Skip to main content

UNITAR Briefing for Delegates on Multilateralism in Practice

30 March·10:00·01:16:56Meetings & Events

Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON

Transcript

Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more

UNITAR

Good morning, Excellencies, distinguished delegates, colleagues, and friends. It's a pleasure to welcome you today to this briefing on multilateralism in practice, reflections from chairing the BB&J negotiations. On behalf of UNITAR, I'd like to extend a sincere thank you to the Permanent Mission of Singapore for their partnership in bringing this session together. At UNITAR New York, our goal is to make the UN system more accessible and more practical for delegates. That means not just understanding how the system works, but building the skills needed to actually navigate it, whether that's negotiating, drafting, or working across different positions and priorities. And that's exactly why today's session is so valuable. The BBNJ agreement is a major milestone, not just because of what it achieves for ocean governance, but because of how it was achieved. It's a strong example of what multilateralism looks like in practice. Complex, but ultimately capable of delivering meaningful results. We are especially honored to have Ambassador Rina Lee with us here today, who chaired these negotiations over several years and led them to a successful conclusion. I'm sure her insights will be incredibly valuable for all of us working within this system. I'd also like to thank Ambassador Ghafur for his leadership and for moderating today's discussion. With that, thank you all again for being here, and I look forward to the conversation. It's my honor to now pass the floor to Ambassador Goh Poh, the Permanent Representative of the Republic of Singapore to the United Nations.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much, Grayson, for the introduction. Thank you also to UNITAR New York office for convening and coordinating arrangements for this discussion this morning. Good morning, excellencies, distinguished colleagues, ladies and gentlemen. It's a pleasure for me, as the permanent representative of Singapore, to welcome all of you to this briefing on multilateralism in practice. I'd like to thank UNITAR for convening this very timely discussion, which is occurring just after the BBNJ agreement entered into force on the 17th of January 2026, and this meeting is also taking place. in the midst of the third and final session of the BBNJ Preparatory Commission. I know that this session is also being followed virtually, online, and the session will also be recorded and, I believe, placed on the website of UNITAR for future reference. Dear friends, colleagues, We are meeting at a moment when multilateralism is under increasing strain, even as the need for collective solutions has never been more urgent. For many states, particularly small and medium-sized delegations, multilateralism is not an abstract ideal, but it is a practical necessity. It provides the framework through which we can engage on equal footing. and through which international law can continue to serve as a stabilizing force. Against this backdrop, the successful conclusion and entry into force of the BBNJ agreement stands out as a significant achievement for the UN and for the multilateral system. It is a reminder that even in a complex geopolitical environment, it is entirely possible for states to come together, to work together, to address shared challenges, and to strengthen the governance of our global commons. The value of the BBNJ process lies not only in its outcome, but in how the outcome was achieved. Multilateral success is rarely accidental. It depends on careful process design. It depends on sustained engagement, and it depends on the ability to build trust across very diverse positions. In this regard, I'm very pleased to have Ambassador Rina Lee with me. And Ambassador Rina Lee, as you know, chaired the BBNJ negotiations from 2018 to 2023, and she guided delegations towards consensus. Her experience offers important lessons for all of us engaged in multilateral diplomacy. Today's discussion is intended to be practical and interactive, and I encourage all participants, whether from states or civil society, to engage actively in the discussions. With that, it is my great pleasure to invite Ambassador Rina Lee to deliver her opening remarks. Rina, over to you.

