on the Earth system has become massive at a level that we're now talking about a new geological epoch that would be called the Anthropocene, and that would be defined geologically by human impact. Second point, very important, particularly from perspective of human rights, is that not all humans, but a small portion of humans or of human societies are having this impact. And the majority of them are actually suffering from the impact and been victims of them. And the third point, a very simple point, is that we need to bring this down to legal terms and try to frame it in ways that actually make legal sense. And one very important exercise was the issue of the climate change as discussed by the International Court of Justice and discussed earlier in the previous panel. In that case, I had the honor to represent the Republic of Vanuatu. I see the permanent representative, Ambassador Anta here. It's something very important because in that specific context, the court defined what the relevant conduct, so the conduct potentially in breach of international law, is with respect to overproduction and overconsumption. That relevant conduct had been pleaded widely, but it was specifically identified by the court in broad terms. So not just overconsumption, but also overproduction would fall under the possibility of a breach of international law. The court also defined the legal obligations that would govern this conduct, including human rights. It spent a significant amount of time describing these human rights, and it talked about both treaty-based human rights and customary-based. So it's not just a matter of being part of the treaty, but every state is subject to those obligations. And third, of course, the court identified legal consequences. from two types, as injured states, and importantly, the victims on the side of the Anthropocene were seen and presented as victims from these potential violations, and also consequences for third states. the consequences of what is called in international law, aggravated state responsibility. That's one aspect that is key from the perspective of the rule of law and human rights. The second aspect that is key from that perspective is a concept of sacrifice zones. This concept was specifically used in the pleadings. So, it was specifically used in order to describe the situations of those that are most directly affected by the adverse consequences of climate change, including, but not limited to, small island developing nations. And the Court actually did not pick up the concept as such, but the concept has increasingly a legal grounding in the work of special procedures. As this audience knows, it was introduced in a report in, I think, 2022 by one of the special rapporteurs, a special rapporteur on the right to clean, healthy, and sustainable environment. The third aspect that I would like to flag here in the framing is how specifically democratic institutions can operate and can play a role in enforcing this framing. And that's fairly simple. The first way is through independent and functioning courts for climate litigation. Climate litigation is a major tool, and it should be used. And I heard earlier today that there was discussion about the directive against SLAPPs, essentially against attempts at silencing civil society. And it's very important that states take that seriously. The second element is by connecting in lawmaking procedures the accountability dimension, so for those entities, whether states and non-state actors, that have caused significant harm to the climate system, and the adaptation finance dimension. This is something that is also discussed to some extent in the advisory opinion, but that has become increasingly clear. There are so-called climate super fund statutes being considered in a number of countries and being already adopted in subnational territories or entities, Vermont and New York in the United States. And the third, and that will be my last point, aspect of democratic institutions that is key for the implementation of a human rights dimension to this overconsumption, overproduction, at the Anthropocene level, is the importance of environmental defenders. It is, in my view, unconscionable that in many democratic states, civil disobedience that is peaceful and sometimes entirely lawful is being targeted with harsh sentences and convictions, while at the same time other type of so-called free speech is not being addressed. Thank you very much.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much, Professor. You summarised quite a lot there in a few points, and one of the points that I think many of us are thinking about in the context of the ICJ ruling is around overproduction being a breach of international law, is how we can use the ruling to drive greater responsibility and accountability through both formal and semi-formal and even informal channels and narratives, which makes us think more consciously about the role of states in the global just transition, as well as in implementing national transitions. And so with that in mind, I'm now going to hand over to Ms. Shweta Narayan, the campaign leader at Global Climate Health Alliance, to talk to us a little bit about just transition and democracy. Thank you.

GCHACampaign Lead

Thank you, Amira, and good morning. In order to understand what a just transition truly means, we must first understand what we are transitioning from. And that's the deep, pervasive harms of the fossil fuel economy. Last month, my organization, the Global Climate and Health Alliance, released a comprehensive report, and very aptly titled Cradle to Grave: The Health Harms of Fossil Fuels and the Imperative for a Just Transition, which documents the harms that we're talking about across the entire life cycle of the fossil fuel industry, entire human life cycle. And we have found that from exploration, extraction, combustion to waste, every stage of the fossil fuel industry has deep, pervasive health harms. Fossil fuels damage every organ system of the human body, harming us from before birth to old age. They cause stillbirths, respiratory and heart diseases, cancers, and mental health disorders. I'm just listing the ones that I can even pronounce over here. When you go into the medical evidence, you see the extent of harm, and particularly cancers, the different kind of cancers we have documented in the report. Communities who are living near extraction and processing sites experience toxic exposure daily, but be reminded, no one, none of us, is spared. The fact that the World Health Organization says that 99% of the world breathes toxic air is evident of the fact that we are all harmed by the exposures of fossil fuels. Millions of premature deaths every year just by air pollution. is the ultimate evidence before us. But they're not only health harms, these are also democratic harms. The same system that poison our bodies also pollutes our politics. Fossil fuel companies have captured decision making, suppressed science, targeted environmental defenders, and flooded public discourse with disinformation. Communities most affected by extraction are rarely those who voice and shape our energy policies. So a just transition, therefore, must be both democratic and health-centered. It must repair the social, environmental, and political inequities that the fossil fuel era has deepened. Centering health offers a unifying way forward. Because health is what every worker, every community, every family, and I'm sure everybody in this room values. It gives us a shared measure of what justice and progress looks like. So what does that really mean? It means for a just transition to truly be just, we must put people before polluters. by embedding health equity in every transition plan, ensuring that workers and communities now dependent on fossil fuels are protected, retained, and empowered to shape new livelihoods. By ensuring clean and healthy environment, cleaning up contaminated sites, as we have learned that chemicals and toxics released from fossil fuel operations stay in the environment for decades and have the capacity to produce harms even generations after the operations have shut. So clean up, contaminated sites, remediation is absolutely essential. Holding polluters accountable. Democracy depends on accountability. Governments must ensure that those who profit from pollution bear the cost of damage, health, and environment. And we need strong regulations, legal actions, and enforcement of the polluter pays principle to protect public health, rebuild trust, and uphold justice. Democratizing decision making. We need transparent community health data, inclusive participation in planning, strong protections for those who speak out. Breaking the grip of disinformation. And this can be done by ensuring that health institutions, governments, and media are free from fossil fuel influence so that public debate is guided by truth and not manipulation. Finally, and this is for all those policymakers in the room who think that there's no money, the money for this transition is there. Unfortunately, it's directed to somewhere else, with over 7 trillion US dollars in fossil fuel subsidies. We are financing a system that is killing us instead of protecting the people and the planet. So redirecting subsidies is absolutely essential, away from the fossil fuel industry that's making us sick towards those that sustain health, clean energy, care systems, safe housing, and resilient local economies. Finally, Democracy cannot thrive where people are too sick, silenced, or economically trapped to participate. A health-centered democratic transition is how we rebuild trust, by making sure that people most affected by pollution, inequality, and climate breakdown are also those who define the solutions. From cradle to grave, fossil fuels have dictated the terms of our economies. our environments, and even our politics. A just transition is our opportunity to reclaim those terms, to move from a system that sacrifices lives for profit to one that safeguards both people and the planet. Thank you.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much, Shweta, and thanks for reminding us how much fossil fuels harm our entire life cycle. With 99% of us breathing toxic air is quite a shocking statistic, which we shouldn't forget. And to address this systemic problem, we do have to have systemic solutions, which, as you say, put people before polluters. And so some of the solutions are contested for not doing this, right, including carbon in nature offsets. with many pushing back that these will not sort of create real change to the emissions that are projected and will require large tracts of land, often at the threat to indigenous peoples and customary land rights. So with that in mind, I'd like to ask your excellency, Mr. José Francisco, what role can carbon and nature offsetting play in addressing climate change, and what needs to be done to ensure that these projects don't come at the expense of indigenous people's rights?

