Skip to main content

Working Group II (9th meeting), UN Convention on Biodiversity - COP 17

27 October·11:30·03:10:05Conferences

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

CBDChair

Good evening, colleagues. I invite you to take your seats to continue with our evening session of Working Group 2. Dear delegates, thank you very much for your spirit of compromise during the last session. We hope we will continue in the same manner. I'm very happy that with a little bit for everyone, we made good progress. So I still looking for your contributions. So I hope, i know we are all tired, it's late, so let's do our best to get through this in a constructive manner. So we now continue with consideration of CRPs. In forest, we have six paragraphs left. that contain brackets, and I call on you to find agreement on them. So these paragraphs are operational paragraphs 4 and 5 in the Annex, paragraphs 15, 20, 23, and 38. Just hold on a second. Yes, so let's continue with paragraph 15 in the annex. I understand that this paragraph was discussed in the presence of the Chair, and there are reservations, mainly around the word "biopesticides". Secretariat, please introduce the paragraph.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you, Chair. So, The entire paragraph is in brackets. There are also some brackets inside the paragraph and some textual changes that were made during the Friends of the Chair. I'll read slowly with the brackets indicated and the textual changes indicated. So the version that the Friends of the Chair worked on, which is still in brackets, would read as follows. Encourage the, open bracket, development and, close bracket, so development and are in brackets, encourage the development and evaluation of options for the use of biopesticides and, and biopesticides is in brackets, lower risk and integrated pest management approaches in forest ecosystems as appropriate. Perhaps I should read again. So I'll read the whole paragraph one more time and simply just tell you where the brackets are after I finish the paragraph. Encourage the development and evaluation of options for the use of biopesticides and lower risk and integrated pest management approaches in forest ecosystems as appropriate. And the words development and are in brackets, and biopesticides and are in brackets. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Secretariat. So I open the floor for comments to fix this paragraph. Panama.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. In the spirit of consensus, as you know, we have insisted on having the word “biodiversity” in this paragraph, but I think that given the consensus, we can go along with deleting the pesticides as a reference, as long as we keep the reference to development and evaluation, just to support the consensus.

CBDChair

It's around development and to continue with evaluation of options for the use of lower risk and integrate pest management approaches in forest ecosystems as appropriate. I see Norway from Panama. Namibia.

Namibia

Okay, thank you, Chair. We are very concerned about the evaluation even of options for biopesticides, respectively, pest control measures in natural ecosystems. And this is why we would suggest to delete the entire paragraph 15. We don't think that this is something that we should include in these activities here, because we believe that in natural or in forest ecosystems, no biopesticides or pest control measures should be taken as a matter of principle. I thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you, Namibia. So Namibia is proposing to delete this paragraph. Is anyone opposing to the deletion of this paragraph 15? I see Bangladesh, Panama, and Brazil. So I think we should entertain, I hope not too long. If Bangladesh wants to keep it, or are you also proposing language to go on? No, you want to keep it. Thank you. Panama mentioned is important, so I guess it's also want to keep it. Brazil, followed by EU.

Brazil

Gracias, señor Presidente. And thank you for Namibia for the comments. We believe that in the case of Brazil, for example, we do have specific legislation that calls upon agricultural areas to include forests, and the use of biopesticides would actually be beneficial to the forests within, for example, private areas. So I think there are a series of examples where, in general, biopesticides would be contributing, beneficial to global biodiversity. So we are flexible on, of course, as always, discussing on the language, but we prefer to keep this paragraph. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Brazil. EU, follow by India.

EU

Thank you, Chair. In principle, we would prefer to have this paragraph deleted, but after having discussed with other parties, and we also understand that in some cases, there may be a need to consider pest management options. We would only consider a possibility where we do not talk about encouraging the development or use or evaluation of pesticides of any type, including biopesticides and lower risk. We could go with language to support the consideration of options for integrated pest management approaches. Thank you.

CBDChair

Can you repeat, please, to see your proposal?

EU

Thank you. To support the development and consideration of options for integrated pest management approaches.

CBDChair

Thank you very much. That's short. I hope this is acceptable, instead of encourage support and the development as Panama wants. You got it? Good. India, followed by Iran and Panama.

India

Thank you, Chair. We are all aware that invasive alien species, okay, they are one of the major threat to biodiversity. And currently, there are no means, number one, to eradicate, even for control also. In such a circumstances, you know, such measures that can help, even, you know, our protected areas like national parks, sanctuaries, and many other areas. In such localities, these things can be of great use. Of course, my previous speaker spoke about integrated pest management, and this will be a part of that only. So we favor retaining it, and we have a small insertion. Encourage the development and evaluation of options for the adoption of sustainable forest management practices. Then it will go biopesticides. and lower risk control products and approaches. So we would like to incorporate sustainable forest management practices.

CBDChair

Thank you, India. So, while Namibia says we should not be using, India is making an example in the case of invasive species where possibly can be used. So I suggest that maybe we can add at the end as appropriate in any of the two options we have. And we have a third one from India, including sustainable managed forest, sustainable forest management, which we already talking about that. I don't know if that's a kind of reiteration. But seems I see that instead of encourage, we can use support the development and to have as appropriate, that's my suggestion. So I have Iran, followed by Panama, Uganda, and Brazil.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Thank you, Chair. Iran also support biopesticides and integrated pest management because the forest ecosystem these days facing new invasive species that need to be taken into account. So it's not just a natural way of management.

CBDChair

So you support the text.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Yeah, we support the text. And for the sustainable forest management that India also has suggested, we are flexible for that. But forest ecosystems concept is also important for us. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Iran. And now I follow by Uganda and Brazil.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. We would go along with India's proposal. Regarding the chopper suggested by EU, we think it's appropriate to have integrated pest management options. I think this is the approach that we should focus on so we can go along with India, but we cannot go along with any deletion of evaluation and development. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. I think we're taking development and evaluation into account, but instead of encourage, we say support. So we're on the right path.

Uganda

Thank you, Chair. Uganda identifies with the position, the submission of Namibia regarding ideally getting rid of the entire paragraph. But also having listened to other colleagues, because we're talking about forest ecosystems, but then listening to the submission of Brazil, where there was mention of agricultural systems that also include private forests, to me, it doesn't come off as forest ecosystems per se, because ideally that becomes agricultural ecosystems. And even when we look at, initially, there was a position on, I mean, there was a suggestion to look at, to include plantations. But then when we look at that, that was discarded. But we're looking at what are the circumstances that actually you would have pest control in an actual forest ecosystem. what creatures do not deserve to be home in a natural forest. But of course, we will remain open to the discussions and welcome the suggestion by the chair as appropriate, and then that can accommodate the rest of, I mean, accommodate the different submissions based on national circumstances. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you, Uganda. Thank you for the support also to include as appropriate at the end any of the options. I will give the floor to Brazil, followed by Namibia and Tuvalu.

Brazil

And we heard from other delegates that there were concerns with regard to the use of the term biopesticides. We would then offer to use the term biosolutions that would be more encompassing than biopesticides. And as mentioned, we would prefer to retain a paragraph not only for forests that are close to other areas, but also for forest restoration and a series of other activities. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Graciela. I understand that, for example, Panama was open to not to use biopesticides, but to have integrated pest management. So maybe that can be a way forward. And I'll give the floor to Namibia, followed by Tuvalu, and I'll make a proposal.

Namibia

Thank you, Mr. Chair. We have heard interesting suggestions. And we would like to align ourselves with the proposal made by Uganda to replace ecosystems with plantations, because we are not having an objection that risk pest control, integrated pest control mechanisms would have a place there. So we would like to propose a solution which is combining the EU proposal and the Uganda proposal. That would look at the development and evaluation of options of integrated pest management for forest plantations. And I think then we would be able to accept this 15. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Namibia. Lots of flexibility. Secretariat is working to accommodate different suggestions. I'll give the floor to Tuvalu, followed by Russian Federation, and Brazil again.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. In the Pacific, I can give you three examples of invasive alien species into natural forests. We have brown tree snakes, we have ship rats, we have cane toads, we have the African tulip tree, which is coming into our natural forests. So we can't just use the term forest plantations. So I think integrated pest management, as the EU suggested, and the use of forest ecosystems is the best approach. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Tuvalu. I hope Namibia take this in consideration. So we need to apply this when it's appropriate, I believe, is adaptive management. Russian Federation, followed by Brazil and EU.

Russian Federation

Thank you. We sadly could not agree to replacing ecosystems for plantations. However, we believe we could work with the start of the proposal by the EU, so add in integrated pest control management and then working with the proposal from Brazil to replace biopesticides with biosolutions. If we combine those two, we believe it could work. Thank you.

CBDChair

I think we are almost there. Brazil, followed by EU, and let me make a proposal.

Brazil

Just to reiterate, I think when the last version was read, just to include along with integrated pest management biosolutions.

CBDChair

Thank you.

EU

Thank you, Chair. We would like to support the proposal made by Namibia to actually complement integrated pest management for forest plantations and add as appropriate. We believe that this actually focuses the scope of potential use of such practices to where it is really necessary. Thank you.

CBDChair

Yes, but please remind what Tuvalu mentioned on concrete examples of invasive species in natural forests as well. So as appropriate can help, and let me see if we can find a combination. We know that it's more logic to use on plantations, but sometimes could be needed. This is on a case by case basis, I believe. Let me see. Give me a few seconds to see with Secretary if we can have a hybrid version. I'll ask the Secretariat to try to have a short possible solution. If it's acceptable, please read it.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you. So, the Chair's proposal for potential compromise text would read as follows: Support the development and consideration of of options for integrated pest management approaches and bio solutions in forest ecosystems and plantations as appropriate. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Secretariat. Can we go along with this formulation? Is anyone opposing to Chair's proposal, raise your hand, because I have now is reducing the number of requests to the floor. Is anyone opposing? Namibia. Have Namibia followed by Iran and EU. I'm trying to accommodate different views.

Namibia

Chair, we respect your intention to accommodate us all. However, we are not quite sure what biosolutions contain, and so we would be able to use this suggestion of yours, provided we bracket and biosolutions and we bracket ecosystems. And so we would be comfortable with the proposal made by the EU in the final reading. Other than that, we will not be able to flexible to lift the brackets and we can move on. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

My mission is to send clean text to the Presidency and all of us. I count with you. Iran, followed by EU and Russian Federation.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Thank you, Mr. Co-Chair. Mr. Chair, we support your suggestions, but we can also suggest biocontrol agents that includes microbial pesticide, parasitoids and predators control. So that we can replace it by bio solutions if it cannot help. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you for the proposal, Iran. EU, follow with Russian Federation and Tuvalu.

EU

Thank you, Chair. Having understood better the scope of what is intended in this discussion, we would insist to either delete this paragraph or go to the option that was also supported by Namibia. So delete "and bio solutions" because we do not understand what that means, and then also "in forest ecosystems and leave-only plantations." Thank you very much.

