Working Group I (8th meeting), UN Convention on Biodiversity - COP 17 Conferences Date: 29 October 2026 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/en/asset/k1h/k1hu78vwvz Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- CBD · Chair [0:03]: Right, dear colleagues, welcome back. We are now resuming our work in the third session of the day and the eighth session of Working Group 1. Yeah, so just for the benefit of the room, we'll go through the order and I give the Secretariat the floor. Secretariat. CBD · Secretariat [0:36]: Thank you, Chair. So we will start our evening session with CBD agenda 9A, global review of collective progress, CRP18, which will be followed by Nagoya Protocol agenda item 11, specialized ABS instruments, Nagoya Protocol agenda item 12, global multilateral benefit-sharing mechanism, CRP7, CBD agenda item 11, digital sequence information; CBD agenda item 8B, financial mechanism, with the document CRP.13/Rev.1; And CBD 20, multi-year programme of work, CRP.14. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [1:28]: Thank you, Secretariat. I would now like to open consideration of CRP.18. on the global review of collective progress in the implementation of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. First of all, I have to beg your forgiveness. I've taken my tie off. Usually, for political meetings, I always keep my tie on. And when there's a scientific meeting, I take my tie off. But given the time I have to spend on this podium, I've taken my liberty to take my tie off, and I hope you forgive me. Thank you. Forgiveness is really important, I think. So I understand that we have mostly reached consensus. So we are taking this up here, and hopefully this will save us time tomorrow. The paper that is before you includes two elements. One, the text coming directly from the contact group, and two, proposals to resolve the brackets which are presented with the word proposal. to indicate that these are coming from the ministerial consultation. So, taking my usual approach here in this working group, I suggest that we approve the clean text. not dealing with the proposals now, but to dealing with the clean text, which are the preambles, and then para 1 to 16, with the exception of 19, and then paras 17 to 25, paras 27 to 44, and then paras 46 to 49, except para 49 e. That is e as in elephant. Right. I see Brazil asking for the floor. You have the floor. Brazil [4:07]: Thank you, Mr. Co-Chair. We would like to raise a point with regard to paragraph 35. We don't have to do it immediately. We can We can start with the bracketed text, but I would just like to signal that, yes, we would like to bring one topic with relation to paragraph 35. Thank you. CBD · Chair [4:40]: Thank you, Brazil. Yeah, so we have a clean text in 35, so I suggest that we keep the clean text, but for the sake of transparency, I would like to hear the proposal you have. Thank you. Brazil [5:10]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. So, as you are well aware, the Global Review will be one of the most politically visible decisions of this COP if we're able to approve it. And this means we cannot afford to get it wrong. So allow me to provide the room with some background. In the discussions on the Global Review, a small group was created to discuss the term "actors other than national governments," which appeared many times in the draft. In this small group and afterwards in the contact group, Brazil, with the support of another delegation, raised the issue of including people of African descent comprising collectives embodying traditional lifestyles in the Global Review decision. This expression, as we all know, is agreed language under Decision 16/6. The inclusion proposed by Brazil was procedurally justified on the basis that the term actors other than national governments was bracketed in many parts of the decision. The mentions to specific groups, such as indigenous peoples and local communities, women, youth, were also bracketed in many parts of the text. So in other words, Brazil aimed to include agreed language in bracketed text, which is a right that we believe that parties have. When Brazil first raised this topic in the Contact Group, the co-chairs answered that we would be able to discuss the issue in the Contact Group after the results of the small group were reflected in the non-paper. On Sunday, 25 October, when the topic was raised by Brazil in light of a new non-paper, The co-chair said that they had been instructed by the chair of the Working Group 1 that this was new text which could not be brought up in the contact group, only at the working group. This, we felt, was a reversal of a previous understanding that had been shared with us. And we see this as an approach that has limited our ability to address a topic that is politically important to us, in spite of the fact that it had been brought up since the beginning of discussions in the Global Review. And this is how we got here today. We all know that the Global Review and the respective report do not specifically mention people of African descent. But that is simply because the review refers to the KMGBF, which is from 2022, while Decision 16/6 was agreed two years later, in 2024. In our view, we cannot afford to leave out from the decision a major development in the CBD regime, which recognizes the role and contributions of people of African descent, comprising collectives embodying traditional lifestyles, in implementing the Convention and the framework. In light of our right as a party to include text in the decision, Brazil would like to request the inclusion of a reference to people of African descent in paragraph 39 of the CPR. The text would be a simple insertion that would do nothing more than reflect the text of 16.6. So the paragraph 35 would read, "Emphasizes that actions from Indigenous peoples and local communities, comma, people of African descent comprising collectives embodying traditional lifestyles, comma, and then it would continue as previously drafted. Thank you very much, Chair. CBD · Chair [8:52]: Thank you, Brazil. So at this stage, and I've taken note of this suggestions, however, at this stage, I do not, because it's Thursday, it's late. I suggest that we don't include new text in the working group. That said, I mean, if the room, so from the starting point, I will not accept new text, and there are many reasons for not accepting new text at this stage. But if the room has nothing against your insertion, I am ready to accept it. So that will be my approach. So on that basis, I will ask the room if there are any objections to including the text from Brazil. Yes, there are at least five parties that object. Please lower your flags. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [10:32]: Thank you. May we hear from the parties? Because I believe that some parties that raise their flags might be in support of the inclusion. And also before I give back the floor, which you gave to me, thank you, I would like to point out that this was the first opportunity that we had to actually bring this topic, so we don't see it as an inappropriate place. It was just the first chance that we had. Thank you. CBD · Chair [10:57]: Thank you, Brazil. No, I don't see it as inappropriate at all. It's just that at this stage, I do have a problem with opening up for new texts. And that's just because we're stretched of time and we have lots of agenda items to go through. So that's just a matter of time management, basically, at this stage. But I hear Colombia, you have the floor. Colombia [11:26]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. We would like to support Brazil's proposals to include people of African descent, comprising collectives and varying traditional lifestyles. We believe that explicitly retaining this reference in the context of this paragraph is important to preserve their recognition established in Decision 16/6 of their role and contributions to the implementation of the framework and to ensure that their contributions remain visible and acknowledged. So we strongly support Brazil's proposal. Thank you, Mr. Chair. CBD · Chair [12:04]: Thank you, Colombia. So my guidance has been from the start that I don't accept a new text unless it solves a problem. And in this case, I think it will complicate things and take us back. But mindful that this is not the last opportunity to air those views. We're still just in the CRP, and there's another level that this can be raised. So that will be my approach. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [12:50]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Our strong preference would be to have that text, even if it were bracketed. And in any case, we reserve the right to bring it up in plenary if that were the case. But our strong, strong preference would be to have it there from the start. Thank you. CBD · Chair [13:11]: Thank you, Brazil. And I do have understanding for your preference, but at this stage, I I want to have a clean text going forward, but you reserve the right, as you rightly point out, to raise this at the L stage in the plenary. That is your right. So I see no more requests from the floor. Then I will ask if we can accept the outcomes of the ministerials, which are marked as proposals in the CRP. Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [14:23]: Thank you. Good evening. And Chair, I saw you in a sporty outfit. So I think that for this evening, having you in jacket, that's already great. If you ask us for all four paragraphs or particular paragraphs. CBD · Chair [14:44]: Yes. Sorry, Russian Federation. We have now approved the paragraphs I've listed. So now we go to the proposed paragraphs, and I want to treat them as a whole. So I ask the room if there are any objections to carry them forward. with lifting the brackets on all of the proposals so they would go forward as clean text to the plenary. That would be my proposal. Are there any objections against doing this? I see there are flags, which I interpret as objections. And now let's hear the views. I'll start with the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [15:45]: Thank you very much, Chair. So as we mentioned many times, we have been fundamentally against prolonging different kind of discussions, dialogue, conversations, what we need and how to do, and particularly in relation to the Global Report. We believe we had a great meeting in Kunming. We had meetings of SBI, of Sub-Stars, this COP, so that's enough from our perspective. We need to spend time and money on actions and implementation and not prolong it. So we were requesting to initially delete three paragraphs related to those workshops. So after consultations and considerations and seeing the proposal of those four paragraphs, We, as a compromise, agree to support keeping the paragraph now numbered 45, because, okay, we agree that if some parties like to be engaged into these discussions and continue it, of course, they can do that. Also, because we have now in this document the section which is Yerevan pathway. So that's important also to support the outcomes of this COP. So, but we still do not see the engagement of the executive secretary and secretariat into this process, also in the view of our discussions at the budget. when we got all clear indications how busy, how complex, and how overwhelmed the whole staff there. So if parties like to do it on their own, using their own funding, asking donors, et cetera, so that's fine. So saying that, we agree with all three paragraphs with the exception of what is now 49E. So we request to delete it, but of course it's in square brackets, so it stays in square brackets until the L document. The other paragraphs we are happy to support. And again, in view of compromise, keep paragraph 45. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [18:15]: Thank you very much, Russian Federation. That is duly noted. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [18:22]: Thank you, Chair. I have two points to raise. The first one is with regard to paragraph 26. And before I go there, I believe that it would be perhaps more organized if we went paragraph by paragraph, because it doesn't seem that we'll be able to approach this as a package. So with regard to paragraph 26, we would like to insert at the end of that phrase, after framework, comma, with developed country parties taking the lead. Thank you. CBD · Chair [19:06]: Thank you, Brazil. Your view is duly noted. And I now take Peru. Peru, you have the floor. Peru [19:22]: Thank you, Chair. Good evening, thank you for giving me the floor. We would ask for clarification with regards to paragraph 19, in particular, these phrases in brackets on parties with economies in transition. With regards to these countries, first, these are developing countries. But we'd like to know what the Secretariat sees as the concept of Parties to the Convention in transition, because here it seems that there's different countries. We have developing countries, Parties in transition, and developed countries. So we would ask for the Secretariat to please provide clarification if Parties identified as Parties in transition are developing countries or not. With that clarification, we should be able to be ready to remove the brackets for this paragraph. Thank you. CBD · Chair [20:35]: Thank you, Peru. We now have the EU. EU, you have the floor. EU · EU [20:42]: Thank you very much, Mr. Vice Chair, and good evening, everybody. We welcome the progress that's been made on the text of the Global Review and strongly appreciate the efforts of the Armenian Presidency, as well as our co-chairs, in finding a way forward. We also welcome the constructive discussions in the Contact Group and the engagement of all parties on these topics. The EU and its member states believe that the Yerevan pathway provides a strong basis to accelerate the implementation of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. And now, as we face the final stages of our discussions with a very few outstanding issues to solve, but of course, these are some of the issues that are most important for our region. The European Union and Member States have made many concessions on the text, in particular regards language on means of implementation and the repeated caveats relating to national circumstances. Mr. Chair, the text that we have today is, in some respects, weaker than text that we had seen after the ministerial consultations. We see a paragraph on harmful incentives that doesn't even mention the word incentives. And we would propose a simple paragraph, therefore, in paragraph 26 to address this matter. The text would read: in accordance with the national circumstances, priorities, and capabilities to scale up positive incentives and accelerate identification, elimination, phasing out, or reform of negative incentives, including subsidies harmful to biodiversity. We see a paragraph on underlying drivers of biodiversity loss, so the paragraph 16 that does not address any of the systemic changes that we need to see. In a spirit of compromise, we nevertheless could live with that language. And in relation to what we've just heard, I would say that the European Union and Member States strongly support the paragraph on the organization of regional and sub-regional dialogues. We believe that such follow-up action will maintain political and technical momentum on the implementation of the KNGBF. We think that the Secretariat needs a clear mandate to be engaged in these dialogues. So the proposal that we see on the table, therefore, is not a proposal that we can support. The aim of the Yerevan pathway is to accelerate the implementation of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework. We need to ensure that the provisions in that text deliver on that promise. And I think with the changes that we've proposed in paragraph 26, we could have a viable way forward. Thank you. CBD · Chair [23:38]: Thank you. EU, India, you have the floor. India [23:43]: Thank you, Chair. We are opposing the paragraph 26, and we also mentioned when the same issue came up in biodiversity and agriculture and other things, it is a cross-cutting issue, and it can't be discussed here. And moreover, We are in favor of deleting this, not to consider this para 26. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [24:15]: Thank you, India. No yoga today, I guess. But Cuba, you have the floor. Cuba [24:26]: Thank you, Chair. Cuba would like to support the proposal to add text as proposed by Brazil. Thank you. CBD · Chair [24:36]: Thank you very much, Cuba. Now to Saudi Arabia, you have the floor. Saudi Arabia [24:42]: Thank you very much, Chair. On paragraphs 26 and 26, the proposal, we would support the insertion made by the delegate from Brazil, particularly in relation to developed countries taking the lead. And we would also prefer a focus on the identification of incentives rather than about accelerating into implementation. And this is particularly due to the gap that was outlined in the Global Review Report. For all we know, the target could be achieved, but countries are not reporting on it. So therefore, we would prefer that the focus remains on identification rather than about accelerating implementation. Additionally, on paragraph 45, we would request the following additions at the end, that where it starts with a view to sharing practices, best practices, challenges, and barriers, and enhancing actions and efforts, as appropriate, in A, facilitative, non-intrusive, comma, non-punitive manner, comma, respecting national sovereignty, comma, and avoiding placing undue burdens on parties. And this is consistent with section J of the framework, paragraph 19 therein. And it is quite important to ensure that when these regional and sub-regional dialogues take place, that countries duly respect each other's policy space and, of course, nationally determined pathways. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [26:27]: Thank you, Saudi Arabia. I now have Switzerland followed by Norway. Switzerland, you have the floor. Switzerland [26:34]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good evening. So, Switzerland on paragraph 26 cannot agree with the insertion by Brazil on developed country parties taking the lead and would like to bracket that. We also would like to bracket the insertion by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. that want to have a focus on identification, for us it is clear that we also have to accelerate implementation and cannot afford to only focus on. Identification. And I would stop here, but reserve the right to come back depending on the positions and other statements. Thank you. CBD · Chair [27:25]: Thank you, Switzerland. Norway, followed by Iceland and Colombia. Norway, you have the floor. Norway [27:31]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. The decision before us is the product of countless hours of work in contact groups, consultations, and negotiations over the past year, as well as the continuing dialogue on collective progress. It reflects significant efforts to identify common ground and move implementation of the KMGBF forward. At a time when we should be focusing on implementation, we continue to spend valuable time revisiting commitments that were already agreed at COP15. This is a good decision, and we believe firmly its approval is overdue. Norway finds it deeply concerning that we remain unable to close on issues where there is overwhelming convergence, where in fact there has been overwhelming convergence for quite some time, and where the science is unambiguous. This COP must send a clear signal that we remain committed to implementing the framework in full. That includes advancing work on harmful incentives under Target 18, addressing the direct and indirect drivers of biodiversity loss, strengthening resource mobilization, and ensuring effective follow-up to assess and improve implementation before 2030. To conclude, Norway strongly supports the comments made by the EU and Switzerland, including the EU proposal for paragraph 26, and also seek flexibility from colleagues in this room to move this CRP forward. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [29:05]: Thank you, Norway. I now have Iceland. Iceland [29:10]: Thank you, Chair. On the paragraph 26. We remind delegates that this is one of the cross-cutting targets, important for the delivery of all other targets, and we strongly support the changes suggested by the EU and also the position of Switzerland. And I hope we can get to an agreement on a stronger language in paragraph 26 than the proposal in front of us is showing us. Thank you, Mr. Chair. CBD · Chair [29:59]: Thank you very much, Iceland. Colombia, you have the floor. Colombia [30:04]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to refer to paragraph 26. We can go along with the proposal, with the new proposal, and then with the insertion proposed by Brazil, but we do think it's important to maintain the focus on implementation. So we will not be in agreement to focus only on the identification of incentives. Thank you. CBD · Chair [30:29]: Thank you. Colombia, Egypt, you have the floor. Egypt [30:33]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's just to highlight that we support the intention that has been made by the honorable delegate from Saudi Arabia, as well as those from Brazil. Thank you. CBD · Chair [30:47]: Thank you, Egypt. And my last speaker is Iran. You have the floor. Microphone to Iran, please. Iran (Islamic Republic of) [31:02]: Thank you, Chair. Regarding paragraph 26, The proposal has been, the proposal of the ministerials and the presidency is short, but in case of. Proposal that raised in this working group, I would like to add some very important elements. Achieving target 18 depends on many means of. Implementation, such