GuatemalaPermanent Representative

Thank you very much for the invitation extended to me, and I think that today's theme on carbon compensation needs to be a highway to try to garner resources. But if we've learned anything over these past number of years, it's that any solution based on human rights, particularly for indigenous peoples, are destined for failure, for inefficiencies. The question is no much as to whether compensation can help, but rather how to ensure that this comes about without creating sacrifices or contributing to costs that further entrench the crisis. I therefore like to share a few ideas from my own experience from indigenous lands, not so much as an ambassador, but rather as an indigenous person myself. First, we need to be mindful of the scale and the speed of the change. The so-called green washing is the flow, which is crucial to help achieve the sustainable development goals and the climate goals. But it brings with it clear risks regarding the rights of indigenous peoples if they're not included from the very beginning. When there's pressure that goes ahead of safeguards, then we see an increase in attacks. We don't see substantial results and we see We don't see the benefits for indigenous peoples, and the result is predictable: conflict, a lack of trust, and ultimately, the worst kinds of climate results. The right road requires us to base ourselves on human rights and inclusive governance. We need to look at carbon compensation. This involves a high level of integrity and a rights-based approach. High integrity is not just a slogan. This means reducing, reduction and a control of flows, and in particular transparency as to the transfer of credits, who's providing the certification, who deals with the damage. Rights-based requires respecting territorial rights, effective participation, and free, prior, informed consent as a prerequisite. Practice shows that when we confuse consent with consultation, the door is open to abuse and to projects that lead to harm. The international framework gives us some guidance. The UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Persons and the ILO Convention insist that prior informed consent should be the foundation for reparation. Otherwise, there can be an impact on the environment and on territories. This should not just be an add-on for climate action, it should be a prerequisite. If we also look at Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, which looked at cooperation within market and non-market looking at transparency, is not an option. These are pillars to ensure that the cure is not worse than the illness itself. When we look at the oversight, we're only too aware of this. In too many cases, entities that provide credit do not robustly include criteria pertaining to Indigenous people or offer independent, accessible mechanisms. If we want conversations to be successful, we need to call for independent certification based on the rights of Indigenous peoples. We need to see public traceability of financial flows and for the final buyer, as well as channels for reparation or remedy. Sometimes I struggle with technology, and here I've brought paper, and I'm getting lost in my paper. And most importantly, the inclusion of Indigenous people with their vote and their voice. I could keep talking at length on this issue, but I am aware of the lack of time, and I just want to say that I'll conclude with a simple idea. Compensation only makes sense if it's a complement, it's not a substitute, and that this needs to be done with high level standards, with rights at the heart, and if we put the emphasis where it should be, Prior informed consent and consultation need to be a reality. We need to see total transparency and certification based on rights, accessible reparation, and accessible finance to indigenous initiatives. Compensation could be part of the solution, of course, but we mustn't run the risk of committing old mistakes with new words. we need to ensure that we're democratic, and it begins with listening, respecting, and co-governing with those who are looking after their own indigenous communities and sustaining life itself. Thank you very much.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you, Your Excellency. This really made me think about the point that you made, which is You know, human rights and territorial integrity are not an option. And when we're working with businesses, there has been too many cases of the violation of human rights. We have to think about the motivation of businesses, whether that's in the fossil fuel industry or in other areas. And there is very little evidence of responsible leadership, although it certainly does exist in some areas. So this brings me to thinking through the next question and intervention from Penina Mbabazi. Apologies if I didn't pronounce that correctly. You're going to talk to us a little bit about investor state dispute settlements and how climate finance can be made more equitable, transparent, and responsive to those affected by climate impacts. the kind of reforms that are needed in terms of ISDS to prevent them from undermining human rights? Thank you.

