SBI 6: 7th Plenary Session
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Good morning, colleagues. I would like now to begin our session. Yes, good morning. I hope you all have had a good rest. I have to tell you that I feel very honored to be here as chair of the SBI, and I really appreciate the good climate and collaboration that we have had so far. Of course, we are lagging a little bit behind, and I will ask for your collaboration so that we can, as Assad has put it, have a very soft landing at the end of this day. So I would ask some things from you. I think that we should limit our interventions to what is really necessary. I would appreciate very much if delegations do not ask for the floor us to support something. I understand that we feel very keen about some of the issues that we deal here. It's very important for us and for our countries and our stakeholders, but we have to be very effective today. And as you all know, effectiveness is one of the items that we have on our agenda today. So, with this, I would like to first explain that you probably checked our schedule. It was foreseen that we would begin with CRP1 on planning, monitoring, reporting, and review. But I understand that there are still consultations going on, so I will shift a little bit, and I would like to start with gender. If you are not prepared with the right teams, please do so. I will give you a minute to do that. Thank you very much, colleagues. Well, as you know, when we suspended our consideration of this CRP yesterday, our distinguished colleague from Cote d'Ivoire had graciously offered, or been offered, to moderate informal consultations on elements on paragraph 3. I would like now to invite the delegate from Côte d’Ivoire to report on their progress. Côte d’Ivoire, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I would also like to thank all the parties who took part in this informal meeting, we were asked to work on paragraph 3. And so the informal group met to agree on alternative text to replace the chapeau for paragraph 3, to take into account national circumstances, priorities and capacities, following consultations with certain parties. And there are capitals. We have a text that's proposed for the chapeau, following a reference to paragraph 4 and in relation to a decision. I am now going to read out the various proposals. For the chapeau for three, it was decided to maintain the text as follows: "Taking paragraph 2 of decision 15/11, and encouraging the continuation of the implementation of the Gender Plan of Action, taking into account national circumstances, priorities, and capacities in line with section C of the framework, in particular, one, this is what we agreed to keep, and then we keep A and B. So there's then a change to three when it comes to C. We kept as follows: enhancing efforts to generate, use, and report data disaggregated by sex, age, and other demographic factors and gender indicators, where possible, in line with paragraph 4 of decision 15/11 to support the monitoring of and the evaluation of progress with the implementation of the Gender Action Plan of Action. Chair, that is what the informal group agreed on when it comes to the chapeau for 3 and then the subparagraph 3c. Thank you.
Perfect. Thank you very much, Côte d’Ivoire. I would like now to seek your agreement to what informal group has came up with. Do I have, yes, I see the Russian Federation. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair and colleagues, and distinguished colleague from Cote d'Ivoire. I just kindly ask Secretariat to read this in English because the translation from French was not exactly the words that we agreed. Thank you.
Okay, perfect. Of course, I will ask the Secretariat to read it in English. Thank you.
Thank you, madam Chair.
Three alt reads.
Reiterating paragraph 2 of decision 15/11 of 19 December 2022 and encourage.
Further implementation of the Gender Plan of Action in accordance with national circumstances, priorities, and capabilities.
In line with section C of the framework, in particular by: Then, paragraph 3C reads: Enhancing enforced to generate, use.
And report data disaggregated by sex, age, and other demographic factors and gender indicators, where possible.
In line with paragraph 4 of decision 15/11.
To support the monitoring of and evaluation of progress with the implementation of the Gender Plan of Action. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. Do I see any other comments? Can we agree on the proposed changes to paragraph 3 as a whole? I see no objection. Thank you very much. Thank you. And I understand that we had also, related to this paragraph, that we have identified the possibility of lifting some bracketed text on paragraph 4. I would like to invite the European Union to have the floor. European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and good morning, everyone.
In order to end up with a clean.
Text at COP, we are happy to stick to the original text of the CRP document.
Thank you very much, European Union. I will just ask the Secretariat to read it aloud so we are all on the same page. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. The original text reads, paragraph four, encourage parties to implement the gender plan of action in all aspects and in all scales of planning, monitoring, reporting, and review related to the.
Kunming-Montreal Global Based Framework in line with paragraph four of decision 15/6 of 19 December 2022.
And to use component indicator 23
Thank you very much, Secretariat. Thank you very much, European Union, for your collaboration. With these changes, we think that it's acceptable. Could you approve CRP2 as a rule? Yes, Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Just wanted to ask for one particular thing, as we discussed yesterday, and our distinguished Executive Secretary explained us that there will be a document for the SBI 7 with the review, with their summary. of all financially related requests to the Secretariat, we would like to be sure that it's reflected in the report of this meeting, but also We would be happy if there would be a place where we can clearly state it as a recommendation of SBI. This is not particularly in this document, but it would come again in another one. So to be sure that we have agreed and it will be happening and it's recorded. Thank you very much. And with that, we are very happy to support approving. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. The Executive Secretary and the Secretariat will provide for what you have asked. So I ask you, Cuba, yes, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. My question is in relation to paragraph 6A. Yesterday we made a proposal for the inclusion of "including developing countries." We would like that to be included in the text. Thank you. in particular, developing countries, when it comes to the implementation of the Gender Plan of Action. Thank you.
Yes, Cuba, it is recorded. Thank you very much. So I would like to see if there is any other comment. I see none. CRP2 is approved. Thank you very much for collaboration. We will produce, yes, of course. Thank you very much, our first CRP. We will produce an L document for this item. Thank you. I will now propose that we consider CRP 4 on agenda item 3B, financial mechanism. As you know, the CRP has been prepared to reflect plenary discussions that took place under agenda item 3B on financial mechanism on the first reading. As you may recall from the discussions, there was broad support for considering funding needs assessment, review of the effectiveness of the financial mechanism, and engagement with relevant financial institutions. with no support, however, for the draft guidance contained in Annex 3 of the pre-sessional document. Efforts were made to capture all the points raised and consultations were held with relevant parties on their submissions and suggested textual amendments. The SCR-P before you contains an operative section and two annexes. As two operative paragraphs are linked with the two annexes, I would propose starting with the two annexes so that no brackets are needed for these operative paragraphs. I would like to go through Annex 1 paragraph by paragraph, and I would request you to be very collaborative because this is a long document, And I know that we had several informal consultations with all the parties that have submitted suggestions. So, Annex 1, terms of reference for a full assessment of the amount of the funds. Section A, objective. I would like to see if you have any comments. I see Argentina has asked for the floor. Argentina, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Chair. I've asked for the floor, actually, before the previous document. I just wanted to ask for some clarification. Argentina interprets gender as according to the Statute of Rome, and we request that to be put in the document. We would like this clarification to be included in the report of the meeting. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Argentina. Your remark will be recorded at the report of the meeting. Thank you very much. So I would like now to invite you all to check paragraph 1. Is there any comment of annex 1? Is there any comment? I see none, so thank you very much. We'll move to paragraph 2, item B, scope. Is there any comment? I see none. Thank you very much. Part C, methodology, paragraph 3 and its sub-paragraphs. Do I see any comment on paragraph 3 as a whole? Yes, Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair, and I'll try not to be too difficult. For para 3, we would like to just see Article 20 referenced as a whole rather than specific subparagraphs of the article. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Canada. So I understand that we would delete paragraph 1, Article 20. No, I'm sorry, paragraphs 2 and 3 of Article 20 and refer it as a whole. Thank you. Can we seek agreement for this proposal? I'm only now asking for agreement to the proposal of Canada. Yes, I see there is no opposition. Thank you very much. I saw that Fiji and the United Kingdom has also requested for the floor on this item. Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madame Co-Chair. For paragraph 3B, we would like to after the word “participation” insert “including financial and logistical support for effective engagement”, just to ensure that we don’t risk adopting a language that communities cannot realistically implement if the text does not explicitly state that. So, if you are okay, I can read it in transcription speed.
Yes, thank you.
Participation, including financial and logistical support for effective engagement. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Fiji. I would like now first to ask if we can support the change proposed by Fiji. I understand it was in its submission as well. Russian Federation, are you addressing Fiji's suggestion?
No.
Okay, so I see no opposition to Fiji, so paragraph 3 is amended as suggested. Yes, I see Russian Federation. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. Just a minor thing. When we look at item C and also paragraph F, so for us, that's a key element that We work on obligations and decisions, but also national strategies. So we have two options. The preference will be to combine C and F, that it will be clearly inclusion of NBSAPs, or at least to place F right after C, that they come together and give clear impression that there are two real sources of priorities and information, the Convention itself and our national priorities.
Thank you very much, Russia. I can see the point of your suggestion. I would rather have F as a new D, so that we have a clear following up. Is that agreeable to all? Can we proceed in this line? So we are just moving up F so that there is a clear sequence. Mexico, are you intervening on this item, on this proposal?
Yes, we can go along. I was thinking that maybe we can put the word including and to merge C and F as Russia proposed, or it can be also separate. But I also wanted to, if Secretary can read again how within session of Fiji, 3B may look like. Because we know the substance, but we don't know in which place exactly that language will be inserted.
Thank you.
Of course, Mexico, and thank you very much for flexibility. I will ask the Secretariat to read the proposal by Fiji. Secretariat, after participation, I think that you can read the whole sub-paragraph. Thank you. Okay, yes. It seems that there was some confusion. Fiji, could you please read it out aloud, the whole sub-paragraph? Thank you.
Sorry, Madam Chair. I think when I walked into the room, it was CRP2, so, and the screen changed, so I was commenting on CRP2, 3B. So my sincere apologies for this.
Thank you very much, Fiji. Thank you, Mexico, for pointing this out. Okay, so, yeah, okay, CRP has been already being approved, so I will ask for indulgence on this. Okay, I'm so sorry for that. UK, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. I'm going to intervene on CRP 4. So picking up on little e under paragraph 3. It's my delegation's understanding that the mid-term review that the GEF will undertake as part of GEF-9 is a very welcome process as part of GEF-9, but we're not sure that it's going to be available in order to inform this assessment ahead of COP18. So it's my proposal to remove everything after the word "funding of projects". If it's available and such a document can inform the assessment, I'm sure it would be very helpful, but I'm not sure we should be referring to it because I don't think it's going to be quite in line with our timings.
Yes, thank you very much, UK. I understand your point. It's a good point. Can we then get along with the proposal of UK? Yes, I see no objection. So we will delete the insertion. Thank you very much, UK. Japan, you have the floor.
Sorry to intervene. We are a bit confused which paragraph are you talking about. Thanks.
I'm talking about paragraph 3, section C, methodology. And I'm talking about subparagraph. UK right now has just made a proposal that we erase everything that comes after for funding of projects on paragraph 3E on Annex 1. There is an addition. It was including its midterm review of the ninth replenishment period of the GEF Trust Fund. And I understand that the problem here is that this mid-term review will not be available for COP17. Thank you very much, Japan, for your collaboration. I see no more interventions for this paragraph. So I would like now to move to paragraph 4 in the context of the assessment. Do I have any comments on this? I see none. I'm taking paragraph four as a whole. Oh, yes, India, you have the floor.
Sorry, Madam Chair. In para three, in methodology, we would like to add as the last point, because it has to, the funding need assessment should take care into account this also, like exchange rate and the inflation volatility and the rising cost of conserving biodiversity in developing economies.
