Working Group II (7th meeting), UN Convention on Biodiversity – COP 17
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Good afternoon, colleagues, and welcome back. I hope you had a good lunch break. Now, I would like to hear some progress reports from co-chairs of the contact groups. First, I would like to invite Ms. Clarice Keller-Siebert to give us an update from the contact group on item 18A, biodiversity and climate change, that met last evening. So, Sweden, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. I'm pleased to report on the work of the Contact Group on item 18A, on biodiversity and climate change, which I co-chaired yesterday evening together with my co-chair, Mr. Zhang Gao of China. The Contact Group worked on the basis of version two of the non-paper. The group considered the remaining outstanding.
Paragraphs from the draft decision, apart from the ones referencing annex two, sorry, annex one. It managed to remove some brackets and made some progress on others. In the final minutes, the group also heard views on Annex 2, which contains the multi-level roadmap for enhancing cooperation, policy coherence, and synergies across the Rio Conventions.
My co-chair and I believe that another contact group session is needed in order for the group.
To continue working on version two of the non-paper and come to consensus on outstanding issues.
We thank all parties once again for their hard work and willingness to engage constructively in order to.
Resolve outstanding issues, and our thanks also to the Secretariat and the Armenian Presidency for facilitating our process.
Thank you.
Thank you very much, Ms. Clarice. The Bureau has agreed to another session of this contact group. It will meet on Sunday morning. Please make sure to check your schedule to confirm the time allocations, and congratulations for the progress, and we wish you all the best. Now, I would like to invite Ms. Kishma Primus. to give us an update from the Contact Group on COP item 18F, biodiversity and health, that also met last evening. So, Antigua and Barbuda, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. I am pleased to provide an update on the work of the Contact Group on the agenda item 18F on biodiversity and health, which was held yesterday from 7:30 to 10:50 in the evening. My co-chair and I are happy to report that the contact group made significant progress. 11 pair of brackets were removed and five paragraphs were cleaned, leaving 10 pair of brackets in the text. We thank all parties for their constructive engagement and flexibility that helped us move the agenda forward. However, some challenges still remain, some of which we believe are issues that are upcoming in several cross-cutting agenda items, and therefore may benefit from more time on these topics to wait for the topics to be evolved. Other remaining issues are in relations to which happens in the biennium, including the potential work on indicators, where some views favouring more work on this, including development on science-based indicators, while others prefer a simpler approach. To advance these discussions, we have requested informal consultations on a small group of parties which are ongoing to help the co-chairs to find a common ground in order to make additional progress. We will consult with the parties to try to provide compromise text, and we will share this with you, Chair. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Ms. Kishma Primus, for your report and the progress. So it's therefore my understanding that the co-chairs will continue to assist me to these informal consultations, and there is no need for another contact group. I appreciate your efforts and that of Ms. Engels. I await as soon as possible any compromise text that you may get from these consultations, which I will consider in preparing the CRP document to be undertaken by the Working Group 2. Thank you so much. Next, I would like to invite Ms. Senka Varujanovic to give us an update from the contact group on COP item 17d, areas of potential further work that met this morning. So, Bosnia and Herzegovina, you have the floor. Can you press your button, please?
Thank you, Chair. The Contact Group on item 17 (a) and 17 (d), which I had the pleasure to co-chair with Ms. Enika Nicholas, met this morning from 10:00 to 1:00 PM. to discuss item 17D on areas of potential further work in the context of Kunming-Montreal, on the basis of the non-paper that was prepared by the Working Group 2 chair. Overall, limited progress was made, despite constructive engagement and efforts to find compromise. The group spent most of the session discussing section A on biodiversity-inclusive spatial planning. and began consideration on section B on pollution and biodiversity towards the end of the session. In light of the ongoing discussions on the issue of ecological connectivity under item 17C and its relationship with the issue of spatial planning, Some parties proposed to address this issue under section A on biodiversity-inclusive spatial planning of item 17D. Efforts were made to bridge differences and facilitating progress under both items. However, these efforts resulted in new text as well as brackets, highlighting the challenges of finding compromise. A small group was established within the mandate provided to the group to find a solution and report back to the contact group in case that time is allocated for another session. With regard to section B on pollution and biodiversity, the contact group agreed to continue this discussion on the basis of option 2, which contains clean text. Some delegations requested to bring a few relevant elements in option 1 into option 2. We started discussions on paragraph 1, but then ran out of time. In view of limited progress and outstanding differences, we would like to kindly request an additional session of the Contact Group to continue the discussion. On behalf of my fellow co-chair, Anika, and I, we would like to thank all delegations for their constructive engagement and Secretariat for their help.
Thank you very much, Senka. So the contact group will meet later this week. Please refer to the schedule to confirm the time and allocation. I invite all parties to keep working with flexibility and to look for ways. Remember, so far our rules are on the line that if you are adding new taxes because you are proposing a solution. Of course, there is linkages with some other documents we have on the table, and since we are talking about the future, areas of work, so maybe some connections, but it doesn't mean that it's hostage of any other document. If this is helping to have clarity in the way forward, good ideas and compromises are welcome. So I invite you to continue doing the good work. Thank you so much. Next, I would like to invite Mr. Vernell Schenkel. to give us an update from the Contact Group on COP/MOP item 13, risk assessment and risk management that met this morning. So, Germany, you have the floor?
Thank you, Chair. This morning I had the honour to chair the second session of the Contact Group on COP/MOP 12, item 13, on risk assessment and risk management of living modified organisms, from 1:00 AM to Sorry, from 10:00 AM to 1:00 PM. During the discussion, we recognized that it is important to address the needs and priorities of parties on topics of risk assessment. However, we have many topics and likely to have even more in line with the process established in decision CP.9/13 and through the national reporting for the Cartagena Protocol. Thus, after hearing some reflection and perspectives of parties, the majority of the parties saw the need to look at efficiency in the CP 913 process. Many also had the view that work should continue on addressing one or two topics in parallel. To address these elements, I made some proposals to capture these points in the decision text. Overall, seven paragraphs and five subparagraphs are clean. However, a few parties expressed reservations, and there was no clarity on which of the topics work could potentially continue on. Thus, unfortunately, many brackets still remain, including many of the requests to the Executive Secretary and the annex. Despite these brackets, I had the impression that we are moving in the right direction, and should we have had more time, we would have been able to achieve our mandate. I would like to thank the members of the contact group, particularly for their flexibility in finding solutions and for the thorough and constructive discussions. Also, thanks to the excellent support by the Secretariat, as always, I would like to add. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you very much for this update. I can see that delegations are making every effort to advance in this very important work for the Cartagena Protocol. I hear that additional session will be required. I hope that delegations can continue with the informal consultations over the weekend. And I will look into scheduling, we will look into scheduling a third session during next week to continue this important work. Thank you very much. Delegates, now following the contact group that will meet on Sunday, I have some news for you. The groups that we meet are on item 18A on climate change, item 17E on IPBES, item 18B on sustainable wildlife management, item 17C on protected areas, and item 16 on synthetic biology. I know some of you were anxiously waiting to start, which will have two consecutive sessions. Again, please make sure to refer to the schedule to confirm the timing and location. So with this, we finish reports and announcements on contact groups, and now we will continue consideration of CRP documents. We will now resume discussions on document CRP.7, matters related to the financial mechanism and resources. From yesterday, we had diverging views on the reference to specific funding for the biosafety protocols in paragraphs 8(a) and 8(d). The text contained in paragraph 8 and paragraph 8. Yesterday, several parties, with the kind assistance of the Armenian Presidency, were working to resolve the matter. I understand that a solution has been found for all the remaining issues. So, I'll give the floor to the distinguished delegation of Armenia. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Good afternoon, distinguished colleagues. Mr. Chair, following your call yesterday, we have facilitated informal consultations among the concerned parties with a view to identifying common ground and achieve progress on the issues. As a result of those consultations, we agreed upon a compromise text for the subparagraph 8e, as well as for subparagraph 8f, that seeks to accommodate the views and concerns expressed by the parties, while preserving the substance of the proposal and maintaining a balanced approach. We would like to sincerely thank all delegations that engaged constructively in the consultations for their openness, flexibility, and willingness to work towards common understanding. So I would like to start with paragraph 8E and propose, instead of the bracketed part of the paragraph, the last part of the paragraph, to read the following: "To strengthen and to strengthen adequate, predictable, and dedicated financing for biosafety to contribute to the full and effective implementation of the Protocol.
Thank you very much. Is this formulation of paragraph 8E acceptable? I don't see any requests from the floor. Thank you very much. Let's proceed with next one.
Thank you very much. With your permission, Mr. Chair, we proceed to the second subparagraph F, which will read as follows: "To continue to explore ways to simplify the process for submitting biosafety project proposals, taking into account Parties' experiences, with a view of making the funding more accessible.