CESRProgram Associate for Climate Justice

Thank you. And it's really a great opportunity to be here. So when we look at the ISDS, divestment state dispute settlement mechanism. And of course, looking at the context today, that we see that there's a lot in trying to address the climate crisis, requiring some more than bold commitments and declarations that require more resources. And countries have been put in a state where they have to sign a number of international investment agreements. those being bilateral in nature, but also pluri-lateral. And at times you find most of these agreements do have a lot of clauses that have created ISDS as a mechanism to see that they're supporting more of foreign investors to actually finance their climate commitments and ambitions. So I'll just kind of get into one of the main features that ISDS regime has, which is currently looking at, of course, having more than, globally, right now, having more about 3,000 international investment agreements that have ISDS clauses today. containing a number of clauses that look at arbitration and consent to arbitration by the host state, meaning that in case foreign investors do, can have the potential to take the host state to court if their rights have been violated. And in regards to that, it's saying that if a treaty or an agreement is signed between the host state and an investor or a country, they are obligated to actually challenge the host state in case they feel that any rights that were in the treaty were being violated. So they would actually take the host state to court. And these arbitrations have been seen to be really expensive. Most times, they are not trialed in the traditional courts. They're trialed internationally, in international courts, but also the different uniform System in regards to the clauses that are continuously emphasized, like the national treatment and most favored nation clauses, that instead show that a foreign investor is actually treated the same as. any investor in the country once these agreements are signed. But specifically, why this is really an issue is because there's a lot of intersection between how, you know, the ISDS continues to be used and abused also in regards to how a lot of these fossil fuel companies are coming more on ground to exploit a number of natural resources, but also leave communities bare in regards to what they're able to actually say that they actually have getting into a full utilization of even understanding what is going to happen with the resources that they have on ground, but also leaving their land bare and having a lot of land grabs as well. So there's no way that countries or a host state can actually be able to trial some of these foreign investors because they're quite expensive. Tanzania, for example, is one that has faced a number of challenges in trying to have peace or trying to have a bit of understanding because of the agreements that they signed with a lot of investors. They have been trialled in international courts. But also we have seen a lot of projects that have come on ground, like all the all the all it's called the ECOP, which is oil pipeline that passes from Uganda to Tanzania, that is actually also having a lot of cases in regards to seeing that more human rights defenders and more communities are coming to trial, to actually push for trial, to say that they want to change a number of the clauses that were already signed and agreed on, because most of them have been left either being exploited, having their natural resources being taken, but also looking at how little is left to the community. They do not have free, prior, and informed consent, which has still put them in a huddle of where they're not able to actually claim much once these projects are actually done. And of course, looking at one key area is the issue of expropriation, and this looks at some of these agreements that have taken even once being signed, take about five to 20 years, and they're still in operation. So meaning that even for a country to actually pull out of this agreement, they still continue to, a foreign investor can still continue to actually you know, use the agreement till date and still trial the host state to court. And this has continued to actually work against host states, those that have found it challenging, especially given the demand around trying to support their climate commitments, but also even looking at the sunset clauses that have been incorporated in most of these agreements. So there is much more need to see that we are trying to also have provisions that do promote climate finance in a lot of these international investment agreements. But still with these ISDS clauses, and ISDS looking at it from a perspective of climate finance, is that you find still countries are not going to actually revive most of these agreements to work for them, because most of them have already been signed, most of them actually coming into a point where they're not going to be renegotiated. as long as countries do not have clear investment frameworks that can protect communities, that can also protect host countries in trying to see that they have a full appreciation and also able to actually reap more in regards to what should be owed to them by most of these fossil, mostly fossil fuel companies that come on ground and actually take full advantage of these clauses in the investment agreements. So the human rights approach really does come clear in this discussion. And looking at what we would literally bench on is the human rights treaties on international court, international convention on economic, social, and cultural rights that does put into emphasis the respect of extraterritorial obligations, ensuring that that their own actions or those of corporations and banks under their jurisdiction do not cause harm elsewhere. And also to see that we are able to mobilize the maximum available resources to realize the rights, including through fair taxation, ending fossil fuel subsidies, but also regulating financial flows. And also the need to see that we can be able to prioritize the needs of those most affected and over the preferences of those most powerful. However, to align climate finance with the principles of reparations and with the human rights standards, it's important that this can actually make it a bit fairer, but more equitable. So it shouldn't be left in a standstill that once these ISDS clauses are in, with the benchmarks of so many of these agreements, there should be a way that countries can still be able to strive to find a way that human rights standards are actually incorporated in them, that we have more understanding of what is at stake when these agreements are being signed, that communities are also made to be part of the decision-making process, that they are actually at the center, because most of them, this is their livelihoods being taken away from them. Most of them have had to actually start from nothing to actually try to revive so many of the resources that are being exploited by so many of these companies. And that's why it's more important to also see that we're able to also work against, more specifically, to try and reform our investment frameworks. And investment frameworks nationally, because they take more precedence when it comes to a lot of these agreements. Once an investor is seen, a foreign investor is seen to be given more privilege more national treatment without any consultations, without even any clauses that can actually protect communities to say that they can also have a voice and that the host state can actually trial this foreign investor in case they do not stand by their obligations to actually create technology transfer, to create decent jobs, to create, protect livelihoods of those communities on ground. to have free, prior, and informed consent. All these, once violated by foreign investors, they should actually be trialed, but in the traditional courts. And that should be a provision that should be strengthened, but also to see that more of the commitments should be also placed to see more resources should actually come to a lot of these countries that are even being faced with a lot of climate crisis conditions, and most of them have been left to be highly indebted. and left to instead rely on having to attract foreign direct investment. And sometimes we have to also pause and ask, FDI at what cost? You know, how much would it cost for countries to be violated, especially for communities to lose their voice in regarding to how they're able to protect their livelihood, but also to ensure that they are also having the right resources on ground to help them meet the climate crisis and conditions? So there's definitely a need for human rights best approach, and I feel that should be anchored in a lot of the reform that we're looking at today.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much. Of course, ISDS is a real example of how the transition is being prevented. It's a huge barrier, and so thank you for talking us through that. But even when transition steps are being taken and implemented, as mentioned already, a key issue is actually around the risks to the rights of Indigenous Peoples. So I'm now going to hand over to Cheryl Lightfoot, who's with the Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, the expert mechanism, and I'd like to ask what has been the impact on Indigenous peoples' rights of renewable energy development across the value chain of transition, mineral extraction in particular, and renewable energy projects. Thank you.

