Skip to main content

4th Meeting, 6th Session Forum on Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law

17 November·09:00·02:52:54Meetings & Events

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

Audio no longer matches transcript

This transcript was made from an earlier 3h13m version of the audio that has since been shortened to 2h52m. Some parts may not match playback.

CzechiaChair

Good afternoon, distinguished delegates, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome back. I hereby officially declare open the fourth and final meeting of this sixth session of the Forum. We begin with a panel titled "Leveling up Democracy: Innovative Approaches to Build Democratic Resilience." Please note that there will be no intervention from the floor for this panel. Let me welcome our moderator, the United Nations Assistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs, Mr. Felipe Poyer. Felipe, you have the floor.

UNAssistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs; Moderator

Thank you, Ambassador and Chairperson of the Forum. It's a pleasure to be with you. Good afternoon. Good afternoon to all of our amazing panelists. to the member states and organizations and young people in the room. It is really a pleasure to join you on, I would say, a very special session on how games, how digital technologies, and how innovative and maybe out-of-the-box approaches can actually help to strengthen democratic resilience. Because democracy is not only sustained through institutions and elections, but it's actually about everyday experiences that shape how people understand their rights, how they engage, and how also they express their views and participate in decisions that affect their lives. And for young people in particular, Meaningful civic participation begins long before the first time we vote. It's actually about how we are ready and we are prepared to test ideas, to work together, and to navigate differences and experience the impact that collective action has. And today we are going to hear from five panelists. whose work actually explores opportunities from different perspectives, from civic education to gaming communities and to virtual reality, artificial intelligence, and a lot, a lot of youth-led innovation. So really looking forward to learn from you. And allow me to start by introducing the first panelist. Ms. Sabine Jenny, and sorry for my pronunciation, if I'm wrong, I'll do my best. Sabine is a co-director and co-founder of Democrative, an initiative for civic education. And drawing on Demogames project, Sabine will explore actually how games can create learning experiences. how they can develop skills and competencies, and she will reflect on why games are effective when they are actually accompanied by a structured reflection and a broader educational process. So Sabine, the floor is yours.

DemocrativeCo-Director and Co-Founder

So start again. Thank you. Good afternoon. To start my input, i would like to remind you by new statements from young people this morning, which impressed me. You remember Ronja, a young girl who participated in a youth council, said that the experience of participating in this youth council changed her life. I think this is what participation means. And I heard a statement from the floor where a young man said that participation by youth That we should stop measure participation by use by the number of young people in the room, but by the influence they have on decision outcomes. So these two aspects, real participation and real empowerment and the strength of it, I think are part of the answer to the first question I was asked to answer. Why use games for democracy and citizenship education? Games allow us to create real experiences of participation, and such real experiences empower us. We also need knowledge, absolutely. But to participate effectively, we need to be able to use it. We must be able to learn, to change perspective, to collaborate with others, to compete with others, and to deal with conflicts. You can already go to the second slide, thank you. No, to the second, just. Just a second slide, which is before. Yeah, no, no, it's still before, but okay. When playing games, you use and train these abilities. Players move game materials on the table, and the slide is about participants that move physically as in the photos. They share a process which they shape themselves. To make use of the real experiences they create, games must be embedded in an educational process. I like to imagine this educational process like a bracket that holds the gaming experience together and makes it fruitful for learning. Of course, learning also takes place in spontaneous play, but today I'm speaking about so-called serious games which are designed for educational purposes. The opening bracket starts the game-based learning sessions, includes defining the interaction tone and the rules. The closing bracket comes after the gameplay. And it's a reflection phase, or debriefing, as we call it. And I think this debriefing phase is important for all learning through participation, not only with games. In this phase, learning deepens as players reflect on their own behavior and skills. Learning is extended beyond the individual experience as players learn to change perspective and to learn from the experience of others. And here is something we observe again and again. Often, in the same room, at the same table, players have entirely different experiences, even when playing with the same instructions and materials. So this brings me to the second question: How is game-based learning or how can it be related to values? I will try to answer this question based on three games we developed within the Demogames project. These games are freely available online. Example number one: Observe. Yes, this is the next slide. Observers is a game in which players learn about and reflect on democratic principles and values. We also call it the Democratic Black Stories game. Some of you may know Black Stories. It is a cooperative riddle-based game. On the right side of the slide, you see an example of an observer's card, a title, an image, a riddle. Think about this picture. What could be the story behind it? I will tell you the story at the end of the presentation. This game has a knowledge aspect, and the guessing process makes you active constructors of this knowledge. As the stories are real, they include the ambiguities of real life. The real people in the stories make the democratic principles and values relatable. Think about the image. We will come back to it at the end of the presentation. Now, another example, draw the line. This game comes without specific political or democratic content. It resembles very classical competitive and strategic board games which are known in many cultures. This means that players behave, thus play, reproducing the norms and values they have inherited for such situations. They play and then they reflect on their experience and in this way they discover their own, perhaps implicit values, which guide them in interactions. The educational guidance helps them relate this to broader questions of society, democracy, and participation. For example, we use it to reflect on cooperation and competition. I remember a workshop when a colleague working in the social sector reflected about her competitive character after playing Draw the Line. She started wondering how she would behave if she ever decided to enter politics. A third example, we did another approach, Demo Dice. If this game is about a value, it is about the diversity of human experience. The symbols you see on the slide are symbols which are on the demo dice. It's a dice-based storytelling game where you tell stories individually or collectively. Nowadays, polarization and the lack of communication across so-called bubbles are often mentioned as a challenge for our societies. I am convinced that participation cannot start weird and must not be limited to the exchange of opinions. We must learn, maybe before, to share and to listen to experiences and ideas. Demodice teaches us that our peers have different associations when looking at the same symbol, at the same picture. In Demodice, we learn that other ideas may came from places and experiences that are very different from our own. We may still disagree, of course, but hopefully we learn to listen first. So last but not least, the biggest question, does this work? Just one disclaimer, educational processes are very complex and participation and empowerment are particularly difficult outcomes to measure. I would like to share three lessons we have learned in more than 200 game-based workshops. One, the process is crucial and it must reflect and implement the values we want the workshop to be about. This is, for example, what the Council of Europe calls education through democracy. If we recall Demodice, If we want the players to be open and show their interest in each other's story, then we must be open and show our interest as well. We cannot exclude a story because it did not meet our expectations. This brings me to lesson number two: Be clear about the rules and open about the rest. Games allow us to provide real experiences through democracy. Beware of the danger of fake experiences. And I think this is what we heard this morning. If young people are can speak, but then they never hear back what happened to their ideas. We must think carefully before the learning session starts about what the boundaries of the participants' behavior should be. Make them explicit, and then really let happen what happens inside these boundaries. For example, we had the competitive game, draw the line as an example. Players may choose not to play. They may say, if we do not move, everyone has the same share of the cake as in the beginning, and we prefer that. Or they may create a coalition of two against the third player. Both strategies may be frustrating for someone. Do not hinder such process ad hoc. Set the rules beforehand. They can be like everything that is allowed by the school rules or by the law is okay, or everything that does not put participants in danger. This is very useful if you are the responsible adult in the room. But be aware that it's very powerful if you let the participants shape the process. It becomes, in part, unforeseeable and uncontrollable for you, but let them choose a strategy and use a debriefing to show your interest in it and give them the responsibility to explain their choice, to face the consequences, and to listen to how their peers experience their action. And this brings me to the third lesson. Game-based learning needs training for trainers and teachers. We offer our materials freely, but we learned that we must offer more. We trained our own team of facilitators and workshops with the demo games can be booked and we send a team. Often it works like this, that a pedagogue then invites us once or twice and then starts to use our material on their own and adapt it to his or her own goals and needs. We also offer trainings for teachers and trainers who wish to learn how to use the demo games or games more generally. And what is more, we share entire workshop plans to make it as easy as possible and as straightforward as possible to use the games in workshops and lessons. Now, I owe you the story behind the riddle left out in the rain. I think, yeah, one slide more. Skip this one. Yes. Here is the Solution, left out in the rain, is the story of a disabled man who could not access his polling station very easily because he could not climb the stairs. In the end, he managed to vote, but the secrecy of his vote could not be guaranteed as the ballot was brought to the street in the rain by a polling station volunteer. This story helps us teach, speak about the right to vote, about inclusion, about the secrecy of vote and why it is important. To summarize, games are powerful tools because they allow people to experience and practice participation and democratic values rather than simply learn about them. But the game alone is not enough. You cannot delegate learning to the game. Meaningful learning requires skilled facilitation and an educational process that embodies the values we want to promote. Like this, we empower people for democracy by giving them the opportunity to experience and practice it together. And we hope that this empowering people makes democracy more resilient. Thank you.

UNAssistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs; Moderator

Thank you. Thank you, Sarene, for your presentation and intervention. I want to highlight the way you started, and the need for really advancing the way we measure participation, not just by numbers, but influence. And I believe this experience you are sharing about how education actually can create opportunities for us to experience democratic principles and engage and reflect on the choices we make is a very powerful one. Our next speaker will take us into the world of digital gaming and the culture and communities that have grown around it. And she will Correct me if this figure is wrong, but there's almost more than 3 billion players worldwide. And video games are actually a major part of how many people communicate, they connect, and they participate in society. And for that, we have with us Nandita Wegehaupt. Sorry if I mispronounce your last name. She's the managing director of the Digital Game Culture Foundation. And she will discuss how gaming communities can become spaces for democratic practice and how existing games can be used in schools and support civic education. Nandita, please, the floor is yours.

Digital Game Culture FoundationManaging Director

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, Excellencies, distinguished delegates, dear colleagues, it's a pleasure to be here, and it's exactly right. Worldwide, more than 3 billion people play video games on phones, computers, consoles, and I'm sure many of you too. In Germany, my country, six in ten people play. Nearly 80% of them are adults, and almost half of them are women. That makes games one of the most important media of our time. And They are as diverse as films and literature, from blockbusters to educational games to artistic experiences. So if we want to get people involved in democracy, we need to take this part of their lives seriously. A Bertelsmann Foundation study from last year shows how worthwhile that is. The study looks at how players in Germany feel about democracy. Like the rest of the population, the vast majority sees democracy as the best form of government. But most revealing are those of whom gaming is a big part in their life. Nearly two-thirds of them say that all in all, democracy in Germany works, compared with just over half of the general population. And almost half of these gaming enthusiasts have taken part in petitions and citizen participation processes in the past year. This is more than average. Gaming does not automatically make people democrats and is not democratic at itself. But in the world of gaming, we find a lot of people who want to get involved. I run the Foundation for Digital Games Culture, a nonprofit based in Berlin. We don't develop games ourselves. We work with existing ones and bring the gaming world together with education, research, and civil society so that people can actively shape society with and in games. We do this in two ways. through the communities that form online around games and through games as a learning tool. Let's start with gaming communities. You will find them on chat platforms like Discord, in livestream chats, or in established groups inside a game. That's where many gamers spend their free time, swap ideas, make friendships that often carry on offline as well. According to the study, almost nine out of 10 community members feel understood and supported there. Just like in a sports club, all kinds of people come together, young and old, with different interests and life stories. Gaming communities reflect our society. And many of them grow from the bottom up, driven by their own members. Like any community, a gaming community needs rules for how people treat each other and people to uphold them. There are two interesting roles. Community managers often do this as their main job, for example, for a gaming studio. And moderators keep an eye on the rules day by day largely as volunteers after work. They resolve conflicts, support members, and push back against hostility. When they explain the rules and make sure that they get followed, that everyone is fairly treated, and everyone is given a say, they are putting democracy into practice. These people are the key figures who shape a gaming community. At the same time, as we all know, democracies around the world are under pressure in the moment. Authoritarian and populist forces spread disinformation, undermine trust in democracy and in democratic institutions, and deepen social division. Gaming communities are not immune to that. These anti-democratic forces deliberately try to misuse them to reach out to young people and spread hateful messages, often disguised as humor and gaming slang. Anyone who stands up to this in their community is showing what we call digital civil courage, and this deserves more attention and more support. That's where our Community Support Network comes in. We launched it to bring together moderators and community managers, volunteers, and professionals alike. In offline and online workshops, they learn from each other how to defuse conflicts, set fair rules, protect themselves from overload. By strengthening these key figures, we work, we make whole. gaming communities safer and fairer places with no room for hate or radicalization. The work is funded by the German government's Live Democracy program, so everything we offer is free. That is public funding that makes a real difference for people who stand up for their democratic values in their own community. Our second approach takes us into the classroom. Like books and films, games can be used for learning, with one key difference: they are interactive. When you play, you don't just watch. You act, you make decisions, and you see the consequences. You experience empowerment within the setting of the digital game, and you are making a difference. And a well-designed game is neither too hard nor too easy, so motivation stays high. Many kind of games work for this, including entertainment games like Minecraft, which is used in schools worldwide. Which game is right depends on what the lesson is about and who is learning. One example. for a game we use in schools, is called The Darkest Files. It's by the Berlin studio Paint Bucket Games. In April, it won the German Computer Game Award for the best German game. It's kind of the German Oscar for games, as you like. The game is set in 1950s West Germany, a few years after the Nazi era. Many people want to leave the past behind, and former Nazis still hold posts. in the courts and in the civil service. Players take on the role of Esther Katz, a young prosecutor working for Fritz Bauer, the real prosecutor general who set the Frankfurt Auschwitz trials in motion. The cases are based on actual historical cases. Players examine files, question witnesses, put together what happens, and bring charges. And they constantly have to separate what they suspect and what they can prove. So, in the game, the rule of law isn't just explained, but players exercise it themselves, and they practice exactly that kind of critical thinking this forum is about. Afterwards, the class talks about how they reached their verdict, and what perspective the game takes on. In our experience, students enjoy learning with games a lot, even though these games often differ from the ones they play at home. We work together with the Ministry of Education, with partners from research and media education, and we develop units on games, on this game and on many more. We introduce teachers to this digital game-based learning methods and test them in school, and we make freely available for everyone open educational resources. Both approaches show how institutions can engage with the world of digital and video games. And yet, gaming's democratic potential remains largely untapped. In civic education and in the support for civic engagement, there are still very few initiatives that reach young people where they play and where they interact around games. So my recommendations to governments and to the civic society organizations is: Make games part of your strategies for education and for democratic participation. Support the people who take on responsibility in gaming communities, and help educators work with games. Our example comes from Germany, but there are gaming communities and gamers in every country. And the right approaches are best developed together with local communities, gamers, and educators. To a substantial degree, our social lives take place in digital spaces today. That's where relationships form, where values are negotiated, and where people take on responsibility. If we want democracy to be fit for the future, we have to strengthen digital civil courage and encourage people to stand up for democracy in the digital realm too. Thank you.

UNAssistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs; Moderator

Danke. Thank you, Nandita. And your presentation really highlighted the importance of of gaming communities as real social spaces in which people collaborate, build relationships, and exercise also their rights and responsibilities. And this is definitely a space that has an enormous potential when it's about civic education. And now we will turn into two initiatives. that demonstrate how digital tools can translate civic learning into practical participation and community engagement. And we are moving from Germany to East Africa, and we have with us Marie Yvonne Ododa, who is executive director of Nuru Trust Network, and she will introduce us to two platforms. One is VoteWise, a gamified civic learning platform, and the second one is PeaceVerse, which is a voice-first, early warning, and youth peacebuilding platform that helps communities to remain safe, to participate. And she will draw on her experience and the experience in Kenya and reflect on how these tools can strengthen young people's civic agency in a country which has a very vibrant, youthful population, and creative. So, Mary, the floor is yours.

Nuru Trust NetworkExecutive Director

Good afternoon, everyone. Good afternoon, Philippe, Chair, delegates. Thank you so much for this opportunity, and I carry the weight of the voices that are not in this room. To begin with, there are two short reels I'd like for us to have a look at, and then I will explain.

Speaker 8

Welcome to VoteWise, where you learn democracy one game at a time. This is a demonstration as to how the website works. Firstly, you click start learning. It takes you to four learning modules. Pick a learning module of your choice and it shows you what the module contains. This module contains five flashcards and three quiz questions. Click start learning to start reading the flashcards. Read and internalize this flashcard as best as you can so that you can do the quiz as best as possible. Click continue to quiz. and start answering these questions. If you get all the questions correct, you earn a badge as well as 30 points to your username. Click on the leaderboard and you will see the ranking of your user. And this encourages competition amongst users and stops them from voting ignorantly and start voting wisely. Choose VoteWise.

PeaceVerse, from early warning to early action.

Voice-first design reaches people facing barriers of literacy, connectivity, or language, and people who distrust the formal communication channels. Communities report what they see.

And humans verify it.

Rumors are all checked.

Credible warning reaches community peace actors and responsible institutions. Many threats now begin online.

That is why cyber safety training and digital incident reporting are part of the approach that we are taking.

In youth dialogue cycles, young people from different communities work through grievances and challenge divisive narratives.

Young people are not a risk to be managed.

Given tools and trust, they are among the most effective early warners and peace builders we have.

Peaceverse, building democratic resilience from the ground up.

Nuru Trust NetworkExecutive Director

Thank you so much. The two short reels that we have just watched introduced two of some of the tools developed through Southeast Up program, which is an initiative of NeuroTrust Network. VoteWise Kenya, as mentioned, is a gamified civic learning platform, and PeaceVUS is a voice-first early warning and youth peace-building platform. They respond to two sides of the same challenge. A resilient democracy needs citizens who know how to participate and communities that are safe enough for them to do so. VoteWise works on the first, PeaceVUS works on the second. In a game, you do not level up by reading the rulebook. You level up by playing, making mistakes, and trying again. Democracy is no different. But neither tool is the destination, and technology on its own does not make a democracy resilient. Democratic resilience is often discussed in terms of institutions. Those institutions matter, but resilience is also built or lost in communities, in other people are understanding their rights, whether they can tell fact from manipulation, whether they can disagree without violence, and whether they can trust that taking part makes a difference. In Kenya, we know very well what happens when the fabric tears. The violence that followed the 2007 elections cost us more than a thousand lives and displaced hundreds of thousands of people. And today, those risks have evolved. We're talking hate speech, disinformation, and mobilization tends to travel faster, often online, and very often they target young people. And the pressures on our social fabric no longer come only from elections. Climate change, for instance, is driving drought, loss of livelihoods, pushing communities into competition over water, pasture, and land. Across our region, some places are living with emerging conflict, while others are rebuilding it, where trust is fragile and a single rumor can undo years of progress. And as we approach the 2027 general elections, civic education and violence prevention are not separate agendas for us. Both are conditions for democracy. I'll talk about each tool and how they connect. On VoteWise, the focus is from civic awareness to civic agency. We often teach young people how democracy is supposed to work, but we do not always give them opportunities to experience how it should work. VoteWise uses interactive, gamified learning to introduce young people to constitutional rights, democratic institutions, voter registration, and electoral processes. The aim is to make these subjects less intimidating and more relatable, particularly for young people who may not encounter meaningful civic education in schools. But knowing when and how to register to vote is only one part of citizenship. Through VoteWise, we want young people to understand how public institutions work, how budgets and public decisions affect their communities, what accountability means, and how to engage beyond the ballots. We see Votewise as part of continuous civic learning, not a campaign that appears before polling day. Votewise can be accessed in English, Kiswahili, and Somali, and we are currently working on five other languages in Kenya, because civic rights mean very little if they're only explained in a language people do not speak at home. Learners can download content and keep playing offline, and their progress syncs when they reconnect. On Peacewise, we are focusing on early warning to early action. Many people who are closest to emerging tensions face barriers of literacy, connectivity, or language, or simply do not trust formal channels. Peace First is designed around voice, so that people can share what they are seeing and hearing by speaking rather than filling in forms. It works in English, Kiswahili, French, Arabic, and Somali, and currently working on Amharic and Luganda. These are the languages spoken across the Horn of Africa, so that people can report in the language that they think and feel in. Collecting signals is not enough, so Peace First combines community reporting with human verification. Rumors are checked and they're acted on. Credible warnings can reach community peace actors and institutions responsible for responding. Because many threats are now beginning online, we are also integrating cyber safety training and digital incident reporting. This matters most in the places where stakes are highest. Peace First also supports youth dialogue circles where people from different communities, including host and displaced communities, talk through their grievances, challenge divisive narratives, and develop their own responses to local tensions. Young people are too often treated as a risk to be handled, but when given the tools and the trust, they are among the most effective early warners and peace builders we have. But we must also be honest about a hard reality. When tensions are highest, connectivity is often the first thing to go. We saw this in Kenya during the Gen. Z protests, when internet access was disrupted at the very moment people most needed to share information, check on one another, and stay safe. Any tool that works only when the internet is on will fail precisely when it is needed the most. That's why we're building for disruption, not just for ideal conditions. Peace First can receive reports through voice calls, SMS, and USSD codes, which do not need mobile data. Trained community focal points can collect and relay reports by phone, radio, or in person. Reports are captured offline and are stored and sent as soon as connection returns, and Peace First can also be used offline. The principle is simple: when the network fails, the community should not be left without a way to be heard. And technology is just one layer. Trusted people on the ground, such as peace committees, youth leaders, women leaders, and local radio, are what keep early warning alive when the screens go dark. From our work, we have come to believe four things. We offer them as lessons from our practice and as an invitation to build together. First, civic and peace innovation is democratic infrastructure. In our experience, it only works when it is sustained. not just in election years. Second, the loop must be closed. We have seen that young people build agency when they are in practice. We're talking about school governance, local decisions, and public consultations well before voting age. An early warning only matters when it connects to national and local peace structures with clear responsibility as to who responds. Third, tools must be built for the hardest conditions. That means climate-affected and displaced communities, places entering or emerging from conflict, local languages, and internet shutdowns. These are the moments when safety and trust matter the most. And last but not least, we need to measure resilience, not just reach. We're learning to ask whether young people are thinking critically, whether violence is presented, whether trust is rebuilt, and whether institutions are responding. This needs to be measured. And we hold one more belief. Innovation must not create new exclusions. These tools must work for persons with disabilities, for areas of poor connectivity, and in the languages people actually speak. Technology can widen access, but it cannot replace trusted community relationships. I will close with this thought. We shall not educate young people merely to participate in systems that remain unchanged or ask them to keep peace in systems that don't listen to them. We should equip them to question, to protect, and improve those systems, while ensuring that institutions are ready to listen and act. Leveling up democracy means moving from awareness to agency, and from early warning to early action. It means making sure that when young people speak up, someone answers, even when the network is down. Asanteni sana. Thank you.

UNAssistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs; Moderator

Thank you, Mary. And I believe your presentation made a very interesting approach to the importance, not only on the ability to participate, but actually on the conditions that make participation meaningful, and the importance of trust and safety, and the criticality about really being informed and empowered when it's about exercising our rights, no? And for us to be able to exercise our rights without fear, which is definitely critical at this time more than ever. So thank you for it. I'll now move to Emily, Emily Gorodetsky. that will share a youth-led perspective on using immersive technology to make civic participation more accessible. Emily is the founder and executive director of VRing Democracy, and through her work, she's developing virtual reality voter education simulations. and bringing them directly to communities. So, Emily, thank you for being with us, and the floor is yours.

VRing DemocracyFounder and Executive Director

Thank you very much. Honorable Chair, distinguished guests, fellow panelists, thank you very, very much for this opportunity. As you mentioned, my name is Emily Goretzky. I am a university student from San Francisco, California, and the founder and executive director of VRing Democracy. So, let's get into the journey of how I started this. Next slide, please. It all started when I was part of a fellowship called the Civic Innovator Fellowship from Civics Unplugged. Within this fellowship, we learned all of these issues that are happening not just in our community, but around the world. Socio-economic issues, political issues, environmental issues. But most importantly, we learned how do we make the solutions needed to tackle these problems. Because as we all mentioned in this conference today, youth are not just the leaders of tomorrow, they're the leaders of today. Within a breakout space within this fellowship, I was connected with two other girls, and we were discovering different issues that were happening within our community, and we wanted to see what can we do to make a difference about this. Next slide, please. So. An issue that we kind of grounded ourselves in during this fellowship that took place in April of 2024 was there was this big election that was coming up, and although we were 15 and 16 at the time, so we were two and three years out from being able to cast our very first vote, we were nervous. We were very scared. And when we heard that our peers that were 18 and could vote were saying, I don't feel confident to do it. Our civic education system within our school just didn't really prepare us for exactly what do you do when you go and you get a ballot? What does it look like and what happens? And so for us, we wanted to fix that gap and make sure that people are very confident by the time that they're able to cast their very first vote. So how do we go about doing this? It started with the idea of what if we create a polling place where you can just practice, practice what it's like to go through the voting machine, to go through the documents that you would need to prepare, and all in all, just feel more confident. We also wanted to make sure that any issues that we imagined could come up on voting day were addressed, because research has shown that if you're more confident to do something, you're more likely to actually go and do it. So it was really important to us, because I'm from San Francisco and it's a very diverse city, that we're able to translate the experience to not just have it be in English, but also in Spanish and Mandarin. Now, let's go and let's check out what it looks like. So this is inside of Yaring Democracy. You'll see two options. You can change the language, so changing it to Spanish or Mandarin. And then you have a list of interactions that you can go through. So first, I did not choose.