Thank you very much, Arminium. I would like to see if we can accept this formulation of subparagraph 8f. I don't see any requests. Thank you very much. So it's Accepted as amended. Next one.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and very much encouraged with this progress. I would like to kindly suggest, we would like to kindly suggest an alternative for the word "specific", which was in brackets in subparagraphs 8(a) and 8(d). We suggest to change the word "specific" to "dedicated" in both places.
Thank you very much, Amelia. So we go along to the suggestions to replace in both 8A and 8D specific by dedicated. I see no Fiji.
Thank you, Chair. Chair, we unfortunately could not be part of the small group. This is for multiple reasons. We have a very small delegation covering a range of agenda items. We also could not, we also had mentioned in SBs as well, particularly on this paragraph, on 8A. We have no reservations with the presidential proposal on replacing specific with dedicated. However, on 8A, there is convention language that is not well reflected. which is to mention after eligible parties, in particular least developed countries and small island developing states, which is also in the Cartagena Protocol as well. So with the indulgence of parties, this is a strong position of the Pacific SIDS and its 14 member states, and we would like to see this reflected in paragraph 8A. Thank you.
Thank you, Fiji. So first, I believe there is no objection to the replacement of the word "specific" to "dedicated." Thank you for flexibility of all. And now I'd like to see if we can include the request from Fiji that was not able to participate. If I understand, it's almost at the end of the first line, after two eligible parties, including SIDS, right? That's the request. Fiji.
Thank you, Chair. We would like the reference to be in the exact same way that the Convention language references SIDS and LDCs. So here we would like to see after all eligible parties, in particular the least developed countries and small island developing states. There is a bigger formulation in the context of Cartagena Protocol that There is also language where it says, among them, is also economies in transition. However, we don't have the mandate to speak on behalf of other group parties. For us, it is important that the references to SIDS and LDCs is maintained.
Thank you, Fijis. I'll repeat again this session after religious parties, in particular, the least developed and small island developing states among them. I see no ring. I see no comments on it, so we include that. Thank you very much to all. I have Panama.
Thank you, Chair. I'd like to ask the Secretariat to once again read out the text. with the proposal from Fiji. Thank you. Thank you, Chair.
Paragraph 8A would read: "To make dedicated, adequate, and timely funding available to eligible parties, in particular the least developed countries and small island developing states among them, for putting in place legal, administrative..." and the paragraph continues.
Thank you, Secretariat. Madam, are you okay? I see nodding. Thank you, everybody, for these efforts and the support of the Armenian delegation and all delegates engaged on this process. So I would like to put for consideration the adoption of document CRP7. in order to turn to L and go for this evening plenary to be approved. I see no objections, so document is approved. Dear delegates, this is good to start with this spirit. We will now consider CRP1 on the Cartagena Protocol agenda, item 8, the fifth assessment and review. of the effectiveness of Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety, and mid-term evaluation of the implementation plan, and the capacity building action plan for the protocol. Yesterday, we made good progress. We have clean text in two paragraphs that have brackets. However, we were not able during this session to resolve some issues in paragraph 27, and 51, and as parties with strong views on the text in these paragraphs, including Egypt and the EU, to get together and find a solution. I very much hope you have found a compromise text, and I am ready to hear the outcome of your consultations. So I'd like to know who will take the floor to report back. Either Egypt or Egypt. So, dear colleagues, I need you to ask you to continue your consultations since we cannot send this document with brackets to the plenary. We need to resolve these two issues in the working group. So we'll come back to this item next week. the working group. In the meantime, I urge those parties with strong views to please find time to resolve it over the weekend. I invite especially Egypt, EU, and Brazil to find time to get together and come with good news in a further session of our working group. Thank you very much. So with this, we finish our business for today with the Cartagena Protocol, and we will continue with COP documents. I'll give you a minute to get ready for it. So, dear delegates, we will now consider CRP1 under agenda 18D of the COP, biodiversity and agriculture. We still have eight set of brackets left in this document. We will go through the document addressing the different pairs of brackets one by one. So let's start with CRP consideration, and with the first operative paragraph, which is number three, that says, it said would encourage parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, sustainable use, and so on, where we have at the end these brackets. So I would like to offer to replace the text inside the first set of brackets to the following, that says: "Encourage Parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national plans as appropriate, so to delete the middle part and just keep it more simple. I read it again, so it would read: Number 3, encourage parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national plans as appropriate. And we go along with this proposal. EU.
Thank you, Chair.
There's a bit of an echo there. We would actually like to slightly expand the text in those brackets to ensure that we make clear that this policy as well needs to align with the KMGBS. And that there is obviously a wider kind of policy piece in that space. So what we would like to do is, and I'll read this out, and I'll try and be nice and slow. So the text would read, national biodiversity strategies and action plans, and national targets aligned with KMGBF, comma, strike the and, into, strike the wider, climate, environmental, agricultural, and land use, land policy instruments, I beg your pardon, including through biodiversity, et cetera, et cetera, and then to the end of those brackets.
Thank you. You really can Your insertion, I was trying to make a simple language, and now you are expanding the already long list of elements. So you were requesting to include national targets aligned with the framework and more elements. So please repeat so Secretary can take note of your amendments.
Thank you, Chair. So the proposal is to add to biodiversity strategies and national biodiversity strategies and action plans after that, and national targets aligned with the KMGBF, then comma, into climate, environmental, agricultural, and land policy instruments, comma, including through biodiversity-inclusive spatial planning conducted in a participatory manner, and other national plans as appropriate. Thank you.
Okay, comments on the proposal from EU. And I have Russian Federation, followed by Brazil and Philippines.
Dear Mr. Chair, distinguished guests, so we disagree with the proposal of the European Union. We prefer your type of formulation, and we want to make a proposal of the following formulation: national plans, as appropriate, in accordance with national circumstances. Thank you.
Thank you, Russian Federation. So you followed my suggestions, but adding at the end, in accordance with national circumstances. So we have two versions. Let's hear more. Brazil, followed by Philippines and Cameroon.
Thank you very much, Mr. President, and thank you also for the proposals made by the EU and Russia. On the first point, we were ready also to go along with your proposal, Mr. Chair. We would, if there is an interest in keeping some of the language, we would propose that the text read encourages parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national biodiversity strategies and action plans, and other policy instruments and national plans as appropriate.
Thank you, Brazil. Now we have three options. I'll give the floor to Philippines, followed by Cameroon and Saudi Arabia.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think we go along with the proposal of European Union. The original bracketed text, I think, is an opportunity for us to synergize the three Rio Conventions. So our proposal is to consider the integration of soil biodiversity into their national action plans for biodiversity, climate, land degradation, and agricultural development. We would like to include agricultural development since we are talking here about the linkage between biodiversity and agriculture. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you very much. Still growing. We are in the end of October, so Christmas is getting close. We are making another Christmas tree with this paragraph. Let's see, Cameroon, followed by Saudi Arabia and Mongolia.
Thank you. Thank you so much, sir. You are quite right when you say that the list of proposals and requests for the floor is getting longer. If you continue to leave the door open to additional texts being added, it will just grow even longer. But as far as we're concerned, We agree with the proposal that you made. It seems to us to be simpler. If we add to the national plans and strategies on biodiversity the fact that it must be in keeping with the global framework, one will have to recall that the national strategies and plans of action on biodiversity the national manifestation of the global framework. So it seems to me that what we'd be doing is we'd be breaking down a door that is already open, and for this reason we think that your proposal is the simplest, and we for one back it, sir.
Thank you very much for the support. So the list is growing, and I think we need to be more effective. I have already about eight requests, and So we have the short version, and another is growing and growing, and we need to be efficient, please. Saudi Arabia, followed by Mongolia and Panama and Canada.
Thank you. Thank you, sir. Chair, we are going to accept the proposal that you had presented. It was something that was acceptable to us. However, following the various proposals that we heard, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia wishes to back the proposal made by Russia. And we would like to reiterate that the fact that we're guaranteeing the sustainable use of soils is something that should be in keeping with relevant national strategies. For this reason, we back the proposal made by Russia. And we do this while taking into account the mandates of each of the conventions, we have to, of course, abide by all of the mandates of all of the conventions, when it's the one on climate change or the convention on desertification. In each of these conventions, there are a number of national plans which all have an impact. Thank you.
Thank you, Saudi Arabia. Mongolia, followed by Panama and Canada.
Thank you, Chair. Mongolia supports your proposal. But then, having observed the previous speakers, my delegation would like to support what Brazilian colleagues proposed. So we would, if the third option is going to be on the table, we would like to support Brazil. Thank you.
Thank you. Mandama, followed by Canada and Morocco.
Thank you, Chair.
On same lines that said by Mongolia, we support Brazil's proposal. Thank you.
Gracias. Canada.
