Skip to main content

Press Conference: Cali Fund: Beyond the Debates around Money in and Money Out, UN Convention on Biodiversity - COP 17

28 October·04:00·01:05:38Conferences

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

Moderator

Good morning, everyone, and welcome to this Kali Fund: Beyond the Debates Around Money In and Money Out, organized by Third World Network. We are surprised to see today morning, early morning letter from presidency talking specifically about money in and money out. So I think our positioning is also in very clear that what we are actually looking more than money in and money out. The world is debating, as you see, how much money should flow into Kali Fund and who should receive it and how its use should be monitored. But we must ask a more fundamental question. Can playing into Kali Fund become a license to exploit genetic resources and their digital sequence information without accountability? If companies can anonymously access DSI, develop products, claim intellectual property, and generate profits, while providers remain unaware of how their resources are used, can a small financial contribution in the end of value chain make that system fair and equitable? The Kali Fund is only the financial component of CBD's broader multilateral mechanism. Fair benefit sharing must mean more than money changing hands. It must also mean respect for rights, accountability for access and use, and meaningful participation by countries, indigenous people, local communities whose biodiversity underpins the scientific innovation. Today, our speakers will examine what is at stake and what must change. And for those of you who would like to have an easy reader on DSI and Kali Fund, Friends of Earth Malaysia has made this booklet, and it's available with us. We'll share it as soon as you want it. So let me first invite the first speaker, Mr. Daudi Manongi. I'm sorry if I am spelling or pronouncing your name in a wrong manner. From the Alliance for Food Sovereignty Africa, Dawoodi, how should we judge the success of Kali Fund beyond the amount of money collected? What tangible changes should farmers and local communities see in their livelihoods, capacity, and control over their resources? Three minutes to four minutes for you. Thank you.

AFSA

Thank you. Thank you for this opportunity. Let us be realistic, the Cali Fund alone cannot resolve every challenge associated with digital sequence information. However, its implementation must complement the broader multilateral mechanism and must not undermine national sovereignty, community rights, opportunities for local research and enterprise. So our message as Alliance of Food Sovereignty in Africa The success of the Kalyfun should not be measured by how much money comes in or how much money goes out, but it's whether it delivers meaningful, fair, measurable benefits for the people who sustain biodiversity. The real test is simple. Are communities gaining greater capacity, stronger livelihoods, more control over their resources, and meaningful in their role. So, are we shaping the future with the caliphate? So if this outcome is missing, then we must ask whether benefit sharing is truly equitable. That's our message from the Alliance of Food Sovereignty in Africa.

Moderator

Thank you, Dawdi. I now invite Professor Gustavo Soldati from the Federal University of Juiz de Fora, Brazil. Professor, can you-- sorry. There's a question for you. OK. Sorry, there is a question for you. Can open science truly be equitable if DSI can be accessed anonymously without adequate safeguards for consent, provenance, and rights of those who provide the underlying genetic resources?

UFJFProfessor

Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you, Nitin, for your question. First, I would like to acknowledge the presence of Cristiane Pincararu, a leading indigenous representative in Brazil on issues related to assets and benefits sharing. All the position I will present here were developed in close collaboration with her. The multilateral mechanism must be seen not merely as a financial mechanism. but as an important opportunity to strengthen rights. For indigenous peoples and local communities, four fundamental rights must be protected: prior informed consent, traceability, fair and equitable benefit sharing, and effective participation in data governance. However, public DSI databases have historically developed without adequate respect for the authority and the rights of parties, indigenous peoples, and local communities. Combined with the implementation of open science without adequate safeguards, this creates a risk of new forms of biopiracy, enabling the biodiverse and associated traditional knowledge without accountability, sorry, traceability, responsibility, or ethical safeguards. The DSI databases operate under principles and practices that raise important concerns. particularly open access and reuse of genetic information without prior consent. We support open science, but open science cannot mean the absence of rights. Furthermore, we must question the asymmetry in how open science is implemented. Today, there is a strong emphasis on open science into genetic data, often originating from the global south. But much less attention is given to ensure equality, open access to benefits generated from this data. Open science cannot mean open access to our biodivest while the benefits of scientific progress remain restricted to a few. So, first, we need standardized, interoperable, and persistent metadata. Sorry, I lost. This should include information on the origin of genetic resources, associated traditional knowledge, prior informed consent, and applicable conditions for subsequent access and reuse. Second, we need access to DSI databases through registered and identifiable user account. Open science must mean free of charge access to scientific information, but not anonymous access. Identifying users does not prevent scientific research. It allows us to understand who is accessing genetic information to establish accountability. Of course, developing a global system of registered use requires time, technical capacity, and financial resource. But these challenges cannot become an excuse of postponing the protection of the rights of the providers' country, indigenous peoples, and local communities. If we cannot change existing databases outside of CDB framework, we need to begin to establish a CDB database or invite the site databases to enter into agreements with the convention. This is how once the International Gene Bank becomes accountable to part two FAO by entering into agreements with FAO plant trade. Third and final, indigenous peoples and local communities must have effective participation in the governance of the side databases, including decision on access condition, reuse, and the protection of associated traditional knowledge. Thank you.