I'm sorry, India, could you please clarify where do you want to make your insertion and then repeat the whole sub-paragraph for better understanding?
Yeah, you know, it is in methodology, that is C, methodology. para 3 and as the last point, it is to be inserted.
Could you please read it?
Yeah, I will read it slowly. Exchange rate and inflation volatility and the rising cost of conserving biodiversity in developing economies.
So, as I understand, you would add this to J, other relevant estimations, including the cost of implementing the gender plan of action, inflation. Well, India, I would like to remind us all that we are really not a financial institution. We are a biodiversity environmental institution, and of course, when we estimate costs as a general approach, we take into consideration several other indicators. I think it when we talk about costs, we already embody things like inflation. Could you please be flexible? I don't know how much to include this verbatim with cost. Could you please be flexible about your?
Madam Chair, you know, this is the methodology, okay? So when various aspects are looked into, and here, you know, it is not only policy, if you see that, you know, we are adding other aspects also. So we feel, you know, keeping this will only add value to this paragraph.
Okay, thank you very much. I will ask the Secretariat to read it out loud so that we are all aware of your suggestions. Thank you.
Thank you, Chair. The paragraph now reads: "The funding needs assessment should take into account the exchange rate, inflation volatility, and the rising cost of conserving biodiversity in developing economies." Thank you.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. I would like now to give the floor to the Russian Federation. Thank you.
Thank you, Chair. It's a minor thing in 4D. We see inclusion of "unknown for us" category. We are aware of Jeff eligible countries and not eligible countries, so we don't understand what's mean and other relevant. Those will be happy to hear any example of it, what does it mean. So just delete and other relevant, because that's not existing category when we are talking about GF.
I'm sorry, Russia, where? In which subparagraph?
It's subparagraph D. The second line, saying by Global Environmental Facility eligible and other relevant. So this and other relevant to be deleted.
Yes. Thank you very much, Russia. I think that we can go along with the suggestion just made by Russian Federation on 4D, and then I think that we have move up to three. I see European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madame Chair. So if I may, I understand very much you want to finish with it quickly, but I feel we are moving a bit too fast here. So again, I wanted to come back to paragraph 3 and make a request on 3B, which currently reads, guidance provided to the financial mechanism by the COP, which may call for future financial resources and the broadening of the contributor base. Our suggestion is to insert after financial resources, which may call for future financial resources, and we would add resource mobilization decisions of the COP, which calls for the broadening of the donor base, of the contributor base. So the reasoning behind this is that we do have existing decision who call for the broadening of the donor base, and if we don't add it, We have the impression that they could be called eventually, so we want to specify that. Thank you.
Thank you very much, European Union. I ask the Secretariat to read your suggestion. Secretariat.
So the paragraph should now read: "The funding needs assessment should take into account guidance provided to the financial mechanism by the Conference of the Parties, which may call for future financial resources.
Yes, European Union, you have the floor.
And from there, and resource mobilization decision of the COP, which calls for the broadening of the contributor base.
Yes.
So the paragraph now reads, "The funding needs assessment should take into account guidance provided to the financial mechanism by the Conference of the Parties, which may call for future financial resources, and the resource mobilization decision of the Conference of the Parties, which calls for broadening of the contributor base." Thank you.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. Okay, so I would like now to call China. China, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Our comments also goes to paragraph 3, and we have a little amendments on the old C.
Sorry, O.D.
So after the information communicated to COP in national reports and by the parties.
Through the financial reporting framework, we want to add, "and other submissions, responses to surveys and interviews." Thank you.
I can read it again. "And other submissions, responses to surveys and interviews.".
Thank you very much, China. I see Canada. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. This is in response to India’s Jbis.
This is not something that we can support at this time, so we would appreciate it in brackets.
Thank you.
Thank you very much, Canada. I will insist, if we take into account the inflation and exchange rate in all parties that are developing countries, this would really increase our work. Can we live without it? I think that if there is any huge difference, it would be naturally being taken into account. Yes, you have the floor.
Madam Chair, we preferred, because when we are thinking for the long term, this is very much essential. So we prefer it to be here.
Thank you. OK, of course. Of course, thank you very much. So can we agree with paragraph 3 and the subparagraphs with the amended text by several parties, and of course, the bracket suggestion by India, as requested by one of the parties? Yes, Jamaica, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and good morning. Madam Chair, on paragraph H, re the additional private capital mobilized through blended finance, we would like to add at the very end of the sentence, taking into account challenges that may be experienced by some parties in mobilizing private capital in this regard. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you so much, Jamaica. Is there any other party who would like to make an amendment to paragraph 3? I see Fiji, you have the floor.
Madam Chair, we support Jamaica's intervention. We just would like if we could recognize that. So perhaps instead of taking into account recognizing the challenges, if that's acceptable to Jamaica. Thanks.
Jamaica, instead of taking into account, could we have recognizing? Fiji just made the suggestion to change your amendment from taking into account to recognizing. Is that acceptable to you? Yes. Okay. I will just ask the Secretariat to read it out loud so that we are all on the same page. Secretariat.
Thank you. The paragraph now reads: “The funding needs assessment should take into account additional private capital mobilized through blended finance, including through the use of non-grant instruments, recognizing the challenges that may be experienced by some parties in mobilizing private capital in this regard.” Thank you.
Jamaica, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair, and to thank Fiji as well. But, madam Chair, just to say, we say some parties, particularly LDCs and SIDS. Thank you very much, madam Chair.
Yes, thank you very much, Jamaica. Can we all agree with paragraph 3 as a whole, annex 1? Thank you very much for your collaboration. I would like now to move back to paragraph 4. Do you have... I would like to take paragraph 4 as a whole. Do you have any suggestions? I see none. I recall that we... Oh, yes, Togo, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. In 4B, the review of reports submitted by parties pursuant to article 6 and 26 of the Convention, here we also refer to protocols, but we know there are specific articles especially 33 of the Cartagena Protocol and 29 of the Nagoya Protocol, that also bring in obligations. Therefore, those parties that haven't ratified both protocols would have different obligations. Therefore, we would like another provision that specifically refers to the funding needs, pertaining to the obligations under these two protocols I've mentioned. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Togo, please clarify. If I understood you correctly, you would like a new E or D-BIS that would have the same language, but only for the protocols. Is that it? Could you please?
Yes, referring to the specific Articles 33 of the Cartagena Protocol and Article 29 of the Nagoya Protocol. Thank you.
Okay, as we have done with the Convention, 25 funding needs relate to the fulfillment of the obligations under Yes, I asked the Secretariat to read it. I think that they grasped it. Thank you.
If we understood correctly, it would now read: "Review of reports submitted by Parties pursuant to Article 6 and 26 of the Convention as well as Article 33 of the Cartagena Protocol and Article 29 of the Nagoya Protocol, to identify funding needs related to the fulfilment of their obligations under the Convention and its protocols. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. I think this is what you meant, Togo. Can I seek Approval for this amended text? I see no objection. Are there any?
That's right.
Do I see any other comments for paragraph 4 as a whole? I see none, so I would like to go to D, implementation, paragraph 5. Are there any comment? I see none. Paragraph 6, the nation of focal points, Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. We have certain issues around 5, 6, 7, 8, as they all speak about some platforms. So our issue is that we find it a bit prescriptive, in particular when we come to paragraph seven and eight, which actually tell us how to do it, what to do it, how to organize it, et cetera. So we are not in principle against. So I can probably give the feeling about all paragraphs, otherwise we will come to each. So in paragraph five, we are happy to keep it except deleting the second last line, such as a country platform. We believe it's for us to decide how we like to organize the process, whether it will be a platform or anything else. In paragraph six, we are happy here to keep platform, but then it will read So national focal points may establish a national platform, including building on existing platforms for ongoing biodiversity project. So we don't want to see a reference to a particular one. And again, I'm not sure that every single party has their own national platform of focal points for climate change. So it's really strange to see it here. But we are happy to keep the overall notion that platform can be established and that also can use the existing platforms. And then our preference is to completely delete 7 and 8. Because if in paragraph 6 we establish whatever we want, so we build it also the way we want, we don't need this prescriptive description how to organize it. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russia. I would like then to propose that we bracket 7 and 8, and I would like to seek for approval of the other changes proposed by Russian Federation. Okay. I will ask Fiji to take the floor and then Canada. Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. We equally share some concerns on the three paragraphs 5, 6, and 7. For 5, we believe that the words "should bear primary joint responsibility" could be reworded with "may coordinate as appropriate." This will also avoid creating any mandatory institutional requirement that is not contained in the Convention. For paragraph 6, on terms of national platform, I think we support Russia's proposal, and if we may, we could, in the context of every country, say: "may establish a national platform or may utilize existing national coordination mechanisms." So we could give the end or how you would suggest it. On paragraph 7, I also believe that at least twice a year is very prescriptive, because frequency requirements do create ongoing monitoring obligations beyond the Convention's reporting framework. And therefore, we could say updated periodically in accordance with national capacity.
So again, thank you very much, P.G.
I'm sorry, may I interrupt you?
Sure.
What I see that there are several parties asking for the floor, Canada, Jamaica, and India. I would like to invite Russian Federation together of those countries that have asked for the floor to convene a small group and perhaps try to find an alternative text and provide this to the Secretariat so that we don't have to spend too much time here in plenary dealing with that. Of course, any country that feels compelled to also contribute is more than invited. Could we proceed this way? Could you please ask for the floor only regarding my last suggestion? Yes, so I understand that we can proceed this way. Thank you very much. So we will park section D right now, implementation, and we move to Annex 2, terms of reference for the seventh quadrennial review. Section A, objectives, paragraph one as a whole, in accordance with paragraph three, and et cetera, do you have any comment? On paragraph 1 of Annex 2, European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madame Chasles. Indeed, we have an issue with 1b. We would like to change the second enable verb into what was originally in our submission, which is support. And he would like also to get rid of the "all" before eligible parties, which is not necessary. And I think also there is another side. We shouldn't read global environment benefits, but global environmental benefits.
OK, European Union, could you please Specify where are you suggesting this?
Okay, so 1B, do you want me to read the whole paragraph?
Yes, please.
Okay, so it would then read, "The effectiveness of the financial mechanism in providing financial resources to eligible parties to meet the full incremental cost to them of implementing measures that support, instead of enable, them to fulfill their obligation under the conventions and its protocol, and that generate global environmental, we add AL, benefits, and the rest unchanged.
Thank you very much, European Union. I think that we are clearer now. Yeah, I see the Russian Federation. Russian Federation, have the floor.