Speaker 12

Great, you can go to the next interaction. Hello there, I am Kate. The time is up. Please leave the voting line.

VRing DemocracyFounder and Executive Director

Part of the Know Your Rights.

Speaker 14

Please, never leave the line if you are waiting and the time ends. Looks like you know your rights.

VRing DemocracyFounder and Executive Director

What would you do if the voting machine was not working? You would go back to the poll worker and ask for a paper ballot.

Speaker 16

You have asked for a paper ballot. That's correct. Great job on knowing your rights. Please cast your vote in the machine.

VRing DemocracyFounder and Executive Director

Oh no.

Speaker 18

Let's say you cast a vote to someone other than whom you intended to. What will you do now?

VRing DemocracyFounder and Executive Director

You would go again and ask the poll worker for a paper ballot.

Speaker 20

You have asked for a new ballot. That's correct. Great job on knowing your rights.

VRing DemocracyFounder and Executive Director

And then something that was really important to us was being able to research political candidates. So we use Ballotpedia, which is a trusted governmental site in our area, to show people what it'd be like if you researched a candidate through like an imaginary laptop situation. Okay, and that was our very first scene. Next slide, please. Something that was really important for me was the outreach part. Creating the scene took a lot of my summer, and it was very intensive, but I was able to work with a lot of partners and other organizations to be able to turn this into something that could really help others. Namely, I worked a lot with my library. I worked with the League of Women Voters, and they were really, really important mentors to tell me who exactly should I talk to, where should I bring this headset, and what changes do I need to make and improve. For all of the community organizations that are out here today, I really hope that you extend yourself to Give the same amount of support to the youth that look up to you. There's a lot of people that might have these ideas, but don't think they have the resources needed to create that. So if you're able to be a guiding light for them, I think that's the most important part, to turn something like this into a real solution. Next slide, please. Another really important partnership that I had was with the New Voters Organization. It's a nonprofit in the US that is entirely youth run, and it helps other youth, help other people to register because, you know, we might not be able to do it ourselves, but we still care a lot about this issue. We want to do what we can. So I was able to work with three different youth leaders in New Jersey, New York, and Texas, and I sent them these VR headsets, and they were able to use them when they were doing their voter registration drives, and we kind of call this like a flash hub partnership. So this was really exciting, and it just happened just before the midterm elections. Next slide, please. But there was a big problem that we encountered after we created this, was what do we do on years when there's no elections? How do we still make sure tools like VR is important for civic engagement? That's where this City Hall and Community Voices experience came out. This is our prototype for it. You'll be able to knock on different neighbors' doors and have these conversations, especially, this is called canvassing. So you're going around, like, you want to help a certain political candidate that you believe in get more votes. We wanted to make sure that people could be able to also practice that. So this is some examples of different questions that you could ask a neighbor and different responses that they could probably come up with. And how do you just have that conversation with that person? As you can see, there's a graphics designer that we were talking to. There's also an opportunity to have a way to look at all of the houses that you visit. and just be able to track them. So it's kind of like a fun gamified version where you can compete with your friends and be like, how many houses have you visited? I also like this town hall feature that we're envisioning where you can reflect on this and also have different community resources where you can learn how to register to vote, how to be involved within your community with local community service. And there's also a volunteer debrief section. So also, you can look at this on your laptops right now. If you go to the website, civicVRpulse.com, you can look at the experience yourself. Next slide, please. But I want to end off my presentation with saying that I came into that breakout room with a question. I'm here today because I had a chance to do something with it. Imagine what more young people could do if they had that chance too. So my invitation to the institutions in this room. is to give young people a real role to design and participate in civic education. That could mean inviting students to help plan a workshop, giving them a space to test a prototype, or connecting them with a resource that can help them bring it into their communities, schools, and the government. And to all the youth in the room, you don't have to wait until you're older to make an impact. I started this at 15. A single idea can grow into something that reaches and helps communities around the world. You too can turn your dreams into reality. I hope you all have taken away a sense of hope or inspiration from my presentation. And please scan these QR codes to keep involved with my journey and my future as a civic leader. Thank you very much.

UNAssistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs; Moderator

Thank you, Emily, for sharing your experience and for demonstrating all of us how young people are actually driving change. and how young people are not just users of technology, but actually are creators and innovators. And for our final presentation, we are going to turn into our panelists that will bring us to the topic of artificial intelligence and the potential of it to make civic knowledge more accessible and engaging. And for that, we have with us Noamyn Tibebe Belete, who is an anti-corruption education youth officer at the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, and she will introduce us to GRAZI, which is an artificial intelligence tool developed through UNODC's GRACE initiative and built by young winners of the Coding for Integrity hackathons. So with that, the floor is yours, Noamin.

UNODCAnti-Corruption Education Youth Officer

Thank you so much, distinguished chair, distinguished guests and panelists. First and foremost, before getting into GRACE, I would like to start off this session by asking everyone a question. What if the same technology that facilitates corruption can also be used to prevent the same corruption that people use to facilitate corruption? And also, what if young people were not simply the users of these technologies, but the ones that are developing the solutions themselves? Now, that being asked, this afternoon, I would like to present to you a practical example on how Gracie Through the GRECE Initiative, GRECE is bringing together education, youth empowerment, and innovative technology to combat corruption and building a more democratic world. Before getting into GRECE itself, I would like to explain the approach that makes our work possible. First, we have this simple belief, which is grounded under the United Nations Convention Against Corruption, which is that building a culture of integrity cannot be the responsibility of governments alone. We think that it requires a whole of society approach. That being said, we have three approaches in the work that we do. The first one is educate. We educate young people, we educate teachers, we educate the society, and all levels of education. We advance anti-corruption ethics and integrity education across all levels of education, as mentioned, while developing tools and knowledge products to promote peer-to-peer learning. After educating, we empower. We empower those we have educated. We work together with young people in strengthening their meaningful engagement in anti-corruption efforts through research, advocacy, and practical solutions. And at the heart of this is our Youth-led Integrity Advisory Board, which comprises of 43 young leaders of today from 46 different countries. And lastly, we connect. We bring together academia, civil society, educators, young people, and states parties. ética y toma de decisiones moral. Vivimos en una época en la que la IA cada vez influye más en cómo capta la.

Información la gente, cómo toma decisiones al respecto y cómo se comunica.

Esto brinda oportunidades y suscita.

También preguntas sobre las responsabilidades, el comportamiento sano y los riesgos del mal uso de la IA. 文化不是一夜而形成,它不能只是立法就能实.

现,它必须通过教育参与和实质性的参与的机会。我还想传达.

的便是,我们要向年轻人提问的是,他们对民主.

有什么样的想法,我们还有呢,就是腐败.

是什么样的想法。

Speaker 24

What if learning about integrity?

Wasn't just something you read about, but something you could experience? Meet Gracie, an AI-powered educational experience where young people explore ethics, challenge.

Assumptions, and discover what integrity looks like in action.

UNAssistant Secretary-General for Youth Affairs; Moderator

And to develop critical thinking and especially to engage with others, no? And also, as many of the panelists reflected, is when people see that their voices and actions can actually make a difference. But perhaps the central message from today's panel is that we need to meet young people not only where they are, but actually it's about recognizing the spaces and the culture and the tools through which they are already learning, connecting, and organizing. So.

空间等,所以我们在这里感谢出色的专家。那么现在我要请主席来为我们这一场专家会议呢来做结论。

CzechiaChair

我们完成了本次的小组讨论,谢谢主持,谢谢.

嘉宾,谢谢各位参与了本次讨论的各位。

现在我请最后一组的小组成员上台加入我们。

OHCHRModerator

Les outils technologiques sont des outils de participation, mais on ne considère pas le rôle joué par ces technologies dans ce qui rend possible la participation. Une démocratie ne naît pas parce que les gens peuvent s'exprimer. La démocratie dépend de la manière dont les gens peuvent se créer leur propre avis indépendamment, travailler de manière constructive avec les autres et influencer les affaires publiques. Si l'éducation se transforme en données, alors qui décide de ce que l'on doit apprendre? Si les médias gèrent l'accès à la connaissance, comment déterminer notre connaissance et notre compréhension de l'espace public? Et qu'en est-il de la reddition de comptes démocratique? Si la participation en ligne accroît l'exposition des gens au harcèlement et à l'exclusion, alors quelles voix sont entendues et quelles voix sont réduites au silence? Ms. Claudia.

Roda, Professor at the American University of Paris and holder of the UNESCO Chair in AI and Human Rights. And we'll start with Professor Beiter. Please, the floor is yours. Thank you.

Professor

Does the right to education include a right to AI and EdTech, educational technology? I'm not sure that it does. One of the key messages of UNESCO's flagship Global Education Monitoring Report of 2023 on technology in education is that there's little robust evidence on digital technologies and AI's added value in education. Even so, for the purposes of my talk, let's assume that access to edtech and AI cannot be denied in education. If edtech and AI cannot be denied in education, what then would be the exact role of governments? Ensure that edtech and AI we currently find in institutions meet certain quality standards? Virtually all such technology is provided by commercial, private actors operating globally. Or should we envisage a much bigger role for the public when it comes to edtech and AI? I want to talk about the public-private divide in education in the age of ethic and AI. I want to talk about public AI. The right to education is laid down in international treaties as first and foremost a right to public education, education provided or organized by the state. This is in accordance with the landmark US case Brown versus Board of Education of Topeka, in terms of which education is a crucial function of state and local governments. Simultaneously, however, international law also protects the right of every person to establish private schools, a right subject to the proviso that education in such schools must meet certain minimum standards laid down by the state. However, gone are the days when the private education assumed essentially the form of non-commercial, value-inspired, choice-enriching private schools. Education today increasingly takes place in digital environments. The threat digitization poses for education, including its liberating democratic and civic function, seems largely to escape attention. Digitization is not merely a change in the modalities of education. It has become the principal instrument driving the privatization of education. While the ideological groundwork for privatization was laid during the last quarter of the 20th century, during a conceptual phase of economization, the present century initially witnessed a more straightforward phase of commercialization, characterized by the increasing provision of education for profit by both states and a growing number of private actors. We have now entered a further phase of privatization, my colleagues Janja Komljenovic, Ben Williamson, Keane Birch, and I term this assetization, in which state presence in education is increasingly nominal because the internal life of public and private schools alike, the very essence of education, is controlled by private companies and transformed into a lifelong rent-producing asset. Underpinning this development is not only ideological faith in the market's efficiency in delivering education, but also the blunt pursuit of rent seeking. The global EdTech market is worth almost 180 to 280 billion US dollars annually. The narrow AI and education market, 6 to 10 billion US dollars, with annual growth rates of more than 30%. Significant among EdTech products are AI-based technologies employed in what is called personalized learning. Personalized learning is a strategy in terms of which every student's behavior, performance, preferences, and attention patterns are continuously monitored, whether in class, at home, in the gym, or at night in bed, through their smartphones or watches, and analyzed by algorithms to paternalistically eliminate any risk of student failure, preventing the student from learning from making real own choices in the education process, whether right or wrong. EdTech AI is protected by copyright and other intellectual property rights. IP rights and licenses are the central legal mechanism enabling assetization. EdTech AI companies' new control of informational resources, the data generated daily by students, parents, teachers, and school administrators through their interaction with EdTech AI, facilitates the continuous selling back by EdTech companies to schools and universities of insight solutions and products. As it were, IP rights and the licensing increasingly convert facets of public education into new rent-producing assets. Such assetization entails a new way of governance in education. While human rights look on education as a public responsibility, IP right owners of software platforms and data infrastructures now acquire decisive power over educational philosophy, goals, content, organization of teaching and learning, assessment, the everyday lives of students and teachers, and institutional administration management. Indeed, over education is hither to a core democratic function of states. Assetization in education weakens governance through public law while strengthening governance through private law, including property, contract, and intellectual property law. Assetization promotes certain values, languages, and worldviews in education at the expense of others. Education designed by ethic AI companies will affirm rather than contest views of elites, capitalism, consumerism. Assetization converts students as citizens into what we call the citizens. The citizen's rights, duties, and agency in the new dystopian world of education are all but clear, but the citizen certainly is a diminished citizen. If assetization contradicts the very idea of education for liberation, democracy, and citizenship, what then is the solution to assetization? Business and human rights framework devised by John Ruggie? I think more is required. In her 2024 AI report, the UN Special Rapporteur on the right to education recommends promoting open source, interoperable, community-driven and owned educational technologies to combat the oligopoly of large corporations and enhance local innovation. The only long-term strategy can be the adoption of a more public approach in the sphere of edtech and AI. Relying on avant-garde scholarship by thought leaders such as Lawrence Lessig and others The solution to be explored for digital technology and AI in education, but also AI more generally, is what may be termed public AI and public ethic. In the same way, the states at some point had to make firm decisions that postal services, the railway, streets, and bridges, and so on are crucial public infrastructure and service, ethic and AI must become, in many ways, a public infrastructure and service. Public AI ethic is not primarily enhanced supervision of the state, of the private sector. Public AI entails public control at or within the various levels of the AI stack. The AI stack comprises actors at three core levels: compute, data, and models. Public AI entails public control at or within various of these levels. Public control may take various forms: actual digital public infrastructure provided by the state. An option already explored in the UN Global Digital Compact, AI development organized by the non-profit sector or public interest communities, including the scientific and education communities, supported by significant state funding, or indeed sometimes actually state-supported private initiatives. So, there is a lot of scope to explore this, and if you think that all this sounds like science fiction, examples of public AI exist already. Just some examples: the National AI Research Resource Pilot in the United States, the European AI Factories, Canada's Sovereign AI Compute Strategy, and Open Cloud Compute in India, all of which aim to provide the necessary compute infrastructure. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you very much, Professor Beiter. Thank you. I would now like to pass it to Professor Roda, but before I do so, I would like to invite the speakers on the panel to kindly speak a little bit slower because I had heard that the interpreters are having some difficulty understanding. So without further ado, I'll pass it to Professor Roda. Thank you very much.