Moderator

Thank you, professor. I now invite Katie Lee Riddle from Te Kōtahi Research Institute, New Zealand. Thank you.

IIFBCo-Lead, DSI Working Group

Thank you, Nithin. My name's Katie Lee. I am one of the co-leads of the International Indigenous Forum on Biodiversity's working group on DSI. We are at a very pivotal moment to shape how digital sequence information is linked to indigenous peoples and local communities. As parties consider the implementation of the multilateral mechanism and the KALI fund, it is very important to recognize that despite being observers in the CBD process, indigenous people and local communities are often not merely stakeholders, but also rights holders. We are having enduring relationships, responsibilities, and obligations for our genetic resources, biodiversity, and associated traditional knowledge. Part of the success of the new multilateral mechanism can be measured not just by the way it addresses, it can be measured by the way it addresses underlying governance challenges that have emerged with increasing digitization of biodiversity. A fair and equitable system requires meaningful recognition of indigenous rights and meaningful participation in decisions about how DSI is governed. This includes embedding indigenous provenance metadata. as well as transparency and accountability across the entire DSI life cycle, from collection and sequencing through to storage, access, use, and the development of downstream products and innovations, as well as operationalising the CARE principles. Without mechanisms that maintain Indigenous provenance and connections to data, we cannot understand and influence how DSI is derived from our biodiversity and see how it is being used. And there is a risk that digital technologies will simply reproduce the same inequalities that Indigenous peoples have long experienced in relation to their genetic resources. There are already important examples that demonstrate options for the path forward, by learning from the approaches taken from databases such as one in my country, Manaaki Whenua, which have built Indigenous provenance into their metadata systems and utilize the local context biocultural labels and notices. This means that Indigenous rights and interests are made visible within the data itself and is able to flow interoperably to other databases such as GBIF. By looking at existing practices and listening to the voices of Indigenous people and local communities, we can begin to build DSIs systems and practices that support both scientific innovation and Indigenous peoples and local communities' rights and interests. The challenge before us is not to choose between science and Indigenous rights. It is to choose and ensure that the future governance of DSIs built on the pinnacles of fairness, transparency, accountability, and respect for Indigenous authority and voices from the outset all the way through the data life cycle. Thank you.

Moderator

Thank you, Katie, for reminding us that Indigenous peoples are right holders and not merely stakeholders, and the importance of Indigenous data governance in this. Thank you. Now, let me invite Teva Lingam from Friends of the Earth Malaysia. Teva, we have taken note of a poster which you have developed on Kali Fund accountability upside down. Would you please tell us about the poster? Thank you.

