Third Committee, 49th plenary meeting - General Assembly, 81st session
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
Okay. Colleagues, we'll start in one second. Okay. The 49th meeting of the Third Committee of the General Assembly at its 81st session is called to order. I'm sure I don't need to remind anybody that today is the last day of school. So there you are. So let's try and get out of here early. Anyway, we're open. The documentation before the committee for this meeting is listed on iGov. Let me remind delegations of the three-minute rule in relation to statements. Let me also now move to Resumption of consideration of agenda item 24A, implementation of the outcome of the World Summit for Social Development and of the 24th Special Session of the General Assembly, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C3/81/L.10/Rev.1, entitled "Implementation of the outcome of the World Social Summit for Social Development and of the 24th Special Session of the General Assembly." I can confirm that there are no budget implications arising from this resolution. I now invite the distinguished representative of Uruguay on behalf of the Group of 77 and China to make a statement. Uruguay, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honor to introduce on behalf of the Group of 77 and China the resolution entitled "Implementation of the outcome of the World Summit for Social Development and of the 21st Special Session of the General Assembly under agenda item 24 A. The resolution reaffirms the commitments undertaken through the Copenhagen Declaration and Programme of Action, as well as the outcome of the Second World Summit for Social Development in Doha. recognizing that progress towards social development has been uneven and that significant challenges remain. It reiterates the three interrelated pillars of social development, poverty eradication, full and productive employment and decent work for all, and social integration, while emphasizing the need to address inequalities, promote gender equality, and ensure access to quality education, health care, housing, and social protection, leaving no one behind. It also highlights emerging challenges and priorities, including the digital divide, the impact of new technologies and artificial intelligence, climate change, debt sustainability, and the need for adequate financing for development. Furthermore, it underscores the importance of international cooperation, capacity building, and strengthened multilateralism, while reaffirming the central role of the Commission for Social Development in following up on the Copenhagen and Doha commitments. The new paragraphs introduced this year add value to the text by placing greater emphasis on the implementation, follow-up, and institutional dimensions of the commitments undertaken through the Copenhagen and Doha Declarations, and calls for translating these commitments into concrete action through national policies, stronger partnerships, and continued monitoring of progress, including ahead of the next review process in 2031. In particular, the additions encourage the integration of social development commitments into national development plans, budgets, and institutional frameworks, and promote stronger statistical capacities and data systems to monitor progress. Finally, they introduce an important dimension of accountability and transparency by calling for information on the potential implications of UN reforms initiatives, including the UN80 initiative for the delivery of social development mandates. Before concluding, we wish to express our sincere appreciation to the delegation of Egypt, in particular to Nada and Amr, for their hard work and dedication in facilitating this resolution on behalf of the Group of 77 and China. We regret that a vote has been called and invite all delegations to support this resolution by voting in favor and by co-sponsoring. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Uruguay. As delegations will know, all current co-sponsors are identified on iGov. I now give the floor to the Secretary to invite additional co-sponsors to identify themselves. Secretary?
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/10/1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see no requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on draft resolution L/10/Rev.1, entitled “Implementation of the outcome of the World Summit for Social Development and of the twenty-fourth special session of the General Assembly.” Does any delegation wish to make a statement or an explanation of vote before the vote in connection with resolution L/10/Rev.1? I have the United States. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you, Mr. Chair. President Trump has called for the UN to finally achieve its potential and return to its core mandate of maintaining international peace and security. The United States has called a vote and will vote no on this resolution because it supports a vision that is fundamentally different from ours. This resolution seeks to subordinate national governments to UN-centered agendas, global oversight mechanisms, and top-down central planning. The United States has made clear that the 2030 agenda for sustainable development goals and the sustainable development program impinge upon state sovereignty as a soft form of global governance, and we will no longer reaffirm them as a matter of course. The United States also takes issue with reference to the right to development, which is not recognized in any core UN human rights conventions, does not have an agreed international meaning, and unlike human rights, is not recognized as a universal right held and enjoyed by individuals, which every individual may demand from his or her own government. Beyond these substantive issues, we invite member states to consider the cost of this process. How much money was spent on organizing last year's conference? What did it cost each member state to send delegates? How many hours were spent attending the conference or negotiating this resolution? What are the hourly wages of those involved? How much money and time was spent on the Secretary General's report, and to what end? Certainly, our citizens' money and our officials' time could be used more effectively and efficiently. The endless resolution, conference, report, repeat cycle this body perpetuates comes at a heavy cost to its citizens. We underscore UN General Assembly resolutions are non-binding documents that do not create rights or obligations under international law. The United States further notes that General Assembly resolutions do not change the current state of conventional or customary international law. Thank you.
Thank you, United States. In the absence of any other delegation seeking the floor, we will now commence the process of voting on the draft resolution. I remind you of rule 128, and you can indicate your voting intentions now, and I pass to the Secretary.
The Committee is now voting on draft resolution L/10/1, entitled Implementation of the outcome of the World Summit for Social Development and of the twenty-fourth special session of the General Assembly. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The voting result is in favour 176, against 3, there are no abstentions. Accordingly, draft resolution A/C3/81/L10/Rev.1 is adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or a general statement after the vote on the draft resolution? I have the Islamic Republic of Iran, Turkey, El Salvador, and Paraguay at the present time. Islamic Republic of Iran, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Islamic Republic of Iran has voted in favor of the resolution presented by Uruguay on behalf of the Group of 77 and China. While my delegation reaffirms its unwavering commitment to poverty eradication, social justice, the promotion of South-South cooperation and the removal of unilateral coercive measures and trade barriers hindering social development, we wish to place on record the following reservations and interpretative declarations regarding certain terminology and references in the text. The Islamic Republic of Iran reiterates its consistent position that the term “gender” and all its derivatives throughout this resolution refer exclusively to the two biological sexes, male and female, and rejects any non-consensual interpretations. Any references to domestic responsibilities and the empowerment of women, particularly in operative paragraphs 7, 19, and 26, shall be interpreted and implemented based on the principles of justice, equity, and the complementarity of rules within the family unit, in accordance with our national laws and religious values. Regarding provisions concerning digital technologies, internet governance, and the protection of rights online, particularly in operative paragraphs 56 and 57, as well as the engagement of non-governmental actors, my delegation maintains that regulatory frameworks for digital space and civil society participation must remain strictly subject to national legislation, public order, cultural values, and sovereign oversight. The Islamic Republic of Iran disassociates itself from any terminology, concepts, and external frameworks referenced in this text that are inconsistent with our constitution, national laws, legislation, and religious principles. I thank you.
Thank you, Iran. I pass to Turkey.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. TURKAY welcomes the adoption of the draft resolution L/10/Rev.1. However, we wish to place on record our interpretive understanding regarding the term "Indigenous peoples" and as referenced in the preambular paragraphs 40 and 52 of the draft resolution. Türkiye declares that there does not exist any group of people in its territory which could be considered as indigenous peoples, and believes that the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples refers to the exercise of self-determination in line with the UN Charter obligations regarding non-interference in the sovereignty, integrity, and political unity of states. Türkiye therefore disassociates itself from preambular paragraphs 40 and 52 of the draft resolution. I thank you.
Thank you, Türkiye. I pass to El Salvador, followed by Paraguay and Peru. El Salvador.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. As we consider the draft resolution, El Salvador would like to thank the delegations for their hard work during the negotiations and their efforts to reach consensus on the various items on the Committee's agenda. We reaffirm our commitment to the promotion and protection of all human rights and the fundamental freedoms on the basis of the inherent dignity of all people and the principle of equality and non-discrimination. Against this backdrop, we particularly attach importance to initiatives to improve people's living standards, in particular those who are the most vulnerable people in our societies. We recognize the importance of this committee's work as a forum for dialogue and international cooperation geared towards strengthening national capacities for the promotion and protection of human rights, on the basis of mutual respect, objectivity, and recognition of the priorities and particularities of each country. When it comes to the draft resolution that El Salvador co-sponsored or has supported through the vote, We wish to make clear that references should be interpreted in line with the national legal order that we have and the international obligations to which we have already signed up, and the positions that the country has already expressed in the relevant multilateral fora in line with its national priorities. With that understanding in mind, we will continue to participate constructively in this Committee’s work to promote dialogue, cooperation, and the quest for agreements that will strengthen the promotion and protection of human rights for all people. Thank you very much.
Thank you, El Salvador. I pass to Paraguay and then Peru.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Paraguay reaffirms its unwavering commitment to social development, the well-being of people, strengthening societies in terms of bringing about more equitable societies. My country has recently presented the National Development Plan, which goes up to 2050, and is a strategic document that is geared towards promoting our citizens' well-being and also the comprehensive development of the country. We recognize the efforts undertaken by Egypt as co-facilitator, as well as Uruguay for its hard work as the chair of the G77+China. particularly to Erica and Carla for their hard work during the negotiations on this document. Paraguay therefore voted in favour of this resolution, reiterating our commitment to social development, whose implementation should be guided in line with national priorities, the principles enshrined in our constitution and every state's domestic legislation. Thank you.
Thank you, Paraguay. I pass to Peru.
Thank you very much. Peru reaffirms its commitment to the promotion and protection of the human rights of all people, with equality between women and men and the elimination of all forms of discrimination and violence against women and girls. We also reaffirm our commitments to the protection of all persons from violence and discrimination, as is stipulated by our National Policy 2026-2031. First of all, Peru understands gender and its related expressions as a gender perspective, a gender approach, or including a gender perspective as referred to women and men. Peru understands these expressions as geared towards promoting gender equality in line with its national legal order. Secondly, When it comes to references to sexual and reproductive health and sexual and reproductive rights, Peru understands them within the context of the International Conference on Population and Development and the Beijing Platform of Action and in line with our national legislation. Peru understands that the expression "sexual and reproductive rights" do not have an internationally agreed definition, and we do not believe, therefore, that this creates new rights or obligations for States. In addition, guidelines on adolescents, boys and girls, should fully respect the primordial responsibility of parents in the education of children, as are enshrined in the Peruvian Constitution and the Convention on the Rights of the Child. We recall that resolutions adopted within the current session As a result of their non-binding nature, do not impose new obligations of any kind on the Peruvian state, therefore its content will be interpreted pursuant to the constitution that we have, our national legislation, and the obligations internationally that we have already assumed by the state. Lastly, Peru requests that this statement should be applicable to all draft resolutions that contain these terms and that are considered in this session, without the need to reiterate this on each occasion. Thank you.
Thank you, Peru. I have no other delegation seeking the floor, in which case that means we’ve concluded our consideration of agenda item 24 (A) and indeed item 24 as a whole. Accordingly, I now invite the Committee to resume our consideration of agenda item 59, report of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, questions relating to refugees, returnees and displaced persons, and humanitarian questions, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C/81/L.48, entitled Assistance to refugees, returnees and displaced persons in Africa. There are no budget implications associated with this resolution. I would now like to invite the distinguished representative of the Sudan, on behalf of the Group of African States, to introduce the resolution for us. Sudan, you have the floor.
Chair, thank you for giving me the floor. On behalf of the African Group, I have the honor to introduce the draft resolution A/C3/81/L.48, entitled “Assistance to refugees, returnees and displaced persons in Africa”. In introducing the draft resolution, I wish to make an oral correction to PP/10, the phrase “African Climate Risk Insurance Facility” to be replaced by the words “African Risk Capacity”.
Chair,
This year's draft resolution reflects open dialogue and constructive engagement with delegations, resulting in a broadly acceptable text. The African Group remains concerned about the continuing suffering of refugees, returnees, and displaced persons across the continent. This draft resolution calls for a comprehensive response that addresses the root causes of forced displacement strengthens protection and assistance, supports host countries and communities, and advances durable solutions for refugees, returnees, and internally displaced persons. Chair, at a time of growing needs and declining humanitarian funding, African countries and host communities continue to shoulder a disproportionate burden. The African Group Therefore, call for international solidarity and equitable burden and responsibility sharing to be translated into predictable, flexible, and multi-year financing, including support for national system and durable solution. Chair, the African group thank all delegation for their constructive engagement and call for the adoption of this draft resolution by consensus. Should a vote be requested, we urge all delegations to vote in favour. I thank you, Chair.
Thank you, Sudan. Co-sponsors are identified on the iGov site, and I now give the floor to the Secretary to invite any additional co-sponsors to identify themselves.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/48 as orally revised, Please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see Estonia, and I see no further requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on draft resolution L/48, entitled Assistance to refugees, returnees, and displaced persons in Africa, as orally revised. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or explanation of vote before the vote in connection with the draft resolution? I have a number of delegations, starting with Mali, followed by Norway, United States, and Ireland. Mali, you have the floor.
Thank you for giving me the floor.
May I know the delegation who has called for a vote?
The vote was called by the United States. Let me now give the floor to Norway.
Thank you, Chair. Norway would like to thank the African Group for its efforts in facilitating this important resolution. Norway has a long-standing commitment to the protection of refugees and internally displaced persons. We remain a strong advocate for principled humanitarian action and durable solution for people forced to flee. We therefore attach great importance to this resolution. At the same time, we would have wished for a more inclusive negotiation process with greater consideration given to proposals put forward by delegations. We remain partially concerned about OP 25, humanitarian action must be carried out in accordance with relevant international law and guided by the humanitarian principles. We regret that language that could unduly restrict humanitarian operating space. This was also reflecting our concerns several times during the negotiations. We also regret that the resolution does not fully reflect recent developments under the internal displaced agenda. Norway proposed previously agreed language aimed at strengthening UN system-wide efforts and support for international-led durable solutions. This proposal had brought cross-regional support, but was not reflected in the final text. Despite these concerns, Norway is pleased to co-sponsor this resolution and strongly supports its overall objectives. Thank you.