Thank you, chair. We clearly can't agree with the first change. That's, we really like to have clarity. And of course, someone like to keep maybe elephant in the room. We don't. So it's whether assessment against all and GAF and who is doing assessment should fully, openly recognize that there is discrimination, and that not all eligible parties are getting this support. So please don't hide it and try to do some games. So that's why it's all eligible parties here. And we will have problems with any financial mechanism under the Convention which will ignore this all. And it's also very strange even to hear it from anyone that there is no interest that all parties of the Convention contribute to the Convention and its implementation. So it's really pretty strange, let's say, or interesting, as some of our colleagues are saying. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I don't think that we will solve this problem right now. I would like to make a suggestion regarding those amendments. We could keep the amendments in brackets with the alternatives and bracket the whole text so that we can do it during COP. Okay? Is it acceptable to you? Yes, I see agreement in the floor. Yes. Fiji, is this about another matter? Okay, you have the floor, Fiji. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Chair. For the Pacific SIDS, we would like the following included in brackets as well in B. After taking into account the need for predictability, adequacy, and timely flow of funds, in between predictability and adequacy, the accessibility. This has been also reflected in our submission, so if we could add “accessibility” in brackets. And then in D – sorry, in F, 1F, after the deployment of resources, which is at the end of the paragraph, we would like the insertion of words “comma, including simplified procedures and excess modalities”. That was also reflected in our submission, madam. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Fiji. I will take all the amendments, perhaps. I see that there are several parties asking for the floor. Yeah. Okay, so India, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. I'm directly coming to para B. In that, you know, when we say all eligible parties, you know, we don't want to, you know, keep it as it is, so it should be elaborated. Even in the preamble also, when the preamble comes, again, we will get back to that. But here also, we want to expand it, including developing countries, in particular, least developed countries, and small island developing states, and the parties with economies in transition. So, these eligible parties to be expanded, that is my first thing in this. And, you know, the European Union, it spoke about instead of enable, it said support, but we want to, you know, have it enable only. So anyhow, the whole thing is going in bracket. So we understand that. Then in F, the Fiji's insertion, we are supporting.
Thank you very much, India. I see that we have lots of new text. And then I would like to make a proposal to you. I see that there are other parties asking for the floor. I have already asked for informal consultations in a small group, but I see that we had, we have perhaps lots of new texts being proposed. I would like to seek your support so that we can convene an informal consultation during lunchtime, so that we can receive all those new tax proposals, and then try to navigate through it. I understand this is a very long document, and I think this would probably be the most productive way to do it. I would like to invite Inka from Germany to facilitate those discussions, and the informal consultations will take place during lunchtime at a time and place that the Secretariat will facilitate before the closing of this session. And I would like to ask you to concentrate on the annexes, and time allowing also to go through the operative paragraphs. I would suggest that all the new texts could be facilitated to the Secretariat, not to be really reflected, but so that we already kind of have it. It would improve our efficiency during the informal consultations. I will ask the Secretariat to please remind us where those texts could be sent. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you very much.
As you have done with other submissions, you can just send your message to secretariat@cbd.int. So we don't need to give you a new one you cannot remember.
Just use your normal submission coordinates.
Thank you.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. I see three parties asking for the floor. I will invite Switzerland, followed by Russian Federation and PUNY. I understand this is on my proposal. So, switzerland, you have the floor.
I think, just to clarify, so basically, everything that we're looking at in this CRP will be discussed in the small group. So then I will not make my specific comment. And we end the discussion on the CRPD now here.
Yes, Svitlana, thank you very much. This was my proposal. I just asked for us to convene an informal consultation, and we, of course, what has been already discussed will not be touched, but new proposals that are being presented here in plenary, I would rather have them during the informal consultations. for the annexes and time allowing also the operative paragraph so that we can save us some time. Okay, I see Jamaica. Jamaica, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Just to say that you did say that a small group should look at section D, so I'm wondering if this other group could, so when would the small group meet as opposed to when the informal group would meet?
Yes, thank you very much, Jamaica. As I said, I had planned on conveying a small group, but I see that there are more suggestions, so perhaps we could do everything in the informal consultations. That's my proposal. So I'm changing proposals. Thank you very much, Jamaica. I think this was the point raised by Switzerland as well, so I think that we are now Okay, I see no more interventions. Thank you very much. So I would like now to ask for your support to go forward to CRP 5 on agenda item 6, capacity building, development, and technical and scientific cooperation, so that we can switch themes. As you know, This CRP has been prepared to reflect plenary discussions that took place under agenda item 6 on capacity building and development and technical and scientific cooperation. As you may recall from the discussions, there was broad support for the draft recommendation, which includes elements related to the process of identifying options, to further address the technical, technological, and institutional capability gaps identified by parties in the terms of reference for the independent evaluations of the long-term strategic framework for capacity building and development and technical and scientific cooperation mechanism. All contributions were carefully considered, and effort was made to reflect textual suggestions to the greatest extent possible. I take the opportunity to remind you that the focus of this CRP is limited to these two aspects. At SCB-7, we will consider additional elements on capacity building and development and technical and scientific cooperation that will emerge from the reviews on progress of implementation of the Long Strategic Framework and the Technical and Scientific Cooperation Mechanism. I would like now to start the consideration of this CRP. Let's start with the first paragraph. Yes, Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. For paragraph 1, after the words "capability gaps", we propose inserting "particularly for developing countries faced with significant capacity constraints".
Yes, thank you very much. I would change a little bit what I've been proposed. First, I would like to ask if we can agree on the two preamble paragraphs as a whole. Are there any comments for the preamble paragraphs? I see none. So I will ask Fiji to please repeat your suggestion for paragraph one.
For paragraph one, Madam Chair, we note the limitations in identifying capability gaps, and therefore, to speak to this, we are wanting to insert the words after capability gaps, particularly for developing countries faced with significant capacity constraints.
Thank you very much, Fiji. Are there any more suggestions for paragraph one? I see none. Can we agree with the amendments made by Fiji? I see no comments. Thank you very much. So paragraph one is approved. Thank you. as amended, paragraph 2 reiterates its request. Are there any comments for paragraph two? Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So in paragraph two, we support the continued identification of capacity building needs. However, we stress that this work must remain anchored in collaboration with the technical and scientific cooperation support centers, which are essential for contextualizing support at the regional level. Therefore, we request maintaining explicit reference to collaboration with the TSCs. and suggest expanding the sources of information used in the analysis. And after the reference to national reports and assessments, Madam Chair, we propose adding, including relevant outcomes of the mid-term review of the Gender Plan of Action, as this ensures the analysis that reflects cross-cutting implementation experience rather than creating parallel assessment tracks, Madam Chair. Thank you.
Yes, Fiji, thank you very much. I understand that this was in your first submission. Okay, could you please read out your suggestions, pointing out where they're going into the paragraph that we have before us? Thank you very much, Fiji.
Madam Chair, so we propose adding, including relevant outcomes of the mid-term review of the Gender Plan of Action.
Yes, Fiji, could you please just tell us where?
After the reference to national reports and assessments. Paragraph number two, comma, including relevant outcomes. of the mid-term review of the Gender Plan of Action.
I'm so sorry, but we can't really pinpoint where do you want to make this insertion, because we have paragraph 2, we have sub-paragraphs A to F. Where are you inserting this text, please?
Madam Judge, just give us a moment, please.
Thank you very much. Meanwhile, are there any other requests for the floor on this paragraph while Fiji is working through it? I see none. I ask for Fiji's indulgence. We will get back to this paragraph, but I would like now to move to paragraph 3 if there are any suggestions. Paragraph 3 encourages. Yes, I see the European Union. You have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. We notice that there's been a lot of additions about IPLCs, women, youth, representatives that have been added on many places, where it mainly makes the text systematically longer, where stakeholders and organizations have been in the original text. We, however, do not oppose this, but we're not sure that in the case of capacity building that we're talking about representatives. We are of the opinion that even though this is agreed text under the convention, when we're talking about capacity building and development, we're really talking about organizations, because this is not just one representative of a stakeholder group, it's really Therefore, we would like to move forward. move "subnational" in front of "indigenous people", delete "representatives" and add before "relevant organization" "other". So it would read: "encourages parties, subnational governments, indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth, and other relevant organizations." We would also like to do this in the next paragraph with the same delegation of representatives. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much, European Union. I will take more interventions from the floor, and then I ask the Secretariat to read it out loud. Russian Federation, you have the floor, followed by United Kingdom, and then we go back to Fiji. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. We are okay with the proposal of the European Union. That sounds reasonable. While we have a minor thing here, which this paragraph and some paragraphs further refer to some relevant partners. relevant stakeholders, in this case, we always have questions: are there irrelevant stakeholders? Are there irrelevant partners? Therefore, in the fourth line of this paragraph, we just suggest to read "support centers and partners", and that's clear that only relevant partners will be taken. Otherwise, we would need to define somewhere how we define the relevance. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I think that was very clear for us as to where the amendments are. I see the United Kingdom. United Kingdom, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. I can support the interventions made by the previous two speakers, but I would like to add with whenever there is a reference to subnational governments that we do agreed language, which is subnational and local government. So I would like and local added for every reference to subnational governments throughout the CRP. Thank you.
Perfect. United Kingdom, thank you for dealing with all the paragraphs. We save time this way. I acknowledge. I ask first for Canada. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And this is perhaps a clarification that the CBD Secretariat can offer quickly. On the last part of paragraph 3, it says, and to validate the assessment results. We're unclear as to what that means in terms of a process. And so we're not opposing it. We support the previous interventions. We have no opposition to what has been said thus far, but we just are hoping for some clarification as to what practically the process is that will be undertaken to validate the assessments. Is it a notification process? What can we expect? Thank you.
Secretariat, please, you have the floor.
Thank you very much. I think this was an adjustment of the original language, which was organizing multilateral consultations to validate the results of the assessments. Having looked at all the submissions that were made, some wondering how those will be organized. So we prefer to leave it general, so every party will decide how that validation process will be organized. Some might be consultative workshops, some might be through circulating the results and getting comments. So we wanted to leave it general. How the validation process is done is left up to the parties. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. Canada, with this explanation, are we okay? Thank you. Thank you very much. Fiji, are you going back to paragraph four or two? Okay, so I will ask the Secretariat to read paragraph three with the amendments. Thank you.
So paragraph three will read, encourages parties, subnational and local governments, indigenous peoples and local communities, women and youth, and other relevant organizations, including research and educational institutions, to collaborate with the technical and scientific operation support centers and partners in the assessment and analysis of capacity needs and gaps at the national and subregional levels, and to validate the assessment results.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. Are we all okay with paragraph three? I see no request for the floor. Paragraph 3 is approved as amendment, amended. Thank you very much. Fiji, we are now ready for you. Thank you. You have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Madam Chair, again, we remain flexible if parties do not agree to the new insertions. However, for paragraph 2, the clarification was around After, I think, paragraph E, we could have that inclusion of the relevant outcomes of the mid-term review of the Gender Plan of Action just before F.
So it would be a new sub-paragraph?
Yes.
Yes. Could you please read it out loud?
So the proposed EB would read as the relevant outcomes of the mid-term review of the Agenda Plan of Action.
Thank you very much, Fiji. I would now like to ask Parties, can we go along with the suggestion made by Fiji regarding the Agenda Plan of Action? United Kingdom, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And it's not an objection, it's really a question on the timing of the mid-term review of the Gender Plan of Action. Will the TSC centres have that when they are doing these assessments in this global analysis? Will that be completed in time or is actually that coming after? Would be my question.
Thank you very much, United Kingdom. I will pass to the Secretariat to answer you. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you. I think the mid-term review of the Agenda Plan of Action has been done, so we'll use the report. Yeah, thank you.