EMRIPEMRIPVice-Chair

Thank you very much. And it is such an honor to join this panel today on behalf of the Expert Mechanism on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. And as a mechanism mandated to provide expert advice and support, Expert Mechanism, or EMRIP for short, assists States, Indigenous Peoples, and other stakeholders in achieving the goals of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. And I want to thank the Forum for the invitation for us as a mechanism to contribute to this very important discussion today. Indigenous Peoples, of course, have long been stewards of the Earth's ecosystems. sustaining biodiversity and environmental balance through their cultures, knowledge systems, traditional livelihoods, and governance practices. Their worldviews emphasize reciprocity and interdependence with all human beings, recognizing that human well-being is inseparable from the health of the planet. Forest-dependent communities, for example, uphold principles such as taking only what is needed to preserve the generative capacity of nature for future generations. And these practices have helped maintain ecosystems that now underpin global climate resilience and food security. Yet, as climate action accelerates and the demand for renewable energy intensifies, Indigenous lands and territories are increasingly targeted for the extraction of critical minerals, such as lithium, cobalt, and rare earth elements, resources essential to the global energy transition. And this new wave of resource extraction often mirrors historical patterns of exploitation. proceeding without adequate safeguards, meaningful consultation, or respect for Indigenous peoples' rights, and thus perpetuates a legacy of human rights violations under a new guise. Indigenous human rights and environmental defenders, many of them women, remain particularly at risk. frequently subjected to intimidation, criminalization, and violence for defending their lands, cultures, and their environment. Extraction of critical minerals carry profound implications for Indigenous peoples' autonomy, lands, and cultural survival. Research shows that a significant portion of the world's critical transition minerals are found in Indigenous territories. Yet, Indigenous peoples so often remain excluded from decision-making processes related to resource extraction and so-called renewal energy projects on their lands. Extraction of these resources frequently occurs without the free, prior, and informed consent of Indigenous peoples, resulting not only in dispossession and environmental harm, but also in erosion of cultural and spiritual relationships with the lands and waters that sustain communities. Such incursions lead to the loss of economic security, disruption of traditional livelihoods, and the weakening of governance systems rooted in customary law. Renewable energy development affects the rights of Indigenous peoples across the entire value chain. from the extraction of transition minerals to the installation of wind, solar, and hydro projects, and ultimately to waste disposal and recycling. Mining often contaminates water, destroys forests and biodiversity, and damages sacred landscapes, threatening rights to health, food, water, and a clean environment, while undermining cultural and spiritual ties to the land. Renewable energy infrastructure often displaces communities, encroaches on sacred sites, and disrupts traditional livelihoods, and even green projects may replicate extractive and exclusionary practices. At the end of the chain, the processing and disposal of materials produce toxic waste that further harms ecosystems upon which Indigenous peoples depend. And these cumulative impacts make it clear that environmental sustainability cannot be achieved at the expense of human rights. The extraction and sourcing of critical raw minerals for the energy transition can undermine several key provisions of the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. such as Article 3, that affirms Indigenous peoples' inherent right to self-determination, including the freedom to determine their political status and pursue their economic, social, and cultural development, as well as Article 32, that guarantees their right to determine priorities and strategies for the development or use of their lands and resources, and obligates states to consult and cooperate in good faith in order to obtain their free, prior, and informed consent before beginning any project affecting their lands, territories, and resources. Article 26 of the Declaration affirms indigenous peoples' rights to their lands, territories, and resources. while Article 10 protects against forcible removal from their lands, and Article 29 ensures the right to conservation, environmental protection, and sustainable use of lands and resources. When all of these rights are ignored or violated in the name of climate progress, it not only violates Indigenous peoples' human rights, but also undermines global efforts towards a just and sustainable transition. A truly just energy transition must begin by recognizing and upholding these rights as foundational principles, ensuring that Indigenous peoples are not asked to bear the environmental and social costs of a transition they did not design or from which they are often excluded. To safeguard the rights of Indigenous peoples in the context of extractive industries and critical raw material sourcing, We should fully recognize and implement the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, acknowledging that its provisions are interdependent, interrelated, and indivisible, adopting a holistic approach that protects land, culture, self-determination, environment, and traditional livelihoods, as well as indigenous peoples' collective identity, governance, and relationship with their territories. The Expert Mechanism underscores that states and companies should comply with the Declaration, with ILO Convention 169, and relevant national and international standards through effective due diligence, monitoring, and accountability mechanisms to prevent violations and ensure respect for Indigenous rights in all policies, projects, and business operations. Respect for Indigenous peoples' right to free, prior, and informed consent should take place for any activity that affects their lands, resources, or cultural heritage, with culturally appropriate processes and the ability to withhold consent. Guarantee their full, effective participation in all decisions that affect Indigenous peoples, from local land use planning to global climate and biodiversity negotiations. The Expert Mechanism reiterates that states should recognize and ensure land tenure and territorial rights of Indigenous Peoples, which form the foundation for ecological stewardship, cultural survival, and climate mitigation, recognizing that Indigenous land rights are a key strategy for biodiversity protection. Finally, the expert mechanism also reiterates its recommendation that states adopt legal and policy measures to protect Indigenous peoples' traditional knowledge systems, including benefit sharing arrangements and protocols for free, prior, and informed consent. These knowledge systems should inform sustainable resource management, environmental stewardship, and the design of policies and projects. States should also ensure the protection of indigenous human rights and environmental defenders, including women and youth, and support partnerships with companies that uphold human rights and environmental standards. I thank you very much for your attention.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much for the detailed run through there. I think I learned a lot personally from your work and will definitely be Keeping an eye on the civil society, sorry, the expert mechanism for indigenous rights. Another sort of major risk related to your intervention is around the use of emerging technologies like geoengineering, for example. Some are concerned about these technologies potentially having harmful impacts on local environments and communities, but also some call them false solutions. So it's a very challenging space to be thinking about. So over to our last speaker, certainly not the least, Francesca Mingrone from the Centre for International Environmental Law, who's going to talk us through how we should think about the safeguards that should be in place to ensure that these interventions are governed transparently, ethically, and with public participation. Thank you.