CBDChair

Yes, but you heard that there is no agreement just to the plantations. Please, we need to be flexible. Let's go to the matter. If you are giving examples, you can say it in a short way and go to the text, your support or which amendments. Russian Federation, followed by Tuvaleu and Panama.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. For us, your proposal works. However, seeing the divergent views, we would maybe suggest to just say in forests and then add in accordance with national legislation, so that would cover the divergence between plantations and ecosystems, because we also would be not really comfortable with just keeping plantations. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. So I see that there is no support for bio solutions so far, but I think it's more or less including pest management approaches, and there's also a biocontrol agents proposal from Iran. I don't know if that can work, if it's more understandable instead of bio solutions. Hold on. OK. Let's see if this new formulation flies. Bear in mind, this is short. Support the development and consideration of options for integrated pest management approaches and biocontrol agents As appropriate, so no mention of forests. We're talking about forests already, and this is part of a target. So could that be acceptable? So I'll ask the Secretariat to repeat it again. Short, concise, and then maybe we can move.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you, Chair. So the proposal on the floor would read as follows. Support the development and consideration of options for integrated pest management approaches and biocontrol agents as appropriate.

CBDChair

Is anybody opposing to this formulation? Raise your hand. EU. That's the only hand I see. Go ahead.

EU

Thank you, Chair. With the understanding that the use of integrated pest management is not limited to plantations or to artificial and more intensively managed ecosystems, we cannot agree to this addition, and therefore we would like to ask for the deletion of this paragraph. Thank you very much.

CBDChair

Thank you. I will listen to more requests. Tuvalu, followed by Namibia.

Tuvalu

Thank you very much, Chair. I think we're very close with your proposal. We think it's vitally important that we look at this issue of integrated pest management in forests, and it's a critical issue for our region. So we would not like to see this deleted. Perhaps you could say, after integrated pest management approaches, including biocontrol, or whatever you had, control agents, because they're within a context of a broader concept of integrated pest management. So rather than having two distinct approaches, we have including. the biocontrol or whatever you're using.

CBDChair

Thank you, Tuvalu. So it would be options for integrated pest management approaches, including biocontrol agents as appropriate. Namibia.

Namibia

Chair, we have been very flexible to accept integrated pest management and forest plantations. This is as far as our flexibility can go. We don't know what our biocontrol agents, and so we would accept the proposal made by the EU integrated pest management forest plantations, but this is as far as I can go. We have no flexibility to accept any additional proposal. I really apologize, but please also understand we are concerned about the use of biopesticides or measures that we are not sure about what they contain in ecosystems. And this is where we'd like to either support the deletion of this paragraph or limit the scope to what we have said. I thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Namibia. Panama.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. We think your proposal is the most appropriate and it covers everything that we have raised as our objective. Thank you.

Brazil

And I think we thank Iran for their proposal on biological control agencies. I think it is also an alternative, and which represents also integrated pest management practices that are recognized in several parties and by several regulatory authorities and governments. So we can support your proposal. Thank you.

CBDChair

So I will ask Secretaria to read the proposal as currently stands to see if can fly, otherwise we'll put brackets and move to next paragraph. Secretaria.

CBDSecretariat representative

So the Chair's text on the floor would read as follows. Support the development and consideration of options for integrated pest management approaches, including biocontrol agents as appropriate. Thank you.

CBDChair

So this is what we have. Some parties don't want nothing saying on this. Some is important to keep the reference. Also, support development for this and to use these technologies when it's appropriate. Some express that should only for plantations, some others express cases where also is needed in forest. So this is something that we're trying not again to consider the different views. And I guess this is voluntary and to use as appropriate. I don't know if you want to put according to legislation, but this is my intent to be in between. And if not acceptable, let's put brackets and move on. Namibia.

Namibia

We would second that. Probably we can just put bracket including biocontrol agents as appropriate. We put brackets around ecosystems, and we move on.

CBDChair

We don't have the word "ecosystem" so far.

Namibia

And we leave the brackets around the entire paragraph 15.

Speaker 62

Thank you.

CBDChair

Just to be clear, Namibia, because there is no mention to ecosystem so far, it's support development and consideration of options for integrated pest management approaches, including biocontrol agents as appropriate. So there is no need to delete ecosystems because it's not there. I understand you can agree on that so far. Namibia.

Namibia

We would still like to keep the including biocontrol agents, because if the scope is not clear, because that's how we understand that the rest of the paragraph would then be deleted, because if we don't have a reference, what's the scope of the biocontrol agents, we would definitely have to keep it in brackets. I apologize.

CBDChair

Now I understand. So we can lift the brackets of the entire paragraph and just to keep the brackets on including biocontrol agents. I see nothing. EU.

EU

Thank you, Chair, for this proposal. Unfortunately, we can also not agree with this formulation as it is, and we would like to ask for the deletion of this paragraph. So thank you.

CBDChair

Since there are requests to keep the language, we cannot delete it. is the right of other parties also to advance language on this, so it will remain in brackets. Tuvalu and Russian Federation, and that's in the understanding that the paragraph is in brackets, outside and inside, and move on. Tuvalu followed by Russian Federation.

Tuvalu

Thank you, co-chair. I thought we gave pretty good examples of where we have invasive alien species in our forests. And this is a critical issue for us that we're having to deal with in the Pacific. The brown tree snake is one of those, which is causing all sorts of ecological problems for some of our island countries. So we would not like to see this paragraph disappear. I think it's sufficiently open as far as the control measures to allow us to at least give a signal that we're looking at this issue. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Tuvalu. So I invite Tuvalu and Russian Federation and the EU to sit together to see if you find a solution. Meanwhile, we keep this formulation in brackets. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. Just wanted to reflect on the fact that the suggestion by Namibia seemed quite reasonable. If we were to unbracket most of the paragraph and just keep the biocontrol agents in brackets, it would practically be the formulation that was initially proposed by the EU. Therefore, considering this paragraph is pretty important for a lot of countries, we really do suggest that we go that way. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Iran.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Thank you, Chair. We think the integrated pest management approaches also include biocontrol agents, but in case of reaching a consensus, we can We can put biological agents in brackets or delete it to help. Thank you.

CBDChair

Okay, I support to delete biocontrol agents. So let's proceed with that. So there is no need to have brackets. And so now it's even shorter. Support development and consideration options for integrated pest management approaches as appropriate. That's it. and still fly that EU and Brazil, and then we've already spent quite a long time on this. It's getting shorter and shorter. In some way, that's good.

EU

Thank you, Chair. It's an important point, and so it's worth spending time to get it right. For us, there is still the issue of clearly defining the scope. application of such approaches. So we would like to either delete the paragraph or have a paragraph where the scope is limited to forest plantations. Thank you. And there are a number of ways to manage invasive alien species.

CBDChair

Brazil?

Brazil

[Foreign Language] And thanks for the proposals and trying to move us forward. We're okay, of course, with brackets, since there is at the moment no agreement, but we are not in position to joint consensus is deleting "including biological control agents." So we would ask to keep that language even in brackets. Thank you.

CBDChair

Okay, I'm in your hands. I have no more requests from the floor, so let's keep the, let's keep in brackets the whole paragraph and also biocontrol agents, including biocontrol agents in brackets. And we are, let's remember that this is part of the alignment with the different targets. So this is talking about forests, and this is also talking about target seven. This is not the expression alone. It's inside our deliberations on the alignment on target seven. If this is helpful for considerations when trying to frame how to use these technologies. So that's the situation, so I invite you to move to paragraph 20 in the annex. The paragraph was discussed with your friends and made some progress, so I'll ask the Secretariat to read where we are regarding paragraph 20 of the annex.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you, Chair. So, in the Friends of the Chair, the discussions largely focused around, where the discussions ended up was the placement of the term sustainable forest management. So there are different, there were alternative options for where this placement should be and how it should be captured. One of those options would be keeping close to nature forest management and sustainable forest management after including from the biodiversity friendly practices. The other would be to have a part of sustainable forest management come after intercropping. So what I'll do now is read, read the two, the two alternative versions of the paragraph, which would differ based on the placement of sustainable forest management and close to nature forest management. So one option would read as follows, and it's largely similar. The most of the language is the same as what's in the current paragraph, so I don't need to read extremely slow, i think. So the first option would be Further develop, promote, and implement biodiversity friendly practices, including close to nature forest management, sustainable forest management, the implementation of safeguards into reforestation measures, reduced impact logging practices, the conservation of areas of particular importance to biodiversity, sustainable intensification, agroecology, agroforestry, and intercropping to reduce forest fragmentation and integrate indigenous knowledge and practices as appropriate. The alternative version of this paragraph would have a different placement for sustainable forest management, and I believe does not include close to nature forest management. So the alternative version would read, further develop, promote, and implement biodiversity friendly practices, including the implementation of safeguards into reforestation measures reduced impact logging practices, the conservation of areas of particular importance to biodiversity, sustainable intensification, agroecology, agroforestry, and intercropping as part of sustainable forest management to reduce forest fragmentation and integrate indigenous knowledge and practices as appropriate. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you, Secretariat. So these two options of paragraph 20 that is under target 10, bear in mind that we're talking about forests under target 10 with two different options. So I open the floor for comments on your preferred options. Maybe we can leave the brackets for me, makes sense, but I'm in your hands. I see no request from the floor, so are you adopting both? Just joking. Tuvalu.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. I think we prefer the option as it stands now in the text, because if we move the word sustainable forest management It appears as though we're defining that within a context of these other concepts, and I'm not sure that that's appropriate. So I would suggest that we leave the wording as it is. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Tuvalu. So you suggest to leave the brackets and approve the paragraph. I hope we can go under that line. You.

EU

Thank you, Chair. It was our suggestion to move sustainable forest management to the end of the list so that it is clear that sustainable forest management is a more comprehensive concept that includes biodiversity-friendly practices, but also other socioeconomic objectives and other aspects. But we see that there is There are different interpretations, and we are okay for the sake of a compromise and moving forward to leave it where it was and leave the brackets around sustainable forest management. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you for the flexibility. So we follow Tuvallu's proposal to leave the brackets, and we have a clean text on paragraph 20. Thank you very much. This is so good. Now let's move to paragraph 38E. This is a difficult one, so I'll ask the Secretariat to read out the current version.