American University of ParisProfessor; UNESCO Chair in AI and Human Rights

Thank you very much, and thank you for inviting us here, because it should have been two of us. And so I am a computer scientist. My work started with the first generation of AI agents, and as AI grew larger and more powerful, pervasive, and concentrated in fewer hands, it was becoming clear that there were significant risks with the advantages of AI. And since then, I've been working with a human rights scholar, Professor Perry, who unfortunately cannot be here today. Together, we have built a set of ideas around the use of technology, and I'm going to look at two questions based on this idea. One is, what kind of AI do we want for education? And the second one is, what kind of education do we want for AI? Next, please. So let's take an example, or let's think of learning for children. We have principles that go, for example, based on the fact that we only want to use AI and probably technology in general when we are addressing a clear problem. So it's not trials that we are doing. We want teachers oversight. We want data staying in the classroom, and in general, human rights protection, human right by design. So more in particular, next. I'm just going to talk quickly about a project that we started in collaboration with First Book, which is an American NGO that distributes books to school in poor communities. And what they found is that the children were happy to receive the book, but they didn't feel represented. And so the books weren't achieving as much as they could have done. the learning wasn't going as smoothly. So with some of my students, we decided to try and put together this storytelling software based on AI, but making sure that human rights were protected. So teachers in control, and data that remain protected in the classroom, and the anonymity of the children. And all this was possible only because we sort of came out of the chain of assetization that was just mentioned before, and we were working with more, with small language models. The system that we developed, it will be tested by first book, and we intend to extend it to multiple languages, including law research languages. and make it a free and valuable. This is just an example of the idea that we need to come out from the big infrastructure. There are things we can do, it's not as easy, outside the big infrastructure. Next, please. So what about the education that we need about AI? So there has been lots of conversation going around of what it is, literacy for AI. And for example, Selbert presented one of the models that is most used, a multiple literacy, functional, critical, rhetorical, so different ways in which you can approach the learning within the digital and AI. But the problem is that digital technology and AI have eroded democratic processes, have amplified disinformation, deepened inequalities, and so on. And these problems are structural. And although very often we say that education and literacy is one of the solutions, this really shifts the conversation from the provider, those who govern AI, to the individual. So we think that on top of this literacy, we should start thinking about civic engagement as a normal way of equipping students with what they need to learn about AI, in the conversation about what we need to learn about AI. And this moves the conversation from the individual to the public and will help us support our students shaping the society they want to live in, and not only to use technology wisely. So just quickly some examples of what this means in practice. For example, we can build right protecting solution to real problems like the one that I presented just before. We normally respond to consultation on draft regulations with our students. We help vulnerable group navigate AI. And you can think of many way in which you can get the young people involved directly and obtaining visible results. So just to conclude, next, what AI we want for education? We want AI that address specific needs. We want human right by design. And probably this can only be really obtained with small, local solution, and certainly not a one size fit all. And in terms of what education for AI? We want a multiplicity of AI literacy, but literacy alone will not solve the problem generated by AI and will not empower enough the young generation without saving participation to strengthen AI literacy. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you very much, Professor Roda, and especially for reminding us of the importance of civic participation in education, as AI tools alone are not going to achieve what is hoped for. And to that end, we now move to our second cluster, which is precisely about civic participation and the use of digital technologies there, both the opportunities and the risks. And so to introduce our panelists, which are three for this cluster, we have Mr. Ruben Escalante Hasbun, the Geneva representative of Global Citizen. Then we have Ms. Aicha Dabo, who is the co-founder and coordinator of Afriktiviste. And then we have Sarah Gowan, the senior project manager from Code for Africa. I will first turn to Mr. Escalante-Hasboun, please. The floor is yours. Thank you.

Global CitizenGeneva Representative

Thank you very much, Wafa. I think we have a video, so you can have a look at what we do and how our model works. So if we can play that.

Speaker 33

Every year at this time, the world comes to New York City, and this concert is all about giving back to the world.

Global citizens have taken over 30,000 actions to support our work.

Thank you all for being a global citizen.

NorwayFormer Prime Minister

Norway has committed $250 million US.

Speaker 35

The one and only Beyoncé.

Give it up for the First Lady.

First Lady

They deserve the same chances to get an education as my daughters and your daughters.

Speaker 37

Everyone beats down the door of the Global Citizen to perform because it's unlike anything else.

You are now part of.

The global fight to end extreme poverty.

Global citizens like you know that that fight for fairness and equality starts with empowering women and girls.

The Global Citizen Movement, which began just seven years ago with a few friends in a broom closet-sized office in downtown New York.

All for her, the cry and the call of the girl child.

All of you beautiful spirits.

That I hear you, I see you, and I believe you.

60,000 people! Persuade all who you work with, all who rule you, that this is our world and our children deserve better, and we intend to save this world.

One World, Together at Home.

This is Lady Gaga.

To make you guys feel good, so.

We are thanking first responders and others on the front lines of this global pandemic.

We all need each other.

This is real, like, it's no joke.

Defending the planet and defeating poverty is truly a global mission.

From Ghana to New York, we're seeing the power of advocacy in action tonight.

Incredible.

Almost 60,000 global citizens have signed the petition already.

What we do and say makes a difference.

If we don't get together and try and heal some of the hurt, that we've inflicted on Mother Nature, then for our children, grandchildren, and their children, life will be pretty grim.

That sound, that roar, represents the massive impact that is amplified when we join together. to create global change, one action at a time.

I mean, how the heck is anyone gonna be able to follow that?

It's gonna be tough.

Yeah, you know what I think we need?

We need some heart, you know.

Someone that has some soul.

Let's go. Let's go.

Pico, start the party

Global CitizenGeneva Representative

Thank you. I'm sure you didn't thought that you were gonna be seeing Shakira today, but there she is. I also have, yeah, thank you for the slides. So I'm gonna be talking mostly about the opportunities of engagement through social media rather than just the risks, but two big caveats. I am not going to be telling you everything that we do in three minutes, what a nightmare. And number two, this is just another tool within the big toolbox that we've been discussing today. But basically, what we do is we take the music. I saw all of you paying attention to the screen because, as Madonna says, music makes the people come together. So we go and the model works, as we call it, pop and policy. So number one, we do the attention. So we go and we meet young people where they are, sports, music, and we try to get through what they're already looking at, through the apps they are looking at. I'm talking about TikTok, I'm talking about Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, in any other way. Now, one thing is all the artists that you saw, they play for free for our movement, and you cannot see them unless you take the actions. And the moment you take the actions, then you get points. Now, all the actions are basically civic education, right? They are actions calling to your politicians to do things. They are actions taking quizzes about what your rights are. We have a couple of actions, for example, with the Office of the High Commissioner that have taken like 30,000 people. We have actions calling for the release of human rights defenders that have been taken by more than 100,000 people. So we make it in a way that it's not obvious that we are giving them heavy tools, but we are making sure that through the process of them enjoying what they like, they are actually getting the tools to be educated and to be empowered, which is number two. And then at the end, we tie it off with accountability, right? We just, I don't know if you heard at the very beginning, there was an announcement by, she was Erna Solberg, former Prime Minister of Norway. And those are the things that we try to push, not specifically on elections only, but across the board, education, health, climate justice, and whatnot. Now, number, if we can move to the next slide, please. Thank you. Now, there you can see all the numbers of everything that we do and how many people follow us, 13 million people. If you don't have the app, please get the app. However, I'm not here to tell you how beautiful the model is. The model also has limitations, and there are three limitations. Limitation number one is civic space, right? There are countries where people are too afraid to take the actions because there are countries, unfortunately, when people go to jail for sending a tweet. So our limits are basically the limits of civic space. The other limit is connectivity. We need to make sure that people do have the connectivity. And the other is there are many partners that need to be more flexible about what is the last golden nugget that I want to leave you, which is audience segmentation. I was a diplomat for 11 years, and then as a former diplomat, I am begging you, you cannot talk to segments of different populations using the same numbers, the same messages, and the same messengers. People just get bored. So I am please begging you, do the exercise of audience segmentation, because that works beautiful for us. And I'll stop here. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you so much, Mr. Escalante-Hasbun. I will now pass the floor to Ms. Aisha Dabo. Please, the floor is yours. Thank you very much.

AfriktivisteCo-Founder and Coordinator

Thank you, madam moderator. It's a pleasure to be here and to talk about the work we do as Africtivists across Africa, but also specifically for the Digitalize Youth Initiative, which is being implemented in 14 countries in West, East, and Central Africa regions. I would like to begin with a simple observation. Being connected does not necessarily mean being empowered, and being able to express an opinion online does not necessarily mean having a voice in decisions that affect our lives. Across Africa, young people are increasingly using digital technologies to access information, mobilize communities, engage in public debate, and demand accountability. But access to technology alone does not guarantee meaningful democratic participation. At Africtivist, we believe that civic education must go hand in hand with digital skills, rights, and practical opportunities to participate and influence decisions. And importantly, young people should not simply be seen as beneficiaries of civic education, they are also producers of knowledge, innovators, and actors shaping democratic governance. This is the approach we have been putting into practice through our programs, including Digitalize Youth. Africa is a pan-African network working to strengthen democracy, good governance, and human rights through civic technology, digital innovation, and citizen engagement. One important lesson that we've learned from our experience in strengthening young people's participation is that civic education becomes more meaningful when people have the opportunity to put what they've learned into practice. So through Digitalize Youth, we're supporting young people to develop knowledge, skills, tools they need to engage in democratic processes. So I'll give two examples. The first one is what we call the Africtivist Citizen Labs. which are labs set up currently in seven African countries, where young people, they learn, exchange experience, identify challenges affecting their communities, and explore technological and digital solutions. So we have a representative of the Cameroon lab who is here in the room. The idea is not to simply teach, but how to use digital tools to have a positive impact. It is to enable them to identify the problem, become part of the solution. This approach brings together civic education, digital skills, innovation, and community engagement. The second example we did on the digitalized youth is the Election Civic Tech Fund. It's an initiative we launched last year. For four weeks, we received 171 responses. We were expecting eight. So we ended up giving funds to 12 projects to strengthen electoral participation, access to information, and civic engagement and accountability. What matters is not only the technology being developed, but the opportunities for local innovators to identify challenges in their own context and to propose practical responses. So young people do not need to wait to contribute, that has been said several times since yesterday. They're already doing so, and our responsibility is to create the conditions for their contributions to have an impact. So the challenges, some of them were mentioned by the previous speakers. So I'll just briefly mention the inequality, specifically in Africa, when it comes to access to internet and all the infrastructures, which are barriers. We have also restrictive digital spaces and civic space increasingly on the continent. We have the issue of access to information, which does not always mean access to reliable information, and that has an impact actually on making informed civic choices. And the fourth gap that's often most not, it's overlooked, is participation and influence, actually. Participation doesn't necessarily mean influence. So now I will go to what we need to change. Drawing from the lessons from the Digitalize Youth Initiative, the first thing we need to do is to move from youth participation to youth influence. The panel we had earlier with young people, they already mentioned that. This involves young people in policy design and monitoring, and show their contributions, and show how their contributions shape decisions that are being made. Second is to invest in practical civic and digital education beyond technical skills, including critical thinking, media information literacy, democratic processes, as well as digital rights. Third is to make digital participation safe and inclusive, affordable access, digital security, but also protection against online violence. The fourth one is to fund locally developed civic tech solutions by providing small grants. and technical support and mentoring actually young innovators in addressing communities and governance challenges. And the final one is to institutionalize the partnership with civil society and youth organizations of movements by including them in public policy processes and establish regular dialogue and feedback mechanism with decision makers. So to conclude, I'll say youth are already contributing to democracy by producing knowledge, developing technology, organizing communities, monitoring public affairs, demanding accountability, and advocating for change. Our role is not simply to guide them for future participation. It is to recognize their agency, strengthen their capacities, and create opportunities to influence the decisions that shape their lives. Ultimately, Technology becomes a driver of democratic resilience when citizens are not merely connected, but informed, empowered, and are able to translate digital engagement into meaningful civic action. Thank you very much.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you so much, Ms. Ayesha Dabho. Next, I would love to pass the floor to Ms. Sarah Gaon. Please, the floor is yours. Thank you very much.