Thank you, Chair. Canada would prefer to retain your proposal and keep the proposed wording “national plans” over the longer bracketed text, as there’s no need to be specific here with the plans, strategies, or instruments. Additionally, most parties have completed and submitted their national biodiversity strategies and action plans, so it does not make sense to encourage new elements into plans that are completed. Now, in the spirit of compromise, maybe to help move things forward, Canada would suggest adding and policy instruments after national plans to help expand the scope without being overly specific. Thank you.
Thank you, Canada. I'll give the floor to Morocco, followed by India and Côte d'Ivoire.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I see that some of the parties are adding the text, and.
We are looking forward to minimize the text, and we go for the proposition made by Cameroon.
And stop the action plans as appropriate and delete all the details and goes with your proposal, Mr. Chair.
Thank you.
Thank you very much. India, followed by Côte d’Ivoire, and last Bhutan, and I’ll come with some concrete proposals.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. India proposes that the matter should be within their national jurisdiction. So we propose that a text as per national circumstances and jurisdiction may be included. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, India.
Yes, thank you so much. Thank you so much, sir. We too would like to back your proposal, and we'd like to back Cameroon's proposal in doing so. Thank you.
Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair. We'd like to keep this simple and straightforward, maybe with an addition of the word strategies, national strategies and plans. Because I think many countries have a lot to do in soil biodiversity, a lot of work to be done. So I think there's no point in putting in a lot of words there and make it very complicated. So just an addition of word strategies and plan would be acceptable to us. Thank you.
Thank you very much. And certainly we're talking about Biodiversity and Agriculture. So we have basically three different options, one short, one medium, and one long version. I will ask the Secretariat for you with the different proposals to read each one and to see where we can find some common ground and move on. We already spent quite time in this first paragraph. We have, I believe, seven more. So, Secretariat.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, the short proposal reads: "Encourage Parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national plans, comma, as appropriate, in accordance with national circumstances. The medium version is encouraging parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national biodiversity strategies and action plans, and other policy instruments. No, sorry. After action plans, comma, other policy instruments, and national targets aligned with the KMGBF, comma, into climate, comma, environmental, comma, agriculture, and land policy instruments, comma, including through biodiversity-inclusive spatial planning conducted in a participatory manner.
Yeah.
I don't know what this.
And then the complete version encourages parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national biodiversity strategies and action plans, aligned with the KMGF. into climate, environmental, agriculture, and land policy instruments, including through biodiversity-inclusive spatial planning conducted in a participatory manner, as appropriate.
So this is the situation. I know it's a little bit difficult to follow such a long text. I would like to know if I need your help, because to start a contest here on voting, I don't believe is not necessarily the best way. I have Russian Federation.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I think here we would like to propose a kind of compromise and with the following formulation. Encourages parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national planning instruments, including national biodiversity strategies and action plans, as appropriate, in accordance with national circumstances. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Philippines, followed by Brazil.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We are willing to shorten the paragraph. to consider national action plans, plus, but can we include agricultural development plan? Since we are talking here about agriculture and biodiversity. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Brazil?
I would like to second the proposal made by the Russian Federation and express that we are also amenable to the Philippine proposal. Thank you.
Thank you. So, we are working on this fourth option that I believe is balance, combining the different from the very much detailed, long and very short and practical one, allows the Secretariat to read it. I hope this is settled. Everybody needs to be flexible, please. So it's not perfect, but enough to allow us to move on.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the new option reads, encourage parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national planning instruments, including the National Biodiversity Strategic and Action Plans in agriculture planning, according to the national circumstances.
Can we accept this formulation? I think it's balanced. Russian Federation.
So, generally, we agree, Mr. Chair, only adding one word: agricultural instruments, national agricultural instruments. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Russia, EU, please.
Thank you very much, Chair. We would prefer to keep climate, environment and agricultural instruments into the title. So if there is support for that, we would like to go ahead with this.
Okay. Since we are almost there, I will ask Secretariat to read it in order to move forward.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the new proposal is encourage Parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national planning instruments, including the national biodiversity strategies and action plans, into climate, environmental, agriculture, and agriculture instruments according to the national circumstances.
Can we go along? Russian Federation.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We cannot agree with climate. Thank you.
Who is willing to help? Maybe you had a very heavy lunch. EU, can you accept the deletion of climate? Or we don't want to send document with brackets. some flexibility. That's why I was trying to have a more general goal to instruments and policy instruments and not including a list, because if we start with a list, we're going to leave something out. EU.
Thank you, Chair. We would like to ask for clarification why climate should be deleted. There are links between climate, biodiversity, and soil health. Thank you.
I better invite you to get in touch with Russian Federation when we move to following paragraphs, otherwise we're going to have many parties in a dialogue. Meanwhile, I invite you to use this as a basis only with the discussion about climate. That's my suggestion, not to navigate with many versions, to use this one. leave at the moment climate in brackets and leave for consultations between Russian Federation and EU, and to move to next paragraph, please. So I invite you to go now to paragraph four. That is, all in brackets, is calling by parties to enhance coordination among agricultural, environmental, and health sectors to mainstream sustainable use of soil and water initiatives across other sectoral plans, policies, and strategies, in line with the framework, ensuring the full and effective participation of IPLCs, women, and youth. Can we lift the brackets? Brazil.
In paragraph 4, I think it's quite important to have this integration with on soil biodiversity and biodiversity in agriculture, particularly for family farming. So we would propose to also include after biodiversity initiatives the references to including technical assistance and rural extension, and in the final part of the paragraph, after women and youth, to include farmers organizations, in particular family farmers and agroecological producers. Gracias, señor presidente.
¿Puede repetir, por favor, su enmienda.
Shukran, Sayeda Rais.
Microphone to Brazil, please. I'm asking to repeat the proposal.
Sorry, Chair. Invites parties to enhance coordination among the agricultural, environmental, and health sectors to mainstream sustainable soil biodiversity initiatives. including technical assistance and rural extension, policies across other sectoral plans, policies and strategies in line with the framework, and ensuring the full and effective participation of indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth, farmers, organizations, in particular family farmers and agroecological producers. Gracias.
Thank you. So this is now quite a long conclusion. I was asking to lift the brackets with the additions of Brazil, farmers' organizations, and also including technical support. I hope this is acceptable. Now we have in the list Guatemala, Saudi Arabia, and the European Union.
Thank you very much, Chair. Guatemala also had similar proposals that made by Brazil with regards to farmers organizations, and agricultural producers. So therefore, we support their proposal. Thank you.
Thank you, Guatemala. So Guatemala supports Brazil. Saudi Arabia, please.
Thank you, Chair. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia supports deleting the brackets in this paragraph. called "add as appropriate" at the end of the paragraph. Thank you.
Thank you very much. I'm not EU.
Thank you, Chair. We have also similar proposal to include at the end of the paragraph subnational and local governments and other key stakeholders, including farmers. We believe that this text could be strengthened with the inclusion of smallholder farmers and agroecology, so we would be also happy to support that. Thank you.
Thank you. In general, I support to leave the brackets and to make these precisions. So, the Secretary is now combining the different proposals in order to make sense.
Are you ready?
So I will ask the Secretariat to read the formulation as amended.
Thank you, Mr. President. So now paragraph 4 reads: "Invites Parties to enhance coordination among the agricultural, environmental, and health sectors to mainstream sustainable soil biodiversity." initiatives, including technical assistance and rural extension, across other sector plans, policies, and strategies, in line with the framework and ensuring the full and effective participation of indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth, farmers' organizations, in particular smallholders and family farmers, and agroecological producers, as appropriate.
Thank you, Secretaria. Can we support this paragraph as amended? I don't see any request. Thank you very much. So we have clean text on paragraph 4. I invite you now to move to paragraph 6. In paragraph 6, we have two sets of brackets, one in a position to do so. and the other one on financial resources. My suggestion, if you agree, is to lift the brackets on the text in a position to do so and to delete financial resources. Can you accept this suggestion? Brazil.
Gracias, señor Presidente. If the idea is to take out financial resources, we would also agree to not including a position to do so and just invite parties and to take the actions in the paragraph. Thank you.
Just to be clear, Brazil, what you suggest is to delete both texts in both brackets. Yes, I see you nodding. It's clear to me. Now, there was another party asking for the floor. Maybe? No? No, so, yeah, DRC.
Thank you, Chair, for giving me the floor. DRC would like to keep the text and proposes removing the brackets. Thank you.
So, i was trying a mixture to leave brackets and delete text. Now we have both deletions of text and both keeping the text. What is better for agriculture and biodiversity?
Cameroun.
Thank you, Chair. Perhaps the best thing would be to come back to your initial proposal, which strikes the right balance, in my opinion. You see, Chair, states can only do what they're able to do. So whether it's said or not, they can't do what they're not able to do. For us, for the second bracket, focus on financial resources, and you've posed eliminating. We agree with this, but I'd like to recall that capacity building can also be financial capacity building, in which case you then come back to what's just been deleted. So I would rather support your initial proposal. Thank you.
