The situation in Libya - Security Council, 10275th meeting
Machine-readable formats: Plain text · JSON
Transcript
Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. Learn more
So, yes. The 10,275th meeting of the Security Council is called to order. The provisional agenda for this meeting is the situation in Libya. The agenda is adopted. In accordance with rule 39 of the Council's provisional rules of procedure, I invite Mr. Mamun Mandiye Niang, acting Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, to participate in this meeting. It is so decided. The Security Council will now begin its consideration of item 2 of the agenda. And I now give the floor to Acting Prosecutor Mame Mandié Niang. You have the floor, sir, and we can't hear you yet. We have no sound. Can you hear us? Can you show a sign? Can you hear us, sir? Can you hear us? Good, but we cannot hear you.
We are open.
Yes, now we can.
Okay.
You have the floor, sir. You may start.
Madame la Présidente, merci de m'avoir donné l'occasion de. Madam President, thank you for giving me an opportunity to address the Security Council today. Please allow me to also express my thanks to His Excellency, the Permanent Representative of Libya to the United Nations. And it is with regret that I am compelled to address you remotely, and this is because of the sanctions imposed by the United States Government. Madam President, Your Excellencies, The report that I am presenting to you shows very clearly that despite the coercive measures and despite the attacks, the ICC and its partners continue obtaining concrete results for the victims in Libya as we implement the mandate entrusted to us by this Council. And it is in the hearing chamber of the ICC that this progress can be seen most clearly. On the 16th of July, the pre-trial chamber of the ICC confirmed the 17 war crime charges against Khaled Mohamed Ali el-Hishri. They include murder, torture, persecution, and rape. This is an important moment for justice in Libya, and based on the courage of the Libyan victims and those who step forward to work with the ICC and provide others with testimony. And this forced the opening of the black box of the suffering in the Mitiga prison and other detention centres in Libya. The histories, the stories that we heard by the victims here at the ICC were extraordinary. We heard about women, children and men illegally detained, physical and psychological torture, which was systematic, their families targeted, presumed sexual attacks using their religion for political reasons, women, men, and children raped. The victims had a lot of courage, and they told us about the deep impact the Mitiga had on them. And let me quote, this is what they told us: "The arrest and torture were just the beginning of an earthquake which broke everything that I had hitherto considered stable in my life. The voice of the oppressed, the cries of people under torture, the darkness of the prison cells still keep within them my soul and my spirit. I never really left the prison. My body may have left, My spirit, my mind is left there. And I keep those memories as a wound that will never heal, trying through the pain to find justice, a sense of equity, and some kind of light that can dissipate the darkness that it had placed within me. So this witness and other victims of Mitiga didn't suffer from one crime, but from many committed repeatedly during their detention. And our position is unambiguous. Mr. El-Hishri was an architect and the main perpetrator of these deliberate abuses. The confirmation of all the charges against Mr. El-Hishri shows that through our rigorous work, with the assistance from our partners, we can honor the courage of the victims who cooperated with our office. The opening of the proceedings against Mr. El-Hishri on 4 May 2027 will be an important step in the judicial proceedings and an opportunity for the victims of the crimes committed by Mr. El-Hishri to tell their story and to have their day in court, and the Office of the Prosecutor is ready for these proceedings. Madam President, Your Excellencies, the progress we have seen in the hearing chamber of the ICC shows how dynamic our work is regarding the situation in Libya. Our investigators Along the main lines of the investigations concerning the crimes of what happened between 2014 and 2020, crimes against migrants also proceed in a targeted and rigorous manner. Thanks to interviews of witnesses and the collection of data and geolocalization, the Office obtained information and very clear evidence to allow us to move forward. And the decisions of the Pre-Trial Chamber of the ICC during the period covered in the report you have in front of you These decisions show that the Court is competent in the N’Jem and El Ishri cases, and it strengthened the foundation of our work. Madam President, Your Excellencies, at this crucial point, we also need to be thinking of the way we have gotten to this point. manner in which we have been able to show to the world what had been happening within the walls of Mitiga. It's not for the ICC alone or the position of our mandate and its people to do that. It's through our partnership, through collective work, on the basis of the mandate issued by this Council, and by pooling the efforts between the victims, the Libyan authorities, civil society, and all of its international partners that we will be able to do that. Our cooperation with the civil society in particular has been critical, and our commitment to strengthen our partnership has never been stronger. In the most recent report, it is shown that our office had 143 interactions with civil society partnerships, in particular through a virtual roundtable that we organized in July. And let me state here that more than 43 organizations participated in this with my colleague, another acting prosecutor, Madame Khan, and I welcome their participation, their determination to work with us despite the hostile context. This cooperation was fruitful in the El-Hishri case, but it's just a first step. Our partnership is based to last and provide advantages to the victims through our various lines of investigation. Madam President, Your Excellencies, in the course of the six months, recent six months, this spirit of partnership and cooperation has also strengthened vis-à-vis the Libyan authorities. And I would like to underscore the very strong dialogue we have developed. with the office of Mr. Mohamed Elnifry, who is the president of the Presidential Council, and Mr. Bagad, the prime minister of Libya. And I also congratulate the work done by the Libyan Ambassador in the Netherlands. And it wasn’t just words; it was a kind of cooperation that provided tangible results in our investigation and strengthened the basis for the political process and stability. And this is the spirit of the mandate given by the Council. The recent request for assistance from Libya, asking our office to provide assistance as regards a presumed terrorist attack in Tripoli, is proof positive of the fact that this is not a one-way partnership. It shows that it is based on mutual assistance. And as you will see in the report you are considering, our cooperation with the Prosecutor General of Libya has seen a very interesting development with, in particular, the recent issue of death