3rd Meeting, 2nd Session of the Intergovernmental Working Group on Older Persons (IGWG) Meetings & Events Date: 27 October 2026 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/en/asset/k1u/k1uka8p5uo Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- Chair-Rapporteur [0:02]: Good afternoon, Excellencies, distinguished participants. I hereby declare open the third meeting of the second session of the Intergovernmental Working Group on the Human Rights of Older Persons. This afternoon, we will start with plenary discussions under agenda item 4. Distinguished delegates, as we start our exchange on the preamble, to the future legally binding instrument, I would like to invite you to consider the context within which our task falls. Societies are getting older, and there is a deeper transformation. This opens up opportunities, but it also brings challenges at the social level, health, security, and well-being. And this is The fact that people are living longer is an achievement, but we must ensure dignity, rights and opportunities throughout those years. Social security systems are challenged, families and communities likewise, and we must wonder how to ensure that ageing does not end in a lack of protection, exclusion, isolation. This is no mere declaration, the preamble. It explains why we're here, why we need collective action, why states are ready to take on commitments. Our goal is to reflect the reality of aging and the challenges of older persons on the basis of international obligations that already exist, recognizing that new realities can require more specific, more effective responses. I invite you to work looking broadly at the issue and constructively thinking about what brings us together to lay solid foundations for the future instrument. Our objective during this session is not only to exchange views on the substantive elements of the draft instrument, but also to deepen our collective understanding of the issues at stake. To support these efforts, a set of guiding questions has been circulated in advance of the session for each of the segments. These questions are intended to help guide our discussions, encourage focused and interactive exchanges, and ensure that deliberations across the different work streams are both substantive and forward-looking. I encourage all participants to make full use of these questions in a spirit of openness and constructive engagement. We also have the privilege at this session to benefit from the presence of the Independent Expert on the enjoyment of human rights by older persons, Mr. Zdeňan Birtosek, who will provide us with his reflections for our discussions on the preamble, as well as the core of a future instrument, namely the catalogue of rights. And in addition, we are fortunate to have with us the previous mandate holders, Mrs. Claudia Mahler and Mrs. Cornfeldt-Mate, who will kick off our discussions on state obligations and on definitions. Mrs. Kornfeld-Mate will deliver a pre-recorded video statement, and for the segment on monitoring, implementation, and international cooperation, we will be joined by Mr. *** Korkes-Akivi, Chief of the Human Rights Treaties Branch of the Office of Human Rights Council, of the Human Rights Office. At the end of the session, the co-facilitators will share their preliminary remarks. to inform our collective considerations of the next steps in this process. I look forward to working closely with all delegations, stakeholders, and co-facilitators to ensure a productive and constructive session. As we begin the sustainment of our discussions entitled "Elements of the APP Preamble," it is my pleasure to give the floor to the Independent Expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons, Mr. is vested on Peter Tosek for some kick-off remarks. Mr. Peter Tosek, you have the floor. UN · Independent Expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons [4:55]: Chair Rapporteur, Excellencies, distinguished delegates, and dear colleagues, thank you for inviting me to contribute as a resource person at this important stage of the Working Group's discussion. This afternoon, we discuss the elaboration of the preamble of a future legally binding instrument. In such discussions, we naturally turn to international law, examining the preambles of the existing core human rights instruments and the principles that should guide the provisions that follow. Under international treaty law, the preamble forms part of the context for interpreting a treaty in good faith, in light of its object and purpose. In this regard, we do not begin from an empty page. Fourteen years of work by the Open-ended Working Group on Ageing established that older persons are entitled to the full and equal enjoyment of all human rights throughout life, while documenting persisting gaps in protection and realization of older persons' human rights. Its work and conclusions should therefore be reflected in the Convention preamble. Beyond that institutional and normative framework, the preamble serves the human rights compass of the instrument. It explains why the instrument is needed, what values it rests upon, and what understanding of the human person should guide its interpretation. Today, I would like to approach this human rights compass from a perspective that centers the human beings whose rights are at stake. As the Chair acknowledged in his opening remarks this morning, It is vital that we keep in our hearts the older persons sitting among us, and those online who are listening to our deliberations today, as well as those who are far away, whose voices are absent from our discussions. Someone who has experienced discrimination, someone who has spent a lifetime caring for others, Someone who now needs care or dignified comfort in their final stages of life, or someone who simply wishes to continue living with dignity and a sense of belonging. What would this person hope to find in the opening words of the instrument? To answer that question, I hope that more older persons will be directly involved in these discussions in the future. Of course, older persons do not speak with one voice. Their experiences and aspirations are extraordinarily diverse, and I would not presume to speak for them. Yet, as independent expert, as a neurologist, and indeed as an older person myself, I recognize some aspirations that may accompany aging and could offer some human dimensions to our discussion today. In that spirit, I would like to reflect on six aspirations that older persons among us and all persons, as we grow older, might share. Aspirations that can help us identify the principles that should find expression in the Preamble. First might be a simple and deeply human wish. I wish to be recognized as a person of equal dignity and equal rights throughout my life. This aspiration takes us to the foundation of international human rights law, the inherent dignity of every person and the universality of human rights throughout the life course. The preamble should therefore reaffirm the Charter of the United Nations, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenants and other relevant instruments, together with the universality, indivisibility and interdependence of human rights. It should also affirm continuity of our human rights throughout our life. Our health, Abilities, relationships, and need for support may change with age. Our standing as right holders does not. Human dignity has no retirement age. This understanding should provide a normative foundation for interpreting the entire Convention. Yet, if human rights already belong equally to everyone, why is a new legally binding instrument needed? Why is it necessary? On that question, older persons among us might observe: I wish for a preamble that recognizes the injustices I may face in older age, including those that society has learned not to see. Behind this wish lies the principle of equality and non-discrimination. It also reminds us that discrimination may become embedded in ordinary social practices. The work of the Open-ended Working Group on Ageing, international human rights mechanisms and older persons themselves has demonstrated persistent gaps in protection and implementation. The preamble should acknowledge these gaps and explicitly recognize ageism and age discrimination, including their structural and systemic forms. Sometimes discrimination is visible. Sometimes it is concealed within seemingly benevolent practices when an older person's wishes are disregarded in the name of protection or care. Recognizing these realities would reaffirm the vital need for the instrument to strengthen and make effective the enjoyments of rights already guaranteed by international human rights law. Yet, whose experiences are we describing when we speak of older persons? On that question, an older person might add: I wish for the preamble that recognizes that there are as many ways of growing old as there are human lives. This aspiration speaks to substantive equality, the recognition that equal enjoyment of human rights requires attention to different life circumstances. And as several speakers underscored this morning, there is no single story of aging. Older persons differ profoundly in their health, identities, relationships, and opportunities. Disadvantages associated with gender, disability, poverty, migration, or other circumstances may intersect and accumulate throughout our lives. I would therefore encourage the Working Group to recognize diversity, multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination, and the importance of a life course perspective in the preamble. While recognizing that some older persons experience situations requiring particular protection, care, and support, Such circumstances do not diminish a person's dignity or equal rights, nor do they define older age as a whole. Recognizing these distinctions would help to ensure that the instrument responds to real human needs without reinforcing stereotypes. A related concern arises when someone needs help with communication, everyday activities, or decisions. How can we ensure that assistance never becomes a reason for disregarding their wishes? On this question, the older persons among us might remind ourselves: I wish for my voice to be heard, even when I need the support of the others. Such a desire is at the heart of human rights principles. respect for legal capacity, personal autonomy, and the person's will and preferences. Over many years, I have met people living with dementia, Parkinson's disease, and other conditions affecting memory, communication, and decision making. I have seen how easily their voices become less audible. and how readily others begin deciding on their behalf. Yet the need for support does not in itself silent the person who receives it. Autonomy can be exercised with support. The preamble should therefore affirm respect for legal capacity, will and preferences, personal autonomy and supported decision-making, together with protection against abuse, neglect and coercion. Support should enable autonomy. This understanding of personhood deserves a central place in the preamble. Respect for autonomy brings us naturally to the human relationships in which our lives unfold. And so, the older person in our discussion might ask us: If I can no longer work, live independently, or communicate as before, will I still belong and be valued equally? I wish to remain part of the human family, valued for who I am and the ways that I can still contribute. Belonging and dignity do not depend on productivity, independence, or perceived usefulness. The preamble should recognize the person's right to full, effective, and meaningful participation, including in developing, implementing, and monitoring the implementation of the instrument. Participation requires accessible information, genuine influence over decisions, and the inclusion of older persons in all their diversity. Families, friends, and communities can provide vital care, connection, and support for older persons. Their role should be recognized, yet without romanticizing every family setting or shifting public duties into private relationships. Some older persons do not have family support. Others experience neglect, coercion, violence and exploitation within family settings. A balanced preambular reference could recognize the important role that families, communities and society may play in supporting older persons, while reaffirming respect for autonomy, dignity, will and preferences, and the ultimate responsibility of States to respect, protect and fulfill rights. Finally, there is one question that I hope we can all ask ourselves as individuals who are older persons now or will be in the future. Will these words still protect those who grow old in a world different from ours? The instrument must endure beyond the circumstances of its drafting. Digital technologies, Artificial intelligence, climate change, migration, conflict, humanitarian emergencies, and changing patterns of care and family life will continue to reshape aging. The preamble should acknowledge such realities without becoming a catalog of present concerns. Its language should remain open to change while anchored in enduring human rights principles. Chair, Distinguished delegates, these questions and aspirations are not proposed treaty provisions. They simply offer a human perspective on the principles that should guide the preamble. The operative articles will define substantive rights and obligations. The preamble should state concisely and coherently the instrument's purpose, the barriers it seeks to overcome, and the vision of human dignity that will guide the interpretation of the instrument over decades to come. Returning to the older person sitting among us, and the older persons who all of us will hopefully become, allow me to ask: When my circumstances change, when I need support, when my voice is harder to hear, will this instrument still see me, hear me, and recognize my equal rights? If the Preamble allows us to answer these questions with certainty, it will have fulfilled its purpose. Whatever changes with age, Our equal dignity, autonomy and enjoyment of all human rights must never be called into question. Thank you very much, Chair Rapporteur. Chair-Rapporteur [20:10]: Thank you, Mr. Birtosek for your statement, it was inspirational and I think very profound. I open the floor for an interactive discussion. I give the floor to distinguished representative of Portugal. You have the floor. Portugal [20:36]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, and good afternoon. And let me start by thanking the independent expert for his introduction to this discussion. And agree with the fact that. We don't start from scratch, and probably for those that are in this discussion for some time, they will recognize some points of our intervention. Mr. Chair, Portugal would like that the instrument includes a preamble that clearly establishes its purpose, ensuring substantive equality and the full enjoyment of all human rights by older persons. It should make clear that the instrument should strengthen existing protection, address gaps, and remove the structural barriers that prevent older persons from exercising their rights on an equal basis with others. The preamble should anchor this ambition on the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and international human rights law, including both covenants, CEDAW, and the CRPD. It should reaffirm the universality, indivisibility, interdependence and interrelatedness of all human rights, ensuring that the instrument encompasses civil, cultural, economic, political and social rights. At its core, the preamble should recognize older persons as individual right holders and states as duty bearers. It should reflect a shift from approaches centered on charity, dependency, or medical needs towards dignity, autonomy, independence, and participation. Older persons must be recognized as active contributors to society whose rights do not depend on their economic contribution or support needs. The preamble should also acknowledge that older persons are not an homogenous group. A life course approach would help recognize how inequalities accumulate over time and shape different experiences of aging. Particular attention should be given to gender equality and multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination. We should also welcome an explicit recognition of ageism. including age-based stereotypes and prejudice, as a structural barrier reflected in laws, policies, institutions, and social attitudes, including in digital environments. Accessibility, reasonable accommodation, and access to information are essential to overcoming these barriers. Finally, the preamble should affirm older persons' freedom to make decisions about their lives, including where and with whom they live and the care and support they receive. Their full, meaningful and effective participation must guide not only the elaboration but also the implementation of this instrument. I thank you, Mr. Chair. Chair-Rapporteur [23:27]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Portugal. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Ecuador. Ecuador [23:35]: Chairperson, my delegation welcomes the guiding questions. which facilitate the ordering of discussions under this agenda item. We would like to share some considerations on the elements that the Preamble could address. First, we should recall, as the independent expert has mentioned, that under treaty law, the Preamble is part of the context for the interpretation of the instrument, and it should therefore be concise. and consistent with the operative part and should be revised as the negotiations progress. Second, it should ensure clear anchorage within the existing framework, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and universal human rights treaties, in particular the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. We also consider it essential to recognize the contribution of regional instruments such as the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of the Human Rights of Older Persons, from a complementary approach. And third, the future treaty could include in the preamble a reference to the need to recognize older persons as rights holders, not just as beneficiaries. In turn, such recognition requires attention to their diversity and the multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination faced, amongst others, by older women, older persons with disabilities, persons belonging to indigenous peoples and Afro-descendants, both living in rural areas, and persons in situations of human mobility. And fourth, the preamble should reflect the conviction that a comprehensive international convention will make a significant contribution to addressing discrimination against older persons and promoting their participation on an equal footing in the civil, political, economic, social and cultural spheres. This Convention is universal, since ageing is accelerating in both developed and developing countries, in the latter with greater speed and fewer resources to deal with it. For this reason, and fifthly, my delegation considers it crucial that the preamble expressly recognize the importance of international cooperation in improving the living conditions of older persons in all countries, and particularly developing countries. Finally, Chairperson, the preamble should make it clear that this instrument is being built together with elder persons and their organizations, and their meaningful participation is an element that must be taken into account throughout the negotiating process. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [26:39]: I thank the distinguished representative of Ecuador. And I call on Colombia. Colombia [26:51]: Thank you, Chairperson and Rapporteur. We also want to welcome the guiding questions, which are going to be very useful in laying the foundations of these negotiations. We consider that the preamble should serve a dual function: to place the instrument within the framework of international human rights law and to explain why it is needed. To that end, we propose that it should have the following elements: first, recognition that ageing is a global demographic reality which poses significant challenges for states and also brings opportunities for more inclusive, supportive societies. Secondly, the reaffirmation of older persons are full holders of all human rights and fundamental freedoms and should enjoy them in conditions of equality, dignity, and autonomy. This affirmation should be accompanied by recognition of their contribution to the development of their families, communities, and societies. Third, an express reference to historic and contemporary practices of discrimination and exclusion that have affected older persons. The preamble should recognize that ageism is a widespread phenomenon that transcends cultures and borders, and it limits directly and indirectly the enjoyment of rights. And stereotypes, prejudices, and attitudes based on ageism are often at the root of other human rights violations. Fourth, In response to the second guiding question, the preamble should reflect that older persons are not a homogeneous group. It should recognize the particular challenges they face in context of poverty, emergency, disasters, armed conflict, and human mobility, reaffirming the commitment of states to comprehensive protection of older persons. Fifth, the preamble should anchor the instrument in the existing universal framework, the Charter of the United Nations, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the two international covenants, and the conventions on discrimination against women, racial discrimination, torture, migrant workers, and persons with disabilities. It should also recognize as references the United Nations Principles for Older Persons, the Madrid Political Declaration and International Plan of Action on Ageing, and the General Assembly resolution cited in resolution 58/13. Finally, although they are not part of the universal framework, the preamble could refer to the progress made in regional systems such as the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of the Human Rights of Elder Persons and the Protocol to the African Charter on the Rights of Elder Persons. Furthermore, it is important that in addition to the pillars proposed, beyond the preamble, there should be a part on its scope and the treaty as a whole. And this would refer to the international legal framework and clarify the scope of States' obligations. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [29:56]: Thank you. I call on Chile. Chile [30:00]: Thank you, Chairperson. Chile considers that the preamble to the future instrument should reflect the development of international recognition of the human rights of older persons and the principles that have guided us, that will guide interpretation and implementation. This is what we are seeking to do. In recent decades, the International Committee has has created a large number of international commitments, which are a fundamental basis for these negotiations. In particular, we should recognise the United Nations Principles for Older Persons of 1991, the Declaration of 1992, and the International Plan of Action of Madrid on Ageing of 2002. as well as the progress made regionally, especially through the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of the Human Rights of Older Persons. Likewise, Chile also believes it crucial that the preamble recognize the interdependence and indivisibility of human rights, recognizing older persons as full rights holders of rights and fundamental freedoms. This must be accompanied by a vision that upholds their dignity, autonomy, independence, and participation, and the contributions that they make and may continue to make to the common good. Getting old does not mean losing one's place in society or giving up on human rights. We also consider it crucial that the preamble incorporate a lifetime perspective and draws on the exclusions and the experience and the vision of older persons. This is particularly important in order to understand how ageism can be expressed in stereotypes and can harm the effective exercise of their rights. It is essential that the preamble establishes that the future instruments complements and strengthens the existing international framework in line with the existing obligations, without allowing any backsliding on the existing rights. Finally, it is essential to include, through the preamble, an article on the goal and the scope. This is essential to give legal security defining the treaty, establishing a comprehensive framework for the enjoyment of the rights and freedoms of elder persons and promoting active and healthy ageing. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [32:42]: Thank you. Representative of Austria. Austria [32:49]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Austria sees the preamble as an essential guide for the purpose, values, and direction of the future convention. In a sense, it should serve as a table of contents of the challenges we seek to address and the principles that should guide our response. Of course, it cannot be an exhaustive list. Additional rights and issues may emerge as negotiations progress. First, the preamble should reaffirm the universality, indivisibility and interdependence of human rights and underline the need to close existing gaps in the protection of older persons. It should recognize older persons as equal right holders entitled to dignity, autonomy and self-determination. This means, for example, that decisions affecting older persons should be made with them, not simply for them. Second, it should recognize ageism and age discrimination as structural barriers, while reflecting the diversity of older persons and the gender-responsive, intersectional, and life-course perspective. An older woman with a disability, for instance, may face overlapping barriers when accessing services or participating in society. We must recognize such realities without portraying older persons as a uniform or inherently vulnerable group. Third, the preamble should acknowledge emerging challenges. When public services become digital only, people without reliable digital access risk exclusion. Likewise, loneliness and social isolation can reveal structural barriers to meaningful participation in community life. Fourth, it should recognize older persons' positive contributions and agency. Many older persons actively support families, communities, and voluntary organizations. Their experiences and voices must help shape policies in the Convention itself. Intergenerational solidarity should strengthen, never replace, individual rights. Finally, the preamble should look ahead to environmental change, emergencies, and international cooperation. During extreme heat or disasters, for example, accessible warnings and inclusive emergency planning can make a decisive difference. The preamble cannot establish every substantive guarantee, but it can provide a clear, shared orientation for the entire convention, without excluding issues that may arise later in the negotiations. Austria looks forward to developing these elements together with other delegations. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [35:39]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Austria. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Jordan. You have the floor. Jordan [35:47]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. At this stage, our delegation would suggest five elements to guide the development of the preamble. First, it should establish a clear foundation in existing human rights law. The two international covenants provide a starting point for reaffirming older persons' entitlements through the full range of human rights. The preamble should then recognize the gaps in protection and implementation that requires particular attention in older age. It should also reflect the established understanding that national circumstances and cultural and religious backgrounds are considered consistently with the universality of those rights. Second, it should reflect the diversity of older persons' circumstances. Longer lives call for public systems that respond to changing needs. Disadvantages can also accumulate throughout life, including for older women and older persons with disabilities. The preamble should acknowledge these differences while recognizing older persons' experience and contributions to the society. Their entitlement to dignity and protection remains unconditional. Third, it should connect recognition of the family with the support for care and the responsibility of the state. This approach is relevant to Jordan's constitutional protection of the family and old age. For an older person who wishes to remain at home, family assistance may need to be complemented by professional care. Recognizing the family role should therefore be accompanied by recognition of the support needed to sustain it. The preamble should also reaffirm respect for older persons' choices and equal protection for those living alone or without adequate family support. Fourth, it should acknowledge circumstances that place the enjoyment of the rights at particular risk. These include poverty and barriers to health services and social protection, as well as violence, neglect, and financial exploitation. Particular attention should also be given to armed conflict, foreign occupation, and displacement. Considering these elements for older persons, we would emphasize protection under applicable international law and continuity of essential care and assistance. Finally, the preamble should recognize the importance of effective national implementation supported by international cooperation. This should include cooperation that strengthens national capacities with attention to developing countries. Together, these elements would provide a coherent foundation for the drafting ahead. grounded in established rights, attentive to national circumstances, and responsive to the realities of older age. I thank you, Mr. Chair. Chair-Rapporteur [38:40]: Thank you, distinguished representative of China. I give you the floor, distinguished representative of the Philippines. You have the floor. Philippines [38:47]: Thank you, Chair. The preamble should clearly articulate the context and purpose of the instrument and guide the interpretation of its substantive provisions. In this regard, the Philippines wishes to highlight the following key elements which we believe should be reflected. First, the preamble should reaffirm the universality and indivisibility of human rights, citing existing international instruments, including the two international covenants, the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and the Migrant Workers Convention, among others. It must be framed using a human rights lens rather than a welfare or developmental lens. Second, Older persons must be recognized as right holders with autonomy, agency, and legal capacity, and as valuable contributors to society. Their diversity and cumulative and intersecting sources of vulnerability and discrimination must be acknowledged. To reinforce this framework, intergenerational solidarity, social inclusion, participation, and accountability must inform the instrument. Third, the preamble must clearly identify the normative gap to be addressed. notably the lack of an explicit prohibition against age-based discrimination, ageism, neglect, abuse, and violence against older persons. Fourth, it should recognize the importance of accessible, quality, and dignified long-term health care, including palliative care. Equally important is acknowledging the indispensable role of care workers, particularly migrant caregivers, whose rights and well-being are integral to sustainable care systems. Fifth, while recognizing the family and community as important sources of support, the Preamble must affirm, in no uncertain terms, that States bear the primary responsibility for respecting, protecting, and fulfilling human rights. Finally, the preamble must be forward-looking and address emerging risks that could impinge on the enjoyment of human rights by older persons. A strong preamble should unite us around an empowering vision of ageing, one of dignity, equality, independence and inclusion, providing a clear and compelling context for the substantive provisions to follow. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [41:03]: Thank you, distinguished representative of the Philippines. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the State of Palestine. State of Palestine [41:13]: Thank you, Mr. Chair Rapporteur. Allow me first to thank you, Excellency, and your team for your efforts, and the independent expert for his presentation and contribution to the discussions of the preamble. We believe that the preamble should reaffirm the universality, indivisibility, interdependence, and interrelatedness of all human rights, while recognizing the inherent dignity, autonomy, equality, and full and meaningful participation of older persons. It should also recognize the diversity of older persons and the difficult circumstances that may affect their ability to fully enjoy their human rights. As my delegation have emphasized during the first session of this working group in July, the specific challenges faced by older persons in situations of armed conflict and foreign occupation must be adequately reflected in the future instrument. Allow me to draw some examples from the occupied Palestinian territory, including East Jerusalem, which demonstrates the importance of such recognition. In the Gaza Strip, older persons have faced repeated forced displacement, destruction of their homes, deprivation of essential services, and severe restrictions on access to food, medicines, and health care. The loss of family members, caregivers, and support networks have further compounded these challenges, particularly for those with limited mobility or requiring continuous care. In the West Bank, including East Jerusalem, older persons also face restrictions on freedom of movement, settler terrorism, displacement, and obstacles to accessing health care and other essential services. These realities underscore the need to recognize that armed conflict, foreign occupation, displacement, and humanitarian emergencies can create additional and intersecting barriers to the full enjoyment of human rights by older persons. We therefore propose that the preamble expressly acknowledges the particular challenges faced by older persons in these situations, while reaffirming the obligations of States under international human rights law and international humanitarian law as applicable. Such recognition would reinforce the universal character of the future instrument, while ensuring that it responds to the diverse circumstances in which older persons exercise their rights. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [43:32]: Thank you, distinguished representative of the State of Palestine. And I want to reflect upon something here. I'm also chairing an open-ended group on disarmament. And you can imagine there's a lot of sensitive issues regarding disarmament. But I always encourage everybody to put aside all political problems, conflicts, because there are so many conflicts now, so many conflicts in the world. And every day, there's more and more and more conflicts. I don't want to create this as a forum of protesting or complaining for conflict that they exist. But I mean, this is not the forum to talk about this. We have to concentrate strictly in our task. We have a lot of things to do here. And it's a very profound work that we have to actually face, so that I encourage, please, everybody to put aside all the problems that we have, there are many, aside, and then focus in our work. Having said so, the next in my list is distinguished representative of Brazil. You have the floor. Brazil [44:54]: Mr. Chair. In Brazil, view the preamble should clarify affirm that older persons are right holders and achieve participation in society on an equal base with people of other age groups. It needs to recognize population age as a global phenomenon. We affirm the principle of human dignity, equality, and no discrimination. They highlight the social, economic, cultural, political contributions of older persons. It is equally important to include a reference to structural inequalities to shape the experience of aging, includes those related to gender, race, disability, geographic location, and socioeconomic status. This test should also recognize different experience of aging and the barriers faced, for example, by women, black people, indigenous people, quilombola communities, Persons with disability, LGBT population, people living in poverty or experiencing homeless, and those deprived for their liberty, live in institution or social isolate. Explicit reference to these realities helps prevent old age from being treated as single, homogeneous experience. The preamble should therefore combine recognition of the dignity, autonomy, and contribution of the older persons with the need to address structural inequalities. It should also situate the future convention within the progress already achieved through regional instruments, particularly the Inter-American Convention on Protecting the Human Rights of the Older Person, while reaffirming the responsibility of states to ensure rights for all people in all their diversity. It's also important to mainstream aging across public policies, enable the states to act, integrate in a coordinated manner, and recognizing that aging is a process that cuts across every dimension of life. This approach helps promote the sectoral, inclusive, and equitable policies capable of responding to the diversity needs and experience of aging. By recognizing this difference, the test should also value meaningful participation of other person in the design of the future legally by the instrument, without assuming that they all have the same circumstance or needs. International protection should be a substantive equality and the pursuit of response switch to different contexts, thereby guaranteeing the right to age for all. Particular attention should be also be given to border regions where the search for facilities and services may place an additional burden on countries that offer better conditions than their neighboring countries. Thank you, Chair. Chair-Rapporteur [47:50]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Brazil. I call on Cuba. Cuba [47:59]: Thank you, Chairperson. At the outset, I would like to welcome the statement by the independent expert, Professor Pitosek. We have taken careful note of his ideas and his recommendations, which we will be analysing in due course. Cuba is in favour of a preamble that adequately reflects the spirit of the international instruments guide interpretation of the articles that come later, it must include five key elements. First, recognition that the rights in the international instrument are universal, indivisible, interdependent, and interrelated, like all human rights. Second, recognition that older persons are full rights holders on an equal footing with others. Third, Recognition of the need for international cooperation, technical assistance and solidarity to support national efforts to fulfil the obligations under the future instrument. 4. Recognition of the contribution of older persons to society, their social, cultural, economic, family and community contributions, and the intergenerational transmission of knowledge and values. 5. an explicit reference to the negative and disproportionate impact of unilateral coercive measures on enjoyment of the human rights of older persons. This is a documented reality, not an abstract question. An instrument that seeks effectively to protect older persons cannot ignore external obstacles that limit their rights as to the goal and the scope of the future instrument. Cuba believes that it must, beyond the preamble, have chapters that refer to the beginning of the operational part of the future instrument, as other delegations have already mentioned, and the goal, in our opinion, should be to promote and protect the human rights of older persons on an equal footing without discrimination. Furthermore, the first article should include a definition of an elder person who is the object of protection under the instrument. This should be flexible and contextual and allow the future instruments to be clear in normative terms. In conclusion, I reiterate our readiness for a constructive dialogue on the drafting of these provisions and a readiness to hear other proposals from other states and organizations. presence here to construct the paragraphs of the preamble. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [50:49]: I thank Cuba. And I call on Mexico. Mexico [50:58]: Thank you, Chairperson. We thank the independent expert for his contributions, and we also welcome the proposals. The preamble should contain the following: first, recognition that older persons are not a homogeneous group. Their experience of ageing depends on social, economic, cultural, and territorial factors, as well as accumulated inequalities. Old age should not be associated with dependency, illness, or vulnerability. Second, dignity and the full holding of rights on equal footing, as well as the active role of older persons in family, community, economic, cultural, and political life. And this should not be seen from a paternalistic or assistentialist narrative. Third, ageism, discrimination, and stereotypes, and barriers, including institutional practices that assume incapacity, dependency, or a lack of productivity. Fourth, the gender perspective and intersectionality, addressing the accumulated inequalities of older women in terms of income, pensions, employment, and care, and the barriers faced by older indigenous, Afro-descendant persons, persons with disabilities, migrants, sexually and gender diverse persons living in rural areas, or living in poverty. Fifth, Autonomy, independence and participation, including decisions regarding life projects and living arrangements without any unjustified substitution of the older person's wishes. Sixth, comprehensive care and support system for the gender perspective and the human rights perspective. And seven, the challenges of digitalization and the technological gap in a context of demographic transformation. Thank you very much. Chair-Rapporteur [52:57]: I think Mexico. Iraq [52:59]: Thank you, Chair. The Republic of Iraq stresses the importance that that the preamble represents a balanced legal basis reflecting the general principles, as this is the cornerstone of the text. It is important to draw on existing legal texts, including the UN Charter, the Universal Declaration, the two covenants, and all relevant international texts and treaties. This confirms the universality, the indivisibility of rights and guarantees, the consistency of the text with the new draft. The preamble needs to reflect basic principles: dignity, equality, non-discrimination, independence, and the rights of older persons to enjoy fully their rights and fundamental freedoms as rights holders and not as beneficiaries. It's important also that this preamble recognizes the status and importance of older persons who contribute to society and humanity, and we must reaffirm the importance of their role in public life and respect their choices and preferences to help bolster their independence and dignity. The Republic of Iraq emphasizes the role of the family and community alongside the state. They work hand in hand in terms of health care and rights, and we must look at cultural context and legal constitutional systems, as well as ethic and moral values, in order to strike a balance between universal principles and integrating the draft into local context. We want to strike a balance and have a universal balanced text. We insist on the importance of the points made by Palestine and Jordan, they refer to the situation of older persons in a situation of occupational conflict. It's important that humanitarian principles and strengthening of the rights of older persons be respected and established, whilst still allowing interpretive clauses when it comes to implementation and for the parties concerned. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [55:57]: I recognize Uruguay. Uruguay [56:03]: Thank you, Chair Rapporteur. We understand that the preamble of the future convention needs to clearly establish the purpose and principles of the instrument and provide a framework for interpretation of its provisions, as well as reaffirming its connection with international human rights standards, both universally and regionally. It is thus crucial to reaffirm the universality, indivisibility, interdependence and interrelationship of all human rights, recognising that older persons are fully fledged rights holders on an equal footing, without any form of discrimination. preamble must also highlight the need to have specific international protection, given the structural barriers and inequalities that exist in older age, including ageism that can be manifested in stereotypes and discriminatory treatment, as well as multiple forms of discrimination that can aggravate a situation of inequality. One of the core aspects is recognising dignity, autonomy and independence of older persons, including their freedom to make decisions and define their own life path. We should not focus merely on assistance or imagine that ageing equals incapacity. We also need to take into account the diversity of experiences of ageing, because Older persons are not a homogenous group, and their realities are determined by different life conditions. It’s part of a life cycle. It’s important to recognise their experiences and provide responses that are adapted to the different needs and circumstances of older persons. The preamble must also recognise the full, effective and significant participation of older persons, both directly and through their organisations, in the decisions that affect their rights and their lives. This involves recognising them as protagonists in the participation and implementation of public policies, and not only as the beneficiaries of measures of protection. Intergenerational solidarity and ties are important to promote inclusive societies that are based on respect and mutual support across generations. We need to recognise that we must not just convey to families the responsibility. We must also look at a fundamental question. The future convention must look at specific provisions on the subject and the field of application, drawing on the background of other conventions, such as the Inter-American Convention. A provision on the purpose will allow us to establish the goal of the convention, which is to promote and guarantee the full implementation of the human rights of older persons on an equal footing, without discrimination of any kind and without this undermining their dignity and autonomy. We should avoid restrictions and ensure that it is in step with the Chair interrupts. Chair-Rapporteur [59:20]: You have the floor. Qatar [59:31]: First, my delegation agrees with your opening remarks. The points raised today are pertinent to shape our discussion. In the preamble, we must reaffirm the importance of the two international covenants and stress the universality, indivisibility of human rights, in step with the principles of 1991 and the Madrid Plan, as well as the reference to the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in the Charter. I must reaffirm that older persons are rights holders. They are fully fledged rights holders like others, and applicable law We must make sure that we do not invent concepts that are not met with consensus. Ageing is a phenomenon that all societies are familiar with, and we need to draw on the wisdom of older persons. We need solidarity across generations. For the second issue, we must insist on the fact that there's not one single group of older persons. There are many diverse elements that can determine the needs and rights of older persons. Legal systems and diverse cultures, as well as ethics and religious traditions, must also be taken into account. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:01:18]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Qatar. Now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Pakistan. You have the floor. Pakistan [1:01:28]: Thank you very much, Mr. Chair Rapporteur, and good afternoon, colleagues. On the preamble, Pakistan would like to highlight six key elements. One, the preamble forms part of the context for interpreting the treaty. It must therefore rest on solid ground, the UN Charter, the UDHR, and other core human rights instruments, reaffirming the universality, indivisibility, and interdependence of all human rights. Pakistan can support only principles and commitments that reflect genuine and sustained consensus among states. Texts adopted by vote or accompanied by significant reservations cannot be passed off as common ground. Two, the preamble should affirm that the family is the natural and fundamental group unit of society, entitled to protection by society and the state. It should acknowledge that the contribution of older persons to families and communities, and the importance of intergenerational solidarity. As we said yesterday, in many societies, the care of older persons is not a burden; it is a privilege and an honour. A treaty that fails to reflect this will not reflect the lived reality of much of humanity. Three, the preamble should recognize the inherent and equal dignity of of older persons and that age discrimination violates that dignity. Older persons must be protected from discrimination on any ground, and the preamble can list those grounds, drawing on the core instruments, but concepts never defined intergovernmentally, such as multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination, have no place in a binding text. The recognized grounds, individually or collectively, are sufficient. To suggest otherwise is to weaken the very instruments on which any new treaty must build. For we agree that older persons are not a homogenous group. The circumstances differ across national, cultural, and economic contexts. Nowhere is this clearer than in situations of foreign occupation and humanitarian emergencies, where older persons are among the most exposed and least able to flee to seek protection or to access care. These situations, together with conflict and natural disasters, must be clearly and explicitly emphasized in the preamble. Similarly, where it refers to other particular situations, such as older persons with disabilities, it should rely on language already agreed in existing instruments. Diversity cannot be a vehicle for importing concepts that this Council has never agreed. Five, the preamble should recognize that many developing countries face serious resources and capacity constraints. Yet despite these constraints, they continue to care for their older people through families and other social institutions. It is an achievement, in our view, that deserves clear acknowledgement. Finally, the preamble should recall the right to development and recognize that meaningful international cooperation, including technology transfer and capacity building where appropriate, is essential to realizing the rights of older people. Obligation without means, Mr. Chair Rapporteur, are only aspirations. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:04:35]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Pakistan. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Greece. You have the floor. Greece [1:04:41]: Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and we're very glad that we're entering the stage of discussing possible concrete elements of the legal binding instrument. The preamble is indeed a very important part of an international treaty. It may not have a normative value per se, but according to the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties and international case law, it forms part of the context of the treaty and guides the interpretation of the operative provisions. It contributes to filling gaps and links the treaty to other instruments, avoiding thus fragmentation of international human rights law, which is a very important consideration. Of course, there is not a single model of preamble paragraphs. There are, however, some common features. In this respect, we are of the opinion that the CRPD could serve as an important source of inspiration for the preamble, as well as for the other parts of the treaty. Attending now to the elements that should appear in the preamble parts, we believe, first of all, that the preamble should establish from the outset that the instrument operates on the footing of complementarity and non-aggression so that nothing in it may be invoked to lower standards already secured under national law or other international instruments. It should also affirm a robust human rights based approach. And we could subscribe to almost all of what has been said so eloquently by the independent expert in this respect. Three more cross-cutting aspects deserve particular emphasis. First, ageism should be condemned as a structural phenomenon. Second, the life course perspective should be included, capturing continuity of human rights protections, but also the cumulative disadvantage that individuals may carry into older age. Third, it should be recognized that older persons are not a homogeneous group and the diversity of their circumstances should be given a prominent position. And finally, of course, we will revert to the concrete text or the paragraph in the later stage of our negotiations. Thank you very much. Chair-Rapporteur [1:06:57]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Greece. Now we go to the distinguished representative of Ghana. You have the floor. Ghana [1:07:06]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. On the preamble, Ghana supports recognition of longevity as an achievement of humanity, alongside recognition of the responsibility of states to adapt institutions, policies, and systems to longer lives. The preamble should reaffirm the principles of one human dignity, equality, and non-discrimination, universality, and indivisibility of human rights, autonomy and independence, participation and inclusion, gender equality, accessibility, intergenerational solidarity, and leaving no one behind. Furthermore, it should also recognize the positive contributions of older persons to families, communities, economies, and national development. Such recognition is essential to addressing ageism and stereotypes that portray older persons primarily as dependent, vulnerable, or a burden to society. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:08:14]: Thank you. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Slovenia. Slovenia [1:08:25]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. At the outset, let me thank independent expert Pirtaschek for his wise words of wisdom. Slovenia welcomes today's discussion that will feed directly into the next stages of the LBI drafting process. Allow me to outline Slovenia's position on some preamble elements, which we consider of crucial importance. A more detailed contribution will be submitted in line with the established timeline. Mr. Chair, Slovenia fully supports the preamble that, as in other UN human rights conventions, first and foremost, sets the stage. It explains the context and motivations, outlines the object and scope, and acts as an interpretive key and moral foundation for the entire document. The starting point should be the reaffirmation of universality, indivisibility, interdependence, and interrelatedness of all human rights and fundamental freedoms. Enjoyment of all human rights in older age must be assured without discrimination of any kind and free from any other violation of the rights and dignity of older persons. The preamble should acknowledge the great diversity of older persons and their individual circumstances, which may give rise to multiple, intersectional and cumulative forms of discrimination. Particular attention should be given to older women and their distinctive challenges. We regard aging as a universal and evolving human experience. However, increased longevity and related demographic changes are profoundly reshaping the societal and cultural norms. The preamble should also remain receptive to evolving aging contexts and probable future emerging gaps in the promotion and protection of human rights of older persons. Chair, Older persons represent fundamental pillars in our society. They are the pioneers who have made countless contributions to our societies, communities, and families. It is our responsibility to ensure their full, meaningful, and equal participation in all decisions affecting them. Slovenia considers that the responsibility to respect, protect, and fulfill the human rights of older persons lies primarily with states. At the same time, we recognize the important role of families and communities in supporting older persons, including in situations of dependency. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:11:05]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Slovenia. And I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Germany. You have the floor. Germany [1:11:16]: Thank you for giving Germany the floor. Germany is pleased to continue working under your guidance. I would also like to take this opportunity to thank everyone who attended today's German side event on meaningful participation during the lunch break. We were delighted by the positive response and the constructive discussions. I would also like to express our appreciation to the Independent Expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons, for his comprehensive and empathetic statement. We share many of the views expressed by Member States, notably regarding the following points of a future preamble. The preamble should, first, set the frame that older persons are adult persons and that all human rights are applicable to them, bearing in mind that the group of older persons is very diverse and heterogeneous depending on the circumstances of their life course and present situation. Second, refer to population ageing as one of the great transitions of the 21st century on an equal level with climate change and the digital transition, bearing in mind the principle of intergenerational fairness that is laid down in the UN Pact for the Future. Third, reaffirm importance of UDHR as a guiding framework. Fourth, reaffirm ensuring the full enjoyment of all human rights over the entire life course. Fifth, reaffirming all the existing treaties applicable to older persons. Six, state clearly all the treaties this new instrument draws upon, such as the applicable human rights treaties, e.g. ICESCR, ICCPR, CEDAW, CRPD, CAT, etc., and the relevant ILO standards. Seventh, recall regional standards of importance for the human rights of older persons, such as Article 23 of the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of the Human Rights of Older Persons and the Protocol to the African Charter on Human and People's Rights on the Rights of Older Persons in Africa. Recall the commitments in MIPA and its implementation as important source for the new instrument, and connect MIPA and the new LBI as complementary in ensuring the full enjoyment of all human rights of older persons. Finally, recall the UN principles of older persons. Thank you very much. Chair-Rapporteur [1:13:47]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Germany. I recognize the distinguished representative of Guatemala. Guatemala [1:13:56]: Chair, Guatemala believes that the preamble of the document should express the dignity and equality of the future instrument, the UN Charter, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and international covenants on civil and political rights and economic, social, and cultural rights. offer a foundation that we should focus on, looking at the indivisibility of human rights. We should emphasize that dignity of rights must be maintained throughout the life cycle. Regionally, the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of Human Rights of Older Persons provides its own experience on autonomy, informed consent, long-term care, and access to justice. Instruments on aging provide substantial guidance for building the new text. The International Plan of Vienna on Ageing from 1982 and the Political Declaration and International Plan of Action from Madrid on Ageing from 2002 contain elements that connect public policy with life, health, and participation in development. we cannot discard the recognition of care as a human right. This is included in the advisory opinion 31 of 2025 from the Inter-American Court of Human Rights. Similarly, the UN Principles on Older Persons adopted in resolution 4691 of 1991 provide elements on their independence, participation, care, and self-development, as well as dignity. It would therefore be advisable to distinguish the guidelines from these treaties for States Parties. Accumulated experience can help contribute to shaping clear definitions. We therefore believe that we should examine these developments to help bolster universal protection and preserve the levels of protection we have already achieved. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:16:41]: My thanks to the representative of Guatemala. Türkiye [1:16:52]: Thank you, Chair. The preamble of the future legally binding instrument offers an important opportunity to establish a clear and coherent foundation firmly anchored in the existing international human rights framework. It should therefore reaffirm the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, CRPD, and relevant international human rights treaties, while emphasizing the universality, indivisibility, and interdependence of all human rights. Central to this foundation is the recognition of the inherent dignity of older persons and their entitlement to the full and equal enjoyment of human rights and fundamental freedoms. From Turkey's perspective, it is equally important to address demographic aging in a balanced and forward-looking manner. While acknowledging the challenges associated with population aging, the preamble should also recognize increased longevity as an achievement of human development and highlight the valuable contributions of older persons to families, communities, and societies. Another essential consideration is the diversity of older persons and the different circumstances in which they experience aging, including the particular challenges faced by older women and older persons with disabilities. This also calls for appropriate recognition of equality, non-discrimination, and meaningful participation. Türkiye places particular emphasis on the supportive role of families and communities, as well as the value of intergenerational solidarity, without diminishing the primary responsibility of states to respect, protect, and fulfill human rights. The preamble will also benefit from acknowledging relevant international policy frameworks, including the Madrid International Plan of Action on Ageing, while maintaining a clear distinction between policy commitments and legally binding human rights obligations. A balanced and inclusive preamble, consistent with existing international human rights law, would provide a solid foundation for the interpretation and implementation of the future instrument. I thank you, Chair. Chair-Rapporteur [1:19:09]: Thank you. Now I give the floor to the distinguished representative of India. You have the floor. India [1:19:16]: Thank you, Chair. I would like to first share that we have shared our draft along with the explanatory note with the Secretariat and all the permanent missions here in Geneva. And now I would like to read out the preamble that also incorporates a lot of elements that the member states and the delegates have mentioned. The state parties to this convention, guided by the purposes and principles of the Charter of the United Nations and the reaffirming the universality, indivisibility, interdependence, interrelatedness of all human rights and fundamental freedoms, recognizing the inherent dignity and equal worth of all members of the human family, including older persons. Recognizing that older persons are right holders, active participants in society, and contributors to families, communities, and active public life. Recognizing that older persons are integral members of society whose inherent dignity Worth and human rights do not diminish with age, and they continue to contribute to families, communities, and economic, social, cultural, and civic life of society, and affirming that population aging should be approached as a matter of human rights, social development, intergenerational solidarity, rather than a burden on society. Concerned that older persons continue to face discrimination, neglect, abuse, exploitation, inadequate social protection, and barriers to the enjoyment of their human rights. Recognizing that the effective enjoyment of the human rights of older persons requires not only their legal recognition and protection, but also development and sustained provision of accessible health care, social protection, housing, transportation, care services, assistive technologies, and age-friendly infrastructure as integral components and sustainable development. Emphasizing that the protection and promotion of human rights of older persons requires not only their legal recognition and protection, but also the development and sustained provision of accessible health care, social protection, housing, transportation, care services, assistive technologies. Emphasizing that the protection of the persons must be pursued in a manner responsive to different national circumstances, demographic conditions, levels of development, institutional arrangements, and available resources. Reaffirming the responsibility of each State to take appropriate action measures for the realization of the rights recognized in this Convention, including through mobilization and effective use of maximum available resources. Recognizing the importance of international cooperation, equitable financing, and the sharing of resources of support States in implementing their obligations, particularly where the scale of need exceeds their domestic capacity. Recognizing the essential contribution of family members, informal caregivers, professional care workers, and community-based support systems, while affirming that such contributions shall not diminish the rights, autonomy, or dignity of older persons. Affirming the importance of ethical international mobility of care workers, fair recruitment, decent working conditions, and cooperation between countries of origin and destination. From a rights-based perspective, the preamble of the draft Indian Convention is a guide to bridge the relationship between universal human rights standards and the diverse developmental, demographic, socio-economic, and institutional circumstances in which states implement them. Population aging presents both a human rights imperative and a development challenge requiring accessible healthcare, income security, affordable. Housing, appropriate care services, digital inclusion, and age-friendly infrastructure. These needs must be addressed alongside competing development priorities, fiscal constraints, geographical disparities, and differences in national institutional capacities. The draft accordingly advances a development-oriented approach to the protection of older persons. It recognizes older persons as right-holders, active participants in society, and contributors to families, communities, and economies. Rather than treating them solely as recipients of care or welfare. We urge States to actively engage with the draft LBA prepared by India. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:23:21]: Thank you, distinguished representative of India. I give you the floor to the distinguished representative of Malta. You have the floor. Malta [1:23:31]: Thank you, Chair. The Preambular section of the instrument should be a catalyst in entrenching the whole instrument in established human rights law principles. We would propose that in your consideration of what elements are to be included, Elements would go beyond those listed in the food for thought paper issued in July. We also recall our own input to this process last May. We proposed that the preamble should include the following elements: recalling the principles enshrined in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, in particular the inherent dignity of all; it should reaffirm all principles of the Universal Declaration; The international covenants on human rights have established the principle of law that everyone, without exception, is entitled to all the rights and freedoms set forth therein without any distinction. The preamble should reaffirm the universality, indivisibility, interdependence, and interrelatedness of all human rights and fundamental freedoms. This point, we believe, is important because it is essential that older persons are identified as rights holders in full and without any form of discrimination whatsoever, and on any form of basis. It should emphasize the importance of mainstreaming issues related to older persons. It should reaffirm the Sustainable Development Goals, in particular goals 1, 3, 5, 8, 10, and 11. It should recognize that, despite the variety of measures in favor of older persons' rights at the national and international level, barriers continue to exist that lead to the exclusion of older persons as equal members of society. It should recognize that older persons are entitled to their individual autonomy and independence in every aspect of life, in particular older women and those with health concerns. Of course, the preamble should clearly outline that race, colour, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national, ethnic, indigenous or social origin, property, birth, age or other status should not serve as a basis for any form of discrimination. We would also prefer to add gender to that list. Finally, we would not favour including in the preamble the notion of duties. We have explained our position clearly at the July session, in our item 4 statement on the food for thought paper, and we reiterate that position today: older persons have rights as rights holders, not through an obligation by others to allow them the enjoyment of rights. Chair, co-facilitators, Malta stands ready to work with you and all other Member States and stakeholders. in elaborating a preamble that sets the right tone for the instrument. Obviously, these nine points are not exhaustive, but these set out the basic framework Malta would like to see included in this section. Finally, we encourage participants of this IGWG to provide space for discussion that takes into account all views expressed during the session. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:26:47]: I thank you, distinguished representative of Malta, and I get the floor, distinguished representative of Algeria. Algeria [1:26:59]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Algerian delegation welcomes this discussion on the architecture and elements of the preamble of this future international instrument. As we seek to strengthen the protection of older persons within international human rights law, our collective ambition must be to build an instrument that is protective, realistic, and balanced. First, it must reaffirm the universality and indivisibility of all human rights while enshrining the rejection of all forms of age-based discrimination. Second, it is essential to pay tribute to the invaluable contribution of older persons to social cohesion and the transmission of knowledge. In this regard, the text must uphold the fundamental role of international solidarity and the central place of family and the community in supporting our elders, values of solidarity that are deeply rooted in our societies, complementing public action. Third, it's most recognized the importance of protective environment that address age-related needs and vulnerabilities, prioritizing support closest to the individual, to the family, the community, and local actors. Finally, Mr. Chair, this preamble must call that such an instrument must adapt to the socio-economic realities as well as the institutional and financial capacity of states while respecting the national sovereignty. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:28:32]: Thank you. The English representative of France, you have the floor. France [1:28:42]: Thank you, Chairperson. We also thank the independent expert for his very rich contribution to this discussion. Frans believes that the preamble of the future legally binding international instrument must recognize aging as an evolutive and extending phenomenon. and must be aligned with the United Nations Charter, the Universal Declaration, and the various human rights conventions, while taking into account the specific features of age and aging. In a human rights-based approach and an approach based on fundamental freedoms, whose principles will be recorded in the preamble, it is crucial to ensure full, significant, equal participation of older persons in all decisions concerning them and all aspects of life and society, the preamble must recognize the autonomy of all elder persons, their capacity to act, and their freedom to make choices, including to be supported in the implementation of decisions when needed. The preamble must also recognize the contributions of elder persons to society and their diversity and the particular obstacles that they face in enjoying their human rights and their full participation in society on an equal footing with others. it must refer to the multiple intersecting forms of discrimination facing older persons. Chairperson, ladies and gentlemen, France considers it is crucial that the preamble recognize that older women face high risks of violence and of human rights violations. France also would wish to emphasize in the preamble the need for gender equality to be mainstreamed in the full enjoyment of human rights and fundamental freedoms by older persons. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:30:34]: Thank you, distinguished representative of France. I call on Peru. Peru [1:30:43]: Thank you, Peru. Welcome to the opportunity to contribute to this discussion on the elements to be placed in the preamble of the future instrument. This must be based on recognition of older persons as full, active right holders. with autonomy, independence, and the right to participate in society. We must uphold their experience, their knowledge, and their contributions to families, communities, and development of societies. For Peru, it is also important for the preamble to recognize that there is no single experience of aging. Life paths are very divergent in social, cultural, and territorial terms. and through the coexistence of indigenous persons, Afro-descendant, rural, and other communities. Thus, it is crucial to reflect the factors such as disability, poverty, rural dwelling, or geographical isolation, they can have a particular impact on the exercise of the rights of older persons. For Peru, the Preamble must also reaffirm that human rights apply fully throughout the life course. It must recognize the need to combat discrimination based on age, stereotypes, and different forms of violence, abuse, neglect and abandonment. In this effort, it is important to take into account the existing normative frameworks, including the experience of the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of the Rights of Older Persons, which provides important references on autonomy, participation, care, inclusion, and cultural diversity. Finally, we believe that the preamble should provide a concept of aging based on dignity, rights, participation, and intergenerational solidarity, and contribute to building inclusive societies for all ages. I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:32:48]: Thank you, Peru. Distinguished representative Israel. Israel [1:32:57]: Thank you, Chair. Israel welcomes the opportunity to contribute to the deliberations of the Working Group on the preamble of the LBI on human rights of older persons and is pleased to share its views on the matter. Israel is of the view that the preamble should set out the context and purpose of the instrument by reaffirming the fundamental principles that underpin it, including equality and non-discrimination, in particular on the basis of age, the elimination of discrimination as well as ageism, inclusion, and the right of older persons to participate fully in all aspects of society. The preamble should also recall the existing international human rights framework, including the applicable core international human rights treaties. In this regard, Israel considers it is important that the preamble acknowledge the normative and implementation gaps identified with respect to the protection of the rights of older persons, so as to reflect the added value of the instrument while avoiding unnecessary duplication of existing obligations. In order to promote and safeguard the important matter in question, we believe focus should remain on the human rights lens, as in the other conventions, without attempts to introduce other normative frameworks. The preamble should reflect global demographic trends and aging and the distinct stages of life encompassed within older age. It should further recognize that the situation of older persons is shaped not only by chronological and functional factors, but also by structural and social barriers, the removal of which is essential to the full enjoyment of their human rights. Israel further believes that the preamble should promote a positive understanding of aging by recognizing older persons as autonomous rights holders and the meaningful role they play as an integral part of our societies. In this spirit, it should affirm the principles of autonomy, participation, equality, and the importance of family, social, and intergenerational ties. At the same time, the preamble may acknowledge the heightened risks faced by older persons, which call for dedicated measures consistent with respect for their autonomy and dignity. The preamble should also recognize the impact of technological developments, including digitalization and artificial intelligence, on the enjoyment of the rights of older persons, both as an opportunity and as a potential source of new challenges. With respect to the overarching and cross-cutting aspects that affect the full enjoyment of human rights by older persons, Israel supports the view that the LBI and its preamble should address ageism as a cross-cutting phenomenon, manifested in stereotypes, prejudice, and discriminatory practices, which may impede the full and equal enjoyment of human rights by older persons. The LBI and its preamble should also reflect the importance of respecting the autonomy of older persons, in addition to their meaningful participation in decision-making processes affecting their lives, as well as their full inclusion in society. Mr. Chair, Israel looks forward to continuing to engage constructively with the Chair, Member States, and all relevant stakeholders in the further work on the preamble of the instrument. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:35:47]: Thank you, distinguished representative. Mr. Rael-Nagui, the distinguished representative of Serbia, you have the floor. Serbia · Representative; Co-Facilitator for the preamble [1:35:57]: Thank you, Chair. At the outset, allow me to say that we're pleased to serve as one of the co-facilitators of this process. And being entrusted together with Philippines with the task of elaborating preamble of the document, which should articulate the vision, purpose, and guiding principles of the future international legally binding instrument of the human rights of older persons. It should represent also a strong foundation for interpreting and implementing the substantive provisions. While existing human rights treaties and international law provide universal protection, they remain insufficient to fully respect, protect, and fulfill human rights of older persons. A future legally binding international instrument should therefore go beyond and establish an effective and sustainable system of protection. Non-discrimination will be a binding principle in combating ageism, and this is a central objective. Mr. Chair, Adyar, and the co-facilitators, The Republic of Serbia is committed to approaching this responsibility constructively and in a spirit of dialogue, inclusiveness, and cooperation. We look forward to engaging with all the delegations, civil society, and other stakeholders in order to contribute to a preamble that reflects the purpose and ambition of the future instrument. Mr. Chair, we are firmly devoted to this process with enormous amount of empathy with elderly persons. They are one of us, they are members of our society, and they shouldn't be neglected. With this legally binding instrument, we are paving the way. For their well-being in the future. Let us all be united in this all long-lasting endeavour. And I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:38:50]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Serbia, and thank you for your contribution to this process. I think it's really very valuable. Now I give the floor to distinguished representative of Iran. Iran (Islamic Republic of) [1:39:06]: Iran wishes to highlight three key elements for consideration in the preamble of the future instrument. First, dignity, empowerment, and active participation. The preamble should reaffirm the inherent dignity and equal worth of older persons. It should recognize them not merely as a recipient of care, but as active member of society whose knowledge, experience, and contribution benefit present and future generation. It should also reflect a comprehensive approach to aging, compassing physical, mental, social, and spiritual well-being, lifelong learning, family solidarity, and meaningful participation in society. Second, diversity and situation of heightened vulnerability. Older persons should not be automatically regarded as a vulnerable group solely because of their age. They are a diverse group with different abilities, experience, and needs. However, certain circumstances, including poverty, disability, social isolation, displacement, armed conflict, and humanitarian emergency may place older persons in situations of heightened vulnerability. The preamble should recognize this specific situation and need for appropriate protection without associating older age itself with incapacity or dependency. We also believe that preamble should reaffirm the inherent value of human life, reject the promotion of euthanasia and assisted suicide as response to aging, illness, or dependency and protect older person against coercion or under pressure to end their life. The preamble should also recognize the particular vulnerability of older persons living under foreign occupation, including in occupied Palestinian territory, and the importance of ensuring their dignity, protection, and full enjoyment of human rights. Third, the condition necessary for the effective enjoyment of rights. The preamble should recognize that the protection of older persons' rights requires not only legal recognition, but also adequate resources, accessible services, supportive infrastructure, and international cooperation. In this context, we emphasize the importance of the right to development and the need to address the structural barrier. Thank you, Mr. Chair. Chair-Rapporteur [1:41:46]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Iran. I now give you the floor to distinguished representative of Gambia. Gambia [1:41:55]: Thank you, Mr. Chairperson. The Gambia appreciates the contribution of the independent expert and shares many of the views shared by