8th Meeting - 2nd Session Group of Governmental Experts on Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems 2025
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Could I ask you to take your seats again? Excellencies, distinguished delegates, before lunch, I had a few remarks stating that with regard to the text, as we will soon again have on the screen, we made some progress with regard to changing human user into human operator. The suggestion on functionally integrated is getting increasingly support as a refinement of what we have now there. We had also a discussion on the chapeau to make a change there that would then probably get more, even more support within the room, so that's helpful. And let me also recall that two delegations, the delegation of Singapore and the delegation of the US, made some proposals with regard to select and engage, something I choose not yet to change any text on because I simply did not feel comfortable to do so. But of course, let me remind you that we now have two proposals. So if you we have opened the discussion on that. So that's that we should not forget about that, because that is, of course, one of the main issues we still have to solve. Having said that, please, again, let me put that in the wider framework that We can't solve all issues with regard, all sensitive issues in just one box. Please be reminded that we are talking about a set of elements. So as was earlier said also in the discussion, this is a characterization, but then we go wider when we talk about possible prohibitions, regulations, measures. That could, of course, then subsequently narrow down or clarify certain issues that we can't all fix in box one. Let me now continue with the list of speakers. I have Belarus, Canada, Israel, the United Arab Emirates, France, Luxembourg, Italy, Belgium. And we are looking around. Yeah, we see Nottingham, Bulgaria. We will closely monitor the room and add you to the list. And if I'm not referring to you in up in due time, please raise your hand with your plaque. But I will now first pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Belarus.
You have the floor.
I apologize. Thank you very much, distinguished Chair. At the outset, I would like to express to you my gratitude for this new version of the text. My delegation would like to make some comment about the critical functions of laws. In connection with paragraph 1 of the new version of the text, we support the compromise approach that was proposed by the distinguished delegate of Singapore in connection with the term "identify" in the context of the explanations about this term that were made by the Russian Federation. We agree with the distinguished delegate from Russia who said that our mandate is limited only to laws and not any autonomous systems. I'd like to say the following. Since we talk about the responsibility and obligation of states to ensure that laws are not just in compliance with norms of international law and IHL, but in light of international law, it is very important to include the parameter "identify" because an error in identification may result in a violation of international law. The result of erroneous identification is publicly known, and it may lead to additional subsequent errors that may lead to irreparable consequences, for example, the wounding or killing of individuals by armed forces or the police, because during the first stage, the authorities felt that the identification was correct, trusting the system because it protects higher values. Also, the term "identify" in paragraph 1 may be relevant in cases of violation of the principle of non-use of force. These are the situations where lethal force is not applied, but and in case the action of such machines may seriously undermine the questions of security and international security. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of Belarus, and let me now pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Canada, to be followed by Israel and the United Arab Emirates. But first, Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. My delegation appreciates the time and effort that you and your team have made in moving this text forward. We welcome the inclusion of the additional framing in the chapeau by adding a reference to the elements of an instrument. On para one, we would recommend changing functional to integral, which would not presuppose that the system needs to be physically integrated. Additionally, on functionality, this could indicate only that a component would work and not that it is linked to laws. By reintroducing the word integral, it would make it clear that the components are necessary to ensure that a system is capable of its intended outputs. As has already been mentioned, a combination of previous and new language to refer to functionally integrity would also be an acceptable compromise. We would support the change in wording from user to operator. Operator defines more precisely the role in activating a system to operate autonomously. Moreover, Canada interprets the selection process of select and engage to encompass identification, which is important in IHL compliance. Therefore, we support the wording as is. On the proposal made to add of these and other tasks necessary to initiate and execute an engagement, we would propose the following. of tasks assisting in the initiation and execution of an engagement. We believe this would allow a more direct formulation focusing on the tasks specific to achieving the mission's output. And finally, we support the Chair's approach on the term "lethality" and support the simplified formulation. Canada agrees with the reformulation stating that the effects of laws may extend beyond the loss of life. And we also find the formulation in para. 3 acceptable. I thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of Canada for comments and the views of his delegation. Next on my list is United Arab Emirates, to be followed by France and Luxembourg. But first, sorry, next on my list is Israel, to be followed by the United Arab Emirates. So you have the floor, Israel.