certificate of Saif al-Islam al-Qadhafi. And we, of course, welcome this kind of a strengthened cooperation with the Office of the Prosecutor General. Here, I would like to underscore a more decisive action of a suspect by ICC, Mr. Osama al-Wasrini Njem. We were informed of the fact that he was sentenced in Libya, but we do know that Mr. Njem nonetheless is at liberty. He meets whoever he wants, including ministers, his family, and his friends. So I don't think he is quite facing justice. We know what the challenges are for the national justice in Libya, and they are huge, given the atrocities committed by the militias, the Rada, for example. We hope nonetheless that with the constructive dialogue we have undertaken with the Office of the Prosecutor General, the case of El-Hishri will be a catalyst, and at one point, the victims in Libya will come to the fore. And our office is always well disposed towards helping the Prosecutor General in Libya in this work. Madam President, Your Excellencies, This partnership is crucial in our efforts to render justice. And ICC is not the only body to dispense justice. We also have, as I said, an investigation of crimes against migrants in the Horn of Africa. And there we had cooperation from various national authorities and Europol. And this kind of a synergy continues providing very good results. On the 20th of October, 2026, Mushikena Zacharias and Mariam was in a court in the Netherlands, is accused of participating in a criminal organization which is involved in human trafficking, hostage taking, extortion, violence, including sexual violence, committed in Libya. The Office shared its information with the Dutch authorities, and this directly supported the national investigations, our collective action yet once again provided greater justice to the victims. Our politics of complementarity and cooperation therefore has a real impact. The cooperation between jurisdictions gives results either within our hearing chambers or national courts, and we are committed to providing greater support to national authorities in situations which are relevant. Madam President, Your Excellencies, to conclude, I would like to make a broader comment beyond the situation that we are discussing today. The history of progress accomplished in Libya is the history of ICC as a whole in many respects. The greater increasing number of victims and communities which were impacted are coming forward to ask to work with us. Increasing numbers of victims which have no other recourse place all of their hopes in the capacity of the Court to render justice. And we can thus note the the creativity and dynamic nature of our cooperation with national actors, whilst we recognize, with all humility, that national jurisdiction have primacy and who need to be supported in their work. And through all of this, We show that international law can give victims what they are looking for when we work together. And it is the spirit of solidarity, progress, and engagement produced results as regards the victims of atrocities, and as we are witnessing in all of the situations in front of us. And I would like to say Those who are trying to undermine the Court should know that this kind of collective work will allow the victims in Libya to face their aggressor and demand justice. And ultimately, if you are undermining us, you are undermining that. representative of the Office of the Prosecutor, I can assure the Council that our work continues in the trial chambers with the victims on the ground, and our work will continue with all of the national partners. A victim, just to quote one stated in its witness account: "I will only Stop when justice is done. That's what we're told by one of the victims. And it is with this that I would like to conclude this, because if you bear this in mind, you'll understand that we need to stay the course, stay the course as we discharge our mandate. Thank you.
I thank Acting Prosecutor Nuyang for his briefing. And I now give the floor to those Council members who wish to make statements. And I give the floor to the representative of Liberia.
Thank you. Thank you, Madam President. Liberia thanks the Acting Prosecutor for his briefing and welcomes the 32nd report of the Prosecutor on the situation in Libya. The confirmation of charges against Khalid Mohammed Ali el-Hishri brings the Court closer to its first trial arising from the Council's referral of the situation in Libya under resolution 1970 of 2011. A Council referral must be followed by sustained Council responsibility. Victims should not have to wait indefinitely for the cooperation that makes justice possible. Liberia welcomes the improving cooperation between the Office of the Prosecutor and the Libyan authorities, as well as Libya's declaration accepting the Court's jurisdiction under Article 12(3) of the Rome Statute. We also welcome efforts to support domestic investigations and strengthen national capacity. For Liberia, complementarity must deliver lasting national capacity to investigate and prosecute serious crimes. International justice should reinforce credible national efforts and help establish sustainable accountability. Outstanding arrest warrants nevertheless remain unexecuted. We urge the relevant Libyan authorities to respond fully to the Court’s request for information and assistance, and to cooperate in the arrest and surrender of persons sought by the Court. Madam President, Liberia wishes to draw particular attention to the situation of migrants. The allegations on the of migrants at Mitiga prison are deeply disturbing. The proceedings must advance with full respect for fair trial guarantees and the presumption of innocence. For migrants, vulnerability can deepen when nationality, race, religion, or gender becomes a basis for abuse. Their status must never diminish their protection or their access to justice. Migrant victims and survivors should be able to engage safely and meaningfully with justice processes. Their experiences must be heard, and victims and witnesses must receive appropriate protection. We value the continued engagement between the Office of the Prosecutor, civil society, and affected communities. Civil society provides a vital bridge to victims whom formal institutions may struggle to reach. Sustaining that engagement strengthens investigations and public confidence in justice. Madam President, for Liberia, the message from this reporting period is straightforward. Progress must now be matched by implementation. This requires cooperation from Libya, support from states, execution of outstanding warrants, and sustained engagements by this Council. The Court and its officials must be able to discharge their mandates independently, and without intimidation. As co-focal point of the Security Council ICC Caucus, Liberia will continue to work with fellow caucus members and the wider Council to support cooperation with the Court and credible efforts to advance accountability in Libya. Ultimately, the measure of our efforts will not be the number of reports presented or commitments made, but whether victims and affected communities see meaningful progress towards justice. And I thank you for your kind attention.
I thank the representative of Liberia for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of Denmark.