Code for AfricaSenior Project Manager

Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for the opportunity to contribute to this discussion. This discussion at this point, which I feel is a continuation of the conversation started by Ayesha, my colleague, on and off this panel in many ways, and even the previous speakers on the panel before this. In my part of the world, when we talk about digital participation, we often begin with the number and diversity of people who have internet connectivity, devices, or access to digital platforms. These conversations about using technological innovations to increase access underpin digital participation, but do not on their own guarantee participation. We need to go a layer deeper and ask what people can do with that access. Can they find and understand information? Can they organize, raise concerns, engage institutions, and influence decisions? In other words, can they exercise democratic agency? I believe Sabine from the previous panel asked a similar set of questions as she discussed her interventions and concluded, it's not so much about the numbers, but the influence. Mary also raised similar points when she spoke about resilience, and that's where I want to meet you as well today. Not so much on barriers, but on the opportunities for influence that digital tooling brings. Drawing on Code for Africa's work in 26 countries with civic actors and technologists across the continent, I want to focus on three connected elements. First, the tooling that enables participation. Secondly, the people who both build and shape solutions. And then finally, the communities that ultimately use them. The first element is tooling. Digital tools can make democratic participation more practical, as we saw in the previous panel and even here, by helping people access information, document what is happening, and engage with governance processes. One example from Code for Africa's work is the Virtual Evidence Platform, which we developed as part of the Charter Project Africa, working with colleagues, including Aisha here, who is also on this panel. The platform, available on web and mobile, brings together accessible evidence and resources to support advocacy around the African Charter on Democracy, Elections, and Governance. This platform includes over 300 data sets, a database of more than 250 tools, over 350 organizations, as well as policy briefs, articles, and other information about the charter, which is an AU legislation. The aim of having these collections of resources is to strengthen knowledge across the democratic ecosystem of actors in AU member states and equip them to advocate for the ratification and implementation of the Charter. Having these tools and resources available is important because civic actors need more than access to technology. They also need the information and evidence to understand governance commitments and engage meaningfully in accountability processes. So let's quickly map these civic actors. A technologist can explore open databases and repositories to develop solutions for specific use cases. These might include a tool like the Promise Tracker, which tracks political commitments over time, or a voice-driven mobile assistant for female factory workers to review their rights and labor laws that leaves no digital paper trail, which could get them in trouble. A civil society organization can use a platform to identify local, regional, and continental events, networks, and opportunities. A funding organization can explore which organizations are working in particular countries or thematic areas and identify potential partners. The idea is to make evidence more accessible and useful to different actors so they can each use it in ways that strengthen participation, advocacy, and accountability. Ultimately, it is not simply about developing a platform. It is about what the tooling makes possible. This also reminds us that technology needs to respond to the context in which people are working. A tool is only useful when it addresses a real need and can be accessed and used by the people it is intended to serve. The second element is the people behind the technology. African young people are often discussed as users or beneficiaries of digital transformation, but as said here, they are people who can design, build, and shape the systems through which we participate in public life. This is a particularly important conversation, as is often repeated, but worth repeating again because of its implications for the rest of the world. The African continent is home to more than 400 million young people aged 15 to 35. Depending on some sources, the estimates are even higher. But the question is whether young people have the opportunities, resources, and institutional support to translate potential into solutions that respond to challenges around them. And importantly, whether young women as well have an equal opportunity to shape this future. For the past decade, Code for Africa has been part of this wider effort through its fellowship and innovation programs. We have supported technologists to work alongside civil society organizations, journalists, and community actors to develop solutions to locally identified identified challenges. So rather than simply training young people to acquire technical skills, the idea is to create opportunities for them to apply those skills to real problems in their communities. This kind of model matters because it brings together two forms of expertise that do not always meet. The technologist brings the ability to build, the civil society organization brings an understanding of the problem. the communities involved, and they also bring the realities of implementation. When these come together, technology is likely to respond to actual needs rather than assumptions about what communities require. The third and final element is the communities that these solutions are intended to serve. Developing a digital tool is not the same as ensuring that it is useful, adopted, or trusted. There is often a gap between building a solution and seeing it make a difference in people's lives. Piloting, community engagement, and local ownership are not optional additions. They are part of what makes technology relevant and sustainable. So what does this mean for the wider discussion about technology, democracy, and civic participation? It means moving beyond connectivity as the main measure of digital inclusion and participation. Meaningful participation requires accessible and relevant tooling. It requires local actors with the skills and support to use and shape that infrastructure, and it requires opportunities for communities to influence the technologies and decisions that affect them. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you very much, Ms. Gowen. It is now my pleasure to actually introduce the last session cluster for today, which will help walk us through some pathways forward. And it's my honor to introduce three main speakers for this cluster. We would have Mr. Alejandro Mayoral Baños, who's a co-executive director of Access Now. We will also have Ms. Asha Allen, who's a director and secretary general for the Center for Democracy and Technology Europe. And finally, we'll have Mr. Tommaso Venturini, who is an associate professor at the University of Geneva, specifically with the Media Lab project. So first, I would love to pass it over to Mr. Mayoral Baños. Please, the floor is yours.

Access NowCo-Executive Director

Thank you. Good afternoon, excellencies, distinguished panelists, colleagues, friends, secretary, and chairperson. First, I would like to thank Wafa and the Office of the UN High Commissioner for the kind invitation. and for bringing us together for this important conversation. As we reflect on the role of education in strengthening civic participation, we often ask ourselves, how can we prepare young people to participate in an increasingly digital democracy? This is an important question, but I believe we must go one step further and ask something more fundamental. Are we building a digital world in which their rights, their voices, and their ability to participate are genuinely protected? At Access Now, we start from a simple premise. Technology is never neutral, and it's never inherently democratic. Whether it strengthens democracy or undermines it depends on who controls it, whose interests it serves, and whether human rights are protected from the very beginning. There is enormous potential here. Young people are using digital spaces to learn, organize, challenge injustice, and will movements across borders. Communities historically excluded from decision making can find one another, share knowledge, and demand a seat at the table. We should celebrate this, but we must not confuse access to technology with access to power. Education is a fundamental human right. It must be protected online, just as it must be protected offline. And civic education is not simply about teaching people to operate digital tools. It is about developing critical thinking, political awareness, and the confidence to question the institutions and systems that shape our lives. Digital literacy is essential, but it must go beyond teaching people how to use digital tools. Young people should understand how algorithms influence the information they receive, how their data is collected and used, and how decisions made by governments and technology companies shape their opportunities to participate in democratic life. This is where digital literacy must become civic education. We need to equip people not simply to navigate these systems, but to question them, challenge them, and participate in the decisions that govern them. However, we must be careful not to confuse education with responsibility. Understanding how a system works does not make individuals responsible for the harms that systems creates. We cannot expect young people to protect themselves from invasive surveillance. educators to compensate for discriminatory algorithms, or communities to overcome the consequences of internet shutdowns through digital literacy alone. That responsibility belongs, first and foremost, to governments that have an obligation to protect human rights, and to technology companies that must respect those rights in the system they design and operate. We cannot educate our way out of a structural injustice while leaving the structures untouched. And those structures are increasingly concentrated in the hands of a few powerful actors. We see the consequences every day. Governments shut down the internet during conflict, elections, and protest. Surveillance is deployed against dissent. Opaque algorithms and artificial intelligence systems can reinforce discrimination, amplify manipulation, and narrow that people are able to see and debate. In 2025, Access Now and the Keep It On coalition documented at least 313 internet shutdowns in 52 countries. This was another record year. Think about what that means for civic education. How do we ask young people to engage in democratic life while cutting off the very networks they use to learn, communicate, organize, and hold power accountable? And the pressure does not stop online. This year, we experienced it personally. RightsCon, the global summit on human rights in the digital age that Access Now convened, could not proceed in Zambia. We were confronted with pressure to exclude members of our community and restrict discussions. We refused. For us, this was not merely the cancellation of a conference. It was a reminder that the spaces where civil society gathers, learns, challenges powers, and builds solidarity are themselves under threat. And when those physical spaces shrink, while digital spaces become more surveilled and controlled, where exactly are people supposed to exercise their democratic rights? That is why meaningful civic participation depends on the full realization of human rights, both online and offline. Freedom of expression, privacy, freedom of association, and access to information are not secondary considerations. They are the very foundation that allow people to participate freely, question authority, and hold power accountable. Privacy is not an optional feature. Encryption is not a luxury. Secure communications are not privileges reserved for technical experts. They are necessary conditions for journalists to protect sources, educators to speak freely, and human rights defenders to organize without fear. Across the world, digital security helplines and civil society organizations provide critical support to journalists, educators, activists, and human rights defenders facing digital threats. Through Access Now, digital security helpline, and the work of many others in this ecosystem, we see how technical assistance, capacity building, and collective solidarity help people exercise their right and continue their civic participation, even in the face of targeted attacks. But civil society cannot be expected to compensate for systemic failures. Technical support cannot substitute for governments fulfilling their human rights obligations or technology companies respecting human rights. I'm particularly concerned about a contradiction we are normalizing. We are pushing more children, more classrooms, and entire education systems onto digital platforms, while simultaneously entertaining proposals that weaken encryption, undermine anonymity, and expand identity verification. Consider a young person living through conflict, displacement, or violence. The ability to communicate privately, seek trusted information, or ask for help without exposing their identity might be essential to protecting their rights and well-being. We cannot claim to protect children while dismantling the protections that which they might depend. So what must change? First, governments must defend the foundations of their democratic participation and not bear internet, freedom of expression, privacy, freedom of association, and access to education. Internet shutdowns on lawful surveillance and measures that we can secure communications are incompatible with our commitment. Second, technology companies must be held accountable for the systems they build. Human rights safeguards, transparency, meaningful oversight, and remedies for harm must be built into products and public sector deployments from the outset, not offered as an afterthought. Third, education system must teach more than digital skills. They must help students understand platform power, data governance, and the political choices embedded in technology. And they must protect students' rights when choosing the tools used in classrooms. Finally, young people and affected communities must have a genuine role in deciding how technologies are designed, governed, and deployed, not as passive users invited to adapt, but as participants with a voice in decisions that shape their futures. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you so much, Mr. Mayoral-Baños. It's my pleasure now to introduce Ms. Asha Allen. Please, the floor is yours.