CBDSecretariat representative

So the version of the text that comes from the Friends of the Chair is the current paragraph as it's written, with a small addition at the end. And the whole paragraph is also in brackets, and the small addition at the end is in brackets. So I'll read the whole paragraph, which is quite short, and explain where the brackets are. But recall that the whole paragraph is also in brackets. So it would read as follows: Ensure the full protection of environmental human rights defenders in accordance with national legislation. And the end, the "in accordance with national legislation" is in brackets. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Secretariat. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. Sadly, we still request the deletion of that paragraph. The 38th point, which we're discussing, initially had five proposed activities. We, in the beginning, were against four of them. However, on three of those four, we have compromised, and we now have four clean activities in 38. Sadly, we are not in a position to compromise on the fifth. Putting general language here, I'm afraid, would also not work. Therefore, we remain firm in asking for deletion. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Russian Federation. Panama, followed by Tuvalu.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. Regrettably, Panama is not in a position to delete paragraph E. We cannot support the deletion of this paragraph. Thank you.

CBDChair

Including in accordance with national legislation.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. We can accept as appropriate in the version that was recommended. it, but we must maintain the paragraph as a whole. Thank you.

CBDChair

It's appropriate, it's in accordance with national legislation, the suggestion for include. But you agree with that? Thank you. Tuvalu, follow by India.

Tuvalu

Thank you, co-chair. We would certainly support the retention of this paragraph. We could support the language by the small group, in accordance with national legislation. with the addition of “as appropriate” at the end to reflect similar concerns we had previously with other paragraphs relating to national legislation. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Tuvalu. So we can lift the brackets inside and keep the brackets in the whole paragraph: “ensure full protection on environmental human rights defenders in accordance with national legislation as appropriate.” All in brackets, nothing in between. India.

India

Thank you, Chair. We are not in favor of retaining it, and as this is a sovereignty issue, there cannot be any oversight over the internal legal issues. So we are not in favor of it. It may be deleted.

CBDChair

Understood. Iran, followed by EU and Norway.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Thank you, Chair. Iran also support deleting this paragraph, but in case of retaining it, in accordance of national legislation as appropriate is important.

CBDChair

Thank you. So you support the amended version. EU, followed by Norway and China.

EU

Thank you, Chair. This is clearly language of the targets of the CMGBF, so with support retaining this paragraph, it's also a very important aspect in relation to forests. We're not sure we understand completely what as appropriate means, and would therefore like to keep that in brackets. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Norway, followed by Colombia.

Norway

Thank you, Chair.

We would like to support keeping this point, and we can live with the compromises in brackets. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Colombia.

Colombia

Thank you, Chair. For Colombia, it's also important that we keep this paragraph. Protection of environmental human rights defenders is key. So we would like to ask that it remain with additions that have been made in the small group and recommend that if changing the verb from ensure to promote.

CBDChair

Yes, Colombia.

Thank you, Colombia. Their proposal is we replace ensure with promote.

Instead of ensure. and supporting the current national legislation. Mexico.

Mexico, please.

Mexico

Thank you very much, Chair. We're grateful to all colleagues for their work, and we also support keeping the paragraph. And it's our view that the last suggestion by Colombia could help us to unblock any blocks to consensus.

CBDChair

Thank you very much, Mexico.

I will ask the Secretary to read the text as we have, in the understanding that many parties want to keep it and some parties want deletion. So we're going to keep it in brackets, but I'm not sure if it should be also with brackets inside, as I guess you propose for as appropriate.

CBDSecretariat representative

So the text for consideration on the floor would read as follows. promote the full protection of environmental human rights defenders in accordance with national legislation as appropriate, and the "as appropriate" is currently in brackets. Thank you. Thank you.

CBDChair

This is where we are. Another follow by you.

Canada

Thank you, Chair. In the spirit of being helpful and offering some solutions, I'm wondering if the room would be open to consider a formulation of enable and promote. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you, Canada. I hope it helps. We have enable and promote. EU.

EU

Thank you, Chair. We would go along with the formulation and in accordance with national legislation. We would prefer not to have "as appropriate" because we still don't understand what that means. So just to clarify our proposal.

CBDChair

Can we delete "as appropriate" and to have "clean text" in brackets, Tuvalu.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. As we explained in other paragraphs, if we're saying "in accordance with national legislation," it defines that this only applies if there is national legislation. So we think it's important to have, as appropriate, to define whether national legislation is appropriate. This is critical for us because we don't have extensive legislation on some of these matters, but we still think it's important to protect environmental rights defenders. That's how we interpret the words "as appropriate", and I hope the EU understands that now. Thank you.

CBDChair

I understand Tuvalu. I have a proposal. Can we use "in accordance with national legislations and circumstances"? So maybe it's more open and can apply, not only as appropriate. So maybe that can be a way forward. Do you agree, you and Tuvalu? Can you tell me we can go along instead of deleting as appropriate to have and circumstances? I see noting. Okay. And Tuvalu? I don't see you. Meanwhile, I give the floor to Tuvalu.

Tuvalu

I'm not sure that helps because it still means in accordance with national legislation and circumstances. So I, or maybe we could say and/or circumstances. We could live with that.

CBDChair

Okay, second time the use of and/or. Chile.

Chile

Thank you so much. Maybe this is just a question of how to turn here and considering that was already language that has been used in other groups. I was thinking national circumstances and national legislation. I don't know if that could accommodate what Tuvalu is suggesting here now. Thank you so much, Chair.

CBDChair

That's what we have here, but in a different order. And I believe it's the same. So my suggestion is to have in accordance with national legislation and/or circumstances. So it's clean text inside. I understand still some parties want this to be deleted. Let's keep it in brackets and move on. My understanding is that this is the last paragraph. Based on this, for this document, we still have brackets on Paragraphs 4 and 5, and paragraph 15. We solve 20.

CBDSecretariat representative

15 of the annex.

CBDChair

In the annex, yes.

CBDSecretariat representative

And 23 of the annex.

CBDChair

23 still. Yes. Okay, colleagues. So my proposal is that we still have five paragraphs pending on this document. And we also had some pending paragraphs on the agriculture one. I already invited to have some consultations. My suggestion is to move to next document on marine. It's a different profile of delegates, so I invite you to continue consultations and when we come back to these two documents on agriculture and forests, I hope you will come with solutions. If you agree, then let's move to next document on marine. So I'll give you a couple of minutes if you need to prepare and to inform your delegations. Thank you. Okay, colleagues, thank you very much for waiting. Now we go to the document on marine and coastal biodiversity. So we have document CRP4. It's a long document and a lot of work on it. My proposal is to address this document in the following sequence: go first to the annex, then go to the operative paragraphs, and to leave the preamble ones at the end. So let's start with the annex. I also like to make I want to take a moment to reflect the recent passing of Mr. Pierre Dunstan from Australia. Pierre was a major driving force for the EFSA process since the very beginning, and as part of one of the two main EFSA data teams, he helped to ensure the scientific integrity of EFSA work. We likely not be speaking about EPSAS here, if not for his tireless efforts. He was not only a leading expert, but a kind person and a friend to many in this room. He passed suddenly at the end of September, and is dearly missed. So let's take a minute. Thank you very much. So let's start with Annex 1. I open the floor for comments on the title. We have some brackets on different options from reference elements for good practice, guidelines and guidance, and other relevant and complementary scientific criteria. My proposal is to lift the brackets on guidance, and it seems to be a compromise, and also to lift the brackets on other relevant, compatible, and complementary scientific criteria. So can we go along with this proposal? Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. Good evening. So we had extensive discussions on that, both at our deliberations in Nairobi, but of course also here during contact groups and some consultations. So that was our request to come with a reference element for good practice, as we suggested back to Nairobi. During our discussions here in Yerevan, So we discussed with many parties, and everything, of course, mixed now after 10 days, but I think there was our colleagues from Canada who came with a suggestion that we may consider for the compromise using the word guidance. So, and we consider it, and we can go with it with a few caveats. which probably I can explain right now, I can explain later when we come to the paragraphs of the annex. So with that, our suggestion is the following. So the title reads, voluntary guidance on peer review process for the description of areas meeting the criteria for ecologically or biologically significant marine areas full stop. We can reiterate that we do not consider CBD developing any guidance, guidelines, reference elements for everybody in the world, for every single other process, for every single scientific organization, country, etc. So we only can develop it for our own processes and this particular for EPSA, which belong to this convention. So that is a Chair suggestion for the title, and I am happy to continue with other paragraphs, or I will follow your ruling and come to those paragraphs later. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you, Russian Federation. So your proposal is to use guidance. So we can delete reference terms of "for good practice" and "guidelines." So I understand this is a compromise. And then you suggest to after EFSAs, full stop, and not to include other relevant and compatible complementary scientific criteria. I hope we can go along and to use the reference of guidance all along the text and to move on. Peru, followed by Chile, Panama and Iceland. Peru. Thank you.

Peru

Yes, we believe that we should use reference elements because it has a lot to do with the title, which we think is, which is voluntary, but there is flexibility and a guidance character to this. Thank you.

CBDChair

I hope that you will be flexible in accepting guidance as coming round. Chile, followed by Panama.

Chile

Thank you very much, Chair. Also, many thanks to the Russian Federation for their flexibility on this matter. I just make to the comment made by the distinguished delegation of Peru. Actually, we had some reflections that were raised in the contact group, and I would like to use this as background. The concept "rescript elements for good practice" would lead to confusion, and some delegations even think it's more restrictive than guidance. So because of that, we would ask the distinguished delegation of Peru to consider showing some flexibility to see if we can accommodate the suggestion from Canada on guidance. Now, with respect to the second proposal from the Russian Federation to delete other relevant, compatible, and complementary scientific criteria. We're flexible on this as far as the title is concerned, but we will be following closely those other caveats that the Russian Federation would like to introduce later on when they come up. Thank you very much, Chair.

CBDChair

Gracias, Chile. Let's remember we're talking about EPSSAS. EPSSAS is our process here for a number of years already in the convention. and the call from the Chilean as co-chair also to support guidance as a common ground. Iceland.

Iceland

Thank you very much, Chair. We support your suggestion to settle on guidance. As you're referring to, that was the discussion in the second contact group. So I think that was a very good suggestion by Canada in the contact group, so we support you on that. On the second set of brackets and other relevant compatible and complementary scientific criteria, we would like to retain this text, but we are willing to show flexibility on this, but in the title. Thank you very much.

CBDChair

Thank you. Panama, follow by EU.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. First, we wanted to mention that we weren't able to participate in the contact group on this, so we would like to reserve the right to open up what's in debate, but we would like to support Chile's position.

CBDChair

Thank you, Panama. EU, please.

EU

Thank you, Chair. I think that we have been discussing this this title quite long, and I think we are approaching a landing zone. So we are willing to go along also with guidance, noting that the title was requested by previous COP. So with that note, we can also probably, we would like to retain the second bracket as well, but in order to move along and be flexible on this, we can live with it being outside of the title, just like Chile and Iceland just said. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you very much. EU, I do appreciate your flexibility. So I invite to follow the example. So it seems we have an agreement to go for guidance on peer review process for description from EPSAS and delete the last part. So this is a common ground, and it's balanced, and it's supported by some parties already. Colombia, I hope we can support me on this proposal.