FoE Malaysia

Thanks a lot, Nitin, and good afternoon to everyone. I am from Friends of the Earth Malaysia, and we work a lot with indigenous communities in Malaysia. And what we have done is that we have actually shown the difference of accountability and governance, or the lack thereof, on the one hand of DSI data banks and vis-a-vis the KALI Fund. So this is what we have done. We made it simple. Hopefully, for everyone to understand. And we'll make this available to every one of you if you would like to have a look at it after this. So the core problem is really very simple. The system is actually the toughest on those who are seeking benefits, and they are weakest on those who are extracting value out of it. And when we look at DSI, countries, indigenous communities, indigenous peoples and local communities provide biodiversity of genetic resources, and often knowledge and stewardship that makes DSI possible. But once the DSI enters public databases, users can often access, download, and use it with little meaningful traceability. And then you have commercial users who may develop products, patents, and profits from DSI without having to identify themselves, obtain approval from providers, enter benefit sharing agreements, or disclose exactly how the DSI is being used. And there is often no systematic screening of these users for human rights risk, biosafety, and biosecurity concerns, or past misconduct. The people and companies benefiting from DSI can therefore remain largely invisible. Meanwhile, we have countries and communities seeking support from the Kali Fund who face eligibility checks, financial risk assessment, binding agreements, project requirements, reporting obligations, audits, inspections, and possible suspension or return of funds. So the question really is, why are biodiversity rich countries and communities treated as the risk to be managed, while corporations accessing and commercializing biodiversity data are treated as trusted actors? So this turns benefit sharing into a donor recipient relationship rather than a question of justice. Communities are made to prove that they are worthy of receiving funds. while users are not required to prove that they have acted responsibly. And that is not fair and equitable benefit sharing. It is actually accountability upside down, and that's exactly what we are saying here. So, benefit sharing actually begins with accountability at the point of access and profits, not only at the point where funds are distributed. And we really need to reverse this imbalance, making commercial users visible, requiring disclosure and due diligence, and make benefits accessible to communities without treating them as a financial risk. There must also be robust user accountability, where there must be registration or disclosure for commercial DSI use, transparent reporting on users and benefits, and forcible contributor obligations, human rights due diligence, and effective oversight of databases and users. At the same time, access to benefits for provider countries and communities must be direct, must be fair, and must be free from disproportionate burdens. Thank you.

Moderator

Thank you, Teva. Now let me conclude our statements with you with a few concluding remarks, and then we'll open the floor for any questions.

To just to say what I hear from my friend. Сай, әркіне хабар тәлізі және бұл мәқке кен сапасының, пайпаның, егкәй оңықтауларынан форум нәрім. Бәйт миозкомитс, бәткемәтәцел әрәйн, тәйіншбесін, һәмәнкнәре, пайпанум, әйст рессурскнәре, егіншбеснән кароген, маснакцел, ег арашнорцел, тегум, хетазотакан, ег гитаканашкатанкнәре, ег тиракан, макардаков, да анеләһенз артар ег. Havasar bashman hen simkne, ajo ishte arja shqetaj dramake në vjetra të cënnerë. Aisima sto mëngte së lëngte, inçpesen ananun ma celi cënë, hajorta kanu cënnerin, harca kan i takde, num masnaxtjucjan i raonkë resursneri, jev gjenagë asman mëc. Konvekcia e postko optas në veqti vore shumneri, nuhine kan asnele Verqerës, mi gytnekan motëcelëra e tjëllnerish në maranë e izmekin, global vorë vorë vorë se pakana tere, global Evropakën, Jevjaponakën, u Amerikën, kërëcunëri hamatëk se pakana zënërr. Na voroshële, ajdësa i oktagurtman vëra, tullutvotunë tërëz, jevn tharapës merjvëz, herë para kël drahiman vëra katratëta dësenar zunknëre, jev Arjanavat, handesnerumraparekiloamrda, am puxarneli paymaneri. Heman am dimela karavori tsunerin, hantreluv, rajarvelait paymaneri. Hetkan chelait paymanere. Sami arazin gurz, devkirvorin yestekasa, koptasiyotid na xashmin, baisnamanonak mikhani, devkir, artanarsanagrelan ashkarovmek. Yevasmiye karavor orinak berelo. Yete, paraniev, Kyun tashan kazma kerputjan praktika e neng, mi qezgajn genetiq bankeri sermanjute. Vazhenvume arsuna verekan derë kataneni, baqë informacioni që ka arënte ove i skape sot vuma e të sermerit, je vinçinor ghitelik, je vinçinor sortërendraniq, araqe ata, vere darsvum. Ayni ergenleri ishhanutsunlerin kam hovaqosnerin vuron iyakanum isqizbane azgayim genetik bankerin pastelein ait serman yutov. Yete genetik bankere sekvensavoren ait sermereyev ananun macheli darsneninche vuranumen henzima, diyse ayt velneri shtemaranneryum. Sangatsa cail pastoren yerkun patakoven sermere tervum. بهنکرین، سلیکشن پاتاک نری همار، هیما دران کاروگنار، اکتا گورسول، سندی وراما شاکمان، برش کاکان، آرشا پاوچیان، یفشاتایل چوهری کومیت، ارانز، واره، پارتاوریچون ستانزnelو، باشخلو، و درانستاسا زوکوت نره، شاهرونرین. یه دره، د، ایت پراکتیکان اشخاتومه اندم تیراکانه هم نری بنیک. ژوور نری شاهری، زارگاسووی کینری، و مایتوکسوف کوزئی، اوارتل مر. Mamalo hajta e rreçunë, është nërka kazma kërpuçunëri, jeha hatnëri ko mitje, baceng. Jete në kërrecunëre ka vunë ananun oktovel di saj, sa jero tashkëri cansi himna kanu versne, moshë këllohamarë rënza rta dëte saknere. Yemushaken, tehnologianeriya prankatizakner, heto matavshse pakantsyan, i ranxner penden drans handep, arans nahapes irazek v hamazani tsun stanalu dran nepastaznerit, sa chikaroh artarye bhavasaleni. Ananon matsheliutsune 90, mašta bagorume, ais kheome kalifon do chikaroh, satarel jentha karosvaskin, vorre khatarume kensa bazmazanutsyana. Hantrem harcer.