SingaporeAmbassador; President of the BBNJ IGC

Thank you. Thank you very much, and a very good morning to Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you for joining me this morning, particularly in this room, CR6, which holds so much memories for BBNG negotiators, because it was here in this very room that we spent something like 40 non-stop hours finalizing the agreement. I'm told that on the Monday following negotiations, the UN was forced to bring in cleaners to deep clean the room because we had spent so long here. But it was the 40 or so hours that helped us to reach a conclusion on the negotiations. So let me first start by thanking UNITA for inviting me to share my experience as president of the BBME. intergovernmental conference and to thank everyone for your interest in this subject. I think it's I can take heart from the fact that even though today many people are predicting, have predicted, will continue to predict the death of multilateralism, that there remains interest in multilateralism. And I think that that is important for us to be able to move forward. So again, I think this is going to be informal, but Today, what I'll do is I'll touch a little bit on multilateralism first, and then give an overview of the BBNJ agreement before going into some of the techniques and processes that are used during the BBNJ IGC. and where the BBNJ agreement goes from here, and maybe share some reflections in line with the hashtag that I see on the signs. It says #BBNJReflections, so I shall. I shall do that. So the starting point, because we're here at the UN, is really about, I thought I would share, I went to do some research, and the UN itself has a web page on multilateralism and how the UN as an institution, as an organization, views multilateralism. The multilateralism is defined, and I quote, "A collective action coordinated between at least three actors. It implies that the actors have a shared realization that it is in their interests to work together to resolve problems that are bigger than their individual efforts would tackle," close quote. And further on, it goes on to say, the spirit of multilateralism is, together, we are stronger. So this is how the UN views multilateralism. We know that it involves at least three actors. In other words, not every multilateral effort involves the entire membership of the UN. And this is in contrast, I think, from that perspective, you see multilateralism in contrast to bilateralism, which is between two actors. And even other terms used, for example, plurilateralism or regionalism, is really they are ultimately, if you go by this definition, different forms of multilateralism in practice. And the key point is about working together to resolve issues or problems because we have shared interests. So two things, I think, follow from this definition of multilateralism. The first is that multilateralism is about substantive outcomes. We are seeking in engaging in multilateral efforts to resolve problems that individual efforts alone cannot resolve. It's not to say that individual efforts don't matter. Actually, individual efforts matter a lot. But it's the collective It's the collective pooling together of the individual efforts in a collective and coordinated fashion that will resolve some of the problems that are facing us today. So that's the first point. The second point, and this is my personal view, but Ambassador Gafoor has alluded to that. Multilateralism is not just about the outcome, it is also about process, it's also about the way that we do things. And again, to quote the UN, it is a tool of statecraft and a mindset, a way to do things, close quote. So really, multilateralism, from my perspective, and was certainly how I approached the BBNJ negotiations, multilateralism I saw as much of a process as it was about the substance, about coming to an agreement. Yes, the mandate was for us to come to an agreement, but I felt like how we came to the agreement was also important, because that also is multilateralism. And the UN views the multilateral system, including the UN system, as a practical implementation of multilateralism. And the key aspects of what they term their philosophy of multilateralism is as follows. First, collective problem solving. Because there are shared interests in the problem, we engage in collective problem solving. Second, equality and inclusivity. Third, a shared responsibility. Fourth, the rules-based international order, which I know there's some discussion over this term. 5th, sustainable development, 6th, dialogue and diplomacy, and 7th, leave no one behind. These seven features articulate the UN's philosophy of multilateralism, and to some extent, I will say that it may be not that I had a philosophy on multilateralism, but was also how I sought to manage the intergovernmental process. It's important, though, for us to remember that multilateralism is not just about concluding treaties. In other words, we don't just see multilateralism from the lens of norm creation or the conclusion of treaty. International law is part of multilateralism, but it's not the only product of multilateralism. And multilateral efforts occur in many different platforms and forums, resulting in different outputs. So there is a research piece called on that was issued, I think, in conjunction with the 80th anniversary of the UN, and it's called 80 Multilateral Agreements That Shaped the World. And these reflect 80 key documents. or watershed moments in the history of the UN. They're not all agreements, although it's called 80 multilateral agreements. If you look at each year, it's one for each year of the existence of the UN. They're not agreements as maybe lawyers understand them. In other words, they are not all treaties. 18 of the 80 key documents that are reflected in this research piece, I think it was part of an exhibition that the UN held to celebrate 80 years, among them, so 18 of the 80 key documents are treaties. Among them, the UN Charter, the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, and the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. Alas, the BBNJ agreement is not one of the key documents. But I think that for those of us who study international law, We can see that, especially in the second-half of the 20th century, it was a period of great growth for international law, driven by multilateralism. If you look at the UN treaty database and you trace how many treaties there were in the UN treaty base at the start of the UN and where it is now, you will see a mushrooming of in intergovernmental, international treaties, many of which are multilateral in nature. So now we go specifically to the BBNJ agreement. To give it its full title, I will say this only once. It's a very long title. It's the Agreement under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea on the Conservation and Sustainable Use of Marine Biological Diversity areas beyond national jurisdiction. In other words, BBNJ. You know now why all of us shorten it. It deals with the areas beyond national jurisdiction, which is defined in the agreement as the high seas and the area, the area with a capital A, meaning to say, for those of you who are familiar with the law of the sea, meaning to say that part of the deep seabed that is beyond the outer limits of the continental shelf, and which is governed by Part 11 of UNCLOS. There are four substantive pillars in the BBNJ agreement, and in the mandate, it was articulated that we would approach the four pillars as a package. And the four pillars are first, marine genetic resources and the fair and equitable sharing of benefits. Second, area-based management tools, including marine protected areas. Third, environmental impact assessments. And fourth, capacity building and the transfer of marine technology. There's also a general section which makes for interesting reading for those of you who are students. of law of the sea and or environmental law, particularly Article 7 on principles and approaches, because it sort of melds principles and approaches from law of the sea and environmental law together. And then the institutional arrangements, dispute settlement, and final provisions. I want to focus a bit more on the process of how we got to where we are today, with the treaty having entered into force and all of us now looking forward to the first conference of the parties, although, of course, I welcome questions that you may have about the agreement subsequently. Just to give a quick rundown of the process, many of you would have read that this was like a 20-year process to get to this point. And indeed, we started off with, and as is very typical in the UN, we started with an ad hoc, open-ended informal working group. to discuss issues relating to biodiversity in areas beyond national jurisdiction. The first meeting was in 2004, and then on and off over the years, we met sometimes three years later, sometimes there were years where there were no meeting, until 2015, when the UN membership agreed that we would start working on a treaty. an agreement on this issue. 