Colombia

Thank you, Chair.

We also are grateful to the delegation of Canada for the alternative text with respect to guidance, but we would also like to keep the second brackets, but we are flexible on the Chilean proposal supported by Panama. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Colombia.

Okay, seems we have an agreement, reached an agreement on this, and thanks to flexibility of all. We're going to use guidance, and we would delete the last part, and we should make use in a consistent way of this language along the document. Thank you very much. Now let's move to next part. Hold on. Okay, if we will use in a consistent way, we see that practically this annex is clean. So, we agree on the title, and we go to the introduction part. We have clean text on paragraphs from 1 to 3. In paragraph 4, we will adjust to guidance, and also we can delete the last part in paragraph 4. I will go through to the main part of the annex, and then we can also use on 5 the same language on 6 and 7 and 8. We have a request from Russian Federation, so this, your comments can apply to sections Roman 2, because Roman 1 is clean. So, Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. When I was speaking first time, I said that we go for this compromise with certain caveats. And paragraph 4 is the first one where we like to see this caveat. So the beginning of the sentence will read: "This present voluntary guidance and its elements are aimed at. So I like to be very clear and straightforward in terms that in a few paragraphs, including later on in operative paragraphs, we will include this language, the guidance and/or its elements, in a few paragraphs, because that's a prerequisite for us to agree to replace reference elements with guidance. Thank you, Chair. And as you rightly said, yes, a full stop after marine areas. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Russia. I hope this is acceptable for all to have consistency and to include guidance and its elements. So this should apply for paragraphs 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8. Is that right, Russia? Can you indicate?

Russian Federation

My apologies, Chair. It's not that simple. We don't need necessarily to write it in every single paragraph. There are actually a few paragraphs where we like to see it. There are other paragraphs when the word guidance can stay just guidance. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you for the clarification. So just for section Roman 2 on purpose, it only applies on 4. And in 4, 5, and 6, and 7, and 8, we will use guidance. Russia.

Russian Federation

Thank you, co-chair. Paragraph 6. So the paragraph we have on the second sentence, on the third line, there are currently square brackets. So we, of course, like to open the square brackets because this guidance, they are intended collectively or in individual basis to serve, because that's the same language related to elements.

CBDChair

My understanding, as I see on CRP4, there are no brackets in the middle of para 6. So I think those are left.

Russian Federation

So, Chair, again, for us, it's a part of it. So we probably didn't attend to every single contact group. So we are bringing it here. Again, it's a part. So that's collectively, yeah, or on an individual basis. So we may say differently, they are intended collectively or by individual elements to be in line with what we said in paragraph 4, to serve as a reference, et cetera. That's again the part of this overall suggestion. Thank you.

CBDChair

Okay, my understanding is that it's clean. And now I have Chile.

Chile

Thank you so much, Chair, and thank you so much, Russia, for this proposal. On the paragraph 4, we could be flexible to have guidance on/or its elements are aimed and blah, blah, blah. Regarding the last part of the paragraph, that dilutes a little bit the purpose. We don't want to be here the ones that start pushing against compromise formula. So if the deletion of the last part could actually allow us to have some compromise here, we could be flexible on that. However, I'm sorry to jump into number six. But my recollection of that working group, it was that Russian Federation agrees to delete the brackets around collectively or on an individual basis. I recollect that there was a distinguished delegation of Russian Federation present at the second contact group, and they agreed upon to leave those brackets. Maybe my recollection is failing due to the hour that we were held in that contact group, but I also checked my notes and also have those brackets lifted. So I would like to encourage, and this is not a direct encouragement to Russian Federation, but to all delegations. to avoid at this stage of the process to try to reopen clean text, unless this could be a formula to leave more brackets, as is the request that you made to us at the beginning of this working group, distinguished Kocher. Thank you so much.

CBDChair

Thank you, Chile. But my understanding is that Russia was confirming the deletion of the brackets in paragraph 6. So it's clean. That's my understanding, unless Russia can correct me. EU, followed by Russia.

EU

Thank you, Chair. We have the same view as Chile on those brackets. But going back to para 4, which Russia had a proposal for, we can be flexible for the insertion in the beginning, but I would also note that it, or those elements, or whatever it was, really makes the last part needed in this place. So we would like to keep the last bracket in 4, particularly if we introduce the Russian proposal after guidance? Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. EU? I have Russian Federation. Please also to consider that probably another relevant compatible can stay in the sense that we already took it out from the title. Maybe it's relevant to keep it here in paragraph 4. But you have the floor, Russia.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. First, I will respond to paragraph 6. I think that recollection from Chile is correct, with the only one, not really a minor, but most significant point. That was in the situation when the title of the document for us was reference elements, and we were saying that collectively or individually those elements will We are changing the title now, so we're changing this portion as well. So to be clear, right? Because we came with this agreement on guidance just now. All our deliberations during contact groups were based on the title, starting with reference elements. So for paragraph 4, I was I think pretty straightforward when introduced the title, that we are not in the position to consider those guidelines as guiding anything beyond EBSA process. So that's why it's not acceptable for us to have reference to other compatible elements anywhere in the text of those guidelines. And I think I extensively explained why for several times in Nairobi, in Yerevan, and even today. So I don't think I need to come back to it. Thank you.

CBDChair

So we have in para 4 guidance on its elements. And it's still the proposal to delete the last part in having congruence with the title. I understand that EU prefers to keep it, so I must for flexibility of delegations for not to send text with brackets. And we're limiting here to EPSAS. Can you leave for para 4 with the deletion of last part? Some flexibility, EU.

EU

Thank you. We have been indeed very flexible, but I would also like to note, Mr. Chair, that we were not the only delegation wanting to retain this element when it's not mentioned in the title. So there were several delegations except and the EU and its 27 member states. Thank you.

CBDChair

Panama.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. Panama supports the EU and its desire to keep this text. Thank you.

CBDChair

We keep it in brackets and move to next. On paragraph 5 and 6, we will use guidance in a consistent way. And now on paragraph 6, so we're using guidance. Sorry, paragraph 6. I will ask the Secretariat to read how the formulation is there, because I'm a little bit confused on the comments if for miscellaneous text, but there's some element on reference text, right? So can you help us to clarify the interpretation in paragraph 6? Yes, please, Secretariat. To my understanding or our understanding, the text is correct as it is, because we don't need to twice make reference in the same line, practically. So I'll ask Secretariat to read this part and maybe we don't see a need to amend.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you, Chair. best that I could understand the proposed textual change from the Russian Federation. The phrase collectively or on an individual basis would be changed to collectively or with respect to individual reference elements, but I may have misheard or not captured that accurately.

CBDChair

Russia.

Russian Federation

Thank you, and thank you, Secretariat. Yeah, almost there. And I will use the benefit of Secretariat representative being a native speaker. So maybe they are intended on its entirety or its individual elements, if that reads better. We don't need to say reference elements, so we get rid of word reference.

CBDChair

Secretary.

CBDSecretariat representative

So, maybe, may require some slight editorial work, but would be something like, maybe I'll read the sentence with the textual change. So it would read as follows, "They are intended in their entirety or, with respect to individual elements, to serve as a reference for good practice in support of relevant decisions of the Conference of the Parties, in particular decision 16/16.

CBDChair

I hope that clarifies. I see noting from Russian Federation. I hope we can go along with that and to move. I'm really anxious to make progress on this annex and to go to the other sections that require more detailed considerations. Tuvalu.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. I'm hoping that we're very close, but I thought if we included noting in a present voluntary guidance and its elements, as suggested by the Russian Federation, then we could just live with the language as it appears, because it then clearly states that they are intended collectively or on an individual basis, means you're referring either to the guidance and its elements. So there's no need to qualify that language. And I think it's quite reasonable as it appears now. And I think if we go with guidance and its elements are non-prescriptive, Then if you say they are intended collectively or on an individual basis, that refers back to the guidance and the elements. So I'm not sure why we need a change to language. Thank you.

CBDChair

Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair, and thank you, Tuvalau. So I agree with that. So if on the first line we have guidance and its elements, we don't need repetition on the second paragraph. Yes, I agree.

CBDChair

So we're set with the inclusion and elements at the beginning and no need to modify the text in between. Thank you very much. Canada, help us to move on.

Canada

Thank you, Chair. Apologies. Just a maybe editorial suggestion. Since we are referring here to guidance as the main document, perhaps it should say, the second sentence should start with, it is intended, and then in its entirety, and so forth.

CBDChair

Thank you. Canada is an editorial amendment.

EU

Thank you, Chair. Just like Canada, we can probably live with that as well. Just a question. This isn't going to be a big issue for us. We just had our understanding and looking at my notes from the contact group, I think we got rid of the word present, the present voluntary. Because that's just in my notes, and I'm not 100% sure that really happened. So it's a question. It doesn't really make sense. Either that sort of suggests that there will be other guidance coming soon, and I don't think that's the case. So it's either a language issue, but I think we dealt with it in the contact group. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you for the heads up, EU. So this is an editorial change. We can leave to the editors to fix it if needed. Thank you so much. So with this, we covered already Roman 2 on purpose. And I invite you to move to Roman 3, where we can use guidance. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Sorry, Chair, not exactly. Of course, in paragraph 7, we replace with guidance. In paragraph 8, we replace also on the first line with guidance. Yes. But we put, of course, full stop after convention.

CBDChair

So you propose to delete the last part saying or any process related to application of relevant, compatible and complementary scientific criteria at the end of paragraph 8? Comments? Can we accept that? Iceland, Canada.

Iceland

Thank you, Chair. Just maybe something for clarification. In this document that I have before me, then the changes that were just suggested by Russian Federation, they're clean text, aren't they? So we would like to just focus on the brackets. and come to an agreement on that. So I hope the room is willing to work with us on that, that we leave clean text, clean. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Iceland. And you are right. We're working on those paragraphs with brackets. And so far, the section with bracket was the beginning, and it's an agreement to follow the use of guidance on caveats as measured by Russian Federation, so I ask for flexibility to my good friend in order to move on. I have Canada and Russian Federation.

Canada

Thank you, Chair. I just wanted to support Iceland. Yeah, this is a clean text, and I'm surprised that we're adding brackets now.

Speaker 173

Thank you.

CBDChair

Russia.

Russian Federation

It is not clean text. It's a part of the deal related to the change of the title. I mean, I believe everyone should understand that change of the title doesn't mean simply change of the title. As we actually, otherwise, within the text, we will keep the reference elements everywhere. If we're changing the title, we need to understand that accordingly, the text of the annex is changing. Thank you.

CBDChair

Chile.