CIELSenior Attorney, Climate and Energy Program

Thank you very much. It's very important that we discuss geoengineering because indeed, we're focusing on solutions, but it's also important to focus on those approaches that are not solutions. And indeed, geoengineering is intimately linked to some of the issues that we've heard on this panel, the need and the imperative to defossilize the economy, achieving deep and rapid phase out of fossil fuels. And we see that geoengineering technologies and approaches are actually used as an excuse to delay that. We heard also about the flaws linked to carbon markets and some of the approaches that fall under the category of geoengineering also are used to further such approaches. So taking a step back, what is geoengineering? Because this is quite a technical term and not everybody might be familiar with that. So this refers to a set of large-scale interventions in the Earth system to counteract some of the effects of climate change. Proposed approaches usually fall under the category of solar radiation modification or carbon dioxide removal, and they target land-based, marine, and atmospheric ecosystems. Solar geoengineering aims to mask the heating effect of greenhouse gases by reducing the Earth system's absorption of incoming solar radiation. And carbon dioxide removals, on the other hand, seek to remove carbon from the atmosphere on a very massive scale. Such technologies are largely hypothetical for now, especially solar geoengineering. And central to understanding geoengineering and also the challenges around governance for it is the scale at which such technologies are proposed. To give you an idea, solar geoengineering deployment, as theorized, would include hundreds of years of continuous deployment at a planetary scale. If we look at ocean carbon dioxide removal techniques, these are theorized that you should utilizing 10 to 20% of the world's ocean surface. And some of the land-based techniques are estimated to utilize twice the world's currently cultivated land. So you can really see the absurdity of the scale of these technologies if deployed. Looking at solar radiation modification approaches, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change has warned that if deployed at the scale needed to influence climate symptoms, such technologies would introduce widespread range of new risks to people and ecosystems which are yet not understood fully. And a growing number of human rights mechanisms, including the Special Rapporteur on the Right to a Healthy Environment, the Special Rapporteur on Climate Change, the Advisory Committee of the Human Rights Council, have also warned about the deep risks to human rights, people, and ecosystems. Geoengineering also threatens procedural rights. We heard at length about the importance of such rights, including for indigenous peoples. And while some geoengineering experiments are already planned or taking place in indigenous territories, we see that often they fail to integrate the free, prior, and informed consent, which is essential to guarantee the rights of the communities involved. So the question of governance is at the core, of course, of the debate around geoengineering. And as I was saying, any solar or marine geoengineering technologies deployed at climate-relevant scale would be intended to be global in its impact. And so it would really entail a risk of permanent technological dependence from certain techniques. Massive industrial infrastructure and operation would be needed, which only powerful countries or military regimes would be able to sustain. And such technologies would therefore require governance systems which are much more sophisticated than anything that has ever existed in human history, and that would have to function also over centuries, which is an impossible requirement. Once again, they do not address the root causes of climate change. So to have even an impact, they would keep running for centuries to go. Currently, regarding the existing governance, there is no treaty that solely address geoengineering, but there are multilateral environmental agreements that do contain provisions that are relevant to geoengineering. We can here recall the Convention on Biological Diversity, the London Convention, the London Protocol under the International Maritime Organization, and the Convention on the Prohibition of Military Use of Environmental Modification Techniques, which is a convention that has a bit less light. And they do explicitly regulate research and deployment of geoengineering technologies, including through moratoriums. And interestingly, the International Tribunal of the Law of the Sea, in its recent advisory opinion on climate change, has emphasized that marine geoengineering could violate the UN Convention of the Law of the Sea because it would constitute a form of marine pollution. So the current framework provides for a restrictive global governance currently. And we also heard about the importance of a human rights-based approach, and indeed, human rights law interpreted in line with the obligations and principles under international environmental law, including the precautionary principle, also entails that when there is scientific uncertainty, states shall not pursue research and activities that would undermine human rights and would pose serious environmental harm. And this very much applies to geoengineering technologies. So calls for geoengineering research, or even for a governance framework that would enable research, must be understood within the context of the particular nature and scale of these technologies. And specifically looking at solar geoengineering, small-scale outdoor experiments cannot provide the information that is needed about the intended or unintended impacts on the climate and its wider consequences. So once again, there is a very fine line between experimentation at the large scale and actual deployment. But we see an increasing number of think tanks and tech companies that are making the case that research is needed on whether or not solar geoengineering could be an effective plan B. And to us, these arguments are very much disingenuous, because first of all, they discard the fact that the best available science really clearly shows that the most effective and safe approach to combating climate change is phasing out fossil fuels rapidly and fully. And such calls also discard the existing regulations under international environmental law and human rights obligations of states, as I was mentioning. And they also normalize highly controversial theories. Once again, most of these technologies are not even proven to be effective. Some of them do not even exist. And so really leads to denormalization of these technologies and create a dangerous slippery slope towards potential full-scale development in years to come. And for these reasons, almost 600 academics and 2,000 civil society organizations are calling for a solar geoengineering non-use agreement. The call recognizes the impossibility to even fairly or democratically governing such technologies, and really puts them in a categories of technologies that humanity has already agreed to never to be used. And we're talking about human cloning, eugenics, chemical, nuclear weapons, and solar geoengineering, and geoengineering more broadly should fall into that category. And the call explicitly entails no outdoor experiments, no public funding, no deployment, while allowing for research that does not advance technology development. And such an agreement would build on the existing precautionary governments framework. We see that political momentum is growing on this idea of non-use. We've heard calls in this sense from the European Parliament, the African Committee of Environmental Ministers, Vanuatu and Fiji, among other countries that are considering and calling for a non-use agreement. So to conclude, relevant regulations and moratoriums on geoengineering do exist and are reinforced by obligations under international environmental law and human rights law, and states have an obligation to uphold them. Given the potential huge risks and uncertainties around such technologies, states should oppose outdoor experiments and research that could lead to technology development. And this also includes disincentivizing the development of geoengineering technologies, for instance, by withholding public support, including funding, also by not granting patent rights for technologies that go towards this sense. And at political level, and to answer the question on governance, to us, the solution is non-use. So we really call upon states to adopt a national position on non-use for solar geoengineering specifically, and ultimately work towards a global non-use agreement. Thank you very much.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much, Francesca. It's interesting that states, particularly those and regions that are investing in overconsumption and overproduction, have billions for investing in their own universities to explore technologies that don't exist rather than relying on the best available science, which would require humans to shift the way that we live in a fair manner. And it's interesting that we want to rely on science that doesn't exist quite yet rather than alternate or shift the patterns that we have as humans with our environment. But for now, I'm going to close the panel. So thank you to all the speakers. But we do have the results of your interventions for those of you who did put some thoughts through the QR code on the question, what does harmony with nature mean to you? So we're presenting those up there now on the screen based on what you shared. Thank you for doing that. So I'll just summarise those now. The first, I guess most prominent one, was about socio-ecological rehabilitation as a remedy for climate harm and collective healing, balance with natural systems, stewardship, biodiversity, and moving beyond anthropocentrism, coexisting again in a balanced and sustainable way between humans and nature without one taking the lead on the other. Respecting planetary boundaries while using natural resources, and finally, living in balance, taking only what we need. So the same theme, respecting the planet's limits and recognizing that our well-being depends on the Earth's well-being. So we have just a couple of minutes, and there were a couple of speakers who were very concise in their remarks. So maybe I can hand over to them to see if they have any thoughts about these themes that have come through. And I think firstly, Professor Vinuales, you spoke in a very concise way. So if you have any thoughts on this, thank you.