2016 and 2017, we had a preparatory committee process to prepare for the actual negotiations for an intergovernmental conference. 2018 to 2023 was the period of the Intergovernmental Conference. It was my privilege and honor to be the president of that conference. I say 2018 to 2023, but in fact, because of the pandemic, we had no meetings in 2020 or 2021. We only resumed in the beginning of 2022. The PrepCom, very confusingly, the PrepCom also, but it's the Preparatory Commission, is currently having its third and final session. It started work last year, and the conference of the parties, the very first one of the BBNJ agreement, is going to begin, is going to be held in January of next year. Now, the treaty was adopted in June of 2023. It opened for signature on 20th of September 2023 for a period of two years, meaning to say states had up to 20th September 2025 to sign the agreement. On the 19th of September, 2025, just one day shy of that deadline, we received the 60th ratification. And the entry into force requirement for the BBNJ treaty was a relatively high threshold of 60 ratifications, and that meant the treaty would enter into force in 120 days. So I have to say, while it did, the process did take 20 years from when we started discussing it, I think it's very also important to note that from the time I introduced the text of the treaty ahead of the third session of the IGC to the time that we concluded substantive negotiations on the treaty text, and this is a treaty of over 70 provisions, It states and observers had only eight weeks, eight weeks of face-to-face negotiations. So eight weeks over a period of, I guess, three years, if you include the pandemic, eight weeks over a period of three years to conclude the actual textual negotiations of the agreement. And that's important to note because sometimes if we want to begin work on certain areas, Maybe some countries will go, "Oh, you know, it's going to take a long time." But in fact, if we have the will and the determination to do that, we can actually negotiate in an efficient manner, if we can put it that way. So on to the practice of multilateralism within the BBNJ IGC. It had always, of course, we had our mandate from the General Assembly, and of course, we had to, the output, the expected output was a treaty, but it had also been when I was elected as president of the IGC, I thought to myself, what can I do with this process? And what I wanted to do, especially that very first meeting, we were in conference room one, which for those of you who are familiar with the conference room one, it's a kind of sloping, so you sit at the podium and you look up into the conference room. And what I noticed was that there were many young negotiators, and many young women negotiators. And so I decided that What I wanted also out of this process was to give, to provide everyone with a positive experience of multilateralism, to be able to come out when we finish the process and say, yeah, multilateralism works, let's go use it on something else. Let's advance and use this and tackle other issues as well. So here I'm going to focus a bit on the process or the procedures or the planning that went into the different sessions of the Intergovernmental Conference. But I want to say it's really important to remember as negotiators that each platform, each stream of work, will have its own process, its own dynamics, its own tempo. So for negotiators, it's really important that we learn to work within each process, within each work stream, within each platform. It's not to say that we cannot have ideas and we cannot share those ideas around how we think the process should be organized, but at the end of the day, if the process is organized in a different fashion, we should be able to still find ways to work together within in that process. So here, I think I'm just really going to share some of the things that I did during the IGC, and whether they were successful, useful, helpful, you have to go and ask the negotiators in conference room four down that way if it worked or not. It's not for me to say, and I frankly would be the first to say that I made a lot of mistakes during the IGC. And I really appreciated negotiators, member states, observers coming and giving me their feedback so that I also knew how to recover from those mistakes. And I'll give an example. During the first part of the fifth session, we tried to move into small groups, but there became a lot of feedback on, oh, the process was a little chaotic, we didn't know which small group was meeting at what time, we didn't know where where they were meeting because they were off in a little corner of the delegates lounge or in the Vienna cafe, and there were some members who said, we wanted to participate, but we had no idea where to go or what time. So when we met, when we came back and we met for the second part of the fifth session, we sort of became more organized. I mean, it was intended to be an informal process, but informal processes also need some organization around. And so we started limiting the number of small group meetings to no more than two a day. We specified a time, we specified a place, so that people could go. And actually all that had been posted on the IGC website, but I realized that many people didn't know how to access that part of the website. So the first thing we did when we reconvened for the second part of the fifth session was to organize a sharing session by the Secretariat, we showed how to navigate the website, so everybody knew how to use the website. And you know, that reminds me that in an early session of the IGC, what we tried to do with sharing the documents was to post the QR code. And then I had delegates coming to me and going, "I don't have an Apple phone. I cannot use the QR code." And I was like, really helping people access the QR code. And then I realized, yes, indeed, the role of the president is to offer tech support. So maybe I'll just share some of the techniques in terms of the So I would say that first was, one of the first techniques was really to have pre-meeting consultations. One week before, because I'm not based in New York, one week before the IGC session started, I would invite meetings from everyone. And that was not just member states, but also other observers, including civil society, including intergovernmental organizations. organizations, and that served two purposes. One, it allowed me to test ideas, it allowed me to outline the program so that people knew what to expect. And two, it also enabled me to hear concerns and for delegations to share their interests and their concerns in a closed setting so that I knew where the different tensions within the room were. And I have to say that It applied to everyone. It didn't matter, you didn't have to be an ambassador, you didn't have to be the legal advisor, so long as you were interested in meeting me, I was interested in meeting you. Second thing was, I also held pre-meeting briefings. Have you gone to a meeting and you look around and you see your