Thank you, Chair. First, we would like to positively note a new chapeau in the text of box 1, which in our view contributes to a clear and more logical structure. Regarding the first paragraph in the revised box 1, with respect to the change of the word integrated to functional, we struggle understanding its practical meaning and how it qualifies the definition. We're concerned it does not, and we think that clear language is needed to ensure certainty in determining which components are part of the system and which are not. Therefore, we request to retain the word "integrated" in the text while adding the words "they're integral" before the words "technological components." We do support India's proposal in this direction. Second, as we stated before, it is very important in our view that the word "can" in paragraph one be changed to "designed." in line with common terminology in international law applicable to weapons, including in the CCW. There is a reason why definitions of weapons are based on design, in particular, since they delineate more clearly the types of weapons under consideration, and since they better reflect the element of intended circumstances of use, which is a crucial element in defining and reviewing weapons. We believe it is helpful to maintain the language that has already been agreed upon by many states here in the context of other protocols, as it ensures clarity and facilitates implementation. In addition, with regards to the functions of LAWS, we believe the uniqueness of LAWS in comparison to many other weapons systems lies in its identification capability. As we know before, we read any definition as being limited to systems that also identify targets. However, recent discussions have reflected a lack of clarity expressed by some delegations regarding the interpretation of "select" as including as including the identification phase. Therefore, as mentioned by several other delegations, and in light of the importance of the identification phase as essential feature of laws, we would like to reiterate our proposal to include the word "identify" in the text. Finally, we believe that the US suggestion presented in one of the last discussions to replace the words "these tasks" after "in the execution of" with the words "this task" is interesting and should be considered. And we're open to looking into considerations and proposals put forward today on this subject, too. Considering the above, we propose the following wording for the paragraph. "A lethal autonomous weapons system can be characterized as an integrated combination of one or more weapons and their integral technological components that is designed to identify, select, and engage a target without intervention by a human operator in the execution of this task. Chair, regarding the second paragraph in box one of the ruling text, we're still reviewing it and remain open to accepting it in the spirit of compromise, as long as no additional amendments are introduced to it. I thank you.
Let me thank the distinguished representative of Israel for commenting on the text and also on proposals brought forward by other delegations. Next on my list is the United Arab Emirates, to be followed by France and Luxembourg. But let me now pass the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Arab Emirates. Madam, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We also would like to thank you for your efforts to facilitate our exchanges. We have the following comments and approaches to share with you on the revised text. We support what was said by our colleagues, and we thank them for their efforts. In paragraph 1, we consider that the text does indeed recognise that laws have a functional combination. Our view is that we should replace "integrated" by "functional", as the text proposes. This change is neutral and has no legal consequences, we feel. We also feel that the principle of human judgment and control, which is context appropriate, is important, which is why, instead of saying "without intervention by an operator", human operator, that is, we propose to add guarantee context appropriate human control and judgment during critical functions. On paragraph two, we feel that we need to cover all cases where there is a resorting to force In a particular where there is physical damage or injury, we have the following proposal. The possibility of using these systems in such a way as that they do not cause any loss of life. This should mention all attacks that might cause damage or physical damage or injury, physical damage or injury. Any exception in the future must be based on IHL. IHL is the ultimate reference in this matter, which would enable us to bridge the legal gaps giving rise to many concerns, which is why in paragraph 3 we propose to add, and this characterisation applies in all cases depending on the commitments of states pursuant to IHL, in particular the principles of distinction, proportionality and precaution. Thank you very much.
I thank the distinguished representative of the United Arab Emirates. Next on my list is France, to be followed by Luxembourg, Italy and Belgium. But let me first pass the floor to the distinguished representative of France, who is available.
I thank you, Mr. Chairman. We also wanted to thank you for your efforts and the efforts of your team to help our work move forward in presenting us this new version on box 1. We are still studying this section on characterization, but we believe it is an improvement on the previous version. In paragraph 1, like other delegations have said before us, the notion of functional combination At first approach, that is not crystal clear, but we would like to thank delegations who have elaborated on their understanding of that notion of functional combination. We are also considering the functionally integrated replacement, which could be more clear. We are considering that option. With regard to the critical functions, we could consider Singapore's proposal and the proposals made by other delegations, making it possible to integrate the function of identification, because we feel that that is integrated within the function of selection. We welcome the change of human user to human operator. which in our view, uh, better ring fence the deli- this qualification to the human chain of command, limits it to that. As to the expression in the execution of these tasks at the end of one, as far as we're concerned, this, uh, uh, expression remains important and we thank you for having kept it in this new version. According to us, this expression in the execution of these tasks. limits the autonomy phase of the system and presupposes, therefore, that it has been previously set up by the human chain of command and control. We remain flexible as to how that can be expressed in the text. Moving on to paragraph 2. In our view, you have found an elegant compromise solution, which is also clear, and we can support it. To clarify matters, we had supported at the beginning of the week the deletion of the section of the sentence that says that "lethal" refers to the capacity to cause death to a person, which is what this version reflects and which is therefore acceptable to us. Thank you very much.