CDT EuropeDirector and Secretary General

Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair. Good afternoon to Excellencies and colleagues. It's a pleasure to be here today on this esteemed panel to discuss how digital technologies are impacting our democracies. I think there'll be some clear alignment with my colleague from Access Now. My name is Asha Allen. I'm the Secretary General for the Center for Democracy and Technology Europe. We're a civil society organization that advocates for human rights in European tech policies and law. Now, the topic of this panel can be approached from a breadth of perspectives, which we've already heard today and throughout the day, and colleagues have already touched upon this. But for CDT Europe, we spend our days, and those are very long days, but we spend our days advocating for regulation and policies to bring oversight to tech companies as well as to governments who are using these emerging technologies. At the heart of our work is the international human rights framework. We strongly reiterate that any measures, including new laws, must strike the balance in addressing the very clear and prevalent harms that some online platforms pose to the most vulnerable communities, including young people, whilst respecting their right to freedom of expression, access to information, community, civic participation, and education. This nuanced balancing approach is in itself a pursuit of evidence-based, human rights-informed lawmaking, and we hope that governments exchange with expert civil societies to achieve this aim. We've been talking a lot about young people today, and they are indeed one of the many groups who are vulnerable to the risks in our online spaces. But particularly in this context of democracy and civic participation, I use this opportunity to highlight the experiences of many women and gender non-conforming persons in the online sphere, because young people's experiences is also a gendered experience. And when we look at the experience of women and gender non-conforming people in the online space, we have a real clear marker of what is happening to democratic participation online. Research conducted by UN Women, the European Institute for Gender Equality, and International Center for Journalists, and many civil society organizations, including ourselves, have all provided us with clear evidence that the proliferation of tech-facilitated gender-based violence and its direct impact on women's ability to participate in the online civic space and political debate in safety is on a marked decline. In Europe, 32% of women have experienced violence during their political career, and 29% of those experience some type of online violence. When focused on the category of women who work in the fields of human rights, activism, journalism, a recent UN Women study reports that 70% of women participants experience some form of tech facilitated gender based violence, and 45% of those were now self-censoring themselves to avoid abuse. Notable leaders, such as former Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern from New Zealand, the first woman of color minister in Italy, Cecile Kenge, and former European parliamentarian Petra De Sutter, have all publicly spoken about the online harassment they faced, which they and many others refer to as a contributing factor to their decisions to take a step back from politically prominent roles. As young women contemplate their future careers, many deem public facing roles too risky in light of the online abuse and harassment they are likely to face, as documented by multiple reports conducted by Plan International, the largest girls rights organization in the world. Now, we ourselves have conducted extensive research into gender disinformation and assessed its impact on democratic participation and resilience. Gender disinformation flows from the same patriarchal context in which people experience tech-facilitated gender-based violence, and so there's an overlap between the two. These campaigns are specifically designed to discredit women, and they are characterized by deeply misogynistic stereotypes that call into question women's role in politics and often sexualizes women politicians. These acts are rarely meant as a direct attack against a specific individual, but are more often part of a coordinated effort addressed to address the speech of politically engaged women and gender diverse persons with the aim of silencing them or even making them quit politics, activism, or the online space entirely. The kinds of campaigns that inform young political leaders and the reality that they face, and the fact that they will not receive redress from online platforms, which is minimal at best, and that current policies are simply ineffective. Alongside this, with increasingly available AI, the increased availability of AI tools, there has been a significant increase in the creation and dissemination of AI deepfakes. One in six women in the European Parliament have been targeted by deepfake *********** in the last 12 months alone. As we saw with the Grok AI incident at the beginning of the year, it took two weeks for over 3 million deepfake non-consensual intimate images to be created and widely disseminated. And this was in a context in which many civil society organizations warned that this would happen, and platforms had expressly recognized the potential risk for this exact situation just last year. So what are the opportunities to combat this and ensure that women and gender diverse persons can enjoy their right to civic participation? The first step is to ensure that the array of laws and policies that many jurisdictions have adopted in a working practice. CDT have successfully advocated for a ban on nudification apps in Europe, which comes into force in two weeks. We successfully advocated for gender-based violence to be recognized as a systemic risk, and for some of the most egregious kinds of tech-facilitated gender-based violence to be criminalized in an EU directive. With increased regulatory oversight, the opportunity to fundamentally change platform design and the incentives behind them is also there. So mandating that platforms prioritise safety by design to mitigate those economic incentives to deprioritise safer engagement is another key step. We cannot have platforms marking their own homework and saying that nothing can be improved. States also have a responsibility to ensure that the policies that they put in place balance the rights that they are obligated to protect. Civic participation and safety online does not come at the expense of the right to access to information and association and free expression. Therefore, limiting access to online spaces because they are unsafe silences vulnerable voices and allows online platforms to renege on their responsibilities under the UN Guiding Principles on Businesses and Human Rights. So I'll conclude by saying that our democracies have been long digitalized, and the service we have been engaging for 20 years have already had a significant impact on our democracies. Our civic participation, debates, and community building happens online, and that's not inherently a bad thing. But great societal change for the better has been achieved, but there's a long way to go to making sure that our online spaces are much more safe. And the very last thing I'll say is that women are 52% of the global population. We're not the minority, we're the majority. And young people are our future. Bolstering democratic resilience, especially in the digital age, is a proactive and deliberate action, and democracy cannot be taken for granted. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Ms. Allen, thank you very much, and thank you also for bringing into perspective the UN Guiding Principles on Businesses and Human Rights. It's really important from a private sector perspective on accountability. Next, I have the pleasure of introducing Mr. Venturini. Please, the floor is yours. Thank you.

University of GenevaAssociate Professor

Thank you very much. Good afternoon. You are getting to the last speakers of the last cluster of the last session of the day, so well done. Hang in there. I will switch gear a little bit, and I will talk about participation, but like kind of a form of like sort of the dark side of participation, the kind of toxic forms of participation that happen off lines, because participation is, in most cases, a good thing, digital participation, but in some cases, it also have dark consequences. And I will in particular talk about conspiracy theory or participation around conspiratorial thinking, and in particular, I will the example of one specific conspiracy theory that is the New World Order conspiracy theory. Here you see a little bit what it kind of what it looked like. And the first message that I want to convey is that conspiracy theories are not what they used to be, but a little bit what they used to be, but they also change a lot. And an example of this, i studied a few years ago by comparing the original website of the Flat Earth Society, which is a very classic conspiracy theory that is a pseudo-scientific theory. If you look at the website, it kind of looks like the website of a proper scientific organization. Of course, it's not, but it kind of mimics the format of proper science. And then the subreddit of the flat earth theory, and that is completely different. So this particular conspiracy theory has been radically transformed by the fact of being mediating by digital media. And this is actually important because while the flat earth society is not that important as the conspiracy theory, The New World Order theory is, and is having a lot of impact, and is particularly doing something very dangerous, which is enabling a convergence of a lot of previously separated conspiracy theories. So people believing in UFOs, people believing in the danger of vaccines, people believing about global surveillance, et cetera, et cetera, they are all coming together around this conspiracy theory, which is something that has been called the conspiracy singularity by Anna Merlen, which has been described in a couple of books that you might have seen. These books are very good, but they describe these convergence as a political phenomenon. And what I want to talk about is the same convergence, but as a media phenomenon, as it is mediated, enabled, encouraged by digital media and digital media participation. You know, sort of following the famous slogan of Marshall McLuhan that the medium is the message. And actually, things are slightly more complicated than that because digital media are, of course, plural. And in fact, they don't, they're not giving us one message, but different messages that we need to separate and understand in their differences. I'm not going to spend a lot of time on this, but the idea is that there are three main communication regimes that it plays nowadays in digital media. The regime of hyperlinks, the regime of feeds, and the regime of memes. And they're very different. So the regime of hypertext is Kind of the regime that is the closest to the classic conspiracy theory, because it's a regime where success is based on persuasion. So giving arguments so you can convince an audience to believe in your idea. Then you have the regimes of feeds, which is the regime of social media and digital platforms, which is based on recommendation algorithm. And here success is different. It's not about convincing someone, but soft tuning the vibes of the feed so that you are able to promote your content at the top of the visibility recommendation system. And then you have the regime of memes. I showed a couple of memes before, and I'll show a little bit more later. And this is the property participatory. regime, in which people are remixing, reposting, republishing again and again the same messages by always transforming them and making them vibrant. So these three regimes correspond to three different forms of conspiracism, of conspiracy thinking: conspiracy theory, as I explained, and conspiracy vibes, and finally, conspiracy folklore, which I'll explain in a minute. So The first regime is hypertextuality, and that's the most classic one, so I'm going to be quick on this one because you know it already. This is the conspiracy theory that are presented in books. These are the four most famous book about the New World Order conspiracy theory, but there are plenty more. There are thousands of book about the New World Order conspiracy theory on Amazon. And even when they are not books, even when there are more digital native formats, they tend to be texts and blogs, and for example, this is Curtains Yavin. infamous blogs where you can see there's a lot of text and a lot of complex arguments. And this works very well online because the whole idea of connecting the dots resonates very well with the idea of archiving and hyperlinking of the web. Now, the second communication regimes and form of conspiracy is based on influence and feeds, and is based on conspiracy vibes. And here, the first thing you have to keep in mind is that conspiracist online do not convince their public through their argument. So sometimes they do it a little bit, but many other times they convince them by their performance. They're extremely skilled performer. Here you see the example of Alex Jones, who's a very famous one. You see Russell Brand, who's been recently arrested. Here we've overlaid all the cover picture of his YouTube channels, and you can see what kind of a Christian-like Aesthetics is going for. Here is Amy Carson for Love as One. Here, this is a more like new age feminine kind of space, but like very, very conspiracist. And here the idea, let's keep this slide, is to sort of hijack things that are already visible online and use them to promote conspiratorial ideas. For example, the famous example is the hijacking of the Save the Children hashtags and campaign to introduce QAnon. And then finally, we get to mimesis, the regime of memes and conspiracy folklore. And here the idea is basically to Convey conspiratorial ideas through internet memes. You'll get one example. For example, so these can be images. I've shown a lot of images. But memes can also be text. Like here is, for example, textual formulas that we have tracked down. Their globalist agenda, very classic dog whistle in the conspiracy world. And they can also be narrative. That's why I'm talking about folklore. It's always telling this story about the villain being one or more international organization, magic weapon being a political or technical innovation, and the damsel in distress being individual freedom. I don't have a lot of time, so I skip a lot of slides here to skip to these last slides, which is important. And it is important to separate these regimes and these different types of conspiracy theory, because the counteraction that we can take against each one are different. So if you want to counter hypertext and conspiracy theory, then you use fact checking and debunking. But that does not work for feeds and meme, for which you would rather use actions such as deplatformization and demonetization, or countermeming or cultural intervention for the memes. This was very, and I'm also late, but it was very quick. If you want to know more, you can find more on my website. Thank you.

OHCHRModerator

Thank you so much, Mr. Venturini. I have to admit this panel has been quite fun. I think just from the videos, the presentations, I'm deeply appreciative of kind of the diversity of perspectives here. Before we move on to our next speaker, I just wanted to say, i mean, there's a couple of recurring themes that are coming up from my perspective. The first is that, and I've heard this from several of our distinguished participants today, is that connectivity alone cannot be an indicator of how we are using technology to hopefully improve the right to education, and it's not enough as an indicator. Nor is it the answer, right? Like I've heard from several of the participants today also that techno solutionism is not something that is our friend in this debate. The second is digital literacy needs to go way far beyond just leaving it to learning how to use a device or how to connect to the internet. It's really about questioning tools and holding their makers and the facilitators of those tools accountable. So I found those two themes really insightful. And finally, I did want to flag also the question of redress and remedy. As Ms. Allen walked us through when it comes to women and non-gender conforming participants or users of different technological tools, I mean, I think it's just a question of not having sufficient remedy. Before we move on to our next speaker, I also wanted to bring to your attention to the UN Human Rights Office's youth survey, where over 300 youth identified what they believe should be done to create a safer space online for both public and political debates. So we have this slide before us today, and it really does respond to some of the risks that were highlighted by previous participants on this panel. So the conclusions of the report when it comes to these 300 youth that spoke was what should be done is, one, protection of freedom of expression in law and in practice as well. It's one thing to talk about it. It's another to actually do it. The second is to act quickly against threats, harassment, and different kinds of hate speech. Third, it's to promote a respectful dialogue and human dignity. Fourth is to invest in media and digital literacy, which as we've mentioned already on this panel, goes beyond just learning how to use a device. It's also questioning what they read online. Then it's to protect privacy, identity, and personal data when using technological tools. And the last two are addressing misinformation and coordinated manipulation, and then finally to use transparent, rights-based moderation and appeals mechanisms. This is something our office works very actively on today. To take us further on some of the ways forward, I have the pleasure of introducing our last speaker this afternoon, Ms. Javiera Atenas. Thank you so much for joining us today, and the floor is yours.

