2270th Meeting, 85th Session, Committee against Torture (CAT) Date: 18 November 2026 Language: English Transcript: https://transcripts.un.org/ru/cat/2270?lang=en Transcripts available through this tool are created by using automatic speech recognition and are not official records nor official documents of the United Nations. Official records and official documents are available on the Official Document System of the United Nations. --- CAT · Chair [14:30]: Let us start meeting number 2270 of the Committee against Torture. And I should once again like to welcome the delegation of Moldova to continue with the dialogue that we started yesterday. So, without further ado, I should like to give the floor to the State Secretary, Mrs. Alexandru-Bejan, to coordinate the responses from the delegation. You have the floor, sir. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [15:03]: Thank you. Honourable Chair, distinguished members of the Committee, I would like, first of all, to thank you for yesterday's session. We view the question raised as a very useful exercise. for the authorities of the Republic of Moldova, given our firm commitment to establishing effective national policies and standards for combating torture and preventing ill-treatment. We will proceed mostly in the order in which the questions were addressed. I ask my colleagues to be briefly in their intervention, about three minutes for each question. I suggest we begin with the section on definition and criminalization of torture. And in this regard, I would like to give the floor to Mr. Leon Apostol, State Secretary of Ministry of Justice. Please. My colleagues report a technical problem. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [16:52]: Stop. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [17:11]: Please try again. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [18:01]: This is the test. Do you hear us? Because we were unable to hear you from the beginning. I'm sorry. And we were unable actually even to notify that we are in this. You were totally silent. I'm sorry for these technical difficulties. Do you hear us? Speaker 6 [18:24]: Yes. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [18:27]: Good. So I imagine, so in order to save time, I think our chief delegation gave me the time to respond to certain questions. So I will begin this with this assumption. Is it so? Okay, good. So I will start to answer certain questions put that members of the Committee formulated yesterday. First, with regard to definition and criminalization of torture, our position of the government is quite clear in this respect. Our legal framework is already compatible with Article one of the convention, and no further legislative amendment is actually required. And allow me please to explain why. Our article 166-1 was amended in 2012, and it criminalizes the entire spectrum of ill-treatment in a single provision already. It looks on various forms inhuman and inigredient treatment in paragraph 1 and 2, and torture in paragraph 3, and aggravated torture in paragraph 4. So, from legal perspective, this is practically a transposition, mota mota, of the Article 1 of the Convention. It contains all main four elements: an intentional act, severe physical and mental pain or suffering, the purpose. Obtaining information and confession from the victim, and so on, so on, punish and intimidating, coercion. I will not go into all these details. the official element, this is what is important for us to actually notify that we, in fact, introduced wider guarantees, specifically in two respect. Our definition is even a little bit wider than it is in Convention. First, we It does not contain so-called exception of lawful sanction, and it expressly covers person exercising public authority de facto. This will not be found in the classical meaning of torture under the Convention. So our legislative definition of torture actually goes beyond that. So Article 1, paragraph 2 of the Convention allows national legislation to provide application. So in this general comment, the Committee asks that domestic offense cover at minimum the elements of Article 1. Neither the Convention nor the Committee requires verbatim a single compact provision that was asked from us yesterday. Integrating this definition into a graduated offence basic form, aggravated forms, and the distinct offence of torture follows the established legislative technique of our criminal legislation, and it falls within the hours of the reign legislative prerogative. Read together, all the paragraphs of article in question covers the whole range of the conduct prohibited by Article 1 of the Convention and including Article 16 of the Convention. In addition, Article 1, paragraph 3, in case of the inconsistency of alleged inconsistency of international human rights treaty, our criminal code provides the priority of application of international treaty. And this priority, I will speak later in answering another question concerning the relation between the convention and its value in our legal system. So overall, amendments in 2012 actually excluded all, it defined torture, it defined the prohibited conduct according to the Convention, and also it excluded all possibilities in ensuring the deterrent effect of these provisions. I here relate to the article 60, paragraph 8 of the criminal code, also mentioned by the rapporteur, that no statute of limitation applies to torture. Also, no amnesty applies to the torture. Courts may not impose a penalty more lenient than it was provided by the law. The aggravated forms of ill-treatment also do not allow a conditional suspension of the sentences and conditional early release, no parole, no everything. So that was the sense of the reform in 2012. So overall, our legislation actually provides an absolute prohibition from legislative framework, an absolute prohibition, including deterrent effect. No amendments are needed, and these provisions were consulted and actually agreed with the. Pending provision of the Committee of Ministers on certain number of judgments that raised some issues of compatibility of our legislations, and the Council of Europe Committee of Ministers actually agreed and close supervision on these aspects. So we do not envisage amending further legislation, because we consider this legislation already compatible. Another question that was raised, this about the role of people's advocate and the role of national. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [25:34]: Thank you. We don't hear you, I'm sorry. I will just pass to next question. I just want to announce that the next question is about People's Advocate and the Council for Prevention in the context of institutional independence and the amendment to law number 16. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [25:52]: Dear members, if you hear us, we would like to have a test for 12. Seconds, because we don't hear you. I'm sorry. We will restart the system and reconnect. Sorry. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [26:43]: Now you hear us. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [27:10]: We would like to reconnect, if you hear us, we would like to log out and reconnect again, and so please take this note. on your part that we will be reconnecting to the link you provided for us. Could you say something? So. Perfect, fine. Do you hear us? Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [28:10]: Thanks. Yes. Yeah. Okay. I'm sorry for technical issues. So once again, thank you, Mr. Apostol. Now we want to pass to next questions connected to People's Advocate and Council for the Prevention of Torture, in the context of the institutional independence and the question that we have in the context of the amendment to law 62. Please. 52, sorry. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [28:45]: Thank you. Thank you, dear Chair and members of the Committee. In order to answer this question, let me first place this question into the context. In 2014, a committee report mentioned the draft law, and the rapporteur yesterday also mentioned this draft law of 2020, that What I would like to mention that at that time, that law, draft law, reflected the legal and institutional situation at that time. Since then, the situation and the context considerably evolved. And let me explain where how it evolved, and you will understand that all the provisions, all initiatives, legislative initiatives from the draft law ensuring independence of the People's Advocates Office and the national preventive mechanisms, the role of the national preventive mechanism, actually evolved considerably. So, law on People's Advocates Office has been considerably amended. A number of amendments since 2014 and 2020. The capacities of the office have been consolidated as well. It's not only legal amendment, but also institutional capacities has been consolidated. The best confirmation of this in 2023 General Assembly of the National Human Rights Institutions actually re-accredited our People Advocates Office, given its status A, and this is the highest status, which means that they considered that how our People Advocates Office works is a means in full compliance with the Paris Principles, including in independence, mandate, and resources. The law is currently, indeed, is undergoing further review as part of approximation of our legislation with EU standards on national human rights institutions. In this, in our overall context of integration and accession process to the EU. Further amendments are underway. in consultation with the People's Advocates Office, civil society, and our international partners. The draft law, though it seems to be withdrawn in 2020, has been absorbed in broader process of reform of national human rights institutions, in particular of our People's Advocates Office. So the issues raised in that draft law already either have been already addressed comprehensively or will be addressed, certain aspects will be addressed in the further amendments. Of our People's Advocate Office. So second point, the module concerning the now National Preventive Institute. I would say that this is our legitimate and sovereign choice, where it lies, how independence is ensured. Article 17 of the Optional Protocol to the Convention allows each state to maintain, designate, establish one or several independent national preventive mechanisms. The Committee's own guidelines on national preventive mechanisms accept that national preventive mechanisms may be placed within the existing institution, provided that it has distinct unit with its own staff and budget. This is precisely Moldovan model. The Council for Prevention of Torture, this is our national preventive mechanism, is established by law. It is not administrative, simple administrative division. It's established by law within the People's Advocate institution. It's supported by a specialized torture prevention department of office and financed through a separate ring-fenced budget line approved by the parliament. The Council is therefore covered by full constitutional and legal independence of the office of the People's Advocate's Office itself. Its five civil society members are selected through a public competition, as the Committee notes. The council independently selects the places to visit and the persons to interview and carries out the visit without prior notice or authorization from penitentiary institutions, for example. It reports and recommendations are published, transparent. Independence, impartiality, objectivity, and confidentiality are therefore guaranteed both in law and practice. In our view, the existing arrangements do not create any ambiguity that would undermine these principles. One question was on the alleged interferences into the people's advocates' activity. The law guarantees that People Advocate is independent, it's a constitutional figure. It is selected and appointed by the parliament. It's independent of any public authority and cannot receive instructions. A request by any official to modify or whatever, to instruct People Advocate's office has no legal effect, has no legal meaning, no legal basis. And the office is under no obligation to follow any instructions, whatever these instructions came from. The People's Advocate reported these attempts, and the government and the parliament, which shows, reported some of the attempts to the government and the parliament, which actually in practice shows that this safeguard of independence works. The government reaffirms that it does not accept any interference into the. Office's work, and will continue to remind all the authorities of this implication of no interferences. And no other interferences registered. This is simply unacceptable. We cannot even provide, we. Should also understand that we should not take freedom of speech of some parliamentarians as an attempt of interferences. This is another discussion, but no interferences were registered, and no interferences, if there are any interferences, the People's Advocate Office has. Has the parliamentary control as a safeguard and a guarantee of his independence. So there is one little question concerning cooperation with other international organizations, and I just have to reaffirm that our government remains open for cooperation with the Office of Human Rights with the Council of Europe and General Assembly of National Human Rights Institutions. We take all this seriously, all their recommendations concerning the improvement of People's Advocates Office and national preventive mechanisms. This is reflected in our legislative process. We always take also expertise, we ask for expertise from these institutions when we pass or discuss amendments. So currently, as I mentioned from the beginning of my answer, we have legislative improvements, and all these considerations reflect actually these corporations. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [37:48]: Thank you, Mr. Apostol. Now I want to continue with the question connected to legal status and domestic application of the Convention. We'll continue with Mr. Apostol. Would the State Party confirm that the Convention is directly applicable and enforceable in the domestic legal system? Mr. Apostol, briefly, please. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [38:12]: Thank you. Thank you very much. The brief answer is yes, the Convention is directly applicable and enforceable in our legal national order. Its legal status, it's even undisputed. Let me explain for this several reasons. First, this is a provision of the Constitution. Under Article 4 of our Constitution, Constitutional provisions on human rights are being understood and interpreted and applied in the corners of the human rights treaties to which Moldova is a party. Where there is a conflict between the national legislation and even the constitution, international law prevails. Article 8 also commits the state to observe the treaties to which it is a party, international treaties to which it is a party. This was the interpretation of our constitutional court in its judgment even for 1999. It gave an interpretation to Article 4 of the constitution, so-called prevalence of international human rights treaty in particular. It prevails in various situations, when there is a conflict in domestic legislation, when there is conflicting domestic legislation between. Ordinary laws and constitution, international treaties always prevail and may be applied directly. in court. That was a development from constitutional court that actually compelled national courts, and I mentioned here also our prosecution system, to apply directly international provision, in particular, this was referred to the European Court case law. But the idea was mentioned to any international treaty, including the present Convention, is also directly applicable. So this is not only a constitutional provision, this principle of prevalence is also repeated in our core legislation and criminal procedure code and criminal legislation, civil procedure code, whatever. For example, article 1, paragraph 3 of our criminal code provides that in case of inconsistency with international human rights instruments, international regulations, international treaty take priority and apply directly. Similar priority exists in our procedural legislation, as I mentioned, both criminal and civil. Judges and prosecutors are therefore obliged, compelled to apply international human rights law, including the Convention, in their daily work. Any party to judicial proceedings may invoke the Convention directly, and the court might give, is actually compelled to give a reasoned answer to that to that application, to that request to apply directly. The Supreme Court of Justice has actually guided the lower courts to apply. International standards directly, and these standards are part of mandatory initial and continuous training at the National Institute of Justice. For specific examples, I think we may have also our colleagues from General Prosecutor Office here. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [42:15]: My colleague, I'll ask my colleague, Mr. Russo, from the General Prosecution to intervene briefly, to intervene with examples. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [42:25]: Yes. Just short form, practical perspective, every decision adopted by prosecutor or judges in criminal cases involving allegation of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment is based on the provisions of national legislation interpreted and applied in accordance with international human rights standards. In this regard, prosecutors and judges apply the provisions of the European Court of Human Rights as well as the United Nations Convention against Torture. For instance, every order bringing a person under accusation for acts of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment includes an explicit reference to the violation of international conventions. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [43:20]: Thank you, Mr. Rusu. We'll pass to next questions about the universal jurisdiction. And in this context, I'll ask once again Mr. Apostol to intervene and to cover the subject with the current situation in Transnistria. Please, Mr. Apostol. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [43:44]: Thank you. Legislation. Our national legislation covers universal jurisdiction, and let me go a little bit further into legal details. So, universal jurisdiction is actually set out in the general part of our criminal code. First, we have article one, paragraph one of the criminal code that actually covers territorial jurisdiction. It covers all offenses committed on the territory of Moldova. This is the basic principle. At paragraph five and six, extend jurisdiction to territorial waters and other territory, aircraft, ships, and so on. So this is territorial jurisdiction. We also have in article 11 of the criminal procedure code, paragraph two, so-called active and passive personality universal jurisdiction. It covers Moldovan nationals and stateless residents who commit offenses abroad. So this is article 11, paragraph three. This is passive personality, covers foreigners and commits offenses abroad against the citizens and residents of Republic of Moldova. This is one application of the universal jurisdiction. When it comes to universal jurisdiction and connection with the principle, "od dederet, od judicari," Article 11, paragraph three, also establishes jurisdiction over foreigners and stateless persons for international crimes. We mentioned that against peace, humanity, war crimes, and any other offenses provided by international treaties to which Republic of Moldova is a party. So, in legal terms, this includes torture under this convention. Accordingly, we have the universal jurisdiction covered in our criminal procedure code. The only condition is that no final judgment has been already delivered abroad, so-called non bis in idem principle. So that is the only condition that limits universal jurisdiction. The same paragraph expressly provides that foreigners who commit offenses abroad and cannot be extradited and criminally liable under the criminal, under the Moldovan criminal code. So this is direct transposition of or didiary or judiciary principle. So mainly I answered the question concerning the universal jurisdiction. And now I will pass to the question regarding Transnistria. So here, the government position remains that is already stated with the reference to the Moser judgment in 2017. The Transnistrian region is an integral part of the territory of Republic of Moldova. At the same time, the Transnistrian conflict remains unresolved, which means constitutional authorities continue to lack access to this region. and cannot exercise its sovereignty over there. The conflict resolution process is ongoing. The situation is further complicated by the continuing unlawful military presence of the Russian Federation in that region. Let me note that the European Court of Human Rights has addressed this situation consistently in a number of judgments. Elashko, Katan, Mozer, let's mention, and more recently, it actually reiterated the same rationale in Lipovychenko and Halabudenko. This is the case of 2024. The court held in all these cases that the Russian Federation exercises effective and overall control and decisive influence over the region, and it is responsible for the violation committed there. So attribution to the human rights violation to Russian Federation. Moldova, for its part, retains its positive obligations to use all legal, diplomatic, and political means available to protect the rights of people living there and to pursue a peaceful settlement and the reintegration of the country. In Moisan and subsequent judgments that I mentioned previously. The Court found that Moldova had met this obligation and found no violation against Moldova. Moldova continues to fulfill this obligation every day. It pursues the peaceful settlement process, raises individual cases with the de facto authorities and international partners. And keeps its institutions, including the judiciary and prosecution service, and the People's Advocate Office, open to residents coming from that region. Moldova maintains zero tolerance for any human rights violation coming from that region. However, the full application of the Convention in this situation remains more or less impossible as long as the conflict is unresolved. Let me mention here that through a dialogue and negotiation, Moldovan authorities managed to secure, for example, release of a number of persons which were detained in the Transnistrian region on political grounds. This work continues on a permanent basis. Moldova counts on the support of this Committee and the international community in this regard. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [49:51]: Thank you, Mr. Apostol. With the permission of Honourable Chair, I'd like to continue with Minister of Justice in the context of two questions that we had from the report of Mr. Abdallah. And in this context, I will ask my colleagues, Mr. Apostol, just to intervene with the response to question for incommunicado detention. Please. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [50:21]: Many thanks. So, again, let me be clear: incommunicado detention is absolutely prohibited in our law and in practice, and is not permitted in any circumstances. We don't have any provisions, any practices actually somehow allowing such detentions to be effected in practice. No one would authorize this kind of incommunicado detention. So legal framework, Article 25 of the Constitution guarantees individual. Liberty, it requires that detained persons should be informed properly, promptly of the reason of detention. It limits the detention to 72, the initial arrest, to 72 hours and the pre-trial detention to one year. Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, article 64, for example, guarantees immediate access to a lawyer. Including state-guaranteed legal aid and two independent medical examinations. Article 173 requires that the officer or investigator who drew up the arrest report to enable It must enable the detained person, the arrested person, to notify the close relative or another person of his or her choice of the place of. Detention immediately, and in any event only within the 60 hours or to make the notification personally, and. This could be delayed only under the judicial control. But no. Longer than, if I'm not wrong, 12 hours and so on, only under judicial control. So there are a number of procedural guarantees that do not allow actually incommunicado detention. On admission to any detention facility, detainees may also notify their relatives of their whereabouts and meet their lawyer in confidential circumstances without restriction. Unlawful deprivation, another question that was raised in this context, that unlawful deprivation of liberty, which is incommunicado detention in our system, is already a criminal offense. It's provided by Article 166 of the Criminal Procedure Code. And it covers anyone who detains unlawfully, either this is an official. Or a private person who detains a person unlawfully incommunicado is actually covered by this article. In addition, if an official makes this detention with the use. Of abuse of power, this is covered by another article, 3. This provision has applied in practice. We have cases on that. Officials are being prosecuted for unlawful detention. We have cases initiated for this unlawful detention. Victims may claim rehabilitation and compensation. For example, in 2025, 70 complaints were registered. Where they were examined, 13 were admitted, and the compensation was awarded in all these cases. So another guarantee is strict system of registration. Every admission on legal basis, the status of detainee, and every transfer and release are recorded, and the records. Of each institution Currently, now under the automated information system, register of. Detained, arrested and convicted persons, this is a government decision of 2008. But this government decision is actually again under the improvement, and we have also ongoing process of making. So-called registered database of detained persons. This is underway. We will improve this system of records for detention. So overall, all the records are kept in all penitentiary institutions and all institutions that have the ability to detain persons. Currently, we also have legislative draft amendments in the parliament that actually give the compensation for unlawful detention. So the draft law was adopted in the first reading in 2026. This is draft law that actually will repeal the so-called law 14, 14. 15. Ah, sorry. So this is a brief answer to your question on incommunicado. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [55:48]: Thank you, Mr. Postol. Just you said about the reparation, and I'll ask you to have some answer about the reparation, rehabilitation, please. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [56:07]: Yes, many thanks. One of the questions was with regard to reparation and rehabilitation of the victims, and that is why I mentioned also, mainly we have two draft laws. First, this is one draft law for compensation for unlawful actions of prosecution and investigative authorities. that may result in unlawful detention that I already mentioned. And another law, this relates to rehabilitation of victims of crime. It was drafted by the Minister of Justice, again, with the scope of transposing a number of EU directives. It was already adopted in the Parliament by the Parliament in its first reading on 24 September current year. It sets up a single framework for information, support services, protection, legal aid, and state compensations. It also introduces an individual assessment of the victim needs both within and outside criminal proceedings. And extends state compensation to victims of crimes against liberty, sexual offenses, and domestic violence, as well as to child victims and persecuted persons. In addition, this draft law is supplemented, as I told you, by the draft. Law on reparation of the damage caused by unlawful acts and criminal contravention proceedings. Rehabilitation It sets up a system of, it proposes a rehabilitation system that actually exists right now, but it improves it. That rehabilitation is guaranteed without waiting for criminal proceedings to come. Under the current law, victims have already access and requests to reinformation, psychological counseling, and legal aid if they are victims of torture. Victims of torture and treatment receive state guaranteed legal aid unconditionally, without any payment. These services. Do not depend on the conviction, on the outcomes, and on the development of the criminal proceeding against the perpetrator. The new law, draft law, adds free medical care and shelter and allows urgent services even before all documents are submitted by the victim. I mean, the simple complaint of a victim of torture will be enough. A dedicated concept of. Rehabilitation programs for victims of torture, ill-treatment has been already developed, and it was discussed with the national referral mechanism for victims of crimes in April current year. We have a number of data. I think these data were provided in our written submissions. I could also reiterate that on the current system, about 1 million was given to all victims. In some cases, 20 complaints of victim of torture were registered. Almost all were admitted. So I will suggest you actually to see for statistical data in our, I think we will submitted them in our written complaint. And last, we have a joint institutional order adopted in August. 2026, current year, that actually approves and improves the regulation on identifying, examining, registering, documenting, and reporting alleged torture and ill-treatment. It will enter into force on 1st of January. This order is actually complemented by absence of statute of explanations of specific guarantees, statute of limitations is not applicable, amnesty to torture as well is not. Applicable, it mandates and compels continuous training of judges, security, and police, and relation with independent monitorial. monitoring national preventing mechanism on torture. So that is the sense, this is another legal development in our country. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:00:55]: Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Poston. And now we will return to the questions from the first rapporteur, Mr. Ishkan. So we will continue with the fundamental legal safeguards, and I invite Corina Zamfirov, she is present here. Let's present the response for the question connected to this chapter of questions, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, National Administration of Penitentiaries [1:01:24]: The National Administration of Penitentiaries has continued to strengthen the practical implementation of fundamental safeguards for a person deprived of their liberty from the moment of their admission to penitentiary institution. Upon admission, the legality of detention is verified, the date and time of admission are recorded, and detainees are informed in a language they understand of their rights, institutional rules, and complaint procedure. In this regard, the adaptation program approved by internal Order number 408 of 2024 is implemented through nine sessions covering access to legal assistance, health care, family contact, and complaint mechanism. Interpretation or translation services are arranged where necessary. Additional safeguards include confidential and unrestricted meeting with the lawyer, the rights to notify family members or another person of their place of detention and their protection or legally privileged correspondence. Medical examination conducted within 24 hours of admission under confidential condition to access detainees' health and identify possible injuries or signs of ill treatment. Medical findings and detainees statement documented while suspected cases of ill treatment are reported to the competent authorities, including the prosecutor and the ombudsman. Medical examination complemented by psychological and social assessment aimed at identifying individual vulnerabilities and the risk of self-harm or suicide. To identify the risk and needs assessment, a tool was approved there internal order number 366 of the 14 of July 2024. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:04:29]: Thank you. Thank you very much. In this context, I'll ask my...connected with the investigation that we have in police, I'll ask my colleagues from the General Police Investigation, Valeria Laptac, just to have a brief intervention connected to following fundamental legal rights: to be informed immediately, to promptly contact a lawyer, to receive confidential medical, to inform a family member. Please, Valeria. Republic of Moldova · Representative, General Police Inspectorate [1:04:59]: With regard to strengthening procedural safeguards and the right to defense at the pretrial investigation stage, we would like to point out that national legislation establishes a set of safeguards aimed at ensuring respect for the fundamental rights of persons suspected of having committed a criminal offense, including persons deprived of their liberty in accordance with international human rights standards. Thus, pursuant to Article 64 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Republic of Moldova, a suspect is entitled to the right to defense, and the criminal investigation body is under an obligation to ensure the effective exercise of this right by all means and methods not prohibited by law. The person must be informed in a language they understand and in the presence of a lawyer of the reasons why they are suspected, the substance of the suspicion, and the legal classification of the alleged criminal acts. Furthermore, suspects are entitled to receive written information concerning their procedural rights, including the right to remain silent and the right not to incriminate themselves. as well as explanations on how these rights may be exercised. They are also entitled to receive a copy of the relevant procedural documents, including the record of detention. Access to legal assistance constitutes an essential element of procedural safeguards. In this regard, the legislation guarantees the right of suspects to benefit from the assistance of a lawyer before their first questioning, as well as the right to communicate and meet with their lawyer confidentially, without limitations as to the number or duration of such meetings. Persons who do not have sufficient financial means may benefit from state-guaranteed legal aid in accordance with the law. Pursuant to Article 167 of the Criminal Procedure Code, whenever a person suspected of having committed a criminal offence is detained, the criminal investigation body shall draw up a record of detention within the time limits prescribed by law. The record should include, inter alia, the grounds and circumstances of the detention, the place, date, and time of the deprivation of liberty, the person's physical condition, any complaints concerning their state of health, as well as their explanations, objections, and requests. The detained person shall receive a copy of their record and written information concerning their procedural rights. Furthermore, article 173 requires the authority responsible for the detention to ensure that the person deprived of their liberty is given the opportunity immediately and no later than six hours after detention to notify a close relative or another person designated by them, or to make such notification on their behalf. With a view to adoption of the legal framework to the specific circumstances of certain practical situations, law number 240 from 2023, supplemented Article 167, which regulates situations where, at common border crossing points, the record of detention cannot be drawn up within the general statutory time limit. In such cases, the record must be drawn up as soon as possible, but no later than six hours from the moment of deprivation of liberty, indicating the circumstances and reasons that led to the exceeding of the general time limit. As regards judicial safeguards against arbitrary deprivation of liberty, Article 66, paragraph 2 of the Criminal Procedure Code provides the right that of a detained person to be brought before a judge immediately, but no later than 72 hours, so that the lawfulness and merits of the deprivation of liberty may be examined and judicial oversight of the measure ensured. In addition, law The law that I mentioned supplemented article 176, introducing limits on the cumulative duration of non-custodial preventive measures, which might not exceed 24 months. As part of the ongoing efforts to strengthen procedural safeguards, the Minister of Justice has drafted a law amending certain normative acts on enhancing procedural safeguards for persons subject to criminal proceedings, registered with number 244. The draft law was adopted at first reading in the Parliament. This law aims to strengthen the protection of the rights of suspects. accused and the indicated person, as well as persons deprived of their liberty through the transposition of six European Union directives. In particular, it addressed the following aspects: strengthening the right to information, strengthening the right of access to a lawyer, guaranteeing access to case materials, and ensuring the right to interpretation and translation, strengthening the mechanism for providing state-guaranteed legal aid, strengthening the presumption of innocence, and also introducing additional procedural safeguards for children. Thank you very much. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:10:29]: Thank you. And in the context of the Committee asked for some information with regard to practice in the context of complaints concerning access to fundamental legal rights, I'll ask my colleague Kononov-Zamfir to intervene, but once again, please be briefly, short. Merci. Republic of Moldova · Representative, National Administration of Penitentiaries [1:10:54]: Complaints concerning condition of detention, compensatory mechanism. Complaints concerning the fundamental rights of person deprived of their liberty have been received and examined by the competent authorities in accordance with the applicable legal framework. Depending on the nature of the allegation, complaints may be addressed to the penitentiary administration, ombudsman, the prosecutor office, the courts, or other competent bodies. The National Administration of Penitentiaries provides the necessary information and cooperation to facilitate the examination of such In response to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights concerning conditions of detention, the legislation established as of 1 January 2019 preventive and compensatory remedy, the relevant provisions of the criminal procedure code code were revised, including by law number 245 or 2023. Person in detentions may apply to the court regarding conditions under Article 3 of the European Convention while the prison system enforces the judgment and provide the information of conditions of detention available in its records. The relevant statistic data will be provided separately via e-mail. Admission, the legal basis and the status of detentions, transfers, and release are entered in the institution's register and in the information system register of person detained arrested and convicted, established on the basis of government decision number 25 of 2008 and regulated by government decision number 716 of 2014. Access to the database is limited by the rules on the competence and data protection lawyers or family members obtain information through the channels provided by law, while the detained person may make use of communication and petitioning. The organization of medical assistance is regulated by Order of the Ministry of Justice No. 343 of the 29 of December 2022. As well, the access to private medical services at the detainees own expense is regulated by the internal order number 272 of 2024. With regard to seriously ill person, we can mention government decision 417 of the 12th of June 2024, which approves the procedure for medical examination for release from serving a sentence or for the replacement or revocation of pre-trial detention together with the list of serious illness that preclude detention, in 2026 were released 5%. Thank you. Thank you very much. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:15:32]: Yesterday, in the context of the report, we had some comments connected to pretrial detention. So we didn't cover the situation with the shortening the duration of pretrial detention and steps taken to reduce the number of cases or preventive arrest in detention. So I'll ask my colleague, Mr. Sergio Russo, to have some answer at this situation. Merci. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [1:16:00]: Thank you. Supplementary clarification in perspective of question of co-rapporteur, Mr. Ishkan, with regard to the measure taken to reduce the duration of pre-trial detention and to limit the use of this preventive measure, particularly in cases involving less serious offences, I would like to highlight the following. On 1 April 2026, the Prosecutor General's Office, by Order No. 46/3, approved the Prosecutor's Office Action Plan for 2026. Under the strategic objective entitled "Ensuring respect for human rights and fundamental freedom in criminal proceedings", action number 25 of the plan provides for the priority use of prevention measure alternative to pre-trial detention. In this regard, the following targets have been established: a 10% reduction in the rate of applications submitted for the imprisonment of pre-trial detention compared to the previous year; a 10% increase in the number of alternative prevention measures applied instead of the pre-trial detention, particularly bail, compared to the previous year. In order to achieve this objective, prosecutors are encouraged to conduct a thorough and individual assessment of the circumstances of each criminal case, the necessity and proportionality of applying preventive measure, as well as the existence of legal justification restricted on a person's liberty. According, submitted application for the imposition of the pre-trial detention should remain an exceptional measure. Whenever the circumstances of the case allow, alternative preventive measures should be considered and applied in accordance with the principle of legality, necessity, and proportionality. At the same time, prosecutors are encouraged to avoid submitting formal or unjustified application for the extension of prevention measure. Each request for extension must be based on a current and specific assessment of the circumstances of the case, clearly indicted the resource justifying the continued application of measure, as well as the legal grounds of which was initially imposed. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:18:54]: Yesterday we have some comments, some answers in the context of the asylum seekers and the non-refoulement, and we didn't cover the situation with the accommodation center and the cases for refoulement, extradition, and expulsion. So I'll ask my colleague from Ministry of Internal Affairs, Daniela Kiperko, to intervene in this subject, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:19:23]: Thank you, distinguished members of the Committee. Yesterday, we made a very short overview on the national policy and legislative framework. Today, in my intervention, I will focus on several key developments concerning access to asylum procedure. So, about the first questions regarding provide effective and consistent access to asylum information and procedures, procedural safeguards. Republic of Moldova has established legal and procedural safeguards to ensure that asylum applicants are promptly informed about their rights and obligations through the entire asylum procedure. Applicants receive information in the language they understand and benefit from the free interpreter service through the asylum procedure in order to ensure that applicants can understand the information communicated to them and effectively exercise their rights. The General Inspectorate for Migration also benefits from the support of UNHCR and other non-governmental organizations in addressing this interpretation needs. Asylum seekers have also access to legal aid. legal assistance, including state-guaranteed legal aid provided through the National Legal Aid Council, as well as legal aid from some specialized non-governmental organizations. According to the National Legal Aid Council, they have assisted more than 300 asylum seekers, refugees, beneficiaries of humanitarian protection, and stateless persons. For this, they have 16 specialized lawyers designated to provide legal assistance. An important development is the area we adopted in January 2026, a joint order between the General Inspectorate for Border Police and General Inspectorate for Migration regarding asylum procedure at the border. This order established a clear procedure for receiving receiving asylum application at the state border and regulate cooperation between those two authorities. Regarding refoulement safeguards in public custody and return procedure. So return measures carried out by the migration authorities comply with the principle of non-refoulement. No person is removed, there are well-founded grounds to believe that they would face torture or some ill-treatment. Regarding the next question, regarding the obligation to reside in accommodation center and where it continues to be mandatory, it is important to distinguish between two different types of facilities. The accommodation center for asylum seeker is an open type facility for a reception and accommodation of asylum seekers. On the other side, we have a temporary placement centers for foreigners, which is a closed type facility intended for foreign nationals placed in public custody in the context of return procedure. So the obligation to reside in accommodation center for asylum seeker during the examination of asylum application is not a measure of detention or placement in public custody. Accommodation center is more like a shelter for asylum seekers. The relevant accommodation provision in accommodation center for asylum seekers are applied without discrimination. At the same time, we have some applicants that have some specific needs. which require individual assessment and appropriate support, the General Inspectorate for Migration is responsible for identifying and assessing the needs from the beginning of asylum procedure and through the asylum procedure, and for taking them into account when determining appropriate reception condition. Children and other vulnerable applicants benefit from special safeguards adapted to their circumstances in accordance with the principle of the best interest of the child. I would also like to underline that unaccompanied children and families with children cannot be placed in public custody, so cannot be placed in the temporary placement centre for foreigners. Regarding living condition in accommodation centers and the freedom of movement of residents, the accommodation centers for asylum seeker provide appropriate condition, material condition, like they have accommodated spaces, playgrounds, study areas, kitchen facilities. At the same time, we acknowledge that further improvements are needed, particularly in terms of accessibility and facilities for persons with disabilities. A person who are living in the accommodation center for asylum have the rights to leave the center between 7:00 AM and 10:00 PM without specific notification. In case when a resident work at night, for example, like a night shift, or needed to be absent for more than 24 or 48 hours, they are required to inform the center's administration. Regarding the possibility of reducing the use of public custody and strengthening alternative to detention, we acknowledge that alternative to public custody should be further considered and strengthened, as well as I mentioned yesterday, public custody is ordered by court upon reasoned request from the General Inspectorate for Migration, and only there the legal grounds for such measures are established. The authorities assess the individual circumstances of each case, and voluntary departure is considered first, whenever the legal conditions allow it. More national legislation provide for a tolerated stay regime in situations when removal cannot be carried out for some objective reasons. Persons benefiting from this regime are not placed in temporary placement centers. So this is all from my side, briefly on the questions. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:26:19]: Thank you very much. Other questions we had about status of ratification of international instruments on human rights. In this context, we have four situations, so I'll ask my colleagues just to be very briefly in this context. And I'll ask Karolina Miśkowi to give us some information about Convention for Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance with the state party that we signed in Thank you. Republic of Moldova [1:26:51]: Thank you very much. Republic of Moldova reaffirms its commitment to the protection and promotion of human rights and the fulfillment of its obligation under the international human rights instrument. In this respect, the Republic of Moldova has considered the possibility of ratifying the International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Unforced Disappearance adopted by the United Nations in 2006. In principle, the intention to ratify this international instrument is supported in accordance with the international recognized borders and territorial integrity of the Republic of Moldova. However, the Republic of Moldova faces objective challenges regarding the effective implementation of the convention provisions throughout its international recognized territory, particularly in the region Transnistrian region, which remains outside the effective control of the constitutional authorities and is administrated by de facto structures. In this regard, While reaffirming its commitment to the objective and principle of the Convention, the Republic of Moldova considers that its ratification at the present stage would be premature, given the objective circumstances and the existing limitation in assuring its effective implementation throughout the internationally recognized territory of the country. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:28:19]: Thank you. Thank you very much, and we will continue with the representative from Ministry of Labour and Social Protection, Galina Damian. She referred to International Convention on the Protection of Rights of all Migrants, Workers and Members of their Family, the Optional Protocol to Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, and the Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Ministry of Labour and Social Protection [1:28:48]: The ODMs related to the International Convention on the Protection of Rights of all Migrant Workers and Member of their Families, I have to mention that this convention has not yet been ratified, but in order to assess the Republic of Moldova's readiness to ratify the International Convention, A feasibility study was conducted, which shows that Moldova has a mixed migration profile. It is a country of origin for migration, and at the same time, the Republic of Moldova is increasingly becoming a country of destination. Our existing legal framework on equality, social protection, and access to justice, together with the international treaties to which the Republic of Moldova is already a party, covers a substantial part of the standards enshrined in the Convention. Furthermore, we are currently engaged in aligning our national legislation with European Union and ensuring its effective implementation. This process also provides an opportunity to further advance EU standards of protection and strengthen the rights of all workers, including migrants, in the Republic of Moldova. Related to the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, we have to mention that Moldova ratified the Optional Protocol in November 2021. The protocol entered into force in December 2022. By ratifying this instrument, the Republic of Moldova recognized the competence of the UN Committee on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities to receive and consider individual or group communications from persons claiming to be victims of violations of the rights guaranteed by the Convention after all available domestic remedies have been exhausted. This mechanism provides persons with disabilities with an additional avenue of protection at the international level and strengthens the State's accountability for respecting their rights. The findings and recommendations of the UN Committee may also help identify protection gaps, remedy violations, and prevent their recurrence, including by improving the legal and institutional framework and the practices of public authorities. Related to the optional protocol to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, I have to mention that in 2025, inter-institutional consultations were conducted and a preliminary analysis of the potential implication of ratifying the optional protocol was presented, identifying a number of challenges. In the context of the Republic of Moldova accession process to the European Union, and the focus of institutional and administrative resources on this objective. As we are currently engaged in aligning our national legislation with European Union IPI and ensuring its effective implementation, it is considered that the ratification of the Optional Protocol is at this stage premature. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:32:06]: We will move on to a question from the next rapporteur that we have, from Mr. Abdallah. But in this context, I would like to ask my colleagues once again to keep in mind the time allotted for responses. So I'll invite my colleague Valeria Laptakro to intervene for a question that we have connected to trafficking in human beings. Valeria, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, General Police Inspectorate [1:32:34]: The Center for Combating Human Trafficking within the National Investigations Inspectorate, the General Police Inspectorate, is a member of the Joint Risk Analysis Group, established by a common interdepartmental order from 2014. In this capacity, this center participates annually in the preparation of the Joint Risk Analysis Report, covering the areas of combating cross-border crime, human trafficking, and illegal migration. The mission of the joint group is to contribute to strengthening the national risk analysis system and to provide an overall assessment of the actual situation, reflecting the efforts undertaken by state institutions to combat cross-border crime, human trafficking, and illegal migration. The Center for Combating Human Trafficking operates a 24/7 hotline through which it receives reports concerning alleged cases submitted by citizens and legal entities. Reports can also be submitted via the center's official e-mail address, too. This center, together with the territorial police inspectorates subordinated to the GPI, cooperates with the Centers for Assistance and Protection of victims or presumed victims of human trafficking, which operate under the Ministry of Labour and Social Protection of the Republic of Moldova. Identified victims of human trafficking are referred to these centres for accommodation and specialised assistance, including medical, social, psychological and legal assistance, as well as other necessary support services, subject to their consent to placement and receipt of the respective assistance. During the first 10 months of 2026, at the national level, a total of 52 victims of human trafficking were identified in criminal cases investigated by the subdivisions of the Ministry of Internal Affairs and the Prosecutor's Office, involving offenses of human trafficking and trafficking in children. Of these, 43 were adults, 15 women, and 28 men, while nine were children, seven girls, and two boys. During the first nine months of 2026, at the national level, according to data provided by the Center for Assistance and Protection of Victims and Potential Victims of Human Trafficking, operating There are a total of eight victims identified by the Center for Combating Human Trafficking within the National Investigation Inspectorate, benefited from assistance and accommodation services. These beneficiaries include two men and five women, and one girl. By comparison, during the same period in 2025, 16 victims benefited from these services: eight men, including one Indian national, two women, two girls, and four boys. Thank you very much. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:35:40]: For the next seven questions connected to domestic violence, I will provide the answer. So, on 20 June 2025, was approved establishing the order number 355, establishing the institutional mechanism for analyzing femicide and domestic violence resulting in the death of the victim or serious injury or bodily integrity or health. The mechanism allow for multi-sectoral examination of cases with serious or lethal consequences, identification of shortcomings in intervention and cooperation, formulation of recommendation and improvement on of institutional practices. It's important increases its importance increases in the context of the new regulation of femicide and the need to identify potential grounds for gender-based bias. in investigation. In 2025, the Commission analyzed 68 serious or fatal cases, of which 21 resulted in the death of the victim, and 30 of them were analyzed as femicide cases. On 11 September 2026, the Working Group on the Review of the Regulatory Framework in the Field of Preventing and Combating Violence Against Women and Domestic Violence was established. The working group was composed of representatives of the MIA and representatives of five non-governmental organizations. The members of the working group examined the regulatory framework in this area and put forward proposals to amend the legislation in order to ensure prevention of recidivism. inter-institutional cooperation and protection of victims. The proposal also seek to amend the operational regulatory framework, which will ensure more effective police intervention in case of domestic and gender-based violence. The draft of inter-institutional instruction on the implementation, enforcement, and monitoring of protection orders in case of violence against women and domestic violence, including electronic monitoring measure, is currently being prepared. The police family, the formally justice center has been operational since October 2023. Government decision number 173 from 2023 approved the framework activity regulation and the minimum quality standards. The center facilities facilitate in one place victims access to medical and forensic care, psychological counseling, legal, and social services. This organization allow for coordinated documentation of the cases and reduced the needs for the victim to report the facts repeatedly to more than one institution. Between 2016 and 2020, 5,200 criminal cases were registered under Article 201-1 of the Criminal Code of the Republic of Moldova concerning domestic violence. During the same period, the prosecution was completed in 4,031 cases. Of these, 3,345 were sent to court for trial. In 60 criminal cases, the prosecution was discontinued. In this context, following the other question, I want to mention that on the 19th of October of 2026, by word of Minister of Internal Affairs, was adopted the instruction on the prevention, identification, intervention, and examination of cases of violence against women and domestic violence committed by public officials with special status within the administrative authorities and in the institution under the Ministry of Internal Affairs. This instruction is to be examined and discussed on the platform of National Agency for the Prevention and Combating of Violence Against Women and Family Violence in order to be developed at national level for all civilian servants. In the Republic of Moldova, victims of domestic violence have the possibility to request directly the forensic examination to establish the injuries and their degree of severity by contacting the territorial forensic doctor or another forensic doctor of their choice. In criminal proceedings, forensic expertise may be ordered by the prosecuting body, the public prosecutor, or the court. In such cases, the body examining the offences shall refer the victim to the forensic medical centre for examination. To ensure prompt access to these services, at the police centre for family justice, forensic examination is available at all times. At the same time, since 2023, the Centre for Legal Medicine has had a specialised unit for examining victims of physical and sexual violence with separate entries. in order to protect confidentiality and ensure an adequate environment for examining victims. Next question, I want to mention that under the legislation of the Republic of Moldova, acts of domestic violence are punishable by administrative or criminal penalties, depending on their gravity and the consequence produced. In accordance with Article 78-1 of the Code of Administrative Offence, acts of domestic violence which have caused unsufficient bodily injury are punishable by an administrative offence. Under Article 201-1 of the Criminal Code, acts of domestic violence which have caused average of serious harm, as well as other forms of violence referred to in that article give rise to criminal liability. The national legislative framework therefore ensure that act of domestic violence are penalized differently according to their gravity, so that no act on violence goes unpunished. And in context In other context, in accordance with Moldovan law, victims of domestic violence enjoy to right to state guaranteed legal aid. In this respect, under Article 8 of Law Number 45 from 2007, the police authorities are required to inform victims on their right to receive free legal aid. At the same time, in accordance with Law Number 198 on state guaranteed legal aid, Victims of domestic violence may apply for legal aid directly at the territorial legal aid office or through the criminal prosecution body, and in urgent cases, a service lawyer is appointed from the list of lawyers specializing in victim assistance. And in connection with the trainings, I'll invite my colleagues from the National Agency for Combating Violence Against Women and Domestic Violence, Veronica Pastello, to have a brief intervention to represent all the efforts in connection with the authorities. Please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, National Agency for Preventing and Combating Violence Against Women and Domestic Violence [1:42:53]: Thank you. It is important to note that the National Agency for Preventing and Combating Violence Against Women and Domestic Violence is a newly established institution created in 2024. Before the establishment of the agency, the Republic of Moldova didn't have a unified training curricula in this field. To address this gap, the agency developed a national training curricula, which is pending accreditation, and forms part of the 2025 2027 program for the training and specialization of professionals. The program is structured around four key areas. academia, multidisciplinary teams, the justice system, and the local public authorities. In 2026, approximately 1,200 multidisciplinary team professionals have been trained out of a total of 7,000 professionals. Regarding the justice sector, in partnership with the National Institute of Justice, the agency is implementing a specialized training program for judges, prosecutors, and criminal investigation officers. Under this program, 118 professionals are specialized. Furthermore, in June 2026, the General Prosecutor's Office issued Order No. 82, establishing the designation of prosecutors responsible for handling cases of violence against women and domestic violence within territorial prosecution offices. The measure contributes to institutional specialization and the harmonization of investigative practices. As regards the sustainability, this training initiatives and specialization programs will be incorporated into the forthcoming national program on preventing and domestic violence against women and domestic violence, as well as in other public policies. ensuring that professionals' training becomes an ongoing process rather than one-off intervention. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:45:24]: We'll continue with the next answers on training and prevention, and I'll ask Mr. Gennadiy Yepuri from the National Institute of Justice to give us answer on these three aspects that we have. Please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, National Institute of Justice [1:45:43]: Thank you very much. The prohibition of the transfer and inhuman or degrading treatment is a fundamental principle of human rights protection. Respecting this principle requires the authorities to respond quickly and effectively, both to prevent such acts and ensure that they are properly documented and investigated, and that those responsible are brought to justice. In this context, the National Institute of Justice has worked to improve the professional skills of those working in the justice sector, including through the study of international standards as well as the standards of the European Convention on Human Rights and the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. Between 2022 and the first half of 2026, the National Institute of Justice organized 48 training activities with a total of 1,326 participants, including 250 judges, 370 three prosecutors and 703 representatives of support staff and other professional groups. The activities covered international standards on the prevention and prohibition of torture, as well as the specific aspect of investigating and judging such offences. These topics were also included in training sessions on the application of the European Convention on Human Rights and recent developments in the case law of the European Court of Human Rights. Particular attention was given to the duty of national authorities to carry out effective investigation into alleged violation of fundamental rights. Through these activities, the National List of Justice has worked to improve professionals' ability to apply international standards and practice and to contribute to effective protection against torture and inhuman or degrading treatment. Regarding domestic violence, in an area that requires not only an adequate legal and regulatory framework, but also continuous professional training for all actors involved in the provision, investigation and adjudication of such cases. In this context, the National Institute of Justice has made continued professional training a priority, with the aim of strengthening professional competence competence and promoting a coordinated victim-centered approach. Between 2022 and 2026, the National Institute of Justice organized 70 training activities, which totaled 2,058 participants, including 305 judges, 456 prosecutor, and 1,297 representative of other professional groups. The training activity were multidisciplinary and focused on strengthening participants capacity to apply the legal framework, identify cases of domestic violence, and conduct effective investigations, protect victims, and improve in professional cooperation. The statistics reflect the continuity and development of these efforts from 12 training activities attended by 368 participants in 2022 to 18 activities with 497 participants in the first half of 2026. Through these initiatives, the National Institute of Justice has contributed to promoting an integrated and coherent approach to addressing cases of domestic Thank you very much. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [1:49:13]: I just want to mention, Honorable Chair and distinguished members of the committee, that we received a list of 30 or 31 questions. Now we reached the answer for number 20 of it. So we'll try to continue to make it more briefly by our intervention. CAT · Chair [1:49:46]: Well, I'd like to recall that we're aiming here to have an interactive dialogue with the Committee. And so, as we move forward, I'm going to open the floor up to the two rapporteurs from the Committee, and then subsequently you will be able to answer those questions as well as go into more depth concerning some of their answers. Bear in mind that you also have 48 hours after our meeting to provide additional information in writing. So with that in mind, I’ll offer the floor to Mr. Iskan as rapporteur. You have the floor, sir. CAT · Rapporteur [1:50:31]: First of all, as far as I could follow, almost all the issues, but I understand there are remaining issues, but I thought all the issues, almost all the issues raised yesterday have been addressed. in a well-organized manner, and this is highly appreciated. Thank you. Of course, our thanks go to the both State Secretaries, State Secretary Mr. Alexandre Bejan of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, as well as the State Secretary Mr. Lilian Apostol of the Ministry of Justice, as well as the Permanent Representative, distinguished Ambassador Vladimir Cook. Before my further remarks, I will have few further remarks with respect to substantive issues, perhaps one or two questions, not more. I need to feel, I should like to reaffirm the Committee's mandate with respect to the presentations raised today. Allow me first to recall that the Committee's mandate is to review compliance with obligations under the Convention. This Committee is not a political body. We do not take positions on political disputes, nor do we make political statements. We do not prosecute or adjudicate. The purpose is to identify the areas where further progress is needed, and we provide recommendations to assist the State Party to revise its policy, legislation, and practice to ensure full compliance. This mandate was formulated in the Convention, created by the States, and this mandate therefore was given to the Committee by the States. It is with this understanding that we raised, put forward questions or remarks yesterday. With regard to the topics and substantive issues, in response to the further extensive information provided by the State Party today, I will follow your line, State Secretary, distinguished State Secretary. First, I will start with the definition and criminalization of torture. In fact, I myself referred to the articles of the Constitution as well as the Criminal Code with respect to definition of torture, and I confirm that almost all elements of the definition offered in Article 1 of the Convention were contained, but I questioned whether you have the non-derogability or the non-derogable character of the definition included in the legislation of the state party, perhaps I might have missed, of course, I'm not an expert of the Moldova legislation, just I wish to ask whether a non-derogability of the prohibition of torture is included in the legislation. I referred to another article where no statute of limitations was referred to with regard to the crime of torture, and the State Secretary, the Honourable State Secretary of the Ministry of Justice, if I understood accurately, referred to the norm which refers to no amnesty of the crime of the prohibition of torture. If you could possibly refer me to the legal norm or article of the criminal code or other parts of legislation where it is prohibited that amnesty will not apply to the crime of torture. As regards national human rights and national preventive mechanism, Of course, we are aware of the different versions of national preventive mechanism to be established under the OPCAT, under the requirements of OPCAT. What we referred to the structure and functioning of the National Preventive Mechanism, and I referred to the budget, financial independence issue, and I referred to the report of the NPM itself, which confirmed that, and I quote, "the Council enjoys full operational independence and partial financial independence." And I asked the State Party to kindly clarify whether those ambiguities undermine the principles of independence, impartiality, objectivity, and confidentiality. Of course, I already yesterday referred to and commended the expressed the appreciation of the Committee for having been reaccredited with A status by GANRI. This is – these are all good steps that we But I wish to further inquire whether the current budgetary line to be incorporated in the Ombudsman's budget, does it create ambiguity and does the State Party intend to clarify this point? With regard to legal status and domestic application of the Convention, yesterday I already referred to the articles of the Constitution, and we expressed the Committee's appreciation. I just wanted to learn if there was any case where any court, any judicial body, made direct reference to the Convention in its ruling. I didn't hear any practical, any progress in practice. I reiterate the Committee's appreciation for the legal norms that confirm the fundamental legal safeguards for all persons from the outset of their deprivation of liberty in law. But I asked yesterday, have there been any complaints concerning access to fundamental safeguards? Have they been investigated by an independent authority? Have there been violations, and have the perpetrators been prosecuted? We would appreciate to receive further information as regards practice of this legislation. Pre-trial detention, we have noted the replies by the State Party. So, as I said, the Committee, as I emphasized yesterday, the Committee reviews not only legal but also practical measures related to implementation of obligations under the Convention. While taking note of the progress, we raise concerns to eliminate the remaining obstacles. That is why we are having this dialogue, and I reaffirm our appreciation for the well-organized replies, extensive further information provided today with regard to legislation. We would wish to receive further information with regard to practical aspects of the legislation. legislation, the implementation of the legislation in practice. I thank you, sir. CAT · Chair [1:59:55]: Thank you very much. I'd now like to pass the floor to Mr. Amdalla. CAT · Member [2:00:02]: Thank you very much, Chairperson. We'd like to once again reiterate our words of welcome to our delegation, and we'd like to congratulate them particularly for their organization, the level of responses, and the standard in terms of the elements they've already provided in the context of this constructive dialogue. In large part, our questions have enjoyed a satisfactory answer, but nonetheless, i'd perhaps come back to two or three elements and then perhaps put a couple of additional questions. So turning to training, first of all, as I understand it, in the report, as well as after the reporting period, there have been diversified training programs, which have been rolled out to the benefit of thousands of participants that have been relevant. According to the sources we have, despite those trainings, we still have heard allegations of abuse and family violence, particularly gender-based violence, and these allegations seem to persist. So, I'd like to know how exactly the steps you've put in place to prevent or indeed to assess the impact, sorry, to prevent that behaviour, but or to assess the impact of the training have borne fruit. A second question also relates to domestic violence. heard today that access to legal aid is sometimes optional for victims. Now, given the scope of the phenomenon over the entire country, I wonder whether or not the state's guidance in that regard isn't something that has given rise to a universal right to victims, particularly victims of domestic violence, in terms of legal access. And then perhaps one additional question which didn't come up yesterday, and that's a question that relates to the matter of rehabilitation and compensation. And sources that we've heard from have indicated that throughout 2025, 299 cases of torture were registered, and that 75 of those led to an investigation, but only three of those were qualified as torture. I’d like to know then what qualification was given to the large number of other cases, how were they defined, and how do you explain that definition exactly? I’ll leave it at that for now. Thank you very much, Chairperson. CAT · Chair [2:03:44]: The Chair: Thank you very much, Mr. Abdallah. I’d like to now ask whether or not any other Committee members would like to speak. That seems not to be the case, and so I will pass the floor back to the delegation. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:04:06]: Thank you for your question. We think that in the context of definition and criminalisation, this aspect and the aspect connected with the people's advocate and the Council for Prevention of Torture, we should bring a more comprehensive, let's say, answer, and in this context, I'll ask the representative of the Minister of Justice to intervene, please. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Justice [2:04:41]: Many thanks. Many thanks for the rapporteurs for the appreciation of our effort. This is our common effort to actually with the same purpose to implement convention, both in legal terms and in practice, and we recognize this, that it is not only enough to adapt our legislation to the convention, but also it is also important for our government, for our authorities, to have effective implementation in practice. So I will address a number of questions given the time. that actually we have on particular, on non-derogability. We cannot include specific provision on non-derogability because absolute prohibition is implied. Non-derogability, it is a question, a declaration that the state may have when the situation, an urgent situation arises. Let me remind that we have such a situation in times of COVID, when our government made the declaration of derogation of certain rights from the European Convention. ICCPR as well, but there We. Of course, did not any derogation, any declaration from specific absolute prohibitions such as torture and according to this convention. So let me briefly answer you that non-derogability is embedded in our legislation, in how we apply this legislation. So we don't have any specific, we don't need any specific provision actually providing non-derogability. It is implied. On the amnesty, I refer you to Article 1. 107 from our criminal code that is actually specified that amnesty does not apply to torture. And next question was about the budgetary lines and whether this would create some ambiguities. Brief answer is not. Budgetary lines, my point was budgetary lines for the whole office of people's advocate office is ensured by its independence. And the national preventive mechanism actually takes, overtakes independence of the whole office of people advocates office, both in institutional independence, in adopting a decision, and in financial resources as well. So it doesn't create any ambiguities. And as I mentioned, we right now, we are reviewing the legislation to strengthen this institutional independence and financial independence of national human rights institutions. And I mentioned also, not only people's advocate office, but also our equality council as well is on the reform. So the logic is the same to ensure both institutional independence and financial independence. For right now, it doesn't create any ambiguities. So I don't see any, but budgetary lines are always discussion. This is normal. The last three questions, actually, you asked about the practical implementations, so I was able to convince that we don't have any legal issues of compatibility, and it is reasonable, actually, to ask how this implementation works in practice. What I may say in this context, we need to see a number of judgments of our courts and decisions made by the prosecutor. They always refer to the European Court's case law, if it is the case, and other international standards. And as I mentioned, we could provide these examples of references, direct references to international human rights treaties, but we need to actually to gather our authorities to look into them, and we will provide this information in writing. So this is on the first part of the questions that were raised as a follow-up. And rehabilitation compensation, too. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:09:52]: In the context of the question, have there been any complaints concerning access to fundamental safeguards, have they been investigated by an independent authority? I will ask my colleague, Corina Zamfirov. Republic of Moldova · Representative, National Administration of Penitentiaries [2:10:10]: I will give the floor to my colleague, join online, to answer these questions. Republic of Moldova · Head, Department of Internal Protection and Penitentiary Inspection [2:10:16]: Thank you. Distinguished members of the committee, dear colleagues, my name is Ruslan Ungu. I'm the head of Department of Internal Protection and Penitentiary Inspection of the National Administration of Penitentiaries. I would like to clarify a few important points regarding the complaints received in the penitentiary system. First, the more than 3000 complaints received in the 2011 should not be understood as more than 3000 cases of torture or ill treatment. This complaints covered many different issues. related to life in prison, it is also important to understand that these statistics do not always show a clear number of separate problems or incidents. In practice, some detainees submit a very large number of complaints, not necessarily to solve a specific problem, but simply to express their dissatisfaction or disagreement with the fact that they are deprived of their freedom. Regarding allegations of torture or ill treatment, I would underline that every such complaint is registered and sent to the competent prosecutor in line with the regulation approved by Prosecutor General's Order No. 77 of 2013. However, registration does not mean confirmation. It does not mean that torture or ill treatment has actually taken place. In many cases, the complaints do not contain reasonable grounds to suspect that torture or ill treatments has occurred. Some do not lead to criminal proceedings. Others concern different matters and are dealt with through administrative procedures. I would also like to make a clear distinction between criminal investigations and internal investigations. Criminal investigations are carried out by prosecutors. Internal investigations are carried out by the penitentiary administration and focus on possible breaches of work duties and internal rules. These are two different procedures, but they can take place at the same time. Therefore, the fact that only nine internal investigations were opened does not mean that the other complaints were ignored or not examined. Finally, I would like to mention two recent developments. The penitentiary system was visited by CPT delegation in 2025 and more recently in 2026. During these visits, the CPT delegations did not receive any allegation of torture from detainees. We consider this an important point when assessing the current situation in the penitentiary system. To conclude, the National Administration of Penitentiaries takes every allegation seriously. All complaints are reported according to the established procedure, and every matter is examined by the competent authorities. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:13:54]: In the context of the practical examples with direct references the application of Convention against Torture, I'll ask Mr. Rusu, we had on point three. So we had some examples in the context of the practical issues, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [2:14:19]: In context of the practical possibility to use the Convention, we can share our order when we make some indication for prosecutors and explain them to apply some standards from the Convention of Human Rights or Convention against Torture. In this situation, we can share this order and to demonstrate we effectively use the article from Convention. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:15:18]: It was, as it was mentioned about the practical aspects of the implementing all the legislation, I just, I'll ask my colleague from the National Agency for Penitentiary, Suzana Junet, just to have some information about the trainings in this context, please. Republic of Moldova · Senior Officer, National Administration of Penitentiaries [2:15:46]: Dear colleagues, my name is Susana Župe, Senior Officer on International on National Administration of Penitentiaries. So related to the question of training of staff prison on prevention on torture and ill-treatment, we can say that National Administration of Penitentiary has continued to strengthen in the professional capacities of medical and non-medical staff through specialized training programs focused on the prevention of torture and ill-treatment, the identification, documentation of injures, medical examination upon admission, mental health assessment, and the protection of persons deprived of their liberty. Additional, we can say that it were 50 torture prevention training sessions involved 252 staff members. Training center of prison system includes a dedicated model on the prevention of torture, including Istanbul Protocol. Furthermore, with the support of national NGOs, Mensana project, approximately 38 staff members were training in 2025 in the identification, screening, and assessment of mental health disorder, as well as in establishing therapeutic relationships with patients. Additionally, we can say that training activities were organized with the Council of Europe project, strengthening the reform of penitentiary probation and healthcare system in closed-type institutions in the Republic of Moldova. In 2025-2026, a total of 89 medical and non-medical staff members from penitentiary institutions participated in training sessions covering medical examination upon admission, mental health screening, identification of mental disorders and substance use-related problems, suicide prevention, medical documentation, and interprofessional cooperation. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:17:30]: Thank you. And in the context of distinguished Mr. Abdallah, I just want for these three questions, we'll have to examine even deeply. So if it's possible, we'll provide information as it established, because it's a context of statistical analysis and some conceptual aspects. So, regarding to question, maybe Honorable Chair, I will continue with the question for yesterday's session or some comments. How can we continue? Distinguished members of the committee, We'll continue with the oversights of detention, health and condition, and I'll ask Susana Žurbia to continue with the situation of prison overcrowding and the condition of detention. Please. Republic of Moldova · Senior Officer, National Administration of Penitentiaries [2:19:03]: Dear Committee, related to the question about prison overcrowding and condition of detention, National Administration of Penitentiaries has taken several measures to reduce prison overcrowding. The transfer of juveniles held in pretrial detention in Penitentiary No. 13 to Penitentiary No. 10, Guayaquil; revision of the regulatory framework governing the application of the amnesty; development of a new regulation on the assessment of detained persons' behaviour. The regulation establishes objectives and verifiable criteria for assessing the behaviour of detained persons, including indicators related to supporting or promoting criminal subculture; improvement of the risk assessment mechanism for persons sentenced to life imprisonment. The proposed amendments introduce a methodology for assessing the risk of reoffending among persons sentenced to life imprisonment when considering the application of Article 91 and Article 92 of the Criminal Code. To expand detention capacity, there are three major infrastructure projects underway: the project of the construction of a new penitentiary in Chisinau. Its objective is to replace the existing Penitentiary No. 13. The project provides for the creation of 1,500 places for the detention of persons held in pretrial detention. Implementation of the project is under Office for the Implementation of Strategic National Projects. Another issue is about the construction of detention center in the city of Belz with the capacity of 650 places. The detention center in Belz is a facility designed in accordance with the standards of recommendation of the Council of Europe, with a capacity of 650 places. It is intended for the detention of persons held in pretrial detention, as well as persons sentenced to imprisonment in closed-type penitentiary. Another project is the reconstruction of the Penitentiary No. 5 in Kahul. The project provides for the creation of 300 new detention places with the aim of improving detention conditions and ensuring the necessary infrastructure. Also, we can say that related to government decision at 2025, the support of Council of Europe, it wasn't updated the minimum food standards, the rules of product substitution and the provision of basic hygiene items. Six food standards are provided for including for special dietary needs. Over the past two years, 120 sanitary facilities have been rehabilitated and 10 complex ventilation systems have been installed in penitentiary institutions. A lot of cells were renovated. Related to the question about the inmates and opportunity for economic activities, we can say that to facilitate the creation of employment opportunities for convicted persons. The amendments concern the organisation and remuneration of work performed by detained persons. The results in terms of jobs created and actual participation in employment activities will be reflected in the implementation reports. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:22:07]: Thank you very much. And we'll continue. In this context, I'll ask for next question on prison medical services. So Irina Barbaruș, please, the floor is yours. Republic of Moldova · Head, Medical Department, National Administration of Penitentiaries [2:22:33]: Thank you. My name is Irina Barbaruș. I am head of medical department. And I would like to highlight the main developments, challenges, and ongoing reforms. in the medical area. First, regarding the organization and independence of penitentiary health care services, health care services currently operate under the Ministry of Justice. However, an important institutional reform is underway. In August 2026, the Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Health approved a roadmap for transferring penitentiary health care services to the Ministry of Health with the support of Council of Free Europe. An inter-institutional working group has been established and the assessment of medical infrastructure, equipment, staffing, and health care needs are ongoing. The transfer is planned for 2029. Meanwhile, clinical decisions remain the responsibility of qualified healthcare professionals in accordance with medical ethics, professional standards, and patient confidentiality. Second, regarding the accreditation on medical staffing, of the 15 old patients medical units for have obtained five years accreditation in this year, eight of are undergoing accreditation extension procedures, one remain accreditation until 2027, and two are preparing to apply once the required standards are met. The main challenge remain the storage of qualified medical personnel, particularly specialists. As of June 2026, 43 of the 209.5 authorized medical positions were vacant. Legislative amendments providing for a 30% salary increase for penitentiary medical staff, effective from January 2027, are expected to improve recruitment and retention. Third, regarding the prevention and treatment of infectious diseases. Medical screening upon admission, early detection, diagnostic testing, infection prevention measures, our continuity of treatment are implemented throughout the penitentiary system. Tuberculosis and HIV services are provided in cooperation with specialized public health care institutions. Statistical data are available by year and sex, however, age-disaggregated data are not systematically collected, and all the data will be presented. Fourth, regarding health care for vulnerable group and mental health. Women deprived of their liberty have access to general health care, gynecological consultation, reproductive health care, mammography, prenatal-related care, and specialized referrals. For persons with intellectual disabilities, health care is based on individual clinical assessments with appropriate medical, psychological and social support. Mental health also is a strategical priority. With the support of Council of Europe, we are developing an integrated multidisciplinary model of mental health in prison. This initiative includes standards, operating procedures, referral mechanisms, case management, professional training and quality standards. The model will be piloted in selected penitentiary institutions with the objective of improving early identification, access to care, and continuity of treatment. This process will be done in one year. Finally, regarding death in custody. Commission for reviewing death has been established with the Quality Council of the National Administration of Penitentiaries. Clinical pathological conferences are organized by the medical staff to analyze the circumstances of deaths, assess medical interventions, and identify opportunities to improve clinical practice. All deaths occurring in penitentiary institutions are treated as suspicious and are subject to legal medical examination. The recorded number of death was 41 in 2021, compared with 27 in 2025. Distinguished members of the Committee, The Republic of Moldova recognizes the challenges affecting penitentiary healthcare, particularly medical staffing and access to specialized services. Nevertheless, the ongoing institutional reforms reflect our commitment to improving healthcare quality, strengthening professional independence, and ensuring that persons deprived of their liberty receive appropriate healthcare in accordance with national and international standards. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:27:19]: And the next question, the answer in the context of management of pretrial detention centers. I'll provide the answer in the context of the responsibility for administration of temporary detention centers of Minister of Interior Affairs. Regarding to committee's recommendation to transfer responsibility for the administration of temporary detention facility from the Minister of Internal Affairs to Minister of Justice, we'd like to clarify that the Republic of Moldova has maintained the current situation, institutional arrangement, whereby these facilities remains under the administration of the Minister of Internal Affairs through the General Police Inspectorate. The decision is primarily based on the specific operational nature of police temporary detention. Under Moldovan legislation, the maximum period of detention is 72 hours for adults and 24 hours for minors. These facilities are therefore intended for short-term detention, during which essential procedural and investigative activities are carried out. Keeping this facility within the police structure ensure institutional continuity and effective coordination between arrest, admission, custody, supervision, escorting, and criminal investigation activities. It also allows for the efficient use of existing infrastructure, logistical resources, and security regiments as the detention facilities are integrated into police inspectorate premises. At the same time, maintaining the administration under the Minister of Internal Affairs does not exclude or replace independent external oversight. The prevention of torture and ill-treatment is ensured through a set of legal, institutional, and practical safeguards. A key role in this regard is played by the National Preventive Mechanism against Torture, operating through the People's Advocate Office and the Council for the Prevention of Torture. This mechanism has the legal authority to conduct regular and unannounced preventive visits to place or deprivation of liberty, access detention premises and hold confidential interviews with persons deprived of their liberty independently of the authorities responsible for managing these facilities. Regarding the material condition of detention, significant investments have been made in renovating and modernizing temporary detention facilities across the country, in line with fundamental human rights standards and the recommendation of CPT. Particular attention has been given to the needs of persons with disabilities. Three temporary detention facilities located in north, central, and the south part have been adapted to accommodate persons with reduced mobility. These facilities provide accessible and dry areas and adapted sanitary facilities. Whenever necessary and in accordance with legal requirements, and territorial jurisdiction rules, persons with mobility impairments can be transferred to one of these facilities to ensure appropriate and accessible detention conditions. Furthermore, all police temporary detention facilities have at least one cell designed for persons experiencing claustrophobia. These cells are equipped with a glass door, allowing natural light to enter and providing greater visibility of the interior. Regarding health care, the right of persons deprived of their liberty to medical assistance is guaranteed under Article 175(1) and 175(2) of the Moldovan Enforcement Code. Medical examinations are conducted upon admission, upon release, and whenever requested during detention. Relevant health condition, visible injuries, ongoing medical treatment, and other circumstances requiring medical attention are identified and documented. Persons under the influence of alcohol or narcotic or psychotropic substances are also provided with the necessary medical assessment and assistance. The authorities further cooperate with national and international monitoring bodies, consider their recommendations and take measures to address identified shortcomings. This mechanism, together with access to medical assistance and the proper documentation of injuries, constitute important safeguards against torture and other forms of ill treatment. Next question is about death in custody. In this context, for the question, i will ask Mr. Sergiu Rusu to intervene. in the context of paragraph 166, and the situation with death in custody, in context of complex, let's say, we'll have to deliver the information about the prisons and about the detained space of police. We'll provide it later in established timeline. Please, Mr. Russo, in your context. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [2:32:23]: Death of a person held in the custody of penitentiary institution or police pretrial detention facilities is reported to prosecutor's office. Deaths occurring in police custody are generally investigated by the prosecutor's office, whereas deaths occurring in penitentiary institution are investigated by the criminal investigation body under the supervision of the prosecutor's office. In every case involving a death in custody, a forensic medical examination is ordered as a part of investigation in order to establish the cause of death. Both of the order authorizing the examination and the results thereof are committed to the legal successors of the injured party who is entitled to request an additional expert examination. The forensic expert report constitutes evidence, and it's attached to the criminal case file. No case have been identified in which the death of a person held in state custody resulted from acts of torture, with the exception of the Braguta case, which was investigated and subsequently referred to the Court. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:33:51]: Thank you. We'll continue with Mr. Viktor Rikshanov from the National Agency for Penitentiary in the context of use of force and violence among inmates. And in this context, please provide the information. Republic of Moldova · Interim Deputy Chief, Security and Regime Unit, National Administration of Penitentiaries [2:34:10]: Hello, my name is Victor Ișanu. I'm currently serving as the Deputy Interim Chief of the Security and Regime Unit within the National Administration of Penitentiaries. Speaking about use of force and violence among inmates, and also informal hierarchies. I would like to point out, first of all, that the National Administration of Penitentiaries has undertaken the following measures: we ensured the recording of every use of physical force or special means through incident reports detailing the circumstances, grounds for intervention, means used, and manner of application. The reports are submitted to the head of the penitentiary institution, while the NAP and National Administration of Penitentiaries is informed without delay. We also ensured the medical examination of persons subjected to physical force or special means, with their health condition, identified injuries and medical care provided being recorded in the relevant medical documentation. We've also strengthened the reporting mechanisms to the prosecutor by ensuring that cases involving the use of physical force, special means, or service weapons are communicated through written reports submitted immediately within the statutory time limit of no more than 24 hours. We've also implemented the electronic register established by NAP Order number 150 from 2024 to monitor bodily injuries and incidents involving the use of force and special means. Also, the Safe Action Plan on aligning penitentiary institutions with European standards and combating the criminal subculture for the years 2024 and 2027 was approved by the order of the Minister of Justice number 244 from 2024. Through this plan, the prison system aims to ensure individual assessment, safe placement, dynamic security, and the reduction of the influence of informal hierarchies. We've also strengthened administrative control over the legality, necessity, and proportionality of interventions, including verification of the duration and intensity of measures, the necessity of force once resistance has ceased, the conduct of medical examinations and the notification of the prosecutor. We've also updated and consolidated the regulatory framework governing the safety and security of penitentiary institutions through the implementation of relevant normative acts, including the regulation on the safety of penitentiary institutions, the Guide on Professional Intervention and the Guide on Special Means and the Legal Framework for their use. In 2026, we approved a new inter-institutional regulation on the reporting of alleged cases of ill-treatment, aimed at strengthening coordination and ensuring a consistent approach to reporting and examining such allegations. We've also promoted amendments to the regulation on the execution of sentences by convicted persons, approved by government decision number 583 from 2006, providing for the exceptional use of handcuffs during the movement of persons sentenced to life imprisonment based on an individual risk assessment and a reasoned decision. According to records updated as of 10 of November 2026, a total of 448 staff members had received initial and continuing training covering professional intervention, communication, conflict management, prevention of field treatment, and documentation of bodily injuries. We've also organized seven additional training sessions to the Training Centre in connection with the case of Petrov v. Republic of Moldova, attended by 91 special status public officials, of whom 65 underwent assessment. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:38:23]: Thank you very much. Once again, dear colleagues, let's be more briefly as it possible. Next question, next answer is connected to cell isolation. I'll ask Corina Zamfir to provide the answer, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, National Administration of Penitentiaries [2:38:43]: Isolation prison system. The legislation regarding solitary confinement was approved by law number 100 of 2016, related to training on Nelson Mandela rules. Prison staff during the reporting period were training on different topics, such as The essential components covered were compression of the rules with national legislation, focus on detention conditions and the physical, procedural, and dynamic dimensions of security, strategies for procedure justice and fair interpersonal conflict management. With UNODC support, prison staff attended professional training on the Nelson Mandela Rules. Every year on the 18th of July, persons deprived of liberty in penitentiary institutions take part in various activities dedicated to Nelson Mandela International Day, which was proclaimed in November 2009 by unanimous decision of the United Nations General Assembly. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:40:17]: Thank you very much. We will continue with the investigation, prosecution, and convictions. In this context, I'll ask Mr. Rusu just to provide answers. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [2:40:32]: The duration of investigation depends on several factors, namely the conduct and cooperation of victims and witnesses, as well as the time required to carry out forensic medical, psychiatric, and psychological examination. The last one is practice take more than one year complete. A separate challenge is the fact that victims and witnesses travel abroad and often do not return or visit the country only very rarely, which makes it difficult to complete the investigation within a short time frame. It is important to mention that in case concerning torture, inhuman or degrading treatment, the authority to conduct criminal investigation lays exclusively with the prosecutor. The prosecutor is responsible for independently carrying out all procedural action necessary for the investigation without the procedural support of the criminal investigation body. So this arrangement place a particularly high level of professionals and procedural responsibility of the prosecutors. who must personally ensure that the entire range of investigative and procedural actions is carried out. Consequently, the workload and the complexity of the prosecutor's duties are considerable, resulting in a significant workload pressure that may affect their ability to handle all cases under their responsibility in a timely manner. With regard to question of whether the Republic of Moldova has issued an official high-level statement firmly condemning torture and ill-treatment and establish a policy of zero tolerance, Towards such practice, I would like to mention that the most recent official statement was made on 21 August 2026, when the state institution signed a joint order approved the regulation of the identification, examination, registration, documentation, and reporting of case of alleged torture or inhuman or degrading treatment. The seven institutions involved are the Prosecutor General Office, the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection, the National Anti-Corruption Center, and Customs Service. The event and the official statement received extensive media coverage. One of the case concerning four detainees, about Barguta case, one of the case concerning four detainees and three police officers who commit acts of torture and ill-treatment against Barguta consisting of physical assaults. On 24 October 2015, the case was referred to the court for examination. By a judgment of the Chisinau Court of 19 July 2019, the court sentenced four defendants to five years in prison with the execution of the sentence suspended while acquitting them of charge of torture and inhuman treatment. For the convicted person were granted condition, suspension of the execution of their sentence for a probation period of five years. The fifth defendant was convicted of inhuman and degrading treatment and sentenced to four years in prison, together with a seven-year ban of holding certain provision with the Minister of Internal Affairs. The sixth defendant was sentenced to four years in prison and banned for holding certain position within the Ministry of Internal Affairs for a period of five years. The execution of sentence was conditionally suspended for five years. The seven defendants were found not guilty for the offence of torture. No civil claims were filed by the injured party. The second criminal case was referred to the court on 4 January 2018. In this case, 30 police officers 13 police officers charged with subjecting Andrei Bragutza to inhuman and degradating treatment. In this case, the individuals were charged with following to intervene and allowing the intimates to force Andrei Bragutza to lie on the cold floor on the cell for more than three hours while completely naked. These circumstances contribute to the develop of bilateral purulent bronchopneumonia, which lead to respiratory failure and medical condition that was linked to his death. By a judgment of Chisinau court of 4 June 2021, all defenders were found guilty of committing the offenses and sentenced to imprisonment, a ban on holding a public office. Eight from the convicted persons, the execute of their prison sentence was conditionally suspended for a probatory period. The third criminal case was referred for examination to the Chisinau Court on 8 August 2018. The defendants in this case were two doctors employed by Penitentiary No. 9, Pruncu, charged with negligently violating the rules of procedures governing the providing of medical assistance. thereby causing the death of patient Andrei Braguta, as well as with falsifying an official document, namely Andrei Braguta medical prescription record. By a judgment of the Kishinau Court of 5 December 2025, the court found guilty one of the defendants, while finding the secondary defendant guilty, but exempting his from criminal punishment because the prescription had expired. The criminal case is currently pending before the Central Court of Appeal. The fourth criminal case concerns the circumstances that lead to death of Andrei Braguta. It was initiated on 4 October 2017 and investigated in relation to offences of abuse of power committed by two persons employed by the medical service of the penitentiary system and one police officer from the escort service of Chisinau Municipal Police Directorate. On 21 August 2017, these individuals prevented Andrei Bragutza from being admitted to Penitentiary No. 13, Chisinau. On 26 March 2018, the criminal proceedings were discontinued because elements of criminal offences had not been established. Also, the elements of the Convention contravention of abuse of power were found to be present. The contravention proceedings were examined by the Chisinau Court, which underd the termination. By a judgment of 12 March 2019, the person concerned were found guilty of committing the contravention of abuse of power. However, the contravention proceedings were terminated because terms of prescription had expired. Additionally, inform of the outcomes of the examination of 108 complaints concerning alleged acts of torture committed in connection with the event of 7 April 2009. Following the examination of the 108 complaints concerning allegations of torture and other unlawful action committed by police officer, prosecutor, order the following: the initiation of criminal investigation in 71 criminal cases, which concerned 42 cases of torture, 90 concerned abuse of power or exciting official authority, and 10 concerned other category of offences. The referral to court of 28 criminal cases involving 48 police officers. In the remaining cases, the criminal investigation were discontinued due to the absence of the constitutive elements of criminal offences or suspended on the ground that the indictments of the person who had acted unlawfully could not be established. I would now like to answer the Committee's question regarding why fewer criminal cases were opened specifically for torture and how the remaining cases are classified. The reason for this difference comes down to the legal requirement in our criminal code, which follows the definition of the Convention against Torture. Specifically, Article 166-1 of the Criminal Code of Republic of Moldova divides ill-treatment into distinct levels of severity. Torture, paragraph 3 and 4: For an act to be classified as torture, it must involve a high degree of physical violence or severe suffering, along with specific legal elements such as intent and purpose. In most of these cases, we investigate the facts do not reach them extreme level of violence. Second is inhuman or degrading treatment, paragraph 1 and 2 from Article 166(1). Instead, those remaining cases, they classified and prosecuted under the same article as inhuman or degrading treatment. This ensures that even when physical force does not reach the threshold of torture and abuse, it still treats as a serious crime. A clear example of this works is practical in the Bragutsa case that I mentioned. In the case, the defense who directly used several physical violence against the victim were charged with torture. Other individuals involved where action did not reach the level of violence were charged with inhuman or degradating treatment. Initial criminal complaints are only based on second A second argument in this clarification, I want to mention the initial criminal complaints are only based on unverified claims, not proven legal facts. Because of this, the true legal classification of the offences, including torture, can only be decided through formal charge by the prosecutor and the final decision of the court. Relying only on Initial complaints give an inaccurate picture of crime statistics. To truly reflect reality, statistics must look at the actuality changes both to court and the final verdict. In any case, every act of illegal treatment is prosecuted according to its exact level of seriousness. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:53:34]: And we'll continue with the question from the rapporteur, Mr. Abdallah, in the context of exclusion of statements obtained under torture. And Mr. Russo, please continue. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [2:53:55]: Article 94, paragraph 1, point 1 of Criminal Procedure Code stipulate the evidence obtained through the following means is inadmissible and must therefore be excluded from the case file, may not be presented before the court, and may not form the basis of judgment of other judicial decision. Since 2018, in how many cases, the second question, cover – CART excludes statement or evidence following substantiated allegation of torture? The Prosecutor General has not recorded any cases in which it was established the statement or other evidence had been obtained as a result of allegation of torture. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:54:50]: Thank you very much. Next question was about the psychiatric institutions, and we had two concrete questions on this domain, so I'll ask my colleague, Mr. Maksim Donich from the Ministry of Health to provide an answer, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Ministry of Health [2:55:09]: About mental health, I want to say that mental health and well-being establish safeguards concerning involuntary hospitalization, including the right to obtain a second medical opinion for an independent psychiatrist. Mental health service provide the required to establish and maintain mechanisms for registry, examining, and resolving complaints submitted by patients. The law provides that the Office of the Ombudsman, the Council on the Prevention of Torture, and civil society organizations active in the field of mental health are intended to monitor the provision of mental health services without any restriction. As regarding the recommendation raised by the Council on the Prevention of Torture and Office of the Ombudsman, we welcome their valuable contribution and reaffirm that the relevant authorities are undertaking the necessary effort to ensure very effective implementation. Thanks. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [2:56:09]: Thank you very much. And the next question will be provided by my colleagues from the Intelligence Security Service, Mr. Sergei Girgichuk, in the context of the counterterrorism legislation. Please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Operational Department, Counter-Terrorist Center [2:56:34]: Thank you. My name is Sergei. I am from the operational department of the Counter-Terrorist Center of the Republic of Moldova. So the prohibition of torture is absolute and unconditional under national legislation and international human rights. Torture is criminalized under Article 166 in the Criminal Code, and fight against terrorism cannot constitute a legal ground for justifying or tolerating acts of torture. This framework is based on the provisions of the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova, in particular Article 4, which establishes the priority of international human rights, and Article 24, which expressly prohibits torture. More than that, Article 6 of the Law 136 stipulates that the intelligence activity, including counter-terrorist investigations, must be carried out in accordance with the international treaties to which the Republic of Moldova is the state party. So the legality of measures implemented in the context of counter-terrorist activities is subject to judicial review and parliamentary control, in accordance with Article 47 of the Law No. 120 on Preventing and Combating Terrorists. Article 4 of the Law on Preventing and Combating Terrorists established the principles of legality, respect for fundamental rights and proportionality. The legality of measures undertaken by the competent authorities is subject to oversight by courts and General Prosecutor's Office, mentioned in Articles 298 of the Criminal Procedure Code. More than that, the Article 42, 43, and 45 of Law 179 on Counterintelligence and Intelligence Activities set out the procedures for monitoring special investigative activities, including those who conducted in the frameworks of the counter-terrorist operation. Article 9 of Law on Counterintelligence and Intelligence Activities sets out the restrictive measures that may be applied to prevent the terrorism actions, and their legality is subject to review by the courts and the parliament. Individuals whose rights have been violated may seek judicial protection in accordance with the procedural criminal legislation, fixed in the chapter 4 in the Criminal Procedure Code. We can speak, we can say the question about the anti-terrorist command. So here we can say that the operational anti-terrorist command was established in accordance with the government decision number 121 on 2021. Under the regulation, article 63 and 64, the command includes a representative of the prosecutor office who is responsible for conducting criminal investigation. Additionally, in order to verify the legality of action of the anti-terrorist command includes also a legal assistance group, which ensures the application of national and international legislation provided in Article 56. So, the last and not the least, during the reporting period, no conviction for terrorism or terrorism-related offences were reported, and no complaints have been registered concerning the use of torture in the context of the counter-terrorist measures and investigation. Thank you very much. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [3:00:17]: And now we'll pass to a question from Mr. Liu. In this context, I'll ask my colleague, Mr. Russo, to interview for three questions that we have about the settlement of judges and prosecutors, and the context of human trafficking and the corruption, and the context of situation of using technologies for preventing torture for some aspects, please. Republic of Moldova · Representative, Prosecutor General's Office [3:00:46]: Thank you. In order of question about leaving judges and prosecutors of system, I would mention the recent departures of judges of prosecutor from the justice system of the Republic of Moldova are not the result of a single issue, but rather of combination of three main factors. alongside individual personal decision. First and most significantly is the ongoing extraordinary evaluation or vetting process. Similar to the integrity reforms implemented in Albania and Ukraine, Moldova is conducting a comprehensive review of the ethical and financial integrity of judges and prosecutors. As a natural consequence of such a rigorous process, a number of practitioners have chosen to resign either prior to or during the evaluation process. Second is the question of remuneration. Salary leaves within the justice sector has posed challenges in retaining qualified personnel. However, the authorities are actively addressing through the new law of remuneration in the budget sector, which is designed to establish a more competitive and motivation pay structure commensurably with the high responsibilities of the rules. Third is, naturally, staff turnover. Like any public institution, our justice system experience regularly cycling of retirements and voluntarily career transition, the account for a study portion of departs. Taking together the three structural factors, combined with the subjective personal consideration, explain the current currently staffing dynamics. On next question about issue of human trafficking and zero tolerance of corruption in this field, the Republic of Moldova takes a zero tolerance approach to any form of corruption that could obstruct the investigation, prosecution, or referral of trafficking in human beings cases to court. To ensure institutionally accountability and close interagency coordination, we have established the Consultative Council under the Prosecutor General for law enforcement bodies responsible for combating trafficking in human beings. This council brings together all specialized law enforcement agencies dedicated to fight human trafficking alongside key institutional partners such as the Ministry of Justice. Crucial, its permanent members, including the Chief Prosecutor of Anti-Corruption Prosecutor Office and the Director of the National Anti-Corruption Center. During the Council's session, the anti-corruption leaders regularly present concerns, updates, the measures taken to prevent and combat corruption, specifically within the anti-trafficking system. They briefing cover three main areas. Case trafficking and outcomes, they reporting on registered corruption cases linked to trafficking, taking their procedural progress all the way through to final court conviction. Risk assessments and transparency and international report. Because this all our institutional effort, we submitted and reported to U.S. Department of States for trafficking in person report. And my last answer from my side. Turning now to the Committee question regarding the use of information technology, and specifically audio and video recording, as a safeguard for the prevention of torture. Over the past three years, the Republic of Moldova has significantly strengthened its procedural safeguard against torture and ill-treatment by integrating mandatory audio and video recording into criminal investigation. Specifically, amendments to our Criminal Procedure Code now legally obligate criminal investigation officers and prosecutors to conduct questioning and interviewing using both audio and video recording equipment. This measure has generally a crucial two-fold impact in prevention of torture. First, a direct prevention impact: the mandatory recording of both voice and image acts are as immediately determining, eliminating risk of physical or psychological abuse, ill-treatment, or torture. Second, an indirect evidence impact. The continuous visual and audio record provide this objectively verifiable evidence of detainee's physical and mental state. To illustrate the legal guarantee, it is Article 104 of the Criminal Proceed Code, establish strict rules for questioning suspect, accused, or defendant. Thank you. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [3:06:49]: Due to lack of time, we had one last intervention for the context of use of electronic ankle bracelets. We have a national inspectorate of probation. And we have developed these systems, but in this context of lack of time, we'll bring this -- provide this information as it's established. Thank you. CAT · CAT · Chair [3:07:18]: Thank you very much. Mr. Alexandru Bejan, Secretary of State, I'd like to On behalf of the Committee, thank you for your very exact and systematic and very well-organized answers, to echo indeed the words of the two rapporteurs, Mr. Iscan and Mr. Abdallah. I believe this has been an extremely constructive dialogue, and we are happy to Welcome and pay testimony to the presence of your delegation here in Geneva, as well as all of those participating from capital to give a wide-ranging, rigorous, and responsible overview of the answers you've provided. As was said earlier, within the next 48 hours, you would be able to provide additional data, statistics, and information which might be significant and you think to be relevant and want to bring to the committee's attention. After analysing the outcome of this meeting, the Committee will draft a document entitled Concluding Observations, which will be sent to your Permanent Mission here in Geneva on 3 December at 6:00 PM for you to have view of that and review it, not in terms of the substance, but in terms of the dates, the institutions, and proper names, and anything else that requires review in that regard. And you will have until 10 AM on the 4th of December, which is the last day of our session, to provide feedback on that to us. I'd like to highlight that In drafting concluding observations, the Committee's practice is to flag two or three comments that the Committee believes to be key priorities, and they will be highlighted as core recommendations being made to the State Party for action. We're very interested in maintaining continuity after this dialogue through follow-up on implementation that you will give to the recommendations contained in the concluding observations. Before we adjourn the session, I'd like to offer the floor to you, Secretary of State, to conclude. You have the floor, sir. Republic of Moldova · State Secretary, Ministry of Internal Affairs [3:10:13]: Thank you. Honourable Chair, distinguished members of the Committee, The Republic of Moldova remains firmly committed to the absolute prohibition of torture and ill-treatment. The progress achieved reflects an approach based on four mutually reinforcing pillars: prevention, identification and documentation, effective investigation and accountability, and the protection, assistance and rehabilitation of victims. The Government of Republic of Moldova recognizes that prevention of torture is not a one-time legislative task. It is a continuing institutional responsibility requiring constant monitoring, professional capacity, adequate resources, and accountability. Our objective remains unequivocal: every person deprived of liberty must be treated with dignity. Safeguards against torture must operate effectively from the very first moment of deprivation of liberty. Every credible allegation of torture or ill-treatment must be investigated promptly, independently, and effectively. Every child victim must receive protection and assistance adapted to his or her needs. And accountability, access to effective remedies, compensation, and rehabilitation must be ensured in practice. The progress achieved reflects our full pillar approach: prevention, identification and documentation, effective investigation, victim protection, and rehabilitation. We, therefore, welcome the Committee’s observation and recommendation as an important contribution to strengthening our national system. On behalf of the Government of the Republic of Moldova, I thank the Committee for the opportunity to present our fourth periodic report and for its continued cooperation with our country. The delegation of the Republic of Moldova stands ready to provide further information and to respond to questions of the distinguished member if it will be necessary. Thank you for your attention. CAT · Chair [3:12:18]: Thank you very much for those words. It is just left to me to wish you much success in your work. The session is adjourned.