Professor of Law and Environmental Policy

Thank you very much. Yes, perhaps the first point that I would like to make is that I would tend to agree with every single statement. that has been made in the answers to what is living in harmony with nature. The problem is how, the problem is how to do it. And particularly, the problem is how to do it from a situation in which we're not living in harmony with nature. We are impacting the biosphere. at levels that are entirely unprecedented at any human timescale, whether history or prehistory. So essentially, our impact has never been seen in the history of Homo sapiens sapiens. I'm not talking about tens of thousands of years, but hundreds of thousands of years. So it is quite difficult to even try to address the question of how, but there are a number of tipping points, this time positive tipping points, that you could call legal tipping points, that if addressed specifically, could unleash a snowball, could unleash a very strong positive reaction. And I think that this panel has touched upon many of them from the perspective of democratic institutions. I just touched upon three of them. I mentioned the issue of climate mitigation, the issue of accountability for past climate harm. and the connection with adaptation cost, and then, of course, anything that is procedure rights, particularly for environmental defenders and civil disobedience when necessary. But there are many more. And I just wanted to stress that. The question is really how, and it has to be a strategy that is quite structured. Thank you.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much. I now hand back over to the chair. Thank you.

Chair

Thank you so much, and thanks to the panelists. So now we are going to go into the statements from states and non-governmental organizations. Before we do that, though, I would like to inject something into the debate. Without any desire to mitigate the message of urgency and the fact that we really have to accelerate and that the situation is alarming, so all states And citizens have to really redouble their efforts. But I do want to mention an example which I think is important in this context, and that's the EU's due diligence directive. So this was adopted this year, if I'm not mistaken, and that foresees that any company working in the EU's internal market has to take due diligence to avoid violations of human rights and environmental degradation. It also explicitly mentions indigenous peoples, and it has the full range of human rights. So what does that mean? That any mining company that wants to export to the EU, whether it's an EU company or a third state company, will have to take due diligence. And if it violates the rights of indigenous peoples, et cetera, et cetera, it is a legal obligation from the commission to take action. So I just wanted to put that on the table. Now, I open the list of speakers with Tunisia to be followed by Bolivia.

Tunisia

Thank you, Mr. Chair. Issues of war and peace, racism, xenophobia, and economic oppression are the result of human interacting with other humans. These functions are as old as humanity, and they cause great pain and suffering that history takes note of. However, loss of biodiversity, desertification, climate change, sea level rising, and disruption of a number of natural cycles are the consequences of inappropriate human-nature interaction. This disregard of nature and the integrity of its ecosystems and life-supporting process is significant enough to implicate international peace and security, too. In fact, the current exploitative system daily harms our environment under the justification of needing to achieve development which threatens our health, way of life, and our existence as well. Indeed, lessons from sustainable development have shown time and again that it's not always possible to avoid choices between the competing priorities, including the priorities of promoting human rights and protecting the environment. From that perspective, the key challenge is to strike a balance between these competing priorities and to restore a healthy relationship between humanity and Mother Earth. Such rebalancing is urgent, as scientists and researchers remind us that we are running out of time. So it's worth knowing where we stand now. Despite global warming, we are still underplaying the risk. Our resilience is not robust enough to face worst scenarios since changing climate is still not addressed in a holistic approach. To address this risk, the recognition of nature as a subject of rights is the primary pathway in the direction of understanding that human rights and the rights of nature are interdependent. Viewing environmental decisions as directly implicating human rights contributes to injecting a new level of urgency into the process. Thus, so, thank you, Mr. Chair, in order to respect the time.

Chair

Thank you for that. Now I give the floor to Bolivia, to be followed by India.

Bolivia (Plurinational State of)

We're grateful to the panel and for the contributions from the panelists. We want to prioritize solutions to try to tackle the climate crisis. We need to understand this in the context of the crisis of multilateralism, the post-pandemic crisis, and the financial architecture. And as the High Commissioner said, 1% of the richest population of the world is responsible for the carbon footprint affecting the majority of the rest of the population. We need to highlight a few principles in striving for solutions. recognition of historic responsibility, the principle of equity, and common but differentiated responsibilities, as well as the fact that the polluter pays. We need to be efficient and have an inclusive democratic order where developing countries, developed countries have a more active participation. We need to also support technology transfer and capacity building. Human beings cannot live without nature. However, nature can, of course, do well without human beings. And when we look at the cosmovision, according to Pachamama, the Mother Earth, we need to reflect as we look for new initiatives. So we need to draw on the cosmovision from our indigenous peoples and campesino peoples and people of African descent. We are trying to accelerate discussion on the rights of Mother Earth. Can we perhaps include nature as a right holder in this conversation? Thank you.

Chair

Bolivia, and now I give the floor to India, to be followed by Mexico.

