Second Committee, 24th plenary meeting - General Assembly, 79th session General Assembly Date: 26 November 2024 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/fr/ga/c2/79/24?lang=en Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- 2nd Committee · Chair [0:08]: I call to order the 26th meeting of the Second Committee at the seventy-ninth session of the General Assembly. In relation to all the draft proposals before the Committee this morning, I would like to remind delegates that statements in explanation of votes should be limited to three minutes. Delegations are also reminded that, in accordance with rule 128 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Assembly, the sponsor of a proposal is not permitted to speak in explanation of vote on the proposal. Before we begin our consideration of individual draft proposals this morning, I will give an opportunity to any delegation that wishes to make a statement relating to draft proposals submitted under different agenda items. I give the floor to Argentina, the distinguished representative of Argentina. Argentina [1:16]: Thank you very much, Chairman. Chair. Argentina today supports the consensus when it comes to adoption at the Second Committee, while also expressing its disassociation from all paragraphs within resolutions which are not in keeping with our country's foreign policy. By way of a note written to the Chair of the Committee, detail is given on the resolutions and paragraphs which we are unable to support. The Republic of Argentina took a new political path under the hallmark of the open market economy, the promotion of investment, strengthening the rule of law, promoting free competition of economic actors, and full integration into the world economy, making it possible to have added value exports. In pursuing these national goals, we believe that international cooperation is key. to resolve common challenges, and so as to build a more prosperous future based on the shared values of progress, development, and freedom. On this path, the Republic of Argentina has as its guide, guaranteeing the guiding principles of the protection of life, freedom, and private property. We also believe in freedom of trade for all, capitalism and free enterprise as an economic system, the only tool which we have at our disposal, in fact, for development and to put an end to hunger, poverty and extreme poverty across the planet. Argentina recalls that it dissociated itself from the Pact for the Future and believes that the 2030 Agreement for Sustainable Development is made-up of legally non-binding aspirations, which each State, in the exercise of their sovereignty, has the right to pursue and interpret freely. Given this, and linked to the draft resolutions to be adopted, the Republic of Argentina reserves its national position on all paragraphs which refer to the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and its SDGs. as well as mentions of the Pact for the Future and climate change. This reserve also applies to all paragraphs which go against the guiding principles of protection of life, freedom, and private property, and those referring to gender. When it comes to gender, the Republic of Argentina wishes the record to state that when this word is used, we understand it as it is used in international treaty law. i.e. two sexes, masculine and feminine, in the context of a society. The word gender will be accepted in no other context, and this is also laid out in the Rome Statute in Article 7.3. The Republic of Argentina states that climate change Well, this should be based on scientific progress, based on evidence without any form of dogmatism or ideology. The Republic of Argentina also recalls that In keeping with Article 41 of our national constitution, all inhabitants of our country have the right to a healthy, balanced environment which is apt for human development so that development activities can meet current needs without compromising those of future generations, which we are duty-bound to preserve. Chair, on the draft resolution, harmony with nature, Argentina, in its constitution, recognizes the right to a healthy environment. Nevertheless, In legislation which is in force, we do not recognize nature as a particular subject of rights. Finally, the Republic of Argentina would like to highlight its potential for the export of critical minerals and renewable energy sources, and would state that the practice of agricultural sector, thanks to extensive forest coverage, land grassland use and no-till technology mean that we are actually far outstripping the so-called developed economies who claim to be sustainability leaders. The Republic of Argentina requests that this explanation of position be placed on the record for the meeting of the Committee. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [5:47]: I thank the distinguished representative of Argentina, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [6:01]: Mr. Chairman, colleagues, the Russian delegation is pleased to support the adoption of today’s resolution on the use of information and communication technology for sustainable development, international trade and development, and the role of the UN in promoting development in a time of globalization. and international migration and development, as well as the third UN Decade on the Eradication of Poverty. Having said that, Russia is compelled to disassociate itself from the consensus on some paragraphs in this resolution that mention the Pact for the Future. The full position about this document was laid out in our statements to the Committee on 22 November and in the General Assembly of the United Nations on 22 September. The text of our statement can be found on our mission’s website. We ask for that position to be reflected in the record. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [7:03]: I thank the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 15, information and communication technologies for sustainable development. in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.33/Rev.1, of the same title, as submitted by Uganda on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, the amendments contained in document A/C.2/79/L.46, as submitted by Hungary on behalf of the sponsors listed in the document, and the amendment contained in document A/C.2/79/L.48, as submitted by the United States of America. I wish to thank the Vice-Chair, Ms. Ivana Vicić of Croatia, responsible for the item. I also thank the co-facilitators, Ms. Souley Abrahamsen of Finland and Mr. Vivek Ganesh of Singapore for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution, and delegations for their constructive engagement in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that the draft resolution L.33/Ref.1 and the amendments to the draft resolution contained in documents L.46 and L.48 have no programme budget implications. In accordance with rule 130 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Assembly, the Committee will first take a decision on the proposed amendments. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or an explanation of votes before the votes in connection with the amendment contained in document L.46 and/or the amendment contained in document L.48? Does the United States wish to introduce the amendment? Or you want to do it later? United States. United States of America [9:40]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Whenever is appropriate to introduce our amendment, we're prepared to do so. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [9:57]: Thank you very much. I would yield the floor to the United States after the brief introductory remark on this agenda item. I invite the representative of Hungary, on behalf of Member States of the European Union, to present the amendment contained in document L/46. I recall that the time limit for introduction is two minutes. So I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Hungary. Please, you have the floor. Hungary · EU [10:31]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Thank you for the opportunity to present the amendment to preambular paragraph 22 tabled by the European Union and its member states. As expressed consistently across multiple processes and fora, including during the Global Digital Compact negotiations, the EU takes very seriously its commitment to international law and standards, including when it comes to harnessing of digital technologies to fast-track progress to achieve the SDGs and to bridge the digital divides. We collectively renewed that commitment when adopting the GDC last September. Therefore, we can surely all agree that the deletion of international law from PP22 in the final text of the ICT resolution tabled for adoption today is a collective loss. The objective of the proposed amendment is to bring back this reference using the agreed language from paragraph 5 of the GDC. We are confident that everyone can agree to restore the reference to international law in this important paragraph. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [11:37]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary, and I now give the floor to the Secretariat to take us through the sponsorship. UN Secretariat · Secretary [11:49]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to announce that since the submission of the amendment, the following countries have also become co-sponsors of L/46: Albania, Australia, Canada, Israel, New Zealand, North Macedonia, Republic of Moldova, Switzerland, United Kingdom, and United States. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor the amendment, please signify by pressing the microphone button. Montenegro. That concludes the list. 2nd Committee · Chair [12:25]: Thank you. I thank the Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on the proposed amendment on draft resolution L.33/Rev.1 contained in document L.46. The Committee will now commence the process of voting on the proposed amendment contained in L.46. In accordance with rule 128, No representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes, those in favour of the amendment contained in L.46, please signify those against and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [13:13]: The Committee is now voting on the amendment to draft resolution L.33/Rev.1 as contained in document L.46. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [13:48]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour, 66; against, 100; abstention, 1. The amendment contained in L/46 is thus rejected. The Committee will next take action on the amendment contained in document L.48. I invite the representative of the United States of America to present the amendment contained in document L.48. I recall that the time limit for introduction is two minutes. United States, you have the floor, please. United States of America [14:30]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. On behalf of the United States government, it is my honor to present the amendment to OP 34 L.48 to the Information and Communication Technologies for Sustainable Development Resolution. As we have consistently expressed, the United States takes very seriously its strong support to the active and meaningful participation of all stakeholders. This includes governments, the private sector, civil society, academia, and the technical community on issues related to the role of information and communication technologies to help advance the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. While multi-stakeholder engagement is essential across all processes and forums related to ICTs, we all agreed in the Global Digital Compact only two months ago that the Internet Governance Forum is the primary multi-stakeholder platform for discussion of Internet governance issues. Regrettably, the deletion of primary from OP 34 in the final text of the ICT resolution tabled for adoption today is a collective loss, which disrupts the delicate balance of this ICT resolution. The objective of our amendment today is to bring back this reference using agreed language from paragraph 28 of the GDC. Therefore, colleagues, we call on all Member States to join us in adopting this important amendment. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [16:01]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the proposed amendment. UN Secretariat · Secretary [16:10]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to announce that since the submission of the amendment, the following countries have also become co-sponsors of L/48: Albania, Australia, Austria, Canada, Croatia, Cyprus, Czechia, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, New Zealand, North Macedonia, Poland, Portugal, Republic of Moldova, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Spain, Switzerland, and United Kingdom. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor L/48, please signify by pressing the microphone button. Bulgaria, Montenegro, Sweden, and Belgium. That concludes the list. 2nd Committee · Chair [17:23]: I thank the Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on the proposed amendment to draft resolution L.33/Rev.1, contained in document L.48. The committee will now commence the process of voting on the proposed amendment contained in L.48. In accordance with rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favour of the amendment contained in L.48, please signify. Those against? And abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [18:09]: The Committee is now voting on the amendment to draft resolution L.33/Rev.1 as contained in document L.48. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [18:42]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour, 57; against, 107; and abstentions, 5. The amendment to draft resolution contained in L.48 is rejected. Before proceeding to action on L.48 as a whole, does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or a general statement after the vote on the amendment contained in L.46 and on the amendment in L.48? United Kingdom, please, you have the floor. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [19:28]: Thank you very much, Chair. At the Summit of the Future in September, leaders agreed a global digital. Compact which described the Internet Government Forum, Governance Forum, as the primary multi-stakeholder platform for discussion of Internet governance issues. We believe this resolution should reflect what was agreed at the summit, and so we are disappointed that. This language has not been upheld. The UN IGF plays a fundamental role in internet governance, and we are grateful to Saudi Arabia for hosting the next meeting of the annual IGF in Riyadh in December, and we look forward to participating there. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [20:09]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Kingdom, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Hungary. Hungary · EU [20:19]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I speak on behalf of the UN and its member states. We regret that our proposed amendment has failed, and therefore we would like to call a vote on preamble or paragraph 22. We ask all Member States to join us in rejecting PP22, which is neither agreed language from prior ICT resolutions nor agreed through informal consultations. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [20:45]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary. And I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of United States. United States of America [20:57]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. Likewise, we regret that our proposed amendment has failed, and therefore we would like to call a vote on OP 34. We ask all Member States to also join us in rejecting OP 34, which is neither agreed language from prior ICT resolutions nor agreed through informal consultations. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [21:18]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Uruguay. Uruguay [21:30]: Thank you very much, Chairman. Uruguay voted in favor of the amendment contained in document A/C2/79/L.46. Its content is part of the our national However, my delegation would also like to make the following position clear: We regret that language based on the recently agreed-upon Pact for the Future was included here. At the end of the negotiations, this was added. Uruguay believes that procedurally, while we agree with this position, it did undermine the understanding and spirit we must foster. as we work within this organization. Second, we wish to highlight that we believe that the negotiation processes are vital for transparent multilateralism. As such, we believe that this – the process in which we conduct ourselves is a cornerstone which we must preserve. We therefore highlight the need to preserve negotiations and their outcomes. and ensure that we have consistency when it comes to our position in the room and then our subsequent additions. That is vital. We will would like to add that this explanation of position, we'd like to ask that this explanation of position be placed on the official record of the meeting. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [22:59]: I thank the distinguished representative of Uruguay, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Colombia. Colombia [23:08]: Thank you very much, Chair. In keeping with what was stated by the delegation of Uruguay, Colombia voted in favor of Amendment L-46 presented by the European Union, as this included agreed-upon language from the Global Digital Compact, and we believe that international law is a pillar which we cannot ignore in efforts to implement that agreement. Notwithstanding that, my delegation would have supported a simple reference to international law as presented in the final text of the co-facilitators, and here there was not silence, was not broken. My delegation regrets that acknowledging the role of international law in this context was not the outcome of our conversations, but rather an amendment. My delegation reiterates the importance of maintaining transparency and good faith negotiations to reach consensus within the work of this committee. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [24:19]: I thank the distinguished representative of Colombia, Excellencies, esteemed colleagues. Okay. I yield the floor to the distinguished representative of El Salvador. El Salvador [24:38]: Thank you very much, Chairman. El Salvador voted in favor of the proposed amendment A/C2/79/L46, in line with our national policy and as expressed in the context of the GDC. and in other intergovernmental processes ongoing in this field. We highlight the importance of leaving nobody behind in the digital transformation. This is the lifeblood of our shared vision for the digital sphere, but we also highlight the importance of protecting, promoting, and fulfilling human rights and international law in the digital world. These elements are mutually reinforcing and allow us to better harness digital technologies. El Salvador's digital agenda highlights the importance of, uh, bestowing rights on all in the digital sphere and protecting the rights of, uh, digital service users and the right to inclusion of all sectors, among other relevant themes. We do deeply regret what occurred at the end of the negotiation process, particularly the amendments made to the language, which, in our view, uh, was not balanced. especially given that this was a recently considered text. Balance should always prevail in negotiations, especially and consensus should always prevail, especially when this has already been previously agreed on at previous processes. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [26:09]: I thank the distinguished representative of El Salvador. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Mexico. Mexico [26:21]: Many thanks, Chairman. My delegation fully agrees with what was set out by El Salvador, Colombia, and Uruguay when it comes to the substantive and procedural issues for amendments which today were not adopted. We regret that we are currently having to vote in favour or against paragraphs which, outwith the amendments presented, we agreed on. And we struggled to see the need to vote on a paragraph which we did agree on in general, but because of procedural matters, it wasn't maintained in the final text. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [27:10]: I thank the distinguished representative of Mexico. Excellencies, esteemed colleagues, we will now take a brief pause for the Secretariat to set up the voting machine. Thank you very much. A recorded vote has been requested on preambular paragraph 22 of the draft resolution L.33/Rev.1. Before we proceed to vote, I will give the floor to any sponsor delegation wishing to make a general statement or non-sponsor delegations wishing to make a statement in explanation of vote. Delegations are also reminded that in accordance with rule 128 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Assembly, The sponsor of a proposal is not permitted to speak in explanation of votes on the proposal. The Committee will now commence with the process of voting on preambular paragraph 22 of the draft resolution. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. UN Secretariat · Secretary [28:31]: The Committee is now voting on preambular paragraph 22 of draft resolution L.33/Rev.1. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [29:30]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favor, 115; against, 51; abstentions, 2. Preambular paragraph 22 is retained. A recorded vote has been requested on operative paragraph 34 of the draft resolution. Before we proceed to vote, I will give the floor to any sponsored delegation wishing to make a general statement or non-sponsored delegation wishing to make a statement in explanation of vote. Delegations are also reminded that in accordance with rule 128 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Assembly, the sponsor of a proposal is not permitted to speak in explanation of vote on the proposal. The Committee will now commence with the process of voting on operative paragraph 34 of the draft resolution L/33/Rev.1. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. UN Secretariat · Secretary [30:44]: The Committee is now voting on operative paragraph 34 of draft resolution L/33/Rev.1. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [31:27]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour, 119; against, 51; abstentions, 0. Operative paragraph 34 is thus retained. Since the amendments contained in document L/46 and L/48 have been rejected, we shall proceed to take a decision on the draft resolution L.33/Ref.1 as a whole. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [32:17]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any countries not a member of the Group of 77 and China wish to co-sponsor L/33/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see no additional co-sponsors. 2nd Committee · Chair [32:37]: I thank the Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L.3/Rev.1 as a whole? I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Switzerland. Switzerland [33:00]: Mr. Chair, Switzerland supports the consensus on this resolution, and it thanks the co-facilitators for their work. We, however, wish to clarify here our position about the process and about the final text. At a procedural level, we regret that modifications were made to the resolution. following the end of the negotiations without the delegations being consulted. We also regret the fact that the two amendments proposed did not garner the majority needed to be included in the resolution. These would have aligned the language of the resolution with the Global Digital Compact, and it would have reflected adequately the importance of international law and its implementation. The Global Digital Compact, recently adopted, is the determinative text in this area, as far as Switzerland is concerned. Furthermore, we regret the fact that the additionals modalities process was mandated with regard to the World Summit on the Information Society, the WSIS+20. In our viewpoint, the document of the WSIS+10 already sufficiently defined the process, we are expecting that the negotiations on modalities will be limited to aspects requiring additional decisions, such as the date of the high-level meeting and the mandate for the outcome document. We call upon the PGA to appoint co-facilitators for this process without delay. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [34:38]: I thank the distinguished representative of Switzerland, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [34:53]: Mr. Chairman, the Russian delegation thanks the authors and the coordinators of the resolution on the use of information and communication technologies for sustainable development. We welcome the decision to prepare modalities for the comprehensive high-level meeting on the world – the WSIS meeting. We wish to stress the intergovernmental nature of this process, the future draft document. should be discussed, and the meeting – the opinions of all member states should be taken into consideration. The preparation of the document for the WSIS is the starting point for further efforts. It lays the groundwork for the internationalization of Internet governance and for closing the digital divide. Given the fact that the Pact for the Future and the Global Digital Compact contain non-consensus-based elements, especially as regards making non-state actors equal to state actors in determining the relevant agenda, Russia distances itself from the consensus. We believe it’s unacceptable to We think it is unacceptable to cater to the needs of Western companies, and the work of the United Nations Commission on Science and Technology for Development should not be undermined. We believe that the Global Digital Compact does not have binding legal force. and the report of the consultative body on artificial intelligence is not the outcome of an international governmental process and is advisory in nature. We ask for our position to be reflected in the record. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [36:52]: I thank the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Mexico. Mexico [37:03]: Thank you very much, Chair. Mexico welcomes the adoption by consensus of this resolution and congratulates the co-facilitators, Singapore and Finland. We express our concern, though, about the procedural irregularities which happened at the end of this negotiation process as new changes were introduced after the negotiations had concluded. We believe that the language contained in preambular paragraph 22 and operative paragraph 34 should be aligned with the Global Digital Compact. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [37:43]: I thank the distinguished representative of Mexico. May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L.33/Ref.1 as a whole? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the draft resolution? I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Hungary. Hungary · EU [38:15]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honour to speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states. The candidate countries, North Macedonia, Montenegro, Albania, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Georgia, as well as Monaco, align themselves with this statement. First, I wish to commend the work of the co-facilitators, Ms. Salla Abrahamson from Finland and Mr. Vivek Ganesh from Singapore, who have led the informal consultations with great professionalism and in the spirit of compromise. I also wish to thank the Secretariat and other delegations for their dedication and tireless work. The EU welcomes the adoption of this resolution. ICTs and digital technologies are crucial for sustainable development. In a spirit of compromise and to maintain the long-standing consensus on this text, the EU did not break silence on the final draft tabled by G77 for adoption. However, we regret to see that some unilateral edits were made to two paragraphs, namely PP22 and OP34, before the text was submitted to the Bureau. Those edits regrettably altered the overall balance of the text while questioning agreed language from the GDC adopted just two months ago. We regret that the amendments put forward to correct this imbalance were not adopted by this Committee. As a result, we dissociate from PP-22 and OP-34. We would like to clarify our understandings of the paragraphs in question. First, regarding PP22, the EU takes very seriously its commitment to international law and standards. Any reference to the GDC implementation and to digital governance and digital cooperation in general shall be understood as being in line with international law, including when harnessing digital technologies to fast-track progress to achieve the SDGs and to bridge the digital divide. Second, on OP 34, the EU recalls that the Internet Governance Forum is the primary multi-stakeholder platform for discussion of Internet governance issues at the United Nations. We welcome that this year's resolution includes references to the GDC. It is particularly important we stick to that GDC language as an important guide for the UN efforts on digital cooperation. We therefore cannot consider PP 22 and OP 34 as agreed language going forward. Finally, multi-stakeholder approach is essential to bridge digital divides, harness the benefits of digital transformation, and address the related challenges that arise. Conducting discussions on broader digital issues without considering the inputs from all stakeholders, including the end users of these technologies, will remain sterile endeavor. The WESIS+20 review offers an excellent opportunity for timely multi-stakeholder discussions on the digital issues. We reiterate the need to account for a pressing time frame and to have co-facilitators appointed urgently in order to kick off the consultations on the WESIS+20 High-Level Meeting outcome document. We accepted the language put forward in OP/62 in the spirit of compromise, but would like to put on the record that by showing flexibility on this matter, we expect a deeper modalities resolution than the one was adopted for the WESIS+10 review accounting for improved ways of meaningfully engaging stakeholders. The EU and its member states remain committed to continue working closely with partners worldwide to advance an inclusive, open, safe, and secure digital space for all. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [41:55]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Colombia. Colombia [42:05]: Thank you, Chair. Colombia welcomes the adoption by consensus of this resolution. My delegation wishes to highlight that the final versions of PP/22 and OP/34 were not any form of disregarding or renegotiating language which was already reached in the Global Digital Compact, whose implementation we remain fully committed to. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [42:35]: I thank the distinguished representative of Colombia, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United States. United States of America [42:44]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. First, I want to commend the work of the two co-facilitators, Ms. Solay Abrahamson from Finland and Mr. Vivek Ganesh from Singapore, for their tireless efforts to lead us towards consensus. The United States continues to support the advancement of the 2030 Agenda and closing digital divides. However, we must strongly disassociate from paragraphs PP22 and OP34 in the current text. The context of these two paragraphs undermines the careful balance we achieved in past versions of this resolution. We regret last-minute edits deleting international law from PP22 and the essential word “primary” from OP34. These edits, which were not proposed during negotiations, are unfortunate and inappropriate. We strongly disagree with the effort to push text through at the end of a consensus-based process, disrupting the balance after weeks of good-faith negotiations. It is unfortunate that after so much progress, we had to vote against those two paragraphs. And now, disassociate from them. Further, we want to clarify our position on open innovation, know-how, digital public goods, and digital public infrastructure. We emphasize that open innovation is a distributed process based on partnership, cooperation, and voluntary knowledge flow across organizational boundaries on mutually agreed terms. Open innovation leverages resources for researchers and others in the innovation ecosystem to unlock the latent economic value of ideas and knowledge. This collaborative process highlights the importance of a strong innovation ecosystem, an innovator-led approach based on voluntary partnerships and respect for intellectual property. It also includes respect for diverse cultures, human rights, the protection of national security, and principles and rules related to academic freedom, research ethics and integrity, privacy, and personal data. Finally, on DPG and DPI, we support efforts that advance the power and potential of DPGs and resilient, safe, inclusive, interoperable DPI for the global community, with appropriate protections for intellectual property. To safeguard incentives for innovation, it is understood that all contributions of information, knowledge, and technology to digital public infrastructure and digital public goods are voluntary and on mutually agreed terms. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [45:16]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of France. France [45:26]: Mr. Chairman, allow me at the outset to thank Singapore and Finland for their sterling work co-facilitating this text. France associates itself and aligns with the statement of the EU and wishes to add the following in its national capacity. France welcomes the adoption of this resolution, which reaffirms, slightly more than two months after the determination showed in the Pact for the Future and the Global Digital Compact, the will of an overwhelming majority of members to step up international cooperation in the digital sphere. Additional references made in the text to the GDC and Sustainability Challenge are steps forward, which we welcome. However, we do regret, and this has already been mentioned, As France fully supports the EU position on PP-22 and OP-34 of this resolution, we therefore would like to dissociate ourselves from these paragraphs, and we regret deeply that the amendments introduced here didn't reflect the balance reached at the Global Digital Compact. Next, I'd like to highlight the importance of the work undertaken by the Second Committee on Governance and Artificial Intelligence. The resolution adopted today clearly reaffirms ambition, which is also France's ambition, to place artificial intelligence at the service of public service and to ensure that there is open architecture for its governance. We must also defend multilingualism. and anticipate and master both the opportunities and risks linked to artificial intelligence. Given all this, France will organize on the 10th and 11th of February 2024 an AI Action Summit, which we believe will be a key step for the full implementation of the ambition shared by all members of this committee. We also welcome the important role of the United Nations in facilitating and supporting international cooperation in the field of AI. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [47:36]: I thank the distinguished representative of France. I see no other request for the floor. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 16A, international trade and development, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79 L.3/Rev.1 of the same title, as submitted by Uganda on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, and the amendments to the draft resolution contained in document A/C.2/79/L.47, as submitted by Hungary on behalf of the sponsors listed in the document. I wish to thank the Vice Chair and Facilitator, Mr. Ezequiel David Anyebue of Nigeria, for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution. I also thank delegations for their constructive engagement in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that draft resolution L.3/Ref.1 and the amendment of the draft resolution contained in documents A/C.2/79/L.47 have no programme budget implications. In accordance with rule 130 of the Rules of Procedure of the General Assembly, the Committee will first take a decision on the proposed amendment. I now invite the representative of Hungary to, on behalf of the member states of the European Union, to present the amendment of the draft resolution. I recall that the time limit for introduction is two minutes. The distinguished representative of Hungary, please. Hungary · EU [49:24]: Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chair. I speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states. believe that this amendment needs further introductions. It speaks for itself, and it is in line with our well-known position. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [49:45]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the proposed amendment. UN Secretariat · Secretary [49:54]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to announce that since the submission of the amendment, the following countries have also become co-sponsors of L/47: Albania, Australia, Canada, North Macedonia, Switzerland, and United States. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor L/47, please signify by pressing the microphone button. Montenegro. That concludes the list. 2nd Committee · Chair [50:24]: I thank the Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on the proposed amendments. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or an explanation of vote before the votes in connection with the proposed amendment contained in document L.47? I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United States. United States of America [50:52]: Thank you, Chair. Thank you, Chair. The United States thanks the facilitator of this resolution for his steady work throughout the process. The United States is taking the floor to explain our vote on this EU-led amendment. We will vote in favor of this amendment, which seeks to remove four non-consensual paragraphs from this year’s trade resolution. And the context for this is important. We worked constructively throughout the negotiations to reach consensus. We even presented delegations with a package proposal that built on last year's agreed language and which would have led to the first ever fully consensus international trade and development resolution. Unfortunately, that package proposal was rejected. Even without that package, there were options. While the text placed under silence was not perfect, it could have resulted in a similar outcome to last year, a paragraph vote followed by joining consensus. Regrettably, the text was altered by a party which had not broken silence, but which chose to insert paragraphs PP16, OP33, and OP34 that had been rejected earlier during our open negotiations. There is thus no basis to include these paragraphs, and they create an unbalanced text. In fact, many delegations, including the United States, made clear throughout the negotiating process the content of these paragraphs was unacceptable. At the same time, silence was broken on OP 31 by the United States, the EU, UK, Japan, ROK, and CANS, clearly indicating disagreement on a contentious paragraph that was voted in last year's resolution. The paragraph remains in the resolution before us unchanged. It should come as no surprise then that, should this amendment fail, the United States will be forced to call a vote on the entire resolution. We urge Member States to join us in voting in favor of this amendment as a final attempt to achieve a consensual outcome. If the amendment fails, we further urge members to join us in voting against the resolution or at least abstaining. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [52:58]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States. I see no other request for the floor. The committee will now commence the process of voting on the proposed amendment contained in document L.47. In accordance with the rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favor of the amendment, please signify, those against, and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [53:36]: The Committee is now voting on the amendment to L3/rev1 contained in document L-47. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [54:11]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour, 52; against, 121; abstention, 1. The amendment contained in L.47 is thus rejected. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or a general statement after the vote on the amendment? I give the floor to the distinguished representative of South Africa. South Africa [54:46]: Thank you, Chair, and thank you to the facilitator for his hard work. Unilateral trade measures masked as climate response measures, such as the EU and UK's carbon border adjustment mechanism, will leave a swathe of devastation in developing countries, reversing development gains increasing poverty, inequality, and unemployment, while having a negligible effect on cutting global CO2 emissions. CBAMs and the deforestation regulation are extraterritorial legislation and unilateral, coercive, punitive, and trade-distorting measures with negative cross-border impacts on developing country economies. They have a direct impact on the sovereignty and development pathways of other countries and ignore the principle of common but differentiated responsibility and respective capabilities. These are nothing more than UCMs aimed indiscriminately at all developing countries. It is perverse that just as developing countries are asking for a fair shake in international tax cooperation, The private companies of sovereign developing countries that bear the least historic responsibility for causing climate change are slapped with a direct tax by developed countries to further extract resources from the South and enrich the North. We have heard much over the past few days about the need to respect the Paris Agreement, and we totally agree, but this should go beyond footnotes. We call on developed country partners to also respect the injunction in the Paris Agreement that responses to climate change should avoid adverse impacts on social and economic development, and I quote, "taking into full account the legitimate priority needs of developing countries for the achievement of sustained economic growth and the eradication of poverty." Or to take into consideration, and I quote, "the concerns of parties with economies most affected by the impacts of response measures." particularly developing country Parties. The UNFCC and the Kyoto Protocol lay down similar legally binding obligations. Again, we must remind our developed country partners that our multilateral cooperation on climate change recognizes that developing countries did not create the climate crisis, and that we, who are still recovering from centuries of cruel exploitation, cannot and must not be the ones that have to pay for cleaning up the mess caused by developed countries. It is not surprising that the unilateral imposition of coercive measures by developed countries, whilst at the same time not providing financial flows, as we just saw in Baku, technology transfer, or capacity building as legally required, is being widely interpreted as an opportunistic attempt to subjugate developing countries to further underdevelopment and deindustrialization. Instead of bludgeoning us with a big stick, we call on our developed country partners to refrain from implementing these measures and instead focus on providing the means of implementation we need to help us respond to climate change. We urgently call for a trade and climate body to be set up at the UNFCCC and for the WTO Committee on Trade and Climate to be fully constituted. While we are fully committed to saving our planet, We will not accept measures that are outside the scope of internationally agreed rules and principles and that are designed to impede our economic development. Our calls have so far gone unheeded, but this resolution today should be taken as a sign that our voices will not be silenced any longer. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [58:46]: I thank the distinguished representative of South Africa, and I encourage us to kindly stick to the time limitation, the time limits allocated for statements. as much as we want to see everything just before the adoption. With that, I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Mexico. Mexico [59:19]: Thank you, Chair. Mexico values the goal of this resolution presented by the G77 on China on international trade and development and reiterates its readiness to reach inclusive, balanced agreements here in the Second Committee. favoring international cohesion on strategic matters such as trade and development. While Mexico shares the principles reflected in the paragraphs covered by the amendment, we do believe that the reiteration of ideas contained in these paragraphs isn't relevant to the overarching goal of the text as a whole. Because of this, my country supported the We believe that the important principles such as arbitrary discrimination or restricted, disguised restrictions on international trade should be understood in the context of this resolution, and we therefore, following the comments from my colleague from South Africa, we would reiterate those comments. They are fundamental. So as to ensure that there is buy-in by all, we need to discuss these matters inclusively and in depth without any form of imposition, and we must not unduly reiterate and repeat concepts. Mexico expressed its concerns about any procedural irregularities which may undermine the legitimacy of negotiations in this text, and we would stress that all negotiations should be conducted professionally showing best parliamentary practice. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:00:54]: I thank the distinguished representative of Mexico. Since the amendment contained in document L.47 has been rejected, we shall proceed to take a decision on the draft resolution L.3/Ref.1 as a whole. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:01:19]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. If any other – if any country is not a member of the Group of 77 and China wish to co-sponsor L.3/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I have no further co-sponsors. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:01:41]: I thank the Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on draft resolution L.3/Rev.1. entitled International Trade and Development. Before proceeding to the vote, I will give the floor to any sponsor delegation wishing to make a general statement in connection with the draft proposal or any sponsor delegation wishing to make a statement in explanation of vote. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or explanation of vote before the vote in connection with draft resolution L.3/Rev.1? The Committee will now commence the process of voting on draft resolution L.3/Rev.1. In accordance with rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favor of draft resolution L.3/Ref.1, please signify; those against; and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:02:59]: The Committee is now voting on draft resolution L3/Rev.1, entitled "International trade and development". Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:03:25]: The result of the vote is as follows: In favor, 129; against, 2; abstentions, 47. Draft resolution L.3/Rev.1 is thus adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or a general statement after the vote on the draft resolution? I give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [1:04:03]: Mr. Chairman, the Russian Federation voted for the adoption of the resolution on international trade and development. The resolution for the first time fully reflects the key problems in international trade, specifically the growing number of unilateral protectionist measures that are taken under the pretext of fighting climate change and protecting the environment. And these are means of arbitrary, unjustified discrimination against the majority of countries, primarily against the Global South. In essence, these measures are introduced to create a competitive advantage for domestic operators. Unilateral economic, financial, and trade coercive measures are taken exclusively for political reasons against countries that have fallen out of favor. It is clear that international trade has been held hostage. In this regard, the resolution correctly notes that our collective task should be swiftly forming rules-based, non-discriminatory, open, just, inclusive, equal, and transparent international trade systems. Having said that, our delegation notes the fact that the resolution failed to include provisions on critically important minerals. The Russian Federation is concerned at the increase at the emphasis on the energy transition, which could lead to geopolitical contexts among countries and which could disrupt supply chains too, especially as regards the production of a broad spectrum of traditional consumer goods such as technology and electronics. In this regard, we must support developing states that have such resources. and production should be localized on their territories. This will not only foster stabilization of world markets for critical minerals, but it will also develop their economies through diversification and through building technological exports. Nonetheless, the Russian Federation once more distances itself from the paragraph OP 9. We believe that in terms of domestic support of agriculture through subsidies, especially determining the criteria for whether that is acceptable, falls under the prerogatives of states and relevant fora. On this paragraph, Russia supports concrete language reflecting agreements in this regard, agreements in the WTO once they are reached. We ask for our position to be reflected in the record of this meeting. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:06:59]: I thank the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Kingdom. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [1:07:10]: Thank you, Chair. The United Kingdom voted to abstain on this resolution. While we see value in areas we were able to progress this year, we cannot offer full support as significant amendments were made during silence procedure without adequate consultation. The UK and others broke silence on OP.30 of the facilitator's text, and we had hoped for another opportunity to resolve our concerns. This opportunity was not provided. Substantial changes were then made to the text to include PP.16, OP.33, and OP.34, although we and other delegations had made clear during the negotiations that this language would be unacceptable to many delegations. As such, We believe the final text was not submitted in good faith. We recognize the importance of ensuring that sanctions mitigate negative effects on trade and development. The UK ensures our autonomous sanctions are lawful, transparent, allow for protections and legal challenge, and align with the UN Charter. Our sanctions target individuals and entities conducting horrific acts. and industries that enable them to do so. It is the acts that lead us to apply sanctions, such as conflict, human rights abuses, and corruption, which threaten trade and development. We are committed to supporting the most vulnerable countries experiencing the worst impacts of the climate and nature crisis. The COP28 Global Stocktake established that measures taken to combat climate change including unilateral ones, should not be a means of discrimination or restriction on trade. Concerns around trade impacts of climate measures are already being discussed in other relevant fora, including the WTO, Climate Club, and OECD. So we don't think this resolution is the place to make unsubstantiated claims on this issue. We look forward to resolving our differences. and hope to find a middle ground in 2025 so the trade resolution can once again be adopted by consensus. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:09:30]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Kingdom, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Hungary. Hungary · EU [1:09:40]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I have the honor to deliver this statement on behalf of the European Union and its member states. The candidate countries North Macedonia, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Georgia, and the EFTA countries Iceland, Liechtenstein, and Norway, members of the European Economic Area, as well as Andorra, Monaco, and San Marino align themselves with this statement. I would like to warmly thank the facilitator, Mr. David Anyegbu from Nigeria, as well as the Secretariat and all delegations involved in the negotiation process. The EU has engaged proactively and constructively with the aim of a consensus resolution that prioritizes the challenges of developing countries. The EU's support to this resolution is based on the strongly held conviction that trade is an engine for inclusive growth and poverty eradication, and that it can contribute to the promotion of sustainable development, structural transformation, and industrialization, particularly in developing countries. Furthermore, we strongly believe that inclusive trade policies can contribute to achieving gender equality and women's economic empowerment, which in turn has a positive impact on economic growth and helps to reduce poverty. Indeed, inclusive and sustainable policies more broadly are, in our view, instrumental to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals. Multilateral rules and disciplines are also the best guarantee against protectionism. Promoting a universal, rules-based, open, transparent, predictable, inclusive, non-discriminatory, and equitable multilateral trading system under the World Trade Organization is the best way to achieve meaningful trade liberalization. Mr. Chair, we acknowledge the concerns of developing countries regarding the EU CBAM initiative. We continue to engage bilaterally and multilaterally with our partners on this issue to dispel and address these concerns where necessary. This is why, after voting to related paragraph last year, we expressed full openness to engage on this issue and tabled several alternative proposals to have balanced and factually correct and appropriate language. Maybe time was not on our side, and these discussions were not conclusive. Nevertheless, we decided to show our appreciation for the engagement and accepted the operational paragraph that we voted last year. However, the EU was very disappointed with the text that was finally tabled by G77. We did not expect to see three new paragraphs, the deletion of which no delegation or group broke silence on, reappear. These three paragraphs target very openly and one-sidedly the EU's carbon border adjustment mechanism. Chair, this is also why the EU tabled an amendment to delete these paragraphs from the text, and this is why the EU has abstained in the vote on the text. This is not the kind of process we would like to see next year. Having made efforts to find language acceptable to all, we disassociate from these paragraphs in this resolution. That said, we will continue to engage in discussions with partners and make every effort in the hope that discussions next year will be more fruitful. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:12:58]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Republic of Korea. Republic of Korea [1:13:11]: Thank you, Chair. I would like to start by expressing sincere appreciation for the facilitator and the Bureau of the Second Committee for their leadership. The International Development and Trade Resolution, which plays a meaningful role in providing views on policy directions for the multilateral trading system, should present a clear vision for reinforcing the multilateral trading framework and fostering an inclusive and productive predictable trade environment. Accordingly, discussions within the Second Committee must also remain predictable and anchored in inclusive cooperation, serving as a catalyst for achieving the SDGs and advancing the spirit of multilateralism pursued by the United Nations. Regretfully, the Republic of Korea had to abstain on this resolution on this particular adoption. Because despite the efforts of numerous delegations who engaged constructively throughout the negotiations to reach an agreement and uphold a consensus adoption of this important document, the final version of the text did not reflect such efforts. Moving forward, we hope to see the positive aspects and progresses achieved in international trade reflected in the future deliberations in a more balanced and inclusive manner. The multilateral trade system is more than just a trade mechanism. It serves as a fundamental pillar of sustainable development. Recognizing its central role, Republic of Korea reaffirms its commitment to supporting member states in their efforts to strengthen the multilateral trading system and creating a fair, transparent, and predictable trading environment. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:15:00]: I thank the distinguished representative of the Republic of Korea, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Belarus. Belarus [1:15:15]: Thank you, Mr. Chairman. We extend our appreciation to the member states of the Group of 77 and China for introducing this draft resolution. We thank the delegation of Nigeria for coordinating this process. We thank them for the inclusive and transparent nature of the negotiations. Belarus welcomes the adoption of the resolution, and we agree that international trade is significant for sustainable development, including the eradication of poverty as well and structural transformations in developing countries. We reaffirm our position that it is unacceptable to apply illegitimate economic sanctions. Such sanctions have an adverse impact on international trade and financial systems while hampering progress toward achievement of the SDGs and having a corrosive effect on the well-being of populations. Many developing States continue to fall victim to measures which are taken for political and protectionary reasons. In this regard, we reject the amendment of the European Union in the amendment. We are convinced that the paragraphs proposed for deletion adequately reflect challenges facing developing countries. We also don't support OP 9 about eliminating agricultural export subsidies. Belarus disassociates itself from this paragraph, and we reserve the right to apply this resolution in accordance with our domestic laws and policies. We ask for our position to be reflected in the record. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:16:50]: I thank the distinguished representative of Belarus, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Paraguay. Paraguay [1:17:02]: Thank you very much, Chairman. The Republic of Paraguay would like to dissociate from OPs 9 and 27 of the resolution we have just adopted, as these are not in keeping with the positions set out and defended by Paraguay. in this and in other multilateral fora, particularly within the context of the World Trade Organization, and we believe that they do not reflect the current status of relevant negotiations. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:17:37]: I thank the distinguished representative of Paraguay. I see no other request for the floor. The Committee has thus concluded its consideration of the sub-item A of agenda item 16. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 18C, disaster risk reduction, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.16/Rev.1 of the same title, as submitted by Uganda. Uganda on behalf of the Group of 77 and China. I wish to thank the rapporteur, Ms. Stephanie Romero Vega of Uruguay, responsible for the item. I also thank the co-facilitators, Mr. Andrés Napuri of Peru and Mr. António Moura of Portugal, for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution and delegations on their and delegations for their constructive engagement in negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that the draft resolution L.16/Rev.1 has no programme budget implication. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:18:59]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. I would like to announce that since the submission of the revised draft resolution, and in addition to those delegations listed on the L document, The following countries have also become co-sponsors of L16/Rev 1: Belgium, Croatia, Cyprus, Finland, Germany, Greece, Latvia, Luxembourg, Montenegro, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, and Spain. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor L16/Rev 1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. Albania, Sweden. That concludes the list. Speaker 83 [1:19:42]: Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:19:45]: I thank the Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement before action on draft resolution L.16/Ref.1? I see no request for the floor. May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.16/Rev.1? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the draft resolution? I give the floor to the distinguished representative of New Zealand. New Zealand · CANZ [1:20:38]: Mr. Chair, I have the honor to deliver the statement on behalf of Canada, Australia, and my own country, New Zealand. Cairns would like to express our sincere thanks to Andreas Napuripita of Peru and Antonio Moura of Portugal for their skillful co-facilitation of the DRR resolution and their leadership throughout the negotiation process. Disaster risk reduction is a crucial issue for our three countries. We are pleased that this resolution continues to strengthen the General Assembly's commitment to implementing the Sendai Framework. Cairns was particularly pleased to recognize the work of the Agenda Action Plan, which acknowledges the urgent need to reduce the negative impacts of gender discrimination and inequality in disasters, and seeks to substantially decrease gender-related disaster risk by 2030. We continue to emphasize the need to focus on understanding multifaceted and systemic hazards with cascading and compounding impacts, particularly extreme weather and climate-related hazards. We also note these hazards' disproportionate impact on vulnerable people, including Indigenous peoples, persons with disabilities, and women and girls. Climate change is undeniably a driver of disaster risk. This is why we must reiterate, as we have in other resolutions across this committee, our support for the UNFCCC and the Paris Agreement, which are separate, stand-alone treaties. These legal documents should be reflected correctly and consistently across the committee. We regret that silence was broken on these keystone documents and that they continue to be incorrectly characterised in this resolution. CANS thanks all delegations for their constructive engagement on this resolution and looks forward to making more progress on this key issue during the 80th session. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:22:44]: I thank the distinguished representative of New Zealand, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United States. United States of America [1:22:53]: Thank you, Mr. Chair. The United States strongly supports disaster risk reduction, including through our humanitarian and development assistance efforts and technical cooperation with other nations to improve preparation for and response to disasters. We joined consensus, however, we would like to make our position on several key issues clear. The United States reiterates our views on the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction from the U.S. explanation of position delivered in 2015. We dedicate significant resources around the world to support disaster risk reduction initiatives designed to reduce loss of life and the social and economic impacts of disasters. This assistance and collaboration helps recipients build a culture of preparedness, promote greater resilience, and aid in climate adaptation reducing impact of climate-related disasters. We wish to reiterate the United States’ understanding that language on technology transfers refers to voluntary technology transfers on mutually agreed terms. Likewise, with respect to our position on the 2030 Agenda, the SDG Summit Political Declaration, and the Paris Agreement’s independence and its relationship to the UNFCCC and international financial institutions, we refer to our General Explanation of Position submitted for the record on November 13, 2024, and posted online at the U.S. Mission’s website. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:24:24]: Thank the distinguished representative of the United States, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the European Union. EU · EU [1:24:34]: Mr. Chair, I have the honor to speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states. The candidate countries Turkey, North Macedonia, Montenegro, Albania, Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Georgia align themselves with this statement. At the outset, let me thank the co-facilitators, António Moura of Portugal and Andrés Pita of Peru, the Secretariat, and other delegations for their cooperative and constructive work on this resolution. The EU welcomes the adoption of this resolution by consensus. This resolution has become increasingly relevant as the number and scale of disasters and their devastating impact continue to result in massive loss of life and long-term negative economic, social, and environmental consequences for vulnerable societies around the world and hamper their sustainable development. We are pleased that the resolution recognizes that disaster risk is increasingly complex and systemic, and that hazards can trigger each other with cascading impacts across sectors and at all levels. We welcome that this year's resolution contains stronger language on wildfire management and a reference to the Landscape Fire Governance Framework. We also appreciate references to the Gender Action Plan for Disaster Risk Reduction and the SG's Action Agenda on Internal Displacement, as well as new references to extreme heat and earthquakes. However, we regret that there is no reference to the Pact for the Future, as there are many references in the Pact that are extremely relevant to disaster risk reduction. We also regret that no consensus was reached on the reference to the Paris Agreement as a legal agreement in its own right and listed in the United Nations Treaty Series. We hope that in the future we will be able to reach a consensus on this issue too. Nevertheless, there are many positive developments that will pave the way for better implementation of disaster risk reduction, which we can hopefully continue to build on in next year's resolution. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:26:40]: Thank the distinguished representative of the European Union. I see no other request for the floor. The committee has thus concluded its consideration of sub-item C of the agenda item 8. Excellencies, esteemed colleagues, would now pause for a brief podium change. I thank you. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 18 (D), protection of global climate for present and future generations of humankind. In order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.21/Rev.1, of the same title as submitted by Uganda on behalf of the Group of 77 and China, and the amendment to the draft resolution contained in document A/C.2/79/L.21/Rev.2, 51, as submitted by the United States of America; in document A/C.2/79/L.53, as submitted by Hungary on behalf of the sponsors listed in the document; and A/C.2/79/L.59, as submitted by the Russian Federation. I wish to thank the rapporteur, Ms. Stephanie Romero Vega of Uruguay, responsible for the item. I also thank the facilitator, Ms. Nishamon Mae See of Thailand, for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution, and delegations for their constructive engagement in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that draft resolution L.21/Rev.1 and the amendments contained in, respectively, L.51, L.53, and L.59 have no program budget implications. Before turning to action on the amendments, does any delegation wish to make a general statement or an explanation of vote before the vote in connection with any or all of the amendments to draft resolution L.21/Rev.1, as contained in documents L.51, L.53 and L.59. I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Colombia. Colombia [1:31:03]: Thank you very much, Madam Chair. Colombia's intervention refers to A/C/2/79/L.53. Climate change is the gravest and most urgent challenge of our times. Climate change jeopardizes even our very survival as a species and restricts any ability to eradicate poverty, hunger, or to achieve any of the SDGs, all the sustainable development of our peoples. There is no greater priority for us than combating climate change, and the science is key about what must be done to pivot to low-carbon development models which are climate resistant. To limit temperature rise to 1.5 degrees centigrade, as we all pledged to do in the Paris Agreement, we need deep, rapid and sustained reductions of greenhouse gases. This will only be possible if we make urgent progress in this transition to put an end to the use of fossil fuels in energy systems. This must be done in a just, orderly and equitable fashion, fast-tracking action in this critical decade. My delegation regrets the lack of openness, readiness and political will from some delegations to abide by the agreement reached at COP28 in Dubai and to reflect updated language which gives account of this. As such, Colombia will vote in favour of the amendment contained in document A/C.2/79/L.53. We believe that a resolution which didn't contain that language, agreed upon not only at the first global stocktake for the Paris Agreement, but also in the pact for the future, would be a resolution which would be far below the minimum acceptable ambition to to reach the Paris Agreement. We invite all delegations to support this amendment, respecting previous agreements and taking into account the principle of intergenerational equity. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:33:12]: I thank the distinguished representative of Colombia. I see no other request for the floor. We now turn to the amendment contained in document L.51. And I invite the representative of the United States of America to present the amendment contained in document L.51. I recall that the limit for introductions is two minutes. You have the floor. United States of America [1:33:41]: Thank you, Madam Chair. The United States offers this amendment to safeguard a critical innovation of the 2030 Agenda, that the three dimensions of sustainable development must be addressed holistically and in a comprehensive way, in a balanced and integrated manner. We object to the use of language in operational paragraph 16 that excludes important elements of international standards and best practices for development, sustainable development that were adopted in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, such as the rule of law, human rights, transparency and equity, equality, accountability, and leaving no one behind. The current language in operational paragraph 16 provides an alternative set of principles that do not enjoy consensus. The amendment we have put forward draws language directly from paragraph 2 of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Declaration to address this concern and facilitate a fully consensus-based text. We urge members, therefore, to vote in favour of this amendment. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:34:49]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States of America. I now give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the proposed amendment. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:34:59]: Thank you, Madam Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor the amendment contained in document L.51, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see no further co-sponsors. Montenegro. That concludes the list. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:35:17]: I thank the Secretary. The Committee will now commence the process of voting on the proposed amendment contained in document L.51. In accordance with rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favour of the amendment, please signify, those against and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:35:54]: The Committee is now voting on the amendment to L21/Rev1 contained in document L51. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:36:19]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour 60, against 107, abstentions 1. The amendment contained in L-51 is rejected. We next turn to the amendment contained in document L-53. I now invite the representative of Hungary to present the amendment contained in document L.53. I recall that the time limit for introduction is two minutes. Hungary · EU [1:36:57]: Madam Chair, thank you for the opportunity to present the amendment to OP-6 tabled by the European Union and its member states and co-sponsored by Canada, Norway, Republic of Korea, Tuvalu, United Kingdom, United States of America, and Palau. As expressed consistently across multiple processes and fora, including during the COP28 and the Summit of the Future negotiations, we take very seriously our commitment on specific actions for an energy transition in line with the temperature goal of the Paris Agreement. The climate resolution is a unique opportunity for the UN General Assembly and its member states to welcome the outcome of COP28. This year, the timing of the resolution negotiations came before the COP29 negotiations and closing session. Next year, we will be reporting on the progress made at COP29, in particular on the new climate finance target. This amendment is verbatim of the consensus reached by Parties at COP28 on specific actions for an energy transition in line with the temperature goal of the Paris Agreement. This is verbatim paragraph 28 of Decision 1/CMA5 on the global stocktake. We have taken the decision to introduce this amendment after it was deleted and replaced by language from COP26 and COP27. We are concerned by the deletion of this paragraph, which sends out a wrong message, even though this language of the deleted paragraph was agreed at COP28 and taken up again a few months ago at the Summit of the Future. We think it is important that this resolution on climate does not forget a key outcome of the COP28 and reflects ambitious, up-to-date, consensus language on the energy transition needed to further implement the Paris Agreement. We are confident that everyone can agree to restore the reference to verbatim from COP28 and energy transition in this important resolution. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:39:00]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the proposed amendment. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:39:12]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I would like to announce that since the submission of the amendment, the following countries have also become co-sponsors of L.53: Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Iceland, Israel, North Macedonia, Palau, Republic of Moldova, and Switzerland. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor the amendment contained in document L.53, please signify by pressing the microphone button. Kiribati, Montenegro, Nauru. That concludes the list. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:40:05]: I thank the Secretary. The Committee will now commence the process of voting on the proposed amendment contained in document L.53. In accordance with rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favour of the amendment, please signify, those against and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:40:40]: The Committee is now voting on the amendment to L/21/Rev.1 contained in document L/53. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:41:14]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour 76, against 88, abstentions 6. The amendment contained in L-53 is rejected. We now turn to the amendment contained in document L-59. I now invite the representative of the Russian Federation to present the amendment contained in document L.59, and I recall that the time limit for introductions is two minutes. Russian Federation [1:41:53]: Thank you, Madam Chair. At the outset, before I present our resolution, allow me to thank the facilitators of the resolution for their tireless attempts to reach consensus on this resolution. We note the fact that we regret the fact that the delegation of the European Union has introduced an amendment with language that is unacceptable for many delegations. Russia, during the consultations, time and again voiced its position about the inclusion of paragraph 28 from the global stocktake. For us, cherry-picking from this consensus-based document is unacceptable. That’s because it upsets the delicate balance achieved in the decision adopted by the Conference of the Parties to the UNFCCC in Dubai. We, together with a number of other delegations, reiterated our position that it was unacceptable to include this language, which – and we broke the silence on this paragraph. And once more, the delegation of the European Union failed to listen to our concerns. And for the third time now, what is up for – during the voting, we demonstrated our position about this cherry-picking. We voted against the amendment. We thank all the delegations that also voted against it. Your voice – your vote against, that is respect for the rules of the negotiations. Your – it is – it shows that you respect the rules of procedure in the Second Committee. Your vote for is a recognition of the immense hard work done by the facilitators of the resolution, who tried their hardest to achieve consensus on the text. Your voice for is a guarantee that going forward, there will be no attempts to unpack the decisions of the UNFCCC COP in the General Assembly. In that regard, I want to say that our amendment against the amendment proposed by the European Union, and we see no point in undertaking a vote on this amendment given the fact that the amendment of the European Union has been voted down. We withdraw our amendment. Merci beaucoup. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:44:11]: I think the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. And we note that the amendment has been withdrawn. I would like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of Mozambique. Mozambique [1:44:34]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Mozambique voted abstain, but I would like to clarify that the right position of Mozambique is against. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:44:55]: I'll give the floor to the Secretary. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:44:58]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Just in the case of any voting intentions, please submit those through the voting intention form on eDelegate and they'll be registered in the relevant report. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:45:56]: We shall proceed to take decision on draft resolution L.21/Rev.1 as a whole. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:46:13]: Thank you, Madam Chair. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor L.21/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. No further co-sponsors. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:46:27]: I thank the Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L/21/Rev.1? I see the United States. You have the floor. United States of America [1:46:43]: Thank you, Madam Chair. We regret that our proposal amendment has failed on operational paragraph 16, and therefore, we would like to call a vote on this paragraph. We ask all Member States to join us in rejecting OP 16, which does not reflect consensus text and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:47:08]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States, and I give the floor to the distinguished representative of Fiji. Fiji [1:47:19]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Fiji's position on climate change is well known and consistent. Small island developing state surrounded by massive Pacific Ocean, this threat of climate change is both real and urgent each day when the world fails to meet its climate goals. In the recent 53rd Pacific Island Forum Leaders Meeting in Tonga, our forum leaders again acknowledged the vulnerability of our region to climate change effects, such as sea level rise and extreme weather events, recognizing that 62% of our critical health facilities and infrastructure in the Pacific are situated within 500 meters of the coastline. In fact, the climate goals, as informed by the IPCC report, as consistent with the Paris Agreement, underscores the urgent need to transition towards 1.5 degrees Celsius pathways, to tripling renewable energy capacity, to phase down coal, to transitioning away and towards halting fossil fuels, all of which are embodied in the carefully negotiated GSD language as proposed in the amendment this morning. Though the language may not be as ambitious as we would have wanted, it provides a minimum benchmark in our collective pursuit, to say the least, to address climate change and in meeting our climate goals. Fiji is concerned that we fell short in this climate change resolution, which should have been channeled to continued advocacy and ambition leading to the next GSD and in our collective pursuit to save our planet. Secondly, we are concerned about the lack of consistency. To be clear, we noted the trends of use of GSD language in resolutions only when it suits our agenda. Agenda item 16A, for instance, on international trade and development that we just considered, it's OP 34, is a GSD language. Unfortunately, it was called to a vote by a group of delegates who called for this amendment. Madam Chair, with this in mind, we need to be guided by science, and we must remain ambitious in our sentiments and actions. Divisive politics and narratives will only weaken our collective ambition in addressing climate change impacts and its means of implementation in ensuring that no one is left behind. We again reiterate our call that immediate, ambitious climate action and financing are essential to mitigate. the severe impacts of climate change. And with this, Fiji voted in favor of both the amendments as reflected L/53/OP.6 and L/51/OP.16. I would like to have this explanation of vote recorded as well in this agenda. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:49:50]: I thank the distinguished representative of Fiji. And I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Micronesia. Micronesia (Federated States of) [1:49:59]: Thank you very much, Madam Chair. And I just had a quick question. We wanted to do an explanation of vote on one of the amendments, but such an opportunity has not yet been given after the vote. Would now be the correct time, or should we wait until after action on the draft as a whole? If you could kindly clarify. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:50:24]: You can please go ahead with the explanation of vote. Micronesia (Federated States of) [1:50:28]: Sorry. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:50:31]: You may go ahead. Micronesia (Federated States of) [1:50:32]: Thank you very much, Chair. I wish to explain our vote on the amendment to L21/Rev.1 contained in document L53. While the language is taken from the Global Stocktake outcome document from COP28, that language falls short of the level of ambition which Micronesia, the Pacific, and AOSIS had advocated for in the COP. For example, we did not think that language on a transition away from fossil fuels was sufficient, especially if it is limited to energy systems. We wanted language calling for the phase-out of fossil fuels in all their forms and uses. Nevertheless, with great difficulty, we joined the consensus in COP28 on the language in the GSD. Since then, we have implored the international community to uphold and build on that outcome, including in various resolutions in the General Assembly. We honor the commitment we made in Dubai, however difficult that may be. We would have expected the rest of the international community to do the same. Therefore, we voted in favor of the amendment. I thank you, Chair. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:52:04]: I thank the distinguished representative of Micronesia, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of China. China [1:52:15]: Madam Chair, climate change is a grave challenge to humanity, demanding a collective response from all countries within the framework of multilateralism. The recently concluded COP29 lends impetus to the global green transition and the implementation of the 2030 Agenda. We hope that all parties can work together, practice true multilateralism, and demonstrate ambition in their collective climate response to create a favorable international environment for the full implementation of the UNFCCC and the Paris Agreement. This draft resolution, OP.16, represents the consensus language of the GA and has been consistently incorporated into this and other resolutions by consensus. Its core content fully demonstrates the way forward and objective requirements of the 2030 Agenda and international collaboration in climate change response. We call on all Member States to vote in favor of operation paragraph 16. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:53:28]: I thank the distinguished representative of China, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia [1:53:37]: Thank you very much, Chair. We would first like to thank you and the facilitators of the resolution on climate. My delegation wishes to provide an explanation of vote on the amendment proposed by the European Union. We have voted against the amendment for the following reasons. COP28 was a significant milestone for the UNFCCC and its Paris Agreement, guiding all countries on the respective paths to achieving its goals. The agreement reached at COP28 was carefully balanced, and is not only in paragraph 28, but across all its related elements. It’s vital that we maintain that balance. Isolating a single element or a paragraph, such as 28, as the core focus of the GSD undermines the full balance. The 196 paragraphs of the GSTR are interconnected and must be considered as a whole. The outcomes of COP28 have reaffirmed the goals of the Paris Agreement as emissions-based and not focused on a specific source. And we stress the need on ambitious action across all areas, not only mitigation, but adaptation, means of implementation, as well as response measures. It's important to note that, as we can see from the vote, there was a majority asking for balance and inclusivity, not against the content, but against the overall balance of the resolution. Therefore, we cannot really accept framing the GST as a single paragraph, losing all the balance that we struck across all areas at COP28. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:55:06]: I thank the distinguished representative of Saudi Arabia, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Singapore. Singapore [1:55:17]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I am taking the floor to explain my delegation's position on the amendment to replace OP6. Singapore maintains our support. Of the UAE Consensus and the outcome of the first global stocktake adopted at the UNFCCC COP28 in 2023. However, we have voted abstain on this amendment to avoid selectively picking certain provisions from this outcome. Nevertheless, my delegation reiterates our continued commitment towards implementation of the UAE Consensus and delivering progress on our efforts. To tackle climate change. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:55:53]: I thank you. the distinguished representative of Singapore, and I see no other request for the floor. A recorded vote has been requested on operative paragraph 16 of L.21/Rev.1. The Committee will now commence the process of voting on operative paragraph 16. In accordance with rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favor of OP.16, please signify, those against, and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:56:42]: The Committee is now voting on operative paragraph 16 of draft resolution L/21/Rev.1. Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:57:07]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favour, 110; against, 52; abstentions, 5. Operative paragraph 16 of L.21/Rev.1 is rejected. UN Secretariat · Secretary [1:57:26]: Retained. 2nd Committee · Chair [1:57:26]: Not retained, sorry. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L.21/REV.1? I see. So I'd like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of Samoa. You have the floor. Samoa · AOSIS [1:58:23]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I have the honor to deliver this general statement on behalf of the Alliance of Small Island States following the adoption of draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.21/Rev.1, entitled "Protection of Global Climate for Present and Future Generations of Humankind". AOSIS wishes to express its appreciation to the facilitator, Ms. May See of Thailand, for her efforts in steering the negotiations on this important resolution, which regrettably could not reach consensus during our consultations. With this in mind, AOSIS deeply regrets that once again, this committee finds itself in the unfortunate situation where a clear lack of willingness and flexibility has undermined the very commitments and decisions that we have collectively taken to address the climate crisis. AOSIS have heard the same promises year after year. We have seen the same pledges made without the necessary political will or follow through. The climate finance we need to adapt to the effects of climate change remain elusive. The mechanisms to hold countries accountable for their emissions are still too weak. Yet with each passing year, this resolution has become a battleground for some to renegotiate, dilute, or entirely ignore decisions of the Conference of Parties to the UNFCCC. At the same time in Baku, we saw too many compromises made for the sake of political convenience. while those who did not cause this crisis bears the brunt of its consequences. In this regard, Madam Chair, this committee plays an important role in ensuring that the international community act on their commitments to ensure that we address the climate crisis. This means keeping our commitment to real, measurable reductions in emissions, a commitment to the global goal of limiting warming to 1.5 degrees. Our commitment to ensure that financial mechanisms are designed not just to meet commitments on paper, but to actually support those on the front lines of climate change. We need developed countries to honor their financial commitments. This must be the baseline that guides our work in this committee. In closing, Madam Chair, AOSIS will continue to demand greater ambition, stronger commitments, and true climate justice. We will raise our voices, advocate for those most vulnerable, and ensure that the world never forgets the urgent need for change. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:00:50]: I thank the distinguished representative of Samoa. I'd like to remind delegates that we have not yet taken action on the draft resolution as a whole. I see no other request for the floor. May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L.21/REV.1? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the draft resolution? I would like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [2:01:35]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Russia has always believed that the climate agenda is unifying in nature. In that regard, we regret the fact that through the actions of a number of delegations which have put the resolution up for a vote – paragraphs up for a vote, the vote on amendments. That said, today’s voting has taught us an important lesson. We’ve seen very clearly that on paragraph 28 of the global stocktake, alas, there’s no consensus among member states. We will remind our partners about the results of this voting if in the future, again, there will be attempts to include this language in – to include this language selectively in the documents of the UN General Assembly. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:02:35]: I thank the distinguished delegate of the Russian Federation, and I now like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of Hungary. Hungary · EU [2:02:46]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I have the honour to speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states. The candidate countries North Macedonia, Montenegro, Albania, Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Georgia, as well as Andorra align themselves with this statement. First of all, let me thank the facilitator and all delegations for their efforts on this year's climate resolution. Climate change is the defining issue of our time, in the words of the Secretary-General. There is indeed an extremely urgent need to strengthen the global response to address the climate emergency with a significant acceleration of global GHG emissions reductions by all countries. Under current NDCs, we will increase emissions by 9% until 2030 instead of reducing them by 43% respect to the 2019 levels, which would be necessary to keep 1.5 degrees Celsius alive. So did this year's climate resolution bring us any further in the global climate discussion? We can hope that, yes, a bit. Together, we have updated this annual resolution with the latest greenhouse gas targets from the latest IPCC reports and the outcomes from COP28. In our new resolution, we confirm the need for rapid and deep GHG emission reductions in this decade, as well as our net zero mid-term goal, which was not a given in the current polarized context. We have added new wording on the just transition pathways and underlined the social and economic benefits of such transitions, consistent with the Paris Agreement. Together, we welcome the second replenishment of the GCF and would welcome additional pledges. However, we deeply regret that this resolution does not reflect ambitious, up-to-date consensus language on the energy transition. As expressed consistently across multiple processes and fora, including during the COP28 and the Summit of the Future negotiations, we take very seriously our commitment on specific actions for an energy transition in line with the temperature goal of the Paris Agreement. That's why, with a group of Member States, we presented an amendment to OP6, which is verbatim of the consensus reached by parties at COP28 on specific actions for an energy transition. We would like to thank all those member states supporting our amendment. We are of the opinion that the Paris Agreement stands on equal footing with the UNFCCC and regret that our proposal to update the reference to the Paris Agreement in the United Nations Treaty Series, like other international treaties, has not found consensus. We hope that in the future we will be able to reach a consensus because to achieve our climate objectives, we must remain united. Here in New York, we will continue to work with interested countries and stakeholders on ambitious climate action, be it in the Security Council, the General Assembly, ECOSOC, or in our dedicated group of friends. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:05:47]: I thank the distinguished representative of Hungary, and I would now like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of Canada. Canada · CANZ [2:05:57]: Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you, Madam Chair, for giving me the floor. I am pleased to deliver this statement on behalf of Australia, New Zealand, and my own country, Canada. We thank Mrs. Maysee of Thailand for her facilitation of this resolution. CANS is deeply appreciative of her expertise and willingness to engage with delegations to reconcile diverse positions. We also extend our thanks to the Secretariat team for their support. Madam Chair, the 1.5 degrees Celsius Paris Agreement global temperature goal cannot be achieved, as has been mentioned. without deep, rapid and sustained reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, including through decarbonizing the energy sector. We therefore supported the amendment to recognize global mitigation actions and ambition, as described in operative paragraph 28 of the Global Stocktake, and it disheartened that this Committee rejected it today. We emphasize that the means of implementation from all sources are an enabler of ambition and should not be treated as a precondition. The overall balance of the resolution does not reflect this. The climate crisis demands that we recognize landmark goals, including in Decision 1/CMA.5, and in particular the global commitments contained in OP.28. Madam Chair, CANS disagrees with the paragraph amendment that packages two distinct elements from the Global Stocktake: the relationship and sequencing between these paragraphs and the context from which they originate. CANS rejects the mischaracterization of the Paris Agreement as somehow subordinate to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change. There's no hierarchy between these two treaties. This is a recurring and cross-cutting issue. We therefore urge future sessions of this committee to address this in a holistic manner across all resolutions to demonstrate a consistent approach. Madam Chair, CANS reaffirms our support for multilateralism and the consensual decision-making that has long been its hallmark. But we cannot deny that the conditions undergirding these customs appear to be eroding year over year. We must galvanize collective climate action and work together to overcome these challenges. Lastly, we reaffirm our commitment to implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development across its three dimensions, economic, social, and environmental, in a balanced and integrated manner. I thank you, Madam Chair. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:08:24]: I thank the distinguished delegate of Canada, and I now give the floor to the distinguished delegate of the United States of America. United States of America [2:08:35]: Thank you, Madam Chair. The United States would also like to join in thanking the facilitator for her efforts and persistence in guiding this resolution over the past several weeks. The United States will join consensus in support of global ambition and efforts to fight climate change. The United States is taking action to tackle the climate crisis at home and abroad to avoid the most catastrophic impacts. This includes, for example, ambitious efforts to reduce net greenhouse gas emissions by 50 to 52% below 2005 levels by 2030; to build global resilience through the Prepare Action Plan, which will help more than half a billion people in developing countries adapt to and manage the impacts of climate change, and to scale up climate finance; We would like to emphasize that the Paris Agreement and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change are distinct international agreements. Although we do not think it is necessary to include footnotes for these well-known agreements in resolutions, where footnotes are included, we further emphasize the importance of using correct and equivalent citations to these agreements, including to the UN Treaty Series number for each agreement. We also emphasize the importance of correctly referencing the distinct nature and respective roles of the Conference of the Parties serving as the meetings of the parties to the Paris Agreement and the Conference of the Parties to the UNFCCC. We will not treat language on the UNFCCC or Paris Agreement in this resolution as precedent or having weight in this or any other forum. Regarding operative paragraph 6, the United States voted in favor of the amendment language that would recognize paragraph 28 of the 2023 outcome of the global stocktake under the Paris Agreement, which sets out a roadmap for keeping the limit on warming of 1.5 degrees Celsius within reach. It is critical that we take forward this key outcome adopted by consensus at the 28th UN Climate Change Conference hosted by the United Arab Emirates, alongside global stocktake elements on adaptation and finance, which are also selectively included in this resolution text. Regretfully, the United States must disassociate from operative paragraph 13 – 16, excuse me. We regret that this paragraph continues to promote the domestic political priorities of an individual member state, rather than including consensus language from the 2030 Agenda that reflects our shared consensus position on sustainable development. We expect that future iterations of this resolution will advance the interests of all Member States and eschew narrow political messaging that undermines consensus, the work of this committee, and our ability to work together in achieving the SDGs. The United States would also dissociate from operative paragraph 23. The developed countries have worked in good faith since 2009 to scale up climate finance to support ambitious climate action in developing countries, drawing on a wide variety of sources, instruments, and channels of finance. We collectively strengthened our efforts when it was clear that private finance mobilization was off track and the 100 billion goal was unlikely to be met in 2020, and have now fully met and exceeded the 100 billion goal as of 2022, delivering 115.9 billion to our developing country partners. It is essential that this collective success be recognized. In order to build trust, we must keep the commitments we make, and we must acknowledge when they have been upheld. Thank you very much. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:12:04]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United Kingdom. United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland [2:12:14]: Thank you, Madam Chair. First, we would like to express our gratitude to the facilitator for their dedication and efforts throughout the negotiations. The United Kingdom is deeply disappointed by the lack of support in this forum for the consensus outcomes of the first global stocktake, in particular on the energy transition. This represents our collective commitments made at COP28 to keep 1.5 in reach and protect vulnerable countries from the impacts of climate change, and were reaffirmed just a few months ago in the Pact for the Future. We have a responsibility to uphold such commitments at the United Nations. The resolution at hand is of critical importance, as it underscores the need to address the climate crisis through urgent and transformative action. The global stocktake has made clear that delivering the energy transition at pace is essential for limiting global warming to 1.5. This requires transitioning away from fossil fuels in a just, orderly, and equitable manner, and a rapid and scaled-up deployment of renewable energy along with energy efficiency measures. The UK stands firmly committed to taking forward these efforts and working with all partners to deliver on the Paris Agreement, supporting the most vulnerable and marginalized countries who are experiencing the worst impacts of the climate crisis. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:13:32]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United Kingdom, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of France. France [2:13:41]: Madam Chair, thank you. I'd like to congratulate the work of the co-facilitators in the line with the EU statement. We'd also like to add the following remarks in our national capacity. Now, naturally, this resolution on climate is a unique opportunity for the GA and member states to welcome the results of COP28 because this resolution and these negotiations took place before the closing session of COP29. COP28 was important because it allowed for there to be a global stocktake of all pillars of the Paris Agreement, mitigation, adaptation, and measures for implementation. I'd also like to recall that it has been signed by 195 member states and is part of the UN treaty collection. It's important to recall that this is also a critical decade as we approach net zero by the middle of the century. We must also meaningfully drive down the use of fossil fuels, double financing, and we also welcome the fact that there was a doubling of financing for adaptation. Technical assistance is also vital, including the operationalization of the Santiago network. We also highlight the link between climate change, food systems, the oceans, and water, and would highlight the crucial role of youth. Regrettably, because this isn't all Perfect. Despite a concrete proposal which sought to return to consensual language, this resolution still contains language which isn't universally accepted. We therefore voted alongside the European Union on this particular paragraph. And here, of course, I'm talking about operative paragraph 16, which France dissociates from. France regrets that the Paris Agreement, which is a universal, open-ended, legally binding agreement for combating climate change, is we regret that this was not subject to consensus here, and this is a fully fledged legal agreement which must not be placed in a hierarchy alongside others. We also welcome the fact that other states, many other states, did welcome the consensus of COP28 on the energy transition. And to end on a positive note, We hope that going forward, we will be able to garner consensus, because to reach our climate goals, we must remain united. We are eager to continue to work together in New York, Berlin, Paris, or elsewhere to strengthen our climate ambition. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:16:25]: I thank the distinguished representative of France, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Mexico. Mexico [2:16:36]: Thank you very much, Chair. Mexico would like to thank the G77 and China for presenting this draft resolution, as well as the delegation of Thailand for their efforts as facilitator for the document. Today, Mexico joined the consensus for this resolution because we firmly believe that humankind is facing a pivotal moment. Mexico's climate change policy is governed by commitment to science and the importance of combating this existential challenge. We have adapted ambitious mitigation goals reflecting our global responsibility and our resolve to stay below the 1.5 degrees Celsius limit. This isn't an idealistic objective, but an urgent need and a prerequisite for the survival of humankind. which we already have committed to as countries. Nevertheless, let us be crystal clear: our support for this text is conditional upon a fundamental principle, and that is just transitions. Mexico is committed to the energy transition and the phasing out of fossil fuels, but only if this transition is a fair one. We cannot accept a transformation which leaves our vulnerable communities behind. disregarding historical inequalities or compounding poverty and exclusion. We regret that elements on a just transition are not reflected in this text because of the failure of amendments to pass. Developing countries such as Mexico wish to and can reach ambitious mitigation objectives, but to do so we need adequate, committed, predictable financing, as well as the transfer of technologies and cooperation mechanisms which need to respect national contexts and capacities. This is a matter of justice, equity and shared responsibility. Throughout the negotiations, Mexico presented proposals seeking to balance the content of this text. We did want it to be ambitious, but also for there to be a better reflection of the more robust language arising out of COP28 on just transitions. Regrettably, these proposals were not fully integrated. Despite this, we think that the text agreed upon is a point of departure and a bridge towards the understanding we so dearly need. We believe that building bridges for discussions is paramount for building lasting, effective consensus in this fight, which affects us all as human beings. Today, we reiterate our commitment towards to continue to be a constructive and ambitious actor in this joint endeavor where no country is able to go it alone. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:19:26]: I thank the distinguished representative of Mexico. I see no other request for the floor. The Committee has thus concluded its consideration of sub-item D of agenda item 18. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 18E. implementation of the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification in those countries experiencing serious drought and/or desertification, particularly in Africa, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.17/Rev.1 of the same title. as submitted by Uganda on behalf of the Group of 77 and China. I wish to thank the rapporteur, Ms. Stephanie Romero Vega of Uruguay, responsible for the item. I would also like to thank my dear co-facilitator, Ms. Audrey Gantana of Namibia, for leading the informal consultations with Iceland on the draft resolution and delegations for their constructive engagement in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that draft resolution L.17/Rev.1 has no programme budget implications. I now give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [2:20:56]: Thank you, Madam Chair. If any countries not members of G-77 and China wish to co-sponsor L.17/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see no further co-sponsors. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:21:15]: I thank the Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L.17/REV.1? May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L.17/REV.1? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the draft resolution? I would like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [2:22:06]: Thank you, Madam Chair. At the outset, I would like to extend my sincere appreciation to you, Madam Chair, and to your co-coordinators of the resolution, to you, the co-facilitators, on the resolution to implement the UN Convention to Combat Desertification, and I thank the Secretariat and the Bureau as well. The COP 16 of the UN Convention to Combat Desertification will take place in Saudi Arabia only next month. That means member states did not have the opportunity to reflect its outcome in the text of the resolution on the implementation of this convention. In order to avoid duplicative efforts, our delegation proposed including in the text of the draft resolution a paragraph that would align the consideration of this resolution with the biennial cycle of the Conference of the Parties to the Convention. We believe that it would be most effective to consider the implementation of the Convention to Combat Desertification in the Second Committee at the session of the General Assembly, which is subsequent to the session of the Conference of the Parties, the COP. I wish to note that during the negotiations, the majority of member states showed flexibility with regard to this proposal. Madam Chair. Given the fact that this paragraph was ultimately not included in the final text, I would like to ask you to include this issue on the agenda of the next meeting on the revitalization of the Second Committee. And I would ask for our request to be reflected in the meeting record. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:23:56]: I thank the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United States. United States of America [2:24:05]: Thank you, Madam Chair. First, we'd like to extend our thanks to the facilitators of this resolution. The United States supports the UN Convention to Combat Desertification in its global efforts to reduce land degradation, increase land restoration, and build resilience to drought. The United States is pleased to join consensus on this resolution. While the Abidjan Call is a useful document, we would like to note that it is not a negotiated document and was not approved by the COP. It was agreed to by a small number, limited number of countries that attended the high-level summit at the head of state level. As such, we do not believe that this belongs in the resolution document. For further elaboration of U.S. policy on the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, technology transfer, climate policy, and other issues, we refer you to the U.S. General Explanation of Position delivered November 13, 2024, and posted online at the U.S. Mission's website. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:25:04]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States. I see no other request for the floor. The Committee has thus concluded its consideration of sub-item E of agenda item 18. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 18F, Convention on Biological Diversity, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.19/Rev.1, entitled “Implementation of the Convention on Biological Diversity and its contribution to sustainable development”, as submitted by Uganda on behalf of the Group of G-77 and China. I wish to thank the rapporteur, Ms. Stephanie Romero Vega of Uruguay, responsible for the item. I also thank the facilitator, Mr. Javad Momeni of the Islamic Republic of Iran, for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution, and delegations for their constructive engagement in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that draft resolution L.19/Rev.1 has no programme budget implications. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship on the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [2:26:23]: Thank you, Madam Chair. If any countries not members of the G77 and China wish to co-sponsor L.19/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. I see no further co-sponsors. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:26:38]: I thank the Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L.19/Rev.1? May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L.19/Rev.1? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the draft resolution? I would like to give the floor to the distinguished delegate of the Russian Federation. Russian Federation [2:27:16]: Thank you, Madam Chair. At the outset, I want to extend my sincere gratitude to the facilitator of the resolution of the United Nations General Assembly on the implementation of the UN Convention on Biodiversity, and I thank the representatives of the Secretariat and the Bureau as well. Having said that, I want to voice our serious concerns about the negotiations process on this resolution. We regret to note that the long length of this resolution prevented full-fledged discussions from taking place on the text. I want to stress the fact that during the six rounds of negotiations, which were an hour and a half each and are stipulated by the Rules of Procedure of the Second Committee, it was impossible to discuss this volume. of text, we regret the fact that our attempts to streamline the text did not meet with understanding. We would propose to the authors of the resolution that they look into the possibility of submitting a more – a shorter and more succinct draft at the future session of the committee that’s pursuant to paragraph 45 of UNGA Resolution 77/335. negotiation process, also the fact came to light, the fact that the outcome of the COP 16 on biodiversity in Colombia was available only in late November. That was at the end of the work of the committee. That meant that the delegations were compelled to respond to new proposals at the final stage of the process, when usually the text should already be agreed upon ad referendum. Our delegation warned about this turn of events during the general debate at the beginning of the work of the committee, and we made a proposal aligning the text of the resolution with the consideration of – we wanted to align the consideration of this resolution with the biennial cycle of the Conference of the Parties to the Convention. We believe that it would be most effective to consider the implementation of the Convention on Biodiversity in the Second Committee. at the General Assembly session subsequent to the holding of the Conference of the Parties. We note – we regret the fact that delegations didn’t find time to fully discuss our proposal. However, I want to note that during the negotiations, we didn’t hear any opinions that would refute the logic of our proposal. In that regard, Madam Chair, we would like to ask you to include this issue on to the agenda of the next meeting dedicated to the revitalization of the work of the Second Committee, and we ask for our request to be reflected in this meeting’s record. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:30:03]: I thank the distinguished representative of the Russian Federation, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the United States. United States of America [2:30:12]: Thank you, Madam Chair. First, we’d like to extend our thanks and appreciation to the facilitator for this resolution. The United States is pleased to join consensus on this resolution. The global decline of nature represents an existential threat to livelihoods, food systems, and health, and continued efforts to advance sustainable development efforts. The United States is committed to halting and reversing loss of biodiversity globally, and has committed significant financial investment towards the national goal of conserving at least 30% of U.S. lands and waters by 2030. We would like to take this opportunity to clarify our position on the following. The United States has always been a strong supporter of the Convention on Biological Diversity, and we continue to support the three objectives of the convention. The United States is committed to the halting and reversing of biodiversity loss globally, and we welcome the Global Biodiversity Framework and strongly support its swift implementation. However, as a non-party government observer to the convention, we are not in a position to ensure the implementation of decisions adopted by parties. Further, the United States has long held the view that negotiated outcomes and decisions of the Conference of the Parties, such as the Convention on Biological Diversity and the UN Climate Change Conference, are not legally binding. The United States supports the rights of Indigenous Peoples and recognizes their vital contributions to biodiversity conservation. We reaffirm our support of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, which is a watershed instrument of moral and political force. We reiterate our legal positions in our 2010 statement of support, including our understanding that free, prior, and informed consent means meaningful consultation with tribal leaders. We further note that the UNDRIP does not make reference to local communities, a term that is undefined at the international level. While we understand Indigenous Peoples and local communities are often referenced together in the climate space, we recognize that Indigenous Peoples as a distinct constituency of the United Nations, not to be conflated with other groups. Additionally, as we have previously stated, we understand people of African descent to refer to individuals of African descent. We reiterate that the United Nations Environment Assembly Resolution 6/4 preamble encourages member states, not conventions, to enhance synergies among environmental agreements and maintain that direct synergies should happen in national level implementation and coordination. Further, we welcome the Summit of the Future and acknowledge the positive contributions of the Pact to the Future and its annexes to our shared goal of making the UN system responsive, effective, and capable of addressing current and future world challenges, including biodiversity. We regret one country's efforts to delete references to the Pact from all 2C resolutions, including this one. For additional detail on U.S. positions, we refer you to the U.S. general statement delivered on November 13, 2024, to the 79th General Assembly Second Committee session. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:33:15]: I thank the distinguished representative of the United States, and I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of the European Union. EU · EU [2:33:25]: Madam Chair, I have the honor to deliver this statement on behalf of the European Union and its member states. The candidate countries North Macedonia, Montenegro, Albania, Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Georgia, as well as Monaco, aligned themselves with this statement. At the outset, we would like to thank the facilitator, Mr. Javad Momeni, for leading the informal consultations. We would also like to thank Colombia as the host of CBD COP 16 in Cali. the Secretariat, and all other partners and delegations who actively participated in the consultations. The adoption of the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework in 2022 was a historic deal for nature and a real watershed moment for halting and reversing biodiversity loss. A couple of weeks ago, at COP16 in Colombia, the world came together for the first time to take stock of the framework's implementation and to agree on steps for the acceleration of its implementation. In this year's consultations, it was our intention to reflect the COP16 outcomes and other important developments in this resolution. Similar to the outcomes of COP16, we believe we succeeded in some areas, while others require further work. We specifically welcome the incorporation of references to several key COP16 decisions, as well as the reference to issues on which the resumed COP will still need to decide. We are also pleased with the references to the upcoming 2025 UN Ocean Conference in Nice next year and the 2026 UN Water Conference. We regret, however, that several important COP16 decisions are not reflected in this resolution, including on climate, on health, and on ecologically or biologically significant marine areas. We also regret that an important operative paragraph with rich language was deleted without a proper discussion, and that numerous other important proposals from our side were not incorporated, including on the global stocktake decision, the BBNJ agreement, and on animal health. In addition, we are disappointed that the text does not welcome the Summit of the Future or the Pact for the Future and its annexes, which were adopted by consensus by our leaders and are very relevant for biodiversity protection. Furthermore, we hope that in the future, we can agree on the reference to the Paris Agreement in the UN treaty series. And finally, we believe the biannualization of this resolution would be inappropriate in light of the biodiversity crisis that the world is facing, as we also repeatedly expressed during the informal consultations. Madam Chair, the EU and its member states joined consensus on this important resolution today. We will continue to keep the issue of biodiversity high on the international agenda. With only a few years left to reach the 2030 targets, the early, effective, and inclusive implementation of the Global Biodiversity Framework must remain a priority that unites us all. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:36:41]: I thank the distinguished representative of the European Union. I see no other request for the floor. The Committee has thus concluded its consideration of sub-item F of agenda item 18. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 18 (H), Harmony with nature, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.39/Rev.1. of the same title, as submitted by Uganda on behalf of the Group of 77 and China. I wish to thank the rapporteur, Ms. Stephanie Romero Vega of Uruguay, responsible for the item. I also thank the facilitator, Mr. Frank Telles Alonso of Cuba, for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution, and delegations for their constructive engagement in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that draft resolution L.39/Rev.1 has no programme budget implications. I now give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [2:37:53]: Thank you, Madam Chair. If any countries not members of the Group of 77 and China wish to co-sponsor L.39/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. No further co-sponsors. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:38:08]: I thank the Secretary. Does any delegation wish to make a statement in connection with draft resolution L.39/Rev.1? May I take it that the Committee wishes to adopt draft resolution L.39/Rev.1? I hear no objection. It is so decided. Does any delegation wish to make a statement after the adoption of the draft resolution? I would like to give the floor to the distinguished delegate of the United States. United States of America [2:38:52]: Thank you, Madam Chair. The United States is pleased to join consensus on this resolution. For elaboration of U.S. policy positions on the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, climate policy, and other issues, we refer you to the U.S. General Explanation of Position delivered November 13th, 2024, and posted online at the U.S. mission's website. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:39:18]: I thank the distinguished delegate from the United States. I see no other request for the floor. The Committee has thus concluded its consideration of sub-item H of agenda item 18. I now invite the Committee to resume its consideration of agenda item 18 (K), promoting the social and solidarity economy for sustainable development, in order to take action on draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.22/Rev.1. of the same title, as submitted by Senegal on behalf of the sponsors listed in the document. I wish to thank the rapporteur, Ms. Stephanie Romero Vega of Uruguay, responsible for the item. I also thank the co-facilitators, Mr. Óscar Encinas Madrid of Chile, Mr. Assane Diom of Senegal, and Mr. Xavier Belmont of Spain for leading the informal consultations on the draft resolution and delegations for their constructive engagements in the negotiations. I would like to inform the Committee that draft resolution L.22/Rev.1 has no programme budget implications. I now give the floor to the representative of Chile to introduce the draft resolution. I recall that the time limit for introductions is two minutes. Chile · Chile, Senegal and Spain [2:40:44]: Madam Chair, I have the honor to introduce on behalf of the facilitators Chile, Senegal, and Spain, draft resolution entitled Promoting Social and Solidarity Economy for Sustainable Development. On April 2023, the UN General Assembly adopted by consensus its first resolution on the social and solidarity economy to encourage its promotion as an inclusive economic model with social objectives based on internal solidarity and with people at the center. Based on this effort, this year, for the first time, the Second Committee will consider the resolution entitled "Promoting Social and Solidarity Economy for Sustainable Development." At this outset, we regret that a vote was requested even though the silence procedure Passed without any objection. This resolution emphasizes the importance of the social and solidarity economy as a key driver for inclusive and sustainable development, particularly in terms of promoting decent work, reducing inequalities, and fostering social transformation. It also recognizes the critical role of SSE entities, including cooperatives, social enterprises, and mutual organizations, in addressing economic challenges, particularly for vulnerable groups such as women, youth, and persons with disabilities. We must not forget the contributions of SSE to achieving the sustainable development goals are significant, particularly in areas such as employment, social services, gender equality, environmental protection, and local economic development. Furthermore, it encourages member states to integrate SSE principles into national and regional policies as appropriate, calling for adequate legal frameworks, financial support, and access to capacity building initiatives. This draft resolution also calls for enhanced international collaboration and the exchange of best practices, and highlights the importance of fostering partnerships and ensuring participatory governance to unlock the full potential of SSE in achieving the SDGs. Finally, Chile, Senegal, and Spain would like to thank the delegations for their active participation throughout the negotiation process. We look forward to the valuable support and co-sponsorship of the text. Thank you so much. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:42:48]: I think the distinguished representative of Chile. I give the floor to the Secretary on the co-sponsorship of the draft resolution. UN Secretariat · Secretary [2:42:57]: Thank you, Madam Chair. I would like to announce that since the submission of the revised draft resolution, and in addition to those delegations listed on the L document, the following countries have also become co-sponsors of L/22/Rev.1: Albania, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Bulgaria, Colombia, Costa Rica, Croatia, Cyprus, Czechia, Denmark, El Salvador, Estonia, Eswatini, Finland, Gambia, Germany, Greece, Guatemala, Honduras, Hungary, Indonesia, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, North Macedonia, Poland, Portugal, Republic of Moldova, Romania, Sierra Leone, Sweden, United Republic of Tanzania, Uruguay, and Uzbekistan. If any other countries wish to co-sponsor L/22/Rev.1, please signify by pressing the microphone button. Cabo Verde, Morocco, Montenegro, Philippines, and Lebanon, and Vietnam. That concludes the list. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:44:16]: Thank you. I thank the Secretary. A recorded vote has been requested on draft resolution L.22/Rev.1, entitled "Promoting the social and solidarity economy for sustainable development". Before proceeding to the vote, I will give the floor to any sponsored delegation wishing to make a general statement in connection with the draft proposal, or any non-sponsored delegation wishing to make a statement in explanation of vote. Does any delegation wish to make a general statement or an explanation of vote before the vote in connection with draft resolution L.22/Rev.1? I give the floor to the distinguished delegate of the European Union. EU · EU [2:45:05]: Thank you. Madam Chair, I have the honour to speak on behalf of the European Union and its member states. The candidate countries, Serbia, Ukraine, and Georgia, align themselves with this statement. First, I wish to commend the work of the co-facilitators, Mr. Oscar Encinas Madrid from Chile, Mr. Assane Dioum from Senegal, and Mr. Xavier Belmont from Spain, who have led the informal consultations with great professionalism and in the spirit of compromise, as well as Mr. Raymond Landveld from UN Trade and Development, representing the Secretariat and the UN Interagency Task Force on Social and Solidarity Economy. The social and solidarity economy is a crucial vehicle to accelerate our efforts towards fully achieving the sustainable development goals in favor of economic prosperity and in social and environmental harmony, leaving no one behind. The social and solidarity economy goes beyond the sole economic lens. It is a broader vision and model for our societies. On the one hand, the social front, it places human beings before profits and reduces inequalities, notably promoting the reinvestment of earnings and democratic governments. On the other hand, the environmental front, it fosters sustainable production and consumption as well as circular economy. The social and solidarity economy richness stems from its great diversity of models and structures, as well as in its flexibility and ability for innovation. All of this opens up many new avenues for making this world a better, more sustainable, and more humane place. The social and solidarity economy is also by nature based on a strong partnership model, working with a variety of stakeholders. In the recent years, we have seen important growth in the social and solidarity economy in all regions of the world, with more recognition, policies, and legislation at national and international levels in its favor. Following the International Labour Organization resolution in 2022, the first resolution adopted by the General Assembly last year was a crucial milestone for the international recognition of the social and solidarity economy and its important potential to accelerate sustainable development. Madam Chair, the EU's commitments to favour the social and solidarity economy remains steadfast, as we believe it has great potential for sustainable development for everyone. I thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:47:41]: I thank the distinguished representative of the European Union, and I see no other request for the floor. The Committee will now commence the process of voting on draft resolution L.22/Rev.1. In accordance with rule 128, no representative may interrupt the voting except on a point of order in connection with the actual process of voting. Delegations are kindly requested to indicate their votes. Those in favor of draft resolution L.22/Rev.1, please signify, those against, and abstentions. UN Secretariat · Secretary [2:48:23]: The Committee is now voting on draft resolution L.22/Rev.1, entitled "Promoting the social and solidarity economy for sustainable development". Will all delegations confirm that their votes are correctly reflected on the screen? The voting has been completed. Please lock the voting machine. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:48:49]: The result of the vote is as follows: in favor, 175; against, zero; abstentions, one. Draft resolution A/C.2/79/L.22/Rev.1 is adopted. Does any delegation wish to make an explanation of vote or general statement after the vote on the draft resolution? I would like to give the floor to the distinguished representative of Argentina. Argentina [2:49:26]: Thank you, Chair. Chair, the Republic of Argentina has requested a vote on this resolution and abstained. on it because of the following reasons: our country took a political path under the hallmark of the open market economy, the promotion of investment, the strengthening of the rule of law, promoting the free competition of economic actors, and full integration into the global economy, making it possible to have added value exports. Argentina therefore has as its guide the following principles: protection of life, freedom, and private property. Because of this, Argentina engage in all necessary discussions to try and uphold these guiding principles. In promoting the principle of freedom, we believe that national sovereignty is vital for solving issues to build a shared future based on progress and freedom. Therefore, capitalism and free enterprise and economic systems are the only tool we have at our disposal to ensure sustainable development and put an end to hunger, poverty, and extreme poverty across the world. Therefore, the Republic of Argentina, in conclusion, abstained from voting on this state-based approach, which would undermine the ability of each individual to pursue their own future. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:50:52]: I thank the distinguished representative of Argentina. I now give the floor to the distinguished representative of Senegal. Senegal · Chile, Senegal and Spain [2:51:05]: Thank you, Madam Chair. It is an honor to deliver this statement on behalf of Chile, Spain, my country, and my country Senegal. First off, I’d like to thank all the delegations that participated in the informal consultations on the draft resolution. I thank them for their flexibility and constructive approach throughout the process. Madam Chair, our delegation was surprised about the vote requested on this consensus-based resolution that successfully passed through the procedure of silence following the informal discussions. This was a technical rollover of the previous resolution adopted by consensus by the General Assembly in April of 2023, and it contained no controversial language or politicized language. Furthermore, the reasons voiced by the delegation that requested the vote were never raised during the negotiations. Madam Chair, the social and solidarity economy is not opposed to capitalism. It offers an alternative framework for action and for sustainability, and it seeks to ensure social well-being rather than simply maximizing profit, as stressed by the report of the SG. Businesses in the social and solidarity economy have a key role to play in bolstering the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, while ensuring equality and sustainable jobs through initiatives and through small, medium-sized businesses, they help to spur economic diversity and resilience. We thank all of the delegations that co-sponsored and voted for this resolution, and it is our hope that it will be adopted once more by consensus in the next meetings. Thank you. 2nd Committee · Chair [2:53:06]: I think the distinguished representative of Senegal. I see no other request for the floor. The Committee has thus concluded its consideration of sub-item K of agenda item 18. It is now past 1:00 PM. I will therefore adjourn the meeting. The next plenary meeting of the Committee will take place this afternoon at 3:00 PM in this conference room to continue taking action on draft proposals. Any updated list of proposals for action will be circulated before the afternoon meeting. The meeting is adjourned.