Thank you for support of this hybrid. proposal. I have Tanzania followed by Switzerland and Benin.
Chair, I was also supporting to lift the brackets around in a position to do so, but we are okay with removing financial.
Resources, but just keep parties in a position to do so.
Thank you.
Thank you for the support. Switzerland, followed by Benin.
Thank you, Chair. We would like to support the proposition made by Brazil, considering that an invitation for party automatically includes that it will be relevant for those and I'm pretty sure to do so, and that seems redundant. Thank you.
Beny.
Thank you, Chair. Benin supports. we're moving in a position to do so and to keep financial resources. As said by Cameroon, this is necessary. Financial capacity is necessary for our countries. Thank you.
Thank you. EU.
Thank you, Chair. Our preference would be to lift the brackets around in a position to do so and keep financial resources. If in a position to do so, is deleted, we would like to also ask for the deletion of financial resources.
Thank you very much. I will try to see if we can delete both texts in both brackets to move on. So it's leaving the door open to multilateral funds and not only financial resources, but leave it also open to capacity building. We don't want to spend more time on this discussion. So, is anybody opposing to delete in a position to do so and to delete financial resources? Please raise your hand. I don't see opposition. I see a request from Sri Lanka, but I want you to respond to my question first. We can delete both texts in both brackets. Sri Lanka.
Yes, thank you, Mr. Chair.
We would like to leave all records, but it's probably better to keep the final rules as it is.
Thank you.
So if there could be some flexibility, Sri Lanka, I didn’t hear any other opposition to delete both texts. Can we go along with that and to delete in a position to do so and to match our resources and to move on? I really would like to send this document to this evening plenary to make progress. Gabon, followed by Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair. Gabon would like to delete the brackets, but with a small change within the paragraph. We would begin by citing policies, strategies and sectoral plans. Thank you, Chair.
I'm sorry, but it's not clear. Are you adding new language? We're trying to solve these two brackets, and I don't believe the solution is by adding more text, and it's not clear to me where. So I ask you to repeat to see if we are following our own rules. Can you repeat your suggestion? Actually, what I was asking is if we can to delete in a position to do so, and also financial resources and move on. So I'll ask once again, previous speaker, didn't get it. If you ask for the floor again. If not, I assume that you agree to delete and go with the consensus, and I have also Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair. We'd like in a position to do so, to be removed, but to keep financial resources and remove the brackets.
Benin.
Thank you, Chair. We can accept deletion of in a position to do so. But we would just ask to remove the brackets for financial resources and not financial resources itself. Thank you.
We already see the different combinations to delete all, to keep all, to delete the first, to delete the second, and we need to move on. I need flexibility. Senegal, you come with a solution.
Thank you, Chair. I think we can keep the text by removing the brackets. Thank you.
Okay, I'll try once again. Do we agree to keep all the text? Parties in a position to do so, and also include financial resources along with capacity building. So we need flexibility and to go to more substantial things. Remember, this is only an invitation. It's no obligation. So you can say no if you don't like to the invitation, and that's it. No problem. So I have Côte d'Ivoire, Brazil, and Saudi Arabia. It's an invitation.
Thank you, Chair. Côte d'Ivoire. We would like to keep in a position to do so, because that allows a certain amount of flexibility in terms of commitments for different parties, and also takes into account the capacities of those parties. We also want to insist upon keeping financial resources. Financing is essential for our country.
Thank you. Yeah, don't give more explanation why. Just like to know if you support to keep the text. You support Brazil? I look for some flexibility. Remember, it's an invitation. You can simply say, I don't want to go to the movies with you. Brazil.
Gracias, señor Presidente. And as we already said, we'll be in favor of keeping it very short and removing the text that is in brackets. If we are to move forward in working with those, we would propose and try to see if this is a bridging proposal that can move us forward. If not, also happy to take it out. To read further invites developed country parties and parties that voluntarily assume the obligations of developed country parties, multilateral funds, and relevant organizations to provide financial resources, capacity building, and so on. This would then be in line with what we have on the text of the convention and other decisions. Thank you.
Thank you. Actually, we already approved some documents following that formulation. Thank you for bringing it up. So this is calling developed countries and. Can you repeat the formulation for those assuming developed country parties and. Please, Vasile.
Developed country parties and, comma, and parties that voluntarily assume the obligations of developed country parties.
And then we can pick key financial resources. Can we accept that formulation? I have three parts requesting for the floor that probably are coming with different comments. Is anybody opposing to the formulation proposed by Brazil? I see that the list is deleting request, which is good. Saudi Arabia, are you against this new formulation?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia supports Brazil's formula. We would like to refer to article 20 of the Convention. That is our addition. Thank you.
Thank you, Saudi Arabia. So I understand you support Brazil's proposal. But before entering more text, let me see if we can fly with this DRC. Can we go along?
I think we can accept Brazil’s proposal. Thank you.
Thank you very much. So it seems we reached an agreement. Thank you for your cooperation. So we will go on, invite developed countries and parties that voluntarily assume the obligations of developed country Parties according – not including according to article 20, please, in a position to do so, no? multilateral funds and relevant organizations to provide financial resources. Thank you very much for your cooperation. So, paragraph 6 is clean. Next one. Now, paragraph 7. On paragraph 7, We have one set of brackets. It's all in brackets. Just give me a second, because maybe Thank you for your patience. So I have a proposal to delete the brackets around the paragraph and also to delete the part of the first part of the brackets at the end, to delete and to redirect them towards promoting biodiversity friendly practices and to keep with in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, and management as applicable. So I will read the text how it can work, i hope. with my proposal, so please follow me. Urges parties and other governments to identify, eliminate, phase out, or reform incentives, including subsidies, harmful to biodiversity, in a proportionate, just, fair, effective, and equitable way. and invites them to scale up positive incentives in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, and management as applicable. I hope this is in accordance to target 18. I hope this formulation is acceptable. Russian Federation.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So here we propose to delete the paragraph number 7. We understand that this paragraph has a lot in common with target 18, so repeating it in this decision, that's no real scientific or technical guidance specific to soil biodiversity. Thank you.
Thank you, Russian Federation. India.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Consistent with India's position on target 18 of KMGVF, and because the identification and reforms of incentives should be undertaken in accordance with the national circumstances and priorities, therefore, we suggest addition of "as per national circumstances" after "as applicable." Thank you, Mr. Chair.
So you suggest that after "as applicable" as per national circumstances. Saudi Arabia, followed by Brazil.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Saudi Arabia supports the deletion of this paragraph because we think this paragraph is inappropriate in this decision, and we support the formula by the Russian Federation. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you. Brazil, followed by EU.
And we remain flexible in a way forward. But I think one of the points that was raised was that the initiatives does not direct to anything new or as a target. Our proposal in that sense would be to add, after protection, conservation, and management, the following sentence: such as those directed to family farming and agroecological producers. So this idea would be to actually spell out some of the actions that could be taken. Thank you.
Please repeat, Brazil.
Such as those directed to family farming and agroecological production. Thank you.
Gracias, Brazil. So what I suggest is to delete part of the very prescriptive part of this paragraph. and redirect towards promoting biodiversity friendly practices, try to shorten it, and now we have the inclusion of such as those directed family farmers and so on, as Brazil, and also at the end, as per national circumstances, but also we hear a couple of parties want to delete the whole paragraph just to be very clear where we are, and I see a list of growing and a number of parties want to take the floor. EU, followed by Argentina, Panama, Bahrain. Microphone to EU.
Thank you, Chair. The EU strongly supports retaining this paragraph, and we would also like to support retaining the text and to redirect subsidies. in the middle, I think, at least I didn't hear that text anymore. So redirecting them towards promoting biodiversity friendly practices is also important to us. To make the sentence make sense, we could move and invite them to scale up positive incentives to later. So after biodiversity, to after including in relation to soil biodiversity protection, conservation and management. So this part could be towards the end, so that it doesn't come with harmful subsidies. And we could also support providing examples, but we would like to keep the text there. Thank you.
So you want to leave all the brackets? add text and to accept the language proposed by Brazil.
We would like to lift all brackets, but move after "and equitable way" and invites them to scale up positive incentives. to bring that to later in the text, so after biodiversity conservation and management, while also scaling up positive incentives. So it is taken out of the context of reforming incentives, including harmful subsidies, and redirecting them. So it comes later. We would like to have these both aspects.
So, we have a paragraph that includes the original text with additions from EU, Brazil, India, and also knowing a couple delegations don't want any, want to delete the whole paragraph, and I have like 10 requests from the floor. Please help me to move on to have a decision on this text. Argentina, followed by Panama, Bahrain.
Thank you, Chair. We would prefer to keep paragraph 7 as a whole as it was at the start. We can leave the text in brackets. We could be flexible and leave the Chair's proposal, and we also think Ine's proposal is quite good. Thank you.