I thank the distinguished representative of France for stating the positions of her delegation and making suggestions in the text. Next on my list is Luxembourg, to be followed by Italy, Belgium, and then we have the University of Nottingham. Yeah, that's it for now. But let me first pass the floor to Luxembourg.
Thank you, Chair, for giving us the floor, um, first of all, I must say we are very impressed by your thorough knowledge of Luxembourgish culture, being familiar with the procession and being able to reference it like that is quite a niche skill to have, to say the least. Coming back to the text, we would like to thank you for the hard work you have put into seeking to find a more consensual language regarding box one. We support the changes you have made to the chapeau as well as to paragraph one of box one. Regarding paragraph two, we appreciated that the previous wording contained an explicit reference to damage or destroy objects. as this wording seemed clear to us in delimiting the characterization. As it stands now, the text appears more vague and implicit regarding the context and type of use under which laws would fall within the set of elements we are drafting. In our view, the current wording would require further interpretation to determine exactly under which context of use the set of elements would apply. And rather than leaving this interpretation open, uh, we would prefer to clarify it, uh, at this stage and therefore suggest to explicitly retain the reference to damage caused to objects, and in that regard, we support the wording proposed by the ICRC, uh, before the lunch break. Thank you.
Let me thank the distinguished representative of Luxembourg for commenting on the tax proposals made. Next on my list is Italy, to be followed by Belgium. But let me now pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Italy. You have the floor.
Mr. Chair, thank you for giving me the floor. At the outset, I would like to thank you and your team for the very hard work on this section, and we would like to provide the following comments. We support the current version of the chapeau, which works well for the structure of this section. In para 1, we support the change from human user to human operator, but we are not entirely sure about the meaning of functional alone without integrated, and we would prefer a better formulation such as functionally integrated combination, as already mentioned by other delegations. In part A2, for us, the suitability of loads to cause death appears to be the necessary requirement for the characterization. If then the system is used to cause damage or injury, This does not preclude it from still being considered a lethal autonomous weapon system for the purpose of the CCW. And in this vein, we can accept loss of life. In terms of the critical functions, our delegation supports the development of an international instrument that applies specifically to low VI levels of autonomy across all critical functions. With reference to your background paper and listening carefully to some of the interventions in the conference room in these days, we are still concerned that there are different interpretations and ambiguity in what is exactly understood with the term "select". In the aforementioned paper, our perception is that the identify phase is addressed as conceptually distinct from the selection. Identification is understood to occur prior to the selection. Despite that, given the centrality of international humanitarian law, in particular the definition of a military objective, and in line with position expressed by other delegations, the absence of the term "identify from the list" of critical functions should not be viewed negative per se. To advance consensus and consistent with our previous interventions where we suggested the cumulative approach, as well as the views of many other delegations, we support the current simplified rolling text that lists "select" and "engage" as the two critical functions in para 1, as long as it is explicit and clear that the identification phase is contained in the selection phase. Assuming that in this version of the rolling text, the qualification of military object is in the selection phase, this phase must include the identification and the selection of the targets based on the mission goals and parameters. We stand ready to work constructively with all delegations to ensure that the instrument remains clear, targeted and enforceable. And I thank you, Chair.
I thank the distinguished representative of Italy for commenting on the proposals made. Next on my list is Belgium, to be followed by the University of Nottingham and Bulgaria. But let me now first pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Belgium.
Mr. Chairperson, my delegation wishes to thank you, your team and the friends of the Chair for the work you have put in redrafting this box and for your efforts to bring us closer to consensus while safeguarding the quality of our work. In general terms, Belgium is supportive of the revised text you have put forward, and we believe it may further advance the convergence of views. My delegation is still studying the introduction of the term "functional", as well as the Russian proposal to use the terms "functionally integrated", which has captured our interest. Regarding paragraph 2, it is our understanding that the revised version proposed by you does not exclude any system, be it anti-personnel or anti-material. To make this more explicit, we are happy to consider the ICRC's recent proposal to amend the text to include the destruction of objects. We are also appreciative of the fact that the term "human" was retained before "operator". I thank you, Chair.