Speaker 10

Snaraku, jest telefonem, mislra grohem, interpretarajcunit, ajpesi timic. Jeves jerku harcunem, meke profesor Gustavo Ineuvac, miuse te vain. Baitsmiusnerne karoren patas khaner tsankhusan debkhun. Professor Gustavo, shnera kalsunem haytnu. Es teresatsits, haskasa vortuk neshetëk hashvetora kanucyan, heta qe celucyan e patas khanatvucyan, aranska e nxhën timerre. Kuzei haskanal, ajis koptasne ioti shurjanek neru, injh karore dursgal borpes konkuret. Gorzochutsun, muntahmane yerkore menatsela, ismenatsa jamanakatvatsom inchkale, anel, yreshkhurulohamar vor avlimets hashvetva kanutsun, khangetsni, avli lafhetaketselutsun, yev patas khanatvutsun. Tvanashain sekvensavraman, tvelnere tesankuni, tekror tarsetevayne haasteg, razuk mehtarkirbanishetaketsik, kasasikvor. Gocununi yergur, vortvanashayn gitelek nire karoghen, chetevan cherkayti nirdi borde asets. Vortvanashayn gitelekhe karoghe hangesnii nuin anhavasaratsun nirin, inchur, vauriden vaurd menk bolores paykaru menk ieskuzei, bolorat andradarnayk, avelit avalun, aitmatski shurch, inch tipi anhavasaratsan masiner khoske. Rogolcha.

Moderator

It is Portuguese, and there is no provision for Portuguese. Yes, yes.

BrazilIndigenous representative

Tenham tentado trabalhar no Brasil sinergias com vários instrumentos internacionais, principalmente o novo tratado da ONP, que nós fizemos uma grande discussão em 2024 e conseguimos vencer dentro da Organização Mundial da Propriedade Intelectual a inclusão do GSI, assim também como os conhecimentos tradicionais associados.

Chris is saying that she is working with a lot of international treatment, especially with the treatment about international property, WIPO, International WIPO Organization, property intellectual in the context of GSI.

And we need to walk together, because it was not a closed point, it was an open point, empty, and we need to connect these points.

Okay, Chris is feeling that this issue is not in the table here, in the COP 17. The issue is that the SI, the World International Property Organization, now you have to register, you have to inform that there is traditional knowledge in a patent context. So please this feeling that this issue is not in the table in the COP 17. Chris is asking for you, for us, if this is a real important issue that makes sense, because she think that, oh, it makes sense for go forward in this discussion. She is asking about that.

Moderator

Would you like to take the questions first?

BrazilIndigenous representative

And then we can.

UFJFProfessor

OK. I can change Portuguese and English. Sorry, Telapo, it's your name?

Speaker 16

Stella.

UFJFProfessor

Stella. Stella, I will try to, of course, I'm not a full English speaker, but I will try to answer you. First, to make all of this attempt, I think that we have responsibilize the DSI data bank. We have to recognize that DSI is a genetic heritage. You know, just like in Brazilian law, this is very clear. DSI is a Brazilian genetic heritage. And to access a Brazilian genetic heritage, you have to explain who is access, what you have to do, what are going to do. And then you have also to explain if there is local knowledge associated with this genetic heritage. So probably the first step is to recognize that DSI is genetic heritage of the country, and the country has his responsibility about that. Also, like I told, probably we can make-- wait a moment. agreements between the CBD and this big data bank. It's a second possibility. But the problem, the two most important, is to create a universal group of metadata that are implemented to all Gen. banks and standardized and interoperable. But more important, I think that is more important, this DSI cannot be used, or sorry, reused without prior consent. So the prior consent need to be in metadata that will be grounded with, joined with this information all of the life of this information. And the last one. the most important also, that we have a beautiful one experience in Brazil that is guided by Christiane Pancararu. It's a use of flora project. It's a Brazilian popular bank about governance of traditional knowledge. Christiane is the main leader of this project. And what I want to say, the local people, indigenous people, need to be inside the governance of this information? It's important to the all. Sorry, I wish that I. Thank you.