Thank you, Panama.
Thank you, Chair. Panama supports Brazil's proposal with regards to this paragraph. Nevertheless, if this isn't possible, we can support the Chair's proposal. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
We support the deletion of the paragraph. Thank you.
Thank you so much, sir.
We find that this paragraph possesses a great deal of added value when it comes to incentives for biodiversity, for actions to be taken in favour of biodiversity. We would therefore back your proposal. which was to remove the square brackets which are found within the paragraph itself. Thank you.
Thank you. Côte d’Ivoire, followed by Uruguay and Sri Lanka.
Thank you so much, sir. We would like to thank you for your proposal, the one you made earlier, which is one where we’ll be back. with the changes proposed by Saudi Arabia, which take into account national situations.
Thank you. Uruguay, followed by Sri Lanka.
We would like to keep the initial wording of paragraph 7. but including taking into account the national priorities.
Promote positive incentives and go on.
English, French? I didn't hear. It was in English? I cut it off after.
So, get away. Uruguay.
So you would like to keep the initial wording, but refer to national circumstances as was proposed by India? And then you want to promote positive incentives, improve the positive incentives? I think that we have taken note of both of your comments. Thank you.
Sri Lanka, followed by DRC and UK.
Thank you, Mr. Ja.
We would fully support India's proposal and oppose to delete that statement.
Thank you.
Thank you. DRC, followed by UK. The list is still growing. That worries me.
Thank you, thank you so much, sir, for giving me the floor. The ADIC backs keeping the paragraph. When it comes to the changes to the last few lines, we are in favor to changing them. Thank you.
I have four requests, and I'll close the list to look for a concrete proposal. UK, followed by Norway, South Africa, and Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair. Apologies for taking us back a little bit, but we are a little bit confused here as to what the conclusion was on paragraph six. So whilst I don't want to hold this particular conversation up, Once you've concluded this, we would very much appreciate if you could return and just run us through the language that was agreed in paragraph 6. We'd very much appreciate that. Thank you.
Norway, followed by South Africa and Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair.
Norway would like to support the intervention by the EU and keep the paragraph, but we would also like to include after management, sustainable use.
Thank you, Chair.
South Africa, followed by Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair. Just to indicate that we would like to retain this paragraph, and we are very much flexible with the additions that are already made to this paragraph. And perhaps maybe just to keep in mind that in paragraphs 3 and 4, We are really making a call to parties to exercise various measures that support soil sustainable use and other practices. So, I do not see why in this paragraph we wouldn't be open to encouraging mechanisms that will enable these practices. So, this is why we see this paragraph being very important to retain. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you. South Africa, Bhutan.
Thank you, Chair. We would also like to maintain this paragraph, because there are many important points in this paragraph. And as one of the party was mentioning that, no, this can be found in another document. I mean, if we have this here, we need not refer to some other document. And we'd like to maintain everything with the removal of the brackets and addition suggested by India as per country's circumstances. Thank you.
Thank you very much. I closed the list, but I leave Russian Federation.
Thank you, Chair, for giving us the floor. It was a very straightforward position of our delegation that we do not see this paragraph here. We understand that the target 18, which it references, exists, and the language is derived from it. However, it is still up to the parties to develop their national strategies and action plans and to determine the sectoral approach in which they will realize that particular target. We believe that having that here makes an unnecessary accent on the agricultural sector, but we have heard some of the concerns from the room and something that we believe that we can offer to to make sure that those concerns are addressed, is, as you have suggested, to make an accent on the second part. We would not be able to keep the first part. However, we would be able to have something along the lines of inviting the parties to scale up positive incentives and promote biodiversity-friendly practices and so biodiversity protection, conservation, and management as applicable. Then we could enter the language that was proposed by several parties. I believe Brazil had some examples, and maybe some others. I'm sorry, I haven't had the time to type that in, but still, if the examples are needed here, we could include them, and then make reference to national That would be something we could work with. Thank you.
Spasiba, Russian Federation, for engaging in the discussions and looking for some way forward. I see the flexibility from your side, so I ask the same for other delegations. move on and trying to go along on taking out some parts that maybe are too detailed, but we want to have this perspective. This is very similar to what we have in Target 18 with some additions from some delegations with coping examples and also taking in consideration national circumstances. So I have two options of the paragraph. Before reading them, I would like to see the EU what can offer as a sign of flexibility to look for a common place.
Thank you, Chair. The EU supports retaining this paragraph, including the part on environmentally harmful subsidies. It is a very important target of the KMGBF and one that is also highlighted as an area where we have not made enough progress. Identifying, eliminating, phasing out, and reforming incentives harmful to biodiversity is very important in itself, and redirecting part of these resources to practices that actually are beneficial for biodiversity is also a very important way of securing financing for implementation. So we would strongly support retaining the first part, which is on environmentally harmful subsidies. Thank you.
Thank you, Ivo. So we have two sets of paragraphs with different formulations. I will ask the Secretariat to read both. Let's see the long one and then the short one. Please, Secretariat.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the long proposal reads, "Urges parties and other governments to identify, eliminate, phase out, or reform incentives, including subsidies, harmful to biodiversity in a proportionate, just, fair, effective, and equitable way, as applicable and as per national circumstances, and invites them to scale up positive incentives and to redirect them towards promoting biodiversity-friendly practices in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, management, and sustainable use, such as those directed to family farmers and agroecological producers. Now, the shorter version proposed by Russia. invites parties and other governments to scale up positive incentives and to redirect them towards promoting biodiversity-friendly practice in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, management, and sustainable use, such as those directed to family farmers and agroecological producers, as applicable and as per national circumstances. Thank you, Chair.
Okay, so we have these two versions, one with very much detail and other shorter. I have three requests: Japan, followed by Russian Federation and EU. Japan, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Sorry, back to paragraph 6. Japan would like to echo United Kingdom regarding paragraph 6.
I want to make a clarification of the sentence.
Thank you.
Yes, I know the request from the UK. When we finish with paragraph 7, we will read how was agreed, paragraph 6. Russian Federation, followed by EU and Philippines.
Thank you, Chair. Just sorry to take up more time. Just a small clarification. In our proposal, there was no mention of redirecting, so it goes to scale up positive incentives and promote biodiversity friendly practices. Thank you.
Thank you for the precision. We adjusted. the paragraph, EU followed by Philippines.
Thank you, Chair. We would also like to make a precision in our proposal. The language was to remove and invite them to scale up positive incentives, to move it to later in the sentence, so that and to redirect them relates to harmful subsidies, because this is where redirecting takes place. And also in our proposal, we would not support, according to national circumstances, the text that was added there, because we don't understand this text. Thank you.
You took clarity on your proposal when making reference to the text to redirect them, and you let us know where exactly you want that insertion to redirect towards promoting biodiversity friendly practices, and where should it be, or how would you like the paragraph read?
The text that in question comes after "effective and equitable way" and invites them to scale up positive incentives. We would like to delete this "and invite them to scale up positive incentives", leaving and to redirect them towards promoting biodiversity-friendly practices. And then, right at the end of the sentence, "while also scaling up positive incentives as applicable." So practically, move this part to the end of the sentence before "as applicable." Thank you.
Philippines.
We would like to give our support to the version of the Russian Federation, except for some change in the language. We would like to change the part promoting biodiversity friendly practices into mainstreaming biodiversity-friendly agricultural practices. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Please, Fiji, repeat your change on the Russian Federation version. Microphones to Fiji. Press your button, Fiji. Secretary got lost with all these changes, it's difficult to follow up. Fiji, you need to press your button to get the floor. I want you to repeat your proposal. I think there's a mistake. There's nothing from Fiji. Sorry about that. It was Philippines.
Thank you again, Mr. Che. We have stated our support to the proposal of Russian Federation, but we would like some change in the language. particularly the portion stating promoting biodiversity friendly practices. We would like this to be changed to mainstreaming instead of promoting biodiversity friendly agricultural practices. We have inserted the term agricultural practices, Mr. Chair. Thank you again.
Thank you, Philippines. Now it's clear. Before reading the paragraphs with the changes or precisions from EU and this change on the Russian version, I have two requests, one from New Zealand and another from Canada.
Thank you, Chair.
I just wanted to express support for your initial proposal, but I think that we can be pretty flexible. I think that we can support the first option that the EU has stated. When it comes to the second option, we think that reforming agricultural support is going to be a very.
Important part of Target.
18, so we cannot accept the second option in this case, but the first option is fine. Thank you.
Thank you, Canada. Now, New Zealand. Now, Canada.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We can be flexible too. In terms of supporting the first option, we'd like to make a slate amendment to change urges to invites, and then add other sustainable practices after the addition of agroecology.