Chile

Thank you so much, sir. I understand that the title sometimes doesn't capture the whole content of a document, because a title is not an abstract, it's a title. But we already have flexibility here to delete or at least to keep in brackets the element on other relevant, compatible, and complementary scientific criteria in number 4. And that was bracketed text, but I don't see the other brackets around Annex 1 that could allow us at this point of the conversation to delete text, delete that proposed text in number 8. But besides that procedural element, I also would like to highlight that here, this is a negative phrase. So actually, I think it's quite convenient for everyone that we wouldn't like to have these voluntary guidelines applying to us, neither here on FSAS, neither anywhere. So I think it's actually, and I don't know, I don't want to advise on a strategy to another party on the here, but I think This is a part where you should take it in the way that it is if you want to protect that interest that was declared at the beginning of this conversation. Just to comment on that. Thank you so much, Erik.

CBDChair

Thank you very much, Shelly. I think this is a very good comment because nothing on this voluntary guidance gives rise to any changes. So maybe we don't It's a negative text, as you said. So maybe Russia can live with that because it's not considering this as that's the intent of the paragraph. EU follow Aytoualou.

EU

Yes, thank you. Chile basically made the point I was going to make that the last point actually makes it stronger. So, on that note, it basically says that these voluntary guidelines does not give rise to any changes. Yeah, that's fine. With that, I think that, given that we also thought it was clean text in this context, I would prefer to retain it. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Tuvalu, followed by Panama.

Tuvalu

Yes, we're trying to understand the logic. We understand the title of this section relates to elements. But I'm not sure that that relates directly to what we're talking about here. So I'm not sure why the provision of talking about the title relates to this issue. So we would like to keep the words as they appear in the paragraph. Thank you.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. supports what was said by Chile, European Union, and Canada on this matter. Thank you.

CBDChair

Given the nature of this negative text intention, can we keep the language?

Russian Federation

No, thank you. So we are not in a position to have this language anywhere in the annex. As I said already, there is one exception. in some paragraphs above, which already clean paragraph and we didn't touch it, because it was a factual reflection of the decision of COP. Otherwise, nothing in this document should refer to any other process outside EBSAs. Thank you.

CBDChair

Okay, so far, we can move and leave this paragraph with brackets at the end, or maybe I can try something more acrobatic, let's say. If we just say, nothing in the voluntary guidelines gives rise to any changes to the modalities adopted in decision 16/16, and full stop. So why? It's a negative thing, including negative elements and other negative elements and so on. This is maybe a naive intent. Otherwise, we keep the whole sentence with the last part in brackets. Can you support my proposal? Chile.

Chile

Thank you so much, sir. I'm sorry for taking the floor here again. We Deeply regret that we are opening here clean text, but thank you so much for bringing here some constructive proposal. Maybe we could actually move from this annex with that. We could be support your proposal here, and we would be glad to have that proposal. We know that at the end, we need to be equally unhappy. So I would add that to my part of the unhappiness here. Thank you so much.

CBDChair

Thank you. I see many requests. Are those against my suggestion? If those, then you can keep your request. If you are supporting my suggestion, please delete. There's only one now. Canada.

Canada

Thank you, Chair. Just wanted to make a statement that since we are removing clean text, I would like to implore that this is the last time that we are adding bracket and then removing text that was already clean. I hope that's clear. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you for your understanding and flexibility. This is against our own rules. There's a difference in interpretation if it's a clean or it's a paragraph in brackets. I don't want to engage in that discussion, but it's a way forward to to continue. So we have clean section 2 in Roman. I believe on Roman 3, in the title, we will use guidance, and there is no need to make any other amendments. And sections C, D, till the end of Annex 1. So we have clean text. Now let's move to Annex 2, terms of reference for the in front of advisory group. We have clean text on paragraph 1, paragraph 2A, and we have brackets on 1 and 2B, 2C, and B alt and C alt. So I open the floor for comments here. And please wait a moment. I was explained by Secretariat that we have B and C, and we have also B and C alt as a compromise text to replace B and C. So my suggestion is to work on the basis on B and C alt and to lift the brackets. Can you support this idea, this proposal? So I have UK and Iceland.

United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Thank you, Co-Chair. The UK is in favour of the proposal here that we proposed in the second contact group for B and C alt. This proposal was made to streamline paragraphs B and C and make it really clear that this work will draw on the cooperation opportunities identified at the expert workshop in Bergen last year. We would prefer a reference to the BBNJ agreement here as well, as the agreement has just entered into force, and so there's a need to ensure that cooperation continues as it is a core element of the BBNJ agreement. And in relation to other instruments, frameworks, and bodies, as noted in the expert workshop, there are many opportunities for cooperation, collaboration, and synergies, and this informal advisory group can really help advise on and navigate those opportunities. So we would be in favor of removing the brackets around B and C alt. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you very much for your support. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. As we have been spoken many times, we are not in the position to agree on those elements. So we only can agree on element A. And we also said it at the contact group, where basically we were not participating in discussions. because the direction B and C goes, we can't support it. So we request to delete B and C. Thank you.

CBDChair

Tubalufayo, followed by EU.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. We're grateful for the work of the UK to try and bring these two paragraphs together, and we think B and C alt is a good wording. It's critical that we make reference to the United Nations Convention of the Law of the Sea on the conservation and sustainable use of marine biological diversity of areas beyond national jurisdiction. And we notice this appears in a number of paragraphs, and we certainly want to make reference to this. And the reason why is the timeliness of this new agreement fits well with the thematic work under the Convention on Biodiversity. So there are clearly synergies between those two agreements to exchange views and to cooperate, and it's critically important. And for Pacific Island countries, you know, we see this is, the reference to BBNJ is vitally important because of our cultural past, our practices of being seafarers across wide areas of the sea, and our connections with the marine biodiversity, such as whales, et cetera, that connect to our beliefs, our social systems, our totems. that are animals that extend beyond the economic exclusion zone. So we see the connection with the BBNJ agreement is critically important in this whole decision. I understand your logic. So we would like to retain it. Thank you.

CBDChair

So you want to keep it. So please, let's focus on the text. And we understand by many reasons why you're supporting some language. So let's be brief. EU, followed by Iceland, Norway, Panama, Chile, Cook Islands, Philippines. Be aware of the time, please. I'm trying to see if we are going, if we're making any progress. If not...

EU

Thank you, Chair. We are eager to work on progress with you and other delegations here in this room. So, yes. We are fine with BNC as they are, and we are grateful for the UK's proposal to join BNC. That works for us as well. And I think that I don't need to go into a lot of arguments why, because our colleague from Tuvalu very eloquently described them. So we support them as well. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you very much. Iceland.

Iceland

Thank you, Chair. So we support your approach to work on the basis of BNC-ALT. Thank you for that suggestion. We would like to keep this version as it is, and given the explanation by UK and further explained by Tuvalu, so we support those speakers. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Norway, followed by Panama and Chile.

Norway

Thank you, Chair. We are happy to support the proposal from the UK here, and we would also like to retain the reference to the BBNJ Agreement. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you.

Panama.

Panama

We too back the proposal of the United Kingdom.

We would like to take as our starting point the B and C alt version. Thank you.

Chile

We would like to move forward with the proposal of the United Kingdom. Yes, we agree with Russia. We can delete B and C. Thank you so much.

CBDChair

Yes, that's what I was to ask, if we can delete A and B, B and C, and I heard someone to retain it, but in order to have less options, I see full support for B and C alt, just to have that as a basis and brackets. Cook Islands.

Cook Islands

Thank you, Chair. We would also support the inclusion of B and C alt. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you so much. Philippines and Peru.

Philippines

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

We support the deletion of B and C. We thank the UK for B and C alt, and we support this current wording.

We feel that this qualified by the clause as appropriate, and it keeps the nature of the advisory group being.

Advisory as described in this.

CBDChair

So you support B and C alt. Thank you. Jamaica? No. Philippines.

Speaker 209

Peru.

CBDChair

Maybe you're using Peru's button. Okay, Jamaica.

Jamaica

Thank you, Chair.

We also support BNC-ALT.

CBDChair

Thank you. So I see full support for BNC-ALT. Peru.

Peru

We too, we back the proposal of the United Kingdom.

Thank you.

CBDChair

Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair, and my apologies if I was not clear enough. So I will repeat. We can leave in this terms of reference only this paragraph A, no B, no C, no new B, no new C, no alt. So I just probably now more explicit than I've been.

CBDChair

Thank you. You are explicit enough, but there is also full support for many countries, many parties on B and C also. Let's keep that paragraph in brackets and move on. Next, we have two sets of brackets on paragraph 3. I propose to leave the brackets on the first set on including from civil society, indigenous peoples, and local communities, and also to leave the brackets and representation of indigenous peoples and local communities and so on. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Unfortunately, we can't do that. Again, we reiterated it many times. We consider all this process and this particular group as a very expert group. So the language currently there, which talking about all relevant stakeholder is opening door for anyone to be part of it if They have expertise, so we don't want to see in this very specialized group anyone who is simply representing one or another organization without this expertise. So we are not in a position to support the first square bracket and also the second square bracket. And probably, again, maybe to limit my interventions. So the position starting from Nairobi was that we are not in favor of this expert group at all. We asked to delete any reference to this group and not to establish it. Only in the spirit of compromise in Nairobi, we offered a way forward how we can keep this expert group and save it. This is reflected in this document, the extent where we can go for the compromise, for having this group at all. Thank you.

CBDChair

Dear delegates, I'm remembering that we already have a modus operandi for SUBSTEP. That's in a decision that we took many years ago, and I don't know why we are having deja vus on this matter. So any ATEC established should be based on nominations. and should go through the Sub-Staff Bureau and to consider different kind of balances in regions, in disciplines, in gender, and some other elements, and also observers. So my suggestion is to make reference to the modus operandi for this and any other ADIC. I personally have been saying that in a different capacity, not as a chair. So we are reinterpreting again text that we already have. I will ask Secretary to remember all the models of. So probably what we can do is to have the first part of this paragraph three, when we say it's composed by 20 experts, five regional groups, I mean, for me, it's not necessary. 10 nominated by intergovernmental bodies on the matter and 7 experts by other relevant organizations, and full stop. We don't need to go to prescription on what the Secretariat should do, when to connect to substate, so we can say in accordance to modus operandi of substate. That can be a way to avoid these discussions. I will ask the Secretary to remind us on this. text in the Modus Operandi for substance.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you, Chair. So the modus operandi of SUBSTA refers to expert groups drawing on, quote, "existing knowledge and competence available within and liaising as appropriate with, as appropriate, international, regional, and national organizations, including non-governmental organizations and the scientific community, as well as indigenous and local community organizations and the private sector in fields relevant to this convention.

CBDChair

I will ask Secretary to keep reading part of the, because I think we can avoid a lot of unnecessary discussions.