Thank you, Madam President, and thank you, Acting Prosecutor Nyang, for your briefing. We do regret that you were not able to brief the Council in person today, as a reflection of the unfortunate consistent practice of non-issuance of visa for these ICC briefings. We reiterate our concern that this severely limits the Council’s opportunity to follow up on important matters it referred to the ICC. Madam President, allow me to make three points. First, Denmark welcomes the continued progress made by the Office of the Prosecutor in the context of its mandate under resolution 1970. We are particularly pleased to note the progress in the landmark proceedings in the case of Mr. El-Hissy. The trial, expected to commence in May next year, marks an important milestone and turning point for victims of atrocity crimes and affected communities in Libya. We also thank the Office of the Prosecutor for its updates and expectations. on the completion of the investigations under this referral. While challenges continue to lie ahead, we do appreciate the Office’s sustained commitment and encourage it to continue its work towards completion, as outlined in previous briefings, as well as its continued engagement with civil society, human rights defenders, and other stakeholders. Madam President, my second point. We welcome the Libyan Government’s positive high-level engagement with the Office of the Prosecutor, as we just heard from the Acting Prosecutor, as well as the improvements in cooperation and dialogue in general, in line with resolution 1970. This strengthened partnership can hopefully contribute to preventing further atrocity crimes in Libya. We are, however, once again compelled to urge the Libyan Attorney General to increase its cooperation with the Court in accordance with its obligations including by arresting and surrendering suspects subject to ICC arrest warrants. Third, we reiterate that continued support for the Court's efforts to ensure accountability is essential to secure justice for victims and ultimately to achieve lasting reconciliation in Libya. This support also strengthens UNSMIL's efforts to promote sustainable peace in Libya. This is a shared objective for every member of this Council. Madam President, this is the last regular ICC briefing on Libya that Denmark will participate in during our current term on the Security Council. I would like to take this opportunity to reaffirm our unwavering support for the Court as an independent judicial institution. In this context, Denmark deeply regrets the US decision to impose new sanctions on the ICC. which seriously impact the work of the Court, victims, and the investigation of the most serious international crimes, including those committed in Libya. Denmark remains firm in its commitment to defend the Court and the principles and values enshrined in the Rome Statute. I thank you.
I thank the representative of Denmark for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of Greece.
Thank you, Madam President. I would like to thank Acting Prosecutor Niang for his briefing and the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court for the 32nd report to the Security Council pursuant to resolution 1970 on the referral of the situation in Libya. Madam President, a few significant developments are indeed highlighted in this report. In the El-Hissy case, the Court confirmed its jurisdiction and told charges against the accused. Following the confirmation of charges, the case is expected to proceed to trial marking an important milestone in the Court’s proceedings concerning Libya since the Security Council’s referral in 2011. Similarly, in the Njume case, the Court rejected challenges to its jurisdiction while requesting further information on challenges regarding admissibility. These developments constitute meaningful progress in advancing accountability for crimes falling within the Court’s jurisdiction in Libya. Despite threats and sanctions directed against it, the Office of the Prosecutor collected over 1,300 items of evidence, screened and assessed more than 41 witnesses, and conducted more than 17 missions in eight States. In light of the above, Greece wishes to underscore the following points. First, the Court, in its pre-trial chamber decisions on jurisdiction in the El-Husri and Tengim cases, found that a sufficient link existed between the alleged crimes and the crisis situation that triggered the referral under Security Council Resolution 1970, and that its jurisdiction is therefore not limited to the 2011 violence. This finding is important in supporting that the lines of inquiry in the situation in Libya cover the period subsequent to the 2011 violence, as set out in the report of the Office of the Prosecutor. Second, Greece welcomes the endorsement of the declaration under Article 12, paragraph 3 of the ICC Statute by the President of the Presidential Council of Libya on 19 September 2026. At the same time, the cooperation of the Libyan national authorities with the OTP remains insufficient, in particular regarding the execution of arrest warrants for suspects residing in Libya. According to the report, prospects for effective domestic proceedings against these suspects remain uncertain while they continue to remain at liberty in Libya. Furthermore, the cooperation from the Libyan Attorney General has been limited, with insufficient responses provided to the Office of the Prosecutor in this regard. My third point relates to the empowerment of victims, witnesses, affected communities, and civil society organizations. We welcome the engagement of the Office of the Prosecutor with civil society, and the fact that victims and these organizations followed closely the developments in the judicial proceedings in the El-Hussein and Tanjim cases. Their support remains as important as ever, especially given the volatility of the political and security situation in Libya. We further note that, according to the report, significant resources will be required during the judicial phase for witness protection, which is impacted by limited existing capacities. We would like to underscore, in this respect, that as a matter of principle, Justice should be victim-centered, and that efforts towards political stabilization in Libya must not, under any circumstances, come at the expense of rendering justice, which is the basis for the rule of law and national reconciliation. To conclude, Madam President, we express our regret that the Acting Prosecutor was not able to brief the Counsel in person. Actions and threats against the Court, the Office of the Prosecutor, and its personnel might impact negatively on victims to the extent that they affect its operational capacity, and as a result, as stated in the report, the timeline of the completion of the investigation phase. We wish to underscore our undertaking to uphold and defend the Rome Statute and maintain its integrity against threats and actions aimed against the Court and its officials. I thank you.
I thank the representative of Greece for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of Panama.
Thank you very much, Madam President. We thank the Acting Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Mame-Madye Niang, for his presentation of the 32nd report on the situation in Libya, and we welcome the Permanent Representative of Libya to this meeting. Panama recognizes the important work of the International Criminal Court and the Office of the Prosecutor in carrying out the mandate entrusted to them by this Council through resolution 1970. Fifteen years after the referral, it is incumbent upon the Council to reaffirm its responsibility to support the judicial processes arising from its own decisions. Effective cooperation by States is indispensable if the Court's efforts are to result in concrete progress toward accountability. Panama welcomes the progress recorded in the recent report, which marks a key milestone in the pursuit of justice. We highlight the confirmation last July of charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity against Khaled Mohamed Ali al-Hishri, as well as the procedural developments that will allow the trial phase to begin. As the first trial before the Court arising from the situation in Libya since its referral in 2011, it represents a concrete opportunity for victims of murder, torture, slavery, persecution and sexual violence to gain access to justice with full respect for due process guarantees. We recognize the steady progress of the investigations and the efforts to strengthen evidence collection and cooperation with third states, and we take note of the progress made in implementing the Prosecutor’s Roadmap. We also welcome the increased engagement with civil society organizations, survivors, and women human rights defenders. Their participation and protection must remain central elements of the investigations, particularly with regard to crimes committed against migrants. We acknowledge the progress made in cooperation with the Libyan authorities and reiterate that complementarity must translate into verifiable advances. and accountability. To this end, it is essential that cooperation with the Libyan authorities extend to the execution of outstanding arrest warrants, the timely exchange of information, and the strengthening of national judicial capacities. As a State party to the Rome Statute, Panama reaffirms its support for the independence and impartiality of the International Criminal Court. and rejects any coercive measures or reprisals directed against the institution, its personnel, or those who cooperate with it. We are particularly concerned that such measures could jeopardize the timelines envisaged for concluding investigations and preparing judicial proceedings. This is why weakening the court's capacity at this stage would mean undermining the progress achieved after years of investigation and international cooperation. For Panama, accountability is not an effort that is parallel to the political process in Libya, but rather it is an indispensable component of consolidating that process, strengthening institutions, and overcoming cycles of violence and impunity. To conclude, Madam President, the Libyan people and the migrants who have suffered the consequences of these grave crimes deserve truth, justice, and guarantees of non-repetition. The commencement of a trial does not represent the culmination of accountability efforts, but rather a new phase requiring sustained cooperation, protection of victims, and respect for judicial independence. For Panama, justice and accountability are inextricable elements of efforts to achieve a sustainable political solution in Libya. For this reason, the progress achieved must translate into effective justice for victims and guarantees of non-repetition as part of efforts to build a future of peace, stability, and the rule of law for the Libyan people. Thank you.