Moderator

I think the question can be addressed out of the 30 minutes. May I request Katie to probably respond to the question raised to you?

AFSA

Thank you. Yeah, I would love to respond to that and maybe just give a link to your question. For Africa, benefit sharing must be more than financial transfers, and it must also translate into tangible benefits of indigenous people, local communities, and farmers. We've been looking at the discussion going on. the industry is pushing for the blanket certificates. And if we have these blanket certificates, I'll give you an example, because someone would ask maybe for Bambara groundnut certificate, then they might get a DSI certificate over Bambara, maybe a certain variety. But they can use the same certificate to say, "We paid for this." So, you know, the Bambara cultivar has so many varieties in it. So they can use that certificate to say we paid for this, and they can take a lot of the DSI information from that Bambara groundnut varieties. So we are looking at following the compliance is one thing, but it has to be really linked to what is taken out of from the community. So communities must have meaningful voices. and voices in decision making, but also their participation cannot end when genetic material is collected or when digital sequence information is made publicly. So it should be, benefit sharing should also strengthen the local capacity. And this should go hand in hand with the level of understanding and the level of our local institutions and local experts understanding the issues related to digital sequence information and how the laws within the country about domestication of the treaty and access and benefit sharing can be practically beneficial to the countries.

Moderator

Thank you, Daudti. May I invite Katie, too?

IIFBCo-Lead, DSI Working Group

Thank you. I will answer both questions at the same time because my answer is interlinked. So throughout history, we have seen a lot of colonial and extractive research processes and practices that position Indigenous people as providers and beneficiaries, and we are people who give so much without receiving much in return. and receiving benefits in order to enable our conservation activities and conserving biodiversity. But not only this, we are also, as Indigenous people, entrepreneurs and users of DS-I itself. We want to have access to DS-I to help it to inform our practices and the work that we're already doing, and we want to also use it for our own commercial purposes as well. So when we ask for being connected to our data, it is not purely for benefit sharing from external people who want to engage with us, also for ourselves to be able to find out which information is out there that is held about our lands, waters, and territories. And we do our conservation and biodiversity work often without external support. We are already doing this work, and we want to be enabled to continue to do that. And as part of the work that is coming out of COP17, there's going to be intercessional work done on creating educational materials that are led by Indigenous peoples. We are able going to be able to provide guidance about the governance of data linked to Indigenous peoples and the operationalisation of the CARE principles and all of these wonderful things that we've been wanting to provide guidance on for a long time. So it's going to be an exciting two years ahead for that. And also it links in with WIPO and their new genetic resources treaty, because there is a disclosure of associated traditional knowledge. And we are seeing that this conversation about Indigenous links to data, as well as Indigenous links to traditional knowledge, is becoming increasingly prevalent in all international spaces. We've seen this conversation in BBNJ as well. And so this increase in connection and provenance and governance of data is being called for in many international spaces. And we need to use this time wisely to allow Indigenous people to speak with their own voice about what our expectations are and what we want going forward. There's also things coming out like the IEEE guidelines about Indigenous provenance, metadata, and data associated with Indigenous peoples. And there's also research coming out of different academic institutions and out of indigenous research in which people are actively providing guidance on this as well that we're hoping to see collected as part of the two-year process to bring it all together and be able to provide guidance on that.

Moderator

Thank you, Katie, for that wonderful ending note. Just to conclude by discussions on the WIPO and the current process, it is exactly the problem. how you handle the knowledge and the products coming out of the use of DSI, right? We are talking about benefits arising out of the use of DSI. And if at the upstream, you are not able to engage with the researchers and industries and manage a contract, understand how you collaborate and participate. Then, towards the end, having a disclosure after some company taking up an intellectual property right is not going to help anybody. It's going to be a very bad bargain for the communities and the competent authorities. So therefore, we think it's very, very important to think about how do communities actually be able to exercise their sovereignty over the data use. Thank you. All of thanks, we are available. We have the EC reads on DSI, Cali Fund mechanism, as well as the poster Friends of the Earth Malaysia mentioned, and also some studies on databases and intellectual property rights. If anybody's interested, can take it from us. Thank you.