Press Conference: Momentum on Target 18 and accelerating implementation, UN Convention on Biodiversity - COP 17 Conferences Date: 26 October 2026 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/en/asset/k1h/k1hio9n45z Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- Speaker 1 [0:00]: I'd be interested in your comments on how those commercial interests have influenced the negotiations here. Wageningen University [0:14]: So, Jelle Bargo from Wageningen University in the Netherlands. My question, I also talked to the press, so I also like to hear from you, is what do you think the CBD conference, or the COPs, can do to start changing this, this corporate destroyers of biodiversity. We see some parties trying to make reference, for example, to structural causes of biodiversity loss. I think almost all the decisions there are still bracketed. We see people try to talk about harmful subsidies, but it's a very political question. Yeah, I don't know. What guidance can you give us there? Moderator [1:02]: Okay, two, if you can be very quick, and then I'll give a very quick round of responses, but yeah. Speaker 4 [1:08]: Please. Yeah, so first of all, maybe I missed it, but I see the mining sector's not there. So why not? And secondly, corporate's great. When next are you gonna list the countries that are primary destroyers of biodiversity by country? Ecofeminist Latin American and Caribbean Network [1:28]: Maria Jose Lubertino from the Ecofeminist Latin American and Caribbean Network. My question is, there are good practices? There is a good legislation all over the world. Moderator [1:45]: Okay, I'm afraid we need to leave it there because we're actually really running out of time. I'll give a few very quick answers and I'll give a last round of responses of the whole panel. What has happened well and what can be done? Not a lot has happened well. What needs to be done is, and somebody also referred to it, we need to make sure that corporates are not in the room, that they are not the ones defining. We need to make sure that the CBD makes countries come together on defining regulation that cannot be undermined in one or another country, but it's binding in every country. And maybe some corporations are doing tiny things to make things better, but when we look at the overall impact, that's why we try to do these fact sheets to look at overall impact, and we see that each of the sectors has a huge impact and growing impact. So you can have a few beautiful measures, but that actually won't change it. We have a report of Friends of the Earth from a few years ago, the Nature of business, and it shows that business are interested in making profit in the first place, and that is their nature, and biodiversity comes a lot later. I want to just give everybody on the panel the chance to give a few last words, and then we will close this press conference. I'm really sorry for those who couldn't ask any more, and we will address questions later on still in the room. Please, Agun. Speaker 7 [3:11]: Yeah, maybe to answer all the question, maybe I have three answer. Maybe for the first, we must end the subsidies, incentive, and policies support that drive deforestation. I think it's the most important thing. The second, we need to require full transparency, traceability, and also the independent auditing across the biomass and pulp and paper sectors. for my issues, and I think the third is also we need to strengthen the rights of the indigenous people whose maybe the rights benefit must be to them, not for the country or etc. Thank you. Speaker 8 [4:04]: Yes, also to add to this, I think it's absolutely important that we protect this space to be not influenced by industry, no? And we are seeing increasing levels of corporate capture, as it was mentioned, the presence of executives from these same destroyers of biodiversity all around pushing for new, false solutions. The same people that progress here now want to bring up the so-called solutions to the problems they caused. And this has to do also with rules regarding dealing with conflicts of interest. We faced many issues here in this space in CBD, actually, when we follow symbiosis, synthetic biology. This year, we had to, from the civil society sector, question the fact that a so-called independent scientific study was commissioned to an organization that had clear conflicts of interest with business, interested in developing biotechnological products. So these are things that we need to guarantee so that the evidence that is produced here is really science-based and not corporate influence, no? And the real solutions are there. Now that you asked, when we talk about seeds and pesticides, humanity in these 10,000 years of agriculture has shown that it's absolutely possible to obtain and produce our food without these inputs that are destroying our biodiversity and health. And agroecology is clearly the way forward. Moderator [5:40]: Thank you very much, Markus. I was told I still have a couple of minutes, so maybe because I know you really wanted to ask a question, so we will give you a chance. Please go ahead. Speaker 10 [5:49]: Thank you. I just actually wanted to say what Markus just said, you know? Because when you talk about pesticides and these big corporations, it's not coming only with pesticides, it's coming with seeds. So, for example, Syngenta, ACI, they are all coming up with hybrid seed or now GMOs. So I think these two are so related. And the main important thing is, there are seeds. We in Bangladesh are collecting about 3,000 varieties of rice seeds in our collection. So it's possible. Moderator [6:28]: Thank you very much. And this indeed shows how everything is connected. I also wanted to briefly connect my response to the question on