I thank the representative of Panama for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of China.
President, I thank Acting Prosecutor Nyon for his briefing. China notes the 32nd report submitted by the Office of the Prosecutor on the situation in Libya, as well as the International Criminal Court's work regarding relevant cases such as investigations, prosecutions, and trials. Fifteen years have passed since the Council's adoption of resolution 1970 in 2011. The international community should reflect earnestly on how to uphold international judicial justice, while effectively responding to the Libyan people's aspirations for peace, stability, and justice. I wish to emphasize the following three points. First, the court should always perform its duties in strict accordance with the law. International judicial mechanisms play an important role in punishing international crimes and combating impunity. They must always safeguard international credibility, their very lifeline. by performing their mandate in an independent, objective, and impartial manner. Whether in investigating and adjudicating the situation in Libya or addressing other major issues, the Court should always exercise its mandate on the basis of facts and the applicable law, and fully ensure fairness and transparency in judicial proceedings. International judicial mechanisms should not be subject to political interference, nor should they become tools for selective pressure. We hope the court will listen attentively to the legitimate concerns of all parties and take concrete actions to enhance international trust in its work. Second, the court should properly handle the relationship between international and domestic justice. China consistently maintains that international criminal justice should not substitute the judicial functions of the countries concerned. and that the principles of international cooperation and complementarity established in the Rome Statute must be fully respected. In investigating and adjudicating relevant cases, the Court must fully respect Libya's judicial sovereignty and take seriously its legitimate concerns. On the basis of mutual equality and consultation on an equal footing, the Court should strengthen communication and coordination with Libyan judicial authorities and the general public. respond to victims' demands through concrete actions, and further win the understanding and support of the Libyan people. Third, all parties should support Libya in accelerating the unification of state institutions. Libya has long been mired in political stalemate, and the recent division of its judicial institutions has further compounded the complex situation, constraining the operation of its domestic judicial system. While respecting the Libyan-led and Libyan-owned principle, the international community should work jointly to push the relevant Libyan parties to resolve differences through dialogue and consultation, engage in UN-led good offices in good faith, and establish unified, independent judicial institutions to safeguard the integrity and authority of the judicial system. Countries outside the region should provide constructive assistance to Libya in advancing political transition and unified state institutions, while refraining from improper interference or external pressure. President, Libya is currently at a critical juncture in achieving national unification and restoring peace and stability. As a good friend of Libya, China has always respected Libya's sovereignty, independence, and territorial integrity. and supported Libya in exploring a development path suited to its national conditions. China stands ready to work with all parties to continue playing a constructive role in promoting fairness and justice in Libya and restoring lasting peace and stability. I thank you, President.
I thank the representative of China for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of France.
Madam President, I would like to first of all thank the Acting Prosecutor Njeng for presenting the 32nd report under resolution 1970 of this Council. France regrets the fact that he was unable to address the Council in person. We regret that for the third time the representative of the Office of the Prosecutor is speaking before this Council only remotely. Nothing would justify this becoming the norm. And with this proviso, I would like to make three remarks. First, the Court's action in Libya yields results which are consistent with the mandate entrusted to it by the Council. Through its resolute and impartial action, the ICC provides a horizon of justice and reparation to the victims who now see the outcome of the process. The Ali al-Hisri case will therefore be the first trial related to the situation in Libya. And finally, Some of these crimes that shock the universal conscience will be judged, and finally, accounts will be given to the victims. This is a strong signal to the Libyan people that those responsible for the most serious crimes will have to be held accountable. This upcoming trial is a result of meticulous work carried out under difficult conditions. The continuation of other cases in parallel suggests that the perseverance of the Office of the Prosecutor will lead to further progress. And in this regard, we recall the importance of full cooperation by all concerned states with the Court in executing arrest warrants. Second, the Court adopted an effective strategy by basing its work on cooperation with Libyan authorities, third states, and civil society. The relationship of trust established between the Court and the Libyan authorities appears to be strengthening. The new request for assistance sent to the Court is witness to that. It usefully complements the cooperation established under Resolution 1970 and the declaration made by Libya under Article 12, paragraph 3 of the Rome Statute. France. welcomes this positive momentum, which was confirmed by Libya's vote in favor of the resolution on the Court's annual report to the General Assembly. To those who sometimes claim to doubt it, this vote completes the demonstration of a simple reality, namely that the ICC is not acting against Libyan sovereignty, but rather for its restoration, not against the Libyan government, but with its assistance. Cooperation established under the principle of complementarity also yields results. An example is given with the Dutch judicial authorities, whose resolute action against those responsible for serious human rights violations involved in human trafficking is combined with that of the Court, Italy, and Europol. Added to this is the Office's ongoing dialogue with civil society organisations, which helps give meaning to the Court's actions. Thirdly, the progress made demonstrates that the ICC's action contributes to that of the United Nations and to the revival of the political process in Libya. Indeed, when unimaginable atrocities are committed, only justice can open a horizon of reconciliation. The progress made in recent months testifies to the Libyan people's aspiration for justice and their refusal of impunity. Through its actions, the Court contributes to consolidating the political process in Libya, to which France reiterates its support. This momentum is essential to advance towards implementing the UN Roadmap to lead the country to free, transparent, and inclusive elections under the aegis of a unified executive. True to its commitment to justice, France gives its full support to the International Criminal Court, which must be able to independently and impartially fulfill the mission entrusted to it by the States in the service of universal objectives. This support also implies a refusal on our part refusal of sanctions imposed on the Court and all those who cooperate with the Court. Moreover, if these sanctions were to apply to those who, under resolution 1970, adopted under Chapter VII, are obliged to cooperate with the Court, they would be directly contrary to the authority of the Council's decisions. Only the withdrawal of these sanctions will remove this inconvenience. France renews its call in this regard. I thank you.