Okay. Thank you for supporting my proposal, but I believe it is somehow lost in translation. So we have two paragraphs and not three. I will ask the Secretary to read the EU one with the many amendments and also the Russian one with the amendments.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I hope I got it correctly. So the EU proposal reads, invites parties and other governments to identify, eliminate, phase out, or reform incentives, including subsidies harmful to biodiversity, in a proportionate, just, fair, effective, and equitable way. and to redirect them towards promoting biodiversity-friendly practice and other sustainable practice in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, management, and sustainable use, such as those direct to family farmers and agroecological producers, as applicable, and scaling up positive incentives. The proposal from Russia with the amendments reads, invites parties and other governments to scale up positive incentives and mainstream biodiversity-friendly agricultural practice in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, management, and sustainable use, such as those direct to farming farmers and agroecological producers. as applicable and as per national circumstances. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretariat. So this is where we are on both paragraphs with multiple amendments. I'll give the floor to Brazil.
Gracias, señor Presidente. And just to express that I think that we're going on a very complicated negotiation, that is, we would strongly support the second proposal as made by Russia and recently amended for the mainstreaming. We also support that. We feel that it takes us closer to getting to consensus. Thank you.
Thank you. This is where we are now. We need to see, there's some support for the short version also. EU.
Thank you, Chair. I would just like to point out that the EU proposal actually now is a proposal made by quite a few parties and incorporates language proposed by many parties. We would like to keep the element of harmful subsidies. We can be flexible about adding in accordance with national circumstances, and also in a spirit of compromise, we can, or to find a solution that could be acceptable to other parties, we could actually put the element on scaling up positive incentives earlier, so it can be first, if that solves part of the problem. Thank you.
Thank you. I feel, as you said, Brazil, trying to find a way forward. So we have two paragraphs with multiple inputs from parties. And I have three requests: Gabon, followed by Benin and Uruguay.
Thank you. Thank you so much, sir. Gabon wishes to take the floor again to this time back the proposal made by the EU. Now, as we underscored, this proposal enables us to clearly understand what are negative incentives when it comes to biodiversity and what isn't, so we back the European Union.
Thank you. Benin followed by Uruguay.
Merci.
Thank you. Thank you so much, sir. I would like to recall that we are here, as the slogan says, to take action. to take action for nature, for biodiversity. And what does this is the European Union's proposal with the various amendments, flexible amendments, which clearly underline the two actions which are to be done, which is to limit negative incentives and retarget them in a more positive way. So we firmly back the EU's proposal, which takes both aspects into account fully.
Thank you, and in, uh, Uruguay.
Well, as the different proposals have been coming, we understand that proposal 2, the proposal by the Russian Federation, is the one that is most agreeable to us, taking into account the fact that it goes along the lines of our national action plans. Therefore, it seems that that will be sufficient. Thank you.
Switzerland.
Thank you, Chair. We strongly back the proposal by the EU, also in the light of what was shaping up as one of the key areas where there was no progress reported in the Global Report. And it would seem strange to not address this exact deficit. And we think, we also think that the suggestion of the EU of being flexible towards natural circumstances is a suitable compromise for those that don't necessarily want to have the two elements in the para, which to us seems logic. Thank you.
Thank you very much to all. I will ask the Secretary to read both multiple parties paragraphs to know where exactly we are, and I'll make a suggestion to go forward. Hold on.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So the first proposal invites parties and other governments to identify, eliminate, phase out, or reform incentives, including subsidies, harmful to biodiversity in appropriate, just, fair, effective, and equitable way, and to redirect them towards promoting biodiversity-friendly practices and other sustainable practices in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, management, and sustainable use, such as those directed to farmers and agroecological producers, as applicable and as per national circumstances, and scaling up positive incentives. The second proposal reads: invites parties and other governments to scale up positive incentives and mainstreaming biodiversity-friendly agriculture practice in soil biodiversity protection, conservation, management, and sustainable use, such as those direct to family farmers and agroecological producers, as applicable and as per national circumstances. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you. I heard recently a number of interventions in support to the first one, to the long one, based on EU initiative, and also some support also to the second one based on the Russian Federation. I propose that we leave these two versions for a moment, because I think we want to start in cycles. So you can reflect a little bit on these two texts. Let's go to repeat what we agreed already on paragraph 6 for those delegations that wanted to know what exactly was the language. So it is better to read.
Thank you, Chair. So the paragraph 6 reads: further invites developed countries, parties, and parties that voluntarily assumed the obligations of developed countries, parties, multilateral funds, and relevant organizations to provide financial resources, capacity building, technical and scientific cooperation, technological transfer, and the training of experts to expand research on soil biodiversity, and it continues.
Thank you very much. I hope that is clear. My understanding is that we already approve it, that paragraph, and I see you okay.
Thank you, Chair. It is with my apologies that we are not able to accept that text. The inserted language, developed parties and parties that voluntarily assume the position of developing country parties, is not acceptable language to the UK. We were very comfortable with the previous iteration that further invited parties in a position to do so, and we'd request that that is reinstated. We feel that that formulation ultimately is better. It better reflects the spirit and the intent of the paragraph. And if I may illustrate that by way of an example, I don't think... No, no, not necessarily.
Okay. The thing is, that was a problem within a position to do so. There were different views, and the compromise proposed by Brazil was that, to include Parties have assumed voluntary, and when I ask the floor, nobody objects. I don't know if you were not here or you were here and didn't mention. So this strikes me that we already reached an agreement.
And now, as I mentioned, Chair, it moved very rapidly. I appreciate the desire to move swiftly. and to get through as much as we can, but parties must be given enough time to consider the text in front of them. We don't see this as a compromise. We see this as a move away from text that would be a compromise. And respectfully, we do ask that our concerns be noted and the previous text be reinstated. We are very much happy to work with other parties to find a landing zone here, but I'm afraid the text currently on the table is not acceptable to the UK.
EU.
Thank you, Chair. We were also in the middle of discussing this paragraph when actually it moved on. So we understand that there is also a similar discussion going on under agenda item 18F in the contact group and that the discussion is not finished. So we would actually appreciate having looking back at this text again. As said earlier, we would favor lifting the brackets around both brackets in this paragraph rather than changing one and lifting the other. Thank you.
Okay, I would like to see where we are, take stock of the deliberations on this document. When we start, we We're not able to reach an agreement on paragraph 3, so I asked some delegations to get in consultations to solve it. Paragraph 2 is clean. Paragraph 6 was clean, now it has brackets. Paragraph 7, we have two versions. And also we have another set of brackets between paragraphs 11 and 14. So in order to get the best use of our limited time, I'll invite you to keep in mind pending paragraphs and to see if we can make some progress on paragraphs 11 to 14. That, for me, looks fine. And this is also in relation to request to the Executive Secretary. And my proposal is to ask you if we can leave the brackets around paragraph 11 to paragraph 14. Is there any objection to remove the brackets? Russian Federation.
Thank you, Chair. We would be okay with paragraph 11. For the paragraph 12, we have three minor amendments or even changes of the language that would allow us to agree with this paragraph. Should I present them?
Please go ahead.
I understand that I can. So for the paragraph 12, in the fifth line, after the words "activities on reducing the impact of pollution," we would like to change pollution to the trace elements. So that would read, activities on reducing the impact of trace elements on soil biodiversity. And then it continues, on soil biodiversity, including through the deleting evidence base, keeping use, and adding of innovative science-based approaches, and then deleting fungal biodiversity, so that it would read: "Capacity building activities on reducing the impact of trace elements on soil biodiversity, including through the use of innovative science-based approaches for soil restoration. And that would be perfectly fine with these changes to agree on paragraph 12 and lifting the brackets. And one more minor amendment in paragraph 13. Should I do it now? Or, okay, for the paragraph 13, on the third line from the bottom, on the fourth line from the bottom, after the word framework, we would like to add prioritizing data from national soil monitoring systems. So that would read, and integrated into the framework, prioritizing data from national soil monitoring systems, comma, and then it continues. With these amendments, we would be perfectly happy to agree to lift the brackets from the paragraph 11 to 14. Thank you, Chair.
Spasiba, Russian Federation. And we take note of the amendments. I will ask the Secretariat to repeat changes proposed by Russian Federation on paragraphs 12 and 13 in order to lift the brackets from para 11 to 14. Just a moment.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. So I will start from the fifth line of the paragraph 12, as suggested by the distinguished delegation from Russia Federation, of capacity building activities and reducing the impact of impacts of trace elements on soil biodiversity, including through the use of innovative science-based approaches for soil restoration, and it continues. For the paragraph 13, I will read the line, the third line from the bottom to the beginning. So it starts with "accessible, inoperable, and integrated into the framework, comma, prioritizing data from soil monitoring systems, comma, and to report on progress to the subsidiary body on scientific, technical, and technological advice, and it continues. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretariat. I hope it's clear. I see a request from Russian Federation, also from Panama and EU. I believe it's a precision of what the Secretariat said, so I will allow the Russian Federation to take the floor now.