as required fair, equitable, and timely means of implementation, including financial resources, capacity building, technical and scientific support, education, technological transfer, public awareness, empowering IPLCs, and also private sectors in developing countries. If we want to achieve target 18, that is very important. We need also to facilitate and provide required support for that. Any changes or any transport change is not happen unless that we facilitate them. We also need to consider the barriers and. Lots of challenges that face in many areas, particularly in some regions that have been faced by armed conflicts. And also sanctions, unilateral sanctions, that has affected the parties for both implementing the. Actions for biodiversity conservation, restoration, and sustainable use, and also reporting the results. Thank you so much. CBD · Chair [32:58]: Thank you very much, Aron. That concludes the speakers list. So now I will now suggest I will proceed. Yeah, well, so this was the discussion on the paras, which we haven't approved so far, which were the proposals, are the proposals after the ministerial discussion. which was para 16 plus 19, and 26, and 45, and 49e. Right. So, and I see, and I heard there are suggestions to include text in one direction or the other on the different paras. And, you know, To me, that's fine, but it also tells me that if we do that exercise with starting to introduce text in those already existing brackets at this stage, we will spend a lot of time here. And mindful that there's also an equilibrium and a relationship between those paras, I would suggest that we just carry the bracketed paragraphs forward as an L doc. And then, of course, that doesn't mean that this will be the final solutions. The paras are in brackets, and consultations, I hope, will be ongoing on those paras, but also on the relationship between those paras. to find the landing zone. But I don't think it's for this working group to find that landing zone here and now. So what I suggest is that we just carry those bracketed paragraphs forward. in an L doc after we have finished our deliberations of this CRP. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [35:47]: Thank you, Mr. Co-Chair. So just two quick questions for the sake of clarification. Do I understand correctly that the L document will reflect the exact text as it was in the CRP without the additions and eliminations from today's discussion? Okay, that was the first one. And the second one is that I would like, if you could, to share with me the delegations that were against my inclusion in the beginning, if you had them, And if you can't do that, I would ask that those delegations please let them selves be known to me, because I would like to discuss bilaterally, please. Thank you. CBD · Chair [36:28]: Thank you, Brazil. Indeed, on the first, you are right, they will be carried over in the LDOC unchanged, so we'll not include any suggestions made, because there was an array of them, which is the second of my point, we'll carry them over. as they are now in the CRP. I will not do any changes. Regarding your letter question, yes, we have it and we will read it out now. CBD · Secretariat [37:03]: So the ones that we saw were Australia, Japan, Switzerland. And Canada, and Peru and Colombia had their flag raised, but I'm not sure. Speaker 45 [37:23]: Yeah, I mean, Colombia mentioned that they supported you, but they raised their flag at the time. CBD · Secretariat [37:28]: Sorry. CBD · Chair [37:32]: Thank you. Brazil? No. Sorry, we're good. Japan, you have the floor. Japan [37:48]: Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. I would like to explain the reason I asked the floor on the proposed insertion by the distinguished colleague from Brazil. We would not support any new text insertion at this stage. I wanted to obey the direction given by the chair on the handling of this meeting. At this later stage, we would not like to support any new incursion. That was the reason behind this. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [38:41]: Thank you, Japan. And then also mindful, I want to reiterate that we're now on the CRP stage. There are more stages, right? So we have the L stage as well. And Brazil, rightly so, and Colombia as well, retain the right to bring this issue up on the next stage. Brazil, you want the floor. Brazil [39:05]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Very quickly, I appreciate very much what my colleague from Japan shared. I just wanted to point out, and I'll seek him out afterwards, to see if he understands that this inclusion is based on a procedural point that we raised in the beginning, and to understand better if his opposition is based on procedurals or substance, because if it's based on procedure, I think we can get it there. because the issue of why it hasn't been brought before is procedural in nature. So just to let that out there. Thank you. CBD · Chair [39:44]: Yeah, I understand, Brazil. That's good. Okay, so that concludes our deliberations, I think. We will now turn the document into an L-doc with the clean, approved text and the proposal, which are the proposals, and that's important, which are in brackets. Thank you very much. I was about to say you may go home, but that's not the case, right? So we'll continue with our next item. Thank you. Right, so we'll now need a change of guards for the most delegations, I guess, because we'll now consider CRP6 on MOP item 11, sorry, specialized international access and benefit sharing instruments in the context of Article 4, paragraph 4 of the Nagoya Protocol. We'll take a short break for about three minutes. All right, delegates, please find your seats, Nagoya people. Let's now turn our attention to CRP 6 under agenda item 11 concerning specialized international access and benefit sharing instruments in the context of Article 4, paragraph 4 of the Nagoya Protocol. Before opening the floor on the document, I understand that the Secretariat wishes to draw Parties' attention to two editorial corrections in the CRP. to ensure that the text accurately reflects the outcome of the contact group discussions. Secretariat, you are the floor. CBD · Secretariat [43:30]: Thank you, Chair. The Secretariat would like to draw attention to two editorial corrections in CRP 6. First, in operative paragraph one, brackets beginning before the words "which provide" and extending to the end of the paragraph were inadvertently retained and should be removed, thus meaning that operative paragraph 1 is therefore clean text. Secondly, in operative paragraph 3, the opening bracket should appear immediately after the word “establish.” Accordingly, the words “decide to establish” are not bracketed, while the remainder of the paragraph remains in brackets. These corrections, as was said by the Chair, are intended solely to ensure that the CRP accurately reflects the outcome of the contact group discussions. Thank you, Chair. We so submit. CBD · Chair [45:02]: Thank you, Secretariat, for that information. So the CRP was prepared on the basis of the work of the contact group. I now invite the co-chair of the contact group to report on their work. Mary Ciacci from the European Union, you have the floor. Microphone to Italy or is it Ireland? EU. Ireland, sorry, EU. Yeah, so I'm a bit confused. Sorry, it's late. EU · Contact Group Co-Chair [45:37]: Thank you, Mr. Kocher, for recalling my nationality, but I represent the European Union and its 27 member states here. Anyway, now I'm speaking under my capacity of culture of this Contact Group. Good evening, distinguished delegates. My name is Mary Chachi from the UPN Union, and together with my co-chair, Henry Ndenjango from Namibia, I had the privilege and the honor of co-facilitating the Contact Group on Agenda Item 11 concerning specialized international access and benefit-sharing instruments in the context of Article 4, paragraph 4 of the Nagoya Protocol. The contact group met on two occasions and concluded its work on 27 October. Between these sessions, the co-chairs convened a small informal consultation with interested parties to explore possible pathways towards convergence on outstanding issues. The contact group began with an exchange of views on the new information contained in the document CBD/NP/MOP/6/9, summarizing new submissions on specialized international instruments received by the Secretariat after SBI 6. The co-chairs recalled that extensive discussions on this agenda item took place already at SBI 6. and led to a balanced compromise, and subsequently focused on the remaining brackets in the text in the draft decision. Discussion centered primarily on the provision concerning the name and the scope of the group to work in the inter-sessional period on specialized instruments, which is now reflected in operative paragraph 3 of the revised text. The informal consultations also sought to advance discussions on the proposed intersessional process related to Article 4, paragraph 4. The contact group reached convergence on the need to continue work on Article 4, paragraph 4 in the intersessional period. Views, however, continued to diverge on the nature of that process, including whether it should be constituted as a formal process or as an informal advisory process. Strong divergence also remained on whether the meetings should only be in person, online, or hybrid. Several scenarios were discussed, including the possibility of holding back-to-back meetings with other potential ABS-related work streams under the Nagoya Protocol, while maintaining the distinct substantive mandates and scope of the possible processes. As progress on this depends on further developments under other agenda item, conclusions on this aspect could not be reached and is pending further consideration. While the Contact Group was able to streamline the draft decisions and remove a number of brackets, several provisions remain unresolved and are therefore referred back to Working Group 1 for its consideration. On behalf of the co-chairs, I would like to express our appreciation to all parties for their engagement, flexibility, and collaborative spirit throughout the discussions. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [49:06]: Thank you very much, European Union. Thank you very much, Mary. And also great thanks to your co-chair, Henry Ngeye from Namibia. I first propose that we approve the clean text in this CRP contained in Preambular paras 4 and 5 and Operative paras 1. I see no request for the floor. It is so approved. And taking the usual approach, we will have to start working on the bracketed text. So, to facilitate our work, I propose that we can begin with the operative paragraph 3 before turning to the related provisions and concluding with the remaining preamble text. So I suggest that we begin with operative paragraph three. And this, of course, is just to be as effective as possible. Yes, and now I'm looking at people. Who wants to go first? The floor is open on operative paragraph three. And if you can clean it, that's fantastic. While we wait, I also want to inform that paragraph 2 was also cleaned, so it will join the other paragraphs as approved. Thank you. South Africa, you have the floor. South Africa [51:23]: Thank you, co-chair. Thank you, Chair. We support an open-ended working group. This item decides when the Geneva Protocol applies, which is a matter for its parties in a formal process, with one in-person meeting and online meetings, as now proposed in Annex 2. The cost is a little different from that of an informal group. What differs is the weight of the outcome. The mandate can end at the seventh meeting. We are also open to a single working group covering both Articles 4.4 and Article 10 to reduce costs further. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [52:04]: Thank you, South Africa. And indeed, I see in paragraph three, there is a choice between a big, heavy process or a light process. So I guess it's the choice between those two or something in the middle. European Union, you have the floor. EU · EU [52:29]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good evening. So for the European Union and its 27 member states, the preferred option would be the open-ended informal advisory group. And we have been quite consistent in this. We have already been discussing this issue at SBI in Rome, where the outcome of our considerations was a clear understanding of an informal group. So we maintain our view that indeed we need a process. until the next meeting of the parties, but this process does not need to be heavy, so be quite light, like a light process. And we believe that indeed we need this process, and this process needs to address the issues that we have not been able to address until now. But at the same time, this process should really be agile and should allow really full and inclusive participation of of parties, but indeed the outcomes should serve later at SBI at the meeting of the parties. So we are very much in favor of the informal advisory group. While I have the floor also, I believe I have to introduce one small insertion here, because the CRP NRU does not fully capture the outcome of the contact group. And maybe to explain a bit better. For us, it was very important to have in this paragraph reference to the article 4 as a whole, because we believe that we cannot consider only one of the paragraphs of this article in isolation. So this was a very important issue for us. We were having some troubles finding a compromise that could serve us all. Then, thanks to the distinguished delegates from Brazil who introduced this compromise, However, at the very last end of the contact group, there was a suggestion to delete that, and we could not react to object to this deletion. So with your indulgence, Mr. Chair, I would kindly like to read what has been in the text during our discussion, but unfortunately is not captured in the CRP. So it will read on the second line, "To advance work on paragraph 4 of Article 4, taking into consideration while working on the subject, on a strictly advisory manner, the entirety of article 4. So this would very much help us to address our concerns. So we do not need any brackets regarding paragraph 4. And while we are cleaning the bracket, I think we can very easily clean the very last bracket that refers to the seventh meeting of the meeting of the parties. Thank you, Mr. Chair. CBD · Chair [55:18]: Thank you, European Union. So I would ask you to repeat the text again and in the dictation speed. Thank you. EU · EU [55:29]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Of course. So on the second line, after "to advance work on paragraph 4 of Article 4", there's a comma, and our proposal goes: "taking into consideration", comma, "while working on the subject". on a strictly advisory manner, the entirety of Article 4. Thank you. CBD · Chair [56:00]: Thank you, EU. And also regarding our text proposal, we will reflect it because otherwise I will see that we will have a bigger problem. So that's what we'll do. Thank you. UK, you have the floor. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [56:20]: Thank you, Mr. Co-Chair. We also agree with the previous speakers on the importance of advancing on the issue of specialized international instruments. But for us as well, an. Open-ended working group would be too heavy a process for this topic, and our preference would be. For an advisory group. We also recall the discussion with the addition from the European Union, and so could support that. I do recall that being in the text previously in the small group discussions. Thank you. CBD · Chair [57:00]: Thank you. UK, Switzerland, you are on the phone. Switzerland [57:04]: Thank you, Chair. So we also, as we've heard from the report back from the contact group, the. Deliberations at the SBI-6 have led to a very balanced outcome. And I think the. Compromise that was found there was to establish an informal group, and that's also reflected in the footnote. And now we have these further deliberations, and our preference, similar to the European Union and UK. Would also be to have an open-ended informal advisory group, which does also reflect what has been agreed at SPI-6. And we think that this would be a very flexible format which could provide advice, and therefore we would support this, and we also support online meetings of this group. In contrast, an open-ended. Working group, which would be much heavier and also does not reflect an informal group in our view. That being said, we also support the addition from the European Union in the preamble regarding recalling. The whole of, or not recalling, but referring to the whole of Article 4 at this place. I think this would be very helpful. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [58:23]: Thank you. So I see a fairly long list building, and we're here to solve the problem, not to hear statements. I think we pretty much know where the divergence is. Let me take Egypt and Japan, and then I will tell you how I want to proceed. Egypt, you have the floor. Egypt · Africa Group [58:45]: Thank you, Ms. Akca. Africa would be willing to have an open-ended working group. We don't see an informal process is sufficient for us to conduct the work that is needed. We already have several informal work dating back to more than 12 years, I would say. So Africa would like to have an open-ended working group. With regard to the proposed addition by the European Union, we recall the discussions that we had And that text was proposed actually by Brazil, trying to bridge the gap as a part of a full package, but it did not fly because the other part of the package was not agreed upon. So basically bringing that text again, we would revise the whole collection of the things. What we think is that to reduce the bracket, we can strike out. the modalities for an online, in-person hybrid, it is present in the annex and it does need to be bracketed here and in the annex. So perhaps if we just delete that part, noting that it is reflected in the annex and in other place, we would reduce the number of brackets. Thank you, Mr. Chair. CBD · Chair [1:00:06]: Thank you, Egypt. And please hold on to your potential solutions. I'll take Japan now as the last speaker before I tell you how to proceed. Japan, you have the floor. Japan [1:00:18]: Thank you, Chair. Japan supports EU, UK, Switzerland, and the establishment of an informal body that would meet online. The Secretariat had explained both in the contact group and in small group discussions the budgetary implications of convening an OEIWG or OEWG, given the significant difficulty in using the core budget for any body established to consider Article 4.4. Japan believes that the discussions should be conducted in the most efficient and cost-effective manner possible. For Japan, it is essential that such discussion take place through an informal body and be held online. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:01:17]: So, I saw Cuba waving the flag. So, is this a burning issue, Cuba? Then I want to hear it. And then I asked the others to lower your flags. I don't want to be unfair, but my own country was number one on the list. So, Norway, I beg your indulgence. Cuba, you have the floor. Cuba [1:01:43]: Thank you, Chair. I'll be brief. For some reason, the system wasn't working, the electronic system. Cuba is in favor of an formal statement, we support the proposals by South Africa and the Africa Group to have an open-ended working group and a formal process. The mechanism of the advisory group has limitations for certain countries, particularly when it comes to online meetings. Our region has stated not all countries have access at the necessary moment to an online meeting, particularly countries subject to unilateral coercive measures. We want this to be an inclusive process where all parties can participate. Therefore, in addition, the informal and formal scope is not the same, so we prefer the open-ended working group. rather than the advisory group? Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:02:49]: Yes, yes. Thank you, Kuba. So I don't want to hear statements because we know pretty much who wants a heavy process and who wants a light process. But India, you have a burning wish for the floor? Yes. OK. But now, we're really, really short before I tell you how we will proceed, India. India [1:03:17]: Thank you, Chair. I will be very short. This Article 4 is very much important and which also is having some effect on the access benefit sharing and on the bilateral system also. That is why we think open-ended working group will be better where we have a formal discussion. things are flowing that direction will be better. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [1:03:48]: Thank you, India. So, sorry, I was told I need the microphone here, otherwise there will be feedback and stuff. So, now, what I want to do now is to create a huddle to discuss paragraph three. and the huddle will meet here, and it will consist of those delegations that spoke and did ask for the floor. Among them is the European Union, India, Cuba, Norway, Brazil, UK, Egypt, and South Africa. Other parties interested may also join. And then you will meet there. I will not appoint a leader. You will self-organize, and you have 10 minutes. This is also good for exercise. It's not yoga, but it's definitely steps, so it's at this hour, I think is quite good. So you will meet here to my left, which is the huddle corner, we're calling it now. So please. And the task is to clean para three. And you have 10 minutes, please. Okay, so I think we're a bit past the 10 minutes. Do you need more time? So I asked delegations to be flexible. You're nodding. So I ask you to be flexible because this is really important and now it's crunch time. Thank you. Yes, five minutes more granted. All right, do you need a little bit more time? Are you close or not? What? A couple of minutes? Speaker 74 [1:28:25]: A couple of minutes, yeah. Days. Days. CBD · Chair [1:28:28]: Oh my God. No, we don't have a couple of days. You know, that's, that's, but Five, yes, five. Five minutes. Two minutes. Speaker 76 [1:31:24]: That's right. CBD · Chair [1:34:57]: So, I think so gradually we have to come back. If you're close, we can extend with a couple of minutes. If not, we will just report back and All right, so I think we have to end. I see no white smoke coming out, but I thank you anyway for your efforts. If one of you could please just make a brief report back. It would be appreciated. Egypt, your answer. Egypt [1:37:09]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. We had a discussion. We could not settle the issue of open-ended working group or informal group, but nobody opposed deleting the online and the modality, noting that it is present in the annex, so that we will have less bracket at least for this time. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:37:31]: Thank you, Egypt. That is an outcome appreciated. I think Secretariat has taken note. So, okay, so what we'll do now, since para three is the key to unlock the whole documents, we will carry it over as is with the change made by the huddle, with the change made by the EU in brackets. So those will be the two changes, and they will be carried over with those two changes as is and turn into an L. Right, so that's what we'll do. So it is hereby approved as an LDOC with the brackets. Thank you. Okay, so, wait. So I wanted to make you aware of one small change in the schedule. Next on the schedule is global multilateral benefit sharing mechanism. NP12, but after that, we included a different item, CVD8A, which is resource mobilization. The purpose here is just to hear a report from the Friends of the Chair group. So we will not be considering resource mobilization CRP. But we will hear a report back from the Friends of the Chair group on resource mobilization. Argentina, you have the floor. Argentina [1:40:11]: Thank you, Chair. I have a question about the previous point. I understand that this paragraph, which Huddle wasn't able to resolve, they weren't able to resolve the brackets for L, but there are other paragraphs that are in brackets. Are we going to address them now or are they staying in brackets in the L? The first three preambular paragraphs in particular, the fifth preambular paragraph, the sixth rather, pardon, and all of Annex 1 are in brackets, so I'd like to know what we're going to do. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:40:44]: Yes, indeed. Thank you, Argentina. So, What we will do is to keep the document as is with the two additions. Otherwise, the document stays as is, including the preamble and the annex. So that's the approach, and it will be considered further as an LDOC. Thank you. Right, so further on the agenda, so I've included resource mobilization, where the purpose is to hear a report from the Friends of the Chair group. And after resource mobilization, we have digital sequence information, where where the purpose is as well to hear the hear our report from the Friends of the Chair group. And then we have financial mechanism, and there we'll consider the CRP 13 Rev 1. And then we at the end for this session, we have CBD 20 multi-year program of work, CRP 40. So The schedule is now updated, so just consult the schedule, please. So next is global multilateral benefit sharing mechanisms, CRP 7. Okay, so the CRP reflects the work of the contact group. I invite the co-chair of the contact group to report on their work. Kim van Seters from Netherlands, you have the floor. Netherlands (Kingdom of the) · Contact Group Co-Chair [1:43:17]: Thank you, Chair, distinguished delegates. On behalf of my co-chair, Dr. Hector Conde, and myself, I am happy to update you on the work done by the Contact Group, established to prepare a draft decision for item 12 of the Nagoya COP-MOP related to Article 10 of the Nagoya Protocol on a global multilateral benefit-sharing mechanism. The Contact Group met three times to discuss this issue. The first session on October 21st was an open exchange of views that allowed us to prepare a first non-paper. The contact group met again on 26 October to discuss this non-paper. A second version of the non-paper was produced, reflecting the discussions, and a small group was established to work on paragraph 8, as well as paragraphs 6 and 7. The third meeting of the contact group was held on October 27th. The contact group took on board the work done by the small group and also managed to clean some other parts of the text. The outcomes of these discussions are reflected in the CRP before you. Chair, the contact group was able to agree to a number of paragraphs, but there are still some remaining issues where agreement could not be reached. As a result, the CRP still has some text in brackets where further discussion will be required. I would like to thank all parties for their constructive engagement and cooperation throughout the process, and also thank my co-chair. It was a pleasure to work together. It's been fantastic. Thank you, chair. CBD · Chair [1:45:22]: Thank you very much, Kim, and thank you very much for your hard work and also your co-chair, Hector, from Cuba. I'm very grateful. So we started with no draft decision for this item, and now we have a well-developed text before us, and thank you for your hard work once again. Despite good progress made during the contact group, during which most outstanding issues were successfully addressed, there remain unresolved brackets in the document that require further attention. Before we address the unresolved brackets, I would like to approve the clean Paris in the CRP. The clean paras are the four preamble paras, as well as operative paras two, three, four, five, sub-paragraph A, and para six. I see no requests for the floor. It is hereby approved. And now we will turn to The brackets, bracketed Paris. Yeah, so I think I'm having like a deja vu kind of experience because in seven, SAS decides to establish an open and an informal advisory group or an intergovernmental open and working group. So, because of my deja vu experience, I will not make you do a huddle again. But I would carry this CRP as is forward as an LDOC. That would be my approach. And also, regarding this item and the previous item, specialized international access and benefit sharing instrument, I would please have delegations consult, and please consult intensively overnight. So you're ready for tomorrow, because tomorrow we have to make a decision and we need consensus on these two Nagoya Protocol items. Egypt, the other floor. Egypt [1:49:06]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Actually, we propose to establish an open-ended working group to advance discussion on Article 10 and Article 4 of the Nagoya Protocol. Because we think while those two issues should be addressed separately, each with its own mandate and substantive discussion, they are closely related in the broader context of ensuring fair and equitable benefit sharing and coherent implementation of the Protocol. An open-ended working group working on both of them would provide a more efficient and inclusive framework, allowing parties to address both issues without duplicating institutional arrangements or resources. After more than a decade of discussion, particularly on Article 10, we need to move beyond repeated exchange of views towards substantive progress. We would therefore support a time-bound working group with dedicated negotiating time for each issue, including one face-to-face meeting to develop recommendations for consideration at the COP/MOP7. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:50:14]: Thank you. And because we thank Egypt, and because we heard then one of you speaking in favor of the open-ended working group, I would also allow one intervention on the other side of the spectrum, just to balance things, if there are any volunteers. How about if I suggest we adopt the open-ended working group? would ever have any volunteers then? Norway? Okay, so now we have volunteers. So Switzerland, I think Norway withdrew its request. No, you're there. Okay, Norway. Mic to Norway, please. Norway [1:51:22]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Yeah, we would like to suggest that we also have the other virtual alternative in this CRP, and that's the open-ended informal advisory group. So, and if anyone else wants to add on that, please, but we need both the alternatives. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:51:48]: Thank you. So, thank you, Norit. No, I don't think there's a need to add on that because I said I will take one intervention from both sides. So what we will do then is to carry this document, which is actually quite well developed, and I thank you for your hard work. We will carry it over. with the approved clean text and turn it into an LDOC for further deliberation. But I would repeat that I would like consultations to take place on this item as well, as well as the previous item on specialized international access and benefit sharing instruments. All right, so it's now carried. It will now be turned into an L-dock. Thank you. So, change of guards. So now we'll have a small change of guards. And then again, to repeat, now the purpose is just to hear a report on resource mobilization from the Friends of the Chair group. We will not consider an ECRP. The purpose is to hear a report. And I will now give the floor to To Nisha, you have the floor. Tunisia · Friends of the Chair Co-Chair [1:53:56]: Thank you, Chair. As a brief report on the Friends of the Chair, we worked well. We were picking up pace and cleared several brackets. But unfortunately, for procedure, we had to cut off and come back to the working group session. I believe we will need about an hour and a half. We still have two criteria in the annex, the chapeau. of the annex or the relationship between the criteria and the preamble. So we seek your guidance as to when we could schedule the continuation. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:54:38]: Thank you very much, Iman. And I thank you and your co-chair for your continued hard work. Now let me consult to see when we can schedule these talks. Right, sorry about that. Yes, indeed. So, the thing is that There is the possibility of continuing the Friends of the Chair on resource mobilization for a limited time, I would say one and a half hour, but it will need the approval from the parties. as it would go over the 13 hours, which we have decided is sort of our general limit for working. But because it's Thursday and we finish tomorrow, and we have quite, I'm looking at the secretary, but we do have quite a load of work in front of us, we need to finish. So I would ask you for permission to meet, the friends of the chair group can meet after we finish this session of the Open-ended Working Group, and it will then work for one and a half hours. Do I see some objections to this, or, well, comments are also welcome. I know it's a big ask, so they're very welcome. Saudi Arabia [1:57:33]: Yes, thank you very much, Chair. This is not an objection. We would just like clarity on the mandate of the Friends of the Chair, because in your previous guidance and then the mandate that you provided to the Friends of the Chair group, you stated that the group will work on paragraph 17g. of the CRP. However, there is no paragraph 17G within the CRP. So if you may please clarify that and clarify the intention so that there's no confusion, it would be much appreciated. Thank you. CBD · Chair [1:58:22]: Yes, thank you, Saudi Arabia. So I know that this was not an objection. And indeed, when I gave the mandate, I wasn't, well, what do you say, entirely within my senses, I think, because indeed, i included 17G. which you rightly point out, doesn't exist. We can't work on texts or paras that don't exist. Even I understand that. But I also refer to para 2225 and 11 to 12 and 19 and 22. and the annex. And I also said that the text by the ministers will not be discussed by the friend of the chairs. Exactly. So that will still be the mandate. And with that correction, I think that's the task. Now, China, you have the floor. China [1:59:47]: Thank you, Chair. It's also not an objection. We just have concern that if all the friends are still available and still in the room, because otherwise, even we claimed it in the Friends of Chair, it will still be opened again during the next session of working group or plenary. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:00:22]: Yes, thank you, China, for that question, which is a good one. So I hear that the facilitators asked the delegates that are part of the Friends of the Chair group to either stay in the room or to be available. So I think there is Well, I wouldn't call it a system, but I think there is a way of reaching those delegates. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [2:01:01]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is also not an opposition to the friends of the co-chair. Just building upon the intervention made by distinguished delegation from Saudi Arabia, which we appreciate, we believe Paragraph 5 is also not part of the mandate, because this paragraph is covered by the document prepared, the non-paper prepared by the ministers. So just to seek your guidance and to have the mandate as clear as possible. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:02:08]: Yes, thank you, Brazil. And as you rightly point out, Para 5 is also in the ministerial paper, so we will not work on that. And thank you very much for your sharp observation. So we will not work on Para 5, and we will definitely not work on 17G. That doesn't exist. And, okay, Saudi Arabia, you have the floor. Saudi Arabia [2:02:39]: Yes, thanks again for giving me the floor, Chair. It would just be much appreciated to know when exactly and what the modality will be to discuss the ministerial proposal. This would provide us with adequate clarity. and would allow us to, of course, expedite discussions within the Friends of the Chair so that we may forward something back to the working group or plenary, whatever it is, based on your direction and guidance. This clarity would be much appreciated, and we seek your guidance. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:03:37]: Thank you, Saudi Arabia, for your good question. So my answer on this one is that it will be clarified in due course how we will treat those paras from the ministers that are still in brackets. Additional information is that regarding the When and where the Friends of the Chair will meet, we'll announce that on the screen. So you can follow the screen as well for more accurate information on that one. Russian Federation, you have the floor. Russian Federation [2:04:16]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. This is not an objection. Just we would like to clarify how the working group will continue from the point of view of the agenda items. Because if we have resource mobilization and the financial mechanism in parallel, that might create certain difficulties. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:04:45]: Yes, thank you, Russian Federation. It will not work in parallel. So that's how we will not have the financial mechanism and resource mobilization in parallel. Right. So that was it for resource mobilization. Of course, we will come back to that. So the next item on the list is digital sequence information. So we'll have a short break. Okay, so anyway, we'll have a short break in about for about two minutes. Thank you. All right. So before we turn to DSI, a small clarification regarding the resource mobilization, Friends of the Chair, where and when? Secretary. CBD · Secretariat [2:06:48]: Thank you very much, Chair. The Friends of Chair for the resource mobilization will meet when this session finishes, basically. So it's not parallel with any of the ongoing discussions, which are starting on digital sequence information and will be followed up by financial mechanism, and the room will be announced on the screen. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [2:07:10]: Thank you, Secretariat. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [2:07:15]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, and thanks for the clarification on the where and when the Friends of the Chair is going to meet. So, financial mechanism will be the last item. And just clarifying, and right after it, we have the Friends of Chair for RM, which means we are going beyond 11:00 PM if needed. And after it, we start the Friends of the Chair. Just to let us know if there is a specified time to start our work in Friends of Chair. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:07:57]: So, Secretary, do you have the floor? Thank you for your question. Yes. CBD · Secretariat [2:08:01]: So this session should finish at 11:15, and 11:15, the Friends of Chair group could meet. And that's why we, the Chair sought special permission that can we do that, and there was no objection. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:08:15]: All right. So, DSI. I would like to turn our attention back to COP Agenda Item 11 on digital sequence information and hear back from the facilitators of the Friends of the Chair group, established this morning and facilitated by Daniel Mukubi Kikuni from the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Mr. Thomas Greiber from Germany. So I would like to hear back from them to see whether there was any progress made with the outstanding issues on this topic. Mr. Daniel Mukubi Kikuni, you have the floor. Microphone to the Democratic Republic of Congo, please. Democratic Republic of the Congo · Friends of the Chair Co-Facilitator [2:09:08]: Thank you, Chair. On behalf of my co-facilitator, Thomas, and I, We would like to report that the group met twice today for a total of three hours, and we made some progress, good progress indeed, more specifically on several issues. We discussed extensively the preamble paragraphs and have an alternative text proposal, as well as some clean texts. We discussed paragraph 28 on governance, and the group agreed to keep the text bracketed as currently drafted for further consideration once receiving a revised document. On Annex 1, rule 11, The group agreed on the importance of discussing this in conjunction with paragraphs related to the nomination and selection of steering committee members. On the allocation methodology and Annex 2, The United Kingdom put forward a proposed text to streamline this section by removing Annex 2 and instead revising the operative paragraphs on allocation methodology to reflect on an option for allocation on an exceptional basis until COP18. This group worked on this basis, and made progress. However, we would benefit from further discussion on this topic, as not all paragraphs were discussed due to lack of time. While we were not able to come up with clean text, we were able to fulfill the mandate to conclude discussions on remaining paragraphs of the second version of the non-paper. We would like to bring to your attention raised questions on the way forward on this item, so we would benefit from any advice you have for us. We want to thank all delegates that participated in these groups and their great contribution that have contributed to advance this further. As you can see with my scarf on and my co-facilitator's hair style, we were all set to provide some yoga coaching. And the conclusion is that yoga works. It requires a bit more time. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:12:17]: Thank you, thank you, daniel. And I must say, i'm very glad for the work you and Daniel has put into this. I must say from my heart, I have a very bad hair day today. So, but yes, I'm glad that you have progress during these sessions. Now, I will take the views on the way forward, because you asked for advice as well. So on the way forward, I will take the views from the contact group, the two friends of the chair groups, and the outcomes of the ministerial consultations. which took place yesterday, and on this basis, I will prepare a Chair's text as CRP in consultations with the Secretariat. So this item has received many hours of discussion and many views, proposals, edits, and ideas that have been communicated, so I will use all of this material to deliver you a balanced document and where necessary, with some compromise text. Thank you. So that will be my way forward. And regarding the posting of this Chair's text, it will be as soon as possible. So, yes, Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [2:14:09]: Thank you very much, Mr. Co-Chair, and of course for your indication on the way forward. I do have a question concerning the fact that some parts of the draft tax that has been on the table, not all of it, a small part, we didn't really have a chance to look, to read it in the contact groups. So will we have an occasion to bring language that relates to these issues in the level of the working group? Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:14:55]: Thank you, Brasil. Yes, indeed, I will prepare a chair's text, which will be entertained as CRP. So definitely, yes, you will have the chance to discuss that document. So that's the next step. And also, there has been ongoing ministerial discussions on DSI as well that will be plugged in to the chair's text. So that will be plugged into the chair's text. So we'll use all of the documentation we have and try to craft a balanced text, but it will be entertained here in this working group. Brasilia, I'll go for. Brazil [2:16:05]: Thank you very much, Mr. Chair. Just for the sake of transparency, I wanted to share with the working group the area where Brazil thinks that we still might require a little bit further work. And this relates specifically to the mandate that the ATEG on allocation methodology would have As indeed was reported by the co-chairs of the Friends of the Chair, we did work on an exceptional modality to allow for the disbursement of funds from the Kali Fund in the period between COP17 and COP18. We also agreed that we need to reconvene an ATAC on the allocation methodology, and a point was made, and I think it was consensual in the room, that we cannot miss the opportunity here at COP17 to pretty much come with an understanding of what is the scope of the policy decisions that we as a COP are making in terms of the allocation methodology and send to the ATAC the technical work on this. So we need to clarify specifically what we need to do on criteria A, B, and C. as currently referred to, Brazil considers that we should develop an indicator specific to biodiversity species richness, considering biological diversity, territorial extent, and the extent of natural ecosystems. This is for criteria A. On criteria B, Brazil considers we should reformulate the indicator to clearly reflect the country of origin of the genetic resource from which DSI was derived, rather than the country in which DSI was generated or uploaded to the database. And on criteria And C, Brazil considers we should develop an indicator based on information available on NBSAPs as well as on national capacity development plans, reflecting capacity needs for the conservation of sustainable use of biodiversity. We have language for all of this, and we will also make it available with the Secretariat if you think it's helpful. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:18:03]: Thank you, Brazil. Yes, that will be helpful indeed. So please send the text to the Secretariat. Argentina, you have the floor. Argentina [2:18:10]: Thank you very much, Chair. We would like to agree with what's been said. And in session and repeated opportunities within the contact group, we need to express our disagreement with the way that this topic was addressed during the two weeks that we've already been here. We had many meetings and many hours. to be invested into discussing this topic, with general topics discussed, rather than actively evolving ourselves and looking at the text and discussing it in these fora. For the text to reflect the consensus adopted by the parties and setting out firmness where we need to, we have to really focus on the text. We can't just have general discussions on sections of the document, because this does not reflect the different positions. It's impossible for a text of the Chair, even with the goodwill that's been shown and with the extensive sharing of information, to really reflect the positions of the Parties if the Parties are not involved in the drafting. Therefore, this is going to be a long process in order to adopt this document, in particular because for several sessions of the Contact Group, These are presented as, for subparagraph, proposals of the Chair. Although they're welcome, they're only adopted as platforms on which parties then discuss the documents. These are not paragraphs agreed upon by the parties. I insist upon this. We have agreed to use these as the platform on which we will begin to discuss our particular proposals. On several occasions, these paragraphs are just diluted versions of agreements or disagreements that we've had during discussions and not reflect the vision of the parties, nor the agreements achieved, which came from last SBI. So I want to once again express our discomfort with the process, and we are expecting with great anxiety the documents, and when If we receive it, we will actively take part in this discussion. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:20:37]: Thank you, Argentina. And yes, indeed, it's always difficult when there's 196 parties that need to agree. And the issue or the challenge that is with the SI is that there was a lot of text proposals. coming from parties, and of course then we have, from our point of view also, it doesn't make our jobs easy either. So that's part of the reason why this was difficult. But I do hope that the Chair's proposal can help. I know it's late, but yes. We hope that that can help. Right, I see Panama, you have the floor. Panama [2:21:37]: Thank you, Chair. I would like to recall the last COP, because I'm going to say exactly the same as we said at the last COP on this topic. A lot was lacking in order to achieve consensus and documents, and we ran the risk of approving documents. which over the two last years we were trying to correct so they could function. And it was never explained to us why the same formula has been repeated with the same kind of L document which we got in Cali. Over the last two years, days, we had an L document which had not been consulted upon nor revised by parties. We are now faced with the same situation as that in Cali. So, Even though you're asking us for flexibility to achieve consensus in order to achieve this, we'll reach a time when we can't do this. So we're going to continue to try to find a solution, but do not pressure us for a decision. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:22:49]: Thank you, panama. Yes, but we're not there yet at the L stage. What I'll do now is I'll prepare a chair's proposal, which will be posted as a CRP. It will not be posted as an L. So it will get back to this working group. You're right about the time issue. I fully agree. But it's also It's also, I will put it back to your parties as well, because when we have two weeks, what we do as a community, it reflects the time we have at our disposal. So it's also a reflection of how we work together as a community and how fast we do it. So I would say that we have to improve. And we know there is an item called effectiveness that was approved as clean text earlier today that established a process, a part of the process to look at these issues, how we can work more effectively. So partly that I hope will in the end come that this group will come up with some proposal that will be considered by COP18 that can take some measures to see to that we work more effectively. Right, so I think that was it for DSI. And now we will turn to CRP CBD CRP 13/rev 1, which is item CBD 8b, financial mechanism. We will break for two minutes. All right. Let us turn our attention to CRP 13/rev 1 on COP agenda item 8b on financial mechanism. The CRP, sorry about that. The CRP was prepared. Yes, the CRP was prepared on the basis of the work of the Friends of the Chair, which met twice and with the help of Yewang of China and Inka Gnitke of Germany, advanced progress on several paragraphs. I would like to invite Ms. Inka Gnitke from Germany to report back. Ms. Knickke, you have the floor. Floor to Germany, please. Germany · Friends of the Chair Co-Chair [2:27:13]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good evening to everybody. On behalf of my co-chair, Yvonne, and me, I am pleased to report back on the work done by the Friends of the Chair, item 8b, the financial mechanism. The Friends of Chair met two times, yesterday and today. The group started from the first paras of the CRP 13 and read through to para 12i. We cleaned six paragraphs, but the rest still contains brackets. A small group has been working on paragraphs one to four, and my co-chair and I compiled relevant paragraphs related to Jeff for Annex 1. On behalf of the group. We are pleased to present the conference room paper 13/1 for consideration by this Working Group Plenary. On behalf of my co-chair, we thank all delegates and relevant organizations for their cooperation and flexibility and good mood in our working together on the financial mechanism issue. Thank you, Mr. Chair. CBD · Chair [2:28:25]: Thank you, Ms. Gnitke. So, despite good progress made during the Friends of the Chair, there remain unresolved brackets in the document that require further attention. The document also includes elements from other draft decisions that contain guidance to the JAF. As per practice, these have now been incorporated under Annex 1. Before we address the unresolved brackets, I would like to approve the clean paragraphs in the CRP. So, this, the clean paras includes Preambular paras and then the paras 5 to 10, 12A to E, and H to P, paras 13 to 20, para 21 A to D, para 25 to 26, paras 28 to 31, paras para 33, para 36, para 38, annex 1 to 4, 6 to 8, 11 to 13, and then on annex, the whole of annex 2, and Annex 3, 1 to 4A, and then C to L, and 5 to 9, and 11 to 12. DRC, you have the floor. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:31:05]: Thank you, Chair, for giving me the floor. I would just like to highlight the fact that in the first annex, there are paragraphs within brackets. So we won't be able to approve them as such, in particular, paragraphs 4 and 5. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:31:50]: So thank you. Thank you, DRC. I'll give the floor to the Secretariat to explain. CBD · Secretariat [2:32:00]: Thank you very much, Chair. So when we prepared this annex with the co-chairs, The text was based on CRP, and we have noted that Working Group 2 already adopted this decision with no bracketed text due to the additional in the document. So this paragraph four will be clean without the phrase you and additional, thank you. In order to keep a consistency with working group two decision. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:32:49]: Thank you very much, Secretariat. DRC, you have the floor. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:32:57]: Thank you, Chair, for giving me the floor. In the opening plenary, we said that since we are small delegations, we reserve the right to come back to issues for which we weren't able to take part in discussions. As you know, there were parallel sessions held of Working Groups 1 and 2 and the various contact groups. In Working Group 1, when we discussed the financing mechanism, which is under review here, there was no reference made to the commitments made in Working Group 2 or the compromises found there. Therefore, we won't be able to accept this because it hasn't been discussed in our own discussions on this agenda item under review in Working Group 1. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:34:03]: Thank you, DRC. Could you be more specific to what Paris or annex your concern relates to? Thank you. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:34:18]: I was speaking here of the first annex, paragraph four, as well as paragraph five. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:35:03]: Thank you, DRC. So what I propose is that when we come to, so this regards biodiversity and health, and it regards synthetic biology, if I'm not mistaken. So if that's correct, I think this is Annex 1. Yes, it's Annex 1. And paragraph 4 relates to biodiversity and health. Here I have a text on new and additional in my version, which is in brackets, and then the whole para 5 is in brackets in my version, at least. So as you just will just address it when we get there. So, so as you nodding, good. EU, you have the floor. EU [2:35:54]: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We just note that in paragraph 1 in three places, the word "dedicated" is used and it's not bracketed. We'd like to clarify then if that is basically a fait accompli, because it doesn't reflect the situation that will be in the body of the decision where we've avoided references to dedicated funding. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:37:22]: Thank you, EU, but as I understand it, the Annex 1, the additional guidance to the JEF from the Cartagena Protocol, where there are requests to the JEF, has already been entertained in the MOP and is it looks clean to me, so I'm not reopening new text. So I hope you can live with that, because that's in line with my previous guidance, and I don't want to sort of destroy the guidance I've been developing myself. So, EU, you have the floor. EU [2:38:16]: It's regrettable because there was never an opportunity for JEF experts to discuss it, and we raised the issue that something like this might happen. But however, we have to be guided by your ruling. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:38:32]: Thank you, EU, for your flexibility. I'll take the two interventions I see now from Saudi Arabia and Norway, and then we'll go back to approving the clean paras, and then we'll go on to work on the bracketed paras. Saudi Arabia, you have the floor. Saudi Arabia [2:38:55]: Thank you very much, Chair. With regards to paragraphs 1 to 4 of the main decision, We see that the language there is not consistent with what was discussed within the Friends of the Chair earlier this morning. We would like clarification on where that language went and whether it will be discussed or brought back to this text. This is because we made a lot of progress, and we would wish to see this progress reflected so that we wouldn't open up these discussions once again in the working group. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:39:41]: Thank you, Saudi Arabia. Right, so this will be parked for now because we're awaiting the results of a small group. So that will not be discussed here. So that's the approach. Thank you. Norway, you have the floor. Norway [2:40:05]: Thank you, Chair. And referring to the intervention just now by my good colleague from the European Union, we too find it regrettable that we will not be able to discuss certain parts of paragraph one of Annex 1, where we see that it would have been very useful to have it discussed in the group of JEF experts. So, like the EU, we of course abide with your ruling, but we would like to state that this is an unfortunate situation. Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [2:40:45]: Thank you, Norway. China, you have the floor. China [2:40:49]: Thank you, Chair. If you allow me, I want to have some clarification on paragraph 1 to 4. I hope can help Saudi Arabia to have better understanding of the procedures, because our original intention is to have the small group working on paragraph 1 to 4, but unfortunately, not all parties in the small group can agree on the co-chairs' proposal. That's why we're still waiting for some parties confirm, so we didn't replace the paragraph 1 to Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:41:22]: Thank you very much, Shaina. That indeed helps us to understand why we cannot work on 1-2-4 at this stage. Thank you very much. Brazil, you have the floor. Brazil [2:41:34]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. With regards to the last intervention made by distinguished delegation from Saudi Arabia and also by China, we would like to kindly ask our colleagues, delegations present in this session, to reach China with regards to the paragraphs we have discussed this morning in the Friends of Presidency, we have made a lot of progress in that section. We have paragraphs that are almost totally cleaned. And This is a 16-page document. It's almost midnight. We need to finish. We really seek your indulgence, colleagues, so we can move ahead and approve this document and send it to plenary. And it also applies to the reference made to dedicated. As Brazil, we also would like to discuss a lot of paragraphs that were already cleaned, that we already discussed in the SPI, but this is the spirit of compromise, and that's what we are seeking tonight. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:42:47]: Thank you, Brazil, and I'm very thankful for this intervention, which is, i think, is a sensible approach. DRC, you are the floor. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:43:03]: Thank you, Chair. It has been a very long day. But you'll recall that this morning, I flagged that there were first informal consultations on the financial mechanism, and then there were the friends of the chair that met on the same point. But the integrity of our group here is starting to be questioned, Mr. Chair. We need to avoid that situation. If you look at the procedure that we're seeing now and the statements that have been made and that are being made, we see there's that the efforts we are making are now at risk. These efforts to reverse biodiversity loss are at risk, because if we continue in this direction, the KMGBF runs the risk of facing the same sad fate as the ICHEP plan. And that is why, Mr. Chair, we would like to be able to touch base with everybody who's working on these texts and everybody who is involved with the discussions, so that we can correctly reflect the discussions in the text. And also so that we don't constantly go back to things that have already been agreed. We're out of time. There are many documents that still need to be considered. Tomorrow, we don’t know whether we’re going to be working until 4:00 or 5:00 in the morning on Saturday. There’s a lot still to be done, and you need to tell us how we’re going to analyze the rest of the document. If we have wording that casts doubt on all the efforts that have been done, that’s not going to work. One small example, Mr. Chair, in paragraph one of this document, it says that in May, the pledges made as of May 2026 reached 4.4 billion US dollars. Is this correct? The report that we had from the GEF mentions 3.9 billion dollars. But who could read that report and then take this seriously. How do we need to proceed? Thank you, Chair. CBD · Chair [2:45:54]: Thank you, DRC. Yes, indeed. So my approach is still to try to work on the bracketed Paris. So I ask you now if we can approve the clean preamble Paris and the Paris I read out. So we will approve. that text in order to move forward, and then we will work on the bracketed paras, starting with paragraph 11. So I take it we can approve the clean text, as I see no one asking for the floor. So let's approve them. They're hereby approved, and let's start to work with paragraph 11. So regarding paragraph 11, Regarding paragraph 11, sorry, I just have to find it. There it is. It hasn't disappeared. It actually exists. That's good. Can we approve the paragraph, lifting all the brackets with the understanding that decision 17 and we don't have the number yet, but on resource mobilization, will have to be updated by editors once adopted by this COP. I will repeat, can we, because it's getting late, can we approve the paragraph lifting all the brackets with the understanding that decision 17-something on resource mobilization will have to be updated by editors once adopted by this COP. I see DRC, you have the floor. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:47:42]: Thank you, Chair. I would like this paragraph to remain in brackets because it's linked to paragraph 21, part of which is also in brackets. So we would like to analyze them in parallel when we can. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:48:04]: Thank you, DRC. It will stay in brackets. I ask the other parties to lower their flags. We'll now go to paragraph 12f. And 12F is about sustained and enhanced support for all eligible parties, and in particular, and then we have a certain category of countries in brackets. So I have noted that there is no bracket around in the context of paragraphs 5, 6 and 7 of Article 20 of the Convention in subparagraph 12 above, and thus suggest using the same phrase in this subparagraph, that is to delete the phrase "landlocked developing countries", which is in brackets, least developed countries, small island developing states. And then. So I'll ask Secretariat to read this suggestion out. Thank you, Secretary. CBD · Secretariat [2:49:43]: Thank you. Chair's proposal is sustaining enhanced support for all eligible parties, in particular, in the context of paragraphs 5, 6, and 7 of Article 20 of the Convention by reducing transaction costs and onwards. CBD · Chair [2:50:19]: DRC, you have the floor. Interpreter [2:50:24]: We regret to announce that interpretations come to an end. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:50:26]: Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:51:10]: So, DRC, you have the floor. I noted that I think we lost translation. Maybe that's what you want to address. DRC, you have the floor. Democratic Republic of the Congo [2:51:21]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, for the floor. I was saying that I support your proposal, and thanks to the Secretariat for reading this. This can be supported by us. And since I have the floor, it is the time you told us that we will adjourn this meeting. So we are asking you to adjourn this meeting and to start the Friends of Chairs. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:51:53]: Thank you, DRC. Yes, indeed. I didn't look at the time. I'm sorry. I was so happy to go on here. But yes. But before that, I assume that there is no opposition against approving the paragraph as amended. So it is hereby approved. Well, wait a minute. Switzerland, do you want to continue the session? Is that what you're asking for the floor? Switzerland, please. Switzerland [2:52:26]: Good evening. I'm just asking for clarification. Was the "all" retained or was it deleted? Because that was also in brackets. Thank you very much. CBD · Chair [2:52:40]: Secretariat, please. CBD · Secretariat [2:52:44]: For sub-paragraph F, the "all" was not in brackets. Thank you. CBD · Chair [2:52:54]: Yes, so it was not in brackets, so it is retained. Is that okay, Svesen? I can't see you, but I have the feeling you're nodding. So, okay, so it is approved as amended, and we will now shortly end this session. Are there some announcements from the Secretariat? No. So, yes. So we'll end now so the small group can commence its work. And I thank you for all your flexibility and your hard work and your continued engagement. Thank you very much.