I thank the representative of France for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of Bahrain.
Thank you, Madam President. First, we thank the Acting Prosecutor of the ICC, Mr. Mende Ngang, and we take note of his briefing. In light of the briefing and the relevant developments, the Kingdom of Bahrain wishes to focus on three key points. First, we stress the importance of respecting the judicial sovereignty of the Libyan State. The Kingdom of Bahrain reaffirms its position on the importance of respecting the judicial sovereignty of the Libyan state and of strengthening cooperation with the International ICC in accordance with the principle of complementarity. in a manner that supports the role of national judicial institutions and their ownership of the judicial process. In this context, the Kingdom notes the recent developments. These include the affirmation by the President of the Libyan Presidential Council last September of Libya's commitment to its declaration under Article 12, paragraph 3 of the Rome Statute. They also include the request by the Libyan authorities for technical and legal assistance from the Court to support their national investigations into a terrorist plot to target civilian facilities. This strengthens cooperation within the framework of respect for national jurisdictions. It also supports the capacity of the Libyan judicial authorities to discharge their responsibilities in achieving justice and accountability. Second, respect for international law and support for national efforts in Libya. The Kingdom of Bahrain reaffirms the primary responsibility of states to respect and implement international law. including international humanitarian law, and to prevent the most serious crimes and hold their perpetrators accountable. This must be in accordance with the fundamental principles of international law, foremost among them respect for the sovereignty of states and the principle of complementarity. The Kingdom also stresses the importance of supporting Libyan national institutions and strengthening their capacity to achieve justice. It stresses the importance of backing Libyan, UN, and international efforts aimed at consolidating national reconciliation, unity, security, and stability in a manner that meets the aspirations of the fraternal Libyan people. Third, the need to intensify cooperation with the Libyan authorities in cases requiring cross-border measures. The Kingdom of Bahrain reaffirms the importance of continuing to strengthen coordination among the Office of the Prosecutor, the Libyan authorities, and the States concerned. This applies in particular to cases requiring cross-border judicial cooperation. That includes the execution of arrest warrants and procedures for the surrender of wanted persons outside Libyan territory. It also stresses that these procedures must be carried out in accordance with international law and in a manner that respects the sovereignty and judicial jurisdiction of Libya. They must ensure effective cooperation among the competent authorities and contribute to implementing legal obligations, strengthening accountability, and combating impunity. In conclusion, The Kingdom of Bahrain reaffirms its support for United Nations and international efforts aimed at strengthening the capacities of Libyan national institutions and consolidating the rule of law, justice, and national reconciliation. This will contribute to achieving security and stability and to fulfilling the aspirations of the fraternal Libyan people. I thank you.
I thank the representative of Bahrain for the statement, and I now give the floor to the representative of the Democratic Republic of the Congo.
Madam President, my delegation takes note of the 32nd report of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court on the situation in Libya, a situation referred to the Court by this Security Council pursuant to resolution 1970 of 2011 and in accordance with the relevant provisions of article 13 of the Rome Statute. It commends the Office of the Prosecutor for the progress achieved in investigations, judicial proceedings, and the strengthening of cooperation with partner States. Madam President, the situation in Libya remains a major concern for international criminal justice. Since 2011, The country has continued to face armed conflict, institutional and political fragmentation, as well as serious violations of human rights and international humanitarian law. The period from May to November 2026 was marked by significant judicial developments, notably in the case of Khalid Mohamed Ali Al-Hishri, but also by persistent difficulties relating to cooperation by the Libyan authorities, the execution of outstanding arrest warrants, the protection of victims and witnesses, as well as developments in the proceedings concerning Osama al-Masry and Jim. With regard to judicial progress, the case of Khaled Mohamed Ali El Ishry, a former alleged official of Mitiga Prison in Tripoli, constitutes an important development. The confirmation of charges paves the way for the first ICC trial arising from the situation in Libya. This progress demonstrates how international investigations can lead to concrete judicial proceedings, even many years after the events in question, while respecting the presumption of innocence and the guarantees of a fair trial. In terms of cooperation, the arrest of El Hishri by the German authorities illustrates the importance of international judicial cooperation. However, The execution of outstanding arrest warrants, access to evidence, and cooperation from the competent authorities remain major challenges. Developments concerning Osama al-Masry and Jim also underscore the importance of respecting the legal framework of the Rome Statute, particularly with regard to jurisdiction, admissibility, and complementarity. It is therefore important to strengthen dialogue between the Court and Libyan institutions, while respecting the Court's independence. Furthermore, the fight against impunity must place victims at the center of its efforts. Victims of torture, sexual violence, and arbitrary detention, as well as the families of missing persons, deserve particular attention. Their participation in proceedings, the documentation of violations, the preservation of evidence, and the protection of witnesses are indispensable to achieving effective and credible justice. Despite the progress achieved, institutional fragmentation, difficulties in gathering evidence, and the execution of warrants continue to limit the effectiveness of the Court’s work. Strengthening national judicial capacities and enhancing complementarity between Libyan courts and the ICC remain essential to preventing all forms of impunity. Madam President, the judicial progress recorded in Libya is encouraging, but this should not obscure the persistent challenges. International criminal justice alone cannot resolve Libya’s political and institutional crisis. Nevertheless, it remains essential for establishing individual responsibility, acknowledging the suffering of victims, and contributing to lasting peace founded on law and justice. The situation in Libya recalls a fundamental requirement of international law: no conflict, no political instability, and no official position can justify impunity for the most serious crimes. The Democratic Republic of the Congo reaffirms its commitment to the fight against impunity and emphasizes that the effectiveness of the ICC's work depends not only on the determination of the Office of the Prosecutor, but also on the concrete commitment of States and the international community. In this regard, my delegation proposes four priorities to guide the collective effort. Firstly, strengthen judicial cooperation between the ICC, the Libyan authorities, and partner states, particularly to facilitate the execution of arrest warrants in accordance with international obligations. Secondly, consolidate national investigative and prosecutorial capacities, particularly through the collection of forensic evidence, its preservation, and the documentation of violations in cooperation with civil society organizations. Third, ensure the protection and effective participation of victims, witnesses, and human rights defenders, so that their rights and dignity are fully taken into account in judicial proceedings. Fourth, and finally, support national reconciliation initiatives while respecting the requirements of justice, criminal accountability and the fight against impunity. Thank you.