Thank you, Norway. United States.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. President Trump has called for the UN to finally achieve its potential and return to its core mandate of maintaining international peace and security. It needs to do less with less and do it better. To be clear, this does not mean the United States is walking away from the UN or the broader multilateral system. We are working to get the UN back to basics so it can be fit for purpose over the next 80 years. Let us speak with total candor. The United States has been the single most generous humanitarian donor to the people of Africa for decades. We have provided tens of billions of dollars in emergency food, clean water, shelter, and medical care to millions of displaced Africans. The United States will continue to provide humanitarian assistance when it serves the national interests of the American people, not because of General Assembly resolutions. What the United States will not do is rubber stamp a 10-page resolution that undermines sovereign border control, stretches the UN refugee agency far beyond its core mandate, and ignores the primary responsibility of the very governments manufacturing these crises. Let's take Sudan as an example. The brutal conflict waged by Sudan's warring factions has unleashed the largest displacement catastrophe on Earth, driving more than 10 million people from their homes, while armed belligerents target civilians and infrastructure essential to survival, starve civilians, deploy sexual violence, and restrict humanitarian access. Yet instead of this body focusing on ways to end the violence in Sudan, which only fuels further displacement, we debate texts like this which treat forced displacement as inevitable. The United States rejects any language that infringes upon our sovereign immigration, border, and asylum policies. Operative paragraph 5 calls on member states to implement the Global Compact on Refugees, while preambular paragraph 20 and operative paragraph 35 press sovereign nations to expand third-country resettlement. The United Nations rejected the Global Compact on Refugees and will not cede our sovereign authority to decide who enters our territory, under what conditions, and in what numbers. Additionally, we should avoid imposing mission creep on UNHCR so that it can return to its core statutory mandate. This resolution attempts to turn UNHCR into an all-purpose development bank, public health ministry, and climate agency, stretching its mandate across climate policy, health systems, and labor integration dilutes its focus, inflates administrative overhead, and undermines its ability to deliver basic life-saving protection to genuine refugees fleeing persecution. The United States will continue to treat humanitarian assistance as a strategic tool of foreign policy to be used solely for the purpose of advancing our national interest. We will not vote for resolutions that compromise national.
Thank you, United States. Ireland.
Thank you, Chair. I speak on behalf of the U27, as well as North Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia, Albania, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, San Marino, and the United Kingdom. We thank the Africa Group for opening this resolution for inclusive negotiations in New York this year and for its constructive engagement as a facilitator throughout the process. While we would have appreciated an earlier indication of the updated Geneva text, so that the New York negotiation process could have been more streamlined, we acknowledge positively the efforts undertaken to find common ground on such an important topic as assistance to refugees, returnees, and displaced persons in Africa. Nevertheless, we wish to express our concern that OP 25 does not align with internationally agreed language regarding humanitarian access as enshrined in the Geneva Conventions and relevant provisions of international humanitarian law. We regret that the text does not include any references on recent developments on the internal displacement agenda, which would have acknowledged the increased efforts in addressing the root causes as well as prevention, protection and improved assistance to IDPs and durable solutions for internal displacement in Africa. We would have wished to see more room for discussion on our language proposals on strengthening protection and assistance. in regions of origin and displacement, supporting the self-reliance of refugees and host communities, and creating conditions for voluntary return in safety and dignity, and sustainable reintegration. We would have welcomed reference to the need to prevent and counter the instrumentalisation of migrants and asylum seekers, which puts the persons concerned at risk and can lead to serious human rights violations. We underline the importance of international cooperation to combat trafficking in persons and smuggling of migrants in full respect of international law, including international human rights and refugee law. In supporting this resolution, we recognize the Global Compact on Refugees as a valuable framework for voluntary cooperation, one that respects national capacities, priorities, and circumstances. We, above all, recognize the importance of this resolution in addressing the protection and assistance needs of refugees, returnees, and internally displaced persons across Africa. In recognition of our shared commitment to that protection, the Member States of the European Union will vote in favor of this resolution. Thank you.
Thank you, Ireland. I have no other delegation seeking the floor, in which case we will now commence the process of voting on draft resolution L-48 as orally revised. I remind you of rule 128, and delegations are now invited to indicate their votes. I pass to the Secretary.
The Committee is now voting on draft resolution L/48, entitled Assistance to refugees, returnees and displaced persons in Africa, as orally revised. Will delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The voting results are in favour 177, against 1, with 1 abstention. Accordingly, draft resolution A/C/3/81/L.48, as orally revised, is adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or general statement following the vote on the resolution? I have the Russian Federation.
Mr. Chairman, We are grateful to the delegation of Sudan and the African Group for drafting the resolution, Assistance to refugees, returnees and displaced persons in Africa. We value the professionalism of our Sudanese colleagues, the flexibility they exhibited in leading the consultations, and the way they carefully took into consideration the concerns of all interested parties so as to make the text as balanced as possible. Russia attaches particular importance to ensuring protection for asylum seekers and refugees, as demonstrated by our large-scale humanitarian activities across many countries and regions, as well as our political efforts so as to prevent and overcome crises. Today, our delegation voted in favor of this very important document. Having said that, we do have some misgivings regarding paragraph 12 in the preamble. there is a link introduced between humanitarian assistance, development, and peacebuilding. We believe it's of principled importance to ensure mandates are clearly separated, as are the principles and purposes for UN activities in the aforementioned areas. Humanitarian assistance should be provided strictly in keeping with humanitarian principles, whereas UN development-oriented operational activities should be neutral and impartial. This work should be conducted in light of national priorities, with a key role, a leading role rather, for recipient states. The promotion of this notion of a so-called nexus should not pave the way for the politicization of humanitarian assistance and cooperation and development assistance. They should not be subjugated to the purposes of peacebuilding, nor should they be used to broaden the mandates of relevant UN entities. However, we do not call into question the need to coordinate and ensure the mutual complementarity of efforts while maintaining their independence, as per agreed language in the UN General Assembly resolution 79/226. In light of the above, the Russian Federation would like to disavow itself from the consensus on the aforementioned paragraph. I thank you for your attention.
I pass to Turkey, followed by Hungary.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We would like to thank the African Group as the penholder of the draft resolution and Sudan, which served as lead facilitator on its behalf. We also thank Kenya, Mali, and Senegal for their efforts in facilitating the negotiations. As one of the world’s largest refugee-hosting countries, we sought to contribute constructively to the negotiations, guided by our conviction that both refugees and host countries should receive the strongest possible support. Negotiations on certain paragraphs were challenging, and our concerns regarding PP7 remain. We would also have welcomed a reference to the increasing use of externalization policies and arrangements that circumvent states' obligations under international refugee law and international human rights law, or shift protection responsibilities to third countries in a manner inconsistent with international solidarity and equitable burden and responsibility sharing. We are concerned that externalization policies could undermine stability and security in African countries, many of which are already shouldering substantial burdens amid significant displacement within the continent. Nevertheless, Türkiye co-sponsored and voted in favor of this resolution, reaffirming our solidarity with refugees, returnees, and displaced persons in Africa as well as in host countries. We commend the generosity of African host countries and communities and emphasize the need for equitable burden and responsibility sharing. Sustained and predictable international support is essential to address humanitarian needs and advance durable solutions, including voluntary, safe, and dignified returns. We also underline the importance of addressing the root causes of displacement through conflict prevention, peacebuilding, and sustainable development. Particular attention should be given to the protection needs of women and children, while ensuring access to education, health care, and livelihood opportunities for displaced populations. International efforts should support national priorities and strengthen the capacities of affected countries and host communities. I thank you.
Thank you, Turkey. Hungary to be followed by Colombia.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Hungary remains deeply concerned about the continuing high number of refugees, returnees, and internally displaced persons across Africa, as well as the humanitarian challenges faced by affected populations and host communities. We therefore recognize the importance of sustained international cooperation and humanitarian assistance in addressing these challenges. Accordingly, Hungary has voted in favor of the resolution. At the same time, we wish to reiterate our long-standing position regarding the references to the Global Compact on Refugees contained in operative paragraph 4 of the resolution. Hungary did not endorse the Global Compact on Refugees and does not participate in its implementation. Consequently, we cannot associate ourselves with references to the GCR in international documents such as this just adopted resolution. In the light of the above, As in the case of previous iterations, Hungary disassociates itself from operative paragraph 4 of the resolution. We kindly request that this statement be reflected in the official records of the meeting. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Hungary. Colombia.
Mr. Chairman, Colombia would like to thank the African Group for presenting the resolution entitled “Assistance to refugees, returnees and displaced persons in Africa.” And we recognize the importance of this initiative to strengthen the response of the international community to humanitarian challenges as a result of forced displacement in Africa. Our delegation particularly welcomes the call to strengthen solidarity and international cooperation, and to support efforts by countries and communities that are hosting people to provide protection to those who most need it. We think it is critical to continue promoting comprehensive, sustainable responses based on human rights in line with international instruments. In this constructive spirit, we would like to make some interpretative clarifications with regard to some of the specific provisions of the text. First of all, on the references to the adverse effects of climate change, Colombia recognizes the importance of addressing the protection needs that people have But we would say that in line with the international instruments that are applicable here and in line with our legal order, climate change is not of itself an autonomous cause for the recognition of the status of refugee without there being other conditions also fulfilled. These clarifications are made on the understanding that the provisions of the resolution should be interpreted in line with the international obligations that each State has already signed up to. Secondly, our delegation understands that this does not mean recognizing autonomous legal categories, nor create or changing the scope of the conventional obligations that the State has already assumed. Therefore, we interpret these references in line with the principle of gender equality enshrined in Article 43 of Colombia's political constitution and the international human rights treaties that Colombia has already ratified. Lastly, Colombia reiterates its recognition to the African Group for moving forward this initiative, and we reaffirm our commitment to the principles of solidarity, international cooperation, and the protection of all refugees, returnees, and displaced persons throughout the world. Thank you.
Thank you. I have no other delegation seeking the floor, in which case that brings us to the end of our consideration of agenda item 59. We can now move to resumption of consideration of agenda item 68B, comprehensive implementation of and follow-up to the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C/3/2023. A/81/L49/Rev.1 entitled, “A global call for concrete action for the elimination of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, and the comprehensive implementation of and follow-up to the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action.” There are no programme budget implications arising from this draft resolution. I now invite the distinguished representative of Uruguay, on behalf of the G-77 and China, to make an introductory statement in relation to this resolution. Uruguay, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honor to introduce, on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, the resolution entitled "Global Call for Concrete Action for the Elimination of Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia, and Related Intolerance." and the comprehensive implementation of and follow-up to the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action under agenda item 60A/B. This resolution reflects the priority that the Group attaches to elimination of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, as well as its continued commitment to addressing all their forms and manifestations. The resolution reaffirms the central importance of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action and the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination as the main international frameworks for combating racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance. It expresses concern over the persistence and resurgence of these phenomena, including hate speech, racist extremism, structural and systemic discrimination, and violence against people of African descent, migrant, refugees, and other vulnerable groups. It also highlights the need to address historical injustice, particularly slavery, the transatlantic slave trade, colonialism, and apartheid, through reparatory justice, education, accountability, and measures to tackle their lasting consequences. The resolution further focuses on strengthening the implementation of existing commitments. and the work of relevant UN mechanisms. It addresses efforts to develop complementary standards to the Convention, reinforces the implementation of the second International Decade for People of African Descent 2026-2035, and calls for greater participation, monitoring, resources, and accountability. It also places particular emphasis on the 25th anniversary of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action, welcoming the high-level meeting of the General Assembly held in 2026 and the adoption of its political declaration, and urge Member States to use this milestone to mobilize, renew political commitment and global support for the full and effective implementation of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action. The text underscores the importance of addressing both contemporary manifestations of racism and enduring consequences of historical injustice, and reiterates the need for strengthened international cooperation, sustained political commitment, and adequate resources to ensure that our shared commitment translate into concrete action. Before concluding, we wish to express our sincere appreciation to the delegation of South Africa, in particular to Murray. for his outstanding work and dedication in facilitating this resolution on behalf of the Group of 77 and China. We regret that a vote has been called and invite all delegations to support this important resolution by voting in favour and cosponsoring. I thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Uruguay. Let me pass the Secretary to invite cosponsors for this draft resolution.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. In relation to the sponsors of draft resolution L/49, revision 1, I wish to announce that the delegations of Colombia and Honduras have withdrawn their sponsorship. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/49, revision 1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see no requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on resolution 49/1, entitled “A global call for concrete action for the elimination of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, and the comprehensive implementation of the follow-up to the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action.” Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or explanation of vote before the vote is taken? I have Brazil, followed by the United States, followed by Israel. Brazil, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Brazil thanks the delegation of South Africa for its work in facilitating this important resolution and Uruguay for its coordination on behalf of the G-77 and China. On the occasion of the 25th anniversary of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action, we believe it's time for an honest reassessment of its legacy. At no other moment in recent history has Durban been more relevant. Wherever we look, racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance continue to affect the lives of millions. In many societies, these phenomena have been normalized in public discourse and political life. In a world marked by growing political populism, widening inequalities, and the rapid dissemination of hate speech through digital platforms. These threats have become more powerful, more sophisticated, and far-reaching. The Durban process provided the most comprehensive global diagnosis of racial discrimination ever undertaken. The solutions are there. They can be found in the recommendations contained in the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action, covering a number of areas such as education, justice, employment, health, participation and equal opportunity, affirmative action, and assistance to development. What we lack is implementation. We therefore encourage all Member States to take a broader and more balanced view of the Durban process, and to also recognize the significant progress that has been achieved since 2001. For too long, discussions in this Committee have reduced Durban's political significance to a limited number of controversial issues. This has obscured the broader achievement represented by the Conference. an unprecedented global consensus on a roadmap to combat racism and related forms of discrimination, as well as a path forward to reparatory justice. Durban is a process encompassing action and permanent review. Brazil believes that discussions must continue to evolve. We would welcome that future resolutions recognize that historical and structural racial inequalities contribute to the disproportionate exposure of racialized communities to environmental degradation, pollution, biodiversity loss, and the adverse effects of climate change. Addressing the pressing challenges related to environmental racism must be part of a comprehensive anti-discrimination agenda. Mr. Chair, Durban remains not only relevant, but indispensable. Our task is not to revisit old divisions, but to strengthen our common commitment to implementation. For these reasons, Brazil encourages all members to vote in favor of this crucial resolution. I thank you.