mining. Absolutely, very, very important. So as we have said, this is a very incipient campaign. We really want to and we will keep on growing this. We will have probably a whole set of fact sheets on different types of mining, because several types of mining have several types of impacts. We will have on infrastructure. We are looking into impacts of military action, etc., etc. So this is really a growing campaign. We have just brought together a few initial ideas to get this started. But absolutely, mining is in our top priority because we know how big the impact is. So thank you very much for raising that. And with that, I would now like to pass on the words to Jeff Conant so he can also give his last words. Thank you, Jeff. Speaker 12 [7:21]: I'll just try to speak quickly to a couple of the questions that came up. One, in terms of political influence. Here, I haven't been tracking that yet, but just to say we know that business and industrial front groups flood the COPs with influence. And just to cite one figure from the last COP, the UNFCCC, COP 30, there were over 300 agribusiness lobbyists there, which was bigger than even big country delegations, that's bigger than the Canadian delegation, for example, and that they had tremendous influence there. And just speaking from the agribusiness front, the companies that had the biggest delegations were Danone, Cargill, JBS. The biggest thing that has happened this week for biodiversity is the victory of President Lula in Brazil. Okay, so I just wanted to, to the question, what's good that's happened this week, that's it. Speaker 13 [8:25]: Yes, and on that point, again, the financial sector is also, of course, very present here. There's a lot of talk in the negotiations about how to mobilize private finance to help with biodiversity protection, but there's not enough talk about how to restrict harmful flows from private finance, and that needs far more attention. Both the global review and the assessment that we did on the financial regulations showed there's a huge gap, so we need financial regulators to step up and regulate finance that should go beyond Strong disclosure, which should be mandatory and should include double materiality, so not only reporting on how nature might impact finance, but also and especially on how finance impacts biodiversity, that is very crucial. It needs to be forbidden to finance biodiversity destruction, to finance any activity or sector that causes biodiversity destruction. And there should be strong regulations that make it possible to hold the financial sector accountable. Moderator [9:20]: Thank you very much. Thank you very much, Mirel. And with this, we close this side of this press conference. Thank you very much. We will be available for further comments in the corridors. And I understand there's a next press conference coming up. So thank you very much. Speaker 15 [10:38]: Two. Two, two. Two, two. Hey, yeah, yeah. Two, two. Hey, yeah, yeah, yeah. Hey, yeah. Yeah. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [21:39]: Hello, everyone. May I have your attention, please? Thank you so much. My name is Eva Zabbay. I'm the CEO of Business for Nature. It's a real pleasure to be with you today. I'm going to moderate today's press briefing. The purpose of this session is to discuss the exceptional momentum on Target 18 ahead of and during COP17, and what accelerated implementation of incentive reform might look like beyond COP. What we're going to do is panel one is going to be a selection of multilateral NGOs, business, and finance to provide different perspectives. And then we will have a second panel with the Presidency of Armenia represented, as well as the French Government. So first, we'll have brief statements from each of us, and then a quick Q&A, and we will pass promptly on to the second panel. Incentive reform is one of the most powerful levers to support natural infrastructure, and that's why there is this exceptional momentum at COP17. It's being realized and recognized, and the need for accelerated action on Target 18. This is also why, ahead of COP17, 130 businesses and financial institutions signed an open letter from Business for Nature and Finance for Biodiversity, calling on governments to work with business on reform. The breadth of these institutions behind accelerated initiative reform is shown here today, and it is exceptional. We have never seen this level of engagement before. The presidency has also showed this leadership. Great. So with this, we're each going to make very short statements, and then we'll open for questions. So without further ado, I'm now going to hand over to Patricia Fuller, who's the CEO of IIASD. Over to you. IISD · CEO [23:52]: Thank you, Eva. Reforming harmful subsidies and scaling up positive incentives provides a critical opportunity to ensure public resources support rather than undermine our environmental commitments. But success requires political leadership, sustained international collaboration, and practical support for governments. Today, iISD released a report analyzing countries' progress on Target 18. While there are significant gaps in both reporting and implementation, it does reveal a suite of emerging examples of countries stepping up to address this gap. And earlier today, we also had the launch of the Friends of Target 18 and the Yerevan BioFin Challenge as part of the Armenian Presidency Yerevan Call on Incentives Positive to Biodiversity. We had 17 ministers speaking at this event. We had two countries committing to join in what is now a formalized Friends of Target 18, and we expect more to join based on the expression of enthusiasm, as Eva has referenced, in the room today. Collaboration is key. What we need now is a platform to share. expertise, learn from one another, coordinate efforts across countries. And that is why ISD is helping countries work together to forge a shared pathway forward through the Friends of Target 18. Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [25:29]: Thank you so much, Patricia. Moving on to Jan-Erik Saugestad, who's the CEO of Stora Brand Asset Management. Over to you, Jan-Erik. Thank you. Storebrand Asset Management · CEO [25:40]: Thank you, Eva. When natural systems degrade, the impacts show up in portfolios through resource scarcity, supply chain disruptions, and increased volatility. This is not just an environmental issue. It's an economic and investment issue. Investors need clarity and predictability. Clear incentive reform plans help reduce uncertainty and support long-term investment decisions. Target 18. is an opportunity to better align public and private capital with long-term economic resilience. That is why 130 financial institutions and businesses, including Storebrand Asset Management, signed the open letter. We recognize that accelerated incentive reform is essential and most effective when governments, businesses, financial institutions, and beneficiaries design it together. Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [26:43]: Brilliant. Thank you, Jan-Erik. Moving swiftly on to Kumi Kitamura, who is the Deputy Director at OECD for the Environment. Over to you, Kumi. OECD · Deputy Director for the Environment [26:54]: Thank you. Much of the discussion on incentives focused on reforming harmful subsidies, but it's also equally about scaling up incentives that are positive and that support biodiversity. Positive incentives that are Those are those that make damaging activities more costly and that reward nature positive action. Taxes, for example, taxes on pollution, could also generate revenue that could be redirected towards biodiversity positive actions. And in other cases, positive incentives can involve redesigning harmful subsidies so that they can better support biodiversity and long-term economic objectives. OECD data shows that there are more than 900 biodiversity positive incentives in place already across more than 100 countries, demonstrating that governments do not need to start from scratch. There's already a lot of good experiences and best practices to share among them. Progress has been made, but that's not happening quickly enough. The evidence shows that well-designed incentives can help address biodiversity loss while supporting economic resilience. And the challenge now is to scale those that work. Thanks. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [28:22]: Thank you so much, Kumi. We're now going to hear from a company representative, Angela Pinhati, who's the Chief Sustainability Officer at Natura. Over to you, Angela. Thank you. Natura · Chief Sustainability Officer [28:33]: Thank you, Eva. As a company that works closely with producers and local communities, we see every day how much business depends on healthy natural systems. Many producers want to adopt practices that protect and restore nature, but they need the right conditions to do so. That's why incentive reform matters, and that's why Natura signed this open letter. Well-designed incentives can help reward stewardship, reduce risk, and support producers, rather than asking them to shoulder the costs alone. Targeting 18 is an opportunity to align public policy with the effort many producers and businesses are already making. The transition will only succeed if producers are rewarded for delivering both economic and nature outcomes. Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [29:34]: Thank you, Angela. Moving on to Patricia Zurita, Executive Director of Conservation International. CI · Executive Director [29:44]: Thank you, Eva. Biodiversity goals are too often undermined by well-intentioned subsidies that end up harming nature. Changing these can unlock progress on the rest of the global biodiversity framework and close the financing gap that we're seeing. The Presidency's leadership here has been and continues to be incredibly important and valuable. Every year, governments around the world are paying more than twice, first, to fund these activities, and then to fix the problems that unintentionally these subsidies are creating on natural systems and their economies. Conservation International has released a report that reveals that the hidden costs are between 11 and 24.7 trillions a year, somewhere between four and 12 times the values of the subsidies themselves. The message of this report is very simple: Governments can spend better. No more by reforming subsidies to get environmental results. This can be done while still supporting the people and the communities that subsidies are meant to benefit. Annually, an estimated between 2.1 and 2.7 trillion a year on subsidies that are harming nature, more than 10 times the $210 billion spent on protecting it. Redirecting this spending can have massive returns for nature and for people. Reforms must be collaborative. That's why we are gathered here today, between governments, private sector, and civil society, to show that only a collective commitment across sectors and stakeholders will be able to support the transformation that we need, and we need it now. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [31:34]: Thank you so much, Patricia. And finally, from this panel, and then I'll open for a few questions, Cassie Flynn, Director of the Planet Hub at UNDP. Over to you, Cassie. UNDP · Director, Planet Hub [31:45]: Thanks, Inga. The Year of Biodiversity Finance Challenge is the implementation platform for the call on positive incentives. Over 130 developing countries have already identified promising solutions to better integrate biodiversity into public financial management systems. They include the design and scale of positive incentives, repurposing of harmful subsidies, results-based budgeting for biodiversity, and budget tagging to track the government's contributions to biodiversity. The Yerevan Biodiversity Finance Challenge calls on these countries to implement their solutions. They can submit an expression of interest on UNDP's BioFin website to join. The challenge is also a call for partners to support them. The government of Germany is already providing 2 million US dollars for 10 countries through the NBSAP Accelerator Partnership. Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [32:46]: Thank you so much, Cassie. I know that was a bit of a lot of information, but we wanted to make sure there are a few minutes for questions from the floor. So yes, please go ahead. Do we have a mic? Sorry, what? If there's a mic for Orla. Oh, you can just ask? Okay. Can you speak up? Okay. No, we can't really hear you. Thank you. Carbon Brief · Journalist [33:18]: Hello. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [33:18]: Yes, much better. Thank you. Carbon Brief · Journalist [33:20]: Orla Dwyer from Carbon Brief. Thank you for that. There's obviously been a big push on tackling harmful subsidies at this COP, but we also know that Target 18 is one of the behind global report, and we know there's still a long way to meet the target. From your engagement with governments, are you confident that this push will have an effect? Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [33:46]: Can we get another mic, please? That would be really helpful. Thank you. And are we confident? Carbon Brief · Journalist [33:52]: I think it's back. Are you confident from your engagement with governments that more will be done after this COP to tackle harmful subsidies and particularly fossil fuel subsidies? Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [34:04]: Thank you so much. I can start by responding briefly on generally, we've really seen a very encouraging momentum in the discussions. There's been leadership by Colombia. It's the first time that there's been this recognition quite collectively, not only that Target 18 is such an essential target that underpins all the other targets and that it is one that is lagging behind. There's also alignment about the progress that needs to happen in phases from identifying to elimination, reforming, and then increasing the positive incentives. So I think that's something that it feels like there is more general agreement. Of course, governments themselves will need to tell you how far along they are, but I would say we've never seen this level of business and finance engagement, and with this commitment to work quickly at a national level so that the engagement is there and the willingness is there, and therefore we are very motivated, you know, feeling encouraged that there will be progress. Does anyone want to add very quickly to that? Yeah, one more, Patricia, and then we'll take some more questions. CI · Executive Director [35:10]: We have been piloting subsidy reform in four different countries, and we're seeing incredible momentum from the governments that have been engaged in countries like Colombia or Fiji, where we are seeing that our work is actually producing results for the government and the community. So I envision that because there are real examples, we are creating enough energy. Also, there are other examples in other countries where we have been seeing momentum. As an Ecuadorian, and not that we are involved in this, I can tell you that the Ecuadorian government made the very brave move of eliminating the subsidy to diesel. And that has gone. It happened. It was enacted. And it's one of the examples that other countries are starting to use so they can start keep moving the momentum of reforming subsidies. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [36:03]: Thank you, Patricia. Yes, so we have behind and then in the front. Carbon Pulse · Journalist [36:07]: Yeah, hi, I'm from Italy. How? Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [36:11]: Will you Sorry, please also say who you're directing the question to. That would be super helpful. Carbon Pulse · Journalist [36:16]: It's actually not a specific person. I mean, I would like to know how will you classify access at the end of the negotiation in terms of the I mean, for us journalists, how can we report that it will be a successful result at the end of the negotiation related to Target 18? Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [36:37]: Thank you so much. For us, we want to have the final decision reflect the fact we need to accelerate progress on Target 18. This is not about renegotiating the target. It's demonstrating, sending that political signal at a global level. CI · Executive Director [36:55]: I think there are a couple of other elements. The number of additional countries that are signing up to the Friends of Target 18 is a huge demonstration of the political momentum. And the declaration from the presidency, the declaration from the presidency has three items. One of them is subsidy reform. So we are seeing a strong political will to push Target 18 moving forward. And as Eva said, not renegotiated, but actually implemented. Carbon Pulse · Journalist [37:23]: How many states do you expect to be a good number of friends of Target 18? CI · Executive Director [37:32]: I mean, right now we have not only Colombia and Finland leading, but we heard from France, we heard from Guinea, we heard from multiple countries that are actually wanting to be part of it. So I would say we're creating the momentum. Hopefully, we will get to more than 10. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [37:50]: Thank you. One last question, please, in the front. IPS · Journalist [37:54]: Thank you. Hi, this is Stella Paul from Interpreter Service, IPS News. I guess I heard some statistics, some numbers here from Patricia, from Kumi, and from Cassie. So I guess those, these three people would be my, the primary people, but then anybody else can maybe jump in. So it's wonderful to hear all this about all these reports and, you know, this very hopeful picture, these numbers. But we are talking about 11 to $14 trillion here, right? So I just wanted to honestly ask you, at the current pace, how many years or what are the chance that we will be there where we want to be in another four years that's remaining? And also, how long will it take us to actually make the shift at the current pace? Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [39:00]: Yes, please, Cassie. And then Kumi, did you want to come in? UNDP · Director, Planet Hub [39:04]: Thank you so much for that question. And I think what, you're getting at something that's really important, which is, the conversation around subsidies is also a conversation about efficiency. It's about how can you help finance. efficient across an economy. And when you start having that type of conversation, something we've really seen at UNDP, and we've had about 100 countries go through a first analytical stage where you're starting to look at efficiencies and subsidies. And what that has done is not only sort of opened up the conversation about harmful subsidies, but also opened up where are the opportunities that can be had by redirecting those financial flows. And so, kind of getting at this, we're seeing a really promising start, and we have to do more, we have to do it faster. And I think that as countries are looking at each other, and today when some countries were presenting about the friends of Target 18, you saw a lot of countries starting to learn from each other about the opportunity that is in addressing this. It's not just a conversation strictly about how do we eliminate harmful subsidies, but how do we open up opportunities for an economy. OECD · Deputy Director for the Environment [40:15]: A really quick one to add. We've been hearing a lot from finance ministries and treasuries from around the world that many governments are in very, very fiscal tight place right now. So in many case, you know, if you even don't talk about environmental goals, many governments can no longer afford to continue to have any spending that's inefficient. And that happens to also be harmful. So I think there's a lot of momentum, as we've already heard today. And I'm personally hopeful that there's this momentum and things will move faster for another reason as well, fiscal. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [40:52]: Fantastic. Thank you so much. I would like-- oh, sorry. Yes, Patricia? Patricia Quigley. IISD · CEO [41:00]: Just to say that certainly the pace does need to accelerate. We were seeing very good momentum in all of the governments who spoke to their intentions and commitment to reform harmful subsidies. And there is certainly a fiscal imperative to do so, as well as a nature imperative. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [41:24]: Great, thank you so much. I'm going to thank the panellists. Patricia, you stay, but all the others, please take your seats. I'm going to invite Her Excellency Barbara Pompili, Ambassador for the Environment, Government of France. Now, what is a real shame is that we were looking forward to welcoming the Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Trade from the Government of Armenia, representing the COP16 presidency. Of course, we would have really welcomed, and he sends his apologies. This is a last-minute change. So apologies for that. So welcome and thank you so much, Ambassador, for being with us. Would you like to kindly share some remarks on this agenda? And then we'll take some more questions from the floor. Thank you for your flexibility and understanding, everyone. France · Ambassador for the Environment [42:13]: Thank you. Thank you, and no worries, because I think this topic is very important. Very important, and that's why I'm very happy to be here with you today, and because we are convinced that Target 18 is critical to achieving the KMGBF. And as reducing armed food subsidies have three positive impacts. First, alleviating ecosystem pressures. Second, redirecting funds to biodiversity, and easing public financing. So even if she's not here, I really thank the Armenian presidency for making Target 18 a priority at COP. I would also like to thank Colombia and Finland, as well ISD for the initiative of the friends of Target 18, and it will be a great pleasure for us to join this initiative in France, so we'll join it. We also support, as France, the Year of Biodiversity Finance Challenge, as we have been a long supporter of BioFin. France has been the first country to start identifying harmful subsidies as early as 2020 through our green budget, and it is not time to move forward, and therefore, I have the honor to announce the launch of France's plan to prioritize their reduction. This policy for us is an example of cross-government platform, as it is co-led by three administration, the Prime Minister Service for Ecological Planning, and the Ministry for Ecological Transition, of course, but also the Ministry of Finance. And we think that it is very important, as it was mentioned earlier, to break silos in order to integrate biodiversity everywhere. Biodiversity has to be integrated in our economic strategy, and that's why we think that reorient harmful subsidy is a first step to succeed in doing that. Speaker 53 [44:33]: Thank you. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [44:34]: Thank you so much, Ambassador. Any questions? More questions from the floor? Yes, please, in the front. Oh, wait, there's a microphone coming. Thank you. Speaker 55 [44:46]: Yeah, I was wondering if you had the list of the countries that are part of the Friends of Target 18. If you had the list of the countries part of Target 18. IISD · CEO [44:59]: So the co-chairs of the formalized Friends of Target 18 that was launched today are Colombia and Finland. We had in the launch event, France and Malawi announced their intention to join. We are now in the process of opening a formal procedure for countries to join this initiative. We have had a number of countries participating in the informal Friends of Target 18, which has existed for some time now, so we expect those countries to become formal members. And as I said earlier, we had 17 ministers speak today at the event expressing their interest and intention. and commitment to reforming environmentally harmful subsidies. So we're optimistic that this momentum will result in a substantial group of countries that will be the friends of Target 18 to sustain this momentum. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [46:06]: Thank you. Yes, one there and then one at the back, please. Carbon Pulse · Journalist [46:12]: Thank you. Tom Cox, Carbon Pulse. I wanted to ask, what is the most important concrete thing you'd like to see achieved as a result of the negotiated outcomes at COP17 on subsidies? Do you want me to repeat the question? Can you hear me? Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [46:30]: We can hear you. I think she's just repeating. What's the single... Repeat it. Would you mind repeating once? Just as from COP17. Carbon Pulse · Journalist [46:40]: What is the most important thing you'd like to see achieved at COP17 on the negotiated outcomes for harmful subsidies? France · Ambassador for the Environment [47:00]: The most important for me is to have some political commitments, because I think it's only with political will that we will move. You know, we have very technical discussions on a lot of topics in this Biodiversity COP. It is important. But if we want to enlarge the basis of those who will act, we need to get out of our biodiversity bubble. And that's why some topics, as harmful subsidies, are important, because we integrate in the discussion other actors that are never usually there in the discussions. And for me, the commitments we are taking are involving, for example, in France, Minister of Finance, which was invested before, but will have to lead the discussions. With other actors, we always think about farmers because farmers are very important actors, but also industries, but also energy providers, and they will be actor of the biodiversity action. And that's why my answer is clearly an answer of political vision and not only of technical discussions. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [48:28]: Thank you so much. There was one at the back, yes, thank you. AFP · Journalist [48:31]: Hello, Nick Perry from AFP. A question for the ambassador. It's somewhat similar, but this Friends of Target 18 is, you're saying it's a positive development. It's obviously also outside the negotiations. It's a coalition outside the formal talks. Is the atmosphere in the rooms, in the negotiation rooms, as positive? Could you give us a sense of how you see the negotiations so far? Has there been enough progress? Are countries moving fast enough? And would you like to see a bit more urgency? France · Ambassador for the Environment [49:10]: It is not the point of this conference, but what I can say is that we are at the middle of the COP. I had the opportunity to attend a lot of COPs, and at the middle, it's always the same thing. We have very difficult discussion, some obstructions, some countries who say that they don't want to move, and at the end, often we find solutions on a lot of topics. So I am quite positive. I think there are interesting discussions on some topics, including financial aspects, which is a good signal. But we know also that sometimes there are some actors want to block and use our consensus system to block. So we will see what will happen in the coming days. I hope that everybody will do their best to find solution, and I'm sure they will do. But if not, maybe we should learn from that to move on for the next steps. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [50:23]: Thank you so much. I can take one more question, if anyone has. Ola, yes? I think you're, Ola, back to you. Thank you. Carbon Brief · Journalist [50:35]: Thank you. Just a quick one, maybe for Patricia. What do countries have to commit to to join the Friends group? Is there any minimum amount of incentives they have to say that they would reform, or what do they have to do to sign up? IISD · CEO [50:54]: The process that begins now is defining a work program, and that will be under the leadership of the co-chairs, Colombia and Finland. At present, this has been a commitment to undertake the contents of what is in the KMTBF framework and in Target 18. And as we move forward with this Friends Group, the parties who are members of this, and this will be a party-driven process, will further define how this initiative will develop. Business for Nature · CEO; Moderator [51:33]: Fantastic. Thank you so much, all of you. I hope you see the level of interest, engagement in the corridors and inside and outside of the negotiation rooms. We feel like that's been a good space to evolve some of these difficult conversations. We'll close the press briefing now, but all the speakers, including from the first panel, will be available if you have any follow-ups. Thank you so much for joining.