Yes, thank you very much, Secretariat. So can we accept Accept the suggestion made by Fiji? Yes, I see no objection. So thank you very much. I think that paragraph 2 is also agreed, approved. I would like now to jump to paragraph 4, encourages Parties, and I understand that we had already agreed that it would be also Parties, subnational and local governments, and then indigenous peoples, and et cetera. So, are there any comments to paragraph four? Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Just a minor amendment from Fiji is the inclusion or suggestion to replace the national biodiversity strategies and action plans with national biodiversity strategies and action plans and related commitments. So just the inclusion of related commitments to that sentence, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much, Fiji. Can we agree with the proposed amendment by Fiji? Do we see any comment? I see none. European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you. Well, we're not sure what those related commitments are, so we're not in favor of adding related commitments, because we're always talking just about the NBSAPs and the framework, so we would not be in favor to add and related commitments. We just wanted to also ask a clarification, as the Russian Federation had proposed to delete relevant before partners, I suppose that this is also the case for this paragraph. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much, European Union. I don't want to dwell. Yes, thank you very much, Fadi, for your understanding. So, paragraph 4, do I have any other comment? No. So, paragraph 4 stands as it was. Thank you very much, and it's approved. Paragraph 5. Requests, Japan, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. So on this paragraph, according to the document SBI 6/6 annex, there is a cost listed there if to implement this request associate with some cost implication. we would like to propose to insert subject to the availability of resources after informal advisory group as we submitted as the pilot modality. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, Japan. I think that was captured by the Secretariat. I will move to Russian Federation, followed by India. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. We are happy with the amendment just proposed by distinguished delegate from Japan, and we have some question, maybe you can help us here. So that's a request to do this in collaboration with the Secretariat and the Global Coordination Entity, while, according to the decision 16/3, Secretariat is acting as a coordinating entity. So in our view, this should read: "Request the Informal Advisory Group, in collaboration with the Secretariat hosting the global coordination entity in accordance with decision 16/3." And then read the text. Otherwise, if it's not like this, could you please clarify then the difference between the entity and the Secretariat? Thank you.
Yes, thank you very much, Russian Federation. I ask the Secretariat to explain. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. The Secretariat and the Global Coordination Entity are two separate institutions. They are not one and the same. The entity is hosted by the Secretariat, yes, but it's not part of the Secretariat. And in this case, the decision, draft decision is requesting both institutions to help the IAEA informal advisory group. Thank you, madam Chair.
Thank you very much. Executive Secretary, I understand that this explanation doesn't really prevent us from taking the suggestion made by Russian Federation, which can make the text clearer. So I would like perhaps to, i will first take India, and then if we see that there are any other additional text, I will ask the Secretariat to read the paragraph as amended. India, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. In third line, after capacity, language to be added, capacity needs and gaps. capacity needs and gaps, after gaps to be applied in a flexible manner, taking into account the national circumstances, priorities, and capabilities.
Yasir, could you please repeat to enable?
After capacity needs and gaps to be applied in a flexible manner, taking into account national circumstances, priorities and capabilities.
India, in dictation speed, please. Capacity, needs and gaps.
To be applied in a flexible manner, taking into account national circumstances, priorities and capabilities.
Thank you very much. India, I think that the Secretariat now have... Yes, India, if you could, please. Yes, it's paragraph 5. I understand that including a topology of capacity needs and gaps To be applied to enabling. India, could you please repeat?
To be applied in a flexible manner, to be applied in a flexible manner, taking into account national circumstances, priorities and capabilities.
Yes. Yes, thank you very much, India. I see no other requests for the floor. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And this is perhaps a clarification for a colleague from India on his latest proposal. This is a request of the Informal Advisory Group to develop assessment framework for the technical and scientific cooperation centers that are regional in some cases. It's not a national based organization. And so, to be applied in a flexible manner, taking into account national circumstances, each technical and scientific cooperation center may have many national circumstances. And so this is not a request for parties to do any work. This is a request of the IAG to provide guidance to the technical and scientific cooperation centers, and the purpose of this is to ensure that future capacity needs assessments done by these cooperation centers are harmonized. And so the purpose is perhaps to be standardized across centers, which are regional and not nationally based. So I'm questioning the appropriateness of the inclusion of India. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Canada. And given the explanation given by Canada, may I ask India if we could be flexible here?
Madam, we will be flexible.
Thank you very much, India.
Capacity needs and gaps to be added.
Yes. Yes. So I will ask the Secretariat to read out the paragraph with the amendment text. Thank you.
Request the informal advisory group, subject to the availability of resources, in collaboration with the Secretariat and the global coordination entity, to develop an assessment framework and methodology, including a.
Typology of capacity needs and gaps.
To enable the technical and scientific operation support centers to design and conduct future capacity needs assessments in a structured and harmonized manner.
I understand that the Russian Federation amendment was not captured. Russian Federation, could you please read it out loud for us?
Thank you. Thank you very much. So request the informal advisory group in collaboration with the Secretariat and the global coordination entity hosted by Secretariat, if you like. Our initial one was in collaboration with the Secretariat hosting the global coordination entity, but we are flexible, let's colleagues who are native speakers to help. And please make a reference to the decision 16/3, which explains that Secretariat is hosting this entity. Thank you very much.
Yes. Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I would suggest that we just say hosted by it as per decision. Yes. Thank you very much, Russian Federation, for your contributions. I see Fiji and Côte d'Ivoire. Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madame Kocher. And we understand that India has withdrawn its request based on the explanation of Canada. But based on the explanation of Canada and because of the regional TSCs that are doing this work, I think it's still important to recognize the differences in the institutional capacities. So we would like to, after structured and harmonized MENA, just insert three words, while recognizing differing institutional capacities. However, we also remain flexible if there's levels of discomfort on that, and we recognize what Canada said, but as a group, we thought that we should also highlight that We get limited resources in the Pacific, so to do this as well, we have differing capacities. Thank you.
Yes, Fiji, could you please repeat your suggestions while recognizing different capacities? Could you please read it?
Thank you. While recognizing differing institutional capacities.
Thank you very much, Fiji. I see Côte d’Ivoire. Côte d’Ivoire, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. Côte d’Ivoire is taking the floor just for a matter of understanding. When I read through 5, it seems to me that the framework and methodology needs to be provided to the centre. And the center then needs to develop and implement assessments. I thought we made instruments available to them for them to carry out the assessment. What exactly is it that we need to develop here, just so I can understand that? Thank you. The part that says design and conduct.
Thank you very much, Cote d'Ivoire. I understand your question. I will pass to the Secretariat to clarify. I would like just to remind us, and Fiji particularly, that when we talk about capacity needs and gaps, of course, we are taking into account different circumstances. So I would ask you to be flexible on that. I read it, and it really, we don't need this. Thank you very much, Fiji. I see the, yes, I will ask the Secretariat to please explain it to Cote d'Ivoire. Thank you.
Yes, I think the paragraph is about developing a methodology that will assist the centers when they are conducting these needs assessments in the future. So, the methodology will be developed, and then the centers will use that methodology in conducting the needs assessments. I think that's what it is about.
Yeah, thank you. You have the floor.
Thank you. Here, where it says. I think that needs to be taken out as far as the assessment goes. It gives us the impression that the centers need to design or develop something else. That's the part I don't understand.
Yes, do we see any opposition to delete designing? Design seems a little bit too prescriptive, perhaps. I see Malawi. Malawi, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madame Cochet. We just wanted to indicate that we were one of the proponents of such a paragraph. For us, this is important work, which we know that some support centers have already started undertaking. Like, for example, the SANB, which is the support center for some of our African countries, they have already undertaken this assessment. And we felt that for each and every regional center that undertakes similar assessment, we need some kind of harmonized approach for us to be at a global level able to be able to have that global analysis in a harmonized approach. So I think I just thought I could provide additional clarification as a party that has undergone an assessment by a support center, that we would also want other support centers to do the same, but we need a harmonized approach, a methodology that is agreeable, so that at global level we are able to take stock in a harmonized way. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Malawi. I see that structure in a harmonized manner are kept. I understand that the Côte d'Ivoire would like to perhaps delete design, design and conduct. I think that design, it's implied, so we really don't need it. Could we just get along with the proposal made by several parties? Here? Yeah. I will ask the Secretariat. Yes, I will just ask the Secretariat to read so that we are all on the same page. Thank you. Of course, I understand that Fiji withdraw its proposal. Yeah, thank you.
Request the Informal Advisory Group, subject to the availability of resources, in collaboration with the Secretariat and the global coordination entity hosted by it, to develop an assessment framework and methodology, including a typology of capacity needs and gaps, to enable the technical and scientific cooperation support centers to conduct future capacity needs assessments in a structured and harmonized manner.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. Just reminding us that we had also the ESPER hosted by it, as per, I didn't recall, I do not recall the relevant decision, but it's the relevant decision mentioned by Russia Federation. And I see Malta. Malta, you have the floor. Malta, it was a mistake, I understand. So Can we approve this paragraph with the amendments? Yes, I see no objection. Thank you very much for your collaboration. Now, paragraph 6 adopts the terms of reference. Okay, United Kingdom, you have the floor.
Madam Chair, it's really just a procedural issue to bracket adopts until we actually look at the annex. Thank you.
Of course. Thank you very much, UK, for reminding us that we still have to check the terms of reference. Japan, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So regarding this terms of reference for the independent evaluation, we consider it is a little bit premature to adopt the TORs because we are still expecting future major developments, including global review. So under the submission of the pilot modality, we proposed to replace, adapt with welcomes as the basis of the future consideration and refinement. However, if most of the parties are supportive of adopting this TOR, we like to propose to adapt this, the TORs as a temporary basis and to revisit the TORs for the future refinement. So our proposal is to insert on a temporary basis after adopts, and at the very end of the paragraph, to add and amend them as necessary in light of any future developments, including the results of the global review. Thank you.
Okay, Japan. I would rather have adopts/welcomes on brackets, and then we move along. And if necessary, I ask you to send your text to the Secretariat so we can revisit. Ah, okay, no, no, they got it. Okay, so, but let's pause for a moment because we still have the terms of reference to review. Thank you. Yes, and the Secretariat is reminding me that, of course, we should specify when it would be revisited, at which COP, at which, yeah, thank you. I have, while you think about it, I have Canada, European Union. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. As this is a COP17 decision, we will, at the point in time where we're adopting the terms of reference for the independent evaluation, we will have the results of the global review and global report. And so I question whether, unless there are other future developments that I haven't foreseen, but I think welcoming the terms of reference doesn't actually action them. We have to adopt them procedurally in order for them to be enacted and then for that work to be able to move forward. And so I'm happy with obviously keeping adopts within brackets. until we've, you know, discussed the terms of reference in more detail, but just temporally speak or sequentially speaking, when it comes time for us to actually adopt the decision at COP, we will have adopted the global review and the global report, presumably. They will happen at the same time.
Yes, I see nodding at the plenary. Japan, could we leave just with adopts and then welcomes, and then we go back to it.
Thank you very much, madam Chair. We are fine with that. And regarding your question, I think this independent review will be conducted 2029, and I think COP18 should be also not too late. I mean, we cannot pre-exempt something happen in the future. We never know we will have something coronavirus or something like that. I didn't mean that. So, no, no, but we are very flexible about that.