I thank the distinguished representative of Belgium. Next on my list is the University of Nottingham, and then we have Bulgaria and Ukraine. First, the distinguished representative of the University of Nottingham, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. Thank you also for the revised version of box 1 that you have circulated. Starting with paragraph one, the reference to lethal before autonomous weapons system is misguided. It creates ambiguity and misalignment with IHL. There is no requirement of lethality, i.e. to cause death, in IHL in order to classify a weapon or a weapon system as such. Rules of IHL will apply to all weapons irrespective of lethality. It is the nature and effect of the weapon or weapon system that is capable of causing injury, death, damage or destruction that IHL regulates. I note that some States are insistent on including the word "lethal". Could we have an explanation from them as to the legal basis in IHL for this? Some States and organizations currently refer to autonomous weapon systems. Would such systems be excluded from the remit of any instrument produced by the GGE on the basis that lethal is not used to describe them? If there is insistence on inclusion of the word lethal, there would need to be explicit reference to effects that IHL is concerned with in relation to persons and objects. And in this regard, I would suggest the following text in paragraph two. "Autonomous weapons or weapon systems may be capable of causing or be used to cause lethal effects, such as death of persons, or non-lethal effects, such as injury to persons, or damage to or destruction of objects. Secondly, in relation to paragraph 1, the inclusion of the word "functional" narrows down the scope of inclusion of the types of weapon or weapon system we are dealing with here. It has no basis in weapons law and is not a requirement of a weapon or weapon system to be classified as such under IHL. It is also not a technically recognized term. Further, its inclusion would be contrary to the legal review obligation for a new weapon under article 36 of AP1, which refers to, I quote, "in the study, development, acquisition or adoption of a new weapon, means or method of warfare, a high contracting party is under an obligation to determine whether its employment would, in some or all circumstances, be prohibited by this protocol or by any other rule of international law applicable to high contracting party. Clearly, the obligation here exists at the study and development stages, which is also reflected in box one, paragraph one of your revised rolling text. Whereas functional would mean waiting for it to be operational in order to conduct a review. I believe the distinguished delegate from South Africa also raised an important point about the word being ambiguous and a form of reactive rather than proactive regulation disadvantaging some And I think we heard earlier on from the distinguished delegate from Israel, what's more current in weapons law is the reference to design, which would clearly fit into the study and development stages of Article 36. Thirdly, in paragraph one, the distinguished delegate from Singapore suggested amended text to include identification is a sensible one. and would mean those weapons or weapon systems that can autonomously identify a target separate from selection would be within the remit of any GGE instrument and crucially, under Article 36 AP1 review obligation. Finally, still with paragraph one, The reference to human operator and earlier on, I think we heard a delegation mention perhaps this should be amended to operator. I'd like to ask, does this include the commander whose responsibility it is to take feasible precautions to reduce the risk to civilians and civilian objects under Article 56 AP1 which may include aborting an attack. How will they be able to discharge this duty, the duty to abort an attack, if there is only reference to human intervention in the form of an operator? Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of the University of Nottingham for further elaborating on the text. Next on my list is Bulgaria, to be followed by Ukraine. But first, the distinguished representative of Bulgaria.
Thank you, Chair. We appreciate your and your team's work on editing Box 1 and presenting a revised and improved version of it. On para one, we join others in expressing support for the APO's suggestion of functionally integrated, as functional alone sounds vague and unclear to us. The current formulation of select and engage is acceptable to us, as in our view, the selection function incorporates the identification phase. We support the change of user to operator. As for us, it's more important to keep the word human. And we also, in part two, we welcome the current text and the simplification of the issue of fatality. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of Bulgaria. Next is the distinguished representative of Ukraine. So you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. Our delegation expresses gratitude to you, Chair, your team, and the friends of the Chair and believes that the existing version of the text should become a basis for our future work. More specifically, we believe that the existing version of the text should not be further complicated by adding additional wording. To be even more specific, the delegation of Ukraine opposes the idea of inclusion of the word "identification" into the list of critical functions as devoid of any added value and capable only of confusing, not clarifying. The position of the delegation of Ukraine is based on both legal logic and logic of military decision-making, in both of which selection and identification do not mean any separate processes or stages of a process, but both present one mental exercise aimed at separation of a potential target from the entirety of objects of the physical world. There is no use to artificially separate the notion of selection and identification. We therefore deem it necessary to remain within the existing definition provided in paragraph 1 of the revised rolling text. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of Ukraine for commenting on proposals made. Next on my list is the distinguished representative of El Salvador. And that is for now the last on my list. So if you would like to react to... Yes, I recognize the UK. So we add... And I recognize also China. So please, um, put up your plaque that we will add you to the list, but first, uh, we will hear the distinguished representative of El Salvador. You have the floor.