Thank you very much, Chair, and thanks to the Secretariat. It's almost captured, but in paragraph 13, while we are speaking about prioritizing data from soil monitoring systems, the word national has been omitted. So it's prioritizing data from national soil monitoring systems. Thank you.
Thank you. So now it's clear. The amendment. So I look for reactions on this amendment on paragraphs 12 and 13 in order to leave the brackets from 11 to 14. I have Panama followed by EU and Switzerland.
Thank you, Chair. Paragraph 11, Panama believes that this is too specific a goal, in particular for FAO. So we want to avoid duplication, therefore propose the elimination of this paragraph, because we'd have a lot of work ahead of us in terms of goals. For paragraph 12, we don't agree with the reference to voluntary guidelines. set out in the document. And paragraph 13, we prefer to delete it and to keep paragraph 14.
Thank you.
Panama, could you repeat your comments on paragraph 12, please?
Yes, Chair. Thank you. On paragraph 12, we would like to delete the reference to relevant voluntary guidance in this paragraph. Thank you.
I thought we were moving forward well in terms of removing brackets, but then we're now asking to eliminate complete paragraphs. I'd like to hear more opinions before sharing my own. in order to facilitate negotiations in this group. European Union, followed by Switzerland and Colombia.
Thank you, Chair. First, I would like to point out that we are moving into cutting into clean text. The brackets that were put in sub-still were around all requests to the Secretariat because of the reference to the availability of resources. We know that all the requests are subject to the availability of resources, and therefore we consider this text clean. So we are moving into an area where other rules should be applying. In addition, I would like to point out that Removing pollution and replacing it with trace elements limits the scope of what paragraph 12 is dealing with. And we would also like to support retaining the reference to fungal biodiversity in this text, because this has been a neglected part of soil biodiversity, and therefore it is important to have it there to draw attention to the need to do more work. Thank you very much.
Thank you, but the manner we have is to entertain in paragraphs in brackets, and there are brackets around these paragraphs. So I do not necessarily have the same interpretation. Brackets are brackets. The reasons behind any bracket in the text could be from different nature. So just to see that I'm not departing from the rules, we agree. Yeah, I understand your comment on the trace elements and also the relationship on fungal biodiversity. Well, I will listen more because I'm giving details to you, and I should also give comments on Panama's comment. So, Switzerland, followed by Colombia and Bhutan, and then we go back again.
Thank you, Chair. I was also under the same understanding regarding the brackets that it was a decision on the resources and not on negotiating the text. As you say, brackets and brackets, then I would like to make it known that from our side, we can accept the addition by Russia, but I don't see a need for the deletions in the sense that trace elements are a component of pollution, but there's no need to, in my view, to delete pollution. And also the innovative approaches, we can agree with that, but not with the deletion of the fungal biodiversity. Thank you.
Thank you very much. I support to keep biodiversity and the comment on trace elements. Colombia, followed by Bhutan and Canada, and then I'll go back to all comments.
Thank you, Chair. Colombia would like to keep the paragraph as they are, but to be flexible, we could go along with Russia's proposal. Thank you.
Thank you, Columbia.
Thank you very much, Chair. We agree with you on retaining, I don't know, the word pollution, because the word pollution is It's, I don't know, under pollution comes so many other sources of pollution. So just mentioning trace element, that is being very specific. Now, if you want to mention trace element, I think it is also important to mention heavy metals, which is more harmful, I think. So pollution would be better, I think. And then retaining fungal biodiversity is also very important because it is an area which is No, not well studied, so important to maintain. Thank you.
Thank you. Canada.
Thank you, Chair. We agree with the EU on questioning the removal of pollution without a further explanation on why to include trace elements instead. Additionally, in paragraph 13, Canada feels the Executive Secretary should not be requested to develop methodologies, that this is not their role. But they can support and follow other bodies in doing this. We know developing and reporting on indicators under the CBD has been a heavy commitment from both the CBD Secretariat and Parties in relation to the KMGBF, so additional tasks that are more in line with other bodies should not be added under the CBD. So we would suggest removing the start of that sentence with the wording “further request the Executive Secretary, subject to the availability of resources, and…” Thanks.
Thank you, Canada. Iceland.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Iceland would like to retain.
All of the paragraphs, preferably in the original text, but at least I would like to echo the opinion of not deleting pollution and fungal biodiversity, since it is quite central here to keep that wording.
Thank you.
Thank you, Iceland. Iran, and let me make a proposal after Iran.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Iran is agree with the suggestions made by Russia. Only we are not agree to change pollution to trace elements. Moreover, our comment is on paragraph 12, which focuses on fungal biodiversity. As all parties are familiar, soil biodiversity includes different types of microorganisms, such as bacteria, fungi, protozoa, archaea, algae, and microarthropods. So these different kinds of microorganisms can be used for soil restoration. So Iran proposed to amend fungal biodiversity to microbial biodiversity, especially fungi. Moreover, also it could be used in preamble of the text, especially line, I think, in the paragraph 3 of, I think, preamble. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Iran. Let me share with you my views on this group of paragraphs. So it's been a request to delete paragraph 11 by Panama, and I have some interventions that want to keep this paragraph. So I ask for the flexibility of Panama to retain this paragraph so CBD can work with the FAO, and in particular, the value of this paragraph is the collaboration with the Commission on Genetic Resources and Pollinators. We have a strategy for pollinators in CBD, and the expectation is in a couple of weeks, the global platform pollinator will be launched. So this is part of the collaboration between FAO and CBD. It's been a 25 years of pollinator initiative, so this is perfectly in congruence with the collaboration with other organizations, so I believe it's good to retain this paragraph. So I ask Panama to be flexible on this, and actually we need to work and support one on pollinators. In paragraph 12, I see that with the amendments from Russia, maybe a way forward could be impacts on pollution, including trace elements, because it's a subset probably, could be acceptable to consider that formulation. Regarding fungi biodiversity, I understand this is an important biological group, but I don't know if we are only making reference to fungal biodiversity, only when we refer the use of them for soil restoration. So maybe, i believe, this part of the difficulties, so probably fungal biodiversity should be better placed somewhere, or when we consider soil diversity, including fungal biodiversity, and not only to leave it to the use for restoration. And fungi we have from also at the microbial level, but also at a microscopic level, so not necessarily we include all fungi, but we make reference on micro I know that was an intention to help. So maybe we should look for a better place where we make reference, so including fungi biodiversity. That would be my set of suggestions. And there's a reference on, there was some comment on the inclusion from Russia to paragraph 13, when we as Executive Secretary also in collaboration to give some priority to this information coming from national information systems. I think that's acceptable, but it is giving preference to parties' information. So those are my comments. I hope you agree with those. So I ask for flexibility to keep all paragraphs as currently amended, including my suggestion to mention pollution, including trace elements. So I'd like to hear your comments, starting with Panama, followed by Russian.
Federation and the EU.
Thank you, Chair. We can be flexible with paragraph 13 if we eliminate the indicators. For other paragraphs, we can't be flexible. Thank you.
Russian Federation, followed by EU.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you for your proposal. The way we understand it, we would actually propose it to be kind of the other way around. We understand that for a number of parties, the fungal biodiversity is a point that they would like to keep. Therefore, we would offer as a compromise to use the use of innovative science-based approaches for soil restoration, including, but not limited to, fungal biodiversity. We also do not really see the point of singling out fungal biodiversity, but if it's important to the parties, then we would be able to agree on that. As for pollution, sadly, I do not think that we can go for that. There is a separate discussion on pollution in the areas of further work. I believe it's quite contentious. If our goal is today at the plenary have a decision here on agriculture, which I believe we are very close to, is something very realistic. We would be happy to unbracket paragraphs 11, 13 with our amendment and I believe the amendment by Panama, and 14. However, if we do not come to a consensus on paragraph 12, we would like paragraph 12 alone to remain in brackets. Thank you.
Thank you, Rosal Federation. So I see that we can go along to innovative, I don't understand my own writing, approaches.
Science.
Yeah, including but not limited to fungal biodiversity. So I see many parties requesting to keep it. So this is a way to keep this element. Yeah, I see that. resolution including is not flying, and also to keep the amendments on paragraph 13. And okay, I'll be closer to the microphone. Excuse me, interpreters. Still the retention from Panama, I would ask you to.
We consider collaboration with FAO, which is key. We have a lot of decades working with the Committee on Biological Diversity, and we have this global pollinator initiative as well, and that's why that paragraph is here. It's very important joint work which has been going on for a long time now, with many initiatives. I think that's the status. And so I'd like to have more feedback from the parties. European Union, followed by Mexico and Panama.
Thank you, Chair. We can go along with the proposed compromise on paragraph 12. So we are happy also to support the use of innovative science-based approaches. This is definitely an improvement, and the proposed wording is fine with us. and we would like to definitely retain also paragraph 13 with a possible compromise wording as suggested by previous speakers. Thank you.