CBDSecretariat representative

So this is from the modus operandi of substance section H, para 18, para 18A, we can start with. The ad hoc technical expert groups should draw on the existing knowledge and competence available within and liaise with, as appropriate, international, regional, and national organizations, including non-governmental organizations and the scientific community, as well as indigenous and local community organizations and the private sector in fields relevant to this convention. Para 18B. reads, "The Executive Secretary, in consultation with the Bureau of Substa, will select scientific and technical experts from the nominations submitted by parties for each ad hoc technical expert group. The ad hoc technical expert groups shall be composed of no more than 15 experts nominated by parties competent in the relevant field of expertise, with due regard to geographical representation, gender balance, and to the specific conditions of developing countries, in particular the least developed and small island developing states, and countries with economies in transition, as well as a limited number of experts from relevant organizations depending on the subject matter. The number of experts from organizations shall not exceed the number of experts nominated by parties.

CBDChair

So this is the general reference that we always follow, so maybe we can just say in line with the provisions of the models of and then we don't need to go to the list of different stakeholders. That's my proposal that we can go forward, so we can delete the last part. This making reference to regions, to technical capacity, to different balances in regions, and so on. I hope this is applicable. Otherwise, we just continue with the text as it is, with brackets, these two sets of brackets for paragraph 3. I see a long list: Chile, followed by UK, South Africa, Iceland. I just want to see if there is support, otherwise I don't want to entertain you.

Chile

Thank you so much, Chair, and we truly appreciate the efforts to be constructive here and try to avoid endless discussions. We need more time to reflect here on the wording that has been proposed, because one of the elements that is mentioned is, for example, gender balance, but we have here some direct mentions about women and youth, and those are not necessarily embedded on the wording that has been proposed. But Before to bring additional elements here, I would like just to ask for clarification from the Secretariat if it's the same an ATEC as an AIG in terms of modus operandi here. I think it could be relevant to have that clarification first. We have some text for proposals here on the regional language, but I would like to hear first the room in order to avoid extend this discussion if we could proceed in the way that you offer here. And I also ask for your indulgence and at the same question, if you could clarify regarding if an ATEC is the same as an AIG, I could like so as your indulgence if it's possible to also take the interventions from observers that already see that youth and women are asking for the floor, so maybe it could be also useful to hear their own voices regarding the importance of having them here or not. But again, we are in your hands.

CBDChair

Thank you. Thank you, Chile. No, an informal advisory is not the same as an article. Maybe we can say as appropriate or as applicable to consider this, but there was an intent not to repeat and to delete the second part. And I see some requests also from some observers, but I give them priority to parties. And if it's just to set importance, we already understand, but we need to save time. So I count with your indulgence, and I know that what you will ask is to be considered, but I just was trying to save time since it's not the case. If it's not, then I withdraw my proposal, and let's continue if you have some more elements for this paragraph, which, to my understanding, remained with the two sets of brackets. If we're not going anywhere, we should move to the next one. UK, follow by South Africa and Iceland.

United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Thank you, Mr. Chair. I wonder if perhaps one solution for the first set of paragraphs may be to insert the word "experts," so including experts from civil society and indigenous peoples and local communities, that may solve some of the concerns around the use of experts in this group. Thank you.

CBDChair

I believe it says already expert and seven experts nominated by relevant organizations, including from civil society. I think it's implicit, but another English native speaker. South Africa.

South Africa

Thank you very much, Chair. South Africa considers the proposal by the Chair to be progressive. I think it will help to avoid the protracted conversation. Alternatively, Chair, we would propose putting the word as appropriate at the end of the bracket with local communities. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, South Africa. We can include this appropriate at the end. Iceland, follow by EU and Tuvalu.

Iceland

Yes, thank you, Chair. Well, we were going to compliment you on your acrobatics and support your suggestion. If it's still on the table, we support it, given questions raised, though, by Chile, if it actually is then applicable to an AIG. So we support your suggestion with that. If not, if it's not still on the table, and if it helps, we support the UK inclusion of experts, as well as South Africa's inclusion of, as appropriate, after communities. We're in your hands.

CBDChair

Thank you, and I am yours, Hans, also. EU followed by Tuvalu and Canada.

EU

Thank you, Chair. I'd just like to say that we EU would like to keep the language as it is, but we realize we need to find a solution here. So maybe if we can keep the second bracket as it is and go along with your proposal in the first bracket, we're referencing the modus operandi of the substa in the first bracket, but we would prefer to do the second part. The second part, I'd like to support as well the Chilean proposal that we are keenly wanting to hear the observer status as well, lest they are keenly part of this draft decision. So we would like to hear them as well. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. We need to go quickly in our interventions if we can, want to allow observers to take it through. Tuvalu followed by Canada and the Russian Federation.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. We thought there was significant overlap between your proposal and what's here on the text, with the exception of not making a reference to women and youth, and we think that's an important element that we could bring in here. We'd have to do some significant wordsmithing to relate to what the modus operandi for ad hoc working groups compared with informal advisory groups, so we could, we'd have to be. manipulative, I guess, of that reference, I guess, because they are two distinct processes and groupings. Of course, we could just use that wording as a model in here. But I think we're very close. We think we could work on this paragraph, remove all the brackets, and move on. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Canada, followed by Russian Federation.

Canada

Thank you, Chair. Just like Iceland, we actually like your suggestion. I just would like to bring to everyone's attention that there are many other paragraphs where we have references to IPLCs, women, youth, and whatnot. So I hope that we'll still be able to consider those on a paragraph-by-paragraph basis, but we'd like to support your suggestion in the spirit of moving forward, of course. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you for the support. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. So I can't agree more with Canada and what we actually tirelessly saying at all meetings. We have context each time. There is no simply a blank formula to be applied everywhere. Here, there is, first of all, very specific group. But overall, Chair, we absolutely agree with you, because this language is a language from modus operandi. So to capture it in its entirety, we fully support your suggestions at the end of the first sentence, after organizations. So there is simply a reference to modus operandi. We, of course, also awaiting the response from the Secretariat. but establishment of all groups, which actually also call subsidiary bodies, but not permanent, of this convention, they follow the same rules. So, and we need to follow those rules there as well. And everything is captured in the document referred to. For those who have certain kind of doubts, I also like to draw your attention clearly to the second last line of the paragraph, where the gender balance is clearly stated, also in line with the document read by the Secretariat. So again, let's put the reference to the document at the end of first paragraph, delete the second paragraph, and move forward. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. I have Panama, followed by women and youth.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. It's very important for us to maintain the mention of the representation of indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth. We think it's very relevant. So it's very important for us to keep these references. Thank you.

CBDChair

Now I'll give the floor to women, seat 253.

CBD Women's CaucusCBD Women's CaucusRepresentative; marine scientist

Thank you, Chair. I'm speaking on behalf of the CBD Women's Caucus and also as a marine scientist. We kindly urge parties to retain the language in this specific annex in paragraph 3. Women around the world are developing science and technology, fundamental pillars for monitoring and providing crucial scientific research. Also, most of us are already part of an IAP and we're contributing in these decisions. So this kind of work needs to be considered as key element in the decision-making processes. We risk losing the integral vision despite important contributions that already exist. We need to address those gaps as well as recognize the women in order to identify cooperation and synergies. And we already see that's the main point of this, the cooperation and the synergies. And we cannot talk about cooperation without women and also without youth. Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you. Women representative, of course, are important. Remember, this is an informal advisory group with only 20 people, and we need to find all the different balances to participate accordingly to support the work on coastal and marine biodiversity. We're not talking about implementation and the different elements of the program. We are establishing elements to define an informal advisory group in the best way.

GYBNGYBN

Thank you, Chair. I'm speaking on behalf of the Global Youth Biodiversity Network. The ocean belongs to us all. Our collective action depends on explicit inclusion of diverse stakeholders and acknowledging synergies between the CBD and BBNJ. We therefore support the establishment of the IAG, and we urge Parties to lift the brackets in paragraphs 3 and 5 of Annex II that explicitly names Indigenous Peoples, local communities, women, and youth. Chair, in many parts of the world, young people like myself are often the first in our families to complete tertiary education, while still being part of the communities whose lives depend on the ocean. The dual understanding and expertise is exactly what this process lacks. Decisions taken here too often remain disconnected from the areas they affect, and the knowledge held on these shores too rarely reaches this room. Removing explicit reference to right holders groups and not defining us widens that disconnect. The KMGVF sets a vision for 2050. Those of us speaking for youth today will be the ones still here in 2050, living with the oceans these decisions shape. We request that you let us help shape it. Thank you, Chair, and we ask Parties to support our proposal.

CBDChair

Thank you, Jude. I will ask Secretariat where we are with the different suggestions on this paragraph. I know some Parties support my proposal to make reference to modus operandi, and there are some elements around, so please try your best, Joe.

CBDSecretariat representative

Thank you, Chair. So I will read language that's on the table, but before doing so, and in hopes that this may also answer some questions that have been raised, specifically regarding whether the modus operandi of Substa and language around ATEGs also refers to informal advisory groups. I'm going to refer to decision. decision from COP 13, which was COP decision 13/12 on EBSAs. This was the decision that created the EBSA Informal Advisory Group. And in that decision is a specific reference to following the guidance, it's quote, establish following the guidance on the expert groups contained in the consolidated modus operandi of SUBSTA and lists the specific paragraphs that I read out before. So, Although we don't have, as far as I know, specific and separate modus operandi for informal advisory groups, when we have created informal or the COP has created informal advisory groups in the past, it has specifically referred to the modus operandi of substa and the specific paragraphs that I referenced before. So, the text that would read here would, and I'll start from the text that's currently in brackets. would read, including from civil society and indigenous peoples and local communities, following the guidance on expert groups contained in the consolidated modus operandi of Substa as appropriate. And we have also, in the previous decision, made a specific reference to the modus operandi decision, which is decision 810, Annex 3, paragraph H. So it would read as, following the guidance on expert groups contained in the consolidated modus operandi of Substa, parentheses decision 810, Annex 3, para H, as appropriate. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Secretary. I hope we can add that reference to help. We still have brackets around. including from civil society and indigenous peoples and local communities, and we still have brackets on at the end on representation of IPLCs, women and youth, and relevant stakeholders. That's where we are so far. Any help to move on? Or we move to next paragraph. Russian Federation.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Secretariat, for clarifying for everyone. So that was also our full understanding how the system works for many, many years. So at this point, we simply ask you, Chair, to keep the including from civil society, indigenous people, local communities in square brackets, and add the text. as provided by the Secretariat, and then, of course, delete the second sentence, because everything from that sentence is sitting in modus operandi, so it's not needed. There's a probably, I think, as appropriate is fine instead of referencing particular paragraphs. Whatever is relevant from modus operandi. Thank you.