friends and you say, "Hey, what do you think we're going to do today?" And people aren't all entirely clear. Of course, we issued the program of work, but in the lead up to the actual start of the meeting, I would hold briefings in rooms like this to share what was going on so that people could be prepared, because The IGC negotiations were undertaken in a lot of negotiating groups, the G77, the African group, the European Union. the CLAM, call Latin American states. So because of that, I wanted to give advance notice of what was going to happen so those people who needed to coordinate could actually engage in coordinations. And then also so that all delegations know what to expect from day one and we could hit the ground running without people taking the floor and asking how are we going to do this or how are we going to advance that. And the key was repetition. Actually, throughout the week, I would have shared this with individual delegates, but I wanted to put it out on the floor as well. It was to give a degree of assurance to all the delegations that I wasn't telling different groups of delegations different things. It wasn't that I was telling G77 one thing and then I was telling the European Union another thing. No, I was telling everybody the same thing, and I shared this openly so that everybody understood that. Another thing I did was to consult the Bureau extensively. I think there are some processes where the Bureau maybe has one meeting. Alas, my Bureau members had to work really hard because I kept flooding them with, you know, I kept drafting like programs of work and all these procedures and saying, how about this? And we held many online meetings, and I would go, how about this? Or shall we do that? and I would share emails with them, and then I would tell them to go consult their regional groups. And I think that this was helpful because it also was another avenue for me to test some ideas, and particularly when the bureau members consulted their groups, so that I would know whether this was an idea that could stick or not. It was also helpful if people came to me and say, "Hey, why like this?" And then I can say, well, you know, I consulted the bureau, and this was what the bureau shared with me, so this is what we did. The fourth thing maybe I'll share is to that I got a mandate to, I got a mandate to to draft text. There was a proposal very early on in the IGC to create a drafting committee, a proposal which I did not act on, because I said we would spend the four sessions of the IGC negotiating how big this drafting group committee should be. How should we choose the representatives? Who gets to be on board? How many people should be in each group? How are they going to do their work? I was like, either we do this collectively, or if you trust me enough, give me the pen. And so, of course, member states did give me the pen, except that when I tried to give it back to them and say, this is your text, they didn't want to take it back, and they kept asking me to update the text. And I think it's really about, because we had very limited time, the General Assembly only mandated four sessions at the outset, it was really, you know, we couldn't, I was very conscious not to do anything that would provoke, procedural debates, because negotiating time is very precious. So I didn't want to create any procedural debates, which was why also negotiating with, not negotiating, but consulting the Bureau was very important, because by consulting the Bureau, I could avoid some of the procedural debates. And it's also useful, I think, to also consider, so for example, when we came back after two years of suspension because of the pandemic, During that period of suspension, there was some level of intercessional work online called the High Seas Dialogue. It was an informal exchange of views, but then many delegations came to tell me I should update the text that was intended to be used as a basis for negotiation at the fourth session. That had been issued before all the lockdowns started, but I refused to update it. the text, because I said what would happen, first was that not every delegation participated in online meetings, in the online dialogues, because for some, it was, including Singapore, it was the middle of the night. And so there were delegations that did not participate. So how would you account for the views of those delegations? And had I put out a second text, it would have meant two competing texts as basis for negotiations. And that could have led to a lot of time spent on arguing which text we should use as a basis for negotiation. So I didn't do that. And it's really like, I think it's, I guess, in a way helpful that I've been a negotiator for my country too, so I can kind of more or less figure out, oh, you know, these are the questions that I would ask if this happened and I was in the shoes of a negotiator. And through it all, I tried to get an inclusive approach. As I said, in my pre-meeting consultations, I would involve observers as well. And during the IGC, I would hold separate meetings with intergovernmental organizations and civil society to understand their issues and their concerns. It doesn't mean that observers got into every room, as for those of you who are familiar with the process, you will know that I held President's Consultations, which were only open to Member States. But there were other ways in which they could be engaged in the process, including by hosting workshops and side events to educate the membership on some of the more technical issues. I also tried to encourage interactions amongst member states, not just with like-minded member states, but also with people who held different views from us. And I thought that was very important because if you can't talk to people who have different views, we're never going to get to consensus. So during the pandemic, there were suggestions that I should organize these sessions, and I refused to organize them because I said, we should all feel comfortable to reach out to each other without having some president or somebody organize the meeting for us. And I think From how the fall session went when we resume our meeting, I know that a number of delegations did reach out to have discussions. And finally, you know, just to share that I also use the text to drive the process. If you look at the text of the agreement that was first issued ahead of, and all this, by the way, you can see on the BBNJ IGC website that's maintained by Dual Law. So there are two BBNJ websites. There's one which is the BBNJ IGC website that covers all the IGC documents and processes, then now there is another BBNJ website which Dualos is running as the interim secretariat of BBNJ. When you look at the text that first appeared before the third session in 2019, you will see that there were many square brackets and there were many options, and you could imagine that there were giant square brackets around the entire text. And that was really to drive discussions. I had asked members to share their proposals with me, and actually, you know, when I printed out the proposals that I received after collation from the Secretariat, it really put my printer out of commission because there were 847 pages of proposals. I ran out of toner, and I had to ask, I was like, "Something wrong with my printer, it's not printing." And I realized to my horror, it's because there were too many pages, and I had to go and find, I had to go and buy more toner. But there were certain issues that when I thought that member states had not yet addressed, I would put them in as options as well, really to drive discussion. So that initial first text was intended to drive discussion. So to take an example, we had long conversations around the inclusion of fish in the context of marine genetic resources. But I then went to put in the text, which you can see, fish shall not be included and square bracket in this part or in this agreement, because it was a question of whether we were talking about the exclusion of fish just from the section on marine