India

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

India, we thank the panelists for their very useful presentations. India's democratic framework provides a strong foundation for addressing climate change through inclusive governance, judicial oversight, and decentralized policy action. The Constitution of India establishes a vibrant parliamentary democracy of over 900 million voters with an independent judiciary and participatory civil society. Environmental protection is embedded in our constitutional framework, mandating both the states and citizens to safeguard nature.

Guided by these principles, India has enacted robust environmental legislation and established key institutions such as the

Ministry of Environment, Forests, and Climate Change, and the National Green Tribunal, which ensure the enforcement of environmental norms. Democratic institutions from Parliament to panchayat, that's local self-government, are increasingly active in shaping climate responses. The judiciary has linked environmental protection with the fundamental right to life, reinforcing accountability. India's accelerated transition to renewable energy, particularly solar and wind, reflects its democratic will and commitment to sustainable growth.

The establishment of the International Solar Alliance in 2015

and efforts to expand the renewable capacity underscore India's leadership in global climate action. India's theme under G20 presidency, that is One Earth, One Family and Future, and Life Mission, Lifestyle for Environment, is a testimony to India's efforts to promote collective action to reduce mindless consumption, which are the main drivers of climate change. Mr. Chair, strengthening participatory governance, empowering local bodies, and Fostering green innovation remains central to India's vision of a climate resilient and sustainable future. India remains committed to protecting its people, its democracy, and planet through collective, equitable, and inclusive action.

I thank you.

Chair

Thank you, India. And now I give the floor to Mexico, to be followed by Gambia.

Mexico

Thank you very much. We would like to thank the panellists for their interesting presentations and for their analysis on this important topic, and we agree that combating climate change and the energy transformation cannot be disconnected from human rights, including the rights of indigenous peoples, who historically have been custodians of these ecosystems and biodiversity. the energy transition needs to be fair, not just environmentally and economically speaking, but also in terms of sociocultural rights. To this end, indigenous peoples are protagonists. Mexico has made some headway with a significant constitutional reform that recognizes indigenous peoples as rights holders with appropriate legal personality. And thanks to the principles of free prior informed consent, free determination, and the building of development models that bolster community-based life, we have placed indigenous peoples as key actors in energy transition policies. We'd like to ask Ambassador Francisco Calitza and Cheryl Lightfoot, what role do you think women and children from indigenous communities should play in this energy transition? And we'd also like to ask the professor and expert Bambassi that, given the advisory opinion in the case of Latin America from the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, What influence can this have in shaping and interpreting international agreements? Thank you very much.

Chair

Now we go to Gambia to be followed by Jordan. We go to Jordan to be followed by Philippines. Philippines. So now we'll pass to the NGO segment, and I give the floor to the International Indian Treaty Council.

IITCIITCRepresentative; Coordinator, Indigenous People's Caucus under UNFCCC

Thank you very much, Mr. President. My name is Ghazali Ojorella. I'm speaking on behalf of IITC, which is an indigenous people's organization, but I'm also coordinator for the Indigenous People's Caucus under the UNFCCC. in the Article 6 carbon market negotiations. On the outset, we have a full agreement with the remarks of the panel, including Ambassador Kali, that Indigenous rights, including FPIC, is essential. But I would also invite everyone to look beyond projects and into the architecture of climate finance itself, as FPIC would be fixing the faucet, but not the well. The contamination of the well is structural. Climate finance tied to carbon markets and results-based logic that turns solidarity into transaction. It rewards performance metrics, but not rights. In this reality, forests become carbon assets. Like Francesca said, our territories become testing sites for carbon capture and geoengineering experiments. And these peoples become service providers in someone's else net zero plan, calling it direct access to funding, which is the deeper crisis. Human rights are being made to perform before they are respected, as geoengineering experiences are starting to look like Looney Tunes episodes where Wile E. Coyote straps on yet another invention to catch Roadrunner. The ICJ advisory opinion and the right to clean, healthy, and sustainable environment gives us a unique opportunity to reimagine the terms. In our view, they should help define the legal firewall between public obligations and private carbon markets, between solidarity and speculation. Therefore, our question to the panel is this: how can we use these to reinforce the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and avoid environmental violence, and rewrite the rules of climate finance itself so that harmony with nature isn't twisted and turned into market performance, but actually grounded in human rights? We thank you.

Chair

Thank you. I now give the floor to the Integración Civil.

Integración CivilEcuadorian communities protecting nature

I want

Ecuadorian communities protecting nature

to speak on behalf of Ecuador, the voice of communities that represent and protect nature, the selva and the sea, the voice that defends life. In 2018, Ecuador had a landmark opportunity recognizing in our constitution the rights of nature, claiming that there is no democracy without respect for the planet that sustains life. This was a promise to the world, but this vision is being betrayed now. Our ancestral traditions are being undermined. Our forests are being cut down. and people are being criminalized for action. In 2023, the Ecuadorian people held a historic referendum where we try to protect Yasuni, which is one of the most biodiverse areas of the country, to say no to oil exploitation. We cannot It would be remiss not to refer to what's happening in Sina, Scotland, or the Choco Andino, where communities also said no to mining, and there was an attempt to impose a mining project in a protected area. So there were, there was social movement to try to ensure that we defended the rights of nature. We also have those who, we are seeing the effects on campesinos, indigenous communities. Today, Ecuador is at a standstill because of the protests that are gripping the country. The government's not listening, and those who are trying to protect water, the the biodiversity and the fish and so on. We are actually custodians of this life, and yet we're being ignored. In Esmeraldas, which is a land where we have an Afro-descended community, we're seeing oil spills that have contaminated rivers and coastlines. And there's an attempt to try to set up a military base in one of the most fragile areas of the planet. Ecuador is calling for coherence because the country, the Our problems are also the problems of the entire planet, and the solution is interconnected, needs to be a brave solution, a humane solution. We need to see democracy for nature and for human lives. Thank you.

Chair

Thank you, speaker. Now I will give the floor to the organization Just Atonement, to be followed by the Global Forum for the Less Privileged.