Thank you, Brazil. United States.
Mr. Chair. In recent decades, we have witnessed a concerted push across and beyond the West to institutionalize a series of radical new ideas, ideologies, and doctrines about race, racism, history, and identity in our political and cultural institutions. The United States stands against any effort to advance this cause. As such, we cannot support this resolution. For all of its talk of justice and equality, and all of its claims to oppose racism, bigotry, and discrimination, the animating worldview behind the Durban Declaration and the flood of resolutions, frameworks, and statements that followed it represent nothing short of a sustained campaign to embed a new hierarchy into our international institutions. As we can see in the text of this resolution, the fundamental premise of this project is a virulent and unique narrative that holds Western civilization and its descendants to be the singular villain of all of world history, responsible for any and every injustice, past or present. This narrative of guilt is not just wrong on the merits. It is the precise opposite of what the proponents of these resolutions claim to be seeking to achieve. Its goal is the opposite of equality, the opposite of tolerance, and the opposite of reconciliation. It seeks to construct an exaggerated and remarkably one-sided story of the past as a foundation for the assertion of power in the present, power to stigmatize and censor the opponents of this revolution, Power to attack and undermine the institutions that stand in its way. Power to expropriate the wealth of its critics to redistribute to its patrons. Power to build a two-tiered system of citizenship, of justice, of law. Power to advance one group's interests at the direct expense of another's. We reject any efforts to advance the implementation of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action, and we call on others to join us. Furthermore, we stand in opposition to any effort at all, symbolic or otherwise, to legitimize the ideas and doctrines contained within it. The United States expects the United Nations to ensure that its documents and programming do not advance this worldview, which ultimately seeks to undermine the nations that helped found this body. For these reasons, we must vote against this resolution and urge other delegations to do the same.
Thank you, United States. I pass to Israel.
Thank you, Chair. 25 years ago, the international community gathered in Durban with a noble ambition to unite humanity in the fight against racism. What followed instead was a betrayal of that struggle. Congressman Tom Lantos, a Holocaust survivor who led the US delegation at the time, described Durban as the most sickening display of hatred against Jews he had witnessed since the Nazi era. At the NGO forum, anti-Semitic propaganda circulated openly. Copies of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion were sold. Pamphlets featuring Adolf Hitler glorified a Nazi victory and a world without Israel. Jewish human rights activists were subjected to threats and harassment. The conference's outcome document singled out the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, recasting a national and political dispute as a question of racial discrimination. This laid the foundation for the false narrative that seeks to deny the legitimacy of the Jewish state and does nothing to advance Palestinian rights or promote coexistence. Rather than confronting the antisemitism that tainted Durban from its inception, The United Nations has continued to perpetuate its legacy. Chair, Israel remains firmly committed to combating racism in all its forms. The Jewish people know, through centuries of persecution and the horrors of the Holocaust, the devastating consequences of hatred and discrimination. At a time when Jews are once again being threatened, attacked, and murdered simply because they are Jewish, The international community must stop celebrating a process so deeply compromised by antisemitism. Israel is not alone in making this demand. Just weeks ago, 49 additional member states refused to participate in the Durban 25th anniversary commemoration. We refuse to allow a noble cause that shouldn't unite humanity to be undermined by hatred and political agendas. Israel therefore calls for a vote on this draft resolution and will vote against it. We call upon all Member States committed to fight against racism to do the same. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you, Israel. I have no other delegation seeking the floor. That means we can now proceed to vote on the draft resolution L/49/Rev.1. I invite you to indicate your vote intentions in the following moment. I remind you of rule 128.
The committee is now voting on draft resolution L.49, revision one, entitled A global call for concrete action for the elimination of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, and the comprehensive implementation of and follow-up to the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The final vote is in favour 122, against 16, with 42 abstentions. Draft resolution A/C3/81/L.49 (Rev. 1) is adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or general statement following the vote that has just taken place? I have South Africa, Russian Federation, Ecuador and Ireland. Followed by New Zealand and France, and a number of other delegations. South Africa, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Due to our own history of colonialism, slavery, and apartheid, South Africa attaches great importance to this agenda item. When we combat racism and xenophobia, we facilitate more equal interactions between humans. This relates to international relations, multilateralism, and in all other daily interactions. When interactions remain unequal, we lose the essence and the original intent of human rights broadly. Addressing these challenges remains central towards the fulfilment of human rights for all.
It is for this.
Reason that we continue to play a role in supporting the coordination of the annual negotiation on this resolution. While only some of the paragraphs for this year’s iteration of the Global Call resolution were up for negotiation, there was a robust engagement on the text, highlighting the importance of this matter for most Member States. We appreciate all of the comments and suggestions provided through constructive dialogue, and we firmly believe that the final result is a balanced one, reflecting suggestions and edits from most of the participating delegations. We can all do more to combat these scourges, and the DDPA remains the blueprint to support progress in this regard. We sincerely thank all Member States who have consistently supported this resolution and the DDPA. Today's adoption highlights the ongoing need to better address these challenges. Racism in its historical and contemporary manifestations is something that we cannot afford to ignore, whitewash, or exonerate. For us to strengthen and enhance our current relations, it is essential that we address the legacy of the past. By doing so, we can better shape the present and lay a firm foundation for a more constructive, cooperative, and prosperous future. We are grateful to all Member States who have taken small or large steps in this regard towards a common path of healing and restoration that brings us closer towards the full equality, not just of Member States, but of all humans coexisting on this Earth. Thank you.
Thank you, South Africa. Russian Federation, followed by Ecuador.
Mr. Chairman, we would like to thank the delegations of South Africa and Uruguay, as well as the Group of 77 and China, for preparing this very important document. We welcome the successful adoption of the resolution, which garnered broad-based support in the international community. The Russian Federation played a direct role in the crafting of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action. We unswervingly reaffirm our commitment to the letter and the spirit of these foundational documents, which, a quarter of a century on, remain the only basis for collective efforts to eradicate racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance. This is why we joined the ranks of the co-sponsors of this resolution, the aim of which is to ensure comprehensive implementation of the Durban commitments and to preclude the politicized revision thereof. We are compelled to note that not all states share in this approach. This was clearly demonstrated by the outcome of today's vote, which once again spotlighted the hypocrisy of neo-colonial powers and their satellites. The so-called collective West is consistently obstructing any initiatives launched by the global majority aimed at fixing historical injustice, overcoming the impacts of colonialism, including all forms of racial discrimination, and at ensuring equal development for all of the world's regions. We see this trend year in, year out, when there's a vote on the Russian initiative on the fight against the glorification of Nazism, which we see as making a significant addition to the document adopted today, the G-77 and China document. Mr. Chairman, it's clear that racism, xenophobia, and neocolonial practices cannot be overcome in one fell swoop. To achieve this, we need not selective rhetoric, but genuine political will and consistent implementation of the decisions that have been agreed. Therefore, we call on those states which today decided to remain on the sidelines or to vote against, we call on them to eschew double standards and to express a willingness to combat in practice any manifestations of racial discrimination or intolerance. I thank you.
Thank you, Russian Federation. Ecuador, followed by Ireland.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Ecuador would like to thank South Africa as facilitator of the negotiations and also Uruguay, as the Chair of the G-77 and China, for presenting this resolution and the efforts they made during the negotiations. Ecuador voted in favour of this resolution in line with its staunch commitment to the promotion of equality and eliminating all forms of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance. We also reaffirmed that no person should be subject to discrimination as a result of their race or other factors, and that the international community should redouble efforts to support states in combating these practices, protecting victims, and ensuring the full exercise of human rights without any kind of exception. However, Ecuador wishes to express its dissociation from paragraph 52 of the resolution, which refers to the political declaration of the high-level meeting of the General Assembly, which commemorates the 25th anniversary of the adoption of the DDPA. This political declaration was not adopted by consensus, and Ecuador, together with many other countries, abstained in that vote. Hence, the vote in favor of this resolution should not be interpreted as a support to that declaration. We reaffirm our commitments to combat any form of discrimination, to promote equality, and to promote human dignity, pursuant to the universal principles of human rights and our international obligations. We request that this statement be reflected in the minutes of this meeting. Thank you.
Thank you. Ecuador, Ireland, followed by New Zealand.
Thank you, Chair. I speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states: North Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia, Albania, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Ukraine, and San Marino line with this statement. When we speak of the elimination of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance, we all agree: there is no place for this kind of hatred in any Member State of the United Nations. And yet, no country or region is free of them, so we have an obligation to work together to eradicate them from our societies. The EU remains fully committed to this work. This is why the EU has invested so much in its anti-racism strategy 26 to 2030, and why on the 2nd of October, EU ministers agreed to renew their efforts to combat racism, antisemitism, and related forms of hatred and discrimination through a range of specific commitments. In the same way, here at the United Nations, we look to build agreement and understanding on the ways that racism in all its forms can be tackled in a comprehensive way. This requires effective measures at national, regional and international levels. Underpinning this work is agreement on the need to ratify and implement the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, which is the universal foundation for efforts to prevent, combat and eradicate racism. This is the common ground on which the European Union seeks to build a shared sense of understanding. Whatever our differences, they are secondary to our collective responsibility to build consensus rather than to entrench differences. Progress in this regard varies. It is dependent on the will and efforts of all UN Member States. This year’s decision not to open certain clusters of the text limited the potential for overdue updates. In light of this vote, we hope for earlier and fuller consultations in future, in the spirit of this Committee. Thank you.
Thank you. Ireland, New Zealand, followed by France.
Thank you, Chair. New Zealand has abstained on this resolution as per our.
Longstanding position on texts that relate to the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action. Racism in all its forms is abhorrent and unacceptable. New Zealand is fully committed to combating racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance.
New Zealand.
Supports dialogue by affirming the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination as the basis for all.
Efforts to prevent, combat, and eradicate racism in all its forms. I thank you.
Thank you, New Zealand. France, followed by Colombia.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. France reasserts its unswerving commitment and our full-scale mobilization in the fight against racism, anti-Semitism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance. France reaffirms our support for the implementation of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination. We call for its universal ratification. France has kick-started various initiatives on this front over the last few years. On 21 May of this year, we celebrated the 25th anniversary of the law which recognized slavery and the slave trade as crimes against humanity. There can be no doubt about the fact that these are crimes. That is why France believes that reparations should be used in the plural. These should include research, culture, education, and international cooperation. The restitution of cultural property, something France is implementing together with a number of African countries, is the concrete expression of this approach. Now, these restitutions, these returns, have given rise to a new conversation underpinned by respect, listening, and the desire to work together on cooperation. This is the thrust behind the international scientific work we've begun with Ghana on the memory of slavery. We're also fully mobilized in the fight against all forms of antisemitism, hate, and discrimination. This commitment guides our action and the approach of the French presidency of the International Alliance for Holocaust Remembrance. in 2027, Mr. Chairman, the recognition of collective group specific rights and the collection of ethnic statistics is in contrast with the universal conception of human rights. France's view of this: For France, equality between individuals is the prerequisite for the effectiveness of human rights. This is juxtaposed with the separation of individuals on the grounds of supposed races or the recognition of specific rights for specific groups. We would therefore like for discussions this year to have been broadened to cover all provisions. We hope that a more comprehensive dialogue can be undertaken in future sessions. This is why France voted against the resolution. France will continue to honour its international obligations in full. We will stand shoulder to shoulder with our partners so that the United Nations remains a universal, equitable and dignified framework for combating racism. I thank you.
Followed by the Kingdom of the Netherlands.
Thank you, Chairman. Colombia reaffirms its commitment to combat racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related forms of intolerance in all of their manifestations. This commitment is based on our political constitution, which recognizes the protection of the ethnic diversity of the nation and enshrines the rights to equality and non-discrimination. As we said in the interactive dialogues in this committee, we recognize that historic inequalities continue to affect people, particularly persons of African descent, and this requires inclusive public policies to be promulgated in order to address these phenomena. We recently accepted the competence of the Committee for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, which is laid out in Article 14 of our Constitution. We also maintain a dialogue with the relevant human rights treaty bodies in line with our Constitution as well. In line with this commitment, we reject the politicization of a matter that is as important as human rights, and we reiterate our commitment to this process, although we abstained in the vote on this resolution, but it doesn't minimize our commitment to combating racism. Thank you.