Speaker 50

Thank you very much. Dear representatives and fellow citizens, the presentation today is framed on our research, but also on the work that we have been doing for the last years with the UNESCO OER Dynamic Coalition. In the context of datafied societies, our participation is increasingly framed as complex and multifaceted, encompassing transparency, policy effectiveness, accountability, and democratic rights. particularly in relation to the inclusion of and empowerment of marginalized and minority groups. At the same time, participation is being shaped by data, by algorithms, and by artificial intelligence that influence information, public services, education, and also civic engagement, as algorithmic systems increasingly mediate how public decisions are made, raising concerns about transparency, bias, and accountability. If we can move to the next slide, thank you. Governments in many countries are making a big effort in opening up information, making the information transparent, as well as opening up their data. However, openness and access alone are insufficient. Can we move to the next slide, please? Thank you. Meaningful participation requires critical data, critical AI literacy, and critical algorithm literacy. For people to understand, question, and influence data-driven systems, advance human rights, adopt data justice, and democratic participation in the context of a datafied society. In this sense, critical literacy, critical data literacy enables us to conduct civic monitoring. AI literacy helps us to understand how automated systems shape rights in data-driven societies. Algorithmic literacy helps us to develop awareness on how algorithms classify us, rank us, and influence people, enabling the recognition of bias, exclusion, and unequal power relationships in society. And also learning to do algorithmic auditing equips us for the scrutiny of opaque systems, challenging harmful outcomes, and demanding accountability. Civic engagement is more and more dependent on citizens' levels of data, AI, and information literacy. Therefore, the current state-of-the-art is a portrait of the significant structural asymmetries in society. The absence of such literacies jeopardizes participation, which can become largely symbolic. This widens and amplifies inequalities in society and limits our ability to participate and hold institutions accountable. While governments increasingly advocate for transparency, inclusivity, these initiatives presuppose high levels of digital, technical, and civic skills among citizens. Participation, therefore, risks to become mechanisms for legitimacy, which merely provide access to information without meaningfully redistributing power or amplifying diverse voices. Can we move to the next slide? In terms of open solutions for meaningful participation, open solutions, which are defined by UNESCO as open educational resources, open access to information and scientific information, open data, and open and free software, we consider those enablers for meaningful participation because help narrowing the digital divide and provide equal opportunity for learn, debate, and engage through publicly funded materials, leaving no one behind. We argue that higher education has a responsibility to strengthen civic skills and democratic futures. Also, that building critical data and critical AI literacies are essential for civic participation to foster human rights and demand democratic accountability in datafied societies. We propose that the students engage in citizenship by using data and interrogating data and auditing public AI and algorithmic systems, promoting open and resilient, sustainable learning ecosystems. We argue that higher education can foster critical data and AI and algorithmic literacies by positioning students as co-creators of knowledge to interpret, question, and use data for public engagement and accountability. Open solutions provide the knowledge, the evidence, and tools needed to move from symbolic participation to works meaningful, inclusive, and accountable civic engagement. Therefore, we call invite and asked the governments, higher education institutions, international organizations, civic society, and UN bodies to publish open data to support informed public engagement and civic oversight while championing open knowledge through open access, OERs, and open software. Invest in digital public goods and open infrastructure, including open artificial intelligence systems. Promote the development of open educational resources that anyone can adapt, adopt, and contextualize to build AI literacy, data literacy, but in the heart of civic participation. Enable civic monitoring and participation through accessible evidence, open consultations, and community engagement. Co-design policies, strategies, and services with students, citizens, and the civil society. Foster collaboration with academia, the civil society, and communities to address complex digital challenge. Rewarding open practices and open scholarship through the value of sharing research, data, methods, and OER. The invitation remains open for all the community to Add open licenses to the resources that you're already producing to make sure that anyone, anywhere can access. Can we move to the last slide, please? If you want to participate, if you want to engage with us, please join the OER Dynamic Coalition. We can provide with guidance and help to opening up your resources. And if you want to see an example, we have a pilot about open educational resources and information in open access papers for data, AI, and citizenship literacy through open education and open research. Thank you very much.

OHCHRModerator

Ms. Atenas, thank you very much. We are about to pass on to the Q&A section of our panel today. Before doing that, I also wanted to flag, as you were speaking about meaningful ways of participation, also, when I walked into the venue today in the room, I caught the very tail end of the last presentation about elections and technology, and I did want to flag recent guidelines that our office at the OHCHR, in collaboration with the Carter Center and the Privacy International organization, where we developed actually human rights standards and guidelines on the use of digital technologies in the electoral process, basically contributing to public awareness raising around the risks of digital tech, which many of our panelists covered today in election context, and also provides concrete guidance to states, companies, and political actors on how to use these tools responsibly. So I definitely invite you all to check out that recent publication. And with this, I'm very happy to give the microphone back to the chair. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

Thank you, Ms. Benasyn. I will now open for statements and give the floor to the distinguished representative of Malta. Your Excellency, the floor is yours.

Malta

Thank you, Ambassador, and well done for the excellent presentations. It's more of a statement rather than a question. and sharing our experience about how education is fundamental in strengthening democratic resilience, civic participation, and human rights and rule of law. That's why Malta continues to invest in values-based education with greater emphasis on integrity, ethical awareness, critical thinking, and responsible citizenship in our curriculum. We want young people not only to gain knowledge, but to understand their rights and responsibilities and to take an active part in society. We are also learning through cooperation with others. As we heard in the previous panel as well, in 2025, Malta implemented the Malta-Ethiopia Connecting Classrooms project with the UNODC GRACI initiative. It brought students and educators from both countries together to explore integrity, ethical values, intercultural dialogue, critical thinking, and global citizenship. Neither side came to this project as the teacher. Students and educators learned from one another, shared their experiences, and saw how the same values can grow in very different classrooms. What we took from this is that education can help build societies that are more inclusive. more accountable, and more resilient. Our work continues at home and with our international partners, and we remain committed to initiatives that put integrity and responsible citizenship at the heart of education. A young person who learns to ask questions at school is harder to silence as an adult. That's why democracy starts in the classroom and why we will keep investing there. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. I give the floor to distinguished representative of European Union. Floor is yours.

EUEU

Thank you, Mr. Chair. On behalf of the European Union, I'd like to thank all the panelists for their inspiring and diverse statements. As we are conscious of time, I make a few remarks to share the EU approach in complementarity also to Asha's presentation on some of the EU regulatory and policy approaches. As many of you have said, in today's world, digital technologies are integral to democratic life, but they're also testing the resilience of our democracy. democracies. The European Union considers digital and media literacy essential to meaningful democratic participation. Citizens, especially young people, must be able to know how to use digital tools so as to best assess information critically, recognize manipulation, and make informed choices. Our policy framework in this area continues to develop. The European Democracy Shield, presented in November 2025, places strong emphasis on media and digital literacy, civic education in schools, and the participation of young people. In May this year, the EU Council adopted conclusions on teachers in the era of AI, calling for a human-centered approach that strengthens AI literacy while preserving the autonomy of teachers and learners. In June, the Commission and the OECD presented an AI literacy framework for primary and secondary education. And then fourthly, the Commission's updated guidelines for teachers also offer practical classroom resources on disinformation, generative AI, and social media. With all of that, I hope we are sharing some ways of approaching the challenges that you've all discussed and outlined today. In closing, let me just say that digital technologies must expand people's ability to think independently, express their views, and take part in public life, not shape their opinions for them. The EU is firmly committed to protecting the right to freedom of opinion and expression and a healthy information space while empowering citizens to navigate it. Our full statement is online. I thank you so much.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. Now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Romania.

Romania

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

First of all, apologies for my voice. Second of all, I would like to thank all the panelists for their very insightful reflections this couple of days. Romania supports all efforts to ensure the full realization of the right to education and believes that democratic.

Participation should be encouraged from an early age.

This is why civic and social education are part of Romania's national curriculum, starting as early as primary school. We nevertheless see that progress is needed, particularly in strengthening teacher training and an increased involvement of students through active practice rather than theory. This is especially important in the digital environment and online platforms, where young people increasingly form their views and engage in public life. One example of how our authorities are tackling this is that by partnering with the Center of Independent Journalism to provide digital media literacy training for secondary school teachers, helping bring digital literacy in the classroom. Around 700 teachers have benefited so far from this partnership. Also, we believe civil participation must be inclusive and accessible to all. Through investments under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan and European initiatives such as Child Act Plus and WISE, Romania is taking steps to address digital divides and expand opportunities for children and young people, including those in vulnerable situations, girls and young women. Allow me to take this opportunity, Mr. Chair, as we are slowly approaching the end of the event, to express our full appreciation for the fresh and broad perspectives reflected at this forum, particularly through the contributions of the children and youth panelists. And we are confident that these exchanges will help inspire new ideas and pave the way for strengthened youth civic participation worldwide. And I thank you.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. I give the floor to distinguished representative of Cuba.

Cuba

Chair, education must meet the 21st century's challenges. In this context, the unstoppable use of technology and social media provide opportunities, but also risks. Education needs to contribute to public debate by also educating about access to information. At the same time, the excessive use of platforms and technology and exposure to harmful content addictions and fake information all carry serious consequences, and youth and young children are particularly vulnerable to this. That's why we think it's so important to strengthen digital literacy and in the media, particularly for young people. They must be taught the skills to use digital technology in a safe and creative fashion. A large part of the world's population is still unable to take advantage of digital technology. Most digital technology continues to be in the hands of a small number of companies, and there is not an effective and transparent regulatory framework. All too often, developing countries are the passive recipients without being able to influence the design of algorithms which condition access to information and participation in public debate. We're worried to see that digital gaps actually broaden the inequalities between the global north and south. So we must ensure that there is literacy and that there is broad access to new technologies, including AI. Technology must be at the service of the whole people. There must be ethical and fair development of it. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

Representative of Uruguay.

Uruguay

Thank you, Chair. Digital technologies provide us with even more opportunities to get access to information, to express opinions and take part in public life. However, if we're to take advantage of these opportunities, we need much more than just access technology. One of the main challenges is to develop the necessary skills so that we have a critical understanding of digital environments and information, so that we can take part in a free, informed and safe fashion. At a national level, this is reflected in our citizenship and technology strategy covering the period up to 2028. It has a human rights-based approach, it promotes critical thinking and the appropriate use of platforms and algorithms, as well as providing opportunities for citizen participation. I would also like to highlight the educational initiative which promotes the use of technology in education through access to educational resources online and provides teacher training. It's in this framework that we have promoted the initiative on citizenship development and artificial intelligence, the aim of which is to strengthen students' skills so that can become involved critically and safely in the digital environment. We believe that skills development in the digital world will help increase opportunities for democratic participation. That's why educational and digital governance policies must develop hand in hand and put civic participation and democracy at their very core. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Indonesia.

Indonesia

Chair. Indonesia thanks the panelists for the interesting and insightful presentations. Digital technology has indeed become an important tool for democracy. It has widened participation and given everyone the space to hold an opinion and to argue it. At the same time, we know the growing challenges. Democracy rests on one person, one voice. But online, one person may hold several accounts and one account may not be a person at all. Both uncoordinated movement can amplify a single narrative and create echo chambers to distort public debate and potentially disrupt democratic process. Therefore, the protection we have online must also apply online. As home to 220 million internet users, Indonesia considers several important points. First, digital literacy. Democracy depends on citizens who can form their own judgment. Literacy equips them to identify risks, such as misinformation and the misuse of AI, and how to counter it. So we partners with various multi-stakeholders, such as civil society and technology companies, to bring literacy programs to the grassroots. Two, the protections of children. Children are now more exposed to harmful content, exploitations, and the commercial use of their data. Indonesia's regulations, which took effect this March, requires platforms to be accountable for child protection, including by delaying children's access to high-risk services and restrict profiling of children and personalized advertising aimed at them. Lastly, platform accountability and AI governance. Indonesia support efforts for an AI governance that uphold human rights principles and safeguards while supporting development efforts. Nationally, we have adopted an AI roadmap that promotes transparency of AI system. Thank you, Mr. Chair.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. I give the floor to distinguished representative of Mexico.

Mexico

Thank you, Chair. Mexico believes that civic education and critical thinking are vital tools for strengthening the culture of democracy. We must provide people with the necessary skills and tools so they can analyze information critically, take part in debates, well-informed and make a meaningful contribution to public life. This is a way of building more inclusive and resilient democracies. Young people are not just the future beneficiaries of democracy, they are democratic actors nowadays. Their participation and creativity is absolutely vital for facing today's challenges and ensuring that democratic institutions react to constantly developing situations. We must remove barriers, we Which prevent the full participation of women, indigenous peoples, persons with disabilities, persons of African descent, migrants, and other groups who have been historically excluded. Democratic systems are more solid and legitimate when all groups are represented and listened to. Digital technologies have transformed the way in which people get access to information, take part in public debate, and interact with democratic institutions. Whilst these technologies provide huge opportunities for increasing participation and inclusion, they also require sustained efforts to combat fake information, harassment of children. Debates on digital governance must put human rights, democratic participation, inclusion at the heart of these debates. Technological innovation should broaden opportunities for civic and democratic participation and at the same time protect human dignity, privacy, and fundamental freedoms. Mexico believes that democracies should help develop abilities, anticipate risks, and for, c) changing situations, drafting inclusive public policies and ensuring broad public participation are absolutely vital for ensuring that democratic institutions continue to be effective in light of digital, social and political transformations. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

I give this floor to the representative of NHRI, Kota Voo.

Côte d’IvoireNHRI Representative

Chair, we have a statement to make.

Côte d'Ivoire, because of its recent.

History, fully understands that peace, democracy, and the rule of law are never acquired for good. They have to be cultured and transmitted. This is why the theme of this forum is particularly vital in our national and regional contexts. In the face of the social networks, the youth people of our country are facing challenges. On the one hand, an unprecedented opportunity of expression and interconnectivity. On the other hand, increased vulnerability in the face of disinformation, hate speech. manipulation, political manipulation, online and cyber crime. For the National Council of Human Rights of our country, the response must not be restricting civic space, but emancipation through competences and skills. Education and civic participation must urgently ensure digital literacy and critical thinking. We must educate citizens that can decode information, reject violence, and be committed in a constructive manner to public debate. The National Human Rights Council makes four concrete recommendations: institutionalize human rights institution and digital media in national school curriculum, and in particular by creating human rights clubs, strengthen inclusive consultations between public authorities, NGOs, civil society, and youth organizations to develop public policies. Protect democratic expression by guaranteeing a safe and free environment for young citizens and human rights defenders online and offline. Support and protect civil society organizations that carry out vital work in the field to educate, marginalized communities. We reassert our commitment to ensure that each child receives the vital tools to be a responsible citizen of the rule of law in our societies. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

I give the floor to Ms. Iman Bukhari.