CBDChair

All right, I think this is the more we can make progress on this paragraph. Maybe we need to update the mode of operation of SOPs that include women and youth, because this is what we're missing. And I believe I heard that many parties want to keep the language to consider the different balances, but remember, this is only to nominate 20 people to go into this informal advisory group on EPSAS, please. So my suggestion is to go forward with the insertion to making reference to the consolidated modes of mandate as applicable, as appropriate, and to keep both set of brackets since we haven't reached an agreement, and move to the next one. So, para 5. So we have informal advisory group made by experts from outside the group as appropriate, including representatives of indigenous peoples and local communities. So I don't know if it's a reiteration of what we had before. I propose to leave the brackets on alternative text, and we know It's a deja vu of previous paragraph, but I leave Chile, Russian Federation, and Tuvalu.

Chile

Thank you so much, Chair. Thank you to women and youth for presenting their inputs regarding the previous discussion that we have here. It's unfortunate that we couldn't have that mention. There's a bigger purpose here, but we agree with you that it's quite important to update the modus operandi. And coming back to number five here, we see that importance and keep the language that is now bracketed. We would like to make a small suggestion here, just to say including experts from Indigenous peoples and local communities, women, and youth. and the lead and representatives of. We think that could address the idea that was mentioned before by Russian Federation regarding that this is an idea to have expertise here, but we see a lot of importance to have here experts from IPLCs, from women, from youth, as has been already explained by their own voices when you kindly give them the floor. So thank you so much, Chair, and I hope this could be agreeable text for everyone in the room. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. So the suggestion is to amend instead of representatives, experts from indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth. Russian Federation, followed by Tuvalu, Panama, and UK.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair, and thanks to Chile for trying to find a solution. So as Chile is also advocating to retain the language, I like just to ask a question. So if What specifically means, in this case, women in use? If we are inviting expert from outside group, and this expert is from a relevant institution with expertise, and it's women, it's not enough. So there is need some specific search for what? So if this is a young scientist, one, for example, as a distinguished delegate and representative of youth who was speaking as a young marine scientist, will come from this appropriate organization as an expert. So what in addition need to be mentioned here? So we will be happy to hear explanation what will be on top of it. But coming back to the suggestion in terms of indigenous peoples, local communities with the language proposed by Chile, we can go ahead with that. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Russian Federation. So if you can support to go along what Chile is proposing, we can delete them brackets, right? You note.

Russian Federation

Not exactly, because again, I need a rationale from Chile for my questions. Because I don't understand. I see complete redundancy in this particular case. I agree there are many cases when all three groups can be mentioned as important stakeholders in a different process. Struggle to understand it in this particular context. So that's why I requested the response from Chile. Thank you.

CBDChair

Well, Chile think about the reply. I don't want to put it now on the spot. I have more requests, so give the floor to Balu, follow with Panama.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. We think we should lift the brackets here. It's important to name the groups. And in fact, I would suggest we flip. Chile's suggestion and delete "experts" and just have "including representatives," because in the first part of the sentence, we're inviting experts from outside the group as appropriate, including representatives of Indigenous peoples. And we know from our own experience in our own country that we have young people who have expertise and knowledge passed on from them by their families, et cetera, that would be important to be included in any sort of consultation we have with this informal group. So that's why we think inclusion of youth, and the same goes with women where knowledge is passed on. So we think I'll throw that back to Chile, whether they could live with just having including representatives of indigenous peoples and not have experts because it's repetitive. Thank you.

CBDChair

I need your help, colleagues. Panama, followed by UK and Chile.

Panama

Thank you, Chair. I wanted to support Chile's proposal, and I wanted to mention, to get some background, why are we stressing so much? Because barriers to financing support for youth and women to be trained in this area is very different from men, and in this framework, it's very necessary for us to give priority to the participation of researchers, women researchers, and youth in these consultations. So we see it as very, very important to maintain the reference to them in this document. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Cesar Chair. Let's remind that this is about forming a 20 person group that will be working online with EBSPS. So let's not confuse it with implementation of the global framework. This is to provide advice on how to move forward, please. So let's be very clear as to what this group is all about, okay? UK followed by Chile.

United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

Thank you, Mr. Chair. The UK would like to support the statement made by Tuvalu. We feel that representatives of indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth, would be the right formulation here, as these are experts from outside the group, and that would be repetitive to use the word "experts" twice here. And so, yeah, we could go along with Tuvalu's proposal. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. So we go for representatives on the second one, Chile.

Chile

Thank you very much, Chair. Since I'm in the hot seat, let me give you some references to explain my position.

To English. First, In comparison with what we are having now regarding the modus operandi in para 3, in para 5, we don't have any kind of safeguards regarding, for example, gender balance. So there's here no obligations to have at all invitation to women, for example, to be part of that space as an invited expert or representative. We will see where we landed on that. And I would like just to recall on the preangular paragraph 13 of the preamble of the convention. I know that this is an informal advisory group, but the convention said, and affirms the need for the full participation of women at all levels of policy making and implementation of Biodiversity Convention. So I think that advice is also part of those policy levers. We can be flexible, but at least we would like to acknowledge here that there's some value on have this mentions, especially because here we don't have any kind of safeguard regarding gender balance. And regarding the participation of youth, I just would like to recall that Particularly, we have a really strong network around the world that is ECOPs, the Early Career Ocean Professionals, and they provide a different and really interesting views regarding the new advances that we are having right now on ocean sciences and other related sciences. And I think it's quite important to also recognize the value, the added value that youth could provide to these particular discussions, and then sending also that there's new developing technology, there's new technologies that could be provide added value the important discussions that we, I hope, we will have under this group. But thank you so much, Chair, for reminding us what is the objective of this group. And I hope that with that explanation, we could accommodate and be more a little bit flexible here to have this recognition, because this is an invitation. And as an invitation, it shouldn't be quite a burden here to accept that invitation as much inclusive as possible. Thank you so much, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you, Chile. We have 10 minutes more, more or less, to finish our session, and I would like to see progress, and I hope we can finish with this annex. Let me express my understanding. In paragraph 3, if we apply the consolidated model of per diem as appropriate for this informal advisory group, we are including civil society, indigenous peoples, and local communities, so we don't need to mention them, right? Just being from the practical part. And when we go to paragraph 5, this is the opportunity to include those groups that are not in part on current models of parana when we can make reference to women and youth. I believe With this, we complement the part that is missing in the model of a run day of substance that was agreed in 2008, I guess, in Germany. So after 20 years, it needs an update, definitely. By that time, stakeholders have been evolving. Our convention has been evolving. So we need to obey that. But to me, for 20 people, if we make reference modus operandi, it's including IPLCs. So we don't need to reiterate there. And we can use the opportunity of paragraph 5 to invite experts from, in this case, not again indigenous peoples and local communities, because already are considered among these 20 people, and to include women and youth. That's my proposal so we can leave delete one text in brackets on 3 and to complement the gap with paragraph 5. This is to get the number of people that will advise for two years working online. Let's see if it flies, and if not, we will move with the leave the Annex 2 with some brackets in it. EU followed by Iran and Cook Islands.

EU

Thank you, Chair. I'll try to be brief. Just a short recap of what, as you very usefully reminded us, Chair, on the purpose of this group. And indeed, it is to provide advice. It is, and we find, we tend to find that groups that have had, that have been very inclusive of different perspectives and different backgrounds, have been working a lot better, and the advice given has gotten a higher quality. So that's also with the sort of view to what the distinguished representative of Chile just said. Having that in mind also, the proposal from, I think it was Tuvalu, on representatives may be a way forward, but we really would like to have this working group delivering as good advice as possibly. So we would definitely want all perspectives included, regardless of which language we use here. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Eyu. I agree with that rationale. Iran, followed by Cook Islands and Norway.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Thank you, Mr. Chair. We want to follow your suggestions in paragraph 5 and delete the text in the brackets because it's just inviting experts for these groups and as appropriate. So it depends on who who is more, the person who's more appropriate to use it, to attend these groups or to these informal advisory groups. So we should not repeat those things that have already been mentioned before. Thank you so much.

CBDChair

Thank you, Dan. And Cook Islands, followed by Norway, Iceland, Russian Federation, and Tuvalu. We have five minutes.

Cook Islands14 Pacific small island developing States

Cook Islands, on behalf of the.

14 Pacific small island developing states, would like to strongly support the proposal put forward by Tuvalu. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. On behalf of SIDS, Norway.

Norway

Thank you, Chair. Norway would also like to support Tuvalu here. We also wanted to add that from an Arctic perspective, IPLCs bring valuable knowledge and experience that can strengthen the group's work and advice, but we also want to find a solution here, so we can, for now, stay open and listen to what the rest of the floor says. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Norway. Iceland.

Iceland

Thank you, Chair. Yes, we are in support. If we are understanding where you were coming from with your latest acrobatics in paragraph 3 to refer to the modus operandi, and then, as you said, bridging the gap for the ones that are not mentioned in the modus operandi, women and youth in para 5. So retaining reference of women and youth in para 5. So if this is the case, I'm seeing some strong nodding. Thank you. So we support your suggestion. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you very much, Aidan. Russian Federation, followed by Tuvalu and Canada.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. Thank you also for Chile for responding to my request. So we just coming back to what it seems forgotten a bit, the suggestion from Chile. So, yes, as two others said, that maybe there is a repetition, but that's important repetition. I like to stress again, for this particular advisory group, which is advisory group on areas beyond national jurisdiction, a very highly technical, specialized group on a very specific topic. So we like to see there Only experts, and not a blankly just a representative of one or another group. Only experts. Who are those experts? That's modus operandi saying we need to have the full balance among everyone, and it will be selected. So in terms of concern by Chile is that some groups are not invited. I just like to say that we all know very well, for this kind of groups, it's not a personal invitation, and it's not invitation to particular group or institution. It's notification, which goes to everyone, and it sits on the website of the convention. Anyone can apply. There is no limitation. And there's no kind of like segregation or discrimination in this way. So every expert can apply. Paragraph five is not about members of this group also. Paragraph five is about certain cases when those members of the group, if they need to draw on a very specific expertise area, They will invite someone outside their group and not actually becoming the member of the group, but simply to address the special question and topics related to a particular area where maybe there is lacking expertise within the group itself. So we are saying here already, as appropriate, that depends upon the group. And also, we already agreed that it may include experts from indigenous peoples and local communities. And it's implicit that when we invite experts, that among those experts could be women, could be youth, young scientists, female scientists. So what else is needed, we still struggle to understand. So our final suggestion is just to say, based on the proposal from Chile, including experts from indigenous peoples and local communities. So of course, that will be included. And go forward. Otherwise, yeah, OK, paragraph will stay with square brackets. Thank you very much.

CBDChair

Tumaluu, follow by Canada and Australia. You have two minutes.