Okay, we'll get back to this paragraph. I would like only to give the floor to the European Union. Please, I would like to hear from you as well. European Union, you have the floor.
No, thank you, Madam Chair. I just wanted to adhere what Canada has mentioned. And it clearly mentioned also in decision 16/3 that we should adopt terms of references, and I think we should not postpone things which we can do and then say we should go back at least, then we'll never end discussions and we'll sit here in Rome and maybe we'll leave now without a coronavirus. Not as the last time that we were here for something which wasn't a COP. So we would prefer to just have adopt/welcome for the time being. Thank you.
Thank you very much, European Union. So thank you very much. So we park paragraph 6 with welcomes and adopts. And 7, I would like to take 7 as a whole. I will be bold. Yes, I see the Russian Federation followed by the European Union. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Here we have similar concerns as in the gender document, as this is the request to Executive Secretary subject of availability of resources. So we are flexible to Not to suggest the brackets here, but please reflect that this has to be referred in the assessment of the resources needed. And this is a recommendation of SBI 6, that at SBI 7, we will review all the requests and take decision which to support and which not. And then as you have asked for the whole paragraph now, We have some questions to sub-para A and B. Actually, we just adopted paragraph 5 above, which requests the EAJ. in collaboration with the Secretariat and the unit, the Global Coordination Unit, which hosted by the Secretariat, to develop all this assessment, et cetera. Then we adopt the terms of reference. And now, we put a question mark. If there will be no resources, does it mean that group will not be supported and that nothing will be further developed? So we would suggest to delete sub-paragraphs A and B, because we have already tasked the group to do it in coordination with the Secretariat. And now it's not a question of availability of resources. This is something we have suggested as a draft decision for the COP. So our proposal is to delete A and B. I also have comments to paragraph C, which If we would adopt this terms of reference, then again, no questions, then we need to commission the independent evaluations. It's not to use terms of reference that we referred above in commissioning. It means that commission the independent evaluations referred in paragraph 6 above according to the TOR in annex to this decision. Okay, I have also the final comment to sub-paragraph D, which addresses: To further support the technical and scientific operations support centers in identifying and gaining access to predictable funding sources, including through the financial mechanism of the Convention. We think that this is not in power of, or in the mandate of Executive Secretary to raise funds using the financial mechanism of the Convention. We are perfectly okay with relevant partners here. So the suggestion is to delete "financial mechanism of the Convention" and that it would read funding sources, including through the relevant partners, and then as it is. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I will get more interventions from the floor, and then we will see how the paragraph stands. European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. I always understand that the request to the Executive Secretary are there so that we're sure that they're going to do the work that is mentioned in paragraphs above. That is why we've got paragraph 7 in this case. So we are in favour to keep all the sub-bullet points. We only would like to propose one small change in D. Exactly, because according to us, the Global Coordination Entity has been asked in their task to look for this type of funding. So that is why we would like to add after "to further support", it would be "in collaboration with the Global Coordination Entity". And then we can add if the Russian Federation wants, as mentioned in Article 16/3 if needed, but for us that's not needed. It's the task of the Global Coordination Entity to look for this type of funding, and they can also contact the financial mechanism. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much, European Union. I see Fiji. Fiji, you have the floor.
Madam Co-Chair, for para 7D, If I recall the conversations from COP 16 and into this, into the first decision that we came into SBI 6, and now with this CRP, we understand where Russia is coming from in terms of their comments on financial mechanism of the convention. But if I recall the discussions that has been happening over time, the technical and scientific cooperation support centers are not only requiring the support to identify, but also to assess the simplified access modalities. This is something that we have been speaking about for some time, or assess the access modalities of the Convention, because this is where we are thinking that the issue lies. So I guess it's It's about framing paradigm in a way that recognize the issue on hand, which is technical and scientific corporations are not supposed to only identify and gain access, but they're not even able to assess the effectiveness of exist, not the effectiveness, but assess the access modalities and whether we have the relevant financial mechanisms to be able to deliver the context-specific support that we require in our region. So, I guess for us, Pacific Seats and our 14 members, the framing of this paragraph is not closely aligned to what the discussions has been from over time. And so we seek the clarity of, and while also recognizing the perspectives of Russia and others in this, We seek clarity on how do we bring in the real problems and the challenges that we have identified. The Caribbean group has also brought this up in several interventions. We don't see that strengthening the context specific or demand driven capacity development is only the sole issue. We have very big issues on excess modalities under the convention and also outside the convention as well.
Thank you very much, Fiji. Do you have a precise proposal to frame little subparagraph D as you have envisaged?
Well, if we are suggesting a language, I don't think it's going to be capturing the essence of the message, but what we thought that the Executive Secretary can do, subject to availability of resources, is to support the technical and scientific cooperation centers in identifying and assessing the access to predictable funding sources and access modalities, and including through financial mechanism of the convention and relevant partners. So that's how we kind of saw it coming. So maybe, I guess, the comfort is whether the Executive Secretary has the mandate to help TSCs to gain access to predictable financing. I can't answer that question. I'll ask Madam Executive Secretary to answer that question, but I think this is It's kind of both like gaining access and also assessing the current modalities. Sorry, we don't have specific language, but if we had to frame this, this is how we are going to put it, identifying and assessing.
Yes, thank you very much, Fiji. I understand that. I think that accessing and It's okay, and I understand that what you really mean is that you don't want to delete the financial mechanism of the convention of this sub-paragraph. Okay, now it's more clear to me. I see that several parties are asking for the floor on this issue. I see Malawi, India, Russian Federation, and Canada. Russian Federation, given the explanation given by the European Union and, of course, also the Executive Secretariat, Could we leave with paragraphs, sub-paragraphs A and B? I think that we need this so that the Executive Secretary can do their job.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Yes, we are okay with this. We are flexible. We just wanted to make our documents less heavy and more concrete, because the paragraph five was already a decision on this, and not a conditionality of availability of resources. But if it's really needed to be repeated, we are fine with this. And also using the opportunity for sub-paragraph D, With the explanation of the European Union and inclusion of global coordinating entity, we would be okay with the reference to Decision 16/3. I'm just looking at the decision, and it would be good if the European Union would help to refer to the concrete paragraph, and then it would help us to avoid further misunderstandings for those who would read these documents and who were not participating in this discussion. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I will ask the Secretariat to look for the relevant paragraphs in the decision so that we are more clear. And while I take other interventions from the floor, Malawi, Malawi, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. For us, we wanted to support EU. And I think Russian Federation has already also gone with your proposal, so I think we are fine. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Malawi. I see other parties asking for the floor. If it's only support, I think that we had really made minor changes to this paragraph right now as we are speaking. I see, okay, I see India, Canada, and United Kingdom. India, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. After intervention of delegation from PC, Madam, just I am suggesting gaining access to predictable, adequate, new and additional financial resources. Access to predictable, adequate, new and additional financial resources, including through financial mechanism.
India. I think that this is not the time to introduce new text. I think that we should refrain from introducing new text. We don't have the time to deal with new text right now. This is framed as it was proposed, and there was no submission in the lines that you have just suggested. I see Canada and the UK. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And I'll risk everything with you here to propose a solution. We have Decision 16/3, para 25, which requests the Executive Secretary, subject to the availability of resources, to identify and facilitate. So there's additional facilitate work, which I think is what Fiji was trying to achieve. So the paragraph 25 of decision 16.3 reads, "Request the Executive Secretary, subject to the availability of resources, to identify and facilitate the mobilization of additional financial resources and technical assistance to enable the regional and subregional support centers to initiate support programs and activities in their respective set of regions as soon as possible in response to the capacity needs and priorities identified by parties. And so we could perhaps just reiterate that approved language. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Canada. I understand that This could help us, but of course, we did receive, as I have just pointed out to India, that we have received this paragraph, and it was framed that was suggested. So I think that just reiterating the paragraph perhaps would not work, but of course, I'm in your hands. I would like to give the floor to United Kingdom. United Kingdom, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and I appreciate the efforts of our Canadian colleague to try and find agreed language. I would support that approach. If that doesn't, if we don't take that approach, then I really think this paragraph should have remained as it is in the CRP. I do identify the issues that Fiji have raised, however, to ask the Executive Secretary to look at assessing how we access financial resources is quite a big task. Not that I think that she wouldn't be able to do it, I think she absolutely would, but it's a very big task, and I don't think that's appropriate. So if we could go back to the language either we had in this CRP or agreed language from COP16, we think that's a way forward. Thank you.
Thank you very much, United Kingdom. I see Russian Federation and Argentina. Russian Federation, I would suggest that we have a small group consultation. out there on this paragraph, so that perhaps we can come up with alternative language, as suggested. I would invite Fiji, Russian Federation, Canada, India, Argentina, the European Union to participate on these discussions. I think we are not so far from a solution, but it would be better not to have this discussion here in plenary, so I would propose that. And I would like to move forward to the annex on the terms of reference. Thank you very much for your collaboration, colleagues. Thank you. So that we are clear, it's an informal for the whole seven, but I understand that now we have basically, some different positions on 7D. But of course, if you have any other suggestions for 7, you can participate in the informal consultations in small group. Thank you. And I would like to ask our colleague from Canada to report back. If you could please facilitate these discussions and report back. Okay, thank you. Canada, you have the floor.
Yes, we're happy to facilitate. Is the proposal for us to pause discussions and do that now, or to come back to the group once the annex has been discussed?
If we, you could pause, no, I'm sorry. If we could continue the terms of reference and then some delegations could go out and discuss it, it would be much appreciated. But if you can't, we can do it later. Yeah.
Canada is happy to facilitate that now if others are available.
Yes. I would ask – okay, perfect. I think others are available. Thank you very much. Thank you. Oh, I’m sorry. I saw – I see Russian Federation. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
I’m sorry, we have to stay here to discuss the annex and then can do it later, but cannot do it in parallel. Thank you.
Okay. Thank you, Russian Federation. Also We have to do it later. Perhaps we could do it through e-mail. I asked the secretariat to collect the emails, so we can begin, you can begin discussions through e-mail and then convene afterwards, if it's agreeable to all. Okay. Thank you very much. So let's go to the annex terms of reference. Oh, I see South Africa is asking for the floor. South Africa, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. South Africa sponsored this text, and we're just curious why now there's a need for an informal consultation on this that also exclude parties that would have been subject to this, but also that we don't think there's necessarily a lot of divergence on the para necessarily. We listened to the comments and understood them to be enhancing the text rather than not agreeing with it. So we'll agree with the Radition Federation. We still need to be in the room to conclude the work. Thank you.
