7th meeting, 33rd Session of the Committee of Experts on International Cooperation in Tax Matters Meetings & Events Date: 23 October 2026 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/en/asset/k1h/k1hobwnqww Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [0:00]: Good morning, everybody. I hope you all had a good night. We will resume the discussions today with item 3K, tax and gender. So the basis for our discussions will be the co-coordinator's report. It's CRP 22. So the committee will be invited to provide comments and guidance on the detailed outlines of the five papers presented. which is first, an overview of taxation and gender. Second, tax policy and the informal economy from a gender perspective. Three, a toolkit for incorporating a gender perspective into the work of tax administrations. Four, the role of tax data in informing policies with a gender perspective. And finally, the paper on gender and international taxation. So I will now invite our co-coordinators, Geneva Bangura and Kapemba Nambuyamba Sikomba, to present the coordinators report. Please go ahead. UN Tax Committee · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:04]: Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Co-Chair. So good morning to everyone. This is the last day. We'll try to keep it brief. As you know, we presented papers in the 31st and 32nd session relating to tax and gender. In the last session, the work plan for the tax and gender subcommittee was approved, as indicated by the co-chair. And so now we and we had a few meetings in between the 32nd session and this session, and that has resulted in the outlines that have been presented to you. And so. We are seeking your guidance on the outlines that have been transmitted. And our presentation will begin with the agenda, a brief background on the work done, although I believe the chair of the committee has already presented that. And then we'll go into the proposed outlines of each of the papers and go into the session where we get your feedback. Next slide. The five papers were, the work plan to do the five papers was approved at the 32nd session. And we are hoping that between this session and the 37th session, we will bring all the papers for first reading, second reading, and final approval by the 37th session in October in 2028. Next slide. The five papers will form a series. They're basically standalone, but we're hoping to give context to the whole conversation surrounding tax and gender, starting with an overview. and then looking into specifically in line with our mandate, looking at tax, gender, and informality, and then trying to provide a toolkit for tax administrations in terms of governance, workforce compliance, and taxpayer services. And then a key topic, one that's quite close to my heart, is the gender data for tax administrations and looking into tax and gender. looking into why data matters to gender equality, existing data and methods relating to capturing metrics and statistics relating to gender. Also, how international tax rules and cooperation shape gender equality. I think that's one that's key to this committees to sort of tie it into the core messages that we have that come out of the UN Tax Committee. Next slide. The first paper specifically will have four main sections. And in the introduction, why gender and inequality matter for tax policy and tax policy matters, the first part will look into the tax system and how this should be seen as a key part of holistic fiscal policy that can foster gender equality. The next part of the introduction will talk about how taxation affects men and women differently because of the differences in work, in income, in ownership, and in consumption of assets and consumption of goods and services. The last part of the introduction will talk about tax design. And. How tax design the shape of incentives and it shapes the incentives to work and how people invest and how they save and how these can either ease or reinforce the barriers or obstacles faced by women. The next part, the next section of the overview paper, sorry, back to the previous slide, Sylvia, will talk about the gender gaps in tax policy, and it will talk about gender gaps in labor and income indicators, and how this is really the basis of the work and how it links to the gender concept. And then the third part of the paper will present a conceptual framework talk about progressivity of the tax system and how this can be linked more clearly to gender and income gaps. And then the next part of the conceptual framework will talk about taxation as one of the key levers in the broader policy toolkit and how it can be worked to address gender inequalities. Next slide. Similarly, taxation and the informal economy from a gender perspective, we'll look at informality and tax in gender, like how informal workers are concentrated in lower income services and how the concentration of women are also found in these segments. And they already make fiscal substantial contributions, but these are not accounted for when we are thinking about contributions to taxation and more importantly, when we're thinking about incentives or reliefs from taxation. And women in the informal economy will speak about how women make up the majority of informal workers in many regions, and they are often doing the lowest or zero income earning activities. And then we look at the design of tax around the informal economy. In many of our economies in developing countries, there is a narrative to say that there's too much informality and we need to tax the informal sector more. But when we think about this from a gender perspective, effectively we are saying that we should tax women more. because they make up the majority, according to statistics, of the people in the informal economy. So we really want to highlight this and bring it into more national dialogue so that even as we pursue domestic revenue mobilization activities, we can think about them in terms of their impact and who they will be impacting and not just generating more revenue for national programs. We'll look at how tax policy may have gendered outcomes, which we've spoken to already, and then how tax administration may have gendered outcomes. And we'll examine the three dimensions, selective enforcement that occurs, face-to-face collection, and digital reform, and how all of these can carry distinct risks as well as distinct opportunities for women in the informal economy if we make our policies more consciously. And then there'll be some practical recommendations for tax systems, looking at tax policy processes, It proposes focusing on high earners within the informal economy, setting thresholds that are not too low, replacing flat taxes with graduated structures, and reducing reliance on trading licenses and market fees. In terms of tax administration, trying to make all of our nations look at tax administration from a more gender sensitive lens using better data, which is why we have the paper on data, and also thinking about how to engage all taxpayers, big and small, in a fair and equitable manner. I think my colleague will proceed from the next slide. I hand over to Madam Jeneba Bangura. Thank you. Sierra Leone · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee; Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs [9:32]: Thank you very much. So the third paper will focus on gender and tax administration toolkit framework. And basically, the emphasis will be on providing concrete, actionable guidance to improve women's interactions within and outside tax administrations, rather than providing a self-assessment tool. So to get that done, we have three parts to this framework. The first part will talk about the background and the rationale for that. And to accomplish that, tax administrations shape gender equality through institutional practice and taxpayer interactions, not only on tax through law and policy. Also, women have limited representation at executive level positions in tax administration, and I can attest to that because I have experienced that. Women in the informal sector face differential enforcement measures and compliance burdens. The second part to this paper will talk about, look at the objectives and the guiding principles. And basically, it aims to embed gender consideration across governance, workforce, compliance, and services, guided by evidence-based equal standards principles that remain practical and scalable. And the final part of this paper will actually be the toolkit framework, which basically is structured, the toolkit will be structured around four pillars. Institutional governance and gender mainstreaming, recruitment, career advancement and workforce management, gender analysis of compliance risk and audit processes, and finally, gender responsive taxpayer services and relations. Next slide, please. The fourth paper will focus on data and gender guidance. So to accomplish that, we have multiple parts to this. So the first part is the importance of sex disaggregated data. This sets out why gender data matters for tax policy and stresses the importance of a strong and effective data system, interoperable with other sources, to enable more equitable, progressive collection. The second part to this paper will focus on what data exists, right? Because we found out that, you know, we have very limited data when it comes to gender in the tax world. So what we plan to do is to review, right, tax administration survey and private or scanner data, and then the methodology confidentiality challenges in estimating tax data by sex. Third part to this will be, of course, the research method, using data for policy analysis. And this will cover specific methods to use tax data, including static incidence analysis and micro simulation to assess gender tax impacts. Also, the part will focus there's a part that will focus on capacity needs of revenue authorities. This will highlight the capacity building required for data collection, curation, analysis, and communication, and the balance between transparency and fiscal secrecy. We have a part that will focus on opportunities for data collection and use, which will identify on the use data and ways to strengthen the exchange between tax authorities, statistical offices, and other registries, plus new collection venues. Finally, this paper will focus, there will be a part that will talk about the topics for the future, right, which will flag the promises and risk of interoperability, digital guardrails, and gender biases in AI systems used for tax collection and administration. Next, please. The final paper will focus on international tax and gender equality. And there are three parts to this paper. We will start with an introduction. And the introduction will explore how international taxation can be analyzed from a gender perspective, which will focus on the role of international taxation and the tax rules in shaping gender outcomes and how a gender perspective can be incorporated into international tax cooperation. It will also highlight the tax evasion, avoidance, and illicit financial flows, how that erodes the fiscal space to gender-responsive public services. The second part to this paper will actually delve into the international tax