I thank the representative of the Democratic Republic of the Congo for the statement. I now give the floor to the representative of Somalia.
Thank you, Madam President. We thank the ICC Acting Prosecutor, Ms. Nyang, for the briefing. We also take note of the ICC's 32nd report pursuant to resolution 1970. Madam President, while justice and accountability are central to peace and stability in Libya, transitional justice remains vital to achieving national reconciliation and lasting peace in the country. In that context, my delegation would like to make the following points. First, strengthening national justice institutions must remain a priority. empowering national authorities to lead this process. An environment that builds the capacity of local institutions to administer justice remains essential for sustainable peace. We therefore welcome Libya’s continued engagement with the Office of the Prosecutor, including the recent request for technical and legal assistance in support of domestic investigations. Second, existing legal frameworks should be reinforced and, where appropriate, adapted to respond to evolving circumstances and the needs of Libyan authorities. In this regard, we note the confirmation of charges against Mr. El-Heshary and the scheduling of his trial for May 2027. marking the first trial proceedings in Libya’s situation since 2011. We reiterate that true judicial accountability is sustainable only when rooted in national efforts and aspirations, and when it reinforces domestic ownership. Third, Libyan leadership in addressing justice must take precedence, supported by regional and African mechanisms including in addressing cross-border challenges and protecting vulnerable populations such as migrants. We stress that this Council should remain vigilant about the role of external factors and monitor these dynamics transparently, including any coercive measures affecting the functioning of international legal bodies, ensuring that sovereign solutions guide the path forward. Madam President, True partnership requires mutual engagement, and we encourage continued constructive dialogue, transparency, and timely information sharing between the Office of Prosecutor and relevant Libyan national legal authorities to achieve shared objectives in a spirit of mutual respect and complementarity. Moreover, a comprehensive approach that integrates judicial accountability, humanitarian support, and diplomatic engagement remains essential to advancing nationally-led initiatives toward justice and peace in Libya. In conclusion, the international community and this Council should fully support Libya’s pursuit of justice, stability, and reconciliation, while respecting Libya’s national ownership, sovereignty, territorial integrity, unity, and political independence. Somalia remains committed to supporting Libya and its people, and playing an active role towards these objectives. I thank you.
I thank the representative of Somalia for the statement and give the floor to the representative of Colombia.
Thank you, Madam President. Colombia welcomes the thanks the Presidency for convening this meeting, and we welcome the Deputy Prosecutor and thank him for presenting the 32nd report. Colombia welcomes the agreement signed in Tripoli on the 30th of August 2026 with a view to holding elections. Nevertheless, the fragile security situation continues to affect investigations and the protection of victims and witnesses. The Council must remain attentive to the risks of escalation. As a State Party to the Rome Statute, Colombia in turn thanks the Office of the Prosecutor for its report and the information contained therein. In particular, Colombia welcomes the confirmation of all charges against Mr. Khalid al-Hishri. His trial will begin on 4 May 2027 and will be the first trial in the Libya situation. My country also takes note of the rejection on 2 November of the jurisdictional challenge submitted by Mr. Osama Ajem. Madam President, although Libya has reaffirmed its declaration under Article 12(3) of the Rome Statute and has requested technical assistance from the Office of the Prosecutor, as noted in the report of the Secretary-General, cooperation by that country's prosecutor general remains insufficient. No response has been provided regarding the announced proceedings against Mr. Enjime, who, according to credible reports, remains at large. In addition, eight public arrest warrants remain unexecuted. In that regard, it should be recalled that Security Council resolution 1970 of this Council obliges the Libyan authorities to cooperate fully with the Court. This is why my country urges the authorities in both the east and the west of the country to respond to the outstanding requests and to execute the arrest warrants that remain in force. Madam President, Colombia takes note of the cooperation of third states and the work of the joint team on crimes against migrants in the central Mediterranean. Colombia is concerned by the Chamber’s findings regarding crimes committed at Mitiga prison against Libyans and migrants, including slavery and persecution. Given the proximity of the trial, my delegation underscores the importance of protecting witnesses and keeping victims at the centre of the process. Likewise, my country will continue to follow closely what the Office of the Prosecutor reports in its next report regarding its goal of completing the investigation phase in 2027. In closing, Colombia reiterates that accountability for the most serious crimes committed contributes to the stability of Libya, while also calling on all States and actors involved to fully implement resolution 1970 of 2011. Thank you very much.
The representative of Colombia for the statement, and I give the floor to the representative of the United Kingdom.