Thank you. Colombia, Kingdom of the Netherlands, followed by the United Kingdom. Netherlands, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Kingdom of the Netherlands remains firmly committed to addressing racism and discrimination. The fight against racism goes hand in hand with our collective and resolute fight against anti-Semitism, anti-Muslim hatred, and all other forms of discrimination. The Netherlands recently hosted UNESCO's Global Forum Against Racism and Discrimination in The Hague, reaffirming our commitment to international cooperation and concrete action against racism and discrimination. We share the importance the Africa Group attaches to addressing the lasting consequences of slavery and the transatlantic slave trade. We fully recognize the profound injustice of this history and its continued impact today. These lasting consequences are also felt across the Caribbean parts of the Kingdom of the Netherlands, each with its own history, experiences, and perspectives on the legacies of colonialism and slavery. In December 2022, the Prime Minister of the Netherlands formally apologized for the role of the Dutch state in the history of slavery. Then, in July 2023, His Majesty King Willem-Alexander also offered his apologies for the Netherlands' slavery past and asked for forgiveness. This marked the beginning of an ongoing process of dialogue and reconciliation on this topic. We remain committed to addressing the lasting effects of slavery through education, commemoration, meaningful dialogue, and concrete measures to address contemporary racism, discrimination, and structural inequalities. We engaged constructively in the negotiations on this resolution and appreciate the efforts to bring forward this important initiative. As a Kingdom with deep historical and contemporary ties to the Caribbean, we also attach particular importance to the perspectives of Caribbean societies and affected communities in addressing the enduring consequences of slavery and the transatlantic slave trade. However, we regret that the negotiations did not result in language that adequately addresses our legal and substantive concerns. The Kingdom of the Netherlands cannot support references suggesting the retroactive application of international law, including a purported obligation to provide reparations. Our abstention does not diminish our commitment to this important agenda, and we remain firmly committed to meaningful dialogue also within our Kingdom, acknowledging historical injustices and taking concrete steps to address racism and discrimination. Thank you.
Thank you, Kingdom of the Netherlands. Our final speaker on my list is the United Kingdom. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The United Kingdom proudly embraces the rich diversity that defines our country and contributions of all communities that have shaped who we are today. We unequivocally condemn racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance in all their forms, and remain steadfast in our commitment to tackling these injustices. The UK is committed to building a fairer society where everyone, regardless of background, has an equal chance to succeed. While progress has been made, racial and structural inequalities persist. We are taking action to tackle these challenges, including through a new race equality engagement group to strengthen engagement with ethnic minority communities, mandatory ethnicity pay gap reporting for large employers, and further work to advance race equality in education. We also fully acknowledge the devastating tragedy of the transatlantic slave trade and recognise that its legacy continues to shape lives, communities, and societies around the world. The UK believes that only by acknowledging and discussing collectively the most painful elements of the history we share with other nations, including the transatlantic slave trade, we can come together in a spirit of solidarity and mutual respect to respond to the challenges we all face today. That is why my Prime Minister announced the offer of a structured dialogue with those affected by the transatlantic slave trade. Listening to calls for a formal apology on behalf of the British state will form an important part of this process, and my Prime Minister has made clear that he is open to them. We remain committed to the fight against racism and the substantive aims and principles of the Durban Declaration and Programme of Action. As such, we thank the G77 for bringing forward this resolution and pay particular tribute to South Africa for its principled leadership in keeping the fight against racism high on the international agenda. But, Mr. Chair, we have longstanding concerns with aspects of the Durban process, including the historic antisemitism surrounding the 2001 conference. which we unequivocally condemn. We also continue to have concerns with provisions in the text in front of us that cut across established UK positions. We do not believe the text yet provides a basis for consensus. For these reasons, we were unable to support at this time. Our concerns with this resolution do not diminish our commitment to combating racism. It is crucial that we move forward together on a common path, guided by collaboration and mutual understanding. Thank you, Chair.
I thank the United Kingdom. I have no other delegations seeking to intervene. Accordingly, we have thus concluded our consideration of agenda item 68 and indeed item 68 as a whole. As a whole, we can now Turn our attention to consideration of agenda item 69, concerning the right of peoples to self-determination, in order to take action on two draft proposals. I first invite the Committee to turn to draft resolution A/C3/81/L21, entitled “The right of the Palestinian people to self-determination”. The resolution, or the draft resolution, has no budget implications. And I would like to invite the distinguished representative of Egypt on behalf of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation to introduce the resolution for us. Egypt, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honor, on behalf of the OIC group, to introduce the draft resolution entitled "The Right of Palestinian People to Self-Determination." Mr. Chair, this resolution which has long enjoyed consistent and broad support across the United Nations membership, reaffirms a principle that lies at the very heart of the UN Charter and the international legal order: the right of peoples to self-determination. This resolution is principled, balanced, and forward-looking. It recalls the relevant international instruments and, guided by the ICJ's advisory opinion of 2024, and underscores the urgent need to end the occupation and preserve the territorial integrity of the occupied Palestinian territory, including East Jerusalem. It reaffirms the Palestinian people's inalienable right to self-determination, including the right to an independent state of Palestine, and calls on all states, UN bodies, and specialized agencies to continue supporting the early realization of that right. My delegation wishes to thank all Member States for their constructive engagement and their continued support for this principles- and rules-based foundation upon which this resolution stands. We invite all delegations to support the adoption of this draft resolution. However, we deeply regret that despite the text being a technical update to an already balanced and principled resolution, a vote has been requested. an action that reflects a selective approach and undermines the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination. We therefore respectfully call upon all delegations to vote in favor of the draft resolution and to reaffirm the broad and consistent support to this topic. I thank you, Mr. Chair.
I thank the representative of Egypt, and I can confirm that co-sponsors to the draft resolution are identified on IGov, and I now invite the Secretary to indicate openness to identifying additional co-sponsors from the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/21, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see Belize. I see Comoros and Libya, who are already sponsors. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or explanation of vote before we proceed to a vote? I have the State of Palestine, to be followed by Tunisia, Israel, and the United States. State of Palestine, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We convey our sincere gratitude to the Member States of the OIC, the main sponsors of this draft resolution, and we extend our special thanks to Egypt for the coordination efforts in submitting the draft on behalf of the group.
We are also grateful to all the co-sponsors of this for their endorsement and support. The exercise of the Palestinian people to their right to self-determination in their homeland is a basic condition.
For achieving a just, lasting, and comprehensive peace in the Middle East, and the violation of it undermines any durable.
Solution to the conflict.
We appeal to all delegations to vote in favor of this draft resolution as a primary and collective step towards achieving shared peace, security, and prosperity in the Middle East. Thank you.
Thank you. I pass to Tunisia, followed by Israel.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We thank the representative of Egypt for introducing this draft on behalf of us all. We fully believe in the right of peoples to self-determination. Today, we discuss this draft regarding the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination, we cannot forget the reality that these people endure today. Have you seen recently images and videos of Palestinian families under rain in tents that do not protect from cold or from floodings? We have all seen these videos. because they went viral, actually, on social media. We continue to see them, and they are poignant, and we feel emotional, but we go back to our homes and our daily lives while these families continue to endure famine, fear, and cold. Here at the Third Committee, we discuss and we talk for long hours about human rights, and how to protect and uphold these rights, but truly, truly, we should feel shame as to the scope of this tragedy and our inability collectively to put an end to it. Tunisia reiterates its steadfast position in support for the Palestinian people and its right to establishing its sovereign independent state with Al-Quds al-Sharif as capital. The Tunisian people knows what it means to fight for one's freedom. That is why we will not allow that the freedom of the Palestinian people remains a legacy or a dream that is passed down generations. We want children in Palestine to go to school. and to listen in the morning to the voices of their friends, not the bombings, not the cries. We want them to find at hospitals, medication and equipment, not disability, not despair. We want Palestinian women to sleep without the fear to wake up in the morning without their children. To uphold international legitimacy and to believe in the force of law, Tunisia will vote in favor of this resolution and calls on all people with conscience in this room to vote in favor. Thank you.
Thank you, Tunisia. Israel, followed by United States.
Thank you, Chair. The resolution before us has no substantive or procedural necessity. Rather, it is another example of the double standards against Israel at the United Nations. As an ancient people bound by a shared history, culture, and ancestral homeland, the Jewish people know the importance of self-determination. Over the years, Israel has made difficult compromises for peace, recognizing that our sovereignty and independence is worth such sacrifice. Palestinian leadership has repeatedly given up opportunities for independence to continue its rejection of Israel's sovereignty. going beyond disagreements over borders to deny the Jewish people's very right to self-determination. This rejection is intentionally being passed down to the next generation. Palestinian Authority textbooks have replaced lessons about peace initiatives and coexistence with glorification of terrorists and martyrdom. The Palestinian Authority continues its pay-for-slay system, paying more than $483 million to terrorists and their families in 2025 alone. Three years ago, Hamas terrorists invaded Israel, massacred families, and abducted civilians into terror tunnels, violently demonstrating their intent to destroy Israel. Rather than implementing the plan set last year by U.S. President Trump and endorsed by the Security Council, Hamas has exploited the ceasefire to rearm, rebuild its terror tunnels, and attack Israeli forces. Hamas continues to rule through public executions and intimidation, while extorting $2 million a day from aid merchants. Its refusal to disarm and give up control is preventing legitimate civilian governance and blocking Gaza's reconstruction and de-radicalization. When seeing videos of those tents in the rain, keep this fact in mind as well. Chair, rather than advancing a genuine negotiated peace, this resolution advances the campaign against Jewish self-determination. It is in no way a balanced resolution. It invokes the Quartet Roadmap while ignoring the preconditions that Palestinian leaders end incitement and dismantle terrorist infrastructure, and it undermines Israel's territorial integrity. For these reasons, we have called for a vote and will vote against this resolution. We call upon all Member States who wish to advance peace and restore this committee's integrity to do the same. I thank you, Chair.
Thank you, Israel. I pass to the United States.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. This divisive, politicized resolution does not advance efforts to establish sustainable peace in the Middle East and does not help create conditions that promote negotiations between Israelis and Palestinians. Instead, it demonstrates the continued prevalence of anti-Israel bias over substantive diplomacy at the UN. Under President Trump's leadership, the Security Council adopted Resolution 2803 to support the 20-point plan to end the war in Gaza and to create a peaceful horizon for people in Gaza, Israel, and the Middle East at large. The General Assembly should support that real-world diplomacy, not distract from it. This resolution prejudges final status issues that only the parties can resolve through direct negotiation. It does nothing to advance peace on the ground. We also reject this resolution's reliance on the non-binding 2024 advisory opinion of the ICJ. Advisory opinions impose no obligations on member states, and the notion that any nation could be compelled by the UN General Assembly to work with any organization is a gross infringement on sovereignty. We reject this notion entirely. The United Nations must return to its original purpose of promoting peace and security and stop these performative actions. For these reasons, we must vote against this resolution, and we urge other delegations to do the same.
Thank you, United States. That enables us. I have – I beg your pardon. I have Egypt seeking the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I make this statement in my national capacity. We fully support the decision of the OIC in supporting the right of Palestinian people to self-determination. The Palestinian people should not be an exception. They must enjoy their rights fully, like other peoples. In this regard, we condemn the Israeli practices to liquidate the Palestinian question through settlement expansion, through settler terror through attempts at displacement and through repeated violations of the ceasefire, the continued killings of civilians, as well as restrictions on delivery of aid, recovery, and shelter. They also attack humanitarian organizations, the United Nations, and they impose restrictions against the Palestinian leadership. There are also voices of extremists in the Israeli government. There are incursions at Al-Aqsa Mosque. There are restrictions against the freedom of religion for both Christians and Muslims. Israel does not have sovereignty in occupied Al-Quds. We also support the Jordanian custodianship on Christian and Islamic holy sites in Al-Quds, as well as the status quo. We call on the international community to uphold these rights in order to put an end to these practices and to abstain from any unilateral practices that go against the international position, allowing for the annexation of any part of the occupied Palestinian territories or the Gaza or the West Bank, or to change the status of the holy sites. Peace in the Middle East, Mr. Chair, requires the end of the Israeli occupation and the establishment of the independent, sovereign Palestinian states on the lines of 4 June 67 with East Jerusalem as its capital, in line with the two-state solution. Egypt continues. to cooperate with all partners in order to support the full implementation of President Trump’s plan as well as resolution 2803 of the Security Council, given the important results that were allowed. However, building on these results and continuing the rest of what has to be implemented as a shared responsibility on all parties, this includes the State of Israel. To conclude. stalling and not respecting commitments and asking for more in negotiations, all this will only keep our region suffering from conflicts. I thank you.
Thank you, Egypt. That does conclude the list of delegations seeking to intervene. That enables us to proceed to take the vote. I remind delegations of rule 128. Delegations are invited to indicate their votes when the screen appears. And I pass to the Secretary.
The Committee is now voting on draft resolution L.21, entitled “The right of the Palestinian people to self-determination.” Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The vote on this resolution is as follows: in favor, 162; against, 8; with 8 abstentions. Accordingly, draft resolution A/C/3/81/L.21 is adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or general statement following the vote that's just taken place? I have Iraq, Argentina, Islamic Republic of Iran. Iraq, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Iraq would like to thank the delegation of Egypt for submitting the resolution on behalf of the OIC. Iraq has voted in favor of the resolution in affirmation of our firm position in support of the Palestinian question and in support of the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people, at the forefront of which is the right to self-determination, and to an independent state with Al-Quds as its capital.