University of Calgary; Pakistani Canadian Cultural AssociationDoctoral Researcher; Association Member

My name is Iman Bukhari. I am a doctoral researcher at the University of Calgary and a member of the Pakistani Canadian Cultural Association. The digital divide is not just about who has a device. It is about who's excluded from literacy entirely. In Pakistan alone, 26 million children are out of school. Many are locked in child labor. Others face discrimination, are restricted by gender and social norms, or simply cannot afford an education. They are not learning to read or write, and therefore cannot participate in civic life. My research addresses this by testing whether a targeted non-generative AI application co-designed with the community can improve foundational literacy for out-of-school children in a Pakistani slum community. In this regard, I want to make two points. First, technology will not fix this. AI can carry the same biases as the systems that built it. For AI to help the most marginalized children, it must be designed for the conditions in which they actually live. If these conditions are not met, the technology will not help. Second, we must start with the most marginalized children, not add them at the end. If we build technology for the easiest to reach children and hope it trickles down, millions will stay excluded. I urge the States and the panelists in this room to ensure that the right to education in the digital age means contextually designed tools that reach those furthest behind. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. Now I give the floor to the representative of Knowledge Foundation.

Knowledge FoundationDirector

Hello, thank you. My name is Aaron Walsh. I'm the director of the Knowledge Foundation, and I'm happy to be here today through our partnership with the UNODC GRACE Initiative. In the prior panel, you actually saw one of the projects that we spent a good deal of time, passionate time working on, and that's GRACE AI, teaching young learners and youth about anti-corruption, ethics, and integrity. The Knowledge Foundation is one of two educational foundations that I direct. The other is the Immersive Education Initiative. Its focus is on using virtual reality and simulations for education. Our members worldwide service several million students around the world. The Knowledge Foundation, however, has a unique technology that we are using. It's nonprofit, based out of Lucerne, its global headquarters, with country and regional offices starting to open around the world. Our partnerships are UNODC GRACE, MIT, Oxford, University of Zurich, Lucerne Universities, and others. And of the technologies we are using, virtual reality, augmented reality, AI, and others, one in particular, knowledge token, is new probably to everybody in this room. And that's the one that excites us as a foundation the most. It's an open education technology. It's an incentive and reward token, cryptographically secured, that the learner earns. They keep themselves, they own it, and that token has a complete academic record of their success. It also, optionally, can be turned into a currency so that they can spend it on either goods that are, you know, enhancements to their life and fun, or that are essential, electricity, water, essential services of this sort. It's programmable in the sense that it can be utilized Specifically for one thing and one thing only. If you learn it, you earn it, and it can only be spent on one thing. And it's this new technology that we're very excited to bring to the community. With only 10 seconds left, there's not enough time to go on, but if you'd like to talk about how we can apply this and help with yours, let me know. I'll be here. And if not here, over by the coffee machines. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. And now I give the floor to the representative of International IDEA.

International IDEA

Thank you, Chair. An important focus of International IDEA's work is the role of technology in democracy, including the opportunities and challenges it presents for electoral integrity and democratic participation. We have produced ample research on these issues, particularly on the growing role of artificial intelligence in elections and its implications for democracy. Digital technologies can make elections more accessible, transparent, and efficient. strengthen election administration, improve access to information, and expand political participation. Artificial intelligence offers further opportunities, but also presents serious challenges. AI-generated disinformation, deepfakes, and increasingly sophisticated manipulation can undermine public trust, distort political debate, and threaten electoral integrity. Online harassment and hate speech can also silence political voices, particularly women and marginalized groups. These challenges are compounded by the growing influence of digital platforms, limited algorithmic transparency, and unequal access to technology. Our response must be to harness technology's benefits while safeguarding democracy and fundamental rights. This requires strong and independent electoral institutions, greater transparency and accountability from technology companies, digital literacy, and regulatory frameworks that protect freedom of expression. International cooperation is essential, particularly to strengthen the capacities of developing countries to address these challenges. Ultimately, technology must serve democracy, strengthening political participation, equality, and public trust. International IDEA stands to support Member States and partners in this effort. Thank you.

CzechiaChair

Thank you. So now I have to thank you, to the moderator, all panelists and participants for their contribution to this timely discussion. Thank you. My heartfelt thanks. Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen, we have had a rich but long two days in considering the theme of this session, fostering civic participation through education and empowering future generations. Seeking and listening to the views of children, our future generations, is essential. We have heard the views of children throughout these two days, and now For their closing statement, I invite to the podium Leon and Julia. Leon is 12 years old from Guadalajara, Jalisco, and is in the first year of education secondary school. And Julia is 14 years old, also originally from Jalisco, Mexico. and is currently a representative counselor of Jalisco before the National System of Comprehensive Protection of Children and Adolescents. Leon and Julia, the floor is yours.

MexicoRepresentative of the Jalisco Children and Youth Climate Assembly

My name is Leon. I'm 12 years old. I come from Jalisco in Mexico. It's my honor to represent the first climate assembly of children and youth in my state. This is a unique event in my country. We review proposals and we raise our voices because of the environmental crisis. In our assembly, we have realized the worsening situation which makes us feel sad. Before this assembly, i thought the climate crisis was a long way off in the north and south poles, but I realised that it goes far beyond that. It directly affects our health, our life in our communities, and calls upon us to take urgent action. We have a number of different activities, such as when We put challenges and clues in a park in our city, which helped us make the connection with our daily lives. We don't compete, we make joint efforts to reach a common target. put forward my ideas, I knew they'd be listened to, and I also listened carefully to others so that we could reach an agreement. We shared our opinions through clear proposals. So this is what we do. We work together with companies, authorities, families, and youth. We come from different areas, but we're equally important. Children's efforts through our assembly have led to a cooperative letter addressed to government, civil society, and the community in general. We're calling for tangible action in order to improve water and air quality, protect biodiversity and our environment. Children and youth assemblies teach us how to live democratically. We don't have to wait until we grow up. We call for these assemblies and councils to be rolled out throughout the world and that there is constant follow-up to these meetings. There should be periodic reviews so that our proposals are put into action, because they provide us with tools as well, such as empathy, critical thinking, and the security to express ourselves. We know that our voice count and that we will be supported in our efforts to build a better world. I'd like to thank you for this opportunity, and once again, I'd like to underscore that we need more fora for children to participate and that we must be listened to and taken into consideration as citizens with the right to propose practical solutions. Thank you very much.

Mexico

The right to participate for children and youth should be a universal right and not a privilege. Being a participant in a forum like this one and the Climate Assembly held in Jalisco, Mexico, is a way of including us and making room for us as citizens. We think that it is vitally important because we're the ones who are going to live with today's decisions in the future, even though we're already here. What happens now affects us. All children should have the right to participate, but in my country, not all children have the same opportunities. There are around 36.2 million young people in Mexico, around 5 million do not have access to internet, and 6.4 million do not go to school, and they've not had the opportunity to learn to read and write. So that's why they don't hear about the chance to participate, and even if they receive the information, there aren't enough opportunities for them to express themselves and be a part of these initiatives. Now, this isn't the situation in Mexico alone. It's common to the whole world. We must ensure fundamental rights such as the right to education, water, and a life free from violence. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child is an unprecedented step in promoting human rights. It highlights the need to promote opportunities for children to be listened to. Participation is the tool for the future development of our personalities. According to Article 6, and Article 29 on education. Progress on human rights is undeniable, but our voices need to be included in decision making so that we can continue to develop our rights. Furthermore, the Convention establishes States' obligations to create fora for us to participate and take our contributions into consideration. As we are under 18, we can't vote, so that's why we need these fora. for our participation. We believe that if you listen to what we have to say about today's problems, then there will be a huge impact. We're here today because participation is a right, and we must be ready to recognise it, and children are ready to protect and defend the rights of all children through fora like this one. But in order for this to be truly meaningful, we need civic education so that we're aware of our rights and we know how our society works, how we can express our ideas, and how to listen to those of other people. We must also be informed about decisions which are taken. A child will not participate unless he realises that he has the right to. Participation means having an influence on processes and activities and decisions, so we need to know the meaning of these words so that we can build a better world for all. If we participate, we're not just observers, we are meaningful actors. I'm here today because I've been given the opportunity, but there are too many children that don't have such an opportunity, so I need to speak up on behalf of them all. Whilst I don't know what the daily lives are like for each children and young people, doesn't mean to say that I'm different to them. Continue to fight for children, please.

CzechiaChair

Thank you very much, Leon and Julia, for those very important comments.

Excellencies, distinguished forum participants, ladies and gentlemen, on this day, 87 years ago, Nazi forces raided the University of Prague, leading to the tragic loss of student lives and the closure of Czech universities. Today, the 17th of November, is marked in Europe as International Students Day, serving as a global reminder of the importance of student rights, access to education, and the power of youth-led movements. Exactly 50 years later, on the 17th of November 1989, a student gathering held to commemorate these events was violently suppressed in the center of Prague. That moment marked the beginning of the Velvet Revolution, which eventually led to the establishment of democratic government in my country. Having participated in the demonstrations of November 1989, I witnessed how students and young people helped bring democratic change to my country. It is therefore particularly meaningful to me that this forum concludes on the 17th of November. And that means that the role of young people in public life is not an abstract concept, but a lesson from history that I have seen firsthand. The world has changed in important respect over the past 37 years. The strength of young people, however, still remains a powerful force as visible in developments around the world every year. Yet we cannot take for granted that power will always be exercised in the service of human rights and democracy. This is where education and learning is as critical as it is powerful. It contributes to the development of human potential. It can strengthen democracy, the rule of law, contribute to the eradication of poverty and reduction of economic inequality, the realization of human rights, and the achievement of all internationally agreed development goals. Yet, as we have heard, learning civic participation is not only about curriculum, and learning is not completed by taking a course. We need to the purposes of education pedagogical practices, and the way authority, responsibility, and participation is organized in education. Education must foster an environment conducive to curiosity, critical questioning, and collaboration. That is where children are encouraged to participate in decisions affecting them, while also understanding the importance of responsibility and accountability in doing so. We have to also recognize and value the critical role of non-formal and informal education and learning, and promote the complementary role played in this respect by civil society, from whom We have heard many remarkable examples from all over the world. Education can foster greater understanding, dialogue, and cooperation among peoples. And we have heard of the importance that it be tailored to achieve gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls, accessibility for inclusion of persons with disabilities, combating racism and all forms of discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance, and recognition of the rights of indigenous people. Fostering civic participation through education requires an enabling environment where there is no fear of participation or of questioning, where science is not pillared and knowledge is not spurned, where people do not fear reprisals for raising their voice. These are sadly not hypothetical situations. Some potential participants could not be invited to this very meeting for fear of reprisals. One organization withdrew their participation as panelists due to their increasing concerns about engaging with the UN human rights system. We cannot shy away from this reality. Excellencies, distinguished participants, we should not underplay the seriousness of the situation we face globally. The consequences of climate change, slowing economies, rising inequality, the rise of authoritarian practices and populism, an unprecedented number of armed conflicts since the Second World War, and new technologies which are increasingly shaping all aspects of our life. This accentuates the urgency to take decisive and coordinated action to invest in a world for our future generations that leaves hope for betterment, and to capacitate those future generations to come together and solve the challenges that they inevitably will encounter along the way. In arriving at those solutions, we should listen to our future generations. As we have heard today from Charlotte in the opening, to Leon and Julia in the closing segment now, and the various other children and young people in between, they can and they want to contribute to their community. And many are impressively contributing. Our responsibility is to give them the space and the tools to contribute to society. We should act to make that a reality. In closing, I would just like to remind all participants that my report on this session of the Forum will be delivered to the Human Rights Council at its 64th session. You may continue to share information and make recommendations towards that until the end of this week by using the QR code shared. Let me now thank all panelists, speakers, and participants, member states, experts, youth, children, and civil society for their inspiring and constructive engagement over these two days. The spirit of respect, and constructive dialogue that has prevailed during the whole session has been exemplary. I reiterate my gratitude to the Human Rights Council for the trust placed in Czech Republic and myself to preside over this important gathering and declare closed the sixth session of the United Nations Forum on Human Rights, Democracy, and the Rule of Law. Thank you.