Tuvalu

Thank you, Chair. As Russia indicated, this is a separate group to the actual informal group, so we're opening it up for experts. And if we get more comfort with the use of the words "experts," we could live with experts of indigenous peoples and local communities, but we also need to clearly identify that women and youth are part of the collective grouping of who we should draw upon. So I think we're very close here. I think we could, including experts of indigenous peoples, local communities, women and youth, And just quickly as an example, you know, we know what the composition of the grouping is that we've created in this informal group, but there may be particular circumstances where the knowledge of women and youth or indigenous peoples may not be represented in that group. So we want to clearly draw on their expertise. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. I think we have a twofold purpose on five. My original suggestion was to include the gap we have already on modes operandi regarding groups, and also, as Rosh expressed, expertise needed in some issues. Of course, this is to advise, and to advise, we need knowledge. We need expertise to advise. on the progress, in this case, for areas beyond national jurisdiction. So not everybody has the knowledge, and it's important to get the benefit of this advisory group. So we maintain open in the last part, we can reach these two complementing experts. and also in knowledge. And as Roshan mentioned, it will be a notification to everybody to make nominations. All nominations will come to the Secretariat, then Substantive Bureau will see the different balances that can include all of them. I mean, it's not limit to, it's not prohibiting anyone. Any party that nominates youth representative or women is gonna be there. And then it's a matter of Substant. I was chair of Substant for three Substant, so I have the experience that we have a proposal from the Secretariat that is put in consideration for Substant Bureau to see all these different balances and to get the best fit to have a good group of experts to support on these ideas. So we are overmodulating or doing micromanagement from my point of view. And I'm sure that we're going to have a good balance when we compose this informal advisory group. We need to close. I have the last two interventions from Canada and Australia, and I request a few minutes more from our interpreters.

Canada

Thank you, Chair. For Canada, we actually would really like to see here indigenous peoples and local communities, women, and youth explicitly referenced here. And I hope I can briefly explain why.

CBDChair

No, no, no, no, no. I think we need to save time. And so you want to keep the language. It's okay. So we keep it, and it will be in brackets.

Canada

Thank you, Chair.

CBDChair

Thank you. Australia, followed by Russia.

Australia

Thank you, Chair.

For the reasons expressed by Tuvalu and Canada, we also want to support, including indigenous peoples, local communities, women and youth, thank you, in paragraph 5.

Thanks.

CBDChair

Experts. And Russian Federation, follow you.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Chair. So we stop. discuss this paragraph, my question is if Secretariat can read paragraph 3, the final form of it, that we sure how it looks like now.

CBDChair

Secretary.

CBDSecretariat representative

So, the first sentence of paragraph three would read as follows: "The informal advisory group shall be composed of up to 20 experts nominated by parties with equal representation of the five regional groups, up to 10 experts nominated by intergovernmental bodies with competence in the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity of marine areas beyond national jurisdiction, and up to seven experts nominated by other relevant organizations following the guidance on expert groups contained in the consolidated modus operandi of SUBSTA as appropriate. Thank you.

CBDChair

So this is in the understanding that IPLCs are included in the modus operandi, and then we have in five the whole sentence by IPLCs, women, and youth. But I'm in your hands. EU.

EU

Thank you, Chair. Just to be very brief, this would have to be Um, the issue in, in three and five needs to be sort of, uh, um, resolved together, um, which means that, that, um, um… depending on the outcome of five, we would be flexible to varying degrees on five. So that leaves us with possibly also considering the original language here as well for if we are just bracketing the text. Thank you.

CBDChair

I have a small suggestion that if we move paragraph 5 just immediately after paragraph 3, so we can see this together, because this is about composition, and then we can leave 4 at the end for the two-year periods that may renew and so on, so we have together all the membership and invitees to have a set. And as I understand from last intervention from EU, they want to send it back, the text in brackets, including from civil society, indigenous peoples and local communities, right? You.

EU

No, thank you. What I meant was that these are linked. that depending on the outcome of 5, we would be in a varying degree flexible on the wording in 3. So basically, if it stays, if the brackets are lifted in 5 on the current text, we would be possibly be flexible to your suggestion in 3. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. for Russian Federation, if there is some flexibility on 5 as invitation to complete expertise and different stakeholders to have including experts from indigenous peoples and other communities, women and youth, to contribute to the discussions on specific issues. And also to move 5 just after 3 to have all composition paragraphs together. Russia, can you go along with this?

Russian Federation

No. Chair, I also like Secretariat after Secretariat finished reading with saying first sentence. I was asking to read the entire paragraph or tell me that it is consist of only one sentence. For five, we have different opinion. We don't see any connection between three and five. I will explain again. although many people here understand, should understand it. Five is to invite a very particular expertise which is missing in the group on the technical issues related to areas beyond national jurisdiction. It doesn't relate to any kind of whether it's from this group, that group, another group, second group. For example, why business is missing here? It's a business which operates in the open sea and has enormous amount of information. Science is not mentioned. Who are actually those who are essential for discussion around ABNJ? So again, number five is inviting very special people exclusively based on the technical expertise on the topic. So that's why there is no really relations between those paragraphs. So that's why we can't see that as coming together. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you, Rasha. So we're going to keep it separate. And also with text in brackets on the list of different stake potential ambiguities. And you mentioned also that maybe private sector can be one of them. We don't agree to have a twofold purpose for paragraph 5, as I suggest, to be on composition and to go to specific needs on expertise. You are referring to last part, only on expertise on particular issues. You don't need to take the floor again. You ask also to Secretary to read where we are in paragraphs 3 and 4 so far. the whole text, please, Secretariat, where we are in paragraph 3 and we are in paragraph 5, and we will adjourn in the understanding that we pass already through Annex 1 and Annex 2 with a number of brackets to continue later on the operational paragraphs and preambular ones. Secretariat.

CBDSecretariat representative

So, the whole paragraph 3 currently reads as follows: The informal advisory group shall be composed of up to 20 experts nominated by parties with equal representation of the five regional groups, up to 10 experts nominated by intergovernmental bodies with competence in the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity of marine areas beyond national jurisdiction, and up to seven experts nominated by other relevant organizations, following the guidance on expert groups contained in the consolidated modus operandi of SUBSTA as appropriate. The Executive Secretary, in consultation with the Bureau of SUBSTA, shall select experts from the nominees with with due regard to a diversity of relevant technical expertise, geographical representation, including from least developed countries and small island developing states, gender balance, and the representation of indigenous peoples and local communities, women's and youth groups, and relevant stakeholders. And the final, as is shown in the CRP, There are brackets around the end of the sentence from “end the representation” until “stakeholders” the end of the sentence. So that’s paragraph three.

CBDChair

Thank you, Secretariat. Russian Federation, last intervention, please.

Russian Federation

Thank you, Secretariat. That’s exactly why first time I asked you to read paragraph, because we said three times in our interventions that with addition of reference to modus operandi, the second sentence should be deleted. So we would like to see this sentence being deleted. Thank you very much.

CBDSecretariat representative

That doesn't make.

CBDChair

Rasha, just to be clear, you are requesting to put brackets starting with "the Executive Secretary" until where? Just to be clear on this, when you said the second sentence to be deleted, please, starting from "the Executive Secretary".

Russian Federation

Yes, correct, because that's actually verbatim from modus operandi. It's redundant. That's exactly what modus operandi is saying. So we already refer to the modus operandi. It's described all this process there. So that's why the sentence doesn't make sense anymore. There's a clear reference to modus operandi.

CBDChair

Chile and Iceland.

Chile

Thank you so much, Chairs, and apologies to interpreters for keeping you also here at this time. I understand what is the point that Russian Federation is making here, but what is said on the first part of the paragraph that we are discussing right now, it said, following the guidance on experts group containing consolidated modus operandi. So, the guidance here is about the experts group, but it's not a guidance regarding what will be the procedure then for deciding on those experts group. So, that is the point to have the second phrase here. So, there's no redundancy here. I hope that could be beneficial to understand why it's important to keep the second part of this phrase.

CBDChair

I'm sorry, Chile, but there is redundancy because the selection It's part of the modus operandi. It has to be a nomination, then the Executive Secretary put for consideration of Sub-Sub Bureau and look for different balances and then set the group. So that part, Rosh is right.

Chile

It's part of the modus operandi. Thank you. Sorry, Chair, but one of the points that could solve this point is just, sir, guidance on expert group selection and nomination containing consolidated. And with that, we can just delete the second part.

CBDChair

Can you repeat your proposal, Chile?

Chile

Thank you so much. Sorry and apologies to come back here. So it will be following the guidance on expert groups nomination and selection, containing in consolidated sub-standards modus operandi as appropriate.

CBDChair

Where? After relevant organizations or what exactly?

Chile

So you have following the guidance on experts group, nomination and selection. So with that, you can do the legal drafting there.

CBDChair

I thank to interpreters for the additional time and please for few minutes more.

Interpreter

Five additional minutes granted, Chair.

CBDChair

Miguel, I give the floor to Iceland. The Secretary is trying to incorporate the text by Chile, having some problems to get something meaningful. Iceland.

Iceland

Thank you, Chair. Just a very kind reminder that we are not to be deleting or bracketing clean text. So Iceland can go along with Chile's elegant solution to this pickle we are in at this late hour. However, just kind reminder again, let's not be spending time on clean tax. Enough time spent on that. So let's move on.

CBDChair

You're right. Thank you.

Iran (Islamic Republic of)

Thank you, Chair. I think that Russia is right. All this sentence has been reflected in and we don't need to repeat it. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. EU.

EU

Thank you, Chair. I'll be short and sweet, supporting the Chilean proposal and also reminding just as Iceland that it we are now touching clean text, which we really would not like to do, but Chile had a constructive proposal we support. Thank you.

CBDChair

Thank you. Let's see if we can go. We hear from Secretary Chile's proposal, if we got it right. Please read it.

CBDSecretariat representative

So, the paragraph would read as follows: The informal advisory group shall be composed of up to 20 experts nominated by parties with equal representation of the five regional groups. up to 10 experts nominated by intergovernmental bodies with competence in the conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity of marine areas beyond national jurisdiction, and up to seven experts nominated by other relevant organizations, following the guidance on expert groups contained in the consolidated modus operandi of SUBSTA with respect to the nomination and selection of experts as appropriate. The Secretariat has not clear whether that means the second sentence would be deleted or retained.

CBDChair

Deleted.

CBDSecretariat representative

Deleted, okay.

CBDChair

Is that correct, Chile? Yes. So can we go along with that to make reference and then to delete the second sentence? Saudi Arabia? No, I don't see any requests, so I think this is an agreement. Thank you very much on paragraph 3. So paragraph 3 is clean. and we keep five with brackets. And I thank you very much to all, so interpretation is over, and thank you very much for extending more minutes, and see you tomorrow morning, I believe, to continue working on remaining paragraphs and documents. So the meeting is adjourned.