earlier speakers and the importance attached to the preamble of the future instrument. As reflected in article 31 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, the preamble forms part of the context for interpreting a treaty and it should therefore explain why the instrument is needed. the protections and the challenges it seeks to address, and the principles and existing agreed frameworks on which it builds upon. The preamble should recognize the cultural diversity of older persons and that ageism, including negative attitudes and stereotypes about aging, can lead to discrimination, exclusion, neglect, and abuse. It should also acknowledge that older persons face different challenges. For example, those living in rural areas may have difficulty accessing health care, social protection, and other essential services. Mr. Chair, a balanced preamble should recognize the valuable contributions older persons make to their families, communities, and societies. It should also affirm their dignity and the importance of involving them in decisions affecting their lives. Families, communities and faith-based organizations play an important role in supporting older persons around the world, and as such, cultural traditions and religious values can also promote respect, care and solidarity between generations. As a result, we are of the view that the Preamble should recognize these contributions and the need to support them, alongside the responsibility of States to promote and protect the rights of older persons. In our opinion, the preamble should also recognize the importance of international cooperation, technical assistance, and capacity building in supporting States, particularly developing countries and least developed countries, to realize the rights of older persons. Finally, Mr. Chair, we are also of the view that the preamble should acknowledge the efforts already made by States, regional organizations, and other stakeholders. In Africa, the African Union Protocol on the Rights of Older Persons 2016 provides an important example of regional action. The future instrument should therefore build on these experiences and the progress made across regions. The Gambia looks forward to working with all States and stakeholders in this process. Thank you, Mr. Chairperson. Chair-Rapporteur [1:44:13]: Thank you, distinguished representative of The Gambia. Thank you also for the contribution to this process. And I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Italy. You have the floor. Italy [1:44:30]: Thank you, Mr. Chair, distinguished delegates. On the occasion of the second session of the Intergovernmental Working Group, Italy aligns itself with the statement of the European Union and once more reaffirms its full support to the process of elaboration of a legally binding instrument on the promotion and protection of the human rights of older persons. In the context of today's discussion, Italy wishes to emphasize the importance of the preamble. the content of which will guide the negotiation of the text as well as the interpretation and application of the treaty on the rights of older persons once it will be adopted, ratified by states, and entered into force. As is well known, the provisions of the preamble contribute to defining the object and purpose of the treaty, in the light of which each subsequent textual provision of the treaty will be interpreted. In this regard, we suggest that the discussion for the identification and description of the elements of the preamble today, and as the work continues, should follow a clearly defined course which allow us to take stock of the current stage of development of the entire body of human rights legislation and jurisprudence available so far. Among the main steps of this course, we would like to emphasize the importance of the following: to expressly refer to the existing legislative framework of human rights treaties on which the new legal binding instrument will build upon; to state firmly that the new instrument should not regress from existing norms and standards, but building on them, represent a step forward in the protection of older persons in their specificity and diversity, since older persons are not obviously a homogeneous group. This taken into account, also the challenges related to current trends and phenomena, including climate change, global geopolitical instability, and the role of digitalization and artificial intelligence in shaping societies and economy. Last but by no means least, the preamble should emphasize the irreplaceable role of advocacy. in the protection and fulfillment of the human rights, and in the discussion about issues covered by the legal binding instrument. In this regard, Italy is ready to make available its experience of the implementation of CRPD, with particular reference to the establishment of the National Observatory on the conditions of persons with disability, as a place in which to carry on a continuous dialogue with civil society organizations and relevant stakeholders. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [1:47:26]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Italy. Now I give you the floor, distinguished representative of the Holy See. Holy See [1:47:37]: Thank you, Mr. Chair Rapporteur. The delegation of the Holy See My wish is to thank Dr. Petrošek for sharing the wishes of an older person and for offering a human perspective of principles that older persons would want to see in the future legal instrument. My delegation also considers that the preamble should rest upon clear legal foundations that reaffirm the value of human life and safeguard inherent and equal dignity of every older person. Since the preamble forms part of the interpretive context under Article 31.2 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, Its language requires particular care. It should recall the Charter of the United Nations, including especially Article 1, paragraph 3, and Article 55C. Principles drawn from other documents should, in our view, be recalled only when they reflect genuine and sustained consensus among States. Their legal status and any expressly stated qualifications must remain clear. The preamble should recognize that age discrimination is a violation of the inherent dignity and worth of the human person. The guarantee of equality before the law and equal protection without discrimination in Article 26 of ICCPR provides an essential foundation. Older persons possess this dignity irrespective of health, dependency, and capacity. The circumstances of their lives must respect that dignity; the circumstances cannot confer or diminish it. Furthermore, express recognition of the family is equally necessary. ICCPR Article 23, paragraph 1 establishes its entitlement to protection by society and the state. Article 10, paragraph 1 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights recognizes the protection and assistance owed to it. Families should therefore receive the support necessary to accompany their older members, particularly those with disability, bearing in mind that some of older persons themselves may also be caregivers to others, including their fellow older persons. Public authorities must ensure care and protection wherever such support is insufficient. Finally, the preamble should affirm the security of older persons and their protection from violence, abuse, exploitation, and neglect. Thank you, Mr. Chair Rapporteur. Chair-Rapporteur [1:49:51]: Thank you, distinguished representative of the Holy See, and you were the last speaker of my list of representatives of Member States. And before continuing with the representatives of civil society, we'll take a break of three, four minutes, and we'll retake in three, four minutes. Thank you. Thank you. Now we are going to continue with the Philippines Commission on Human Rights. You have the word, you have the floor. Philippines · Representative of the Commission on Human Rights [2:04:44]: Excellencies, the Commission on Human Rights of the Philippines recommends that the preamble of the LBI should affirm the principles of universality, indivisibility, and interdependence of human rights, and that these principles apply to all, including older persons. The preamble can cite the life course approach, the autonomy of older persons, the duties of states to protect, respect, and fulfill human rights, and the obligations of states over non-state actors, while citing the positive aspects such as strides made to promote active healthy aging and the significant contributions of older persons to societies. The preamble should recognize the existing normative and implementation gaps in international human rights law that impact the full realization of rights of older persons, also noting with concern the widespread ageism and age discrimination that affect their civil and political rights and economic, social, and cultural rights. We acknowledge that the LBI is building on the current international human rights and labor rights treaties and regional original human rights conventions, and it should not reduce rights already guaranteed. The elements of the preamble should appreciate the diversity of older persons, intergenerational solidarity, intersectionality, and the emergence of third generation rights, such as right to development, right to a healthy environment, climate change and human rights, and humanitarian protection. The rights of older persons in the digital sphere and the impacts of artificial intelligence and biotechnology on the promotion and protection of human rights of older persons can as well be mentioned in the preamble. National human rights institutions, such as our Commission, will continue to work together with older persons, their representative organizations, civil society, governments, and other stakeholders in negotiating an LBI that is comprehensive, enforceable, and that recognizes older persons as full and equal rights holders. Thank you. Maraming salamat po. Chair-Rapporteur [2:06:45]: Thank you. I give the floor to distinguished representative of Poland, the Commissioner for Human Rights. You have the floor. Poland · 19 national human rights institutions of Australia, Cameroon, Finland, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Guatemala, Namibia, Nigeria, Palestine, Philippines, Poland, Republic of Korea, Slovenia, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Sweden, Uganda, and United Kingdom · Representative of the Commissioner for Human Rights [2:06:53]: I would like to speak on behalf of 19 national human rights institutions of Australia, Cameroon, Finland, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Guatemala, Namibia, Nigeria, Palestine, Philippines, Poland, Republic of Korea, Slovenia, South Africa, Sri Lanka, Sweden, Uganda, and United Kingdom. We welcome this opportunity to contribute to this discussion on the preamble of the new Convention on the Human Rights of Older Persons, drawing on our monitoring, research and engagement with older persons across different regions. The preamble should reflect key elements that explain the need for a new legally binding instrument and establish its human rights foundation. As highlighted in Gunry's submission of April 2026, Existing international human rights frameworks remain fragmented, leaving significant protection gaps and legal uncertainty for older persons. Age-based discrimination, inadequate implementation of existing protection frameworks, and barriers to the effective enjoyment of rights persist. Ageism remains a major discrimination intersects with gender, disability, poverty, indiginity, sexual orientation, economic status, ethnic origin, and obstacle and can be embedded in laws, institutions, policies, and social practices. Therefore, a new convention is needed not merely to reaffirm existing rights, but to make them visible, effective, and enforceable in older age. Age-based other leading to other characteristics lead age and other characteristics leading to various forms of disadvantage that often accumulate throughout life course. Older persons, who are not a homogeneous group, must be recognized as full and equal rights holders, not primarily as recipients of welfare, protection, or care. Their inherent dignity and rights do not depend on their independence or functional abilities. The preamble should therefore establish a rights-based understanding of ageing grounded in autonomy, equality, participation and respect for dignity. The Convention must be anchored in the universality, indivisibility and interdependence of all human rights, while addressing the gaps that continue to affect older persons. We encourage a preamble that provides a clear normative foundation for the full and equal enjoyment of all human rights by older persons. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:09:16]: Thank you. I give the floor to distinguished representative of Australian Human Rights Commission from Australia. AHRC [2:09:26]: Thank you, Chair. In May and June this year, the Australian Human Rights Commission, in collaboration with civil society through the Rights of Older Persons Australia Network, held a national workshop and webinar to support engagement and gather inputs to inform the current working group session. These events brought together more than 300 participants from across Australia, including older persons with lived experience, civil society organisations, government, and academia. We are pleased to share some key themes that emerged to inform the preamble and broader concepts of the convention. Across the two events, participants expressed strong support for a new convention, highlighted the importance of ensuring older people are at the centre of its development, consistent with the principle of nothing about us without us. Noted that there are significant gaps in current human rights protections for older persons, both internationally and domestically, including the absence of a national human rights act in Australia. Recognised ageism as widespread and a significant cause of human rights violations. emphasized that older people are right holders and active contributors to society, stressing that human rights should not simply focus on care and protection, but also guarantee participation, autonomy, dignity, belonging, and self-determination. Finally, there was a strong message that older people are not a homogenous group. Participants emphasized the importance of recognizing diverse experiences of aging, including those of older women, older persons with dementia, First Nations or Indigenous older people, people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds, LGBTQIA+ older persons, people with disability, and those living in rural and remote communities. First Nations participants particularly stressed the importance of Indigenous voices being included from the outset of the Convention's development. Drawing on these perspectives, the Commission encourages the working group to consider that the preamble affirms that human rights apply equally throughout the life course, acknowledges ageism as a key driver of human rights violations, recognises older persons as active rights holders, reflects the full diversity of older people from the outset, not as an afterthought, responds to evolving understandings of aging and emerging challenges, including climate change, digitization, and emergencies; strengthens States' obligations to respect, protect, fulfill, and promote the human rights of all older persons. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:12:12]: Thank you. Now I give the floor to distinguished representative of the National Human Rights Commission of Nigeria. NHRC · NARIWA [2:12:20]: Thank you for the opportunity of this intervention on the preamble to the legally binding instrument on the right of older persons. I'm making this intervention on behalf of the National Human Rights Commission of Nigeria and the Network of National Human Rights Institutions in West Africa, NARIWA. We fully associate ourselves with the earlier intervention of the Global Alliance of National Human Rights Institutions, GANRI, at the second session of the Intergovernmental Working Group on the Rights of Older Persons. The NHRC and NARI were considered that the preamble should reaffirm the inherent dignity, equality, and universal human rights of all older persons. It should recognize their contributions to family, communities, and national development, while acknowledging the persistent challenges they face. including ageism, discrimination, abuse, neglect, poverty, social exclusion, inadequate access to health care and social protection. The preamble should reaffirm the principles ensuring the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, the African Charter on Human and People's Rights, and the Protocol to the African Charter on Human and People's Rights on the Right of Older Persons in Africa. It should also acknowledge gaps in existing existing human rights frameworks and emphasize the need for a legally binding instrument that clarifies State Parties' obligations, strengthens accountability, and guarantees that older persons can enjoy all their human rights without discrimination. The legally binding instrument should recognize that older persons are not a homogeneous group and that their experiences and needs vary according to factors including gender, disability, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, health, geographic location, and other personal circumstances. For instance, in Nigeria and West Africa, the family bonding is a key way of life and should be integrated into any arrangement for the protection of the right of older persons from Africa. The following cross-cutting issues should be reflected in the legally binding instrument and its preamble: equality and non-discrimination, gender equality, disability inclusion, autonomy and independence, protection from abuse, participation and inclusion, accessibility and digital inclusion, life course approach, accountability. The legally binding instrument should also require the collection of an analysis of appropriate disaggregated data to identify the areas and circumstances of older persons who experience disadvantages or marginalization. Mr. Chair, I thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:14:55]: Thank you. Now I give you the floor to distinguished representative of Age Platform Europe. AGE · More than 100 member organizations of AGE Platform Europe [2:15:02]: On behalf of the more than 100 member organizations of Age Platform Europe, the largest European network of organizations of and for older people, we align to the opening statement by the Global Alliance for the Rights of Older People and its discussion paper on this topic. The preamble is a core element of the future LBI, establishing the context, rationale, and transformative purpose of the convention, while also guiding interpretation and application as a coherent whole. The preamble must reaffirm the universality, indivisibility, interdependence, and interrelatedness of all human rights, and the need to ensure their full and equal enjoyment in older age without discrimination of any kind. It should clearly affirm that the central purpose of the treaty is to guarantee the rights of older persons as equal and autonomous rights holders. Population aging is one of humanity's greatest achievements. The Convention should therefore not be framed as a response to aging or to demographic change itself, but to the structural barriers, including ageism, that prevent all of us from enjoying our human rights equally in old age. The preamble should articulate the human rights rationale for the treaty by recognizing the historical and ongoing discrimination experienced by older persons, the impact of ageism on individuals and societies, and the fact that aging is a natural part of the life course throughout which all human rights continue to apply equally. Contemporary challenges, including among others digitalization and climate change, should be acknowledged where they create new forms of exclusion and inequality requiring human rights responses, not because they constitute the raison d'être of the Convention, but because the Convention must remain relevant to the realities of older people's lives. Importantly, the preamble must recognize that older persons are not a homogeneous group. It should reflect the diversity of their experiences and the intersectional, multiple, and cumulative nature of discrimination, including how inequalities across the life course shape the enjoyment of human rights in older age. It should also recognize the valuable contributions of older persons and their representative organizations to society and their communities, including to the promotion, protection, and monitoring of human rights. It should articulate the overarching vision of the Convention and its role in strengthening the overall international human rights framework. Ultimately, the preamble should lay the foundation for a legally binding instrument that not only protects older persons against rights violation, but also challenges and transforms the ageist structures, attitudes, and norms that prevent the full and equal enjoyment of human rights in practice. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:17:41]: Thank you. I give the floor to the International Network. the prevention of elder abuse. INPEA [2:17:48]: Thank you, Chair. INPEA is a founding member of the Global Alliance for the Rights of Older People. We align to GAROP's opening statement and welcome its discussions paper on this topic. The preamble should affirm clearly that older persons, in all their diversity, are human rights holders on an equal basis with others. It must reaffirm the universality, indivisibility, independence of all human rights and make explicit that these rights must be fully enjoyed in old age. First, it should clearly articulate why this convention is necessary. Existing protections remain fragmented and inconsistently applied. The new instrument must close protection gaps while maintaining and strengthening existing human rights standards, including autonomy and legal capacity. Second, the preamble must explicitly recognize ageism as a structural barrier and a root cause of discrimination, violence, abuse, neglect. And exploitation. This violation must never be accepted as an inevitable consequence of aging. Third, it should recognize intersecting and cumulative discrimination through the life course, including the specific experience of older women. Older age must not automatically be equated with dependency or disability. The preamble should also acknowledge Changing condition, including digitalization, climate change, and humanitarian emergency, which can create additional barriers to enjoining rights. Families and communities can provide valuable support, but legal responsibility must remain with states. Such support must always respect older person autonomy, will, and preference. Finally, the preamble must recognize older persons' agency and their full and meaningful participation in all discussion affected them. The purpose must be clear: the full and equal enjoyment of all human rights through old age. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:20:23]: I think I will give the floor to distinguished representative of International Federation on Ageing. IFA [2:20:29]: Mr. Chair, the International Federation on Ageing believes the preamble should clearly establish the principles and aspirations guiding the future convention. We align with the opening statement of the Global Alliance of the Rights of Older Persons and welcome its discussion paper on this topic. The preamble should emphasize that human rights do not expire at any age. Recall that the Madrid International Plan of Action on Ageing recognise that the foundation for a healthy and enriching old age is laid early in life, and encourage prevention and preparedness throughout the life course. Recognise the dignity, autonomy, independence, and diversity of older persons, and their contributions to families, communities, economies, and societies. and affirm that dignity and rights do not depend on health, functional ability, economic contribution, or need for support. Recognise the cross-cutting nature of ageism and all the levels in society where it manifests. Articulate the need to eliminate ageism in all its forms. Acknowledge that it can even lead to hatred of older persons, which may need to be recognised in law. Understand that prohibiting age discrimination will not be successful without efforts to eliminate ageism. Acknowledge the persistent impact of ageism, discrimination and inequalities accumulated throughout life, particularly those affecting older women, and persons facing multiple forms of discrimination. Recall, the former UN Independent Expert on the Rights of Older Persons recommended that legislation avoid exceptions, exemptions, or justifications that mask age biases that limit the autonomy of older persons and their ability to participate in society on an equal basis with others. Recognize the inherently intersectional nature of age discrimination, including intersections between age and disability. Recognize that older persons with disabilities comprise those with lifelong disabilities and persons who acquire disabilities at older ages. Affirm equal protection and access to support regardless of when disability begins. recognise States' responsibility to ensure access to affordable, accessible, quality long-term care and support for older persons who require it, respecting their will and preferences, dignity, autonomy, and inclusion in the community, including during crises. The preamble should recognise the importance of solidarity between generations and meaningful participation of older persons in all decisions affecting their lives. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:23:43]: Thank you. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Liberation. Liberation · Centre for the Human Rights of Users and Survivors of Psychiatry [2:23:49]: Thank you. Liberation is representing the Centre for the Human Rights of Users and Survivors of Psychiatry during the session. The preamble should explain the vital need for a legally binding instrument which addresses the human rights of all older persons. sets the concept for it. In doing so, it should emphasise the importance of addressing ageism, including its roots in social constructs and medicalised approaches to older persons, together with the widespread intersectional discrimination which all too often compounds the already harrowing effects of ageism. It should draw attention to the fact that rights should be an inherent part of human life, from the cradle to the grave, and that recognising older persons too as rights holders is an essential component of us having an equal place within the human race. It should counter the widespread portrayal of controlling and coercive approaches to older persons, as representing care and protection. Instead, it should recognise the rights of all of us as persons with continuing rich contributions to make at home, within our local communities, nationally and internationally. In line with the UNCRPD, It should include clear recognition that all older persons’ legal capacity is an intrinsic component of our human rights, irrespective of any disability which we may have. It should affirm all older persons’ right to live independently, free from substitute decision-making and institutionalisation. and our right to access the everyday resources which facilitate that. It should emphasise the importance of moving away from professionally dominated services to services directly stemming from older persons' own choices, including the rich diversity of these. And it should acknowledge that older persons, together with organisations led by us, should have a leading role, both in relation to this legally binding instrument and in relation to the national and international measures needed to enforce it. Chair-Rapporteur [2:26:45]: Thank you. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Alliance Defending Freedom. ADF [2:26:52]: Mr. Chair Rapporteur, as Article 31, paragraph 2 of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties provides, the preamble forms part of the context for the interpretation of the instrument's provisions. We therefore consider it important that its content be carefully formulated. On sources, we suggest that the preamble draw first on the Charter of the United Nations and the core international human rights treaties relevant to older persons. Principles and commitments contained in other documents should be recalled where they reflect genuine and sustained consensus among States, and are consistent with existing obligations. On content, we would respectfully propose that the preamble recognize, inter alia, the following well-established principles: that discrimination against older persons on the basis of age violates their inherent dignity and worth; that older persons should be able to live in security, free of violence, abuse and exploitation of any kind, and that the family, as the natural and fundamental group unit of society, is entitled to the widest possible protection and assistance so that it can contribute towards the full and equal enjoyment of the rights of older persons. Mr. Chairperson, we have noted the use in earlier statements of expressions such as "living with dignity", "aging with dignity" and "dignified aging". We understand the concerns underlying them, which are best framed in terms of the conditions in which older persons live, including their standard of living, highest attainable standard of health, and access to appropriate care and support. As a matter of treaty drafting, however, such expressions are capable of being misconstrued as suggesting that dignity is contingent upon circumstances and susceptible to diminution or loss through illness, dependency, or lack of resources. Dignity is inherent and present throughout the life course, and we are confident that the elaboration of the legally binding instrument will consistently reflect that character. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:29:14]: Thank you. I give the floor to distinguished representative of HelpAge Deutschland. HelpAge Deutschland [2:29:21]: Chair, and thanks to the independent expert for your valuable, comprehensive contribution. As a lawyer, I would say a good convention is like a good book. It must captivate the reader right from the start. Of course, I understand a convention is not a sci-fi thriller. Therefore, the preamble has to be more than just an introduction. It set out why this convention is necessary and serves as a guide to its indulgence. It must have positive attitudes. Hence, we propose five elements aligning with positions from Age Platform Europe and GARP. First, The preamble should recognize the historical and ongoing discrimination and exclusion faced by senior citizens and identify its root cause, age-related discrimination. Age-related discrimination is not a widespread phenomenon that transcends cultures and borders. It is embedded in laws, policies, institutions, and societal attitudes, and is increasingly taking place in the digital and technological sphere. It is the main barrier to the full enjoyment of rights and the root cause of violence, abuse, neglect, and exploitation, but not limited. Second, it should reaffirm a holistic understanding of senior citizens as active right holders with full legal personality and legal capacity, as full participants in society who are entitled to the full range of human rights and fundamental freedoms. Senior citizens are not sole passive recipients of care and charity. Third, it should recognize the valuable contribution senior citizens make to their families, communities, and societies, as well as their full, meaningful, and equal participation in all decisions affecting them and in all aspects of society. Fourth, it should reflect the diversity of senior citizens as well as multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination, including gender, disability, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, and geographical isolation, which can accumulate over the course course of lifetime, with particular attention being paid to older women and older people in humanitarian and emergency situations. We mentioned this earlier this morning for the draft of the PPED, which still needs urgent adjustments. The experience and significance of older age are shaped by social and cultural norms, not by a chronological threshold. Fifth, the preamble should recognize that increased life expectancy and demographic change have transformed our societies and intergenerational relationships and set out the objective of transforming narratives and social constructs surrounding aging so as to enable senior citizens to realize their full potential and to foster a culture of mutual respect and solidarity between generations. Thank you very much. Chair-Rapporteur [2:32:17]: Thank you. Now we will have the floor distinguished representative of International Disability Alliance. IDA [2:32:25]: Thank you, Chair. We appreciate this opportunity to share comments on potential elements for the preamble. Firstly, IDA believes that the preamble should follow the model of paragraph D of the CRPD and explicitly refer to previous human rights treaties, including now, of course, the CRPD as well. It is important to reflect that the current standard-setting process builds upon existing human rights standards, in particular those based on the CRPD, and further elaborates and specifies them for the situation of older persons. While it is