for gender equality, such as looking at the corporate income tax. And by doing that, we'll focus on how strengthening the international framework to improve the system's progressivity and redistributive capacity, taxation of individuals, the gender dimension of wealth taxation and remote work, and then finally, international tax administration that has to do with cooperation, information exchange, and capacity to counter illicit financial flows. Finally, and in conclusion, there's a part that talks about what will present policy recommendations on international tax cooperation, illicit financial flows, and good practices linking international and domestic tax and gender policy. Next slide, please. So what we bring, what the subcommittee brings to the committee is for you to provide comments and guidance on the detailed outlines of the five papers that we propose to the general body this morning. Thank you very much for your audience. Before I go, we both want to say thank you, first of all, to all the other committee members that are part of this subcommittee present here today, and the other stakeholders that are either in the room and/or online following us. And then most importantly, we want to say a big thank you to Lorenzo and Cecilia, who is not with us, and the secretariat for the support that they have been giving us throughout this process. But I want to come back to, I erred yesterday during my presentation during the AI and tax. We forgot to say thank you to Lorenzo and Luis for the support that you have been giving us. So I guess it's never too late to correct your error. So I do that right now. Thank you very much. UN Tax Committee · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [17:27]: And would also just like to mention and thank our subcommittee members who are in the room today. I believe Elisangela is one of our drafters. She's actually helping to draft the gender and international tax paper. And Laura from ODI is sitting at the back. And so hopefully, if any questions come that are too complicated for us, we'll hand you over to the experts. Thank you, Chair. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [17:56]: Thank you, Janiba and Kapemba, for presenting this paper and highlighting and giving attention to considerations to be taken into account when designing good tax policy, but also in tax administration and beyond. So I invite you, committee members, stakeholders, observers, to provide comments on the very comprehensive outlines we have received. Enrique, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [18:35]: Thank you, Trudy. I tremendous support on this topic, so I commend Bangura, Lorenzo, Akapengwa, Angela, and the entirety of the team involved in the work. I just wanted to make a specific comment. on part one of the document, section four, policy implications, and the use of a comprehensive approach to different types of taxes. I know that they mentioned an income tax on individuals and also the tax on capitals, not speaking of gender or generic concepts of taxes. Perhaps you already have included it there, but I would like for there to be a specific mention of taxes on inheritance and property. I had the opportunity upon reviewing the topic to see a CIAT article, the Inter-American Center for Tax Matters, and that article addressed the gender approach and the rationale, the technical rationale. And there in the article, they mentioned numerous examples of countries in the Americas in Africa and in Asia as well. It says that in many of those countries, women are denied the right to own and inherit property. Or in other cases, there's preferential policies for certain individuals when it comes to land and houses and even family businesses as well, since some get preferential tax treatment. Further, I had occasion to look at an NGO document. I think the name was Ayuda en Accion, Help in Action, and there was mention made of countries in which women can only inherit from their parents if they're single or if they have ended up -- have become single. And women are only land owners or property owners through men in some cases, through family members, men, of course. Now, in other cases, they cannot, women cannot inherit land or property. In other countries, they can only inherit a certain percentage of the property. much less than the percentage that men can inherit. So, as a result of that, I think it's important that we do include in this topic specifically the matter of taxes on inheritance and property. And Angora had mentioned that this topic seeks to address all. areas of tax administration or oversight, and thus the importance of looking at the design, what goes into the design of this type of tax, for example, inheritance and property, and how this can contribute to gender inequality in the design phase. So also, I think that this matter is also specifically related to, well, in the UNGA meeting, In 2015, there was a specific goal mentioned in the SDGs. And that SDG refers to gender equality and the empowerment of women. And among the sub-goals in that SDG was that of undertaking reform, for example, the design of this type of tax that would give women equality in economic rights. And it mentions specifically the issue of inheritance. So I think that all of that gives this greater weight and importance when it comes to mentioning that area specifically in part one, section four, again, inheritance and property. Now lastly, two data points in Mexico, if you look at the 21 richest in Mexico, 17 are men. A Mexican newspaper that is very powerful in tax matters, when it began to speak of wealth tax, they called it the tax on the patriarchy. That makes clear the message of how things, because that's the comment I wanted to make. Thank you kindly. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [24:13]: Thank you, Enrique. Guidry, please. UN Tax Committee · Member, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [24:22]: Thank you very much. Co-Chair, thank you very much. First of all, to co-coordinators for putting together this really, really ambitious and very important work plan. As I have participated in the subcommittee, I will not take all the space here. And I have already given my comments, which were very taken into account. So thank you very much for that. Perhaps just for fellow experts and observers, I wanted to highlight one general thing about which we discussed is concerning part five about international taxation and gender equality, which for me personally is one of the most challenging issues here, completely relevant. but very difficult to prove, because obviously the indirect impact of tax law on gender positions in the society must be proved empirically. And the research on that point is very lacking, and also data is very lacking. So there is a link, obviously, with the data part of the paper. And just to shout out, if anyone works on this project on international on international tax law and its impact on gender, socioeconomic conditions, how this affects how international financial flows, BEPS or corporate tax planning affect gender, that would be very, very important for the subcommittee. And just one more thing, because I have never raised it actually in the subcommittee because I did not think about it, but I just Um, I read a research about Colombia, uh, concerning the gender desegregated data that actually it, um, it could be sometimes misleading because, uh, the research done by one World Bank economist and, um, I think a Colombian economist showed that even though women are in the much lower percent, uh, percentile of, um, income. income, so poorer part on that part. They are surprisingly important owners of wealth, and that might also represent tax planning, intra-household tax planning. So perhaps this is something which we should also take into account, to what extent this data reflects the women's real ownership of assets. Yeah, so those were my points and congratulations once again and good luck with the further work. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [27:05]: Thank you. Claudia, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [27:11]: Good morning, everyone. And first I would like to congratulate the co-coordinators and the members of the subcommittee for the comprehensive and ambitious work plan. The proposed papers cover the issue from multiple complementary perspective and provide a useful framework for policymakers and tax administrations. The focus on practical guidance and implementation challenge in developing countries in particularly valuable. One aspect that I would like to put for consideration of the subcommittee is that the paper provides an important discussion of the potential gendered burdens associated with taxation of the informal economy. But at the same time, it may be helpful to present a more balanced view of formalization. In many developing countries, moving into the formal economy can also provide important benefits for women entrepreneurs, including improved access to finance, government support programs, legal protection, and social protection mechanism. A discussion of both the cost and the potential benefits of formalization could improve the analysis and help policymakers design reform that promote inclusion while minimizing unnecessary burden. But overall, I fully support the subcommittee's work and believe this paper will make an important contribution to helping policymakers design more inclusive and effective approach for taxation. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [28:58]: Thank you. Darlington, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [29:03]: Thank you, co-chair. Good morning, colleagues. Good morning, co-coordinators. And thank you for the level of work done on this very important topic. I think personally for me, tax and gender as it relates to women is every time I listen to it, I'm very passionate about it. Because most times, like you mentioned, even though sometimes I wonder that we are redefining gender, I mean, Because we are also gender, and gender. I mean, let's not forget that we are male too, we are gender. But the joker side, I think is a very good piece of work. Just one consideration in part four that we'd like to point out. I know you mentioned the sources of data, particularly property registries, but I would like for you to please consider that data also has a whole of government approach, especially when there are several tiers of government. So data can also be found in other tiers of government. So I see that we have not mentioned that in part four, but I think it would be very good to mention that data, the sources of data, as well as other departments of government, and data, the source of data as well. Secondly, I will also think that the issue of data governance and data management is also key. The integrity of data, most times, data from tax administration from our experience is still lacks integrity. So I think that if some consideration should be given to data governance, data management, the integrity of data, especially coming from tax administration and coming from other sources of government, they are key. Just for an example, In our region, we are still saying that intra-regional trade still hovers around 13%, but most of that data does not reflect the fact that women actively participate in cross-border trade and they make up a huge percentage of cross-border trade. Statistics also show that intra-regional trade, especially across our region in Africa, has reached about 40-45%, but because of the lack of data, or because the current data lacks integrity, we are still reporting around 13, 15%. So I would think that consideration should be given to the integrity of data and how data is managed and how data is governed. But again, congratulations, and I thank you for this great piece of work, and I look forward to the further development of this paper. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [32:37]: Thank you. Shanice, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [32:43]: Like my colleagues before me, I want to commend the subcommittee for the comprehensive guidance paper, in particular the emphasis on the practical guidance and how it is going to respond to priorities and challenges of developing nations. I would like to highlight just two points. Firstly, What I think would be a very helpful inclusion in either the first or second, um, sections as the case may be, is the importance of the country context and political economy. which will impact gender. As we know and as the report indicated, the effectiveness of any gender responsive tax reform depends not only on the technical design, but also on the country's economic and political structure. And so it is important that those factors be clearly articulated in the guidance itself, it is important that the subcommittee ensures that the guidance gives practical consideration to how these factors can impact and influence the actions and implementation and design of any reform. So I do believe it is important to state that explicitly and to develop it somewhere in the earlier phases of the paper and ensure that any developing nation that is intending to use these guidance papers have those ideas in mind. Secondly, I want to emphasize the importance of building the capacity within the tax administration. The toolkit is very practical and it's adaptable, which is wonderful because that means tax administrations with different resource constraints and different amounts of data will be able to implement it according to their particular circumstances. But we also want administrations to be able to assess what their current status is It is, I think, very helpful for the toolkit to be used to indicate where you are as at this moment, so you can determine what your needs are, what your goals are, and what you will need in order to actually be able to manifest whatever the desire of the tax administration is. So I do think the guidance paper would be helpful if there's a part somewhere that will allow a tax administration to be able to assess what gaps exist in its compliance processes, what gaps exist in its audit practices, which may create unintended gender disparities. If you can identify those, at least I think the tax administration would be one step closer to being able to fix these gaps or these issues in their processes that create gender disparities. Overall, however, I think it is an excellent paper and I think it's a very good starting point for any developing country to be able to remove a lot of the disparity that exists due to gender, and I look forward to the work of the committee and support in any way I can. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [35:47]: Thank you. Angie, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [35:52]: Thank you, Chair. I would like to thank the subcommittee for their very ambitious and well-structured work plan. I think you've done a very good job. I appreciate the effort to develop practical guidance that can be useful for the policymakers and tax administrations with a specific focus for developing countries. Although we can say on part three, the gender and tax administration toolkit, I think it's also still the case in some developed countries that women still have limited representation at an executive level. So I think we can all benefit from this exercise. I think the practical orientation of that proposed toolkit is very interesting. And I think it will help us to integrate the gender considerations into day-to-day the work of the tax administration. So I want to thank you for your work and good luck with the further work. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [36:52]: Thank you. Mary, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [36:56]: Thank you, Chair. First, I would like to congratulate to the subcommittee, especially our colleagues and secretariat and all the members for the outcome of the policy paper. I jump into the specific one on the part three regarding the promoting of the gender in the tax administration. In case for us, I think that for the successful of encourage the woman in the tax administration, It could be come from the SDG and then turn it into action of the government strategy as well as into the lower level of the tax administration. And for us, we have experience on that. We have developed, let's say for us, I think maybe not too late, we have two term of the woman enforcement. promotion and become to the leader in our tax administration. So in case the any requirement for us to share or to present to the subcommittee on the experience that we have, I think I willing to do so as I'm one also the one who charge in this issue and this what I can have for the subcommittee. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [38:26]: Thank you very much. Sierra Leone, please. Sierra Leone [38:36]: Thank you, co-chair. Sierra Leone thanks the coordinators and subcommittees of tax and gender for the preparation of this wonderful document. We welcome the proposed five guidance papers and commend the committee's effort to integrate gender equality into tax policy and administration. For Sierra Leone and other developing countries, this work is particularly important. Domestic revenue mobilization is essential to financing national development priorities, strengthening public services, and advancing the sustainable development goals. However, effective revenue mobilization must go hand in hand with fairness, inclusiveness, and the sensitivity to different economic circumstances of women and men. We wish to highlight three priorities for the committee's consideration. First, gender responsive taxation should promote equitable revenue mobilization and women's economic empowerment. In Sierra Leone, informal economic activity and small scale enterprises are important sources of livelihood. We therefore encourage practical guidance on simplified tax regimes, appropriate tax thresholds, and the cumulative burden of taxes fees, and levies, particularly for low-income women traders and micro businesses. Formalization should also deliver tangible benefits, including improved access to social protection, public services, and finance and business development opportunities. Revenue mobilization and women's economic empowerment should be mutually reinforcing objectives. Second, tax administrations need practical tools and reliable data. We support the proposed gender responsive tax administrative toolkit and guidance on sex disaggregated data. This should help countries identify disparities in taxpayer services, compliance cost, enforcement practices, and women's representation in tax administration leadership. For Sierra Leone and other resource constrained countries, the guidance should prioritize affordable and practical measures, including accessible tax education, simplified procedures, transparent collection practices, and effective complaint mechanisms. We also encourage the progressive development of reliable data on women's economic participation, business ownership, and access to formal, while ensuring appropriate safeguards for taxpayer confidentiality. And thirdly, international operation, international tax operation must protect developing countries' revenue bases. We welcome the proposed work on international taxation and gender equality. Tax avoidance, illicit financial flows, and challenges in taxing multinational enterprises and the HNWIs can limit the resources available for essential public services and development. Sierra Leone emphasizes the importance of strengthening developing countries capacity to protect their taxing rights, improve international tax information exchange, and evaluate tax incentive against their actual economic and social benefit. A fairer international tax system can expand fiscal space, strengthen domestic resource mobilization, and support greater gender equality. Co-Chair, we encourage the subcommittee to ensure that the five guidance papers are coherent, practical and responsive to the circumstances of developing countries, particularly when it comes to least developing countries like mine. The recommendations reflect country experience, realistic implementation capacities and measurable indicators, allowing countries to adapt them to their national context. Sierra Leone supports the continued development of this guidance paper and looks forward to their consideration at the Committee's 34th session. I thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [42:45]: Thank you. India, please. India [42:51]: Thank you, Chair. Thank you to the Subcommittee for the most important work that is necessary amongst all subcommittees, in my personal opinion at least. Congratulations on a solid work plan for the time ahead. On behalf of India, just three questions that I wanted to ask. One is when you mentioned gender gap, I was wondering if you are going to calculate gender gap vis-a-vis different countries, or is it going to be a conceptual introduction to what gender gap means? And if you're going to calculate gender gap, then how -- what is the data basis which you will be calculating that? And are you going to foresee any cultural differences in how that data may be presented? I would like to take my previous speakers point on this as well, that data integrity, what are the steps that we might be taking to ensure that, especially for calculation of something as numerical as gender gap, if the plan is that it should be numerical. The second thing is that, do you expect tax administrations to contribute data points on any any of the aspects that you will be covering in the report? And if so, what is the manner in which you expect tax administrations to contribute? Will it be in some sort of a survey? Is it voluntary? India, for example, we don't have a gendered policy for tax administration. So we always struggle in terms of showcasing our data points vis-a-vis what is expected from international organizations. So in that manner, how do you see tax administration's participation in the work ahead? Are you also looking at gender-based exemption or gender-based tax policies that would provide benefits to women in general, are you looking at policies like that that administrations may have implemented? And would you be coming out with some sort of analysis on any of these regimes? These are the three questions. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [45:14]: Thank you. We now return to committee members. John, please. UN Tax Committee · Member; Co-Coordinator, Ad Hoc Group on Dispute Avoidance and Resolution [45:24]: Thank you, Trudey. Also to voice my support for this important work. I appreciate the dedication and it really is something where we can, there's really big room for improvement both in developing countries and developed countries. We're all fighting the same battle in different situations, of course, and thank you, Madam Core Coordinators and the whole tax subcommittee for your appreciated work on this important matter. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [46:01]: Thank you. Amon. UN Tax Committee · Member [46:07]: Thank you very much, co-chair. I'd just like to start by thanking Janneke and Kat Wemba for their leadership of the work, and in particular to the support that was given by Lorenzo and Cecilia. I also want to recognise the really valuable contribution that was made by non-committee participants in the sub-committee. I think that we have Laura and Elisangela present here today. I think that this is a great initial document from the sub-committee. I think that the different areas covered are good. The overview is very comprehensive. The informal economy aspect is really interesting, and I would like to come back to that in just a moment. On the toolkit in relation to tax administration, I was interested in what Shanice had to say. I think that the text on the tax administration aspects sets a very high bar at the moment, because it is very comprehensive. aspirational possibly will be too strong a word but I think it's setting a very high standard but it is broken down ultimately into a sort of a progression, a process of maturation so to speak of administration in this respect and going from level one to level four and I certainly think that administrations that reach level four will have reached a very high standard indeed but I think There are numerous references throughout part 3 to practicality. I think that a focus on, number one, the diagnostic aspect that Chenise mentioned, but also trying to emphasise right throughout the whole maturity cycle, so to speak, practical steps that can be taken. I think that that would be good, to balance the high standard, the high bar that's being set with achievable progress, so to speak, tangible elements of progress. And I think a vital aspect in that regard is the Um, the tone set from the top, so to speak, if, if there isn't the really explicit, uh, leadership from the top on this, on this issue, it, it won't take hold in the way it might otherwise do. I think that topics 4 and 5 are the most challenging in terms of the paper. Data will continue to be particularly challenging, and it is great that the report is setting out the means of grappling with that issue and the various sources that could be used, including private sector data on consumption patterns and so on. That will be a really challenging aspect. In relation to international taxation, I think the big challenge there is in recognising the indirect effects of policies and indeed the direct effects on gender equality. It would be hard to resist the temptation to steer into addressing the actual international tax policies themselves. So I think if you can try and maintain as strong a focus as possible on the direct and indirect links in that part, that would be really good. But I think there are various aspects there that are points that are well made. But if I can come back for a moment to the second part of the paper, which has to do with tax policy the informal economy, this is the part that I found most striking in terms of what has been produced to date. Partly, it is because of the counterintuitive, which is not perhaps the best word to try to convey that sense, whereby there is a very strong case being made in the paper for thinking long and hard about formalisation and registration in respect of the informal economy. The informal economy can represent a very high percentage in some countries, and it is not simply the overrepresentation of women in that sector. On top of that, the almost oppressive cumulative burden of different charges on participants in that sector, which in turn then leads to a gendered burden, so to speak. And so I was particularly interested in Claudia's remarks on this part of the paper because, to me, It is the most, sorry, innovative again is the wrong word, but it has the potential to, as a UN document being issued, it has the potential to really challenge what would be the administrative orthodoxy, so to speak, that we need registration, we need formalisation, we need to bring people into the system. One aspect of that is that the evidence base is quite regional, or indeed sub-regional, so to speak. It currently reflects the experience in a number of countries. I think I consider it really important, I think, because it challenges an orthodoxy and if it's correct, it has, I think, a really, really important message in terms of gender equality and effectively oppressive circumstances for women, say, operating in markets where they're the most visible operators and they're subject to targeting both from official operators, from a subnational level and from various additional charges that cumulatively are particularly difficult. If we want to be successful in delivering that message, we have to test ourselves in relation to the evidence base. It would be really important to try to engage and deal with the counterview that Claudia has expressed, that at minimum we need to set out the pros and cons. It is the part of the overall paper that I think is potentially the most valuable in the short term in terms of influencing policy. To have that effect, it has to be very robust. We have to challenge ourselves to engage strongly with the alternative views and see balance what results ultimately. I commend the work in the paper, and I particularly appreciate the non-committee participants who have offered such valuable inputs to the work on this subject. Thank you very much, Madam Co-Chair. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [54:45]: Thank you. Van Gera, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [54:52]: Thank you, Madam Co-Chair. Thank you to the subcommittee for the presentation and for the work done so far. I agree with the presentation highlighting that the drive shouldn't simply be to tax the informal sector because of the disproportionate effects that that would have, and the paper adopting the approach of applying a holistic approach to different kinds of taxes. and also guiding countries that they should measure the impact that a tax would have so that they can make informed policy decisions. I think that would be a good approach to have. Specifically on the informal sector, I think it would also be important to guide countries on how revenue which originates from that sector should go back to supporting that sector in terms of infrastructure and other socioeconomic benefits, because there are challenges that are unique to them. So as much as we may be looking to tax them or make them more visible, I think it would also be very important to support that economy and address some of the challenges that they face in conducting their business. I also support the direction of adapting different tax measures to different countries because one size would not fit all. I think all of us, as much as we may be developing or developed countries, there are unique circumstances to each, and I think policy measures need to be adaptable. So it would be good for the papers also to follow up on that strategy. And the outline has also addressed issues like simplicity of tax measures. and focusing on the less visible but high earning players in the informal sector. And I do think that's a good consideration to include in the papers. So I support the work of the subcommittee and I look forward to discussing the papers. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [56:47]: Thank you. Alice Angela, you are in the back there somewhere. Drafter, Gender and International Tax Paper [56:55]: Thank you, Chair. And Just to make a short point on this paper, I, of course, support this work, as I'm a part of it. This has been a long time coming, and it will be, I think, groundbreaking to have UN guidance for tax administration specifically on how to address gender. This paper will bring the practical application. It has a very practical essence to it, because the topic of gender equality, as much as we all agree on its importance, we know that in most of our countries it is still a hurdle. There's still a lot of convincing that has to be done. So it's not enough to have research and have right on this. We will still have to go back to our tax administrations and buy in interest and convince our leaders that the gender agenda is not charity, it's not kindness. This is real economic impact. Women are not, in some cases, more than half of the population and more than half of those in the informal and formal economy. So this is a revenue conversation. So besides the work that we're doing in the research and in writing about it, I'd like to point out the importance of a mindset change, capacity building, and stakeholder buy-in. at the national levels that this will call for after the guidance is ready. I also wanted to emphasise what others have already mentioned. I think the key aspect of this work is data disaggregation. It starts there, and it starts there for the different sections of the paper. For the international tax and gender section, for instance, the question is there, is how do we establish these direct and indirect links, as Iman has said. We know the links are there, so the challenge is really to make them visible. and show that this is not a frivolous agenda item. This is relevant for policy decision making. And actually, ideally, the gender and tax correlation should not come as a mitigating, risk mitigating factor. So at the end of the line thinking, oh, how have we left women out of this conversation or how have we not accounted for revenue generated by women or impacted that impacts women? It's the ideal scenario is that these policies are thought of from the beginning, bearing in mind that they might have an impact on women or they might have a an unequal and unfair impact. So, this would be the ideal outcome of this work, the way I see it. And so, and we see this in some of the discussions we've had, for instance, It is not only a positive policy approach in the sense of what governments should have in place in order to prevent the unequal effect on women of tax policies, but there is also another side to it, which is about the harmful tax practices and their impact. on women disproportionately on men. They are harmful for everybody, but is there a correlation on gender? Can we establish a correlation between illicit financial flows and gender specifically? Is there a correlation between tax evasion and an impact on social protection of women? So Those are the -- that's what we're hoping to establish. And I think, as I said at the beginning, it will be key to have a UN communication or guidance and as practical as it can be to talk about these aspects so that we can have support, factual and data-backed support to show our, you know, our leaders that, as I said, This is not a marginal agenda item. This is central revenue, economic policy, fiscal policy that has to be accounted for. So these are just my my some of my thoughts. And thank you for all the comments and and guidance. We've taken them down and then thank you for the co-coordinators for guiding us through this and to Lorenzo as well. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:02:52]: Thank you very much. I am looking around the room to see if we have missed any speakers. No, there's someone in the back. And who will that be? Well, we see an observer in the back. Could you go ahead and please present yourself? ODI / IFS · Observer; Contributor to Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:03:17]: Hello. Yeah. Yeah, my name is Laura Abramovsky. I'm from ODI and the Institute for Fiscal Studies based in London, and I trying to contribute to these subcommittees work and thank the co-coordinators and the members for their leadership and Lawrence and Cecilia as well. I want to just reflect on, like, taking a step back from all these discussions. A very important consideration throughout our work must be what are we trying to achieve in general. closing which specific gaps between women and men, what are the drivers of these gaps, say, like low productivity, micro enterprises that cannot grow and earn a decent income level. So what is the best way to address that problem, for example? And sometimes the best way is not through specific taxes, but through other type of policies. And that's what we talk about, holistic approach to tax and spending policies. That is important to consider the barriers that are, or the drivers of these differences between women and men in terms of their income outcomes or well-being and how best to address those. I think that that would be quite key throughout the different papers, and links to different points that people have been making. For example, low-income women might be charged a fee to go to the toilet in a market, which Maybe they pay more fees because men don't need to go to the toilet as much as women do for many reasons, biological and even like safety reasons and so fine, they pay more fees and what is the solution to that? It's not at the national level, so we've been talking about revenue authorities and tax administration and that we shouldn't be imposing say, presumptive taxes on these very low income earners and I totally agree, such a bad policy and we should reflect on that in our guidance, but then we have to be mindful of what are we trying to achieve and how best to achieve it. So If they don't pay a fee, they won't have a toilet, and then we have other issues, which are important and we care, but like, is it, how do we think about it? Is it through taxes at the national level or subnational level, or is it about other type of policies. And I think it's really important to bear that in mind and to be quite specific about what are we trying to achieve, what are the issues for women, and how much tax administration can do for solving these issues and how much we have to delegate or think about through other policy levers. And I think, for example, again, insurance, taxation and insurance in many countries, particularly not high income countries, low income earners have a type of work that is like very, they don't have a continuous employment with a big employer that is formal and pays social security contributions in such a sustained way that they then access social insurance. And in African countries, many African countries, they don't even have much of a social insurance system. So again, some observers and people and members have highlighted the importance of considering the context and the country and the institutions. And I think that's exactly right. Like in some type of workers, they may have an opportunity and it's good to encourage formalization and for them to access insurance and that will work better for certain workers, women or men, and certain type of country. So, and then going to illicit flows and social protection and insurance and the link, I think it's quite an indirect link and the evidence, so Angela, I think you said like it's important to have the evidence to link that. Unfortunately, it's very difficult to establish a causal link between illicit flows and social protection access by low-income women in low-income households. It's really like empirically, methodologically, conceptually very difficult to establish, and so maybe it's not like we should care about social protection and insurance for poor households and low-income women, but maybe then don't link it to illicit flows directly, just focus on how can we curb illicit flows in general, increase revenues, and then think about other policies in different ways. So I think it's something we will continue to discuss and will be, I think, important for all of us to to reflect and consider in the papers and as much as we can. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:09:19]: Thank you very much. Now I see no further requests for the floor. So I think we've had quite a rich discussion and a lot of enthusiasm about this project and comments pointing to the role that tax policy can play in promoting tax gender equality more broadly. With respect to formalizing informal economies, I think inputs have brought nuances to that discussion that is important to look into and explore further. A lot of enthusiasm for the toolkit for tax administrations. and the gender approach. And also finally data, lots of input both with respect to sources of data, ensuring integrity of data and in this project basing analysis and conclusions, recommendations also on what can be evidence in the data available. So, and some specific questions that I hope that you will be able to to respond to. So, Kopembo and Geneba, any comments you might have? UN Tax Committee · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:10:49]: Thank you very much, Madam Co-Chair, and thank you for the rich and lively participation in this discussion. It's extremely encouraging, especially Darlington and Gian's reminder that gender is not just about women, which is why I really like the interventions that talked about women empowerment, because maybe that's a little bit more. But it would probably look like an unfair statement to put across the book, women empowerment from the UN. So Darlingstone, unfortunately, we have to stick to gender equality. And Jihan, thank you for reminding us that the challenges we're facing in Angie are not. Strictly developing country challenges, and we hope that we'll then get more participation from all across the membership in this room, because it's a global challenge that we're facing. So I think to go into the question specifically, we really appreciate Enrique's points relating to inheritance and property tax, highlighting the fundamental issues and the legal issues that hamper women's participation in society and in the economy. And I think as much as possible, we'll see how we can narrow that down and bring it to the tax aspect. because some of the issues like were said for other papers extend beyond taxation. They go towards deeper societal and cultural practices that appear now in law. And so I think as a subcommittee, we'll definitely take it into account, but bearing in mind the limitations of our particular topic. I love the point about the richest, 17 richest women in Mexico, and I think it leads. To the point that Giedri made about inter-household tax planning that comes about where women empowerment can be used as an avenue of tax planning. And I think you also, from the robustness of the discussion from among our own drafters, Giedri is in the subcommittee, Laura is in the committee, you see that there's definite rigor that will be brought to the table, and it speaks to the fact that women are quite balanced. And no matter what we do, we'll try to ensure fairness. And speak to the fact that even as we're talking about women and empowerment and recognizing the statistics that say that most, many people at in the lowest income are female. We we recognize that a lot of strides have been made to have participation and inclusibility and asset ownership by women across the sector and so even as we design the tax policies, I think in paper one, we'll be will be very careful to ensure that even as we are encouraging more participation and inclusivity and access by women, we're not then opening up lacunas and loopholes for tax planning. Thank you for the reminder. And Claudia, on formalization, I think Laura has spoken to that and how indeed we'll have to ensure the balance and bring out the discussion about the merits of formalization and also the challenges of overcoming informality. And I think Matthew often quotes the Bible. The Bible says that the poor will always be among us. So I think informality will never totally be eradicated, but rightly, perhaps other measures should be taken, I think, as was said by Laura, to address some of the issues that lead to unfair, perhaps, tax treatment of women. And then Shanice spoke to the issue of practical guidance. And I think in our. Formulation of the paper, we were quite privileged because we had some input from the OECD and ATAF. I think the lead drafter for our paper is actually from ATAF, and they've developed a diagnostic toolkit on, on tax and gender that's being rolled out at least across Africa. I think Sierra Leone is one of the countries, um, implementing this. So in terms of tax diagnostic, quite a rigorous work has been done and I think it was published last. year between 2024 and 2025, the OECD can guide me. So I think we will rely heavily on the work that's already been done and reference it a lot, perhaps pull it into the paper as you've guided. But we thought in our paper to move a step beyond that and go to the very aspirational fourth level where it's not only internally an identification of the problem, but also seeing the influence that the tax authority can have on other institutions and all the wonderful things that can happen when, as Elisangela said, we consider tax and gender as a foundational issue because as we try to improve humanity, we can't improve humanity and leave 50%, 60% of the population behind. And so I think we love the support for the tax administration paper, and we'll look to making it as complete as possible without repeating or duplicating work that will still be relevant at the time of publication. I think Sierra Leone, we thank you for your support and your emphasis on the flexibility of the work and adaptability so that countries can then pull and pick and locate themselves in the whole tax and gender conversation in order to build and go to the highest level that we can all attain in terms of tax and gender. Eamon, thank you so much for your comments. And really, the issue of the biggest challenge of the paper to the informality, we'll definitely ensure to make that work as rigorous as we can. With regards to the questions from India, I hope Laura took note of them. And since it's in the originating paper, I would love to ask Laura to speak to the three specific questions that we received from our excellent delegate from India. And I'll hand over to you. I can remind you of the questions if I find them. But yes. Sierra Leone · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee; Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs [1:17:37]: The data. The data. Data integrity. UN Tax Committee · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:17:43]: Yeah. Lorenzo, please remind us of the questions. Thank you. UN Secretariat · Secretariat staff [1:17:49]: Yeah, so, India can correct me, but the first question was about how we measure gender gaps. And so I'm sure Laura can also mention that, but it's mainly like economic indicators from the World Bank and ILO. The second question was about whether we are going to request help from member states, and that's, I think, something that we can answer. And I think the third one was. About whether we are going to include, like, concrete policy analysis or concrete policy tools on specific taxes, but. That one, I wasn't sure that was exactly the question. And then I think the rest the answer is yes but I'm sure Laura Geneva and can also complement those were the three questions. But India can correct of course. UN Tax Committee · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:18:42]: Um Laura please take the flow. ODI / IFS · Observer; Contributor to Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:18:45]: Yeah so I as I understand it I think um the first question as well related to a conceptual definition of the gaps. And I think it's a very good question, which gaps are we speaking about and how then we capture in which data can measure these gaps in a comparable way across countries, accounting for many idiosyncrasies that sometimes stylized data may mask. And I think We are going to focus on quite specific gaps that relate to interacting with taxes, such as participation in the labour market, and labour market outcome gaps, such as whether women work or not, if they work, how many hours, if how much they are paid, and that results in income gaps. There are many other drivers of these gaps, one of which is time use, which I think is the key driver of many of the gaps between men and women throughout their lives. It impacts how much they can access many different how they participate in society. But like I think we'll try to capture the data sets and analyze the data sets. Lorenzo mentioned and maybe there is new data on time use and work outcomes that is out there that we will try to reflect and summarize and how they vary with income levels and regions and discuss why they may be important for thinking of tax policy design and implementation of different tax types. Sometimes they will mediate how taxes affect women and men differently, but doesn't mean that we have to design taxes in a gender responsive or accounting for gender at all. And sometimes there are explicit Discriminations in tax laws, for example, like women cannot be the file taxes in some countries. I think Morocco still the case, but maybe not anymore. And that's discrimination is very important to highlight. Or for example, personal income taxation on earnings, including national insurance contributions, sometimes have the type of the policy design in a way that discourage in second earners of a household to participate in the labor market, have a paid job. That, for example, we try to reflect this really an important aspect, and there is evidence and policy lessons in terms of how you design personal income taxes, national insurance contributions, et cetera. So I don't know if I answered the question, but yeah. Sierra Leone · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee; Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs [1:22:17]: I would just like to add. So in addition, thank you very much, Laura, for that contribution. So we are also happy, really, for your inputs, right, from other countries. So if you have any data that you can share with us, you know, we are welcome to look into that. UN Tax Committee · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee [1:22:45]: Yeah, I think that answered your question of do you want tax administrations to contribute to the work? Absolutely. Absolutely. If you have case studies, as you can see, we have very rigorous economists and analysts working with us. And so even if you bring in your questions and your data, perhaps we can work with you. As you know, we have about two more years till our designated target. delivery date in October 2028. And so if if things come up over the next two years, we would be very grateful and and interested to explore them with each and every member that's here. Thank you. Sierra Leone · Co-Coordinator, Tax and Gender Subcommittee; Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs [1:23:31]: Thank you again, everyone, for your comments. And we'll take everything under consideration and we'll bring it back to the subcommittee. And Neri, you did mention that you do have a case study. We welcome that. You know, you can share that with us. So thank you, everyone. And back over to you, Co-Chair. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:23:50]: Thank you very much to Kapemba and you, Genevra and Lorenzo, for this presentation. And thanks to you all for this rich discussion. We will now move to the next agenda item on dispute avoidance and resolution. And while the co-coordinator is preparing and coming up to the podium, I might also take the opportunity to say that we have rearranged the agenda a little bit so that we will move the item on the capacity building until after the lunch break and after the dispute Avoidance and resolution. We will move to other matters, the provisional agenda and arrangements for adopting the report of the Committee on its 33rd session after the coffee break, followed by a closed meeting for Committee members right before lunch. And also, A reminder that your input to the tax and gender work is welcome. The deadline is 6th of November. So we are just giving John a little bit of a moment to set up here. Whenever you're ready. Dispute Avoidance and Resolution. The basis for the item is the coordinator's report CRP19. The report is submitted for information, and the committee is invited to take note of it. John, please go ahead. UN Tax Committee · Member; Co-Coordinator, Ad Hoc Group on Dispute Avoidance and Resolution [1:25:43]: Thank you very much, Trudie. So hello to everybody. Before I start my report, there's a couple things I wanted to say. The first thing is I wanted to welcome the... I wanted to say a warm good morning to the French-speaking students who've been with us for a couple of days now. I hope it's not going too quickly for you to follow carefully. Students from a tax camp who you can you can do like swimming camp, tennis camp, or this tax camp and that's their choice and they've been following us two days. I also want to say hi to everybody who's watching online. I hope you you're enjoying season three of the UNTC. I hope it's as good as the previous seasons and hopefully you can make it physically to the next meetings. Another preliminary comment I wanted to make is the selfie we made at our cocktail, I sent to Michael Leonard and he responded to me and he wants me to send all of you his best regards. So best regards from Michael Leonard. And then in very good news, I also want to mention that for those of you who know ICC colleague, Louisa, she had a baby boy on 21st of October. His name is Elio, and mother and baby are doing very well, and she also sends her best regards, and I am sure she is not watching the stream right now. But she can watch on replay. So anyway. And then I feel quite honored to follow the previous co-coordinators, as maybe not all of you know that Geneba has recently been promoted Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of Sierra Leone. So good for you. So let's get to our slides. Thank you, Sylvia. First, I'd like to also thank Farid, who's the focal point for the UN Secretariat, who's back in New York. And thank you, Farid, for all the work. One of them is putting these slides together. So what does the ad hoc group on dispute avoidance and resolution, what's our mandate, as a quick reminder? It's a monitoring group. So it's not a subcommittee per se. It's an ad hoc group, even though we have enough people in it now to make a subcommittee. But we would only upgrade if we find the need to do that. At this point, what are we monitoring? We are monitoring developments in dispute avoidance and resolution. We also are monitoring feedback from capacity development activities. We also have the job to liaise with other relevant subcommittees as appropriate to ensure coherence across the committee's outputs. And we report to the committee at each session, which I am doing right now. Next slide, please. So we met on the 20th of May. We've had two -- 20th of May is one. We've had two virtual meetings to review recent developments in international tax dispute, prevention, resolution, and to identify matters requiring continued monitoring by the group. Next slide. The second meeting was on 15 September 2026, where we continued those discussions and in particular, substantively, what are we following? We're following work stream three work on dispute prevention resolution at the International Negotiating Committee of the UN, linked to the UN Tax Framework Convention. which this committee meets three times a year until 2027 when the work should be completed. We have the developments under pillar two of the OECD G20, IAF inclusive framework on base erosion and profit shifting. And the LIE is part of our tasks. There's the work of the subcommittee on indirect taxes. I think we've covered that already mostly in our discussion yesterday on indirect taxes. And then finally, there's the feedback received from recent capacity development activities regarding dispute prevention and resolution. So regarding work stream three, there's the fifth session of the INC in August, from the 13th of August 2026, we discussed a co-leads draft, the protocol on prevention and resolution of tax that was based on the virtual discussions that had happened between our previous meeting during the spring. And then after those discussions, all countries also sent written inputs. And this will be continued to be discussed at the sixth session in Nairobi in December. There's nine days of total discussions. Two will be relative to work stream three. Next slide, please. So what are the key elements? For those who aren't following, just very brief recap of the key elements. of work stream three, there's two big, of course, two big chapters, the dispute prevention and dispute resolution. In the dispute prevention chapter, the different mechanisms that are in the draft now are APAs, advanced rulings, coordinated unilateral APAs, cooperative compliance arrangements, and simultaneous tax audits, and joint audits. So those are the different options or the different mechanisms that are being discussed regarding dispute prevention before the dispute happens, or to avoid disputes to happen. And then in the other chapter, it's dispute resolution, so you can go to the next slide. Chapter three are dispute resolution mechanisms. So you have mutual agreement procedures, which is the typical dispute resolution mechanism of a double tax treaty. You have mediation and conciliation, and then you have