Yes, South Africa. Of course, I apologize. I did not mean to exclude anybody. I just mentioned the parties that have asked for the floor on this issue. I'm really in your hands if you want to continue discussing this, but I think that perhaps some informal consultations could help us on this. As always, every party that wants to participate is more than welcome to participate. Just a moment, I will consult with the Secretariat. Yes, thank you very much. I would then suggest that if you could please talk to each other when we finish this session for 15 minutes or so, so that we can move along with this paragraph, I have two suggestions. We can just modify the part about access and to go to facilitate, or we can make a reference to the relevant decision, and perhaps with this we can go along those lines and approve this paragraph as a whole. I would like now to Go to Annex on the terms of the reference for the independent evaluations of the relevance and effectiveness of long-term strategic framework. I would like to take the annex as a whole. I understand that there were some additions, but mainly the additions were to refer to IPOCs and other major stakeholder groups. So if you have any comment, please feel free to go through the annex, but I would not go through the annex paragraph by paragraph. I would like to take it as a whole. Thank you. I'm sorry, the Secretary also has a correction to make. Secretary, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Just a minor editorial correction and paragraph in on page, page six, paragraph nine. I think there was a repetition of women and youth in that paragraph in the seventh line, eighth line. So we'll fix that. It's an editorial mistake. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. I see the United Kingdom. United Kingdom, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. And I note in your opening of the annex that you suggested that there were additions. Within our submission, we also requested deletions of the non-exhaustive list of design and methods. Now, I know we are strapped for time, so I'm not about to go through and ask for my deletions again. Within these tours, this is a non-exhaustive list. It feels like brain dump of methodological choices, and it feels like either the IAG maybe didn't go through and double check those to see if they were relevant or even possible to do them. I note some of them are the extent of awareness or the extent that the LTSF has been taken up. These are very difficult things to measure. And so, I think it would be really good that we insert a bit of transparency into this process and that we ask the evaluators within their report to detail which methodological design and which methodological choices they have taken within this evaluation. So, I don't want to change the list because we will be here for a very long time, but within paragraph four, under the section where I think it's either in the methodology section or in section objectives and scope, the paragraph that says subject to the availability of resources, the Secretariat will commission, et cetera, et cetera. At the end of that paragraph, I would like to insert the words, the evaluation will detail its chosen design and methods of analysis in its report. I think that's quite a neat way of us being able to understand exactly how this non-exhaustive list was taken into account within those reports. I'd like to see that in paragraph 4 and then in paragraph 9, so that both of these terms of reference reflect that. Hopefully, that's amenable for the room. Thank you.
Thank you very much, United Kingdom. Could you please just repeat your suggestion? I know it's section B, methodologies and sources of information, paragraph four, the end of it, but just the phrase, the language. Thank you. And then also in paragraph nine. Yes.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So right at the end, the words as a new sentence, the evaluation will detail its chosen design and methods of analysis in its report.
Thank you very much, United Kingdom. I see Ken. I know that there are three parties that are asking for the floor, but I would like to know if there is any opposition to the UK amendment. It's not about this. Is there any opposition to the UK amendment to paragraphs 4 and 9? Russian Federation, is that about it? No. Okay. So, European Union? No. Okay. So, the amendments made by the UK, which are very neat indeed, are approved. Thank you very much. European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. As I mentioned before, when we're talking about the operational paragraphs, again, there's been representatives added of the IPLCs, women and youth. So I would like to ask the Secretariat also to take that into account for this place, again. We have some small, there's been an addition about the global information gathered. will be analyzed and disaggregated by region and subregion. We would like to add before disaggregated only a small word, also. That's all. And that's on two places, so the Secretariat can look up for the second place or we can send it in. And then there is an, and I'm scrolling very fast down to assist you, in paragraph 7i, small i, There's the wording of donors, and as far as we understand, we do not use the word donors in conventional language, so we would like to change it by funding agency, funding institutions, or whatever the Secretariat can come up with as standard language, but not the word donors. The only three tiny changes that we have in the whole annex. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much, European Union. I would like to seek your approval for the suggestions made by the European Union. I understand that the change to paragraph 4, the addition to paragraph 4, And I ask the secretary to read it out loud, and then the other paragraph is where? It's probably nine, but I don't know. Yeah.
So, paragraph four, we will be reading: Subject to the availability of resources, the Secretariat will commission an independent evaluation in 2029 in conjunction with the second global review of the framework.
No, I'm sorry. I will save us time. The suggestion from the European Union was only at the last, well, now before last sentence, to add also and also disaggregated by region or sub-region as relevant. And this is the change that they are suggesting. Thank you very much. I'm sorry for that, but we don't need to read the whole paragraph. And then in paragraph seven, the little i, they are suggesting to change donors by funding agencies. Can we get, and I understand that the same also is also being added to the other paragraph. I imagine it's paragraph 9. I will check with the European Union. Yes. So to paragraph 4, to paragraph 9, and changing donors for funding agencies, which is agreed language here. Can we get along with those changes? Yes, I see no objection, so it is approved. Thank you very much. I see the Russian Federation has asked for the floor. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. We have a minor clarification here through the text where it refers to relevant stakeholders. It should be other stakeholders. Again, as we discussed, the relevance is not defined. And the usual language is other stakeholders. So it starts in paragraph four and goes further through sub paragraphs. Just please check this, that it's reflected everywhere. Then we support the proposal of changing donors to funding agencies. And we are not quite sure where the disaggregation on region and sub-region is now mentioned, but in paragraph six. When we speak about indicators, we would like, and there is a list of indicators, we would like to specify at the end of this paragraph six, before sub-paragraphs, and present resulting data disaggregated by region and sub-region on each indicator below. We think that we are speaking about regional and sub-regional centers, and as soon as we have the whole number of organizations throughout the world, or countries of the world, it won't help us to see how the centers work. So here it's very important, and it comes again in chapter two of the annex, in paragraph 11. the same amendment and present resulting data disaggregated by region and sub-region. I believe that's all. Thank you very much.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I would like to ask the Secretariat to give us some insights about the idea of having regional and sub-regional indicators. I thought that we are measuring the KMGBF, and we have to have harmonized indicators so that we can have comparability, but of course, I'm in your hands, and I would like to ask the Secretariat Please enlighten us on this issue. Thank you.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I think this is referring to the indicators below listed in this paragraph, but of course taking into account the indicators in the monitoring framework. This particular, when you refer to indicators in this context, it's really with the indicators listed below, and these would be disaggregated by region or sub-region. That's my understanding. Thank you. Our understanding. Thank you.
Yes. And well, there are two additions. I think it's paragraph six and other paragraph. Russian Federation, could you please clarify the other paragraph?
Thank you. The other paragraph is number 11, and again, these indicators are listed in the paragraph. So it's like number of countries receiving support. This needs to be disaggregated by region and sub-region. Then it's clear for us, because if we know that 50 countries in the world are getting support, we are not sure how good or bad that could be connected to the work of the centers in the future. And the same for all these sub-paragraphs, number of successful matchmaking efforts. Globally? No, we want to have them regionally and sub-regionally. So our proposal was exactly for these two paragraphs of the annex. Thank you.
So your suggestion would go to the second on the following indicators and not alongside relevant indicators. But I will give the floor to the European Union, perhaps they can help us. European Union, you have the floor.
Yeah, thank you, madam Chair. I think in paragraph 4 and 9, we already asking to aggregate according to region. If the Russian Federation would like to specify that it's especially for 6 and 11, if I heard correctly, we could add maybe some language of there instead of adding a complete new sentence. Or we can just add something like, in particular, the point 6 and 7, paragraph 6 and 7 below in paragraph 4 and in paragraph 9. paragraph 10 and 11? I don't know the exact numbers, but would that help Russian Federation? Thank you.
Thank you very much, European Union. I see... I will give the floor to Canada. Perhaps they have also a suggestion then to Russian Federation. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. It was same point as the, you are understanding is the additions in paragraph nine and four, the global information gathered, that's all of the information, that's the data included in those indicators. So all of that information gathered as part of these processes will be analyzed and disaggregated by region or sub-region as relevant. So I'm not sure if an additional specification is needed when we're already saying that all this data will be disaggregated.
Thank you very much. Canada, Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you very much. If this refers, the paragraph four, if it refers to all the information, including these additional indicators, it is common understanding that it's like that, probably we can leave without amendments, but paragraph four says by region or sub-region as relevant. And for those particular paragraphs, we would like to see the information by region and sub-region, because it makes difference. If you take a region and then look at several parts of that region, you would see that situation is really different. We either change this for the whole text and say disaggregated by region and sub-region and without as relevant. or have the amendments in paragraph 4 and 11, oh, 6 and 11, sorry, as suggested. That's our proposal. Thank you very much for consideration.
Yes, thank you very much. I think that perhaps it's more neat and more clear for us all right now at the plenary if we just amend the two paragraphs with regional and sub-regional. So I ask the Secretariat to read it, just the relevant part, please.
So it will read, "The global information gathered will be analyzed and disaggregated by region and sub-region.".
European Union, you have the floor.
Okay, I think the Secretariat forgot the only word that I wanted to add also in before disaggregated. This is the only thing that I asked for and it was accepted, and now you leave it out. Thank you to put it back in.
Yes, indeed. So it will be amended. Thank you very much. Can we approve it as read out with the correction from the European Union? Russian Federation, you have the floor.
My apologies. Just explain, are we amending paragraph 4 now? It's amendments to 6 and 11. Okay. And with the also, it also works. Thank you very much.
OK. I think there are some mix up here. Paragraph 4 will read The global information gathered will be analyzed and also disaggregated by region or sub-region as relevant. Okay, that's one. And then we go to paragraph six. And then it begins with, in addition to, and just after the KMGBF, we will put draw on the following indicators, disaggregated by regions and subregions, proposed by the informal advisory group on technical and scientific cooperation during its third meeting. Is it agreeable, Russian Federation? You have a better language because I didn't really have written anything, but I grasp the... Okay. I ask the Russian Federation and European Union to take the floor, please.
Thank you very much for trying to do that. I think that this additional language should go after the reference to informal advisory group, because the group already drawn the following, they proposed this indicator. So at the end, after, in 2024, we suggested And present resulting data or data or results disaggregated by region and subregion on each indicator below. So again, and present resulting data disaggregated by region and subregion on each indicator below. And the same thing for the second paragraph, 11, I think. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. European Union, you have the floor. I understand that you prefer everything on paragraph 4.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I thought in my earlier intervention, I proposed to not put it in the paragraph 6 and 11, as it was already captured in paragraph 4 and 9. So that is why we changed the wording at the end of paragraph 4 to read also disaggregated by region and sub-region to avoid a new language in paragraph 6 and 11, because it's already there. So we, as Canada also mentioned, we do not need to repeat ourselves, but we're getting tired. It's almost lunchtime. So I hope this to keep it simple and not any additional language in 6 and 11, just that we can accept the changes in 4 and 9. Thank you.
Thank you very much, European Union. Russian Federation, can we leave with paragraph 4 as it is? Do you want to add, especially paragraph 6 and 11 or something, because I heard something on this matter? Yes.
A couple of moments ago, I understood that the European Union proposed to change the language in 4, that it would read, as it was just said, "disaggregated by region and sub-region." period, without "as relevant" and with a change of "or" to "and". And with that, we would be fine and don't request for additions. Thank you.
Okay, so I'm sorry, I misunderstood. Thank you very much for your collaboration. And I understand that there are no more requests for the floor on the annex on the terms of reference. We can now agree to it as a whole. Thank you very much. Annex is approved. Thank you. Oh, yes, South Africa, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. It's just a small one under paragraph two. After effectiveness, we add efficiency, coherence, sustainability, and impact.
Yes, South Africa, could you please repeat?