Thank you, Madam President. Let me begin by thanking Acting Prosecutor Niang for the Office of the Prosecutor's report and for his briefing to the Council today. We regret that the Acting Prosecutor was unable to brief the Council in person today. Madam President, I will make three points. First, we welcome the progress reported by the Office of the Prosecutor since our last briefing. In particular, we welcome the confirmation of all 17 charges of war crimes and crimes against humanity against Mr. Khaled Mohamed Ali El-Hishri. as well as the decision to commit his case to trial. The trial, scheduled to commence on 4 May 2027, represents an important further step towards justice for victims and affected communities in Libya. The gravity of the confirmed charges, including murder, torture, enslavement, persecution, rape, and sexual violence, underline the importance of ensuring accountability for victims. The UK further welcomes the strengthened cooperation between the Office of the Prosecutor and the Libyan authorities. This builds on Libya's declaration made under Article 12, paragraph 3 of the Rome Statute in May of 2025. Libya's recent request for assistance from the Court in support of a domestic investigation is a further welcome indication of such cooperation. Additional steps could further strengthen this cooperation. In that regard, we continue to encourage all relevant actors, including the Office of the Attorney General, to respond promptly to outstanding requests for assistance and to cooperate with the Court in relation to outstanding arrest warrants. Second, lasting accountability requires strong, independent, and unified Libyan institutions. In order to further this goal, we continue to encourage all Libyan actors to work towards a sustainable political settlement, including through progress towards free and fair elections. A durable settlement should rest on effective and accountable institutions, including an independent and unified judiciary capable of upholding the rule of law. We urge all actors to avoid steps that may deepen institutional divisions and to engage seriously with the UN-facilitated political process. The United Nations Support Mission in Libya remains central to these efforts, supporting a Libyan-led and Libyan-owned solution that delivers the security, stability, and opportunity that the Libyan people deserve. Third, the United Kingdom reiterates our strong support for the International Criminal Court as an independent and impartial judicial institution. We regret and strongly disagree with the announcement of institutional sanctions against the Court. Measures which impede the Court in carrying out its work undermine our collective efforts to secure accountability for the most serious international crimes. Madam President, to conclude, the UK continues to support the efforts of both Libya and the Office of the Prosecutor to strengthen accountability and the rule of law in Libya. Thank you.
I thank the representative of the United Kingdom for the statement, and I give the floor to the representative of Pakistan.
Thank you, Madam President. We thank the Acting Prosecutor Nyang for presenting the 32nd report of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court pursuant to resolution 1970. We take note of the progress reported by the Office of the Prosecutor, particularly the confirmation of charges against Khaled Mohammed al-Ahri and the scheduling of his trial for May 2027. We also note the continued investigative activities and engagement with the relevant national authorities and international partners. Madam President, I wish to make three points. First, Pakistan reaffirms its unwavering support for Libya's sovereignty, independence, territorial integrity, and national unity. An inclusive Libyan-led and Libyan-owned political process remains essential for lasting peace, stability, and reconciliation. Accountability efforts must reinforce these objectives. Second, While Pakistan is not a party to the Rome Statute, we remain committed to credible and impartial accountability for serious international crimes. We reiterate the importance of ensuring consistency, objectivity, and non-selectivity in the pursuit of international justice. The credibility of international accountability mechanisms depends on their independence, impartiality, and the consistent application of international law without double standards. Third, we recognize the importance of cooperation between the ICC and relevant Libyan authorities in implementing resolution 1970. Such cooperation should respect Libya's judicial institutions and legitimate concerns, while prioritizing national ownership and capacity building to strengthen accountability and the administration of justice. Madam President, Pakistan stands in solidarity with the brotherly people of Libya in their aspirations for lasting peace, stability, and national reconciliation. We reaffirm our support for an inclusive political settlement that brings an end to the prolonged transitional period and reunifies national institutions. I thank you.
I thank the representative of Pakistan for the statement, and I give the floor to the representative of the United States.
Thank you, Madam President. At the outset, I must reiterate our ongoing, unequivocal opposition to the International Criminal Court's attempts to assert jurisdiction over the United States or any U.S. ally that has not consented to ICC jurisdiction. The core U.S. objections to the ICC have been the same for nearly three decades. As our longstanding concerns have not been realized, our response has escalated in proportion to the threat presented by the ICC and to the degree to which our concerns remain unaddressed. Our objectives are clear. The ICC and States Parties have the opportunity to change course. We will continue to take action as needed to safeguard United States interests. Turning now to Libya, the United States remains concerned that the division of Libya’s political, economic, security, and judicial institutions continues to undermine the rule of law. We urge all Libyan actors to respect the integrity of judicial institutions and their rulings, and to avoid actions that could divide the judiciary or weaken public confidence in judicial institutions and their rulings. The United States supports accountability for human rights abuses in Libya and justice for victims, including in official and unofficial detention facilities across the country where abuses occur with impunity. Last month, the United States designated former Libyan judicial police official Oussama al-Masry Habish Najim for his role in gross violations of human rights in the Mitiga and Al-Jadida prisons. We urge Libyan authorities to investigate alleged arbitrary detentions, enforced disappearances, and abuses of Christians and members of other minority groups. U.S. efforts to support the reunification of Libyan institutions are complementary to the UN Roadmap for Libya and are grounded in the desire of the Libyan people for a unified government that serves their interests and respects their fundamental rights and freedoms. We will not hesitate to pursue serious consequences against those who obstruct this Libyan-led political process to unite the country. We also reiterate our longstanding calls on Libyan authorities to ensure that former senior officials of the Qaddafi regime face justice. Ending impunity, for those who commit serious human rights abuses in Libya is critical for the country's continued progress on a path to greater unity, stability, and prosperity. I thank you.
I thank the representative of the United States for their statement, and I give the floor to the representative of the Russian Federation.