genetic resources or from the entire agreement. And I wanted Member States to discuss this issue sooner rather than later. versions of the text were intended to drive really thinking about how, you know, about these issues in order that we could have a more robust agreement. But then if you look at the text that emerged and that was presented, that I presented before the fifth session of the IGC, you will see that the text was largely clean. Not to say that we had agreed it was really clean. No brackets. There were giant brackets around the entire text, but no option one, option two, option three, except for a couple of provisions. And the reason why I didn't choose this model which I had applied in the earlier versions of the text to say option one, option two, option three, was because the fifth session, we really needed to get down to negotiating the agreement, the text of the agreement itself. And you know what will happen if you produce option one, option two, option three. One group of countries will say, I prefer to work off the basis of option one. Another group of countries will say, no, no, no, I think option two probably is more likely to be the consensus text. And if you have six options, we'll never get there because everybody will have their own preferred options. So I chose to cut out all the debates on which option we should work off and present a clean text so everyone had to engage with the text. There were a few provisions that had options. And here, the reason why I left those few provisions with options, because the mandate from the General Assembly was that we had to work everything as a package, I wanted to signal to the negotiators that these few provisions with options were very likely to be where the package was. And so, the text itself can help to drive people to consensus. So the text, whether it's of a resolution or a declaration or treaty, itself can help to coalesce the multilateral efforts into an outcome, the outcome that we seek. So those are some of the techniques that I shared. Where do we go from here? When we adopted the BBNJ agreement, I set everyone a challenge. I said I wanted the BBNJ agreement to break the record of the Paris Agreement. The Paris Agreement is on record for being the agreement with the fastest entry into force despite a very high double threshold 55 parties representing 55% of total greenhouse gas emissions, but it came into force in nine months. The UNFCCC agreement came into force in two years. Okay, so we didn't beat the record, but I think two years, particularly during this period, is still a really decent It's still a really decent outcome. It's pretty darn good. So where do we go from here? So the prep comm is currently in session down across that way in conference room four, so I don't want to say too much about the details because I don't want to prejudice any of the discussions that are going on, but I'll share some broad general thoughts. First of all, I make no bones of the fact that my ambition is for universal participation. From the very outset, I wanted to build a treaty that everybody would want to sign and be party to. Because we are dealing with the areas beyond national jurisdiction, they belong to nobody and they belong to everybody. And so I think the pursuit of universal participation is very important. What bearing does this have on the implementation of the treaty in building the processes, the procedures, the mechanisms? It's important for us to remember that we want to build this in a way that will welcome people, that people from the outside looking in will want to come in and join and say, "Oh yes, this is an agreement that we must be part of." Secondly, we must be pragmatic. The agreement is in force. We need to understand what needs to be done now to get us really going, and what will take a little bit more time, and try not to overload the entire system. So I think a central feature of the BBNG agreement is the clearing house mechanism. Building a technical platform like a clearing house mechanism is an endeavor that is going to take us a little while more. It cannot be done in a matter of months, it will take years. And I think we need to be realistic in recognizing this. And third and maybe most important is don't chase perfection. We don't have to get everything right. When we were negotiating the BBNJ agreement, so many delegations said we must future-proof this agreement. And I was very clear during the IGC that we cannot build this agreement on current science, because our knowledge of the areas beyond national jurisdiction will increase. During the IGC, nobody ever heard the term dark oxygen. Today, you can read so many articles about dark oxygen. So the systems and the mechanisms that we put in place today, the way the BBNG agreement is designed, is flexible enough to change as we know more, as we learn more, as we do more, we can adjust. So there's no reason to chase perfection. We just need to get going. Is multilateralism still worth pursuing? And I'm aware I'm running out of time, so I'm going to tie up here. The world, as Ambassador Garfall says, is really chaotic today, and some countries appear to be disregarding what we have spent the last 80 years building. And it seems like most don't care anymore. They want to go their own way and predict a new world order. A new world order, I feel there will still be a place for international law, there will still be a place for multilateralism. Remember at the start, we said that multilateralism is collective action of at least coordinated between at least three actors. So not everybody has to be on board all at once. It's still worth pursuing because global issues demand global action. It's not to say that individual action cannot matter. Like, you know, many people know that I carry a water bottle every one. I try not to touch plastic, single-use plastic. And yes, it's true. The 6 million people who are living in Singapore, we can maybe say, "Okay, let's cut down one less plastic bottle a week, in 52 weeks, it will be six times 52. Bottles that are taken out of circulation, the demand drops. And if we take the whole world, that's many bottles out of circulation. But in and of itself, that is not enough. It's important, I don't, you know, it's important that we take on the demand side, we cut it down, but that is not enough. We still need to work together. And I think, i hope that I have shared some ways in which maybe we can possibly find a way to work together. At the end of the day, though, at the heart of it, multilateralism is about a commitment to a shared outcome. So I want to thank everyone for your attention. I'm happy to take any questions now. Thank you very much.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much, Rina, for that very, very comprehensive presentation outlining your approach to the process, your techniques, and how you handle what was a very, very complex process spanning several years, and which eventually led to a very positive outcome for all of us. So, friends, we can have some time for an interactive discussion, but to kick off the discussion, I wanted to ask you, Rina, a question. Now, it is true that in any multilateral process, it is important to be inclusive and transparent. How did you create the sense of ownership in the process? And when did you get the sense that people were really wanting an outcome? Is there anything that you can share in that regard? The reason I ask this question is that, you know, in the General Assembly here at the UN, we adopt about 350 resolutions annually. The negotiations for each of them is also a mini multilateral process. And these are not challenging. We're not always able to achieve consensus. Quite frequently, we resort to adopting decisions by vote. But in a treaty-based outcome or a treaty negotiations, of course, consensus is ideal. And I think that's what you achieved that in the BBNJ process. So back to the question. How does one create a sense of ownership? And when did you begin to get that sense that there was a strong momentum towards an outcome?