Under paragraph two. After line 3, under after effectiveness, we request to add efficiency, coherence, sustainability, and impact of the long-term strategic framework.
Yes, South Africa, I will ask the Secretariat to clarify on your proposal. Thank you.
Thank you, madam Chair. The mandate in this paragraph 7 of decision 16/3 really focused on assessing relevance and effectiveness of the tool. It didn't – that's the scope of the mandate in 16 – decision 16/3. Thank you.
So I will ask South Africa if it can be flexible and stay with the mandate that we have. We don't really can go beyond this. Okay, thank you. So we have already approved the annex. Thank you very much. I will consult with the Secretariat just a moment. And so I understand that we still have some pending consultations. I would like now to ask your attention to CRP 1 on agenda item 4, PMRR.
And we can come back to approve this.
Yes. Colleagues, you know that after the session last night, And in consultation with Colombia, they informed me that they prefer to reiterate a different but similar paragraph from the Secretariat in the preamble of text. The paragraph is 23C, and I hope this works for all of you. I can have the Secretariat read the text so that we are all on the same page. but I have to say that I looked at the text, and I think it captures the main message that we would like to convey. The main difference is that 23C refers to NBEs and national reports, whereas the paragraph that included yesterday only referred to NBEs. Additionally, after the session, I talked to the delegate from Iran, and my understanding is that she would propose to move her proposal to the L document on the financial mechanism. I would like to ask for Iran to confirm this understanding, and once we have that confirmation, then I assume that we can go with this proposal as the text proposed by Iran. Iran, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair, and hello, everyone.
Actually, I just want this to be heard, to be mentioned, to be taken action about.
So if you suggest another document, we can move it there.
But it should be done, something should be done about it.
And this is the SBI, Subsidiary Body of Implementation.
We have the same commitments, so we should have the same conditions.
Thank you.
Thank you very much, Irene, on your flexibility. I would like to ask the Secretariat to provide an explanation of where this text would appear in the document on the financing mechanism. And of course, I would ask the Secretariat to also read out the text and explain for us precisely where it will go. I also would like to ask the Secretariat to read the other addition that we have made, the other agreement. I hope that we can go with these changes. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Chair. So this paragraph, in consultation with the colleagues that are working on the financial mechanism document, would go to 14 bis. So if you are looking at that document, this will then become a new 14 bis, and the text would be, invites.
The JEF to facilitate financial support for eligible parties that have not yet received support for the development of the National Biodiversity Strategies and Action Plans and national targets or the preparation of national reports. This is my understanding that that was the sort of final text that was agreed with the chair and Iran.
Then I would like to come back to the preambular text, which this, as was mentioned, is a quite similar.
Paragraph that will say, recalling also in subparagraph 23C of decision 15-6, parties are encouraged to enable.
The full and effective participation and engagement of women, indigenous people, and local communities, youth, civil society organizations, academia, the private sector, and all levels of government and stakeholders.
From all other relevant sectors in all levels of development and implementation of the National Biodiversity Strategies and Action Plans, as well as in the preparation of the 7th and 8th national reports.
I also want to mention.
Since I have the floor, because many people have asked me, there are three national reports that are currently online, and those are the European Union, Uganda, and Lesotho, and there are 87 national.
Reports that are in draft stages on the Secretariat's portal.
Good news and congratulations to those that have already presented their national reports, and of course, those that are working very hard on this. I would like now to ask, I see that Iran has asked for the floor. Iran, you have the floor.
Yeah, and I want to have a text in the report of the SPI meeting, please.
Okay, Iran, no problem. Can we agree with the amendments that have been presented by the Secretariat regarding the preamble text about the participation of several different stakeholders? And of course, the, oh, and nothing else for the PMRR CRP? Okay. I see no objections, so CRP 1 is approved. Thank you very much for collaboration. We are making good progress. I will prepare an L document on this CRP, and I would like now to turn to the Secretariat to make some announcements. And let's remind us that we still have some work pending on the documents that have been reviewed today. Thank you.
Thank you very much. Should I announce that we are getting some tailwind, which is helping us to fly faster? So three things. Number one, the informal on financial mechanism will, the colleagues who are willing to participate, will meet in Red Room, which is our room on the first floor at 1:00 PM. And Ms. Inka from Germany had kindly offered to coordinate that effort, and she will report back. So 1:00 PM, Red Room, for those who are willing to meet on financial mechanism discussion. Number two, there will be a small huddle outside this area on capacity building, para 7D, just outside here, and we are grateful to our respected delegate from Canada kindly offer to report back and help with that one. Number three, you may have seen and received that a survey on the success of early modalities of submission has been sent to you. We would like to request you to please fill it up before 25th of February. It only takes like five to seven minutes, so that we can prepare a report that we will submit to the COP on your views about the early submission modalities and further improve it. Just one second.
Thank you very much. Please, colleagues, do not stand up right now. I have just been informed that we still have translation time, and I would like to take advantage of it. And perhaps, i'm so sorry, because I was informed that we would close by 12:40, but I was mistaken. So could you please direct our attention to Could you please go back to CRP 5 on agenda item 6, capacity building, development and technical and scientific cooperation? I'm so sorry. I think I didn't understand very well our projected time right now. So, just Well, first, I would ask you to please that all that you that are involved on the capacity building pending paragraph, that if you could please arrange ourselves to go outside and clean this, if possible. But now I would like to do something different and to draw our attention to CRP-6 on the functional review. It's a very small document. Few changes have been proposed. I would like to say that CRP 6 has been prepared to reflect the plenary discussions that took place under agenda item 10 on administrative and budgetary matters, functional review of the Secretariat. The Secretariat received a total of 25 submissions, including 23 from parties and two from observers. You will recall that the Executive Secretariat provided a background briefing intended to respond to the questions raised in the submissions and to address additional issues that emerged during our consideration of this agenda item. In addition, UNEP also provided contextual input, clarifying the administrative arrangements pertaining to the functioning of the Secretariat. All contributions were carefully considered. Several textual suggestions were made and have been incorporated in a streamlined manner, with a view to keeping the text concise. Where possible, multiple requests have been integrated into a single formulation that reflect the spirit of the submissions received. We will note that the CRP contains brackets around specific elements in the recommendations to the conference to the parties, of the parties. Kindly note that these are procedural brackets, reflecting the fact that the relevant elements have not yet been undertaken and therefore parties are not in a position to express a view about this at this stage. So, I would like now to open for comments on the draft text. I will take this paragraph by paragraph. I would like to start with paragraph 1. Takes note. Do we have any comment on paragraph 1? I see none, so paragraph one is approved. Thank you very much. I would like now to go to paragraph two, notes on the ongoing consultations. Are there any comments? I see none. Thank you very much. I will go to paragraph three, notes with appreciation. Canada, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. As we had submitted in our early written submission on this item, for us of paramount importance is the background.
On this item, in that.
It was requested by parties at COP 15 and again at COP 16 with the express purpose of better aligning the Secretariat with the priorities of the KMGBF and its main objective, which is the servicing of our meetings.
And in this regard, in this particular paragraph, we have a small insertion that we would like to include to better reflect that.
After, on the second line, after "Secretariat," we would propose inserting, "particularly the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework and the servicing of CBD meetings." And then it would continue. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much, Canada. I acknowledge that the Russian Federation probably also has some comment on this paragraph. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. That's not maybe a comment, it's more a question to you and Secretariat that we have a proper understanding. In our Well, maybe we make a mistake, probably. So our understanding is that all three, A, B, C, that's ongoing. None of them are completed. So just to ensure that the language is designed properly, that there is no impression that anything of it was really taken and done, that they are progressing. So maybe follow-up actions in progress or something like that, that we clearly understand that it's not completed and there is not a feeling that they are completed, right? Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. I don't see any further requests for the floor on this item. I understand that we have two amendments. I will ask the Secretariat to please read them. Thank you.
Thank you, Chair. Notes with appreciation the ongoing follow-up actions taken by the Executive Secretary, that align with the core functions and strategic priorities of the Secretariat, particularly the KMGBF and the servicing of CBD meetings, as determined by the Conference of the Parties.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. I think this captures what have been suggested here. Can we approve? I'm not sure if I had said, so the chapeau of paragraph 3, can we approve? I see no objections. It's approved. Do we have any comments to subparagraph A to C? I see none. So, oh, yes, Russian Federation, you have the floor.
In line with what we said, so maybe B should start with initiating, because our understanding that it's just at the very beginning of the process, this type of development and updates. Or maybe we are wrong.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. Argentina, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. We had made a comment in the first reading, and we also sent through some written comments with all the different points we wish to remark on here. What we don't see reflected here is our concern on the post category, if they're at management level or at the technical level. We also don't see reflected the principle of geographical representation, balanced geographical representation, which needs to be considered in the proposed restructuring initiative. Also, generally speaking, we still have several doubts on the points that we mentioned around transparency, accountability, budget allocation. and the principle of balanced geographical representation. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Argentina. I understand that those suggestions were not taken because they relate to the operation of the operational aspects and not really to the mandate for the functional review, but I will ask the Secretariat to further clarify. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. So we did reflect on the inputs and have tried to capture the elements around transparency and accountability by incorporating the spirit of those intentions. Regarding the geographic the regional and geographic representation, we didn't capture it in this element because we were talking about the Secretariat as a whole, and that would be something that would be taken up once the posts have been reviewed and we reach the point where we are dealing with recruitment aspects. So we didn't include it at this point in time.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. I will take more interventions from the floor and then we can get back to it. China, followed by Fiji. China, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair.
I heard from the Secretariat that the new amendments will be the.
Ongoing follow-up actions, which will reflect it in the chapeau, but it will not be that rational if we use ongoing follow-up actions. And then among the ABC, we use initiating, so because we cannot ongoing initiating.
So we think it's better not to mention it in the chapeau, but use initiating in all the ABC.
Thank you.
Thank you very much, China, for your very precise observation. Perhaps we could just keep what Russia has really suggested, so actions in progress instead of ongoing follow-up, because I think that the impression of Russian also was really about that the actions ourselves that they are being undertaking right now and not precisely the follow-up. I think that the follow-up is part of our mandate every year, so perhaps we should keep the actions in progress on the chapeau of three. Okay. And I see Fiji. Fiji, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair. Apologies, we were outside the room for the informals. So we just wanted to go back to para two. If that's okay, I know you have gone past it, but we were not in the room. And just in para 2, we understand that this is related to the Secretariat's budget report, and we had made a submission during our intervention that we would like to see transparency on how seeds are funded. But in this case, we are suggesting that if we could include, takes note of Secretariat's report on budget utilization, and after that, we could have a language around and invites disaggregated reporting on SIDS-related activities.