Madam President, The UN Security Council is once again forced to spend its time reviewing the sixth month report of the so-called Office of the Prosecutor of the so-called International Criminal Court on the Libyan file. Almost 15 years have passed since the adoption of the 1970 Security Council resolution, and the main conclusion that emerges from the study of the 32nd report is very simple: The ICC not only made no contribution to achieving peace and justice in Libya, it serves the interests of a narrow group of Western states. Madam President, they are trying to present to us as a historic milestone the decision of the pre-trial chamber in July to confirm the charges against Mr. Khaled al-Hishri and to set a date for the start of the trial proceedings. But let's analyse this accomplishment. The first and only defendant to be on trial in The Hague in a decade and a half has nothing to do with the events of 2011, for which the Security Council at the time referred the situation to the ICC for the investigation. This area of investigation is essentially completely closed. The organizers and perpetrators of the NATO military invasion in 2011, which destroyed the Libyan statehood and plunged the prosperous country into the chaos of civil war and triggered a large-scale migration and terrorist crisis in the region, were granted absolute immunity from the ICC. Former Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi was torn to pieces without trial or investigation, and now the ICC Office of the Prosecutor proudly reports on receiving the death certificate of his son, Saif Gaddafi. At first, the ICC acted as an information-gathering accomplice to NATO's aggression, churning out fakes, dehumanizing the Libyan leadership, and then just simply closed cases regarding the murdered people, completely shielding the Western masterminds behind this tragedy. Realizing that it is impossible to report to the Security Council on the results of its main mandate, the ICC Prosecutor's Office has been for many years engaged in unauthorized expansion of its jurisdiction. Without any new Security Council decisions, the Court began to independently carve out new areas of work for itself from the events in Tarhoun in 2014, to crimes in detention facilities and the migrant storyline. If the ICC is now grasping at everything indiscriminately, well, the following question arises: Why do reports of Ukrainian drone operators acting partly on the side of terrorist groups and undermining security in the Mediterranean remain out of its sight? But let us now turn to the direction of investigating crimes against migrants, which the ICC is so proud of in the report reporting on trials in the Netherlands against two smugglers from developing countries. The causes of the catastrophic migration crisis in the Mediterranean are well known. It is a direct consequence of the destruction of the Libyan state by NATO forces in 2011. However, The ICC stubbornly turns a blind eye to the role of European states, not just in this strategy, and also the Frontex agency, whose policies of harsh interceptions at sea, obstruction of rescue operations, and forced return of people to conflict zones regularly leads to the deaths of thousands of migrants. Instead of applying the principle of complementarity and giving a legal assessment of the actions of European authorities, the ICC's Office of the Prosecutor joined the joint investigation team based on Eurojust and Europol and joined forces with those whose activities against migrants should have become subject to independent verification. But as we know, sponsors are not prosecuted in The Hague. All responsibility shifts exclusively to small perpetrators and intermediaries from countries of the Global South. Madam President, The results of the vote held on 2 November 2026 in the UN General Assembly on the latest resolution on the ICC report convincingly confirm the deepening crisis of the legitimacy of this body. The number of States openly opposing its work and abstaining has increased. Even more symptomatic is that in 2026, Six states officially announced their withdrawal from the Rome Statute, explicitly stating in their depository notices that the ICC has completely ceased to meet its original tasks and became a tool of selective and unfair justice for purely political purposes. All of this clearly shows that most countries in the world are rapidly losing the remnants of trust in this puppet tool. Madam President, The Russian Federation has consistently proceeded from the view that a genuine, sustainable settlement in Libya and restoring of justice there is only possible through strengthening sovereign national institutions and achieving national consensus. ICC interference in Libya's internal processes only creates new lines of division, undermines trust between parties, and blocks political process. The true principle of complementarity is being replaced by the imposition of external solutions which ignore the will of the Libyan people. The Security Council needs to make a long overdue decision and withdraw the Libyan file from the ICC, as well as the Darfur file, leaving law enforcement activities to the Libyan authorities themselves, with technical assistance from the relevant UN bodies. I thank you for your attention.
I am the representative of the Russian Federation for the statement, and I shall now make a statement in my capacity as the representative of Latvia. And I thank the Acting Prosecutor Nyang for his comprehensive briefing and for the continued efforts of the Office of the Prosecutor to advance accountability for crimes committed in Libya. And we welcome the significant progress reflected in the 32nd report. And I would like to highlight three points. First, there is tangible progress in the fight against impunity. Let me welcome the confirmation of all 17 charges against Khaled Mohamed Ali el-Hishri, including war crimes and crimes against humanity, and the decision to commence his trial on 4 May 2027, the first trial before the ICC in the situation in Libya since the Security Council's referral in 2011. It is a landmark development for victims and survivors who have waited far too long for justice, and we commend the Office for its continued investigative progress and efforts to strengthen cooperation with national authorities. We welcome Libya's demonstrated commitment to the ICC's role and its contribution to justice and accountability. We call on Libyan authorities to continue to work towards the unification of judicial institutions in the eastern and western regions of the country. Second, progress in The Hague must be matched by cooperation on the ground. We welcome the constructive engagement of the Libyan Government and Presidential Council with the Court, particularly the cooperation under Article 12(3) of the Rome Statute. However, serious gaps remain. We are concerned by reports that Mr. Njim remains at liberty in Libya, and we call on the Libyan Attorney General to provide the requested information concerning national proceedings and the suspect's whereabouts in order to execute the arrest order issued by the Court in accordance with resolution 1970. Third, victims must remain at the centre of accountability efforts. We welcome the continued engagement of the Office of the Prosecutor with victims, CSOs, and human rights defenders. Their contribution is essential in documenting violations, gathering evidence, and helping bring perpetrators to justice. We thank each and every one of them for the increased trust they have placed in the Court. over 143 interactions and engagements that were held with CSOs, human rights defenders, and victims associations during this reporting cycle. And we have no doubt that these efforts will accelerate progress towards accountability. The progress achieved in Libya demonstrates what international justice can accomplish through sustained cooperation. Yet, as the report makes clear, these achievements are taking place against the backdrop of increasing measures targeting the Court. And we reiterate our unwavering support for the independence and impartiality of the Court and for its continued efforts to end impunity for the gravest international crimes. And I resume my function as President of the Council. As there are no more names inscribed on the list of speakers, the meeting is adjourned.