arbitration, which is another dispute resolution mechanism. You can go to the next slide. Other key aspects of our key articles of the draft are reservations. It's chapter five. You have article 5.1, which is reservations to specific mechanisms. I guess here the whole goal is to try to provide flexibility to this tool. It is seen as a list of tools and not something where if you sign in, you're agreeing to every single mechanism that's on the list, so countries will be able to choose from the menu what suits them best, and they don't need to take on board every single mechanism. However, at this point, the draft provides for one core mechanism for prevention and one core mechanism for dispute resolution, which means those two, if you sign on to the treaty, will be mandatory. So that's still under discussion on which one is the core mechanism. Regarding dispute resolution, I think it's pretty clear that the core mechanism will be mutual agreement procedure. So what are the scenarios where that would apply? Well, it could apply in situations where there's no tax treaty. It could apply in situations where there is a treaty or a multilateral convention that doesn't have a dispute resolution mechanism that you could add it to that. And then it could also, these mechanisms could apply to situation where there is already a full-fledged tax treaty. For instance, maybe some of the dispute prevention mechanism that probably wouldn't be, aren't in a typical model tax treaty. Another important article is article 5.2 of the co-leads draft. And there there's different options on how this protocol would apply in relations to existing tax treaties, or existing treaties. So you have option A and option B in situations where you have substantially similar instruments. So one One option, I think it's option A, says we'll just, everything that is existing doesn't change. And then the other option was option B would be that more of an approach where the, what's ever in the work stream three would supersede what's already in the existing tax treaties. So that's something that's being discussed. One important thing to mention that as the whole structure, I mean, If you think of the whole structure of the work of the UN framework convention, you would have a kind of a high principle document, the framework convention, and then you'd have detailed protocols with more precise obligations. So this would be protocol two, protocol one is on services. To be able to sign up to a protocol, you have to have signed up to the UN -- the general high-level framework convention. So, you can't just like choose this protocol if you haven't signed up to the UN framework convention. I think that's what I have for work stream three. Maybe we can go to the next slide. So, another work that we're monitoring, this is more on the OECD side, and there it's Working Party 1, which is the working party of the OECD that works in tax treaties, that are one of their tasks and current work is developing a coordination mechanism for the application of sets of domestic legislation implementing the global minimum tax. So the difficulty here, of course, is there's no substantive material provisions to arbitrate a dispute or a problem because from purely a vocabulary point of view, it's not dispute resolution, but the OECD has decided to call it coordination mechanism, even though it's, at the end of the day, resolving disputes. But It is more of two domestic laws applying in a way that's not satisfactory. So there's not the double taxation side, or violating a tax treaty side that you have in a dispute related to a tax treaty. So the mechanism would establish a taxpayer initiated process, enabling competent authorities to discuss and consult together. with a view of resolving specific questions on the application of the respective sets of qualified domestic legislation. So this, of course, is in pillar two. It's about the global minimum tax. We're not talking here about assessing if a certain country's pillar two domestic provisions are qualified. That means they meet the standards of the guidance that has been agreed upon. That's, there's a peer review process that's separate for this. This is really when you have problems between two or more countries, which could happen pretty easily to have more countries than two in big groups. When the taxpayer is unhappy or finds that there's an overly burdened tax solution when you add up the taxes paid in every single country. So some people could say, well, this is quite soft. You just, you just, you just, the only thing this would do is push people to consult with no obligation. Reality is most mutual agreement procedures are the same. You, you're, you're, you don't have any obligation unless you have an arbitration clause. And that's the great advantage of arbitration is there's tax security and you, the taxpayer knows that there'll be no double taxation at the end of the day. But in a normal mutual agreement procedure, you just have to endeavor to find a solution, but there's no obligation. And if you really can't come to, if you can't agree to the final solution, then you agree to disagree. So, but what's interesting is in the mutual agreement procedures, even with that structure, if you look at the statistics, there's a very high rate of solving the cases. There's very little cases, it's very low percentage of cases that end up where people agree to maintain the double taxation. So that's encouraging and encouraging also for a process like here. So even if you're just obligating yourself to consult, it still means there might be some tangible results at the end of the day. Working Party 1's objective is to finalize the work on the core features of the mechanism and its scope in 2027. And If I've said anything wrong or if you have any further questions, Jessica and Lee are here from the OECD who are leading this work. And you're welcome to say something or welcome to ask questions when I'm done. We can go to the next slide. So regarding the liaising, there's the subcommittee on indirect taxes. Well, as we mentioned yesterday, the work stream three of the VAT is on cross-border VAT dispute prevention and resolution. And it's at the domestic and international level. It's specific to the VAT world. We saw there's not much overlap with direct taxes. And as yesterday was mentioned, the importance of prevention in that situation. So we'll continue to be in contact with this ad hoc group and the subcommittee. Of course, at the end of the day, it makes much more sense that you'll have a specific guidance solely on VAT. It wouldn't make sense to add that guidance or to have that in the handbook and dispute resolution, which would be a little more lost. It's better to have it in everything, on all the documentation on VAT, since it's very particular to the VAT world. We can go to the next slide. Feedback from capacity development activities, that's the last one of our tasks. There was a, I'll be brief here because we're going to have capacity building later on. There's a regional workshop on the practical application of the mutual agreement procedure map that brought together tax officials from 30 African countries. And then there was a global workshop on APAs, 30 countries across Africa, Asia, Pacific, Europe, Latin America, and the Caribbean where came to those. And what feedback did we get back, you can go to the next slide. So the feedback from capacity development activities highlighted the practical value of the UN guidance and dispute prevention resolution. So everybody who worked on that handbook that was completed, I guess now eight years ago, time flies, but something or maybe five years ago. That's something that's very useful and we're happy to hear that. Participants particularly valued the sharing of country experiences and opportunities to apply the Committee's guidance to practical situations. And then I think one thing that's quite interesting is that participants suggested complementing the existing APA guidance with additional practical tools, including examples of domestic tax provisions and model templates to assist tax. administrations in negotiating concluding APAs. So I think that's important feedback. Now, APAs is a work stream that is in the transfer pricing committee, and there's an agenda, it's in the timeline. But what's interesting here is the feedback from developing countries is the same as the feedback we have from businesses. If you remember, I believe it was ICC in the last session, And others from the business community believe that it would be very useful to have more work done, more guidance on APAs in view of dispute, I mean it's a huge instrument of dispute prevention. So it's interesting that developing countries and business are giving the same message here, so I think that's really important work for us to take up in the future. And then more broadly, the feedback highlighted the importance of ensuring that international guidance takes into account the needs, resources, constraints, and institutional circumstances of developing country tax administrations. So, you can go to the next slide. So based on this, we're going to continue our monitoring and I'll be happy to present the next report and report all the incredible progress of work stream three in April of 2026, which is our next meeting and other for us. So that's it for me and I give the, give it back to you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:45:11]: Thank you, John, for this comprehensive reporting of activities that have been going on since our last session. I now invite the committee members and observers and stakeholders to provide input and comments to this report. Enrique, please go ahead. UN Tax Committee · Member [1:45:43]: Thank you, Trude. I would like to explain. As always, the explanation was very eloquent and precise, a very good response. I think it's all very clear to us, the areas in which you're working, for example, the convention framework protocol 2 and the working group, you know, OCD and then as well. In the last slide, follow-up is being given to other topics as well. I'm not sure whether I map digitalization is specifically contemplated among those tasks for follow-up. I do see that there's been a great deal of progress in the procedural manual and the I map, the digitalization. And I think that much of this was published by the OECD this year. already mentioned that they have implemented tools in various jurisdictions, digital jurisdictions, forms are online that can simplify the process of IMAP. So that's what I wanted to know. On this specific topic, are you following up on these issues? or whether additional topics will be addressed as well. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:47:17]: Thank you. Angela, please. UN Tax Committee · Member [1:47:21]: Chair, and thank you, Jian, as the co-coordinator of this workstream and ad hoc committee, and of course, the co-coordinator of our social programs as well, giving us an update on all the important stakeholders to our life in UN. But I just wanted to say that I think the work on effective dispute resolution and avoidance is a very key part of international tax cooperation. It provides tax certainty for many stakeholders, tax administrations, and even the businesses, going beyond just taxes, but also enabling cross-border investments. I also appreciate the lens that you have taken in providing us the picture beyond what we are doing here at the UN Tax Committee, but also in the INC as well as at the OECD. And that is precisely how we operate in the international tax space. I think when we engage the students, there were also questions on opportunities for cooperation and the perspectives that you offer enable us as a tax committee, even though we may not participate in some of these discussions, to be plugged in on them and enable us as a committee to progress on that basis. So I appreciate that update and I think the purpose of this is also to take on a monitoring approach and I trust with your connectedness that you will be the right person to alert us where there's any things that we need to follow up on. But in this case, given that there's extensive work that's done, I support the approach that you have taken and thank you for being that connector for us. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:49:01]: Thank you. Sierra Leone, please. Sierra Leone [1:49:09]: Thank you, co-chair. And also, I want to take this opportunity to welcome the Haddock Group effort to strengthen tax dispute avoidance and resolution, particularly through practical guidance, coordination, and capacity development. We appreciate the attention specifically given to developing countries, resources constraints, and the use of countries' experience and simulations of support implementation. Building from this effort, I would like to offer a few practical insights and recommendations drawn from Sierra Leone's perspective. So in the tax administration, specifically, that which operates in my country, We want to definitely relate to this gathering that the resources are relatively low and tax disputes are rarely presided on. And majority of taxpayers definitely perceive tax policies and reforms as additional tax burden. So based on this, the major concern will be how does this mechanism help protect domestic revenue give taxpayers greater certainty and resolve disagreements without placing excessive demand on limited administrative resources. Furthermore, in an economy such as ours, mining and other multinational operations provide relevant examples. Related party financing, management charges, and technical service payments can raise difficult questions about transfer pricing and tax treatment. We will therefore welcome practical examples showing how administrations can prevent and resolve disputes involving these transactions. Co-Chair, therefore, from my experience, I would like to offer a few practical recommendations to ensure that the documents reflect the realities facing countries such as ours as the committee takes this work forward. Firstly, implementation should reflect countries' capacity. We support the request of illustrative domestic provisions and model advanced pricing a template. We also suggest readiness checklist covering legal authority, staffing, and staffing cost and case selection so that administrations can introduce this mechanism in manageable phases. Secondly, We would like to recommend that there is access and clarity on matters. Taxpayers again need to understand where to submit a case, what information is required, and how international procedures relate to domestic objections and appeals. Thirdly, We will also recommend that capacity development should continue beyond individual workshop. Clearly, there are so many, there are series of workshops that were definitely presented in your work. And for the practical case, simulations, monitoring, regional exchanges will help officials apply what they have learned. Examples relevant to country economies, including mining and cross-border services, will also be practically useful. We also welcome coordinations with the subcommittee on indirect taxes, because for countries such as Sierra Leone, which operates a goods and services tax regime, practical guidance on preventing and resolving cross-border indirect tax disputes will be practically useful. Finally, as the UN Dispute Protocol develops, we encourage clear explanation on the cost, safeguards, and legal implications of different mechanisms, particularly arbitrations. Countries should be able to access available options in light of their laws, resources, and revenue interest. Sierra Leone supports taking note of of the report and encourage continued emphasis on practical tools and sustained support for developing countries tax administration. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:53:25]: Thank you very much. And I appreciate all the comments you made, and it gives me an opportunity to also point to the broad work of this committee, in particular the work on the extractives industry and the transfer pricing manuals as something that will hopefully assist in both protecting countries' tax base but also prevent disputes. So thank you very much for that. ICC, please. ICC [1:54:02]: Thank you, Co-Chair, and thank you, Gian, for the presentation and for sharing the good news with everyone. ICC welcomes the work of this ad hoc group as well as the work on dispute resolution at the INC. From the business perspective, preventing disputes is often more effective than resolving them after they arise. We encourage the committee to continue building on its existing work on bilateral APAs, which are a vital tool for preventing disputes before they arise and for providing certainty to both taxpayers and tax administrations. ICC would welcome opportunities to contribute practical insights on commercial realities across global value chains and business models, as well as on the application and administration of bilateral APAs. Given the close link between transfer pricing and many cross-border tax disputes, we would also welcome continued consideration of APA-related issues in the Transfer Pricing Committee. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:54:58]: Thank you. we see no further requests for the floor so I will hand it back to you John for any comments you might have. UN Tax Committee · Member; Co-Coordinator, Ad Hoc Group on Dispute Avoidance and Resolution [1:55:09]: I believe very brief because I feel like we need some coffee at this point it's been going on for quite a bit without it thank you Enrique I want to take this time to thank you for your excellent preparation for every single topic It's -- you're an example for all us other committee members on how well prepared you arrive. You always have interesting input for every single topic, and are very well prepared when you come to these meetings, and have always interesting things to say. So, thank you very much for that, Enrique, a more general comment. Regarding digitalization, we haven't really followed that topic per se to this point, so I think we should Let's stay in contact and see what you would see as being useful and work on that in view of the next session. And yeah, see how-- and maybe report on that at the next meeting. Angela, thank you very for your very kind feedback. Sierra Leone, thank you very much also for your detailed comments. I would appreciate if you could send those in a written form because I went pretty fast, so I probably missed some of it. And they're very interesting points you brought up and quite cross-cutting to many of the subcommittees, not only this ad hoc group. So thank you for sending written comments on that. And then ICC. Well noted, and thank you also for your comments. And I'll pass the floor back to Trude. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [1:56:57]: Thank you. Well, the Committee has taken note of your report as requested, and we will break for coffee. Deadline for comments also on this report, 6th of November. 15. Thank you. if everybody could take their seats we can resume please take your seats So, first, we will move to item 3M, other matters for consideration, and I would like to invite committee members to put forward any other matters they wish for consideration under this agenda item. The floor is open. I see no requests for the floor. We will then move to item 4. on the provisional agenda of the 34th session. I now invite the secretariat and Caroline to present the proposed provisional agenda for the 34th session to be held 5th to 8th of April in 2027 in New York. Please go ahead. UN Secretariat · Secretariat staff [2:14:20]: Thank you very much, Chair. Yes, so as you see on the screen, the provisional agenda is looking very similar to your agenda from this session. I will run through it for the record. So item one, opening. Item two, adoption of the agenda and organization of work. Item three, your main substantive work program is discussion of issues related to international cooperation and tax matters. This list of items from A to M is the same as for this session with one update, which you all may recall. You've already updated the title of the UN manual, negotiation manual, so that's item 3B. We've now adjusted the language there to read with the new title. So update of the United Nations manual for the negotiation of bilateral tax treaties by developing countries. And then as usual, we'll have items four and five, provisional agenda of the 35th session, and item five, arrangements for adopting the report of the committee on its 34th session. Back to you, Chair. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [2:15:35]: I open the floor for any comments on this agenda item. So I see no requests for the floor. May I take it that the committee approves of the provisional agenda for the 34th session as presented, for inclusion in the report on this session and submission to the Economic and Social Council? I see no objection. It is so decided. We will move to the next agenda item, which is quite quickly item 5. arrangements for adopting the report of the committee on its 33rd session. So I now invite Caroline and the secretariat to take us through the arrangements and timelines for finalizing the report of this 33rd session. UN Secretariat · Secretariat staff [2:16:28]: Thank you so much, co-chair. This is based on the committee's practices and working methods, specifically paragraphs 18 to 24, where the reporting procedures and practices are laid out. Committee reports to ECOSOC after each of its regular sessions. The report is not a verbatim report. It sets the course of your discussions and any decisions taken during the session. The secretariat will prepare a draft of the report and share it with members so you have at least two weeks to comment on the draft report. After that, the secretariat will finalize the report in consultation with the co-chairs and submit it for formal processing and production into the six UN languages. Thank you. UN Tax Committee · Co-Chair [2:17:20]: Thank you, Caroline. Are there any comments or observations? I see no requests, so may I take it that the Committee will agree to these arrangements? Yes, it is so decided. And now the Committee will move to a closed meeting before lunch. 00 with an open meeting and a presentation on the capacity building activities. So I will ask that anyone who is not a member of the committee to please leave the conference room. Thank you and enjoy the lunch.