We also emphasize that our voting in favor is not an adoption or acceptance of.
The reference to Jerusalem in accordance with our historical position and legislation.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you, Iraq. Argentina, to be followed by Iran.
Muchas gracias.
Thank you very much. Argentina wishes to reiterate its full support to the right to self-determination of peoples subjected to foreign occupation. This right should be interpreted in light with the purposes and principles of the UN Charter and Resolution 1514 and other relevant UN resolutions. Self-determination is only applicable where there is a people who has such a right, that is to say when there is a people subjected to foreign occupation or domination. That is the purpose of resolution 1514. If those conditions do not exist, then the right is not present. In addition, the resolution should be interpreted in line with the previous relevant resolutions of the General Assembly, including the Special Committee on Decolonization. Thank you.
Thank you, Argentina. Islamic Republic of Iran.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Islamic Republic of Iran voted in favor of the resolution and reaffirms its strong and consistent support for the inalienable right of the Palestinian people to self-determination. Decades of occupation, displacement, and the systematic denial of fundamental rights of the Palestinian people have prevented them from freely determining their future and living in dignity on their very own land. We further stress that the full realization of the right to self-determination must be inclusive of all Palestinians, Muslims, Jews, Christians, and others, who have historically lived together. Any just solution must ensure the equal participation and protection of the rights of all, free from discrimination and occupation. We also reaffirm our commitment to combating racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia, and related intolerance in all their forms. In this regard, we underline that the continued plight of the Palestinian people under prolonged occupation and systematic discrimination, which constitutes a stark manifestation of racial injustice, must be addressed. My delegation also wishes to place on record that the Islamic Republic of Iran does not recognize the two-state solution as referenced in the text of the resolution. Our support for the resolution is without prejudice to that long-standing position. I thank you.
Thank you, Iran. Cuba.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. My delegation would like to thank Egypt for presenting the resolution on behalf of the OIC, the draft resolution L21, which reaffirms the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination. And this is something that Cuba is proud to be a co-sponsor of. Over the last three years, the Israeli aggression against the Palestinian people has led to the death of more than 70,000 people and has led to more than to hundreds of thousands of people becoming being injured. Many communities have had to flee, and there have been countless buildings damaged and destroyed, including schools, hospitals, churches, and mosques. The nature of these facts means that we need to call it what it is, genocide. We are facing a systematic, widespread violation of the human rights of an entire people, including their right to self-determination, development, life, education, health care. And Israel has used these practices to exert control over more of the Gaza Strip and have continued to build settlements in occupied Palestinian territory. This includes in East Jerusalem, where we have seen an increase in attacks carried out by settlers and the forced displacement of Palestinians. The occupying power must be held accountable for their crimes against humanity. These are systematic violations of international humanitarian law. We reiterate the urgent need for Palestine to be admitted as a fully fledged member of the UN, and we must reiterate the inalienable right of the Palestinian people to their own sovereign territory in line with the two-state solution. in line with the pre-1967 borders with East Jerusalem as the State's capital. The struggle for the inalienable rights of the Palestinian people is a struggle for peace, humanity, and multilateralism. I conclude by reiterating Cuba's full solidarity with the Palestinian people and our commitment to continue to advocate a lasting settlement to the Palestinian question, without which there will be no lasting peace in the Middle East. I thank you.
Thank you, Cuba. I have no other delegation seeking the floor, in which case that brings to a conclusion our consideration of document L/21. I now invite the Committee to turn to draft resolution A/C/3/81/L.47, entitled "Universal realization of the right of peoples to self-determination." There are no programme budget implications associated with this draft resolution. I now invite the Permanent Representative of Pakistan to introduce the resolution for us. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honour to introduce on behalf of my delegation and the co-sponsors the draft resolution A/C3/81/2. L/47, entitled “Universal Realization of the Right of Peoples to Self-Determination”. Mr. Chair, the right to self-determination is one of the most fundamental principles enshrined in the UN Charter. Article 12 of the Charter calls for the development of friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination. This principle is codified in Article 1 of the International Covenants on Civil and Political Rights and Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. The Declaration on Principles of International Law and General Assembly resolution 1514 also articulate this right as a bedrock of international law. Mr. Chair, the universal recognition and exercise of this right has transformed the course of history. Millions of people have exercised this right, their right to self-determination, liberating themselves from foreign subjugation and establishing sovereign states as equal members of this Assembly. The vast majority of Member States represented in this Assembly achieved their independence through the exercise of this inalienable right. Yet the promise of self-determination remains unfulfilled for many peoples still living under foreign occupation. In several situations, their legitimate aspirations continue to be met with military oppression, excessive use of force, extrajudicial killings, arbitrary detentions, enforced disappearances, restrictions on fundamental freedoms, and attempts at demographic engineering. Such practices constitute grave violations of international law, undermine the credibility of the international legal order, and pose a serious challenge to the principles of justice and human dignity. Mr. Chair, the resolution before us reaffirms the universality and indivisibility of the right to self-determination. It expresses solidarity with peoples whose fundamental rights and freedoms remain denied and underscores the international community's collective responsibility to uphold this fundamental, foundational principle of international law. Its continued relevance is reflected in the broad cross-regional support it has consistently received. Given the universal nature of this right and its enduring relevance to situations of foreign occupation and alien domination, this resolution has traditionally enjoyed consensus in both the Committee and the General Assembly. We once again look forward to the consensus adoption of this resolution to reaffirm our collective commitment. I take this opportunity to express our sincere appreciation to all co-sponsors for their continued valuable support and encourage those delegations that have not yet joined to consider co-sponsoring this important resolution before adoption. I thank you.
I thank the Permanent Representative of Pakistan. Delegations co-sponsoring this resolution are identified on iGov. Let me give the floor to the Secretary to invite additional co-sponsors to identify themselves.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/47, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see Cote d'Ivoire, Maldives, Islamic Republic of Iran, Cambodia, Mauritania, Kyrgyzstan, Timor-Leste, Suriname, Gambia, Belize, Burundi, Djibouti, Comoros, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Somalia. I see no further requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L/47? I see no delegation wishing to do so. May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt the resolution? It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the resolution? I have Spain, to be followed by India. Spain, you have the floor.
Mr. Chairman, Spain joined the consensus on this resolution, and we thank Pakistan for presenting it. Resolution 1514 of 1960 establishes that the right to self-determination of peoples subjected to a colonial situation coexists with the principle of the territorial integrity of states. Hence, the right to self-determination cannot and should not be used to justify colonial situations that violate a state's territorial integrity. Administering power cannot try to create the perception that the colonial link has been severed through the misinterpretation of this policy. In this context, Spain wishes to refer to the case of Gibraltar, one of the 17 non-self-governing territories on the list of the C24. Spain does not agree that in the case of Gibraltar there is a people sheltered by this supposed right, as has been laid out in successive UN resolutions. Spain is suffering from colonization on its territory. Spain should be, is suffering from this situation as a result from violation of its territorial integrity. The doctrine of this recognizes that the situation in Gibraltar seriously affects Spain's territorial That is why for decades we have been trying to seek a solution to this situation based on the peaceful settlement of disputes and engaging in good faith. This is something that the United Nations has called for in Resolution 2070, calling on Spain and the UK to engage in negotiations on this regard. We believe that this year in Brussels there was an agreement between the European Union and the UK on Gibraltar. Nevertheless, in this forum, I would like to say that nothing in that agreement, nor any measure taken as a result of the agreement, means any kind of amendment to the legal position that Spain has vis-à-vis its sovereignty and its jurisdiction over Gibraltar. Mr. Chair, We wish here to reiterate once again our invitation to the UK to engage in negotiations within the aegis of the UN, so as to put an end to this colonial situation, which is anachronistic and belongs to previous centuries. Spain remains open to dialogue on this issue. Thank you.
Thank you, Spain. I pass to India, to be followed by Argentina.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The right to self-determination is a fundamental right for the people of non-self-governing territories and trust colonies. This would allow people to freely choose and establish their governance structures. India has played a leading role in the historic struggle for decolonization and was at the forefront of the movement to secure the right of peoples to self-determination, to enable them to determine their own political status and pursue their economic, social, and cultural development. Mr. Chair, India as a former colony aptly understands and values the importance of the principle of self-determination. However, the right to self-determination cannot be abused to encourage secession and undermine pluralistic and democratic states. The value and importance of the principle of self-determination should not be misunderstood. The right to self-determination should always be seen in historical perspective. The international community has consistently affirmed that the right of self-determination does not extend to component parts or groups within independent sovereign states. Self-determination, in the UN context, refers to the rights of people that have been colonized or continue to be under foreign domination. It clearly refers to peoples of non-self-governing territories or trust territories. The UN has established that the principle of self-determination is a vehicle for decolonization. not a justification for secession or undermining territorial integrity of any Member State. Mr. Chair, it is unacceptable that attempts are continuously made at the United Nations and elsewhere to reinvent some of the basic principles of the Charter, such as self-determination, and to apply them selectively for narrow or domestic political ends. To conclude. We would like to reiterate that in states that have now become independent, self-determination is best maintained through the regular exercise of democratic choice. I thank you.
Thank you, India. I pass forward to Argentina.
Thank you very much. Argentina wishes to make clear its full support to the right to self-determination of peoples subjected to colonial domination or foreign occupation. This right should be interpreted in line with the principles of the UN and Resolution 1514 and other relevant UN resolutions. Self-determination is exclusively applied when there are subjects that are actively under foreign occupation or domination or exploitation. This is in line with Resolution 1514. If this is not the case, then the right cannot be applied. Therefore, the resolution should be interpreted in line with the previous relevant resolutions of the UN, particularly the Special Committee on Decolonization. Thank you.
Thank you, Argentina. A delegation has requested a right of reply. Let me remind you that 115 of the Rules of Procedure apply, and I would remind delegations that the number of interventions in exercise of the right of reply for any delegation at a given meeting should be limited to two per item. The first intervention should be limited to five minutes and the second to three. And I now give the floor to the representative of the United Kingdom. You have the floor.
Thank you, Chair. I would like to exercise the right of reply in response to the statement made by the distinguished representative of Spain. The UK-EU agreement in respect of Gibraltar sets out the new arrangements governing Gibraltar’s relationship with the EU following the UK’s departure from the European Union. Sovereignty was never on the table, and the treaty text makes clear that it in no way affects our sovereignty position and cannot be used to challenge it. The United Kingdom recalls its sovereignty over Gibraltar and the territorial waters surrounding it, and reaffirms that as a separate territory recognised by the United Nations and included since 1946 in its list of non-self-governing territories, it enjoys the rights accorded to it under the UN Charter. We also recall that the people of Gibraltar enjoy the right of self-determination. The 2006 Gibraltar Constitution, which was endorsed in a referendum by the people of Gibraltar, provides for a modern and mature relationship between Gibraltar and the UK. The United Kingdom restates its long-standing commitment to the people of Gibraltar that it will not enter into arrangements under which the people of Gibraltar would pass under the sovereignty of another state against their freely and democratically expressed wishes. The United Kingdom also confirms that it will not enter into a process of sovereignty negotiations with which Gibraltar is not content. We reaffirm our commitment to safeguard Gibraltar, its people, and its economy. Thank you.
I thank the United Kingdom. Spain has requested the floor. You have the floor.
I'm just taking the floor, Mr. Chairman, in response to the statement just delivered by the distinguished delegate of the UK. This organization has said on many prior occasions that Gibraltar is a colony that negatively affects Spain's territorial integrity and is incompatible with resolution 1514. That is why it is included on the list of the 17 non-self-governing territories. And there is only one way which is set out by the resolution, in which Spain and the UK, in line with the UN, engage in negotiations and fulfill the goals set out by the Special Committee on Decolonization. Only the UN can say when the process of decolonization has been completed. Resolution 2353 says that any situation that partially or totally infringes upon a country's territorial integrity is incompatible with the United Nations Charter, and it stipulates that the decolonization of Gibraltar should be carried out in line with the principle of territorial integrity. Hence, the General Assembly, through this same resolution, condemned the holding of the referendum in 1967, organized by the occupying power without notifying the UN. In this same regard, the General Assembly has been very clear in denying the existence of an alleged right to self-determination of a supposed people of Gibraltar that does not exist in this case. In the framework of negotiations to solve this issue, they say that Spain and the UK should bear in mind the interests of the inhabitants of the territory. That is what is stated. In line with UN doctrine, Spain also rejects any attempt by the administering power and the authorities of the colonized territory to change the political statements to say that there is a right to self-determination that should be applied when the situation continues to pertain. We are still talking about a colonial situation that is a vestige of previous centuries. The distinguished delegate of the UK refers to other issues. I would like to say that Spain does not recognize the maritime areas around Gibraltar as pertaining to the UK, in line with the relevant resolutions. That is why, in our view, we're talking about the city and the castle of Gibraltar, and nothing else. We're not talking about the territorial waters here. The UK is occupying a portion of the isthmus, and this includes a part of the landing strip of the airport of Gibraltar. Spain has always protested against this state of affairs because it is an occupation that is contrary to international law, and we are requesting that this land be given back as it was taken by force. When the UK refers to the territorial waters around Gibraltar, this is something that is totally baseless. It is not grounded on law. This is something that Spain has already pointed out when ratifying the Convention on the Law of the Sea. In addition, Spain has no doubts about the limits of its territory, and hence the surrounding waters of Gibraltar are waters that belong to Spain, in which vessels that belong to Spain have always sailed. This is something that has been a source of dispute up into very recent times. Lastly, and regardless of the solution that is reached to structure relations between the UK and the EU after Brexit, that the delegate from the UK has just referred to, this to the benefit of the citizens in the area, we reiterate that on the question of Gibraltar, there is no other solution than a decolonization process that is negotiated between Spain and the UK along the terms that the UN has stipulated, a process to which Spain remains fully open. Thank you.