I think that perhaps you refer to paragraph one and not two, but at any rate, I think that we This would really implicate on a discussion about budget, so I would ask for your flexibility on this issue right now. And of course, it could be reflected on the report of this meeting, and then we can reassess it on SBI 7 because we will have a discussion. Okay, thank you very much for your flexibility, Fiji. And so now, we are back to paragraph 3. I will take paragraph 3 as a whole. Could we just consider that we change the ongoing follow-up to actions in progress, and we keep the initiating on paragraph B, and then we can approve this paragraph? I see no objection, so it's approved. Thank you. I would like now to take paragraph 4 as a whole. So, paragraph 4, the chapeau, A and B. Yes, Jamaica, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair. Madam Chair, we have no difficulty with 4A, except that 4A only references paragraph 3, which are the actions which have been initiated. But in later paragraphs, there is a call for the Secretariat to do the additional work. And so, if we are to send a message on the progress report to the 17th Conference of the Parties, then the additional reports or the additional actions will not be in that progress report. So, Madam Chair, I just want to be sure that paragraph three above, which are the ongoing activities or the activities in progress, as well as the additional actions that are to be taken, are also included in the progress report to COP17. So it just so happens that the paragraph comes above and not below. Thank you, Madam Chair.
Thank you very much. Jamaica, I will take the European Union while the Secretariat drafts a text for your suggestion. European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you very much, Madam Chair. We have a request for an addition in paragraph 4B.
Because we think that the information sessions should not only be focusing on the budget, but also on the actions that are listed in paragraph 3.
So the additional words would be after "to briefing parties on", it would follow with "the actions listed in paragraph 3, including", and then the rest can continue.
Thank you.
Thank you very much, European Union. I think it's very clear, your suggestion. So it would be at the final part of B, with a view to briefing parties on the actions listed in paragraph 3 and budgetary implications of D. OK. So, I was the secretariat, if you have a proposal text for the Jamaica's suggestion? I see not yet. So I would like to go to our draft decision for COP. Paragraph one, takes note. Any comments? I see none. Thank you. So paragraph 3 notes the outcome. And of course, as stated on my summary for this CRP, there are some brackets that relate to things that we have to wait until COP. So they should be here. I see none, so paragraph two is approved. I would like to take also paragraph three as a whole, 3A, B, and C. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. For paragraph three, we OK with A, as we will be appreciating initiation, and we OK with C. As it seems like compared to upper part, the analysis here is already done. So then we hope you will appreciate it. But with B, we need a clarity. We think that it needs to be updated and developed because we like to put a little bit of pressure on the Secretariat by October, they need to have it done. And I will explain why, because if it's not done, I don't know how we will work in the Budget Committee with all requests of the Secretariat for new, I believe, posts or changing post, upgrading post, et cetera. So that's why I think that we put this language this way. And that's also will signal Executive Secretary that it needs to be done by COP. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Russian Federation. So should we say on little B, the updated and developed list of job descriptions, or just get rid of the off? Yes, Executive Secretary, you have the floor.
Thank you, madam Chair, and thank you, Russian Federation. We work best under pressure.
I think that's good.
Now, I just have a question because I have a different understanding of this paragraph.
So, of course, we want to advance with the updating of job descriptions, et cetera, that are budget neutral. But if that updating were to involve a classification upward, that would have budgetary implications and would not be completed.
Before a possible approval by the Budget Committee. And hence, I find it better to have the formulation as it is.
But let's see how you see it.
Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you. Yeah, I understand this part, but we can't appreciate something which you maybe will do in the future, maybe not. So we're appreciating here only things done. No, but even square brackets, that will be, I don't remember the last day of the COP, like 30th of October. And you are talking about something what can be done after, based also on budget committee considerations. So we can't appreciate it for the future. So we only can appreciate what was done. And maybe at the point of our discussion in Yerevan, So we will have a new paragraph basically requesting to follow up on the budget decisions and, if necessary, do some additional classifications, et cetera, based on the decision of the Budget Committee. Thank you.
Okay, yes, that's fine. Okay, we can then consider that paragraph 3? I see Mexico. Mexico, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. A similar reflection to the one made by Russia, perhaps in paragraph, in the first paragraph, paragraph 1, we could add at the end, and this is a question to the Secretariat, because we could say it takes note of the report in document SBI 6/10. This is what we've done until now, but perhaps we could add "and additional actions taken at the request of SBI 6" or wording to that effect, so that COP not only takes note of the document, but also the actions that the Executive Secretariat will do between now and COP, updating this document, SBI 6/10, or creating an annex or having additional information. I think that this should be connected to what we have in paragraph one, and then we could have additional information in paragraph three. Perhaps we could add at the end of paragraph 1, "and additional actions developed as requested by SBI 6" or wording to that effect. Thank you.
Yes. Thank you very much, Mexico. Do you refer to requests made on paragraph 4? Or in a more general. Thank you. You have the floor, Mexico.
Thank you, Chair. I'm referring to amending paragraph 1, because we take note, we have the functional review that we're looking at this meeting, but it also needs to take note of the additional actions that the Executive Secretary will carry out at the request of this meeting. And I think that is then described in more detail in paragraph 4. So we're simply trying to find consistency and coherence. Of course, the conference doesn't want to just adopt a document which is already expired, document 10. We need to have an updated version. And I think that would cover everything. Thank you.
Thank you very much, Mexico. So I would like to ask the Secretariat to please read your suggestion. And yes, Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. It will read, takes note of the executive summary of the report on the external in-depth functional review of the Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity as contained in Annex 1 to the document, CBD/SBI/6/10, and views expressed by SBI 6 and actions in response to those views. or more elegantly, and the views expressed by SBI 6 and as well as additional actions taken. Apologies, Chair. The new text would be, additional actions taken at the request of SBI 6 and any activities related to the implementation of the functional review.
Yes, Secretariat.
You are lost also?
No, no, no, I'm not lost. I would only ask you to repeat your last version so that we are all more clear about what we are proposing.
And additional actions taken at the request of SBI 6.
Yes, Mexico. Okay, thank you. Russian Federation.
That’s more technical. I agree and support suggestion from Mexico and text from the Secretariat. I think that we usually will say, and additional actions are requested in SBI 6 recommendation, whatever number. So you need to refer to a document of SBI 6. Otherwise, okay, thank you.
Thank you very much, Russia Federation. I will ask the Secretariat to repeat as amended by Russia, and I see that Jamaica is also asking for the floor. Will go back to your paragraph. Okay, thank you. I have not forgotten. So I will just ask so that we can finish our recommendation to the COP. Yes, Secretariat, you have the floor.
And additional actions requested in SBI 6- and we'll insert the name of the recommend, the number of the recommendation.
Thank you very much, Secretariat. If I can ask for Jamaica's indulgence so that we can finish the conference of the parties. Okay. So I understand that with those amendments, we have approved paragraph three. Okay. Thank you very much. And I would like now to ask if there are any comments to paragraph four, request the Executive Secretary. Yes, I see. I see several requests for the floor. Okay. So, Jamaica, is this on the conference of the parties? Yes, you have the floor.
Sorry, Madam Chair, you're on paragraph four, request of the Executive Secretary. Okay, excellent. So, Madam Chair, are you taking all three items? Okay. So, in the chapeau, it says subject to the availability of resources, but it doesn't work with item C. because it doesn't have subject to availability of resources to inform the bureau of the progress. So that's one issue. The second issue, Madam Chair, is in item A, in which the other actions are going to be done in line with the approved budget. This is a concern of ours. So we would want probably before this item A, an item Well, this item A will be item B, and we want item A to say that request executive secretary to prepare and submit to, and secretary can tell me if this is okay, to the budget committee proposal and rationale for the staffing required based on the actions taken in paragraph three above. So what I'm asking, Madam Chair, is for, after the executive secretary has done her analysis of the staffing that exists, and she is saying we need this additional staff to submit a document to the budget group with the rationale for the new staffing, both number and levels, and have that to be submitted for deliberations at the meeting. Now, normally it is done, but there's no specific request to do it. And I don't want the group to not be able to cherry pick, these are my words, cherry pick which staffing levels they will fund or not fund.
Thank you very much, Jamaica. What I would like to suggest, because now we are indeed running out of time, is that we park paragraph 4 and we go back to your suggestion on the draft recommendation from SBI. I ask the Secretariat to read it out loud so that we can agree with the draft recommendation? Yes, Secretariat, please.
Thank you, Chair. It would read: To transmit the Executive Summary Report on the external in-depth functional review of the Conference of the Parties at its seventeenth meeting, and to submit a progress report on the activities listed in paragraph 3 above. and any additional activities related to the implementation of the functional review, together with proposals for adjustments in post-classifications, as well as changes that have budgetary implications, to the Conference of Parties for consideration at its seventeenth meeting.
Okay, I think that perhaps this is too much to take right now. We will go back to it in the afternoon session. I thank you very much. I will pass the floor to the Secretariat. We will resume the CRP when we begin this afternoon. Thank you so much. Thank you. Secretariat, you have the floor.
Thank you very much. So the same announcement stands. So we will be, there is informal huddle outside now. And then the informal discussion on the financial mechanism will happen in the Red Room at 1:00 PM, and we will be meet here back here at 2:30. Yes, I'm correct this time. Thank you.
Myself, the small group which was meeting for discussing capacity building 7D paragraph will be meeting now where?
Outside. Outside. In Canada. Under the leadership. Yeah. And as we mentioned that it's, we are grateful to the delegate of Canada for coordinating that work. Thank you.
Oh, and I see that Fiji wants the floor. Fiji, I'm sorry. Technician, please give the floor to Fiji. Thank you.
Sorry, Madam Co-Chair, we also would like to.
Excuse me, colleagues, can we have your attention, please? Fiji would like to take the floor. Thank you very much.
Sorry, Madame Kocher. I understand for 70, that's why we came in late. We have solved the issue on capacity building. So we've just completed that and come back in. Thanks to Canada for facilitating. But for CRP3, paragraph 6, we did not have Russia and India yesterday, so we could not complete that. So if I can ask that CRP3 On resource mobilization, paragraph 6, colleagues, can we meet in this room now before lunch? Thanks.
Thank you. I think the CRP3 will meet here now, but there is a bit of the unfinished work on the capacity building side. That's what I have been informed by my colleague. So if there is that part, so they just meet outside for a few minutes. Thank you. And UK wants to have the floor as well, probably.
Yes, I see several delegations asking for the floor. I think that we are not very clear about our instructions. Canada, you have the floor. UK, you have the floor.
Thank you, Madam Chair, and I do appreciate the efforts of Fiji. However, there is currently an informal on the financial mechanism happening right now, so our financial experts cannot be in two places at once.
Yes, thank you very much. UK, I see the European Union, you have the floor. And please, we have to acknowledge that there are no more translation and interpretation right now. European Union, you have the floor.
Thank you very much.
I had asked the floor in relation to the CRP on item 10.
Paragraph 4 of the composition.
Are we still on that, or is it now to be taken after the break? Because we're a bit confused what we're doing right now.
Thank you. I see the Russian Federation. Russian Federation, you have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. It's just to echo the fact that there is a consultation going on now in the Red Room, so please clarify when resource mobilization will be discussed, and those people need to eat.
Yes, of course, Russian Federation. I would suggest that you could meet just after the Red Room consultation, and of course, you are more than welcome to do this in the cafeteria. Thank you very much, Russian Federation. Japan, finally Japan, you have also asked for the floor.
Thank you very much, madam Chair. It is about item 4, so.
I would like to make a brief.
Perfect. Thank you, thank you, thank you, colleagues. I'm so sorry for this confusion, but we will reconvene in the afternoon at what time?
2:30.
At 2:30. I hope this gives us time to have lunch as well. Thank you.