clear that previous treaties and relevant documents derived from them have not had sufficient positive impact on older persons, which could be explicitly acknowledged, it is still important to present in the legally binding instrument as a new development of broader human rights law. The preamble should reaffirm the human dignity, autonomy, independence, and freedom to make their own choices of older persons. advancing equality and non-discrimination, supported decision-making, and the respect of the will and preferences of the person. In addition, while acknowledging that families, communities, and society can have a supportive role, the State's primary responsibility to respect, protect, and fulfill the human rights of older persons should be stressed. The preamble should refer to the relevance of an intersectional approach to prevent discrimination against older persons with disabilities, including multiple intersectional discrimination based on age and/or disability, and to reduce inequalities caused by ableism and ageism in laws, policies, and societal life. In connection to this, a reference to the intersection of disability and aging could be included in a careful way to prevent any inaccurate confusion. The expertise of right holders in their diversity needs to be acknowledged explicitly, and the relevance of closely consulting and actively involving them in public decision making and their voices being given priority should be advanced as a basic element of a human rights-based approach. The preamble should highlight the complementary roles of domestic resource mobilization including through effective and progressive taxation, and of international cooperation for the implementations of rights, the eradication of poverty among older persons, and the resourcing of right holders organizations for them to effectively engage with states actors in consultations and public decision making. Thank you very much for your attention. Chair-Rapporteur [2:35:03]: Thank you. I give the floor to the International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care. IAHPC [2:35:10]: International Association for Hospice and Palliative Care aligns with the opening statement delivered by the Global Alliance for the Rights of Older Persons and welcomes its discussion paper on this topic. We wish to highlight three established rights that the preamble should explicitly recall. First, the rights to autonomy and dignity throughout life, including at the end of life. Rights to autonomy and dignity must be respected not only during healthy and active life, but also when a person is living with serious illness and approaching the end of life. Palliative care enables older persons to express and document their preferences for future health care and supports respect for those preferences in accordance with applicable law. Second, the right to be free from extreme poverty. The preamble should explicitly recall the right to be free from extreme poverty, which is both a cause and a consequence of older persons' inability to enjoy the rights to health, autonomy, participation, and life. Extreme poverty, which particularly affects older women and widows in the global south, prevents older people from exercising autonomy and accessing essential health and social services. Likewise, discrimination and social exclusion deepen poverty and further undermine older people's dignity and independence. Third, the rights to health, life, and care. By 2060, population aging and rising rates of non-communicable diseases are expected to double global demand for palliative care. Yet few health systems are sufficiently equipped to meet the needs of older persons who need palliative care, which is an essential component of the right to health, primary health care, and universal health coverage. We therefore urge states to recognize the growing burden of serious health-related suffering, particularly in the gap between average life expectancy and healthy life expectancy. The preamble should draw on existing regional precedents, including the Inter-American Convention, the African Union Protocol, and the binding advisory opinion of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights on the right to care, which stipulates inclusion of palliative care. Chair, these three basic rights are interconnected. Stipulating respect for autonomy and dignity, protecting older persons from extreme poverty, and providing access to palliative care are fundamental to ensuring that older persons can exercise their human rights throughout their lives until natural death. We urge states to reflect these priorities explicitly in the convention's preamble. And so they can be recognized not as recipients of care, but as right holders whose dignity, choices, and preferences duty bearers are obliged to respect. Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:38:23]: Thank you, Naguib, for the distinguished representative of AgeWell Foundation. AgeWell Foundation [2:38:34]: Thank you, Chair. We all have been talking about the chairs we must fill this afternoon. We speak of the first page that welcomes everyone to them. The preamble is the first page, and the world will read it and decide whether this instrument begins with honesty or with comfort. We respectfully ask that it should begin with three truths. First, older persons are right holders, not recipients of charity. Dignity does not expire at 60. Two, by 2050, according to WHO, 80% of older persons will live in low and middle income countries, many in conditions of extreme marginalization. The global south is not an annex to this instrument. It is where most of the beneficiaries will live. A preamble that begins from that reality will serve the many who need it, not only the few who just demand it. Third, ageing is a journey across generations. Young people are not visitors here. They are the older persons of tomorrow. We also ask the preamble to to recognize that those who benefit from longer lives, whether states or the markets, built on longevity, share responsibility for the care and support those lives require. Chair, consider the precedents. The Americas and Africa have each adopted a binding regional instrument on the rights of older people already. Asia, home to the largest number of old people on earth, has none. I hope sooner than later, we from India should be able to lead that. This is the first global text that we are preparing here. It should carry the voice of the whole world, with Global South at its center. In the first session, we asked for a preamble with moral courage. We thank the core members for the spirit in which that was received, and today we ask for a first page that does not flinch. If we are brave on the opening page, the rest of the book will stand on the firm ground. Can this preamble speak not only about the Global South, but for it? Thank you. Chair-Rapporteur [2:41:33]: Thank you. Now I give you the floor, distinguished representative of the University for Peace and the United Nations, Maria Soledad Sistanos. UPEACE [2:41:42]: Reyes. Thank you, Chairperson. At the outset, I would like to thank the representative of Serbia for the contribution to the preamble. It's a difficult task because the preamble can't contain everything. The Convention is going to be setting out a lot of content, but in this context, the preamble seeks to set the preamble out, and if we look at it metaphorically, we see three parts. First, it is the axiological basis, in other words, the propers owner principle as expressed in the convention, and that's throughout the that runs throughout the multilateral human rights system. A number of delegates have mentioned this, from the Charter of the United Nations to all of the international instruments. and right up to the 21st century, with the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, the Inter-American Convention on the Protection of the Human Rights of Older Persons, and the African Protocol on the Rights of Older Persons. The regional instruments will certainly be a rich source of references for our Convention. That's the second block. The Convention seeks to recognize the human rights-based model for older persons. In other words, persons who, because of their age, are facing obstacles, and the obstacles undermine recognition, enjoyment, and exercise of human rights and fundamental freedoms. So, the priority obligation of states is to remove the barriers. And in this way, we speak of the right to dignity, autonomy, and independence. But it is really important to clarify properly the issue of ageism as a barrier that generates discrimination, and then we can define that in more detail. There's also the issue of violence, abuse, and ill-treatment of older persons, and abandonment. And this is also a scourge, as is poverty, that affects millions of older persons. intersectionality with disability, with discrimination against women, and so forth. And finally, there's a third segment. We, in this Convention, aspire to raise awareness that is an obligation of States, and When, as the rapporteur stated, means in the future, we seek to have intergenerational dialogue. Those are the points I wanted to make today. Chair-Rapporteur [2:45:14]: Thank you. CGIL [2:45:20]: And thank you, independent expert, to be with us. The union that I represent, that was established in '48, it chose from the beginning to be a branch of the general union, showing the indivisibility of the movement of workers and pensioners. I remind this fact, since we think that it is for the preambular part of the instrument to state the commitment to the intergenerational solidarity, with all the caveats that my friend from OKRA said this morning. Many young people are taking the streets these days, having a sense of being denied the future of dignity. When we establish the right of older person, we ask our governments not only to work for positive actions toward those who are old today, but also to create the conditions for sustainable and positive conditions for older workers of tomorrow. In line of the statement by Age Platform Europe, GAROP, we also think that it is necessary to acknowledge ageism as a widespread phenomenon that still exists in laws, policies, social and economic institutions, etc. It seems incredible that in 2026, we still need to recall that older persons are right holders who have the right to full legal capacity and who are entitled to enjoy the full range of human rights and fundamental freedoms in dignity and autonomy. but we have to do it. Crucial will be to set out the ambition to overcome structural social economic barriers and redress the profound social disadvantage experienced in older age. From older workers facing discrimination in the workplace, to women and men who do not receive adequate pensions allowing for a dignified living, to society denying active participation for all, the preamble can set the of the instrument. Fight against discrimination with particular attention to older women based on the intersectional perspective is also a must, including age, gender, race, ethnicity, gender identity, disability, socioeconomic status, and geographic isolation. Finally, Chair, and understanding and agree with you that this is not a working group on disarmament, but in a world that dangerously build war arsenals, we think that the reference to the right to peace would be necessary, with human rights as the threshold in order for older person to be entitled to live free from war, armed conflict, and violence. I'm sure that you can think of a language that could go in the preambular part, and maybe, you know, that doesn't go too far where we cannot go. Thank you very much. Chair-Rapporteur [2:48:25]: Thank you, distinguished representative of Confederazione Generale Italiana del Lavoro. This was the last speaker that we can accommodate for today. I mean, all the statements will be placed in the website. I don't know if you really realize that today is a historical day, because for the first time after so many years of discussion, so many years of aspiration, so many years of waiting, we're finally beginning to build something that the world has needed for far too long. Today, we begin to move from aspiration to obligations, from recognition to protection, from promises made to rights guaranteed. History We remember this day because as long as it lasted, we began turning those words into the protection that all the persons have deserved all along. Let us remember, we are not simply describing a preamble to a convention, we are designing the opening lines of a new chapter in human dignity. And now, I want to give you the floor to Mr. Pirtosek for his final remarks. Thank you. UN · Independent Expert on the enjoyment of all human rights by older persons [2:49:41]: Mr. Chair, Excellencies, friends, I thank delegation for their thoughtful interventions regarding the scope and content of the preamble, and particularly to the NGOs, which really, I mean, reflect very, very much of what how I see the preamble. But of course, the decision makers are states and many states, and the discussion today and yesterday afternoon, i think, really reveal considerable convergence I mean, regarding both the purpose of the preamble and the principles that should guide interpretation of future convention. Now, many states emphasize that the preamble should explain why this convention is necessary and provide a clear statement of its purpose. Slovenia, Saudi Arabia, Portugal, Colombia, Austria, and the Philippines stressed that the preamble should articulate the rationale for the instrument, identify the challenges and protection gaps gaps faced by older persons and provide a coherent framework for interpreting the provisions that follow. Austria described the preamble as both a table of contents of the challenges confronting older persons and a strategy for addressing them, while the Philippines underscored its role in guiding interpretation of the Convention as a whole. And these observations are particularly important. The preamble should explain why a dedicated instrument is needed, acknowledging the substantial work already undertaken by the open-ended working group and its finding concerning persistent gaps. And the preamble should therefore situate the convention within this broader historical and normative context. A second recurring theme was the need to firmly establish older persons as right holders. Delegations including Chile, Mexico, the European Union, South Africa, Cabo Verde, India, and Colombia emphasized the importance of a human rights-based approach that moves beyond welfare and the assistance paradigm. paradigms, and I fully support this approach. And several delegations, including Portugal, Colombia, Chile, Jordan, Kuwait, France, the United Arab Emirates, emphasized that the Convention must be firmly anchored within the existing international human rights framework. States also repeatedly highlighted equality, non-discrimination, and the need to address ageism. Germany, Greece, Colombia, Austria, Portugal, and others emphasized that ageism is not merely an individual prejudice, but a structural form of discrimination that can be expressed through stereotypes, assumptions. Colombia specifically referred to both historic and contemporary forms of discrimination against older persons, and Austria further drew attention to loneliness and social isolation. Another area of broad agreement concerned diversity and intersectionality. Ecuador, the Philippines, Uruguay, Greece, Jordan, Palestine, and others stressed that older persons are not a homogenous group. And some delegations also highlighted the particular challenges faced by older persons in situations of armed conflict, occupation, displacement, disaster, humanitarian emergencies, and the preamble may appropriately acknowledge these realities as part of the contemporary context. Several delegations also highlighted the importance of accessible support system, including long-term care, palliative care, for which I'm very grateful, as well as recognition of the contribution of caregiver. So finally, many states emphasized intergenerational solidarity, the role of families and communities, and the contributions of older persons. The preamble can appropriately recognize this contribution, as well as the support provided by families, caregivers, and communities. At the same time, several delegations stressed that such recognition must not diminish the primary responsibilities of States. I thank you very much for this opportunity, Mr. Chairperson. Chair-Rapporteur [2:54:24]: Thank you. Thank you so much, Mr. Pritoušek. Impeccable summary. Well, Excellencies and distinguished participants, it brings us to the end of this meeting, and tomorrow we will resume our work at 10:00 AM for the debate on definitions. I hereby declare this meeting closed. Speaker 100 [2:54:49]: Thank you.