Thank you, Spain. I have no other delegation requesting the floor. Accordingly, we have concluded our consideration of Agenda item 69. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 70 A, entitled “Implementation of human rights instruments”, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C3/81/L.28, entitled “Human rights treaty body system”. I would like to inform the Committee that there are no budgetary implications attached to this resolution. I now give the floor to the Permanent Representative of Iceland to introduce the resolution for us. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honour to introduce the draft resolution on the human rights treaty body system contained in document A/C/3/81/L.28, on behalf of Belgium, Slovenia and the five Nordic countries. This is the sixth time that the Third Committee considers this biennial resolution. It represents an important contribution to the ongoing process of strengthening and enhancing the effective functioning of the human rights treaty body system. Since 2016, this resolution has sought to build on and support the full implementation of General Assembly resolution 68/268, providing an opportunity every two years to reaffirm our collective commitment to strengthening the treaty body system. Mr. Chair, the treaty body system is a cornerstone of the UN human rights architecture. We reaffirm our unwavering commitment to its independence, effectiveness, and efficiency. The treaty bodies play a vital role in promoting the universal realization of human rights, strengthening accountability, and providing authoritative guidance to states in fulfilling their international human rights obligations. The system is operating in an increasingly challenging environment. The ongoing liquidity crisis and related constraints have further compounded existing pressures and structural vulnerabilities. This makes it all the more important to ensure adequate and predictable resources while continuing efforts to strengthen the system and improve its working methods. Mr. Chair, we maintain that there remains room for improvement within this existing framework. However, one of the strengths of this resolution is that it is adopted by consensus. In that spirit, we decided to present a technical rollover this year. We received broad support for this approach from Member States during informal consultations. We sincerely hope that the adoption by consensus will serve as an encouragement to the treaty bodies, the UN Secretariat, and to OHCHR. in the continued effort to support the full implementation of resolution 68/268. In particular, we reaffirm the importance of its key elements, including those related to reporting, harmonization, and further digitalization. While this resolution does not include any programme budget implications, we urge Member States to continue to support the treaty bodies in the fulfilment of their mandates, including by providing adequate and predictable resources through voluntary contributions and the appropriate regular budgetary channels. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
I thank the Permanent Representative of Iceland. I note that the iGov site identifies the existing co-sponsors. I now pass to the Secretary to invite further co-sponsorship.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/28, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see Bulgaria, Peru, El Salvador, Paraguay, and Ecuador. I see no further requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in relation to this resolution at this stage? I see no delegation seeking to take the floor. Accordingly, may I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L/28? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement following the adoption of the draft resolution? I have Switzerland. You have the floor.
Mr. Chair, Switzerland would like to thank Iceland and the members of the group for presenting the resolution L.28 on the human rights system. We would like to welcome its adoption by consensus, which bears witness to the collective commitment by Member States to the treaty body system. Switzerland has for a long time co-sponsored this resolution, pursuance to its unwavering support to the treaty body system and also to the strengthening process. Effective protection of human rights requires not just standards, but also robust mechanisms to oversee and support their implementation. The conventional bodies are the heart of this system. We therefore take this opportunity to express our concern about the current status of the system, which is subject to significant pressure. The liquidity crisis has had an unprecedented impact on its functioning. It has broadened pre-existing shortcomings and it has constrained it to cancel dialogue with Member States and other meetings. At the same time, the number of reports is only going up. That is the reality in which the committees are operating today. Although we respect the approach taken by the by the sponsors of the resolution, we would have liked this to be reflected in the document. We hope that future resolutions will bear in mind the situation that the bodies are facing faithfully. We remain convinced that the system can be made more efficient, predictable, and consistent thanks to pragmatic reforms, without nevertheless undermining the body's independence, notably through digitalization, predictable planning, and enhanced harmonization of their methods of work. This belief was shared by more than 90 States who signed the Common Declaration on the Treaty Bodies, which we presented at the beginning of this third Committee session. We are convinced that this dynamic can be maintained, and we are ready to continue with dialogue between the treaty bodies, States parties, the OHCHR, and civil society on these matters. I thank you.
Thank you, Switzerland. I see no other delegation wishing to take the floor, in which case that concludes our consideration of agenda item 70 (a) and of item 70 as a whole. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 110, crime prevention and criminal justice action on draft resolution, in order to take action on the two draft resolutions. We first turn to draft resolution A/C3/81/L6/Rev.1, entitled Preventing and combating corrupt practices and the transfer of proceeds of corruption, facilitating asset recovery and returning such assets to legitimate owners, in particular to countries of origin, in accordance with the United Nations Convention against Corruption. I’d like to inform the Committee that there are no programme budget implications of this resolution. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Colombia to introduce the resolution for us.
Mr. Chair, distinguished delegates, On behalf of the delegation of Colombia, I have the honor to introduce the draft resolution entitled Preventing and Combating Corrupt Practices and the Transfer of Proceeds of Corruption, Facilitating Asset Recovery and Returning Such Assets to Legitimate Owners, in particular to countries of origin, in accordance with the United Nations Convention Against Corruption. Corruption is one of the most persistent challenges facing our societies. It undermines public trust, weakens institutions, divert resources from essential public services, and hinders sustainable development. Addressing these challenges requires sustained political commitment, effective institutions, and a strong international cooperation. The United Nations Convention Against Corruption remains the cornerstone of our collective efforts in this regard. This resolution reaffirms our shared commitment to its effective implementation, including through a strengthened international cooperation, the prevention of corruption, and the recovery and return of assets and proceeds derived from corrupt practices. Mr. Chair, allow me to briefly reflect on the process that brought us to this text. Throughout the negotiations, as facilitators, we sought to conduct an open, inclusive, and transparent process, providing delegations with opportunities to present their views, raise concerns, and contribute to the development of the text. We listened carefully to the positions expressed by all delegations and made every effort to identify common ground, bridge differences, and develop formulations that could accommodate diverse perspectives. The process required considerable engagement, flexibility, and a willingness to find compromises. We recognize that negotiations of this nature inevitably involve different priorities. Our responsibility as co-facilitators was to approach these differences fairly and constructively, while preserving the overall balance and integrity of the resolution. We believe that the text before us reflects these collective efforts and provides a balanced outcome that can command the broadest possible support. Distinguished delegates, we wish to express our sincere appreciation to our co-sponsors and to all delegations for their active participation, substantive contributions, and constructive engagement throughout this process. We are particularly grateful for the trust, flexibility, and spirit of cooperation extended to the co-facilitators. We would also like to convey our special appreciation to the UN ODC, to the Secretariat, and to all those who contributed to facilitating this process. Mr. Chair, ultimately, the value of this resolution lies not only in the text we adopt, but also in our collective determination to translate our commitments into concrete action. As we move forward, we reaffirm the central role of the United Nations Convention against Corruption and the importance of building upon the achievements and outcomes of this Conference of States Parties to advance effective implementation, strengthen cooperation, and deliver tangible results. In its spirit of shared responsibility and cooperation, that we submit this draft resolution for the consideration of the Committee and sincerely hope that it will be adopted by consensus. I thank you.
Thank you, Colombia. Co-sponsors for this draft resolution are identified on the IGOF site. I now pass to the Secretary to invite additional co-sponsors to identify themselves.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to join as co-sponsors of draft resolution L/6/1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see Chile, Peru, Israel, Paraguay, and Bolivia. I see no further requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement in connection with draft resolution L6/1? I see no delegation seeking to take the floor. Russian Federation.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Distinguished colleagues, we're grateful to Colombia for introducing the omnibus resolution and for constructively leading discussions on the text. Russia deems the document to be first and foremost an opportunity to reassert the central coordinating role played by the UN in international anti-corruption cooperation on the basis of UNCAC and with other formats playing a secondary role, first and foremost APEC and BRICS. In the resolution, there are passages covering the prevention and the fight against corruption. In our discussion on the resolution, the Russian Federation paid particular attention to growing international cooperation. We condemn the politicization of law enforcement cooperation last year. The competent authorities of foreign states saw rejected, in fact, 113 Russian requests for extradition. Almost 40% of those were politically motivated. These were rejections coming from, refusals coming from European states. At the same time, competent authorities of foreign states also struck down seven Russian requests for mutual legal assistance in criminal cases. These were all from Western states, and these were politically motivated. This situation is unacceptable. The only people who win as a result of such practices are the criminals themselves. We therefore insist that all states implement their Convention obligations. We need to strengthen the international legal asset recovery regime. We're particularly disquieted by the fact that there's no progress on the repatriation of ill-gotten gains. Day in, day out, year in, year out, we are hearing that many states do have practical experience returning vast swathes of assets, whereas the vast majority of states don't actually have any experience on this. The political declaration of the special session of the UN General Assembly against corruption back in 2021, states proclaimed that they will double their efforts aimed at the return of assets. Therefore, significantly reducing illicit financial flows by 2030. Five years on, we've seen little progress. On the contrary, there is a trend of imposing on states not making any progress. We condemn such practices, which are at odds with the fundamental principles of the Convention. In our discussion on the resolution, we initiated, we put forward a proposal to call a special session on this matter before 2028, but this was blocked by States which receive these assets. They, of course, value these illicit assets.
The speaker's microphone has been cut off.
I see no other delegation seeking the floor. In that case, may I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L6/Rev1? I hear no objection. Therefore, it is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement following the adoption of that resolution? I have a number of States seeking the floor: United States, followed by Cuba, Peru, Argentina and Ireland. United States, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The United States is a leader in international anti-corruption efforts and stands firmly behind efforts to combat corruption worldwide. We thank Colombia for its efforts to focus global attention on this issue. As such, we have joined consensus on this resolution, but we remain concerned by several elements within the text. The United States notes with dismay that this resolution rehashes at length the responsibilities of State Parties to a treaty to which 98% of UN member states have signed. Rather than restating legally binding obligation many states made decades ago, members should focus efforts on actually preventing, investigating, and prosecuting corruption. This resolution also remains unbalanced and ignores where action is actually needed to combat corruption. Far too many paragraphs focus on asset recovery, with barely any mention of preventing and combating bribery or money laundering, crimes that directly impact the lives of citizens and fuel other criminal enterprises. There is also no acknowledgment that the greatest challenge we face is some governments' clear lack of political will to take meaningful action against corruption. The United States notes that this resolution has become a laundry list of requests for member states that does not advance the UN's core responsibilities of promoting international peace and security. UN resolutions should be concise, actionable, and outcome-oriented. We reject the performative exercise of regularly revisiting this and other resolutions in this body, especially when such matters are best addressed in Vienna under the auspices of the UNCAC. This is where the technical expertise lies, not in New York. We also reject the inclusion of gender ideology, the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, and the UN Sustainable Development Goals into this and other Third Committee resolutions. Such language only serves to politicize the work of this body and adds to the already bloated length of resolutions under consideration by the Third Committee. Finally, we reiterate that General Assembly resolutions are non-binding instruments that do not create legal obligations for sovereign states or change the current state of international law. Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, United States. Cuba, to be followed by Peru.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Cuba reaffirms its commitment to preventing and addressing corruption in all of its forms and manifestations. This is a phenomenon that undermines the rule of law, it hinders sustainable development, and it directly affects the well-being of our peoples. We believe that the fight against corruption should be an unwavering responsibility of states, and it should be part of development strategies. That is why it is critical to strengthen prevention and oversight mechanisms to promote transparency in public office, ensuring the suitable use of State resources and combating impunity. Cuba attaches particular importance to ethical education, rejecting corruption, and strengthening institutions responsible for addressing these practices. We are also in favour of ensuring due procedural guarantees and rights to due process. We reiterate our commitments to the full implementation of the UN Convention against Corruption, to which we are a State Party. And we recognize the importance of engaging international cooperation to addressing these phenomena, particularly its transnational dimensions. Technical assistance, the exchange of information, judicial cooperation, and the recovery of assets should be a critical part of these efforts. focusing in particular on the needs of developing countries. Mr. Chair, we believe it is critical to ensure that cooperation in this domain is carried out on the basis of respecting state sovereignty and the sovereign equality between states, non-interference in states' domestic affairs, and the full abiding by international law. The combat against corruption should not be politicized in any way as a means of exerting selective pressure, nor as a means of carrying out unilateral coercive measures. We reiterate that effectively addressing corruption requires political determination, it requires robust institutions, suitable legal frameworks, and genuine international cooperation based on mutual respect and shared responsibility. Thank you.