Thank you very much, Chair, for giving me the floor. My delegation really appreciates the work that has been carried out by you and your team to come up with a compilation of proposals made by delegations to come up with this text. On box one, my delegation thanks you for your efforts, and we support, in general, the text that we see on the screen. Nevertheless, as I mentioned in my previous statement, my delegation believes that it is fundamental that we say explicitly to hear that lethal autonomous weapons can make cause and damage to objects and also cause serious injury to civilians. In this respect, I do hope that this can be mentioned in paragraph 2, as requested by other delegations and representatives of civil society. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of El Salvador for stating the position of his delegation and would now like to pass the floor to the distinguished representative of the UK. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair, and the UK would like to express our thanks to you and your team for the work you've done in addressing this box following all of our comments that we made earlier in the week. The UK made some general statements about the concept of identify, select and engage on Monday, and I do not intend to repeat them. However, we have been listening closely to the various opinions that have been put forward on the new text, particularly the various opinions around the inclusion of identify or not, those who support and those who do not. The suggestion from Singapore to include identification within the functions of select and engage and also the suggestion from our US colleagues about the inclusion of the term once activated. In that vein, we, the UK, would like to make a suggestion that we hope addresses the various points that have been made both for and against the various issues that are before us and hope that it could be a a good compromise solution, so I will speak to it now. The text that the UK proposes will read: "A lethal autonomous weapons system can be characterised as a functionally integrated combination of one or more weapons and technological components that can, once activated, use information in the environment to select and engage a target without intervention by a human operator." Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Could you perhaps read it once more, and also a little bit slower so delegations can blot it down? That would be helpful. Thank you very much.
So, Mr. Chair, I'll read it once more. A lethal autonomous weapon system can be characterized as a functionally integrated combination of one or more weapons and technological components that can, once activated, use information in the environment to select and engage a target without intervention by a human operator.
I thank the distinguished representative of the UK for sharing this proposal. Next on my list is China. Let me pass the floor to the distinguished representative of China, to be followed by Chile.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Chinese delegation would like to thank you and your team for the work done in bridging all the differences from different parties and for presenting the new Box 1 of the draft. As for the current Box 1, we have the following comments. First is on the functional, the terminology functional. This word appears in the draft for the first time and we currently believe this term is quite unclear and causes confusion. And we would like to propose deletion from the draft and restore or retain the integrated as in our previous draft. And secondly, as for the key characterizations, You are all very familiar with our position. China is still of the position that identification is a critical feature of the autonomous systems and the word identification should be included or reflected in the document in a certain way. China thanks Singapore and United States for making new proposals, and also our UK colleagues who just made a new proposal. We'll be looking closely into those three proposals and assessing the connotations there at this stage. And third, as for lethality, we understand that the draft language in dated May 12th is a compromise product. And now we only deleted the first sentence, which makes logically problematic, at least for me personally. So we are still of the view that lethality is an integral part of the mandate of this group. And we are quite interested in our India colleagues' formula this morning, adding causes of death at the end of the first paragraph, but I'm not very accurate on this. So we will appreciate if the text could be or the previous version could be restored because we think now the second paragraph, it's logically, it's not working. Thank you so much, Mr. Chair.
I thank the distinguished representative of China for commenting on also previous or on proposals tabled this this afternoon. Next on my list is Chile. Let me now pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Chile.