SingaporeAmbassador; President of the BBNJ IGC

Thank you for that question. I mean, how to create a sense of ownership in the process? I think really it was A few things, one was really, I think, as I shared, the consultation process that allowed people to really share their ideas and share their interests and their concerns. And I'll say that in the pre-meeting consultations before the fifth And final session of the IGC, I asked every delegation in the bilateral consultations to name me their top three items. There were five work streams, by the way, so saying three items was very deliberate, because throughout the process, I had been telling people, you're going to have to make hard choices, because you cannot have everything you ask for. And then I would get, it's interesting to see, some people could immediately name the three items are A, B, C. Others were like, oh, but there are five work streams. Could I name you like three items in each of the five work streams? I'm like, no, three items only. So, but I think that was part of that process for giving them a sense of ownership, allowing them to know at each step of the way how we were progressing, I think, maybe also contributed to a sense of ownership. And really, this is a question that should be addressed to negotiators. I will say that, of course, some people wanted the outcome sooner than others. There were some others who took a little bit more time to come on board. I think in any multilateral process, but very importantly, I think, in a multilateral process for negotiating a treaty, managing the pacing of the negotiations is also important. You can't go too fast, you can't go too slow. So I always use this analogy to negotiators. I said, some of you are acting as if this is the 100-meter dash and you are sprinting to the finish line. Others of, can you please slow down a little? Others of you are acting as if you are running in a marathon. You have 42 kilometers, so you are taking your time in getting to the finish line. But in actual fact, all of us are in the 3,000-meter steeplechase. You know the steeplechase where you have to jump over hurdles and go into water? It's like no apparently, the hardest race in athletics. I mean, all the races to me would be very difficult, but, you know, and so it was really trying to get those who were a little slower to come forward a little faster, and then those who were really fast and pushing for an outcome to maybe slow down the pace to enable others to catch up. And this is where I think that that gap between sessions when we had the lockdown was helpful because it gave people time to think. You know, because when you have meetings every two, three months, you spend a lot of time with your own internal agencies getting your own clearances and getting your bosses to sign off on all your positions, right? You don't really have time to reach out and talk to each other and really understand what is it they are trying to say, but that longer spacing really enabled, I think, people to really consider some of the issues, and it's fair to say that some positions shifted as a result for it. On voting, I would not have hesitated to call for a vote if necessary, but I really wanted to push for consensus. Why? Because in a lot of countries, you can only ratify ratify a treaty if it goes to parliament, as in many countries have parliamentary processes for ratification. Even assuming we got, what, I don't know, 120, 130 votes, and we needed a two-thirds majority, you know, parliamentarians who may not be familiar with this issue may then say, "But why should we agree to an agreement that only 100 countries voted for, and then that would have put a roadblock to my ambition for universal participation. So I really pushed very hard for consensus, and I'm very grateful to Member States for giving me the space to work on countries for consensus. Thank you.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much, Rina, for your responses. Friends, we can take some questions from the floor. I'm not sure we can take questions from online participants, but maybe from those in the room. Are there any comments or questions? Yes, please, to our friend on the right here, please.

OmanDPR

Oh. Yeah, it's on. Okay. Thank you very much, Ambassador Arena. It's been really a good platform for me to learn a lot. I was not here that, you know, I didn't have the privilege really to go through all this negotiation, but I think you did an amazing job just, you know, kind of just bringing there and just have at least the insight of what happened. And there is no question this is an amazing milestone for the marine environment to achieve, you know, this treaty. My question is, I take where you left your last point when you said we're living now in a new world, which take some country tend to take different directions. This is on one side, and on another side, it's just to look in the challenges in the area itself. Can you envisage the challenges that may arise with implementation of the treaty in the area? Thank you very much.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Can I also invite friends to introduce themselves so that everyone is familiar?

OmanDPR

My name is Adnan Alasri. I'm a DPR from Oman Mission.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you. Thank you, my brother. I think there is another question over there. Yes, please. Yeah.

ArmeniaSenior Counselor

Thank you, Ambassador. My name is Vartuhi Melikian. I'm the Senior Counselor of the Mission of Armenia. First, I wanted to thank the UNITAR and the Mission of Singapore for organizing this briefing, and I also wanted to recognize the presence of Ambassador Lee. Ambassador Lee, we all I want to acknowledge your invaluable contribution throughout the whole process. Thank you for sharing your positive and encouraging experience on multilateralism. I also wanted to echo Ambassador Goffert's words that you have were able to create this ownership through the process, and we all are privileged now having you here among us to learn from you. For those who have not been present throughout the negotiations and maybe refreshing the knowledge and experience of those who have actively participated throughout the process. Armenia is a landlocked developing country, and we have no access to the sea. We have been lacking all the expertise and knowledge in the ocean affairs for obvious reasons. We have expertise in other challenging areas. But we have signed and ratified the BBNJ agreement with the understanding and being part of the multilateralism of the basic principles that you just mentioned. And Ambassador Garfúez just noticed how important it is to be in a multilateralism and share the global vision of what we are doing. So Armenia signed and ratified with the understanding that we have to equally invest in the sustainability of our global commons. But we also acknowledge the achievement of the BBNJ agreement that the special role of landlocked countries has been recognized. In this context, I wanted to ask you, Ambassador Lee, a simple question, since you have this huge experience and reflections from the negotiation process. What would be your practical tips for landlocked developing countries? to position themselves in future discussions in the COP when we are approaching to the COPs? That would be very practical and useful. Thank you very much.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much. I think we've had two very specific questions already looking quite forward. I think they still want to take advantage of your knowledge and expertise, Rina, to prepare themselves for the implementation phase. preparation phase. So, over to you.