Thank you, Cuba. I pass the floor to Peru, to be followed by Argentina.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. We would like to thank the mission of Colombia for their work on the facilitation of the draft resolution L6, with which we co-sponsored and we supported. We reaffirm our unwavering commitment to preventing and combating corruption in all of its forms. This is a national priority, and it is a critical part of strengthening democratic institutions. the rule of law, and citizens' trust in public institutions. In this regard, we would like to say that corruption does not just hinder the effective delivery of public services, it also deviates essential resources which could otherwise be allocated to poverty eradication. Hence, effectively combating corrupt practices and identifying and recovering assets as a result of corruption are critical aspects to move towards a more transparent and effective society. These actions are also closely linked to the national priorities that the President of the Republic presented to the General Assembly in September of this year at the GA, specifically combating organized crime. having education as a tool for social transformation and preventing crime, and strengthening institutions and democracy. Mr. Chair, Peru wishes to highlight, in particular, the importance of beefing up international cooperation so as to prevent and combat corruption, and also to facilitate the recovery of assets to their legitimate owners. particularly countries of origin. In this framework, we reaffirm our commitment to the full implementation of the United Nations Convention against Corruption. This is the main legal tool in this domain. It provides the framework to promote cooperation and assistance between States. Lastly, on references to the term gender which are contained in the draft resolution, Peru stipulates that the content should be interpreted in line with our political constitution, our laws, and the international obligations that the State has already signed up to. Thank you.
Thank you, Peru. I pass to Argentina, to be followed by Ireland.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Argentina wishes to express its thanks to the delegation of Colombia for their hard work as facilitators on the negotiations on this document. Argentina wishes to make clear its disassociation from the references to the SDGs and the 2030 Agenda. Argentina recalls the non-binding nature of these instruments, which each State, in exercising its sovereignty, has the right to interpret as they see fit, in line with their national priorities and national frameworks. Lastly, Argentina understands the term gender as women and men. Thank you.
Thank you, Argentina. Ireland, followed by Switzerland.
Thank you very much, Chair. I speak on behalf of the European Union, its member states, North Macedonia, Montenegro, Serbia, Albania, Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and San Marino. Combating corruption is a priority for the EU at the global, regional, and national levels. Corruption is a persistent challenge which erodes citizens' trust. undermines democracy and the rule of law, hinders good governance, distorts economic activity, and creates openings for organized crime and hostile actors. It is a structural obstacle to the enjoyment of human rights and is interlinked with violations and abuses. We appreciate that Colombia has again presented the omnibus resolution on corruption and organized informal consultations. The EU engaged constructively and put forward several proposals to strengthen and enhance the text in line with international standards. While we thank the facilitator for taking on board some of those proposals, we regret that many were not included in the final text. We are particularly concerned by PP12, which in its current formulation interprets Article 4 of the UN Convention against Corruption beyond its reach. Transparency and accountability safeguards are necessary to ensure that the return of assets derived from corruption benefits the populations of the countries of origin and that these assets do not fuel corruption. We also regret the lack of changes in OP 27 and believe that we should focus our efforts and resources on the effective implementation of standards that do exist. With its near universal reach, the UN Convention against Corruption is widely recognized a reference standard with regards to anti-corruption matters. We hope that future deliberations on this resolution will be based on a more balanced approach, taking into account all delegations' views, including a stronger focus on the prevention, detection, and incrimination of corruption. We encourage the facilitator to open more of the text for negotiations in 2028. Notwithstanding these aspects, the Member States of the European Union joined consensus on the resolution, and the EU remains firmly committed to combating corruption and upholding the best standards in anti-corruption under the UN Convention against Corruption. Thank you very much.
Thank you, Ireland. The final speaker on my list is Switzerland. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Switzerland would like to thank the facilitators and Colombia for the commitment and the efforts deployed throughout the negotiations. We supported the consensus adoption of the resolution. However, we'd like to underscore that we do not lend our support to the second paragraph of the preamble. We support the maintenance of references to the Lausanne guidelines, a practical guide which goes hand in hand with the Lausanne process. This process is a valuable platform which seeks to bolster international cooperation on asset recovery. Nonetheless, we regret the weaker references in this, in the previous versus the previous resolution, including the deletion of the preambular paragraph which welcomes the Lausanne workshop, as well as the passage which recognizes the important role that this process can play as a cooperation platform. We also regret the deletion of references to the ADIS process, including the seminar organized in October by Switzerland, Ethiopia, and the STAR, Stolen Asset Recovery Initiative, something that once again showed just how relevant asset recovery and the return of stolen assets are for sustainable development. I thank you.
And I have no other delegations seeking the floor, in which case that concludes our consideration of document L6/Rev.1. We turn next to draft resolution A/C3/81/L8/Rev.1, entitled “Implementation of the resolution of the Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime on the establishment of an ad hoc committee for the purpose of elaborating an additional protocol to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime to tackle illicit trafficking in wild fauna and flora, including timber and timber products, the illegal mining of and illicit trafficking in minerals and precious metals, and illicit trafficking in waste. I wish to draw the Committee's attention to a statement of programme budget implications in connection with draft resolution L/8/Rev.1, contained in document A/C3/81/L76. I now give the floor to the Permanent Representative of Brazil to introduce the resolution. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. President. Colleagues, Brazil is honoured to have presented the draft resolution before us. Its very short text simply intends to give effect in the General Assembly of the decision taken at the 13th Conference of Parties to the Convention against Transnational Organized Crime to establish an ad hoc committee to negotiate a protocol on crimes that affect the environment. Here, my delegation could reiterate the need for a universal, coordinated framework to help Member States in their fight against a billion-dollar criminal industry, one that makes billions of dollars from illegal deforestation, destruction and abuse of wildlife, water, air, and soil contamination, and serious threats to the health of local communities. one that impoverishes peoples and governments, especially in the global South, including through illicit financial flows. Luckily, this discussion already took place in Vienna a few weeks ago. Hence, the draft the Committee is called to consider today is strictly procedural in nature. We respectfully ask all delegations to support this draft resolution as tabled. Thank you, Mr. President.
I thank the Permanent Representative of Brazil. Co-sponsors of this resolution are identified on iGov. I now pass the floor to the Secretary to identify additional co-sponsors.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor the draft resolution L/8/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see Costa Rica, Colombia, Ecuador, Gabon, South Africa and Bolivia, as well as the Central African Republic and Angola. I see no further requests.
Thank you, Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on this resolution. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or an explanation of vote before we undertake the vote? I see the United States, followed by Brazil. United States, you have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. Wildlife trafficking, illegal logging, and the illicit mining generate hundreds of billions of dollars every year for transnational cartels and terrorist networks. We know the devastation these criminal networks cause to communities and the rule of law. The United States is a leader in the fight against environmental crimes. We know that you stop timber poachers or transnational mining syndicates with handcuffs, financial sanctions, asset seizures, and prosecutorial backbone. You do not stop them by spending five years in conference rooms arguing over an extraneous treaty. The UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime and the UN Convention against Corruption already contain provisions that require or encourage the mechanisms needed for mutual legal assistance, extradition, cross-border information sharing, effective enforcement, and asset recovery to counter environmental crime when supported by appropriate domestic legislation and political will. The United States regrets that this resolution is neither fiscally responsible nor results-oriented, and will therefore vote no. It is basic arithmetic that the United Nations is facing a liquidity crisis. Still, this resolution asks for an open checkbook. The UNODC Secretariat has estimated that holding ad hoc committee sessions will cost 300,000 per week just for interpretation and administrative services before a single investigator is deployed or a single ranger is funded. Meanwhile, the existing UNTOC review mechanism to assess treaty implementation is floundering. Out of 194 State Parties, only six countries and the EU have contributed voluntary funding. The main sponsor of this protocol, Brazil, has not contributed any extra budgetary resources to support the UNTOC review mechanism, and Brazil will likely contribute zero in extra budgetary resources for this process to negotiate a new convention to counter environmental crime. The United States will not endorse launching a multimillion dollar treaty process when member states refuse to fully implement existing international conventions or pay for the process that already exists. Please note that the UNTOC 13/1 resolution itself calls to minimize impact on the regular budget and encourages use of voluntary contributions. This resolution ignores that objective. The United States further notes that the term "crimes that affect the environment" has no agreed definition. The February expert group in Vienna ended in a stalemate because countries could not agree on what they were trying to criminalize. Guided in large part by the existing provisions of the UNTOC and the UNCAC, the United States will continue to dismantle nature crimes syndicates through tough domestic laws, bilateral enforcement, international cooperation, and targeted sanctions. We will not waste American taxpayer.
Thank you, United States. I pass to the Permanent Representative of Brazil.
Thank you, Chair. I'm sorry to take the floor once more. Brazil is of the view that the procedural draft resolution, such as the one we have before us, should be adopted by consensus. We regret that this good practice was not followed today. At the same time, I believe all delegations are entirely clear on the single and simple purpose of the draft. Member States made a decision at UNTOC COP 13 which is the appropriate and legitimate substantive decision-making body in the matter, and it needs to be made effective by the General Assembly. Therefore, Brazil respectfully asks all delegations to vote in favor of the draft resolution. Thank you, Mr. President.
I thank the Permanent Representative of Brazil. The Committee will now commence with the process of voting on draft resolution L8/Rev1. I remind all colleagues of rule 128 in relation to points of order. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. I pass now to the Secretary.
The Committee is now voting on draft resolution L/8/1, entitled "Implementation of the Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime." Resolution on the establishment of an ad hoc committee for the purpose of elaborating an additional protocol to the Convention against Transnational Organized Crime to tackle illicit trafficking in wild fauna and flora, including timber and timber products, illegal mining of and illicit trafficking in minerals and precious metals, and illicit trafficking in waste. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The final voting result is in favour 152, against 18, with 18 abstentions. Draft resolution A/C3/81/L.8/Rev.1 is therefore adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or a general statement following the vote that's just taken place? I have Saudi Arabia. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. We voted against this draft resolution in line with our position in Vienna. We also voted against Resolution 13/1 of the COP to establish a committee. related to the UNCOT. This draft resolution B4 us asks for the Secretary-General to support this committee. As we established and explained in Vienna, we believe that this is premature. We think that there are essential issues that require further study and further consultation, including the scope of this protocol, its definition, its relationship to other existing legal instruments, including multilateral environmental instruments. There is also the legal, institutional, and financial impacts. And the GGE was not able to reach a consensual agreement regarding the value of this additional protocol. Mr. Chair, our concerns regarding what was mentioned in OP/7 of COP13/1 remain. We also believe that preparing an additional protocol, despite the fact that the GGE did not reach consensus, is not in line with the approach in the previous resolution 12/14, which looked into potential choices and stressed consensus. We stressed the importance of continuing consultations and bringing positions closer before starting the elaboration of an additional protocol with new international commitments. To conclude, we remain committed to fighting transnational organized crime through international cooperation that is effective in line. And through this convention, we continue and we stand ready to participate. participate in relevant deliberations. I thank you.
Thank you, Saudi Arabia. I pass to the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The Islamic Republic of Iran underscores its steadfast commitment to combating all forms of transnational organized crime, including environmental infractions. My delegation voted against the resolution and wishes to place on record the following explanation of vote. outlining our fundamental institutional and legal concerns. The establishment of a new, legally binding additional protocol must under no circumstances infringe upon, undermine or interfere with the permanent and unassailable sovereignty of Member States over their national territory, internal governance systems and natural resources, including minerals and precious metals. Moreover, Oil, gas, their derivatives, related industries, as well as their trade, export, import, and all other associated activities are strictly excluded from the scope of any such additional protocol. My delegation remains concerned over the expansion of the UN regular budget and the allocation of additional resource mandates to newly established subsidiary bodies without exhaustive consensus among all parties. Administrative and financial mechanisms of the proposed ad hoc committee must remain strictly within the confines of established intergovernmental oversight, without diverting critical resources from existing technical assistance frameworks. We firmly maintain that existing multilateral instruments, including the CITES and Basel Convention, already possess the necessary mandates to address specific environmental offenses. Redundancy, duplication of efforts, and the overlapping of mandates among international bodies must be avoided to ensure national legislative frameworks are respected. The Islamic Republic of Iran states that its vote against this resolution, as well as any subsequent adoption thereof, does not constitute an endorsement of the mandate of the Ad Hoc Committee, nor does it create any current or future legal and financial obligations for my Government regarding the elaboration of the proposed additional protocol. I thank you.
I thank the Islamic Republic of Iran. That concludes our consideration of draft resolution L/8/Rev.1, and it concludes our consideration of agenda item 110. I now invite the Committee to resume our consideration of agenda item 111, international drug control, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C3/81/2. L11/Rev1 entitled “Addressing and countering the world drug problem through a comprehensive, integrated and balanced approach” and the amendments thereto contained in documents A/C3/81/L73 and A/C3/81/L74. There are no budget implications. for any of those documents. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Mexico to introduce the draft resolution. You have the floor.
Thank you very much, Mr. Chairman. Mexico has the honor to present draft resolution entitled Addressing and Countering the World Drug Problem through a Comprehensive, Integrated, and Balanced Approach. Throughout the negotiations, our priority as facilitators was to lead a transparent, open and inclusive process that would make it possible to hear the priorities of all delegations through a frank dialogue. The consultations allowed us to ponder the different positions so as to preserve what we have achieved and the delicate political balance that was achieved through consensus two years ago. In this way, we have also updated the content of the resolution in the light of the most recent technical updates and the resolutions adopted by the Commission on Narcotic Drugs during its recent sessions. Unfortunately, the Russian Federation presented two amendments to the draft resolution, in spite of the fact that Mexico had the understanding to have achieved consensus. We believe that these two amendments are hostile. not just because they undermine the understanding that was agreed and the many concessions that were given to the Russian Federation during the negotiations, but also because they do not bear in mind the considerable efforts that were made by all delegations during the negotiations to try to strike a balance and achieve compromise. We trust that the version that we present here to address the issue takes on a Broad, comprehensive approach and bears in mind public health, human rights, and development, as well as preventing crime and ensuring public security. It preserves the achievements that have been made in the past, and it continues to put people at the heart of public drug policy. It also reaffirms the importance of respecting and protecting human rights, strengthening access to prevention services, treatment, care for overdoses, and at the same time, it also recognizes the alternative development programs and the new independent panel of experts. It also strengthens the prevention of crime, the application of the law, and international cooperation. cooperation to address the illicit trafficking in drugs. It also responds to emerging threats, which is done by strengthening early warning systems and protecting supply chains. It also recognizes the importance of safeguarding security and the integrity of law enforcement officials who are involved in these efforts. In this context, it preserves the spirit of consensus that has guided our work. This is particularly important. Mexico therefore invites all delegations to support the resolution and vote against the amendments. Thank you.