Thank you very much, Chair. Chile supports you in your work, and we thank you for the efforts aimed at proposing us a text that brings together the discussions that took place. Now, let's we would like to join those delegations For example, El Salvador that requested the mentioning and the references to the damage and destruction in the text. And we need to have this reference in light of humanitarian law and the lethal nature of such weapon systems. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of Chile for stating the position of her delegation and commenting on proposals made by other delegations. I have a further request for the floor, this time from the ICSC, so let me pass the floor to the distinguished representative of the ICSC. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I apologize for taking the floor again on this discussion, but we just wanted to comment very briefly on the suggestion just made by the distinguished delegate of the United Kingdom, which we think is very good and may solve some of the problems that have been besetting us. In particular, we wonder if it might solve the issue with identify and select, or just select, or identify and/or select. Because it seems to us that the introduction of this idea of using information in the environment that the UK has suggested actually usefully narrows the possibilities of what words like identify and select might mean. And this resolves at least some of our concerns, for example, about using the word identify because it really constrains the meaning. So While we'd be very happy with what the UK has suggested, we'd also, I think, be quite happy to reintroduce the word "identify" into what the UK has proposed, so that it would read, "a functionally integrated combination of one or more weapons and technological components that can, once activated, use information in the environment to identify, select, and engage a target," et cetera. So that additional constraint, it's a temporal constraint as well. So perhaps that helps the United States and others who have that issue about the time. So it's really talking about what the system is doing while it's in operation. It's activated, it's using information. to identify, select and engage, or just select and engage. We'd be comfortable with both, but perhaps this does present a possible way forward to find consensus. Thank you very much.
I have a further request for the floor from South Africa, so let me pass the floor to the distinguished representative from South Africa. You have the floor.
Thank you very much, Chair, for giving me the floor. After carefully listening to constructive views regarding our previous assertion to the inclusion of "identification" or "identify" in the text, we have the following submission. My delegation reaffirms our position that "identify" remains a critical step in the process, and we do not see this as a subset of "select" and "engage". We view identification to include profile matching and radar signature detection. And when this criterion has been fulfilled, the selection process begins subject to inputs that stem from the identification phase. While we recognize the submission by other delegations that identification remains a subset of selection and engagement, we would like to move to a position wherein a compromise can be reached. We further submit that the previous proposal by Singapore is supported as the element of identification is catered for in the text and would seek to address this ongoing discussion. If a wider interpretation is supported, the question on identifications bear no negative implications stemming from the text and provides for inclusivity for the States that have specifically mentioned that they view identification as a separate process or element. In this regard, we believe that identification is a prerequisite for target selection. One cannot select a target without identifying it. And identification itself is a result of scanning and interpreting the environment. The sequence is fundamental to how autonomous systems operate and should be clearly reflected in the definition. Furthermore, We wish to clarify that our concern is not whether the function of identification is embedded in a system or not. Rather, we view the inclusion of the word "identify" as essential to capturing the full scope of critical functions that we have implications for all states. These discussions are not about the technical architecture of specific systems, but about the broader normative and ethical consideration that affect the international community as a whole. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of South Africa for commenting on proposals made. I have two more requests for the floor, France to be followed by the Republic of Korea. But let me first pass the floor to the distinguished representative of France, who is available.
Thank you very much, Chair, for giving me the floor once again. I simply wanted to react to the proposal that was made by the United Kingdom. We believe it goes in the right direction with the addition that was proposed by the ICRC. At first breath, we believe that this is a very good solution for compromise to reflect the notion of activation and the time related, the moment in time related to activation. and also the question of identification. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of France. Next on my list is the Republic of Korea, to be followed by the Philippines. But first, the distinguished representative of the Republic of Korea, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. Sorry for taking the floor again, but I promise to come back on the revised text on para one. So for Republic Korea, we also support the new in this box. And also we support the amended one functionally integrated. And also we suggest again to include their integral before technology components to make it even more clear. And also now comment on the various suggestions or compromise text for identify that we first thank all the delegation suggesting creative solutions to resolve this issue and especially the UK colleague. suggesting this using information in the environment and ICRC suggestion put the identifier back and use this. So I think this is promising way to solve this problem. I think it's the I call it the little model because at the first time we had also similar discussion on whether to put it or not. And now we settled on the and put the explanation about the second paragraph. So similarly, identification, we can put it in and then put some explanation on it. So we address the concerns that some delegations have about what they don't understand what identify mean or is too broad. So, but it's preliminary comment and also we might think more clearly about how to describe this identify. But we agree with the general direction that we put identify and maybe some words to describe it. And coming back to the lethality problem, it's our distinguished delegate from China mentioned the second paragraph was that we carefully designed a compromised to have "little" in the first paragraph. And I'm very afraid we are moving in a different direction with the changed words. So that's why in my first intervention, that we prefer the original text. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of the Republic of Korea for elaborating on the proposals made and commenting on changes. Next on my list is the Philippines, so let me pass the floor to the distinguished representative of the Philippines.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Philippines would like to thank you and your team for coming up with the revised text for box one, as well as for your efforts to find consensus among delegations. Our delegation appreciates this new version, which we find to be more concise and straight to the point. We would like to register our support for the term functional combination, as we view it to be more comprehensible. On paragraph one, we find the proposal functionally integrated combination to be interesting, and we look at it more closely. We note the request of other delegations to include "identify". However, our delegation would like to be clarified if it means that it is about giving the machine or the weapon the decision-making task during war operations. An elaboration on this would be appreciated. We also do not see the necessity to include "upon activation" in the first paragraph of box 1. Inclusion of "upon activation" will unnecessarily narrow the characterization of loss. On paragraph two, we find the revised formulation to be simpler but more comprehensible. Nevertheless, we support the call of other delegations to include and specify the other impact of loss aside from the loss of life, such as damage or destroy objects or cause injury. In this regard, we are open to adopting the proposal by the University of Nottingham. Thank you.