Thank you. EU, Mexico, followed by Panama.
Thank you, Chair. Perhaps to accommodate the concerns of Panama, We propose it at the end, considering that's mentioned on the joint work between CBD and the FAO. At the end, we would add:.
Existing initiatives and avoiding duplication of efforts.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you very much, Mexico, for proposing that wording. I hope it will be acceptable to the others.
Panama.
Thank you, Chair. I think the experience we've had in particular with delicate points did not give us good experience. Parties weren't able to report, so therefore we'd like to preserve our concern with any theme related to FAO. So we would continue to ask for this to be kept in brackets if there's no consensus. One paragraph. We thank Mexico for their efforts, but that's not acceptable to us. Thank you.
Microphone for Canada, please.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We would support your proposal on pollution, as the term "pollution" is a common term already in the KMGBF under target 7. Thank you.
Thank you, Canada. Any help? EU.
Thank you, Chair. I would like to point out that paragraph 11 is very important for us. We would not want to, we cannot support its deletion. Thank you. We would prefer to look for a compromise.
Thank you very much. Anybody else want to take the floor to help us to move forward. Let me have a consultation with the Secretariat. I have a request from Russian Federation, and I will propose a way forward for the last minutes we have available.
Thank you, Chair. I've consulted with our science team, and I've heard the concerns on pollution from some delegates. I believe heavy metals were mentioned. That might be an issue of linguistics or terminology. If those are not considered to be the same thing, or if there are slight differences, we could go with trace elements and heavy metals, if that solves the situation, because we really do believe that that would be the area of focus. Thank you.
Thank you very much. So it's a proposal to consider trace elements and heavy metals instead of pollution. And so immediately, you're asking for the floor.
Thank you very much. We would like to retain pollution. We can then add types of pollution, but heavy metals and trace elements are not the only types of pollution that are a really significant problem for soil. We have also pesticide, nutrient pollution. We have very different types of pollution.
Thank you. Russian Federation.
Thank you, Chair. As we have outlined, we do believe that that should be the priority focus. If we cannot agree on trace elements and heavy metals, we do kindly request paragraph 12 to be taken into brackets in its entirety. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Colleagues, I believe it's been a very long session on this document only, and we still have many pending paragraphs. I see that – I’d like to know if there is some progress on paragraph 3. I asked for some consultations. Is there anyone willing to report progress on paragraph 3? Russian Federation.
Thank you, Chair. We've consulted. I do not know whether we have come to an end consensus formulation. However, as a way forward, instead of mentioning climate specifically for reasons that we discussed, we have offered to make a reference to the KMGPF where there is a target on climate. So we think that would be pretty appropriate here. Thank you.
Thank you, Resolution Federation. So I'll ask EU, who want to keep climate, if consideration of the framework is enough to have consensus on this paragraph. EU.
Thank you, Chair. So this is indeed an agreement. So instead of listing climate among the policy instruments, we add after policy instruments in line with all relevant targets of the KMGBF.
Thank you for the flexibility of all, so we have a clean text. I will ask Secretary to read it, paragraph 3.
Thank you, Chair. So now the paragraph 3 reads: "Encouraged Parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national planning instruments in line with all targets of the KMGBF.
Thank you very much. Russian Federation.
Yes, just a clarification. I believe the proposal was in line with all relevant targets of the CMGBF, and also, as far as I remember, during the discussion, we have agreed on as appropriate and in accordance with national circumstances and legislation. Thank you.
Thank you for the precision. I'll ask once again, Secretariat, to read the paragraph.
Thank you, Chair. So now the paragraph reads, "Encourages parties to integrate the conservation, restoration, and sustainable use of soil biodiversity into their national planning instruments in line with all relevant targets of the KMGBF as appropriate and in accordance with national circumstances and legislations." Thank you.
Thank you very much. So, I hope this is acceptable. I don't see any objection, giving time to parties. So, we have clean agreed text on paragraph 3. Also in paragraph 4, we have pending issues on 6, 7, brackets in 11. by one party only. We have also brackets on 12. I'm not clear if we can have clean text by accepting the amendments by the Russian Federation on 13. I know there were some objections from Canada, but I look for some flexibility on 13. And my intention is to establish our Friends of the Chair to address these pending paragraphs. I don't think we're going to make substantial progress today in the few minutes we have, and maybe we can use a few minutes more to see agreed paragraphs on forests. I know there are some that maybe we can clean now and to continue and to close our deliberations of this afternoon. I have Brazil followed by Panama.
Gracias, señor Presidente. And thank you very much. We'd like to express our appreciation for the work today. And just reiterate our concerns that some delegations have asked to reopen the discussion on Paris 6 after we are under the impression and there were no objections at the moment to the text that was proposed. We feel that this does not take us forward on this resolution and other processes. And with regards to that particular subject of financial resources, it is unfortunate that we are not able to agree on text that is ipsi litteris from the Convention. Thank you very much. Gracias, señor Presidente.
Thank you, Brazil, for your concern. It's the second time that we agree a paragraph and it's been requested to go back after it was approved. And so I invite you to maintain a constructive spirit and equity. I mentioned this also in the Bureau from what happened yesterday. And now it’s the second time that we agree after I asked, “Do we have an agreement?” I saw no objections, and then we went back, even though a compromise was accepted. So, I have Panama.
Thank you, Chair. On paragraph 11, to try and find a consensus, we would recommend changing “requests” to “invites.” also include the recommendation suggested by Mexico at the end of the para. On paragraph 13, we would like to ask the Secretariat to read out the latest version with the comment suggestions made by Russia and Panama. Thank you.
Thank you, panama. I understand that suggestion to replace the word “requests” by “invites”. I see nodding.
With this and the inclusion from Mexico, we can leave the brackets there. Is this acceptable by parties? I don't see any objection. I'm waiting a little bit more. If that's the case, so we lift the brackets on paragraph 11. South Africa, come on.
And yes, sorry, Chair. So we are in favor, of course, of paragraph 11. We just wanted some bit of maybe operational or context clarity when you replace the request with the invitation, especially to the Executive Secretariat. How would that work? I don't know. I feel a little bit confused. Sorry, Chair.
Thank you, South Africa. I understand you mean because our Secretary of the work for us. So that's a very gentle way to ask somebody to do something that is under our authority, but the usual practice is to request things to the Executive Secretary. So under this explanation, maybe Panama, can we have some flexibility and go along my request? Because this is the usual way. Our Secretariat is ours.
Panama.
Thank you, Chair. I'd like to recall that our initial proposal was to delete paragraph. So we're already being sufficiently flexible in terms of changing some language in the paragraph. So if we invite the Secretariat. to carry out this activity, and that will be under activities which are already underway, as suggested by Mexico. Thank you.
Can we accept to request in a very kind way to our Secretariat by inviting them to move on and leave the brackets? Is there any opposition? I don’t see anyone. So, paragraph 11 is agreed without brackets and makes reference to the Secretary-General by inviting. Thank you. So, we have clean text on three, on four, still pending on six, seven. Now it's clean 11. On 12, Still pollution, right? And 13, I was asking if in 13 we can accept inclusion by Russia, just given this prioritization of national soil monitoring systems. So I asked for flexibility from Canada to accept this session. from Panama, also, what is giving preference to the use of, giving priority to national soil monitoring systems, that's a inclusion. And also, I believe it was, can you repeat, panama, what you asked in particular on paragraph 13, because we have mixed views in the Secretariat about your request.
Thank you, Chair. On 13, so we have other comments, but the proposal was to eliminate the reference to compatible indicators for conservation. That would be acceptable, but I understand that the Russian delegation has some different comments on that.
Thank you, Panama.
Develop national harmonized methodologies for conservation, and your request is only to delete incompatible indicators. That's Panama's suggestion. So I'm wondering if it's acceptable to delete incompatible indicators. I mean, methodologies can include it. I see Noring in the room. So I don't see any opposition to delete incompatible indicators, and with the inclusion of the language by Russian Federation on prioritization of prioritizing data from national soil monitoring systems, I think we have a clean text on paragraph 13. I don't see any objection, so We have clean text on paragraph 13, and the brackets are removed from 11 to 14. So, the Friends of the Chair that I would like to establish will be working on paragraph 12. paragraph 7 and paragraph 6. The Secretariat will later inform when will be the time and the room to work on this. I think we almost exhausted the time, so I was very ambitious in trying to see some progress on forests, but let me check there's any other pending matters so we can join our meeting. Just give me a sec. So with this, we finish the works of our group for today and for the week. I'm happy to see that we are sending some good number of documents for the plenary to be adopted tonight. And I remind you of the many contact groups that will be working on Sunday, and I invite you to keep informal consultations to come with solutions for our next session of the Working Group 2. So thank you very much. I wish you all the best for the weekend, and see you next week. So the meeting is adjourned.