SingaporeAmbassador; President of the BBNJ IGC

Thank you. You know, I tried to create ownership, but I tell you, there was one point, we were having a meeting, it's probably late at night, and then I said, "Well, you know, this is your text. Take the pen." And they were like, "No, no, no, Madam President, can you update the text?" And I'm like, "It's your text now. Take back the pen." But, you know, so I I don't know. I think, again, as I say, I see a place for landlocked developing countries, for all landlocked countries, in the BBNJ agreement. So I don't know if you were at the LLDC workshop for BBNJ, so you know. I think the sustainable use of ocean resources and the access to ecosystem services in the oceans is open to everyone, not just coastal states or island states. The access to open science, which is a benefit of the agreement, and the kinds of innovations that can emerge From from the from ocean science, I think should be open to everyone and should be accessible to everyone. And you don't have to be an island nation or coastal nation to benefit from that. It was very deliberate, the example that I chose, and so for the benefit of the others, in the workshop, i gave the example that Samsung, which is a electronics manufacturer from Korea, they have launched an e-ink, electronic ink display that is made from bio resin developed or extracted from phytoplankton. We typically see science and marine genetic resources as maybe more relevant to the pharmaceutical industry or the cosmetic industry, and then we say, oh yeah, we don't really have that industry. But actually, the potential of ocean resources is a lot broader than just medicines or treatments or cosmetics. And that, I think, for those country, for all countries, we should be able to benefit from that. What are the practical tips for LLDCs? I will say between now and COP1, there are many, many, there have been many, and there will continue to be many capacity building workshops and programs. And I imagine that for landlocked developing countries, maybe there are fewer experts in your country for these areas. And so one very practical tip I can say is to take advantage of these capacity building programs. You can check in with Dualos as the interim secretariat, and that enables you to bring bring, you know, colleagues up to speed on what are the issues that are going to be discussed, and that we should have a say in order that in the future implementation of the agreement, we can see, we can play an active role as well. So I think that would be a practical tip. And of course, I always encourage dialogue, dialogue across all the different missions. There's nothing that says that you cannot engage somebody from an island state or from a coastal nation and say, "Hey, what do you think of this issue? Can you help me understand why this is a problem?" To do that. In respect of the question from Oman, what are the challenges in the area? You meant the deep seabed, or you meant the areas in areas beyond national jurisdiction? Broadly, areas beyond national jurisdiction, which also incidentally also includes the area in capital letter A and not just the high seas. I think that It actually presents scope for us to be really creative in our implementation, because these are very remote areas. Just to get to some parts of the high seas, you maybe have to sail like four days or five days in order to get there, and not many people can do that. And if we want to realize our ambition, for example, for continuous monitoring and surveillance, we have to be innovative in how we're going to do that. I think there's some discussion on satellite technology, there are other innovations, and really, i think people should also see the BBNJ agreement not as a dampener on the private sector, but really presenting opportunities and potential for innovative practices and innovations themselves. I also think that another challenge really is to, you know, this is one thing I said last year when we were beginning the prep comm process, don't re-litigate the issues that we had already resolved in the BBNJ Treaty. The PrepCom process is not a reason to go back to ancient history and start saying, "Oh, but you know, last time we said this or we said that," but to really look ahead and to be able to understand how can we advance this. This is so precious because everybody, you know, almost everybody cites the BBNJ agreement as a bright spark. So it's a precious opportunity that we shouldn't squander through, I guess, maybe not so really core issues. And that's what I meant when I said, i really wanted to give everyone a positive experience of multilateralism. It's because I want for people to take this experience and go elsewhere in negotiating resolutions or declarations, or elsewhere in the UN system and say, we can do this because it was hard. And I'll tell you, when we started the IGC, so many people told me that it couldn't be done, that we wouldn't get to a conclusion. So, but to to now have that confidence to say we can do it because we've done it before, and that five years down the road, we don't have to cite BBNJ anymore because there'll be many other examples that we can cite. And that's how we should move forward. Yeah.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much, Rina. Yes, I think we'll take another round of questions. Yes, please.

AustraliaSenior Advisor

Thank you so much, Ambassador Lee. My name is Caitlin. I'm from the Australian mission. I'm a senior advisor there. Australia is also a middle country. We are not particularly dominant, but we do strive for significant engagement and very targeted interventions to make sure that we have impact. However, the regional grouping that we negotiate in is CANS. And I like to say we're small but mighty, but we are only three countries versus, say, 27 in an EU delegation. One of my questions is for smaller regional groupings in a big negotiation. What advice do you have for making sure that our voices and priorities are heard when a co-facilitator is balancing some of these really big groupings that come with a larger number of votes to appease them?