I thank the distinguished representative of the Philippines. I have two more requests for the floor from Italy and Norway. So let me first pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Italy. You have the floor.
Thank you, Chair, for allowing me to come back to comment in on this section. I just would like to react very briefly to the intervention by the distinguished UK delegation to say that, according to us, this intervention contains good elements for a compromise and it's a good step forward towards the right direction, and I thank you, Chair.
I thank the distinguished representative of Italy, and next now is Norway, um, so let me pass the floor to the distinguished representative of Norway.
Thank you, Chair. It's great to have the final word. The addition in the chapeau we think is good. In paragraph one, the replacement of user with operator is okay for us as well, in as much as it still conveys that laws are those weapons which don't need humans to perform any action after the weapon has been activated in order for them to be able to select and engage a target. Regarding the combination of the words human and operator, We, uh, hear that this still poses some problems, uh, for some delegations, and the argument, if we got it right, is that it seems to suggest that there could be other than human operators if we qualify it this way, so, uh, for us, of course, it's important to retain, uh, in the characterization, a very clear focus on the human element, uh, which we, uh, elaborated on, on Monday. What to do? One solution could be to simply delete the word "operator" and say "without intervention by a human." I think that there's been some problem with that in the past. I can't remember why exactly, so I'll just raise it. And an alternative could be, as we mentioned on Monday, to just not qualify the word "operator" and rather say "without intervention by the human that operates the system." And that way, we describe the human instead of the operator. On the critical functions, we're happy with the current formulation, but it's clear that we're not quite there yet. So, Singapore's suggestion to add, which includes identification, we think is useful to highlight what is, after all, an important function in laws, but like Ireland, we think it could be or should be preceded by a may. So they would read, which may include identification. And the reason is that there are diverging technical understandings, it seems, of what the stage of identification entails in practice. So for some, it seems to be the matching of an object among many with a target profile. And for others, it seems that identification could include the very determination of the target profiles. The system is then tasked to find and engage. which would make the characterization very narrow, but with a may, we avoid that. And on the UK proposal, it sounded quite promising, but I think we'll just have to see it on paper to digest the nuances of it properly. Thank you.
Good. Thank you. And it's now up to the room whether you have the last word or not. Any further requests for the floor? If that's not the case, then I have the challenge in trying to, to wrap this up. I think I'm not prepared to wrap this up. That's not only to make my, my life easy, but I think we, we have a certain dynamics and we, we get proposals, most recently also from the UK, and some of you already said they would like to reflect on that. If you are reflecting, then I should also be reflecting, I think. So the Chair and his team will do some reflection and we will try to send you something to continue tomorrow the discussion. I need also to get some better understanding for some of the proposals to be able to stay at the meeting then tomorrow. So that would make that I would like to propose that we start tomorrow morning at 11, um, so either you have a long breakfast or you have some extra time for reflection, that's up to you. Um, and of course, uh, we are not done, uh, we have also then, um, the issue of any other business tomorrow afternoon, and I promise that I will share with you some ideas on the way forward with regard to the work of our group in 2026, uh, uh, as is now, uh, a kind of a tradition, um, so I'm, I'm now looking at my staff, have I covered what I should cover now? There are no-- no, we are not going to have evening side events. Nothing from the ISU? Then I think this meeting stands now adjourned. So please, we will reach out to you with something further. And looking forward to see you in this room tomorrow morning at 11:00. Thank you very much.