JAI

Distinguished Chair, distinguished delegates, to achieve harmony with nature, we must do more than protect ecosystems. We must redefine the purpose of government itself. We are confronting a harsh truth in our world today. The boundless extraction of resources and the endless pursuit of growth have exhausted both people and planet. In an era of climate disruption, the central task of government must evolve. In addition to defending fundamental freedoms. A core purpose of government must be to restore balance between humanity, our societies, and fragile Earth systems. We must imagine and build a new era of climate sovereignty, an era where political collectives defend fundamental freedoms, fragile ecosystems, and the maintenance of a habitable planet. Sovereignty itself must change to acknowledge stewardship, regeneration, and restraint, grounded in the right to a healthy environment now recognized under international law. Defending fundamental freedoms and guiding our species back to a habitable planet, these must become the two pillars of why we enter into political communities together. Harmony with nature also requires that we elevate alternative worldviews that emphasize relational balance with the earth and the right of nature itself to thrive. The transformation we now face is not merely technical or economic. It is constitutional and philosophical. Governments must reorient their purpose to become guardians of planetary well-being so that both peoples and the environment may exist and thrive together. We must be willing to imagine a world where governments bring out the best in us and can act as sentinels of a more dignified and peaceful world committed to planetary stability and homeostasis. Thank you.

Chair

Thank you, speaker. Now I give the floor to the Global Forum for the Less Privileged.

GFDLPGFDLP

Thank you, Mr. Chair, for giving me the floor again. Excellencies, distinguished delegates, ladies and gentlemen, the recognition of a healthy environment as a fundamental human right is no longer a matter of debate. It is a global imperative. By now, that should be clear. In July 2022, the United Nations General Assembly adopted Resolution A/76/L.75 by a vote of 161 in favor and eight abstentions, affirming the right to a clean, healthy, and sustainable environment as a human right. It should come as no surprise that this resolution has catalyzed significant legal developments. In July 2025, the International Court of Justice issued a landmark advisory opinion declaring that states have a legal obligation to combat climate change and protect both current and future generations. The court emphasized that climate change is an, I quote, urgent and existential threat, end quote, and that nations must cooperate to address it, with high-income countries supporting developing nations in climate adaptations. Similarly, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, in its advisory opinion OC-32/25, recognized the human right to a healthy climate, affirming that states have binding obligations to address climate change as a human rights issue. Yet despite these advancements, challenges persist. The UN Special Rapporteur on Human Rights Defenders has reported a global surge in state-led repression against climate activists and environmental defenders. Furthermore, the world faces a triple planetary crisis: climate change, biodiversity loss, and pollution. And to comment on the data given by Ms. Shweta Narayan from the 99% of the population worldwide being affected with air pollution, that is 8 billion people affected with this issue, as well as 8.1 million deaths per year. The United Nations Environment Programme's Global Resource Outlook of 2024 warns that the global economy continues to consume natural resources at an unsustainable rate, while the world is already falling behind on achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. While progress has been made in recognizing the human right to a healthy environment, much work remains to ensure its full realization. We must continue to strengthen legal frameworks, protect environmental defenders, and take decisive action to confront the environmental challenges that threaten our collective time ahead. I thank you.

Chair

Thank you, speaker. Now we have a very few minutes left, and I'll hand it back to the moderator.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you, chair. So some really important questions and interventions from the floor. Rights of nature has been a key theme, integrity, so many interventions related to implementation over words. And of course, we've got your interventions that you shared with us that we had on the screen. So I'd like to open it to see if any of our panelists have any thoughts or would like to respond to anything that just came up. OK, over to you, Cheryl.

EMRIPEMRIPVice-Chair

Thank you very much, Chair. And I want to direct this to Mexico that offered the questions. And Mexico celebrates the constitutional progress that has been achieved in your country. And just to address your question about the inclusion of women and children in FPIC processes, as an example from my own country, Canada, There was a legal development earlier this year, 2025, in Canadian federal courts. The case is Kapeewik First Nation versus Canadian Nuclear Labs, and this was a very important ruling in Canada. landmark on affirming again the status, legal status of the Declaration within the Canadian legal framework, but taking some very concrete and positive action concerning FPIC. And the court here affirmed that Indigenous people do have the right of FPIC on any project involving hazardous waste in their territory. And the judge actually sent the community and the company back to the table and provided a deadline of time. The company was ordered to pay the First Nations capacity funding to develop their own FPIC protocol that mandated the inclusion of women and children within that protocol, and then once the protocol was developed, put it into practice before coming back to the table. So this was to be financed by the company. The case is currently being appealed by the company and also some other third-party stakeholders. But I think it's an important example of a very micro project that has larger impacts on the development of FPIC and indigenous people. So thank you very much for the question.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you. I now hand over to His Excellency Jose Francisco.

GuatemalaPermanent Representative

Thank you.

Well, I'd like to thank the delegate from Mexico for the question. There are many examples out there. I think Mexico is one of them, not just with the constitutional reform, but the practice of indigenous communities, and particularly of female indigenous people. There are many examples. that we see in Mexico and in other countries. And from there, we see the idea of building a study of the role of women in development, application, and the transfer of knowledge from indigenous communities. In Oaxaca, for example, those who were conducting irrigation or the use of water, and they managed to recover a water basin, a water table in those communities. There's a lot that involves acknowledging the role played by female indigenous leaders, but not just in mitigation, but also how to live in harmony with Mother Earth. And I also heard from one of the speakers saying, we need to just take what we need. And I think that indigenous women in the state of Oaxaca showed that not only did they just take what they need, but they actually return to the earth what they took from it. And there are many examples like this. Also in India, I know about the water collection, and in Bolivia and Peru, in the Andes, how women get up early and they go to try to collect water, not just for their own consumption, but water for their crops and water to give back to Mother Earth. I think the role is fundamental, the role played by Indigenous women. I'll leave it there. I mean, I could talk at length about this, but I'll stop here. Thank you.

Moderator; Head of Research

Thank you so much. I hand back to the Honourable Chair. Thank you.

Chair

Thank you very much, and thanks to all the panellists for your interventions and And important input, as well as to the floor. Now, I would, before closing the panel, I would like to remind everybody that we have two side events that are starting in a quarter of an hour. One is in room 11 in building A on global ethical stocktake, and the other is in room 12, again in building A, elections for people and the planet. And with that, I'd like to close the fifth panel. Thank you.