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much. CANS, I've always thought CANS was a big grouping. Yeah, no, but it's a fair question. Yeah. Yeah, I think the gentleman there, please.

RomaniaLegal Advisor

Thank you. My name is Simion Poza from the Romanian mission, the legal advisor. First of all, thank you to our Singaporean colleagues and Ambassador Garfou and Ambassador Lee for hosting us. A very timely exercise, actually, for me, especially, although we are nearing the end of the third and final prep comm, the type of lessons that we've heard here in the room today are definitely worthwhile and can inform our process moving forward. Before, this is a slight comment to my Australian colleague. One, as a member state of the EU and having the privilege of having colleagues from Brussels heading the negotiations, which is always a plus, obviously, when you're in New York, you're kind of divided into many things. Yeah, discussing with like-minded, it's always good. And we've had very, very good results in this, apropos of how to leverage the voting quantity of some groups. But a good question. On my side, just one thing in relation to, as I said, the usefulness of having the experience and of wisdom of how this came to be. It's especially salient today in the room. We see many of the positive things gaining momentum, but also some of the more, I guess, difficult aspects of negotiations still creating difficulties in the room. But again, moving forward, from your experience in helping this come into being, what would you think would be the primary challenges in terms of decision making on establishing ABMTs? protected areas, as we will see, hopefully soon, the BBNJ coming into full play and realizing its concrete objectives. Thank you so much.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Over to you, Rina.

SingaporeAmbassador; President of the BBNJ IGC

Thank you very much. First of all, I will say CANS did not negotiate as a group in the BBNJ IGC. You came up with a group called CANZ. And CANZ was Canada, Australia, Norway, New Zealand, and Iceland. So you knew to expand the group. And towards the end, you had I can't remember what you called yourselves, all the, you know, I term them the non-allies, the countries that don't belong to big regional groupings. You all started meeting as a group and coming to me as a group. Did you call yourself the dolphins? I think you did. Yes. So, your Japans and your Koreas and the US and Switzerland all came together in a group. No, no, there were a few groups. I know for EIA, there was a group called the Whale Sharks. But I think for your group was the Dolphins. So, I mean, you may not have a formal regional group, but there is a way of finding like-minded people that cut across all these regional groups that can enable you to negotiate as a group. And I will say much, I think, to the dismay of some, that I didn't really look at the size of the group, because when you're trying to find consensus, it's not which group has the biggest number, because then the rest of us can go home, right? We just let the biggest group dictate everything. And that's not multilateralism in that context. Of course, I think the biggest groups carry weight, but I think when we are trying to find consensus, I think it's really important to hear everyone and to really appreciate and to really appreciate the different points of views, because sometimes it could be, "Oh yeah, I didn't think of that." And then, you know, it helps to sort of reframe your perspective a bit. So maybe go and revive, go and find the dolphins and figure out if, and, you know, if that can be a group. But I thought the Kenzie had revived themselves or the prep com, I could be wrong, but certainly that. In terms of the primary challenge in establishing area-based management tools, and I will say that the BBNJ agreement, as I said earlier, has many elements, and area-based management tools, including marine protected areas, is only one aspect of the BBNJ agreement. I will say don't overload the system. By which I mean, you know, let's be very focused. The first ABMT is going to be a test of process and procedure as well. And so we should bear that in mind when we are trying to put out the ABMT. But again, I will say very broadly, I think it's also important to adjust our mindset moving forward. What do I mean by that? If you were a negotiator in the IGC, you knew what were working for. We had to work towards a treaty, a treaty in which all elements of the package would be represented in a balanced fashion, if I can put it that way. But moving ahead, Maybe the prep comm, we haven't finished as many documents as we set out to do, but then there's COP1. We're not waiting 10 years for COP1. We're not even waiting 10 months for COP1. COP1 is going to come very soon. And after COP1, there's COP2, and then there's COP3. So how we approach the future and the implementation of BBNJ has to be a different mindset. That's not an end point as such, but it will be a continual iterative process to drive deep and sustained implementation of the provisions of the agreement. And that I think we will need some time to reframe our perspective, but that is where, that is the future we are moving towards.

SingaporePermanent Representative; Moderator

Thank you very much, Rina. I know that all of you are very passionate about the BBNJ, and you're already thinking forward in terms of how to get it implemented and dealing with the challenges. But I think we need to wrap up. Are there any last questions or comments before we wrap up? Good. You know Ambassador Rina, she is here. She was here all of last week. She's leaving today, New York, but she will be back very soon in June. And then she will certainly be here from September onwards. So she'll be very accessible. Do also approach the Singapore mission team if any specific questions or comments for her. And I want to take this opportunity to once again thank UNITA for helping us to organize this. Thank you very much. And my thanks also to all of you for your time and participation this morning. I wish you a pleasant day ahead. Thank you very much.

UNITAR

Thank you all. Thank you, Ambassador Gafford. Thank you, Ambassador Lee, for your engagement today and for everyone for your questions. Before we close, I would kindly ask that everyone takes a moment to complete a very brief one-question survey. This helps us record our attendance and continue to improve our programs. You can scan it by using the access code on the screen right now. Thank you very much. Thank you.