Thank you, Mexico. Co-sponsors for this resolution are identified on iGov. Now let me invite the Secretary to seek additional co-sponsors from the floor. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor draft resolution L/11/1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see South Africa, Chile, and Paraguay. I see no further requests.
Thank you, Secretary. I now give the floor to the representative of the Russian Federation to make a statement in connection with the amendments contained in documents L/73 and L/74. You have the floor.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Russia is committed to a common objective that is eradicating the world drug problem. We've consistently supported the regular adoption of the relevant resolution. Having said that, we regret that the delicate balance in the text, which was adopted by consensus at the previous session two years ago, that this balance was undone in favor of medical and human rights aspects. Thus, Russia introduced the first amendment, so as to introduce greater balance, into para 12 of the preamble. In it, the General Assembly takes note of the Human Rights Council resolution and relevant reports, which promote a liberal anti-drug policy, including the establishment of some sort of special mandate on human rights and drugs. As a reasonable compromise, factoring in the interests of various states, we proposed including into the report a paragraph about the impact of UCMs on the right to health. The document notes that UCMs and excessive implementation of sanctions regimes Well, this has nefarious impacts on the enjoyment of the right to health for people in all countries under sanctions, including from a drug use perspective. Specifically, we underscore that under difficult economic conditions, children and adolescents become particularly vulnerable to becoming addicted to drugs and involved in crime. Life expectancy of people in countries under sanctions falls by four months for every year of sanctions imposed. We also note that over the last 15 years, a quarter of countries have been subjected to such sanctions. Most of them are in Africa. According to the medical journal The Lancet, between 1971 and 2021, such illegal sanctions were the main cause of death for almost 570,000 people per year. In light of the above, we believe it's important to note this negative impact in the report. On the second amendment, Russia has consistently fought HIV/AIDS. The effectiveness of the measures were adopted is seen in the results. Over the last decade, the level of HIV infections in Russia has fallen to historic minimum. Russia stands ready to share its experience. The Russian delegation worked constructively on the political declaration on HIV/AIDS. However, during the negotiations, instead of internationally agreed approaches, countries saw imposed on them contradictory concepts such as harm reduction and new rights introduced for persons addicted to drugs. As a result, eight member states, including Russia, voted against, 14 abstained, and 22 did not partake in the government. We stand convinced that the fight against HIV/AIDS should be an area where we support and pool the efforts of the international community, as opposed to imposing odious non-consensus approaches. In light of the above, we call on all States to support the Russian amendment.
Sponsoring the amendments contained in documents L/73 and L/74 are reflected on iGov. I pass the floor to the Secretary to invite additional co-sponsors.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor the amendment contained in document L/73, Please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see the Islamic Republic of Iran. I see no further requests. Turning to the amendment contained in document L/74, if any countries wish to co-sponsor the amendment contained in document L/74, please press the microphone button. I see no requests. Thank you.
Thank you, Secretary. In accordance with rule 130 of the Rules of Procedure, the Committee will first take a decision on the proposed amendments. Recorded votes have been requested on the amendments. And I now invite any delegation which wishes to make a general statement or an explanation of vote before the vote in connection with either or both of the amendments to draft resolution L11/Rev1 as contained in documents L73 and L74. I have Ireland. You have the floor.
Thank you very much, Chair. I speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states. and North Macedonia, Montenegro, Albania, Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Georgia, and San Marino. For the European Union, addressing the world drug situation in a comprehensive and integrated manner is a priority. We attach great importance to all relevant aspects: public health, development, the social dimension, law enforcement, criminal justice, and full respect of international human rights law. A human rights-based approach is key to all of these, as is international cooperation. Following a successful return to consensus on this resolution in 2024, this year we had constructive negotiations under the able leadership of Mexico, and despite diverging views and priorities for UN Member States regarding how best to address the world drug situation. Only one red line was identified by any delegation throughout that negotiation process. In response to that red line, the European Union let go of a priority in the spirit of constructiveness and compromise. we did not insist on the inclusion of a clear reference to measures aimed at preventing and minimising the adverse public health and social consequences of non-medical drug use. We are therefore dismayed to note that one delegation has identified this red line, that had subsequently been accommodated, and has now decided to table two amendments that reopen other parts of the agreed compromise. To honour that compromise and to uphold the balance reflected in the text as submitted, The Member States of the European Union will vote no on these amendments and urge all other delegations to do likewise. Thank you.
Thank you, Ireland. I have no other delegation seeking the floor. Accordingly, we will take action on the amendments one by one. Let me first turn to the amendment contained in document L-73, and the Committee will now commence the process of voting on L-73. I remind you of Rule 128. Delegations are requested to indicate their votes, and I pass to the Secretary.
The Committee is now voting on the amendment to draft resolution L/11/Rev.1, entitled “Addressing and countering the world drug problem through a comprehensive, integrated and balanced approach”, as contained in document L/73. The Committee is voting on the amendment contained in document L/73. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The final result is in favour 35 votes, against 72 votes, abstention 47 votes. Therefore, the amendment to draft resolution L14/Rev.1 as contained in document L73 is rejected. We next turn to the amendment contained in document L-74. The committee will commence the process of voting on that proposed amendment. I remind you of rule 128. Please indicate your votes imminently.
The committee is now voting on the amendment to draft resolution L/11, provision 1, as contained in document L-74. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The final vote is 11 votes in favour, 92 votes against, 46 abstentions. Accordingly, the amendment to draft resolution L-11/Rev.1 as contained in document L-74 is rejected. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or a general statement following the vote on those amendments? I have no delegation seeking the floor. Since the amendments contained in documents L-73 and L-74 have been rejected, we will proceed to take a decision on draft resolution L-11/Rev.1 as a whole. As you'll be aware, a recorded vote has been requested on that resolution. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or explanation of vote before we proceed to the vote? I have the United States.
Thank you, Mr. Chair. The United States firmly supports efforts to neutralize the world drug problem. We remain committed to dismantling narco-terrorists and other transnational criminal organizations that manufacture, transport, and distribute deadly illicit narcotics worldwide. and we support such efforts around the world. Our disengagement from this resolution’s negotiation and our lack of support of the final draft does not signal an argument over the merits of countering the global trade in illegal drugs. In fact, the United States has taken decisive action to reduce that trade, and we will continue to do so. The United States does not support this resolution because it politicizes the work of this body without seriously advancing the UN's primary mandates of international peace and security. We reject the wasteful exercise of spending time and resources revisiting this resolution every two years and continuing to add to its length. Furthermore, this effort duplicates work being adequately addressed by experts at the UN Office on Drugs and Crime in Vienna. a forum expressly designed to handle efforts addressed by this resolution and where international counternarcotics policy belongs. Today's resolution offers a misguided approach to the illicit drug trade, placing the focus overwhelmingly on addressing the world drug problem through public health initiatives rather than dismantling of terrorist and criminal organizations responsible for perpetuating it. the exact opposite of advancing international peace and security. As such, we have refrained from engagement, both in negotiations as well as the consideration of the resolution for adoption, to avoid expending human and financial resources on this exercise. Third Committee resolutions should be short, actionable, and forward-looking. Instead, many continue to include problematic language referencing the SDGs and gender that does nothing to advance the United Nations core mandate of maintaining international peace and security. Finally, we reiterate that General Assembly resolutions are non-binding instruments that do not create legal obligations for sovereign states or alter international law. Thank you, Chair.
I thank the United States. Japan has also requested the floor. Japan.
Thank you, Mr. Chair.
Japan would like to express its sincere appreciation to Mexico for its leadership in facilitating this indispensable resolution. As the resolution mentions, the rapid emergence and illicit distribution of New non-scheduled substances and designer precursor chemicals, as well as the illicit manufacture of and trafficking in synthetic drugs.
And the trafficking and diversion of precursor chemicals pose a grave risk to our international community.
Transnational criminal organizations enable illicit drug flows across borders, requiring robust international cooperation to effectively counter this threat, including the sharing of experiences and best practices. Additionally, human rights-based and scientific evidence-based approaches are essential.
While the World Drug.
Problem is primarily discussed in Vienna, raising global awareness also requires active engagement at the discussions here in New York.
Japan believes that this resolution is of great significance to this end. Furthermore, by focusing on a limited number of paragraphs this year, we were.
Able to engage in intensive and in-depth discussion in which Japan participated constructively.
Japan has been actively providing capacity-building assistance in close cooperation with UN entities, including UNODC, and remains committed to doing so.
For these reasons, Japan has joined as a co-sponsor of this resolution and will vote in favor. We encourage other Member States to do the same.
I thank you, Mr. Chair.
Thank you, Japan. I have no other delegation seeking the floor, in which case we will now commence the process of voting on draft resolution L/11/Rev.1. I remind colleagues of rule 128 in relation to interruptions. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes.
The Committee is now voting on draft resolution AC3/81/L.11, revision 1, entitled “Addressing and countering the world drug problem through a comprehensive, integrated and balanced approach”. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting is completed. Please lock the voting machine.
The final vote is in favour 151 votes, against one vote, and abstentions 26. Accordingly, draft resolution A/C3/81/L.11 (Rev. 1) is adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or general statement following the vote that's just taken place? I have a number of delegations. I turn first to Argentina, to be followed by China.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Argentina recognizes the efforts that all delegations made during the negotiations, and we reaffirm our commitment to international cooperation to address the world drug problem. This requires a comprehensive, integrated, and balanced approach that is evidence-based and that takes into account national realities and sovereign rights and allows for effective responses to be rolled out to address problems pertaining to drugs. Nevertheless, the resolution does not adequately reflect Argentina's position, and that is why we abstained in the vote. First of all, we are concerned by the inclusion of references to the so-called gender perspective in drug-related programs. We must bear in mind the specific needs of persons, bearing in mind objective criteria and the particularities of each state of affairs, without recurring to concepts that have not been agreed internationally. Secondly, the reaffirmation of the 2030 Agenda and the SDGs as a yardstick to refer to this issue does not reflect our country's position. International cooperation should be based on legal foundations and agreements that states have signed up to without making political programs binding in nature. In addition, references to financing international organizations should respect the budget competencies of each state and the voluntary nature of contributions. That is why we cannot support provisions that urge countries to increase financial contributions or to provide support to them without bearing in mind national priorities and the budget capabilities of each state. We believe that multilateral cooperation should be focused on specific results, respecting each country's sovereignty, the diversity of our legal systems, and the priorities that each country may have. The effectiveness of international efforts does not hinge on including problematic references or categories that do not have adequate support. Lastly, Mr. Chairman, Our abstention does not mean that we do not understand the importance of international cooperation to address the global drug problem, but rather we have specific reservations on specific parts of the text that we are not able to support, and we would like to reaffirm our commitment to effective solutions which respect state sovereignty and the international obligations that states have assumed. Thank you.
Thank you, Argentina. Our final speaker for this morning, before we resume at 3:00 PM this afternoon, is China. China, you have the floor.
Chair, at present, the global drug problem is complex and grave. Synthetic drugs, drug abuse, and drug-related organized crime, and other new issues and challenges continue to emerge, posing serious threats to people's health, security, and well-being. There is an urgent need for the international community to consolidate consensus, strengthen unity, and jointly counter the world drug problem. China actively participated in the consultations on the draft resolution introduced by Mexico. We thank the facilitator for facilitating these consultations in an open, transparent manner. The draft resolution reaffirms the goals and objectives of the three international drug control conventions. maintains an overall balance between reducing drug supply and demand, and recognizes the principle of common shared responsibility. China acknowledges these efforts. At the same time, in terms of clearly affirming the authoritative status of three international conventions and other areas, there remains room for improvement. With regard to policy concepts, relevant documents, and institutional arrangements where clear differences remain in the international community, a more prudent and inclusive approach should be upheld. Positions within individual mechanisms or specific policy frameworks should not be simply extended to the international drug control system as a whole. In view of the above, China abstained from the voting on the draft resolution. Chair, the Chinese government maintains a firm position on drug control and adopts a comprehensive and systematic approach to the drug problem, which has achieved notable results. China earnestly fulfills international obligations on drug control, continues to deepen practical cooperation with relevant UN agencies and countries, and actively carries out cooperation in drug law enforcement. information exchange, and experience sharing, making positive contributions to addressing global drug challenges. China is ready to continue working with the international community to firmly uphold the international drug control system based on the three international drug control conventions and advance the global governance of the drug problem. Thank you, Chair.
Thank you, China. The Committee will reconvene at 3 PM to continue our consideration of this item and hear the remaining speakers. I adjourn the meeting, and we will resume at 3. Nearly there. Well done.